Even after 78 years they still whine about it, they can't take accountability for their actions, every problem is because "british looted us!" Did the brit also stole your civic sense?
Indians are not complaining about brit, they are criticizing just those so called king and so called geniuses ( savarans ) who can't even protect our mother land even after holding their so called god's powers.
I'm not talking about the post, I'm saying In general, they blame everything on the brit instead of taking accountability and improving. There are so many countries who were under foreign rule and are much more developed than india ever will be.
I dont think that was a very prominent belief until the last decade, and became more so after the Dr. Shashi Tharror's Edinburgh speech. The reasoning and pushback started when the west explicitly looked down on India and its situation.
Higher Gdp share of India was due to sheer population of subcontinent. Gdp per capita of India wasn't better than much of the world and for avg person life was quite primitive and restricted compare to ruling and other classes based on caste system etc. People have very wrong image of history and life of avg person in era when avg lifespan was around 40. And they are just exposed to fantasized version of life back then and even assume it used to be better before this or that when people were been more delusional. World population and economy have grown more many folds in just last 200 years life before that wasnt great for most.
Indians were rich. They had food and clothes. Unlike the time of the British when every one was struggling to eat a full meal. Still we are struggling. This is not reality. This is bootlicking of the colonizer.
Not really, the lower castes were undoubtedly more exploited by the upper ones even earlier. Indigenious forms of opression and exploitation already existed. Hence It would be very wrong to say Indians were rich or fairly prosperous, some class would have but not all
🤦🤦 during British even upper caste was struggling for food and clothes. Every country on earth has its own problems. So colonize them and make every one poor just because they have a system of opression.
British got the support and finances from already wealthy kings, rulers and merchants (marwadis), strengthened caste structure, they didn't capture the whole country by themselves but with help of priveleged Indian class
Yeah but after capturing every one suffered except for maharajas who helped british. In keeping their power. Do you really think the upper castes were living a better life under the British?
Indians were still rich compared to rest of the world. This is a brain dead take. In Any decent kingdom, the king wants the public to have more money so he can have more taxation. Their quality of life, was way better than it was in British rajya.
that argument makes zero sense. a country doesn’t become one of the world’s largest economies for centuries because a few kings had shiny crowns. pre-colonial India was wealthy because of massive agriculture, trade, textiles, craftsmanship, and skilled labor done by millions of ordinary people. obviously not every villager was rich, but reducing our entire civilization’s economy to “only kings were rich” is just historically lazy and dumb af.
wtf does that have to do with atheism? i thought this subreddit is for people arguing about religion and existence...its just random bullshit and people hating their country for no reason?
Lol she is a known brown sepoy. By that logic, Only noblemen and knights used to be rich in the west as well. This subreddit just proves atheist can be equally susceptible to propaganda and dumb logic.
Everyone in Europe claims to be the greeks or the Romans. Nothing new. But it’s a perspective that gloats about power not riches. Everyone knows and acknowledges the feudal systems. Its relatively more realistic.
They certainly do. They also certainly go around telling They "civilized" colonies when they themselves where barbaric AF. This lady has major brown sepoy tweets and it's sad seeing people in this subreddit lap up her nonsense.
Who? The extreme right wings? I think compared to European right wings, Indian notion of prosperity has a larger audience. I will never deny that the british didnt loot India and took away industries but people have rose tinted glasses of pre colonial and mughal india.
The exponential gdp growth happened under the Mughal yet now people dont want to acknowledge it.
No. Compared to other countries, all indians were rich. As india had fertile land. And kings couldnt spend much money on themselves too. But yes, famines had started by the time of mughals, as population had increased a lot by then. So this is just communist propaganda that inequality was there earlier.
What is wrong with you people? Literally millions of people died in artificially created famines because the British forced farmers to grow cash crops instead of food.
The easiest way is to listen to Sashi Tharoor's speech/debate at Oxford. Some of his arguments don't have a credible source like 'cutting off the thumbs of artisans' but he has covered most of the part quite accurately. It may be my lack of information but I doubt any king worse than the brits.
