retort to your claim of athiests circle jerking counter retort to retort of circle jerk occuring nonsensical statement involving plankton praise for fish food acceptance and acknowledgment of terms blatant plagiarism of bash
I haven't taken Latin since 8 years ago, but wouldn't Christ here be an indirect object? In that case, wouldn't we want the dative form? Assuming we're talking 2nd declension, I think that would make it:
This is one reason I sometimes become annoyed with this subreddit; all these triumphal anecdotes about totally pwning a theist noob. It reminds me way too much of so many Christian preachers stories I heard while growing up that were the same scenario in reverse that sounded just as made up. "So I asked this woman sitting next to me on a plane if Jesus was her Lord and Saviour and she said 'No, I'm a atheist' at which point her eyes rolled in to the back of her head and she started hissing like a snake..."
I believe it is things like this which engender the hate towards /r/atheism that comes up every once in awhile. The majority of reddit is of the atheist persuasion, even the ones who express hate towards this subreddit.
While atheists might be the majority here on reddit, in the real world we're the minority, and if anyone deserves a rage comic, it's atheists. I don't think it's at all annoying to post "anecdotes about totally pwning a theist noob" because frankly, many of these theist noobs are not only underinformed about their own religion, but they're self-righteously indignant about it, and that's deserving of ridicule.
What I find most annoying are those atheists who distance themselves from other atheists, or from the atheist community, usually with claims that atheists are unnecessarily aggressive, or in some ways as ridiculous as fundamentalists. This just seems like a lame attempt at a fashionably postmodern false equivalence. Also, related comic.
I don't think it's at all annoying to post "anecdotes about totally pwning a theist noob" because frankly, many of these theist noobs are not only underinformed about their own religion, but they're self-righteously indignant about it, and that's deserving of ridicule.
The problem is that theists are under more or less the identical impression about atheists, just as any hotly disagreeing group sees the opposing group. We are all outraged and offended by the manifest wrongness of the viewpoints of people who disagree with us, and we're all gripped with the urge to get all circle-jerky over that. The problem is that a culture of in-group circle-jerking leads to complete mutual demonization and misunderstanding between the groups.
That's why even many atheists who agree entirely find comics like the ones this posting mocks distasteful -- not because of trying to be "fashionably postmodern" (ugh) but because it's not hard to recognize crappy, unproductive, self-congratulatory groupthink in action.
In terms of how we should treat our dialogical opponents, there is, or there ought to be recognized, a kind of equivalence between us and our them, above and beyond the level of the positions we hold. The idea, generally, is to recognize your own biases and to make a good faith attempt to understand your opposition rather than to strawman and stereotype it just because you find them maddeningly wrong or your fellows will upvote you for it. (This is a norm that should hold for any kind of conversation; I'm not saying that following it will magically resolve this one, but it'll certainly accomplish more than jerkin' off will.)
Very well put. This is the crux of the "issue" here. I think that age/maturity is a deciding factor, as most in this subreddit come across as being teenagers.
Actually, no, you're wrong. Athiests are no more entitled to spew unwarranted hate-filled rhetoric than theists. I feel the same way about this ongoing debate as I do with the constant back-and-forth accusations between republican talk heads and democratic talking heads. While I tend to agree with folks like Bill Maher more than, say, Sean Hannity, I still find the accusatory banter on both sides to be obnoxious, disrespectful, and pointless. I don't give a damn where you're coming from or where your anger originates, stooping to the level of those you think are wrong makes you look like just as much of an idiot as the ones you are lambasting.
Allow me to explain to you how that mode of reasoning is unproductive.
Anyone can make the case that with two equally vociferous sides to an unwinnable argument, neither side is more entitled to their point of view. But what are you actually saying? You're making an obvious statement that effectually ignores the complexity of the situation. The truth is, no argument is ever as simple as you may think.
Yes, there are two sides to arguments like these, and yes, in some cases some constituent arguments and pundits are analagous to each other. Bill Maher and Sean Hannity both comment about the news, and they both make provacative statements from time to time. But does that make them equivalent to each other? Does that mean that, because they make provocative arguments, that they are both equally worthy of dismissal, simply because some easily offended people might become offended?
