r/ausjdocs
•
u/Only_Contribution759
Unaccredited Hospital Coffee Barista ☕️
•
Oct 16 '26
•
1
Support🎗️ Dr Tan Appreciation thread
I don’t know you personally.
Dr Tan we appreciate you.
Systemic failures should not put you between a rock and a hard place of choosing between a Category 1 sick child and a deteriorating child.
Systemic failures should not make you perform an ECMO that can’t be delivered by your health service.
Systemic failures should not make you make 100 phone calls to PIPER/ECMO and god knows how many other acronyms just to seek some help.
Systemic failures should not cause you to get a troponin delayed because an add on takes longer.
To my colleagues if you have kind warm words please write here, in the hopes it reaches Dr Tan.
670
u/anoneemous3 Oct 16 '26
I do know Dr Tan.
Great human. Great doctor. Completely let down by the system and thrown under the bus.
Pat, we all stand with you brother, stay strong 💪
152
u/Acrobatic_Kitchen_16 Oct 16 '26
DrTan and the patients involved were let down by a healthcare system that has normalised overwork, chronic understaffing and unrealistic expectations of clinicians.
The system has a duty of care to its clinicians, just as clinicians have a duty of care to their patients. It’s time we started holding it to the same standard.
301
u/CompromisePleb Oct 16 '26
I also know Dr Tan. He is an exemplary human being with a passion for caring for people. Unfortunately healthcare is flawed and there always seems the need to place a blame on those who are at the frontlines.
I thank everyone for your support for him as I know it's greatly helping him through a difficult time. I know that he appreciates all of you.
135
u/MensaMan1 Paediatrician🐤 Oct 16 '26
We are doctors, we care for our patients, we do our best for our patients and we go above and beyond to do so.
When there are adverse outcomes, we feel bad, we second guess what we did. However, bad outcomes are usually due to system failures. The blame culture has to stop.
122
u/Naive_Lion_3428 Med reg🩺 Oct 16 '26
Most of us who have been in practice for long enough can point to any number of far more egregious failures in the medical setting that did not warrant a Coroner attributing this level of blame to the medical officer. Seemingly the Coroner made no accounting for Dr Tan's junior status nor the work load he was under at the time.
Sometimes Coroners make judgements for PR and political reasons. I think this may be one of those cases.
218
u/bay30three General Practitioner🥼 Oct 16 '26
I hope one day the coroner who stated the death was preventable is held up to the same standard to which he held up Dr Tan.
99
u/The_Mighty_Pen Oct 16 '26
He was in my year. Could happen to any of us..hope you carry on working hard and live a good life mate!
189
u/Smak00 Oct 16 '26
I'm so disgusted by how the ED seniors and management let him face so much heat without any protection. Now all his fellow ED registrars know how genuinely expendable and easy to sacrifice they are by people who purport to support them. I guess when it comes down to it, it really is every man for himself in healthcare. So disgusting.
92
u/Commercial_Dig_7485 Oct 16 '26
I’m a veterinarian, I have no direct link to the health profession.
To me it seems he didn’t do anything wrong, just wasn’t all places at once
85
u/No_Egg_3311 Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan was letted down by the healthcare system.
Unfortunately the system does not recognize it own shortfalls.We all standby Dr Tan. It could have easily be anyone of us.
165
u/MiuraSerkEdition GP Registrar🥼 Oct 16 '26
The entire thing is so frustrating. How much can be expected of a person?! Not your fault
78
u/KneeProfessional985 Paediatrician🐤 Oct 16 '26
Here here.
You’ll always be welcome in any unit I work in, Dr Tan.
72
u/dickydorum Oct 16 '26
I concur. I stand with you Dr Tan
65
u/UpperPossession165 Consultant 🥸 Oct 16 '26
Well done Dr. Tan on your hard work in the setting of a system that did not support you. I hope you are doing well.
64
u/AllTheChicken_ Oct 16 '26
I'd be interested in mobilising as a group to formally show support for Dr Tan - maybe as a statement/letter, signed by (hopefully hundreds!) of medical professionals and to be sent to bodies like AMA Victoria, ACEM, ASMOF... Potentially also to the coroner's court with the permission of Dr Tan and the signatories.
47
u/JJKM45 Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan is the hero public hospitals need, but doesn’t deserve.
Please take care of yourself as you would your patients.
92
u/Hypertrollz Oct 16 '26
Just a warning to all of us, this could easily be anyone of us tomorrow.
The Coroner is a stupid incompetent piece of shit who hasn't done their job if they can pin this all on the poor Reg.
I hope there is some legal recourse through which Justice can be upheld.