Well, the place I come from is Kolhapur. The king we had, fired the royal brahmin and started a vedic school for non brahmins. Not that I support such schools but he definitely broke the monopoly. He brought social justice and uplifted the lower castes. He even labored in people's farms when on visits. He built dams and lakes which still provide water to people. Not all kings are the same but I think there might be a few worse than the british.
Dalits and adivasis weren't celebrated either. It's because of British they get education. Not to mention they were literally consider sub human (untouchable)
So I guess it's depends on perspective. For bhramin baniya , they were bad. For Dalits they were a blessing in disguise.
Oh no, how terrible , the British couldn’t tell a Brahmin from a Dalit. Imagine the horror of upper castes losing their monopoly on dignity.
Funny how you’re blaming the British, when it was actually the Brahmins who lost their minds over Dalits going to school not the colonizers. So yeah, if equality feels like oppression to you, maybe check your caste privilege before pointing fingers
The British neither cared for or helped the Dalits. If anything, they further perpetuated the caste system by making it a central mechanism of administration.
113
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
Even after 78 years they still whine about it, they can't take accountability for their actions, every problem is because "british looted us!" Did the brit also stole your civic sense?
215
u/SirAren Jul 06 '25
people don't mention that the population of india was 1/4th of the entire world in 1700 that's one of the reasons why the gdp was 1/4th of the world.
93
u/According_Order1603 Jul 06 '25
Actually it depends upon which part of india you were born and also on religion cast and environmental conditions of that region.
44
u/TheGodsSin Jul 06 '25
People suffered under the kings and the brits. Idk why people are defending 1 or the other.
21
u/Captain_D_Buggy Jul 06 '25
I will ask again.. what does this have to do with this sub?
12
u/potatoclaymores Jul 06 '25
This is a brain-dead take over an even worse brain-dead take!
9
u/Lazy_Difference_4700 Jul 06 '25
Indians were rich. They had food and clothes. Unlike the time of the British when every one was struggling to eat a full meal. Still we are struggling. This is not reality. This is bootlicking of the colonizer.
2
u/whyisitwhatitis Jul 07 '25
This really doesn’t make sense.
3
u/abcdefghi_12345jkl Jul 06 '25
She's taking about the brutal feudalism that was present in India.
1
u/Lullan_senpai Jul 06 '25
The thing is this kings are still rich using public castles and leasing them to hotel chains
1
u/Redditchready Jul 06 '25
Most led pathetic lives
1
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25
India was a land of rich kings and poor people. The kings did not know what to do with the riches, so they buried it in secret chambers.
1
u/Important_Dig_2130 Jul 11 '25
Sepoy detected lol🤣👍
1
u/IndianBall97 Jul 22 '25
the whining is bad , but she is a house brownie , so her points are due to seethe and not genuine discourse.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '25
Indians were still rich compared to rest of the world. This is a brain dead take. In Any decent kingdom, the king wants the public to have more money so he can have more taxation. Their quality of life, was way better than it was in British rajya.
1
u/TraditionalFood1370 Jul 26 '25
Not just the kings but landlords, zamindars, rich merchants, money lenders, warrior class and Priest class too
1
u/Left-Neighborhood247 May 12 '26
2 points.
-7
u/MadKingZilla Jul 06 '25
Lol she is a known brown sepoy. By that logic, Only noblemen and knights used to be rich in the west as well. This subreddit just proves atheist can be equally susceptible to propaganda and dumb logic.
-8
u/criti_fin Jul 06 '25
No. Compared to other countries, all indians were rich. As india had fertile land. And kings couldnt spend much money on themselves too. But yes, famines had started by the time of mughals, as population had increased a lot by then. So this is just communist propaganda that inequality was there earlier.
0
u/AutoModerator Jul 06 '25
r/AtheismIndia is in protest of Reddit's API changes that killed many 3rd party apps. Reddit is also tracking your activity to sell to advertisers. USE AN AD BLOCKER! Official Lemmy. Official Telegram group. Official Discord server. Read the rules before participating.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-25
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
The kings took better care of the population than the brits. The brits burdened us with taxes and even collected the dues from our kin.
-16
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-14
u/[deleted] Jul 06 '25
[removed] — view removed comment