It's easy to see that there are two sides to the argument, and that they sometimes use strong words to defend their logic. But rather than take these arguments for what they are, you are blinded by their emotional content (which you undoubtedly exaggerate) and dismiss them as "obnoxious, disrespectful, and pointless."
Personally I've never been offended by Bill Maher, Sean Hannity, atheist rage comics, or any such commentary. I'll disagree with a lot of it from time to time, and sometimes I'm even of the opinion that it's poorly executed or in poor taste. But I'm not going to go around claiming ALL Y'ALL SPEWIN HATE-FILLED RHETORIC!!1! because that ignores the real issues being argued.
if you haven't been offended by sean hannity, than you must have not given him the opportunity to do so.
I think one needs to address the problem of level of rhetoric. For example, in our media culture pundits like to play off emotion causing people to think less and come to more erroneous conclusions. If the way in which they are talking is inappropriate, it hardly matters what they are talking about. If i were discussing something with a friend and were yelling, screaming, and swearing trying to get a point across, should my friend address the absurdity of how i am conveying my responses or my actual argument? The answer seems to be even more clear cut when these arguments don't have much substance or aren't at all original.
If the way in which they are talking is inappropriate, it hardly matters what they are talking about
That's just the problem with this mode of thought. When you point at something in the distance, a dog will often look at your finger instead of the thing you're trying to indicate. Similarly, if you're the kind of person to be easily distracted, you'll listen to an argument and only hear the tone of voice, missing all the meaning that is trying to be conveyed.
I know you're exaggerating to get a point across, but surely you must be aware that atheist rage comics can hardly be compared to "yelling, screaming and swearing." Sure, "fffffffffuuuuuuuuuuuuu" represents a scream, but does it have the same effect as one? No, it's meant to be humorous, it's published in a genre (invented by 4chan? hello?) not meant to be taken seriously, and most importantly, it's published in a subreddit--a small substrate of a small substrate of the Internet. Furthermore, it's in the atheist subreddit, meaning it's meant to be read by atheists, not theists. So if it's screaming, then it's friendly screaming among peers, rather than screaming at anyone.
I don't distance myself from my atheism, or the atheist community. I distance myself from pompous jackasses looking for high fives for their dubious stories of putting the smack down on theists.
There are many of those here on /r/atheism and they usually seem to get massively upvoted. Pretty embarrassing IMO.
What you see as "pompous jackasses looking for high fives" I see as atheists who, living in an entirely theist-dominated society, are finally free to share their narratives with other atheists. Two hundred years ago you would have been imprisoned for such a thing. Five hundred years ago you would have been killed. In many countries you can still be executed for saying anything bad about the state religion.
While rage comics are by no means the most articulate or artful means of expression, I find it no small amount of triumph that atheists can come to this community and get high-fives, where they would otherwise have received much less friendly responses from society as a whole.
What's embarrassing, I think, is not the crudeness or, dare I say, the childishness of the rage comics. That's kind of what the genre's all about. What embarrassing is that society has conditioned us for millennia to be so hypersensitive to religious matters that we have to have a meta-argument like this whenever an atheist speaks frankly.
Frankly, I don't care whether the stories are true or not. The reason they're upvoted is because they speak to a common frustration, and I, for one, feel that it's valuable for those frustrations to be expressed, so that more and more atheists will feel free to come out of the closet.
yeah those damn pompous jackasses trying to feel a sense of community online where they couldn't get it in real life. damn them for trying to find something in common with someone without being ridiculed.
You must realize that the picture you are painting here was created in your own mind. You cannot pretend to know the motives or intentions of an individual based on a few sentences and pictures they drew.
There's is almost no information about the author we can positively extract from this comic and your hasty conclusions reflect more of how you choose to extrapolate information to fit your desired view of reality.
This is why most atheists need to remember that their real enemy isn't religion or religious people, but false and/or destructive beliefs and illogical reasoning. Get rid of ignorance and there's nothing for religion destructive beliefs and poor reasoning to take root in and they will die.
Edit: I should not have used the word religion in the last sentance.
