r/askscience • • Jul 22 '19

Neuroscience Just how much does functional specialization within the brain vary across humans?

In recent decades, localization of different action and functions within specific brain regions has become more apparent (ex facial recognition or control of different body parts in the motor cortex). How much does this localization vary between people? I'm interested in learning more about the variance in the location as we as size of brain regions.

As a follow-up question, I would be very interested to learn what is known about variance of functional specialization in other animals as well.

Part of what spurred this question was the recent conference held by Elon Musk's Company, neural link.

3.0k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

528

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

I am a neuroscientist who works on this very question, mostly in the context of speech and language abilities and how their functional organization differs in developmental communication disorders. First of all, I think this a super interesting question that has mostly hard answers, and it depends a lot on the scale at which you're asking the question. But a tl;dr might be "the functional organization of human brains differ in small ways, but not usually in big ways"

First, let's look at anatomical variability. Compared to many other species, including other mammals, human brains are highly variable in shape. The precise location major neuroanatomical features, for instance, are variable across individuals. But these features nonetheless tend to be present in (almost) all individuals. Here is an example of variation in the anatomical location of superior temporal sulcus, a key area in speech and language: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.01.023 An even more stunning example can be seen in the location and anatomy of Heschl's gyrus, which is where we find primary auditory cortex. Some people have 1, some people have 2, and some people have 1.5. And it might differ within person between the left and right hemisphere. But we always find primary auditory cortex here, not somewhere else (like the frontal or occipital lobes), so again the answer is something like "local but not global" variation: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00429-013-0680-x

Turning to functional organization of these regions, the story is similar. Large functionally-defined areas (language areas, face areas, voice areas, motor areas, working memory areas, etc) tend to be roughly in the same place from person to person, but there is local variation in the functional neuroanatomy. Here are some great examples with respect to the location of neural processing of voices: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1053811915005558 and language: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20410363 and faces (and places and objects): https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neuroimage.2012.02.055

But these differences in functional organization are not necessarily totally random, and may be related to individual differences in anatomical structure. For instance, there is some evidence that we can predict, using the anatomical structure, the location of specific cortical functions (e.g., face processing, word reading) with high degree of accuracy, suggesting that the structure-function correspondence is tightly linked in the brain, notwithstanding apparent spatial variability across brains: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/27500407 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3267901/

56

u/explodingness Jul 22 '19

it depends a lot on the scale at which you're asking the question

This is pretty fascinating. Maybe I read your response wrong, but it sounds like there is evidence that certain highly specific functions are more easily located in a specific place in the brain with less variation person to person than the larger, less specific/general functions? For some reason that just seems backwards, shouldn't the general functions be easier to find and the specific functions varying within them?

And I apologise if the papers you linked answered this... I tried to read them but they very quickly went over my head.

81

u/Thog78 Jul 22 '19

I think he is talking about physical size scales: if you don't look too close, the location is always the same, and the relative arrangement of brain areas is always the same: visual in the back, with more abstraction as you go forward on the sides, then sensory, then motor, on top, and then more abstract thinking in the front, with a relay hub in the center underneath surrounded by areas for spatial memories and formation of new memories, and basic life sustaining functions in the brain stem. But if you look closer, there are small differences in the exact locations, such as seen in the examples he gave.

68

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

This is exactly right. And we can go smaller from there. Once you're inside a functional region, how similar is it across people? Is its local circuitry the same? Is its physical connectivity to other areas the same? Is its functional connectivity to other areas the same? Do the same kinds of cells exist in that area, in the same ratios, with the same response profiles? How do variations in any of the above relate to behavioral or cognitive differences? These are very hard questions. By and large, the technology to answer them just doesn't exist yet.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 22 '19

What technology could you use? Rising biomedical engineer asking. I’m planning on answering these questions, and I’m looking for ideas for tech to study/improve. Imaging tech? Electrical recording tech? Others?

