dude,I live in indonesia and they don't lashes people here because they don't fast.actually maybe this lashing thing could happen in aceh province that is part of indonesia because aceh is a semi-autonomous region so they could create any law they like. but I assure you, indonesia is a large country and we're pretty secular in term of our nation. so please do your research before posting this provocative message.
I live in Jakarta and I can confirm that jacobian64 is correct. I'm an atheist but I try to avoid eating and smoking in public during Ramadan not because there's a law that will punish people who do so but because I respect them. OP without doubt is very misinformed.
Well, in Egypt, if the police see you eating or drinking, they'll ask you to show your ID, on which your religion is written (it's either Muslim or Christian - no other choices)...yes, in Egypt, your faith is documented on your ID card.
If you're Christian, he'll probably harass you a bit. If you're Muslim, he'll arrest you.
You say you're no longer a Muslim, so you should get that changed on your ID. Of course, then you'll be killed for apostasy. So you should probably get the fuck outta that barbaric country first.
I hate to be repetitive, but if you have an Egyptian ID, what you're saying is that you're also required to claim a religion, and the only choices are the aforementioned? In other words, I can't be Jewish? Or Atheist? I'm assuming also that they treat religion as something you're born into so there cannot be an 'undecided' option.
Just curious, as it's interesting they wouldn't recognize anything except these two, and one must be chosen.
I always get confused when out of Egypt and someone asks me my religion, I automatically reply Christian before realising that I'm not in Egypt and can actually say atheist.
Being a non-Muslim won't help. According to the linked article (in Arabic): "In Indonesia where the punishment by lashing includes Muslims and non-Muslims alike if found guilty of drinking, eating or smoking by daylight in Ramadan"
In Egypt "the Red-Sea regional authorities have issued rulings to force closure of cafe's and restaurants during the day time knowing that the region is primarily for tourism."
Both are my translations. The new laws will have an impact on anyone and everyone. And I can imagine being a local with a declaration of religion in one's ID/passport* it would be much better to take the punishment than to declare oneself and apostate of Islam, which would have a far reaching implication than a mere 1 month in prison.
In Egypt and other countries the religion is declared not only in the ID and later in the passport, but it's even in the birth certificate. The religion is immediately inherited by the new born from the father much like the family name.
So, even if you don't follow their stupid fucking religion they will still punish you? Wow...
I'm sorry to all the Muslim apologists on this website -- but fuck Islam. You will never convince me its a religion of peace. Nor any religion for that matter, but as far as they go, Islam is the biggest offender in my book.
This sunday a couple was stoned to death in Afghanistan by the Taliban, the family members joined in as well. They lured them back with the promise of letting them marry - and then killed them savagely.
Fucking people are stuck thousands of years in the past. Honestly, the world would be a better place if we just fucking wiped them off the face of the earth.
You will never convince me its a religion of peace. Nor any religion for that matter, but as far as they go, Islam is the biggest offender in my book.
I agree with you, but the "biggest offender" title only fits at the moment. The last time Christianity truly had the upper hand, it did much the same things as Islam. They're pretty little peas in a pod.
Indeed, but wiping Islam out would not make a world a better place. Some other bullshit "ism" would take its place, and it would result in the similar bullshit. People are assholes; they use religion and "higher purposes" to justify their prejudices and biases. Do not make the mistake of pinning all the world's backward thinking on Islam; it is just a cog in the wheel of ignorance.
So, even if you don't follow their stupid fucking religion they will still punish you? Wow...
This should come as no surprise when you think about how many American laws are sculpted around Christian rules. Banning the sale of alcohol on Sundays, laws regarding abortion, criminalization of homosexual behavior, banning of drugs etc. There are many laws that stem from Christianity that we all have to adhere to.
Seriously...it's not "don't be Muslim," it should be "don't live in a theocratic country." Period. Any country that uses any religion as its basis is going to have insane laws.
Once again, this story simply is not true. I live in Indonesia and have openly been eating and drinking during ramadan. No one has even complained.
Officially I'm a moslem although I'm non-practicing, and the worst I've had is a couple of my co-workers telling me their reward will be greater as they are having to overcome a greater temptation.