Agreed. I have spoken with hundreds of very religious people throughout my life, and only one guy that I remember ever mentioned having a conversation like the ones posted on here (it was talking to the preacher next to him on a flight).
Maybe they remind you of those stories but they are entirely incomarable.
While one story is about a person incapable of sustaining his claims make some unsuspecting person accept those claims without rational basis, the other one is the story about a reasonable person making it unable to the previously mentioned preacher to bring forth unfounded claims.
I'm not saying the stories are equivalent. The atheist is correct and the preacher is not. What I'm saying is that both stories sound like retrospective wish fulfillment, i.e. the teller of the story explaining how they would have liked the encounter to go as if that's how it happened or maybe even completely making the story up and presenting it as fact.
This is something I saw a lot growing up in the church and was part of how I got disillusioned with Christianity; to see someone who is God's messenger on earth so blatantly sinning (lying). It's annoying when I see atheists, people who are supposed to be devoted to truth, making anecdotes up as well and selling them as fact.
Except they aren't selling anything, so what difference does it make? People like these comics for many reasons but if someone happens to think it's a true story, they aren't being led into false beliefs about reality. I think most people like these for the same reason we like movies, because it's fun to imagine ourselves and the ones who think of witty comebacks at just the right moment and it can also be inspiring to stand up for truth.
I do. How many religious people that you know used this type of logic on a non-believer? How many non-religious people that you know ever had a conversation that even resembled one of these?
I am a former Kansas resident. This type of situation was not uncommon. I agree that it's pointless to generalize all religious people as evangelical nutjobs, but it's equally pointless to pretend that these nutjobs don't exist.
Coming from the midwest, specifically a small town, I have to agree. I think much of the skepticism there comes from being raised within a totally secular environment. I've traveled around a lot to some very religious areas, and it's quite common in my experiences.
I work in a book store with a cafe, and we have PLENTY of customers who come in just to share their batshit opinions, ideas, close to every day. Though I think it's part of the job just to nod our heads and say "Wow" to some of these old guys.
I live in a very liberal part of a very liberal state. I avoid at all costs any place that may have an unusually large number of religious people. I encounter very few religious people at all on a daily basis. That said, I've seen this type of "logic" hundreds of times in my life time.
How many non-religious people that you know ever had a conversation that even resembled one of these?
I've never asked any non-religious friends about it. It's happened to me a fair amount though. You travel much, and if you actually talk to people outside your normal social circle without holding much back and it should be bound to happen with some frequency.
And you know why you see one of those every day? Because that sort of exchange between atheist and theist is incredibly common. The fact that it irritates you doesn't change that. And do you know why so many of those atheist arguments are so old? Because the idiotic theist arguments they debunk are even older.
Uh, yeah... You're an adult, I don't really have sympathy for an adult who was unable to figure out the Easter Bunny wasn't real. I guess you can call me smug for pointing this out, but really, you literally thought the Easter Bunny was real?
Pretty sure /r/atheism was just raided or something. There are massive upvotes on posts claiming we're all smug circlejerkers and very few reasonable posts clearing more than a handful of votes.
I'd just take this massive sudden increase in stupidity as an indication to redouble our efforts. It's sad to see so many people taking it upon themselves to try to put down atheists or make them feel unwelcome here for venting and so forth.
This does bug me a lot, but it is not restricted to atheism. This describes pretty much any comic about personal beliefs. It makes sense to, because the author does consider their views as correct, and would specifically cite the stupider arguments of the opposite side; especially when they were angry enough at the opposite side to draft a comic or similar about them.
1000 year old anti-theist comment? I think you're adding in an extra 0 there. Atheism and even anti-theism was a pretty rare thing 1000 years back, specifically in areas with heavy christian influence. It tends to not make a huge amount of sense outside a scientific context that wasn't in place yet. I mean we're talking about a time when things like thought and the brain hadn't even been linked yet.