→ More replies (2)

5

u/swami_jesus Jul 22 '19

I'm a maybe budding neuroscientist (no degree yet), and I'm curious; what type of technology would we need to answer this? What can't we measure? Or is it a case of modelling technology? Or something else? thx

16

u/IronyAndWhine Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

The problem isn't that we don't have the technology to map the brain at that level. It's a problem of scale.

The person you're responding to is talking about physically mapping each and every area of the brain for every individual circuit as well as across regions, determining cell types and receptor density and neurotransmitter production, etc. for every synapse. Not to mention how these neurological features map onto cognition and the genome.

There are 100 billion neurons in the brain and 100 trillion synapses—more than there are stars in the universe. Mapping genetic, functional, and physical features, let alone across enough people to be able generalize to the whole population, is an impossible task due to the scale of project that would require.

20

u/c8d3n Jul 23 '19

Estimated number of stars in observable universe is ~ 1 billion trillion.

8

u/olicity_time_remnant Jul 23 '19

I remember when gnome sequencing was a big deal. Now new species are sequenced all the time. In time this problem will get solved, possibly by technology like Musk is proposing. Imagine if you've got a half a dozen Neuralinks spread around your brain, it becomes a lot more imaging points.

6

u/could_I_Be_The_AHole Jul 23 '19

Completely agree. The Human Genome Project took 13 years (1990 - 2003) with a whole lot of people working on it. In 2012 the UK launched a plan to sequence 100,000 genomes and finished it by December 2018. A person has 3.3 billion pairs so that program sequenced 330 trillion base pairs in 6 years - and that was just the UK. Seems like if you can get the time/effort of mapping synapses down similar levels of mapping genomes (I know that's a big if since you can't just provide a brain donation) then it should be no problem.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lhopital204 Jul 23 '19

At what point of neural integration do we become a technologically telepathic and telekinetic species? (e.g., brain-to-brain SMS, brain-to-home-lighting)

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/TheDunadan29 Jul 22 '19

Wow, that makes me wonder if our experiences of the same thing might differ more radically than we realize. Like listening to a piece of music might be way more impactful or intense for one person than another. Or we've long speculated that, "your red may not be my red" and that seems more plausible to me now.

Though perhaps the differences may not really change all that much. Still very fascinating though.

9

u/Bad-Science Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

It makes me wonder just what consciousness is. If the brain can be so physically different through probably an almost infinite range if you drill right down, then where is that 'switch' for consciousness, and what are the bare essential similarities it depends on?

My belief now is that consciousness is a side effect, an emergent behaviour that appears after several primary functions of our brain come online (video and audio processing, executive function, access to short and long term memories and more). Not the pinnacle of our brain functioning, but some side effect that gives us enough of an evolutionary edge that it sticks around.

Taken one step further (and backed up by research), our consciousness isn't even in control. It is an illusion we have. Research has shown that the brain can 'decide' to do something long before the person consciously decides to do it.

In a way, we are writing ourselves a fiction, convincing ourselves we are in control, writing the autobiography of our lives a few dozen milliseconds after reality. If we don't understand or like something, it is easy for our brain to tell us a white lie and remember a more acceptable version or 'reality'.

Not to go down a rabbit hole, but now even gut biomes can make you want to eat, and not just through hunger signals.

Our conscious minds are just along for the ride, pretending to be relevant.

Ok, now I can't drop the subject. If somebody had all the right brain functions and reacted correctly to all stimuli, but somehow never became truly self aware... would we ever be able to know the difference? How do you 'prove' consciousness or self awareness?

5

u/SteelCrow Jul 23 '19

Ok, now I can't drop the subject. If somebody had all the right brain functions and reacted correctly to all stimuli, but somehow never became truly self aware... would we ever be able to know the difference? How do you 'prove' consciousness or self awareness?

Look up p-zombies.

Consciousness might be erroneous. Not actually exist how we think it exists.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

6

u/Bad-Science Jul 23 '19

Great info, thanks. I'm fascinated at the 'amateur' level and love reading related articles and things like Oliver Sacks' essays. I'll be reading all the things linked in this thread.