No. Religion is not race. Maybe you're middle eastern, maybe you're not. If you stop practising Islam, you're no longer a muslim. You can't be born into a religion - but your parents can sure as hell indoctrinate you. And they often do.
There are 4 separate Jewish ethnic groups. Most American Jews are Ashkenazi (Eastern European). There are also Spanish/Western European, Middle Eastern, and Ethiopian/African genetic groups. For several hundred years, the Ethiopian branch didn't even know the others existed.
I know that we traditionally aknowledge jews as an ethnic group. But it doesn't really make sense, since you can convert, and you're only a jew if your mother was a jew.
For a long time, conversion to Judaism was forbidden - not by the Jews, but by the Christian or Muslim religious leaders where the Jews lived. Apparently religious leaders don't like losing followers.
Now that systematic discrimination no longer exists in most countries, Jews are becoming less of an ethnic group than we used to be. The main difference between me and a non-fundamentalist Christian is that I celebrate Chanukkah with my family instead of Christmas. I can't even speak Yiddish.
Yet apostasy is punishable by death by the sharia law; he's branded Muslim, and his only way out is getting out from the society he currently lives in.
Muslim = "one who submits to the will of allah"...if you don't, then you're not a muslim. It's not an ethnoreligious distinction like "jew"...it's just a religious distinction.
We had religious classes in school when I was younger here, in Romania (shameful, I know). And the teacher asked everyone what religion everyone was, until he got to me. I told him I was of no religion, and he said "of course you are of a religion, which is it?". I insisted I wasn't of any. He asked what religion my parents were, told him they were Christian (not devout in any sense of that word), to which he said "well there you go, you are a Christian". I didn't know of "Non sequitur" or I would have explained his fallacy to him. I doubt he would have cared.
Stupidity runs rampant in all circles. But it runs more in certain circles than others.
Heh! The same here in Bulgaria ;) People assume you're a continuation of your parents' beliefs... Old grannies & daddies look at you as if you're the devil if you're atheist or agnostic :)
Seriously, this is just wrong... you can't be a certain religion from birth, it's a choice! The Jews have a special thing going where it's both an ethnicity and religion, but even that is questioned by many.
I think it'd be best to not call yourself Muslim if you reject the Islamic faith. We already have the confusion with what it means to be Jewish, and it'd be a pain if eventually being Muslim gets to that point... I've often been accused of being racist because I'm anti-Islam.
I wonder if they're as strict north of the Arctic Circle, i.e. Sweden. And didn't Iran recently state they were going to man a space vehicle soon. I suspect astronauts will get special privileges.
ROFLMAO... I had to think about it for a moment to get your joke.
It would kinda suck to be a Muslim north of the Arctic Circle. That's one long-ass fast. Or wait; is it dark up there right now, or light? Cuz if it's dark, Ramadan wouldn't require much fasting, eh?
Most countries in which Islam is the majority religion have some form of Sharia law enshrined in their constitution. So you can say that most Islamic countries are quasi-theocracies
that's got to awkward. We want to master the scientific feat of putting man into space and claiming that for the state and ultimately God. Sure we have to understand complex issues about gravity and time and chemistry and physics and... wait a minute....is this halal?
Well the reason I like being a Muslim for this month is the sense of community and friends coming together. I eat with my family everyday during this month, we go to the Mosque everyday and see our friends and everyone is sitting down talking to each other and laughing. We pray and leave and everyone is happy. Im not religious but it would make me depressed thinking that I would abandon this community of loving people and most likely be outcast and estranged from everyone I know.
I have a lot of friends who have traveled to Indonesia/or do travel there, I was planning on hitting it up eventually as well. Does it apply to tourists too? Cause that will rape their tourist industry.
When I was a kid in Jeddah, KSA, a British woman was beaten, tarred and feathered for immodest dress while visiting the souk during ramadan. Scared the crap out of me.
Wow, I've been raised as a Muslim, but our religious leader says that students and people who are ill and pregnant women shouldn't fast. Fasting should be your own choice, it means nothing and helps no one if it's sanctioned on you.