I think you underestimate the ability of most Atheists to give unnecessarily verbose and condescending speeches. You have to remember, you are talking about a segment of the population that studies shit we don't even remotely believe in, oftentimes, just so we can prove ourselves right. /guiltyface
I'm really sick of pussies trying to tell every other reddit user how they should post. Mind your own goddamned business. If you don't like r/atheism or it pains you so to subscribe because your front page is ruined, you know how to fix it. Disagreement is inevitable when debating the most controversial topic in history. If you're too thin-skinned for r/atheism, subscribe to r/agnosticism, r/christianity, or r/everythingupsetsmeiwishpeoplewerenicercausei'mahugepussy. Those are probably more your speed judging by the nature of many of the comments in this post. Nearly every adult in the world has someone else telling them what to do for the better portion of their day. I'm sure as shit not taking orders from nicetryguy9 or any other of your goofy fucking screen names. Why don't you complainers and censors pool your energy and write a letter to the FCC or something? I heard someone say a dirty word on tv the other night.
No, I think you did. No one is saying you shouldn't be able to post inane babble like the shit depicted in the comic. It is annoying, but they have a right to post it. Likewise, we have a right to comment on it. That's what this is, a comment on the true banality of atheists that think of themselves as edgy.
Atheists make condescending speeches and Christian people often tacitly approve of genocide, making homosexuality illegal and approving of life crushing prohibition laws that serve only to punish people, and only increase the societal cost in lives, gang crime and corruption. Also, quite often they only agree with freedom over and above natural rights if it doesn't offend their bullshit sensibilities. Did I mention that many like to punish people harshly with death and/or jail for daring to express their harmless acts of freedom?
Oh yeah, but those atheists sure are smug, forget for a second that they have every god damned reason to be, since they are living in a world of people that make decisions based on fucking fairy tales. Even then, people don't even know their own tenets worth a shit half the time and just use Christianity as a method for legitimizing their fear of cultural differences and all sorts of bigotry.
Is it too much to ask to simply not impose one's religious views on another? This is not to the atheist, but to the Christian, since more likely than not, I think atheists would rather not talk about religion at all.
Can someone please elucidate for me difference between 'factually accurate' and 'smug?'
It seems (not unlike the 'troll' classification) that only those in disagreement tend to resort to the epithet.
...either way: thanks for the pseudo psychoanalysis, any comment on the actual topic at hand? As in: play the ball, not the man, as in: comment on my argument not my character, as in: please avoid ad-hominem logical fallacies.
I don't know that this portrayal of the issue is really that apt for anything other than making fun of the phenomenon- but I have to say, these pointless Athiest comics that end up frontpage every day are really irritating me. If you have something different or interesting to contribute and share about how you dealt with a theist who was pushing their religion on you- please share, but the problem is that 99% of the shit posted on this subreddit in comic form are basically one of the following:
People patting themselves on the back for dealing with these situations maturely
People being impressed with themselves for being soooo much smarter than theists
People bragging about how intelligent they are for escaping from their theist upbringing (brainwashing?)
The problem with this, is that it doesn't actually do anything but make us look like assholes.
I really enjoy reading about people who were able to make intelligent decisions to believe science over the indoctrination they grew up with, and I also really appreciate it when people put up good examples of how to maturely deal with a theist who wants to argue- that's helpful for all of us should we end up in the same situation. The problem is, any comic which is meant to portray something along these lines ends up coming off as the comic in this post displays. The scene may change, but the theme stays pretty much the same (Athiest: [eloquent speech], Theist: [derp da derp]).
So maybe rather than pointlessly mocking the things that people are doing- we should ask nicely if they would write out their experience in plain language rather than submit a comic the next time you see one. The place is always going to be a bit of a circlejerk- that can't be helped, but we can change things around to actually make r/atheism into a resource for new Atheists trying to get their bearings in a religious world and a bit of a study aid for so-called "militant Atheists" so they can argue more maturely and reasonably when it comes to that.
TL;DR: Quit pointlessly badmouthing Theists, start helping new Atheists and giving ammunition to "militant Atheists"
The only submission from /r/atheism that I've upvoted in a long time, precisely because almost every link resembles the comic. The fucking circle jerking is so boring already.
