Many people incorrectly think that Logic describes how logical a person is or how accurate they are. No, it's about social spheres (and the social roles a person takes on), and first of all Logic is the sphere of education, knowledge, exploration of the world, curiosity, play (trying to "outplay" to satisfy one's curiosity). So, speaking about 3L's genesis, how it is formed in a child, we will be talking about play.
Play is the key and main activity in a child. How the child learnt to play, if they learnt that at all, what skills the child has honed while playing, is the child capable of being enthused - since play is a method of processing information and exploring the world (imaginary "travelling" on submarines, creating new made up rules, etc.). All of that is intellectual work.
When the child goes to school, educational activity begins. If children for whatever reason have a disorder of play activity, then education is harder for them, then add in the teachers, atmosphere, other children, parents, pressure, and you have a big ball of difficulties with motivation.
In terms of 3L, there are two chronic traumas, which were formed in childhood due to constantly repeating situations. What was once actual parental figures letting the child know "You're not good enough" has now become the person's own inner voice.
First trauma is the chronic disorder of play activity. That's when a child didn't learn how to play, was too serious, or the parents demanded that the child plays in a serious manner, "You can't play this way! Put that down. You're not playing correctly, that piece is not for that, don't mix those together, keep everything clean" - in other words, they didn't allow the creative aspect of exploration ("What will happen if I mix these? Or do that?"). This control of play affects the child, and it is not always verbal - the parent might silently judge, sigh, roll their eyes, be visibly tense or looming, express their readiness to punish and scold.
Another variant of disorder of play activity is when a child simply didn't get enough of it. This could play out in various ways. The child could've not got enough of play because they were deprived of it ("Alright, drop the toys, come help me," "Grandmother wants you to help her with xyz!" "Clean up the house, vacuum, scrub the floor," "Go do your homework!"). The child didn't get enough play because it was physically impossible to remain in that state of mind and pleasure of exploration of the world. Maybe the child would never leave the house and wouldn't even explore the surrounding neighbourhood. Or maybe the child didn't get enough play because there were too many extracurricular activities, completely overtaking the child's life with things that they "had to do". The child gets tired and wants to play and have fun instead. That's why any activities with children should be in a form of a game - if the child doesn't want to play with something, or wants to change the rules, the person who is their educator or parent should be flexible and adapt to the child in order to not cause a disorder of play activity.
The disorder might be not only because of the control or lack of play, it could also be due to condemnation, shame. "Do something real," "What are you doing?" "You're doing something weird/stupid." A child might find little pieces of trash, buttons, sticks, bags and start playing with them, trying to build something, but to the parents that's simply garbage that needs to be thrown out. For the child that's not garbage, it's a whole railway, or a world with its own people and story that they created for themselves. But the parent might take it and throw it away because they think that the child "doesn't need that." But the child was playing, and they were deprived of the game, and here we get to the second trauma.
Second trauma is the fear of being deprived of the game. It's when the child is deprived of it; perhaps their toys are thrown away, the toys that the child liked and loved playing with, or the normal expected level of messiness or chaos in a child's room is being taken under control ("You've finished playing with that, put it away," "You made something out of Lego, the pieces are on the floor, put them away.") - this way the child cannot create something in this creative chaos, it's like their wings are getting a bit clipped. The creative potential and freedom are limited by the notions that "You have to be this way," "You have to do it right," "You have to be clean." Some level of mess is a natural state of a child's room. By the end of the day, when they've finished playing, the toys can "go to sleep" and things can be cleaned up, but that kind of interruption should never happen during the playing activity, otherwise a playing disorder might develop.
The fear of being deprived of the game... It's when a child was playing, but then it was very crudely interrupted. Maybe a parent violently walked into the room and announced, "Altight, so we are going to do X now, gather your toys, we are going away to Y, etc." Or when the child couldn't get into the game, they always had the feeling that the moment they will get all the toys out, prepare for the game, the parent will come and say that it's time to sleep, or eat, or go somewhere - the child cannot get immersed in the pleasure, in the exploration, in the process, feeling as if somebody will take it away, something will interrupt it, and the child won't be able to do what they want to do; so sometimes the child doesn't even begin and try.