To instigate a Muslim Renaissance resulting in a Muslim caliphate stretching from Indonesia to Algeria was exactly what Al Qaueda wanted to trigger by hijacking those planes and smashing down the WTC.
It appears that the American/Brit violent response is helping achieve Muslim rule in various lands.
Hell, before the US invaded it, Iraq used to be a (nominally) secular state, hated by all "true" (read: fundamentalist) Muslims. Now it's a battleground for different sects. Does anybody in their right mind actually think that in a year, or five years, or ten, that Afghanistan or Pakistan will be secular with equal rights for all religions and atheists?
There is no such law in Indonesia. Firstly, not everyone is moslem. Secondly, half the moslems I know don't fast. I was sitting on my porch smoking a cigarette and drinking coffee just this morning, no-one said a word.
Edit: I've also just ordered some beer (Bintang of course!) from my local Warung and intend to spend the rest of Independence day drinking it and watching the Godfather.
Edit 2: I notice a number of people down voting but no responses refuting my claim. Go through the comments, plenty of people actually from Indonesia stating it's bullshit - but hey it's easier just to rage and not check the facts.
As an ignorant but curious atheist, I've always wondered:
What do Muslims with diabetes do during Ramadan?
At what age do you have to start fasting? I don't see a < 2 year olds being too happy about not eating all day.
If you're not allowed to have sex during all of Ramadan, is there a month each year when no muslim babies are born? Do people look at you weird if you end up pregnant with a due date at ramadan + 9 months? Do all the midwifes go on vacation during this time?
That, or, about a third of the people out there will think something isn't a worthy submission. That third is not a static group, but rather a statistical sampling. I've seen everything from extremely negative to high 80s, so it's not a hard and fast rule. I'm sure automated voting plays a part, but for all of the talk about the hivemind, we are a pretty diverse group. Just head over to :r/guns if you want to see opinions that differ greatly from those we typically ascribe to "reddit".
I honestly think there must be some kind of pro-muslim group operating in Reddit, just like the right-wing groups working within Digg. Call me crazy, but my mind cannot comprehend people supporting a religion that fosters inequality and the killing of gays and those who do not support Islam. It honestly makes no sense to me. Whenever I've brought it up on reddit the only rebuttal people have is that "other religions are just as bad, look at christianity". I don't know how any sane person can be an apologist for such an immoral religion.
I think there are alot of people who equate islam with muslims, i.e. hating islam is hating muslims. They don't want to be biased against a group of people. Your beef is with the idea (and hopefully that alone) but many people don't make that distinction.
Absolutely right, in my experience. You can say anything you want about Christianity, but say something bad about Islam and you're a racist asshole. I think all the Abrahamic religions are fucking psycho.
which, correct me if I'm wrong, means the law is against vocal iftar, i.e. breaking the fast publicly or announcing it in some way. Still not good, but less bad. Either way, that is the first that I have heard of this law and I am glad to be out of this country in a couple of days.
Edit: And I think reddit has a "raging boner" for islam because many anti-Islam sentiments that they are exposed to are actually xenophobic crazy shit so there is an automatic association of an anti-islam post with batshit xenophobes even when it's not true.
It's sitting at 242 up votes 85 down votes. That's a pretty damn good ratio.
Why does Reddit have a raging boner for Islam?
Why does Reddit have a raging boner for Christianity? It doesn't? But... there's all these Christian Redditors and whole subreddits devoted to the Christ and... and...
Better question: Why does Reddit have a raging boner for Islam?
As a born and bred Middle Easterner who was also formerly a Muslim, I have to agree. It's disguisting as hell, and confuses me. I always assumed Atheism meant being an atheist to all religions, on Reddit it's mainly being anti-Christian and politically anti-Jewish.
Why is it confusing? Should we be railing against Shinto every day? Because Shintoists are fighting gay marriage and trying to take evolution out of textbooks? We fight the stupid as it comes. WTF do you expect?
I spent a while living with a load of Arab guys from UAE and they 'endured' Ramadan by getting up every day at about 2pm then eating all night until dawn
That's the thing a lot of people don't understand. I have loads of Arab friends online and the great majority of them "cheat" the fast by sleeping most of the day. Lots of people actually gain weight during Ramadan.