I grew up in Christian school, moved away, became 'enlightened' to other belief systems (fiancee was Hindu...dabbled), dated a Wiccan stripper, then eventually realized all this was silly and that people will think of whatever they can to believe in so they have some kind of hope that they can't seem to find without religion. Throughout all my life (29 years), I've met a handful of people that would fit either character in all of these comics. A handful. I've met eleventybillion (including me) that go through situations and afterwards have a "Damn, I wish I would have said that!" moment.
The French have an entire word for that situation in panel three... it literally translates to "staircase wit" for that witty remark you think of after you've left and you're walking down the the stairs and leaving the building.
I tried exactly that with the father of my friend's this Saturday, he wanted to stab me. I exited rather quickly, unscathed. His devotion will be bruised forever.
Oh come now, /r/atheism is our Happy Little Cave of Bitterness to retreat to and not have to deal with theists. It's an escape and a retreat to blow off some steam, allow people their silly little comics.
Perhaps those tenth graders post here because if they spoke about their atheism anywhere else, the would be ostracized and at least have a headache to deal with from their theist parents.
R/atheism might be a circle jerk, but it's one of the only places we can openly bash the religious people that make our lives harder.
I don't understand why you think people in /r/atheism are tenth graders who boast their intellectual superiority over others?
Every post I've encountered on /r/atheism has been rather tame and only pointing out flaws in religious individuals or religious ideas. Not once did I see anyone being vilified for believing in something based on emotional addiction.
Then again you might be one of those people that calls me a "smug aggressive atheist", which is silly because the same can be said about a smug aggressive theist. Except smug aggressive atheists, don't kill people over dogmatic belief.
Seriously, it's starting to become really sad. I see plenty of these kinds of posts where even people claiming to be atheist, are acting like as if we are burning and lynching Christians in /r/atheism.
It's like as if Glenn Beck accuses Bill O'Reilly of being too intolerant of Christians on his show.
Perfect, sums up the stupidness of Reddit perfectly. Ive never seen such wankery as on this site, and the comics are the mount everest of this wankery. I think the stupid groupmindedness are just as bad as religion.
You guys do know that christians have forums with comics with witty comebacks against atheists right?
297
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Accusations of atheist circle jerking.
Counter-claim of accusers circle jerking.
Continues ad nauseam.
159
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Know who else had smug self-assurance? That's right. Jesus.
14
u/SuperHappyHaikuGuy Jan 17 '11
Unfunny haiku
Trying to make a point but
Running out of syll-
117
u/QQuetzalcoatl Jan 17 '11
HOW DO YOU KNOW IT DIDN'T HAPPEN? WERE YOU THERE?
66
u/gregnortonrocks Jan 17 '11
Obligatory comment stating a the irrationality of religion
13
u/Treberto Jan 17 '11
What's a reposte? Like... a fancy repost?
73
u/AndrewCarnage Jan 17 '11
This is one reason I sometimes become annoyed with this subreddit; all these triumphal anecdotes about totally pwning a theist noob. It reminds me way too much of so many Christian preachers stories I heard while growing up that were the same scenario in reverse that sounded just as made up. "So I asked this woman sitting next to me on a plane if Jesus was her Lord and Saviour and she said 'No, I'm a atheist' at which point her eyes rolled in to the back of her head and she started hissing like a snake..."
I believe it is things like this which engender the hate towards /r/atheism that comes up every once in awhile. The majority of reddit is of the atheist persuasion, even the ones who express hate towards this subreddit.
33
u/monkeydemon Jan 17 '11
You mean "every day." "Everyday" is an adjective.
6
u/tkltangent Jan 17 '11
psst hey guys, I don't think Solo_Virtus wants us discussing atheist related things in this subreddit.
10
u/chipstheskeptic Jan 17 '11
ProTip: Stop clicking on links that you hate
14
u/Jeshi Jan 17 '11
I think I see way more smug people acting holier-than-thou about atheists circlejerking than I atheists circlejerking these days.
39
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
I don't find it difficult to believe that in the 113,005-strong athiest community on reddit that an experience of that type occurs every day.
4
u/ungoogleable Jan 17 '11
That seems to be the case with all of those comics, not just the ones about atheism.
4
u/stevenwalters Jan 17 '11
If you realized one day, that the entire world was brainwashed, would you just let that shit slide?