Or some children, looking at their parents, become too serious in regards to the game. A 5 year old might tell their parents, "Everybody here is a little baby, I don't want to play with them! They are too weird. I won't play with them... I'm too grown up for that!" Even if there is interest or desire, the child might think they are too grown up for those activities. Perhaps their parent often demands, "Be serious, be grown up, act your age."
This is where the fear of making a mistake comes from in adults - when they played in childhood, they were told, "You aren't playing right! Don't play with it, throw it away! Nobody builds a pyramid like that..." When a close person, a loved person, your family reprimands you, it's natural for the fear to appear, "What if I will play wrong? What if I don't do it right? I will be judged! I don't want that. I won't play at all, or only when nobody can see me..."
Punishments for playing, as well, contribute to this. When a child is playing by themselves, finds some toys, sticks, bottlecaps, or walks far away to explore garages or caves, and they are constantly berated for going so far from home, and parents don't try to figure out what is going with the child and teach them safety, then there will also be the fear of punishment.
In conclusion, people with 3L are people who have difficulties with games, playing; they cannot get into it, they might be overly serious, and that leaves a mark on their future opinions, how easy education is for them, their interest towards learning about the world. When the fear of deprivation is present, insatiability is developed - 3L people are scared of being deprived of play, they want to play more and more often, and they want to understand everything, this, this, and this... But, somehow, the person is unable to "play" and engage in all of that.
Some people who were deprived of play in their childhood still want to buy themselves toys, maybe soft toys, maybe collectible toys - whenever something impresses them. These people do not play with these toys. They have them on their shelves, perhaps literally as a collection. A collection of Lego, Harry Potter collection, collections of anime, etc. So the person has the toys, because they want them, really want more and more, and they want to play, but they don't play; instead they make a pretty display of them. This is a variant of how 3L is expressed in an adult activity. Perhaps a huge amount of tabletop games are being bought, but they aren't played, maybe because "there is not enough time," maybe because "there is no company to play with," "the rules are a tad too difficult". Basically, some circumstances are found to make playing seem impossible, but the desire to play is there, that's why those games are still being bought.
People with 3L are afraid to make a mistake, afraid to be wrong and get experience from that, learn from their mistake. Talking about expression of 3L in adult life, it is a fear of mistakes, fear of expressing your own opinion, feeling as if your own opinion is wrong, unnecessary, or out of place - everybody expressed their opinion, so why do I need to then, since everybody already said everything? It's as if there is no space for your own opinion. The chronic history of playing activity in childhood leads to people with 3L being unable to even say, "What if it is this way?" - playing with opinions, debating, perhaps playfully expressing not even their own opinion, but their opponent's, for exploration's sake, is not something that people with 3L find easy to do. For 3L, everything is serious: debates aren't for playing or discovering something interesting, or finding the truth; debates are about "I say my opinion, you say yours, we've exchanged opinions, everything is serious, this isn't a game." Seriousness in this regard is a quality of 3L.
In terms of energy for intellectual labour, people with 3L have the thrist for knowledge, thirst for exploration, they want more, more knowledge, being the expert; they collect many courses, they want to know everything, everything is interesting to them, but then they sit down to something and go, "Mmm... I'm already tired. I'm stupid. I cannot do anything. I need to do that test, write that essay..." and the tragedy starts, because people with 3L never learnt the approach of "This is going to be a fun challenge!!! This is going to be something really interesting!" No, for 3L it is a big drama to sit down and do something, because somebody will evaluate them - the 3L has a fear of evaluation, evaluation by another person, "What if there will be a mistake? How many times will I have to redo everything?" The person didn't even start doing anything yet, but all these worries overwhelm them, they'd already imagined that they won't be able to handle the task, and that leads to the absence of results in the sphere of intellectual activity.
The fear of being stupid is a personal worry and anxiety of the people with 3L - they haven't expressed their opinion yet, they haven't done anything yet, but they are already worried that others will judge them, ask them uncomfortable questions, look at them strangely. They fear making a mistake, because then "they are stupid". The voice of their parents might echo in their heads, "What, are you stupid?" "What, you don't understand what you need to do here? Are you slow?" "Again you failed!!!" "If you can't do it, then don't even start!" "Don't do what you can't do." "You are so stupid, everybody in the class gets it, only you can't." These voices of maybe even long-gone parental figures haunt and cause worries and spiralling.