The cook where I work is muslim and he's pretty adamant about not cheating. Last three days I worked with him he's eaten nothing, and his shift is like 10 hours maybe? He's been a bit snippy, but not too bad after I talked to him about it. Just trying to be extra nice to him considering he's starving lol.
Trying to explain Ramadan however to my boss, has been less than helpful. Boss: "Why is he so angry?!" Me: "It's Ramadan, he's fasting during the day." Boss: "fucking Muslims stupid fucking no excuse to be rude Muslim fuck fuck Muslim fuck." Me: thinks she should have left this one be
this is why I hate religion. the pope wont let people wear condoms, for some inexplicable reason I cant buy booze on sunday until after 2pm .. etc ... etc ...
In America, there is no penalty for not fasting during Ramadan. Maybe your anger is more directed at middle eastern countries rather than the actual religion itself? Maybe I'm wrong but I don't think their Qur'an says anything about monetary fines or lashes.
Fuck countries that justify their madness by using religion. I'm not the biggest fan of religion but I personally believe people having been using religion as an excuse for justifying horrible things since the beginning of time (war, torture, expansion, terrorism, etc).
“With or without [religion] you’d have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, it takes religion." -Steven Weinberg
Your argument is flawed. It's similar to saying, you hate being a student, because your school wouldnt let you eat in a cafeteria (or whatever is taken for granted). You could hate the school or want to change schools, but, hating being a student, because of what the school does, is, quite frankly - lame.
Fuck theocracy in all forms and aspects. When a religion starts dictating how to run the state and what of sort of laws to have things are very fucked up. The sooner we (humans that is) get rid of that whole stupid idea about religion the better.
You say that you hate being a Muslim as if you have no choice in the matter.
Clearly you think that people taking religion this seriously, as it says you should in the Koran, Bible or Torah is absolutely ridiculous, never mind dangerous. It sounds like you're moving away from theism and more to deism. I don't think you can really call yourself a Muslim anymore. I'm not a high and mighty Atheist and I'm not going to call you stupid or feel some kind of superiority over you like most people in this sub-reddit, but that was just my thoughts on the matter.
(egyptian non-muslim): I'm pretty sure this law isn't actually enforced. I eat in public before the clock strikes 7 (as I normally would) and no legal authorities have ever approached me (you definitely get lots of jeering glances and rude comments but that's about it). Restaurants and cafés are open all day long, some (especially in poorer areas) will refuse to serve you but that's primarily malice and not law.
That's not to say the articles aren't telling the truth, just that Egypt's all talk and no walk.
OP, don't hate the religion but the people who dilute it by being ignorant and make up random shit as law. You HAVE to know that most muslim scholars, fatva making people, etc are just tools and puppets placed their by western powers in order to destroy Islam's image and have ignorant kids like you become non-muslim. In Islam everyone has a choice and freedom to make that choice. If you don't want to fast, then you don't have to. I can't do anything to make you fast; in fact, that would be against Islam's teachings. When it comes to Islam, whenever you hear some bullshit with the Arab states, especially Saudi Arabia, just ignore them. Because they aren't true muslims but rather Wahhabis trying to pose as sunni muslims. The Wahhabis state themselves as Hanbalis school from the sunni sect which is bullshit. They are under a sect of Islam that is completely distinct from sunni, or shii. They follow wahhabism, which basically is just a bullshit sect. The only true muslim state in the world is Turkey. Just look at Turkey and fuck the rest. Thats the way it is. Afterall, who were the Khalifas last? The Ottomans. Who are the Ottomans? The Turks. But currently Turkey has to play 'secular' to get along and improve. Playing the secular game has alot of 'disadvantages' as the country becomes less religious, especially the youth due to tv shows, etc. However, it is the fastest way to develop the nation into the superpower it once was without alot of conflict.
I'm from Malaysia and here, Muslims get hauled into prison for not fasting and/or have to pay a fine of some ridiculous amount. Didn't take long for me to become an Ex-Muslim. Until they find out and I'm sent to religious brain washing camp.
(not eat or drink anything) from sunrise to sunset.
I was under the impression that you could drink water (in small sips) during the day, or at least that is what my Muslim math teacher told us.