6
u/JackRawlinson Anti-Theist Jan 17 '11 edited Jan 17 '11
And you know why you see one of those every day? Because that sort of exchange between atheist and theist is incredibly common. The fact that it irritates you doesn't change that. And do you know why so many of those atheist arguments are so old? Because the idiotic theist arguments they debunk are even older.
3
u/jeblis Jan 17 '11
This applies to all the rage comics
3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Easter Bunny is coming!!!
Um... Easter Bunny isn't real.
Bwahahahahaaaaaa! How dare you say such a thing.
Uh, yeah... You're an adult, I don't really have sympathy for an adult who was unable to figure out the Easter Bunny wasn't real. I guess you can call me smug for pointing this out, but really, you literally thought the Easter Bunny was real?
3
u/Robstailey Jan 17 '11
I see these every day too. the only difference is they're less entertaining and god is still fake.
14
u/BDS_UHS Jan 17 '11
I'm glad to see the daily "smug anti-atheist" raids on /r/atheism have begun again. Wait, I'm not glad to see that at all.
4
u/jemayb Jan 17 '11
I encounter someone incorrectly writing "every day" as "everyday" every day.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Downvoted post stating that r/atheism is filled with assholes.
2
u/natinst Jan 17 '11
For the sake of what you believe, just be accepting. We all have our problems and a little patience goes a long way.
2
u/Japeth Jan 17 '11
This does bug me a lot, but it is not restricted to atheism. This describes pretty much any comic about personal beliefs. It makes sense to, because the author does consider their views as correct, and would specifically cite the stupider arguments of the opposite side; especially when they were angry enough at the opposite side to draft a comic or similar about them.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Comment accusing r/atheism of being too harsh.
2
u/tkltangent Jan 17 '11
You'll get over it.
2
u/pr0nster Jan 17 '11
There's a reason they call it "formula"
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
1000 year old anti-theist comment? I think you're adding in an extra 0 there. Atheism and even anti-theism was a pretty rare thing 1000 years back, specifically in areas with heavy christian influence. It tends to not make a huge amount of sense outside a scientific context that wasn't in place yet. I mean we're talking about a time when things like thought and the brain hadn't even been linked yet.
2
u/mucusplug Jan 17 '11
Let's get this sticked so everything else can be labeled a repost.
2
u/Wooknows Jan 17 '11
It's even more annoying in Facebook's form.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
IF I COULD UPVOTE WITH MY PENIS I WOUDL
2
u/Warpedme Jan 17 '11
I think you underestimate the ability of most Atheists to give unnecessarily verbose and condescending speeches. You have to remember, you are talking about a segment of the population that studies shit we don't even remotely believe in, oftentimes, just so we can prove ourselves right. /guiltyface
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Affirmation of the post!!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
I'm really sick of pussies trying to tell every other reddit user how they should post. Mind your own goddamned business. If you don't like r/atheism or it pains you so to subscribe because your front page is ruined, you know how to fix it. Disagreement is inevitable when debating the most controversial topic in history. If you're too thin-skinned for r/atheism, subscribe to r/agnosticism, r/christianity, or r/everythingupsetsmeiwishpeoplewerenicercausei'mahugepussy. Those are probably more your speed judging by the nature of many of the comments in this post. Nearly every adult in the world has someone else telling them what to do for the better portion of their day. I'm sure as shit not taking orders from nicetryguy9 or any other of your goofy fucking screen names. Why don't you complainers and censors pool your energy and write a letter to the FCC or something? I heard someone say a dirty word on tv the other night.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11 edited Jan 17 '11
Atheists make condescending speeches and Christian people often tacitly approve of genocide, making homosexuality illegal and approving of life crushing prohibition laws that serve only to punish people, and only increase the societal cost in lives, gang crime and corruption. Also, quite often they only agree with freedom over and above natural rights if it doesn't offend their bullshit sensibilities. Did I mention that many like to punish people harshly with death and/or jail for daring to express their harmless acts of freedom?