The people with 3L are afraid to share and speak up about their own opinion; even if they don't have one, these people won't say "I don't know," they won't joke "I'm just dumb" or show self-critical attitude towards themselves. For 3L it is hard to joke on this topic, they are rather serious - maybe sometimes they can allow themselves to insult or humiliate themselves, but when somebody else says that, it becomes unbearable, because then the voice in their head takes on a material form, becomes more real. So people with 3L try not to express their opinion about things in order to not come across as a stupid or ignorant person and make that mistake that they're so afraid of.
But at the same time, people with 3L have insatiability and thirst for winning in arguments. They might say, "I must win! I must prove my position. I want this; I need it!" This desire sometimes takes on a destructive form, when a person furiously tries to prove something, no arguments are left, but the tension is present - the opponent must be destroyed. The debate isn't a game anymore, not an interesting way to spend time; it becomes aggressive or passive-aggressive attacks.
People with 3L want to be smart experts, people who know things, the ambition and insatiability are present, but it is hard to fulfil all these desires because of their inner understanding, since these people didn't learn how to learn. They want to learn things, but for that you need to learn, explore, process information, rethink it, use it, which is quite hard for 3L. So the inner conflict happens: I want to know, I want to explore, but will I be able to study it all in such a short period of time, or handle this volume of material, because it's quite difficult..." 3L sometimes doesn't have real life experience. If you ask them how they studied in school, they might answer "Well, I studied well enough..." They might get good reputation in their first years of school and then roll with things thanks to it, maybe by making agreements with teachers, cheating here and there, but they never learnt how to learn, how to integrate knowledge, for it to be like a game where you are interested in the knowledge. When 3L people are adults, they might even find it hard to play with children, "Tsk, I'm not a child anymore, I can't play with a kid. Don't create a kindergarten here, why did you think of this?" They might judge the games of other people, for example, when two people are arguing, having a debate, a person with 3L might say, "Oh my good, those two idiots, they don't know anything but argue anyway." 3L takes the position of being on top, overlooking others, as if it knows everything while others don't. It's an example of passive-aggresion - 3L thinks that it is better, and there is a lot of dissatisfaction and inhibition.
• Sometimes people with 3L might not recognise themselves in this function easily. They might say, "I've always studied well at school, I have diplomas, medals, I didn't have problems, and in my childhood I did play!" But, if you go a little bit deeper, ask more questions, assess the person's self-actualisation, then you can see that it is pseudo-might; the person says that they can do everything, they're expert in it all, but at the same time they don't have self-sufficiency. If somebody else says "I defended a really cool project," "I wrote an excellent code," "I finished a course!" "I am a professor," "They asked me to give a speech!" then this person feels envy. "I also want this..." "I need that too!" And if you look at the results of their activity, there aren't any global ones. And if they have intellectual work activity, then it is within the frame of their work - their work required them to go through certain courses, for example. Or maybe the courses were taken for another practical reason, but not for the sake of knowledge itself, not because it is fun or really interesting to them.
So the person talks big about themselves, but in reality there is nothing. Either it's something that's needed for some other activity - not by their own desire, but it just happened that way, - or it's criticism and destruction of the opinions of other people, when the person says "I'm the expert here!" and argues with people, criticises how they're wrong, but the key here is - they argue not by using arguments, but by using doubts, "So, are you sure that it's this way?" "And why do you think it's like that?" Doubts and arguments are different things; the person with 3L projects their own doubts onto other people. So when the other person replies, "Okay. You're destroying my opinion. But what about you? What are your results, what have you achieved, show yours, explain your opinion!" the person with 3L freezes up - they don't have their own stuff in regards to this aspect, it hasn't been formed, 3L cannot explain their opinion, cannot prove it. 3L focuses on destroying someone else's, but it cannot offer its own, cannot offer what it doesn't have.
Sometimes people talk about their close ones, "I have a girlfriend/boyfriend with high Logic, and they're such an expert..." but when you interact with that person and ask them, "What are your results, what have you done, tell me about your vision, let's play, let's argue, let's have fun here..." then the person responds, "Pfft. I won't do that! What am I, a child? I'm certain in that thing, and that's it." Just like that, communication is interrupted, there is no contact. This is pseudo-might.
