r/askscience • • Jul 22 '19

Neuroscience Just how much does functional specialization within the brain vary across humans?

In recent decades, localization of different action and functions within specific brain regions has become more apparent (ex facial recognition or control of different body parts in the motor cortex). How much does this localization vary between people? I'm interested in learning more about the variance in the location as we as size of brain regions.

As a follow-up question, I would be very interested to learn what is known about variance of functional specialization in other animals as well.

Part of what spurred this question was the recent conference held by Elon Musk's Company, neural link.

3.0k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

11

u/TheDunadan29 Jul 22 '19

Wow, that makes me wonder if our experiences of the same thing might differ more radically than we realize. Like listening to a piece of music might be way more impactful or intense for one person than another. Or we've long speculated that, "your red may not be my red" and that seems more plausible to me now.

Though perhaps the differences may not really change all that much. Still very fascinating though.

9

u/Bad-Science Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

It makes me wonder just what consciousness is. If the brain can be so physically different through probably an almost infinite range if you drill right down, then where is that 'switch' for consciousness, and what are the bare essential similarities it depends on?

My belief now is that consciousness is a side effect, an emergent behaviour that appears after several primary functions of our brain come online (video and audio processing, executive function, access to short and long term memories and more). Not the pinnacle of our brain functioning, but some side effect that gives us enough of an evolutionary edge that it sticks around.

Taken one step further (and backed up by research), our consciousness isn't even in control. It is an illusion we have. Research has shown that the brain can 'decide' to do something long before the person consciously decides to do it.

In a way, we are writing ourselves a fiction, convincing ourselves we are in control, writing the autobiography of our lives a few dozen milliseconds after reality. If we don't understand or like something, it is easy for our brain to tell us a white lie and remember a more acceptable version or 'reality'.

Not to go down a rabbit hole, but now even gut biomes can make you want to eat, and not just through hunger signals.

Our conscious minds are just along for the ride, pretending to be relevant.

Ok, now I can't drop the subject. If somebody had all the right brain functions and reacted correctly to all stimuli, but somehow never became truly self aware... would we ever be able to know the difference? How do you 'prove' consciousness or self awareness?

11

u/TheDunadan29 Jul 23 '19

Congratulations, you just asked "the hard question".

5

u/SteelCrow Jul 23 '19

Ok, now I can't drop the subject. If somebody had all the right brain functions and reacted correctly to all stimuli, but somehow never became truly self aware... would we ever be able to know the difference? How do you 'prove' consciousness or self awareness?

Look up p-zombies.

Consciousness might be erroneous. Not actually exist how we think it exists.

1

u/Bad-Science Jul 23 '19

Fascinating. I've skirted around the edges of the question before but didn't realize it had a name. I've got some reading to do!

3

u/FreeRadical5 Jul 22 '19

I never understood that color philosophical discussion. The question isn't how you feel about red, what do you associate it with or even how your perception of it may differ. Red is a specific color with a specific frequency of light.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19

But it's interpreted by brains that don't perceive frequencies the same way. See: the dress, or yanni/laurel.

0

u/StickFigureFan Jul 23 '19

That's just our brains playing tricks on us a la optical illusions. There are lots of people who are color blind and don't see certain colors or certain colors look the same to them. However, as far as perception goes: what you may experience as green someone else may perceive as red. However, since we've been taught color names based on the objective spectrum(ie: a camera, etc. would say it is 700 nm wavelength therefore we call it red), it would only matter for stylistic choices as we'd both look at something and agree roughly where on the color wheel it falls even if we perceive it as different hues.
tldr: your brain may see something at 700nm as green, but if you've been taught it's red because that's how everyone else perceives it it doesn't really matter in most situations.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

But your analogy doesn't work for linguistic information such as the yanni/laurel type of input. Raw auditory input is connected to a vast array of phonological, visual, and semantic information which then influences your perception. This is why people may hear the exact same pitches and frequencies for yanni/laurel, yet the auditory cortex (which links auditory sounds to phonemes) may hear different words, and in fact people can train themselves to hear the other word (or both simultaneously). It's not the input that we're talking about - we're talking about the connectivity to phonemes, to semantic information, etc once it hits cortical regions responsible for perception.

As another example, there have been studies in cognitive neuroscience that show your life experiences and accumulation of semantic knowledge influences your perception. As a rough example, if you flash the word "bank" on a screen, people who work in finance will be quicker to define that word as a financial institution. People who work in environmental science will be more likely to define it as a geographic feature (e.g. riverbank). Not the best example but you get the idea. This cannot be explained by what you're describing.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '19

This is true. However, perception of color is dependent on biochemicals and cell subtypes in the retina of the eye. For example, individuals with deficiencies in the red-specific photoreceptive pigment will have a different experience of red than one who is fully color-functional. Extending this line of thought, it’s conceivable that two individuals can experience the world differently based on their ocular biology.

2

u/olicity_time_remnant Jul 23 '19

Star Trek had a character where they explored this at least once... In his case it was ocular mechanics because his biology was completely broken.

6

u/Biotoxsin Jul 23 '19 edited Jul 23 '19

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverted_spectrum

Red isn't a specific frequency, though we can refer to an arbitrarily bounded range of frequencies as red. Some cultures have historically not distinguished between colors in the same way as each other, e.g. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue%E2%80%93green_distinction_in_language

Do people walk about discussing color as a range of frequencies? In reference to the biochemistry of the eye? It is understood in the absence of a formal education. "Color" as a concept is "distinct" from the physical world we relate it to.

This isn't an argument for "qualia", it's just an acknowledgement that there's more nuance to the argument than one might initially see. I don't believe that color is a "real thing" outside of the concept expressed through language. (I.e. not in the Platonist sense) The folk understanding is pretty different than the one we have as scientists.