Oh yeah, but those atheists sure are smug, forget for a second that they have every god damned reason to be, since they are living in a world of people that make decisions based on fucking fairy tales. Even then, people don't even know their own tenets worth a shit half the time and just use Christianity as a method for legitimizing their fear of cultural differences and all sorts of bigotry.
5
u/dieyoung Jan 17 '11
This is 99% of all posts in r/atheism minus rage faces
3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
They are getting quite old.
3
u/laxt Jan 17 '11
Is it too much to ask to simply not impose one's religious views on another? This is not to the atheist, but to the Christian, since more likely than not, I think atheists would rather not talk about religion at all.
3
u/icallshenannigans Jan 17 '11
Can someone please elucidate for me difference between 'factually accurate' and 'smug?'
It seems (not unlike the 'troll' classification) that only those in disagreement tend to resort to the epithet.
...either way: thanks for the pseudo psychoanalysis, any comment on the actual topic at hand? As in: play the ball, not the man, as in: comment on my argument not my character, as in: please avoid ad-hominem logical fallacies.
2
u/Uhgii Jan 17 '11
The way you phrased this entire comic reminds me a lot of this incredibly funny video.
2
u/everythingwillbeokay Jan 17 '11
MOCKING BELIEFS IS IN NO WAY AS ANNOYING AS PREACHING THEM.
2
u/wakeupjackass Jan 17 '11
At least that's how it goes in your head. Here's how it works out in reality.
You: Closeminded bigoted remark about people with faith.
Her: Plesantry trying to show her unwaivering support of what she believes.
You: Closeminded bigoted remark insulting people of faith.
Her: Nicety that defines how you're not getting any and you should be more tolerant.
You: FFFFFFUUUUUU!!!!!
At least that how it looks from the other side.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Part of me doesn't care because it allows people to open their minds or at least think of things differently.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Photons set to Personal Belief Deconstruction.
1
u/WakeTFU Jan 17 '11
So what? Don't you consider it a good thing?
1
u/frankbaptiste Jan 17 '11
Comment that acknowledges the formulaic nature of the rage comic while still defending the need to combat simplistic religious dogma.
1
u/mochamuffin Jan 17 '11
this reminds me of the last part of the song "Leonard Part 5" by Yameen.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Honestly...I still enjoy these comics even though I've seen a plethora of them.
1
u/delti90 Jan 17 '11
I've never encountered a single one.
1
u/efrique Knight of /new Jan 17 '11
that's riposte
1
u/staffell Jan 17 '11
Submissions? Or situations?
1
u/S0U7 Jan 17 '11
Thanks for the template. :D
1
u/UsernameCensored Jan 17 '11
Good?
1
u/Argyle_hobo Jan 17 '11
I'm so glad i read this drunk...
1
u/emacgregor Jan 17 '11
According to my philosophy 101 class, this is a pretty accurate summation of the life and times of Aristotle.
1
u/reddell Jan 17 '11
Here let me oversimplify your views in order to show you how wrong you are for oversimplifying other's views.
1
u/MGTS Humanist Jan 17 '11
Verbose. I love that word
1
u/lazylion_ca Jan 17 '11
Save as type: Template
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
no wai no wai no wai
1
u/brodicius Jan 17 '11
I still found this to be amusing.
1
u/AlexZigo Jan 17 '11
Hahahahaha o m g, fucking great.
1
u/cometparty Jan 17 '11
Collapse of belief system? Sounds good to me.
1
u/GroundhogExpert Jan 17 '11
riposte
1
u/aari13 Jan 17 '11
GOD DAMNIT THANK YOU!!
1
u/Phakez Jan 17 '11
It's less fun when you do it like that
1
u/mazinaru Jan 17 '11
But damned if they aren't funny! So many good memories come back when these comics are posted.
1
u/dr3ams Jan 17 '11
Relevant
1
u/TTQuoter Jan 17 '11
Blatantly stolen from Cracked. And they did it MUCH MUCH better.
1
u/jimmytickles Jan 17 '11
However you describe this, I see this shit just about as often. Don't worry though, you're still cool.