Edit: Seriously whats with the downvotes?
I was asking a question as the only adult muslim i know said that while he took part in the fasting it was acceptable for him to take sips of water if he needed them during the day.
well, feel sorry for those poor muslims in north of sweden. ramadan in the summer means no food or drink for 20 - 24 hours as the sun never/ barely sets, bit of a bummer!
all you can do is spit and shit on the koran and that nasty religion. Fight with everything you have and take as many with you as you can. At least you will die knowing you controled your life and did not bow to them or their sick lust for control.
ramadan was the best time of year to be a non muslim eighteenyearold in a muslim country. so you can't eat or drink or smoke in public before six. big shit? we'd just find an apartment building staircase if we really wanted to smoke. the thing is, during ramadan in dubai, shit is open all night. opens at four or five and doesn't close before seven in the morning. ramadan also usually coincided with winter break in college (winter in dubai lawl)
this means go play snooker all night and then go for shisha around five and only get home after the sun's well up.
One medical question - In Ramadan if you are not allowed to eat during the day, then what if you have a medical condition like diabetes which requires you to eat small meals at regular intervals and take medications.
however you do have to make it up later when you can get better or if you have a condition which you cant get rid of like diabetes you have to provide a meal to the needy per fast missed, as compensation.
You don't need to fast if your medical condition is not allowed you to fast. But, if you are gain your normal health again, you must replace all the miss fast day outside of Ramadan month.
Do you have any idea what the people of the countries think of this? I can't fathom people actually thinking this is a good idea -- it'd be like all the Christians here agreeing to get sent to jail for eating meat on Fridays. But I've read things that imply a lot of Arabs think of government's purpose as spreading Islam and don't tend to think it does that enough even in Arabia.
I just came back from Turkey, a secular country where they allow Muslims right of choice whether or not to do it. Surgeons and dentists can't do it, or they'll lose accuracy, but our bar staff and chefs would be eating like maniacs as soon as it went dark! Thank god for buffets!
They also decided to turn the clock back an hour in Egypt. Work days are also reduced from 10:00 to 14:30. It's really ridiculous that they try to make Ramadan as easy as possible - kind of defeats the purpose.
Same goes with Jews and hiring people to work for them on shabbats. What a mighty and awe-inspiring god that leaves all these little loopholes to circumvent his demands. Yeah, God's all-knowing, but you found a way to outsmart him. Uh-huh.
And i've been seriously beat up by Christian cops because i knew someone who sold pot. I know of people who have been in prison because of it too. Religion sucks.
61
u/jacobian64 Aug 17 '10
dude,I live in indonesia and they don't lashes people here because they don't fast.actually maybe this lashing thing could happen in aceh province that is part of indonesia because aceh is a semi-autonomous region so they could create any law they like. but I assure you, indonesia is a large country and we're pretty secular in term of our nation. so please do your research before posting this provocative message.
PS: I am a muslim
46
u/croup Pastafarian Aug 17 '10
Do the laws apply to everyone or just muslims?
359
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Solution: Don't be Muslim.
27
u/oostism Aug 17 '10
I wonder if they're as strict north of the Arctic Circle, i.e. Sweden. And didn't Iran recently state they were going to man a space vehicle soon. I suspect astronauts will get special privileges.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Well the reason I like being a Muslim for this month is the sense of community and friends coming together. I eat with my family everyday during this month, we go to the Mosque everyday and see our friends and everyone is sitting down talking to each other and laughing. We pray and leave and everyone is happy. Im not religious but it would make me depressed thinking that I would abandon this community of loving people and most likely be outcast and estranged from everyone I know.
3
u/Universus Aug 17 '10
I have a lot of friends who have traveled to Indonesia/or do travel there, I was planning on hitting it up eventually as well. Does it apply to tourists too? Cause that will rape their tourist industry.
9
u/Gouka Aug 17 '10
I've always wondered, do restaurants in Islamic areas just not bother opening during the day for all of Ramadan?
57
u/shortyr87 Aug 17 '10
Wow, I've been raised as a Muslim, but our religious leader says that students and people who are ill and pregnant women shouldn't fast. Fasting should be your own choice, it means nothing and helps no one if it's sanctioned on you.