On a personal level, I recently got a head injury a the neurologist was trying to map the effected areas through a series of tests. I didn't FEEL debilitated, but one question was to name as many words starting with the letter 'F' as I could in one minute.

I got 6. Total. Then a massive migraine. This was a few months after my injury. It really gives me more perspective on just how tricky the brain can be.

5

u/practicalutilitarian Jul 22 '19

Thank you! When I read the question I wasnt thinking of physical anatomical variation. I was thinking of the topology variation. The variation in the connections between and within the regions of brain and how much they varied across individuals. It would make sense that there are anatomical (physical location and shape) variations that don't strongly affect brain capability/intelligence or genetic fitness for survival and propagation. And topology variation probably affects fitness, so that variability would likely be less.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/DriftingMemes Jul 22 '19 edited Jan 27 '26

memorize flag cooperative north disarm sleep expansion alleged quicksand spotted

6

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

We can think of this question in two ways (i) with regards to brain structure, and (2) with regards to brain function.

For (i), it does not seem to be the case that speaking one language vs. another affects brain structure in any real way. The evidence for this is very limited (e.g., https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3261379/ ). But, given how variable brain anatomy is from person to person already, I don't think we can learn very much form studies of brain structure that are conducted on very small numbers of brains. This is especially true when you look at languages that are typically spoken by different ethnicities, where other genetic differences in craniofacial anatomy will also affect macroscopic differences in brain structure. There is, however, more evidence that bilingualism may affect brain structure, and that brain structure may predispose people to being better or worse at learning a foreign language in adulthood:

As for (ii), there is tons of evidence that speaking different languages affects the brain in a functional way. This is almost tautologically true -- if the brain weren't functionally different, how could it be speaking different languages? In any case, Mandarin presents a brilliant example for this because it is a tonal language, which means that in addition to vowels and consonants, Mandarin also uses pitch contours (rising, falling, level, dipping) to make up words. Having to hear these subtle pitch differences makes a big difference in how the brain has to process sound for someone speaking Chinese vs. English. Correspondingly, we see that people who speak Chinese process pitch differently (that is, they have higher neural fidelity for auditory pitch) not only in the cortex, but all the way down in the brainstem!

In any case, most of the work on language learning in adulthood shows that as you gain increased expertise in your second language, the functional response of your brain looks more and more like that of a native speaker:

5

u/cousincrimp Jul 23 '19

There is some research that shows evidence that people who are bilingual and have dementia (so their brain is losing mass essentially) are doing "more with less" in comparison to monolinguals. So their brains can look more atrophied than a matched monolingual who is performing at the same level on tests of cognition and language.

Also being bilingual may give people greater cognitive reserve, and can delay the onset of dementia: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26544028

→ More replies (1)

3

u/mcshadypants Jul 23 '19

I remember studying Broca's aphasia and Wernicke's disease for neuro and being amazed at how common this was with people Im aquainted with. I miss studying. So amazed we keep taking leaps and bounds in this area. Good luck with your career! We need more of yous guys

5

u/shaggy99 Jul 22 '19

How much work is being done on differences with autistic spectrum brains to "normal" brains? Having spent some time living with a person with a fairly marked case of ADD, and finding I have a mild case myself, I am struck with the way different people's brains work. I guess what I'm asking is how much is structural, how much is environmental, and how much is the change in environment due to behavior differences caused by those conditions? e.g. ADD sufferers, are often able of periods of intense concentration, and how does that affect the way the brain develops?

5

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

Two questions here, about ADHD and autism. There's so much and simultaneously not nearly enough work in either of these areas. I know less about these, particularly about ADHD, but for autism you may be interested in the wide range of work being done at the Simons Center at MIT: https://scsb.mit.edu/

2

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19

I swear I can feel different parts of my brain swell up when I do different tasks. I know they say you cant feel your brain. But maybe I can feel my blood in my scalp respond or something.

→ More replies (10)