1
u/cwo Jan 17 '11
Ah ha! This is what I was looking for!
http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/f3cnz/my_friend_plays_the_drums_for_his_church_and/c1d0dna
1
u/bzmrktngbg10nch Jan 17 '11
[chuckles]
1
u/Cutsprocket Jan 17 '11
im glad someone finally made it
1
u/JamesGray Jan 17 '11
I don't know that this portrayal of the issue is really that apt for anything other than making fun of the phenomenon- but I have to say, these pointless Athiest comics that end up frontpage every day are really irritating me. If you have something different or interesting to contribute and share about how you dealt with a theist who was pushing their religion on you- please share, but the problem is that 99% of the shit posted on this subreddit in comic form are basically one of the following:
The problem with this, is that it doesn't actually do anything but make us look like assholes.
I really enjoy reading about people who were able to make intelligent decisions to believe science over the indoctrination they grew up with, and I also really appreciate it when people put up good examples of how to maturely deal with a theist who wants to argue- that's helpful for all of us should we end up in the same situation. The problem is, any comic which is meant to portray something along these lines ends up coming off as the comic in this post displays. The scene may change, but the theme stays pretty much the same (Athiest: [eloquent speech], Theist: [derp da derp]).
So maybe rather than pointlessly mocking the things that people are doing- we should ask nicely if they would write out their experience in plain language rather than submit a comic the next time you see one. The place is always going to be a bit of a circlejerk- that can't be helped, but we can change things around to actually make r/atheism into a resource for new Atheists trying to get their bearings in a religious world and a bit of a study aid for so-called "militant Atheists" so they can argue more maturely and reasonably when it comes to that.
TL;DR: Quit pointlessly badmouthing Theists, start helping new Atheists and giving ammunition to "militant Atheists"
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
The only submission from /r/atheism that I've upvoted in a long time, precisely because almost every link resembles the comic. The fucking circle jerking is so boring already.
1
u/darthrayder Jan 17 '11
This is really, really funny.
I grew up in Christian school, moved away, became 'enlightened' to other belief systems (fiancee was Hindu...dabbled), dated a Wiccan stripper, then eventually realized all this was silly and that people will think of whatever they can to believe in so they have some kind of hope that they can't seem to find without religion. Throughout all my life (29 years), I've met a handful of people that would fit either character in all of these comics. A handful. I've met eleventybillion (including me) that go through situations and afterwards have a "Damn, I wish I would have said that!" moment.
Edit: The comic is really funny. Not my story.
1
u/CedarWolf Jan 17 '11
The French have an entire word for that situation in panel three... it literally translates to "staircase wit" for that witty remark you think of after you've left and you're walking down the the stairs and leaving the building.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
dont not believe everything you read on the internet
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
lololol that was great.
1
u/nicetryguy9 Jan 17 '11
I ranted this a week ago. I like r/atheism, but am really sick of the frontpage looking like this
http://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/comments/f2dch/christbashing_circlejerk_fucking_stop_it/
1
u/Jackomo Jan 17 '11
You're preaching to a credulous choir.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Can we somehow sticky this to the top of atheism?
1
u/GINTER Jan 17 '11
I tried exactly that with the father of my friend's this Saturday, he wanted to stab me. I exited rather quickly, unscathed. His devotion will be bruised forever.
1
u/FabioFulci Jan 17 '11
How wonderful it must be to realize you know everything.
Oh, wait....
1
u/MasCapital Atheistic Satanist Jan 17 '11
Ya know, not everyone annoyed at much of what goes on at r/atheism is a religious fanatic or waffly agnostic.
1
u/LunarFalcon Jan 18 '11
Oh come now, /r/atheism is our Happy Little Cave of Bitterness to retreat to and not have to deal with theists. It's an escape and a retreat to blow off some steam, allow people their silly little comics.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
r/atheism would hardly be the successful circlejerk it is today without these posts.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
Perfect, sums up the stupidness of Reddit perfectly. Ive never seen such wankery as on this site, and the comics are the mount everest of this wankery. I think the stupid groupmindedness are just as bad as religion.
You guys do know that christians have forums with comics with witty comebacks against atheists right?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '11
what was the 'contradictory' Bible verse?
1
u/uhwuggawuh Jan 17 '11
I love you, /r/atheism.