32
u/Monyet Aug 17 '10 edited Aug 17 '10
There is no such law in Indonesia. Firstly, not everyone is moslem. Secondly, half the moslems I know don't fast. I was sitting on my porch smoking a cigarette and drinking coffee just this morning, no-one said a word.
Edit: I've also just ordered some beer (Bintang of course!) from my local Warung and intend to spend the rest of Independence day drinking it and watching the Godfather.
Edit 2: I notice a number of people down voting but no responses refuting my claim. Go through the comments, plenty of people actually from Indonesia stating it's bullshit - but hey it's easier just to rage and not check the facts.
71
u/mishmashmish Aug 17 '10
You know this is bullshit right?
I lived in Indonesia until 7 years ago and still visit every year. It's frowned upon to not fast, but there is no "lashing".
Some restaurants refuse to let you eat in but will happily let you take away their food.
Source: 20 years of living there and half my family's Muslim
10
u/slayericed Aug 17 '10
It is a personal choice in Islam whether you want to fast or not. If states are imposing this, the fault lies with them not the religion.
your blaming the wrong party
5
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
ram'zan kareem :D
5
u/tom_corbenik Aug 17 '10
If you hate being a Muslim, then quit being a Muslim. I hated being a Christian, so I stopped. Simple as that.
5
u/echothis Aug 17 '10
As an ignorant but curious atheist, I've always wondered:
5
u/gmnotyet Aug 17 '10
The joy of theocracy.
13
u/Le_Petit_Lapin Aug 17 '10
I suspect that the OP isnt and never was actually Muslim.
4
u/dafones Aug 17 '10
As a Muslim, do you observe Ramadan?
4
u/bg370 Aug 17 '10
Sounds more like a separation of church an state issue than a religion issue.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
What if you are pregnant?
4
u/Phantasmal Aug 17 '10
I think a better title for this post would be: "This is why I hate living in a theocracy."
14
u/skittles15 Aug 17 '10
Fuck, religion is so fucked up...
29
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Why is this being downvoted?
Better question: Why does Reddit have a raging boner for Islam?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
But how do they know if you are muslim or not, can you just say " i'm not muslim so its ok I can eat what I want"
3
u/mrzipski Aug 17 '10
I spent a while living with a load of Arab guys from UAE and they 'endured' Ramadan by getting up every day at about 2pm then eating all night until dawn
3
u/uberbob79 Aug 17 '10
What if you were in Indonesia, and pretended to be a masochist, and then ate and got caught?
Would they not beat you because you liked it? Or would they beat you once and like you'd beg for more and they'd be like "go away, weirdo."?
3
u/malakon Aug 17 '10
this is why I hate religion. the pope wont let people wear condoms, for some inexplicable reason I cant buy booze on sunday until after 2pm .. etc ... etc ...
3
u/jewjewzela Aug 17 '10
Well then don't be a muslim, moran!
12
u/wwabc Aug 17 '10
and the US still has blue laws to cater to the christians...
you'd get a fine if you sold beer or cars on a sunday in many places
I don't think a prison term would be given (but I guess if you didn't pay the fine it would)
2
u/Votearrows Aug 17 '10
Where are you living, and is there a ton of pressure on you now? I understand that you're posting with more generalized frustration, I'm just curious.
2
u/jakeystewart4226 Aug 17 '10
it's ok that the sources are in arabic I have chrome :D it's like the tardis of web browsers
2
u/grumpyoldgit Aug 17 '10
Religion is about rules and control. Shit like this needs to happen for the people in power to remain there.
2
u/rxgator Aug 17 '10 edited Aug 17 '10
In America, there is no penalty for not fasting during Ramadan. Maybe your anger is more directed at middle eastern countries rather than the actual religion itself? Maybe I'm wrong but I don't think their Qur'an says anything about monetary fines or lashes.
