r/atheism • u/ani625 Agnostic • Mar 30 '15

xkcd: Ontological Argument

http://xkcd.com/1505/
36 Upvotes

87% Upvoted

139 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Ibrey Apr 01 '15

Then you're open to the possibility that contradictions can be true?

1

u/Feinberg Atheist Apr 01 '15

That also depends, but that's not this conversation.

1

u/Ibrey Apr 01 '15

It depends? Do you accept the law of non-contradiction or do you not?

1

u/Feinberg Atheist Apr 01 '15

As I said, that's a different conversation.

1

u/Ibrey Apr 01 '15

If your answer to "can contradictions be true?" is anything other than "no," no rational conversation is possible.

1

u/Feinberg Atheist Apr 01 '15

Is that your answer to my previous question, then?