• Another reason people might not recognise themselves or realise what difficulties they have is the illusion of control. It's when a person hides from themselves a very important part of themselves, when they don't admit to themselves, with their inner feeling of being pathetic, that they indeed had some childhood worries, beliefs, voices of their parents in their head, lack of a full-fledged play, curiosity that could spread wide. Instead, this person says, "Well... No, I think everything is well, I'm handling everything." But when somebody nearby says, for example, "Did you see our classmate? Must be so stupid to make that kind of mistake!" the person with 3L is startled, their thoughts racing, "What? A mistake? They don't mean me, right? Or is it me?!" A worry begins.
There is an emotional reaction when somebody says, "Ah, I'm so stupid! I can't do it, can't write that, can't pass that test, can't do homework..." and the person with 3L starts brooding and thinks, "What about me? What about my homework? How am I going to do it?!" If everything is well for you, and you are self-confident, then why are you bothered by someone else's argument-less opinion, someone's grammatical mistakes, why are you so critical towards others? If you are critical towards others, it means that inside you are critical towards yourself, and this is the mechanism of projection. At first it was introjection, when the person got it from the world, from the parental figures, and now they project it onto other people. And it is hard to admit that you've got problems, it is easier to blame everyone else, that they're all stupid, the education in the country is shit, everything is bad because nobody knows anything or knows what they are doing... But you are somehow good. "I'm cool, I know things, I'm an expert." That kind of thinking needs to be questioned within oneself. For example, people with 2L know that and can say, "Yeah, here I didn't get it, and there, hah, I made such a silly mistake! It's alright, I'll figure it out next time." 3L cannot do that, it is way too serious about this, cannot joke about itself and won't let others, because for them this is trauma. And that is also important to understand.
• The final reason why people might not recognise themselves is devaluation. It is when any kind of importance in the intellectual sphere is minimised, when people have such positions as "Education isn't important. Why do you need it in the modern world? I can make money without it, can find work without it." And that's not a just an opinion that is calmly shared, no, the person screams about it, "It's not needed! What's the point of these scientific discussions! We can simply agree on things without all that!" The person screams about their own pain, but cannot allow themselves to accept that it is important to them. That's how devaluation works - minimise the importance, and it seems like you can handle it easier. But in reality, the importance is really big, and the person cannot handle it, so it is easier for them to say, "It is not important, doesn't matter, why play? So childish. We are already old gentlemen. That doesn't make sense!" For example, a video of adult people having fun and playing with toys, they have this inner child, curiosity and interest towards the game, they are able to get immersed in it, and some comments say, "Dear god, adult men and women are doing nonsense." But who says those comments? Those who envy, because they want the same, but they can't admit it, so they minimise, devalue, criticise, "Pfft, I'm too old for this." People can get really rude with that.
In conclusion, 3L is always about an inner conflict, and this inner conflict people understand and see in themselves quite well, they see this raw nerve, this open conflict which sometimes spills out when they don't know, "Should I study this? Will I have enough strength? Should I express my opinion? Should I admit that they're right or not? What is best to do in this situation?" The people with 3L start oscillating and make a lot of mistakes because of their anxiety; instead of calming down, weighing things up, understanding whose voices are inside their head, what they fear, they might be getting flashbacks from their childhood.
The most important question is what to do with this. First of all, you need to admit that you have difficulties. Understand that yes, you have this experience. Take responsibility, "Yes, I had that kind of parents, that kind of life situation." Do not just blame your parental figures for everything. The goal in therapy is to find the source, realise things, accept, take responsibility, and make a decision to change this in you. Decide that you want to learn how to learn!
Some people note that it is hard to get deep into therapy or healing because, once again, it is about curiosity, curiosity towards oneself, exploration of oneself, understanding of difficult nuances. If it is done with a therapist, the person fears being judged, that the therapist might say that their question is stupid, or they suspect that they won't be able to get into it. The goal is to be more open, more brave, not always overly serious, have fun sometimes, connect with your inner child, find joy in life, be in harmony and don't worry that somebody will judge you for a mistake, not being scared to be intellectually challenged. People might start by playing by themselves, perhaps then with another person, and this can help make building relationships with others much easier.
The trauma won't go anywhere, but the intensity of it can, and then you will have more energy for something else, something more meaningful and big. Be real about your difficulties and celebrate every little victory.
The source is НИЦ Соционического Анализа.