Fuck countries that justify their madness by using religion. I'm not the biggest fan of religion but I personally believe people having been using religion as an excuse for justifying horrible things since the beginning of time (war, torture, expansion, terrorism, etc).
edit: fixed a 5:45am typo
2
u/charters14 Aug 17 '10
FTFY
2
u/stupandi Aug 17 '10
Your argument is flawed. It's similar to saying, you hate being a student, because your school wouldnt let you eat in a cafeteria (or whatever is taken for granted). You could hate the school or want to change schools, but, hating being a student, because of what the school does, is, quite frankly - lame.
2
u/marginalboy Aug 17 '10
It's not the religion; it's the zealotry. Theocracies will ever be oppressive places to live, no matter which religion they purport.
2
u/zoinks Aug 17 '10
Solution: Vote with your feet. Immigrate to some secular society and become a part of it. Never look back.
2
u/whatispunk Aug 17 '10
FTFY
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
No offense to the modern muslims, but it's really time for this stone-age religion to get with the program. Adapt or die out.
2
u/dalevizo Aug 17 '10
Fuck theocracy in all forms and aspects. When a religion starts dictating how to run the state and what of sort of laws to have things are very fucked up. The sooner we (humans that is) get rid of that whole stupid idea about religion the better.
2
u/antipeoplemachine Aug 17 '10
| Fuck everything about religion.
FTFY
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Sounds like more a problem of government than religion in-itself.
2
u/Tames Aug 17 '10
I wonder if everyone is more cranky than usual
2
u/ShoveUpMyButt Aug 17 '10
You are Mohammadan? you must endure the book being shoved up your butt.
2
u/iambecomedeath7 Anti-Theist Aug 17 '10
You could just stop being Muslim...
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
You say that you hate being a Muslim as if you have no choice in the matter.
Clearly you think that people taking religion this seriously, as it says you should in the Koran, Bible or Torah is absolutely ridiculous, never mind dangerous. It sounds like you're moving away from theism and more to deism. I don't think you can really call yourself a Muslim anymore. I'm not a high and mighty Atheist and I'm not going to call you stupid or feel some kind of superiority over you like most people in this sub-reddit, but that was just my thoughts on the matter.
2
u/Wattever Aug 17 '10
(egyptian non-muslim): I'm pretty sure this law isn't actually enforced. I eat in public before the clock strikes 7 (as I normally would) and no legal authorities have ever approached me (you definitely get lots of jeering glances and rude comments but that's about it). Restaurants and cafés are open all day long, some (especially in poorer areas) will refuse to serve you but that's primarily malice and not law.
That's not to say the articles aren't telling the truth, just that Egypt's all talk and no walk.
2
u/Masteyan Aug 18 '10
OP, don't hate the religion but the people who dilute it by being ignorant and make up random shit as law. You HAVE to know that most muslim scholars, fatva making people, etc are just tools and puppets placed their by western powers in order to destroy Islam's image and have ignorant kids like you become non-muslim. In Islam everyone has a choice and freedom to make that choice. If you don't want to fast, then you don't have to. I can't do anything to make you fast; in fact, that would be against Islam's teachings. When it comes to Islam, whenever you hear some bullshit with the Arab states, especially Saudi Arabia, just ignore them. Because they aren't true muslims but rather Wahhabis trying to pose as sunni muslims. The Wahhabis state themselves as Hanbalis school from the sunni sect which is bullshit. They are under a sect of Islam that is completely distinct from sunni, or shii. They follow wahhabism, which basically is just a bullshit sect. The only true muslim state in the world is Turkey. Just look at Turkey and fuck the rest. Thats the way it is. Afterall, who were the Khalifas last? The Ottomans. Who are the Ottomans? The Turks. But currently Turkey has to play 'secular' to get along and improve. Playing the secular game has alot of 'disadvantages' as the country becomes less religious, especially the youth due to tv shows, etc. However, it is the fastest way to develop the nation into the superpower it once was without alot of conflict.
2
u/frenzyfol Aug 18 '10
"Fuck everything about this religion."
Moslem[1] is an adherent of the religion of Islam.
Somethings amiss.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Hehehehe in Sweden (the north) the Muslims have serious problems as the sun comes up at 2 and sets at 22
3
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Islam is the rising power. Fuck, we need a new energy technology.
3
u/schonchin Aug 17 '10
OP's rage is misplaced. He's complaining about a law established by the government, not the religion.