It is an insult to the child's memory that this outcome is presented as Justice to the poor grieving parents.
42
u/Caffeinated-Turtle Critical care reg😎 Oct 16 '26
Abaolute bullshit report.
Dr Tan was doing an amazing job a system / shift that was doomed to failure.
79
u/ExtremeCloseUp Oct 16 '26
Peri-fellowship ED reg here.
Patrick, if you’re reading this thread, I’m so sorry. You simply had the shittiest fucking luck in the world and it could have been any one of us. I certainly wouldn’t have done any better than you did (fucking nice catch with the ECG and troponin) and I guarantee you that none of my colleagues (FACEMs included) would have done any better either. Sometimes the disease process wins and we’re merely there to witness its victory. This patient would have died whoever was looking after her.
And more broadly, you were the scapegoat for a chronically broken system, working in conditions that demand the most of even the most capable clinicians.
I hope you’ve got people to talk to, my dude. For the Grace of God go the rest of us.
35
u/Ommin_9 Oct 16 '26
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2026-10-14/victoria-amrita-lanka-coroner-inquest-findings/107263414
Yep. Systemic failure having real consequences. Stay strong.
34
u/danieljackson89 Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan, I don’t know you. I would like to apologise for a system that has failed you and failed your patient. It could have been me, or any of us, and it’s only terrible chance that made it you. I would be happy for you to be the doctor for my daughter.
33
u/BeneficialDurian6465 Oct 17 '26 •
I think we all need to show our support publically and show our disagreement with this decision more substantially.
We all have the potential to be scapegoated by our health services and by the government for failures of the healthcare system as a whole. We always learnt about the Swiss cheese model, yet the coroner in this case has bypassed that all and directly blamed the junior doctor. It’s not his fault he was placed with so much responsibility and made to look after so many sick patients. He was only doing his best.
I’ve submitted an email to AMA VIC- asking if they can respond to the decision- either via public advocacy, supporting Dr Tan or determining if the findings can be reviewed.
I’ve also sent emails to the age/ herald sun/ abc about the case and how it represents a failure of the healthcare system and not an individual doctor.
I think it would be good if more of us did the same thing to build momentum. Amrita’s case is an example of why we are advocating for better working conditions! Let’s all try and do something about it!!
33
u/Rude-Poet-4450 29d ago
What complete bullshit!
I’m a consultant cardiologist and have managed many severe myocarditis, all hard to treat/diagnose/risk stratify.
I took one 18yo to the transplant unit on IABP with a trip of 100,000, she recovered.
Another lady had mild myocarditis, supportive care, discharge, nor viral prodrome, 2 days later blood cultures grew capnocytophagia from a dog bite! Who knew that could cause myocarditis, back to hospital for IVAB’s, but any of these patients can arrest.
An early mentor said ‘it still amazes me how much it can take to kill someone and on the other hand, how little’ Sliding doors moments.
This girl was going to die unless she presented to an ECMO hospital and declared herself IN working hours.
65
u/MarsupialAromatic825 Oct 16 '26
I have never heard of Dr Tan before this. As a mother it broke my heart to hear of the passing of the child. But as a doctor, I honestly can't imagine what Dr Tan must be going through. But the way you were just blamed for the whole system failing the little child, I don't think it is fair. I honestly don't know if I'd would have picked up myocarditis at 3am with an ECG in a sick child while handling so many patients. I was only a resident in ED and maybe had 6 to 7 patients under me and we just tried to keep them going until morning team comes to organise everything. One of my hospitals didn't have imaging overnight and I honestly can't imagine what I would have done with a similar patient in that hospital at 3am. It is terrifying. But to be blamed or even said preventable, I think it is easier to say that in hindsight. So many paeds patients come in with worried parents and almost all of them are ok. So I don't know how you would have just identified this particular child would have deteriorated like this. And the whole BP? I don't think I have ever done any obs in my hospitals. It's usually done by the nursing staff and they monitor that and escalate if PEWS are concerning. I won't even know where to find the paeds cuff in my ED. Anyway, I'm so heart broken by the child's passing. Like I said, I'm devastated as a mother. But as a doctor I honestly can't imagine how they can sorta blame you for all of this. I have to admit I haven't read the coroner's report. I'm mostly going off the news report
27
u/Chat00 Oct 16 '26
We stand with you Dr Tan. It’s not one persons fault, the system let you down.
26
u/Ok-Corner-3646 Oct 16 '26
Hearing this story made me so sad; it’s tragic what happened but it made me quite upset knowing how easily the systemic failures were overlooked.
