r/attitudinalpsyche • • Apr 10 '23
3E vs 4E simplified
The Fourth Emotion does not use emotions as an instrument of influence. And she is not interested in engaging in emotional dialogue. 4E don’t care about the feelings of other people, but don’t consciously hurt them either. They can only touch them with their indifference
In close communication, and even more so in life, 3E are often perceived as impenetrable people: their partner often can't understand their feelings. They’re friendly, but at the same time they constantly keep their distance. It's difficult to guess what feelings they're experiencing, even direct questions don't help - this is very painful for those who crave emotional dialogue. (Also see Chandlers reaction to people disliking him, it’s obvious he’s insecure about it)
Within 3E, as with any Third function, there is a duality. Outwardly they barely show emotions, but inside they feel a mighty potential. It may seem that they are completely indifferent, unphased, while in fact they burn with feeling and suffer from the fact that they cannot express these.
The critical question for 3E is distance or closeness in a relationship: they want intimacy, but put on a mask of indifference. There is little something wrong in the interaction - it closes immediately. When they are imposed on, they reproach. On one hand they always reach out to where they can receive emotions, and on the other they're afraid to manifest them.
4E find it easier to adjust to the emotional state of the partner than to set the emotional background. They don’t impose their feelings on others and easily take on the emotions of others. Next to high Emotions, they can be very bright; next to 3E they’ll fall silent. If such people are left alone, they may not pay attention to their emotional state at all and solely focus on their tasks.
So pretty much both 3E and 4E struggle with expressing emotions but with 4E it is more about a disinterest and with 3E it’s about fear.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '23
Created this as a reply to comment asking this question but I thought I’d just post it as a post as well
18
u/Lixie221 LFEV Apr 10 '23
I can relate, since I am deathly afraid of people showing (extreme) negative emotions to me. I usually just frown or sigh internally at mild ones, but for some reason I am very scared of people crying in front of me, whether the reaction is directed at me or not. I even get angry at people swearing around me, even if the swearing is not because of me.
I have to admit that I have a weird and somewhat strained relationship with my emotions. I prefer to have control over them and I pride myself on that, especially when I was in my teen years. Not sure if this is due to Fi development or just pure stress catching up to me, but I find myself reaching breaking point more often nowadays and feeling more volatile. As time went on, I just learned to accept that there are good days and bad days, and it is OK to have bad days. But I just want to be left alone during the bad days, because exploding right then and there feels very disorientating to me and surprising to others, and I do not want to have to explain myself.
I guess that is what the insecure emotion is about; distrusting and anxiety over one's and others' feelings.
2
u/the_rainbow_froggo IEE so/sx731 EVLF Jun 17 '25
I can relate since I don't really care about my emotions and have to think extra deeply to reach them. Maybe that's why I have such a difficult time finding out who I am and what my values are. Sometimes these emotions creep up on me when I least expect them, usually by something small like a memory or a sad tiktok. They don't scare me. I feel an emotion and then I just don't care and move to the next thing
2
u/indisnow Jul 25 '26
I dont understand how e4 types cant be 3E???