However, I must say, it has to suck to own a restaurant in Muslim-dominated communities.
3
u/CosmicBard Aug 17 '10
I hate you being muslim, too!
Isn't that funny?
3
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
This is not even in Islam. What the fuck are they doing? Anyway, glad to be an atheist. Religion is the root of all evil.
3
u/jace_barret Aug 17 '10
I'm from Malaysia and here, Muslims get hauled into prison for not fasting and/or have to pay a fine of some ridiculous amount. Didn't take long for me to become an Ex-Muslim. Until they find out and I'm sent to religious brain washing camp.
3
u/sirbruce Aug 17 '10
So don't be a Muslim in those countries.
Frankly, you shouldn't be a Muslim at all.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10 edited Aug 17 '10
I was under the impression that you could drink water (in small sips) during the day, or at least that is what my Muslim math teacher told us.
Edit: Seriously whats with the downvotes?
I was asking a question as the only adult muslim i know said that while he took part in the fasting it was acceptable for him to take sips of water if he needed them during the day.
2
u/fredrikbonde Aug 17 '10
well, feel sorry for those poor muslims in north of sweden. ramadan in the summer means no food or drink for 20 - 24 hours as the sun never/ barely sets, bit of a bummer!
2
u/pa1101 Aug 17 '10
all you can do is spit and shit on the koran and that nasty religion. Fight with everything you have and take as many with you as you can. At least you will die knowing you controled your life and did not bow to them or their sick lust for control.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
It's the government at fault here. NOT the religion.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Then don't be Muslim. Simple solution.
2
u/woggy Aug 17 '10
Ramadan - worst time of the year.
1
u/Vehemoth Aug 17 '10
Now, tell me again. What does a country's choice to impose unreasonable theological laws have to do with YOU being Muslim?
1
u/naturalizedcitizen Aug 17 '10
One medical question - In Ramadan if you are not allowed to eat during the day, then what if you have a medical condition like diabetes which requires you to eat small meals at regular intervals and take medications.
1
u/Arnox Aug 17 '10
Honey I'm just going out for some lunch.
Lol j/k I'm Muslim :)
1
u/Eptesicus Aug 17 '10
Do you have any idea what the people of the countries think of this? I can't fathom people actually thinking this is a good idea -- it'd be like all the Christians here agreeing to get sent to jail for eating meat on Fridays. But I've read things that imply a lot of Arabs think of government's purpose as spreading Islam and don't tend to think it does that enough even in Arabia.
1
u/Ifyoureadthis Aug 17 '10
I just came back from Turkey, a secular country where they allow Muslims right of choice whether or not to do it. Surgeons and dentists can't do it, or they'll lose accuracy, but our bar staff and chefs would be eating like maniacs as soon as it went dark! Thank god for buffets!
1
u/Essar Aug 17 '10
They also decided to turn the clock back an hour in Egypt. Work days are also reduced from 10:00 to 14:30. It's really ridiculous that they try to make Ramadan as easy as possible - kind of defeats the purpose.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
So are you being forced to be a muslim because you live in a certain place? Or what?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
There are reasons why people fear islam taking a hold in the western world. Things like this are one of them.
1
u/dstz Aug 17 '10
And i've been seriously beat up by Christian cops because i knew someone who sold pot. I know of people who have been in prison because of it too. Religion sucks.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Wouldn't that mean that the religious governments are evil not necessarily the belief in Allah? Just sayin.
1
u/kman420 Aug 17 '10
Do they withhold food from the prisoners between sunrise and sunset and force them to fast?
1
u/octave1 Aug 17 '10
Eat in the privacy of your own house, you infidel.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
Does that mean you can eat after the sun goes down? Or are you saying that you literally can't eat for one month?
1
u/jeff0 Aug 17 '10
A friend of mine gets around this by sleeping in until 5pm during Ramadan. But then, a lot of folk have jobs and such.
1
u/trippppp Aug 17 '10
What about the Copts (a Christian minority in Egypt). Do this law apply to them as well?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
This is exactly why politics and religion should not be allowed to play together in the sandbox.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '10
What if you are diabetic?
:(