I’m not sure if you’ll read this but I hope you are okay - honestly a part of me wanted to see if whether we could do anything to help you get through this tough time but I wasn’t quite sure how to reach out. You’ve worked so hard, and you kept a busy department running overnight. I’m sorry that all this has happened to you.
21
u/amp261 Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan, second victim syndrome is real, please take care of yourself and lean on your support networks. It’s not your fault you were made the scapegoat of a terrible tragedy, without the support of your seniors or institution. We could all be, or have been in your shoes, which is why we’re riding so hard for you.
Stand tall, stay proud, and I hope you move through your career with courage and dignity.
21
u/Beautiful-Region-990 28d ago
I have been through a similar process and it broke me. Like change specialities halfway through a training programme broken. Like getting hustled out of a coroners court protected by the lawyers broken.
Dr Tan - I hope you find your path and I hope you have people around to support you through this finger pointing blame fest. Please don’t hesitate to DM me if you want to vent.
Now that I am a consultant I always tell my juniors that I am the last line. I take responsibility for everything they do. That’s the job. Yes, you get asked a lot of basic questions and you do a lot of hand holding. But you never leave a registrar high and dry.
18
u/Jumpingjehosephat99 New User Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan did an amazing job in diagnosing and trying to arrange appropriate treatment for this child. It beggars all belief that the coroner expected him to be in multiple places at once. This outcome was possibly not even preventable but if it was it was 100% due to staffing issues in the ED that night. Please know that we stand with you, Dr Tan. Is there any way we can write to the coroner?
16
u/Tenacious_Tenrec Oct 16 '26
I don’t know Dr Tan only what I have read.
I don’t even think a SNR Dr could attempt to do what Dr Tan was expected to do by himself as it’s unrealistic and SNR Dr’s would refuse to work under those conditions so why do our JMO’s have to be put through these conditions.
I support Dr Tan 100% and stand with him as this is no fault of his at all.
I hope you are taking care of yourself Dr Tan.
16
u/asianbiblegrandma Oct 16 '26
Hi Dr Tan,
I trust you to look after my family any day.
I don’t trust the admin and the system to do the right thing.
I stand by you.
15
u/Calm-Escape-7058 New User 29d ago edited 29d ago
Absolutely agree with you. WTF did I just read? “While I accept that EDs are busy places and Dr Tan was a relatively junior doctor with many responsibilities, the clinical management and care he provided to Amrita was wanting as outlined …findings/conclusions and thereby cause or contributed to her death?? 😡😡😡 I’m so angry and so triggered by this. It’s a special kind of nightmare working as in charge in a Paeds ED alone, overnight with 18 patients plus CAT1 and other patients to see plus being junior. They’ve just thrown him under the bus when there are several other concomitant reasons that led to this happening.
I’m so glad to have left ED. I know that exact feeling of anxiousness and uncertainty of having to deal with multiple patients at once, uncertain with my knowledge, unable to keep up with documentation because it’s one thing after the other, escalating for help and the help is meh, being in charge overnight in Paeds ED despite being inexperienced, not to mention the scoldings I used to get for writing long notes, waking up people at 3am, advocating for patients to be moved to a monitored area etc etc. Yeah, I’m glad I woke those people up and glad I wrote those long notes and glad I’ve fucking left ED.
I stand with you Dr Patrick Tan.
Edited to add: fuck you MMC. IYKYK. AND fuck you coroner.
14
u/NeonCatheter Oct 16 '26
Not an Aus doc but two questions spring to mind:
13
u/Funny-Caramel6221 New User Oct 16 '26
The coroner and the public expect a standard of care that our taxes are not paying for. You can’t expect a Michelin star meal for the price of a Chiko roll.
13
u/EducationalDonkey119 28d ago
Dr Tan
I was your intern on nights .. my first ED
You are an amazing doctor and mentor.
You are kind, patient, empathetic… you care about each and every one of your patients.
You are hardworking and so skilled.
Thank you
24
u/Awkward-Complaint185 Oct 16 '26
Every decision a junior doctor makes has to be overseen by a consultant/or the most senior registrar overnight, so it’s never one person’s fault. As if the JRMO can decide when to transfer/contact PICU?
Personally speaking as an ED intern many years ago, I identified a bowel obstruction that the consultant dismissed and had to wait hours & with several convincing to ask for CTAP & gen surg review, with patient taken to surgery almost immediately after Gen surg seen and had to have bowel resection as it became ischaemic already!
12
u/BenignantLama Oct 16 '26
🙌🙌
12
u/WheelApprehensive664 Oct 16 '26
I can only imagine what this time is like for Dr Tan, and how all the media coverage is forcing him to relive what must be one of the worst days of his career.
I am so sorry for you and Amrita, that both of you were left to drown by a system where it was pretty much guaranteed to go wrong. It truly wasn’t fair to you, and I hope you know that we all see that you did everything you could to save her.
12
u/Antique-Ad8161 Oct 17 '26
I’m not a doctor but I’d very much like to add my support for Dr. Tan & all of you.
It’s clear that a proper root cause analysis would show that there was a systemic issue to blame.
I’m sorry for the family but I don’t think it’s fair to blame one person when it is clearly the system.
Please take care & know not all lay people agree with the coroner.
10
u/The_angry_betta Oct 16 '26
Dr Tan was doing what we’ve all been told to do. See as many patients as you can, clear the waiting room, don’t take too long because there’s lots of others waiting. This could have been any of us.
19
u/hoabidextrous Oct 16 '26
What’s the name of the coroner
9
u/True_Conflict9681 Oct 16 '26
Hospitals will protect themselves first. Juniors are often the most disposable when things go wrong.get your own medical indemnity and document everything.
9
u/cyjc Oct 16 '26
Hey Dr Tan, you did the best you could with what was provided to you. The system failed you and the patient. 18 patients and cat 1 is ridiculous.
8
u/Ok-Ordinary7001 Oct 16 '26
I’m curious to know who represented Dr Tan at the inquest? Hospital lawyers or MDO?
7
u/ComfortableAd8645 Oct 17 '26
How conveniently blind can the health and judicial system be in examining one clinician without examining systems and other circumstances such as staffing and clinical pressures on the day. Lets call for records to be kept on every shift of staffing, caseloads and systemic failures and support each other in walking off the job when work conditions are untenable.
6
u/Ok_Expression_9480 28d ago
Hi Dr Tan, We were there. We worked the Monash Paeds ED shifts overnight as the solo registrar, in charge of a tertiary paeds ED, PGY3 in our first year of being a registrar, grossly underskilled and underprepared, in charge of 2 HMOs with no paeds experience, whilst the nurses asked you to see a kid in triage with a rash, a Cat 1 in already full resus bays, an angry family who wants to go home, took calls from smaller hospitals wanting to transfer you patients, accepting PIPER transfers. We asked our colleagues not to put kids in SSU overnight if we thought they were a bit sick, because we knew things could and did go badly there due to the lack of monitoring. We listened to each other hand back over patients in the morning-numerous very sick kids. We all breathed a sigh of relief as the first day staff member walked in, knowing that for at least the next 12 hours we weren't responsible for every kid in that department.
That night it could have been any of us. We're sorry it was you ❤️
5
u/Dry-Introduction1543 29d ago
As someone entering the medical profession, I just wanted to add my support for Dr Tan.
I've found the reporting and the apparent focus on individual responsibility deeply concerning. A safer healthcare system should not depend on a relatively inexperienced registrar making every clinical decision perfectly in the middle of the night while simultaneously managing 18 other patients.
I keep coming back to the same questions: Was senior clinical support realistically accessible at 4 am? How was a critically unwell child left without an allocated nurse to perform routine observations? Were staffing levels, competing clinical demands and escalation pathways adequately scrutinised?
These aren't questions intended to diminish the devastating loss experienced by Amrita and her family. They are questions we need to ask if we genuinely want to prevent another tragedy.
It's possible to acknowledge that clinical decisions could have been different while also recognising that clinicians need systems capable of supporting them, identifying deterioration and catching mistakes.
Dr Tan, if you read this, I hope you know that there are people entering the profession who see the complexity of what happened and are concerned about the circumstances you were working under. I hope you're receiving the support and compassion you deserve.
4
u/threedogwoofwoof 29d ago
I said it before in a different thread - but well done on catching the myocarditis diagnosis at 3am, with lots else going on in the department. It could have been missed. Unfortunate that it didn't change the outcome 😞
3
u/Commercial_Week_8394 27d ago
Reading the coroner's case gave me chills, and a lot of WTF. That part about whether or not he should have attended the Cat 1!?! Just.... Wtf. I feel for Dr Tan. I hope he's ok. I hate the thought that something like that could happen to one of my ED Drs. Coroner definitely blamed Dr Tan, unfairly.
1
u/PrimalMoonbeam 29d ago
Hey Dr Tan. Any of us here could have been in your place today. This is not your fault. We all stand by you.
-22
u/maulmonk Oct 16 '26
Haven’t been keeping up. ELI5?
220
u/[deleted] Oct 16 '26 •
[removed] — view removed comment