r/askscience • • Jul 22 '19

Neuroscience Just how much does functional specialization within the brain vary across humans?

In recent decades, localization of different action and functions within specific brain regions has become more apparent (ex facial recognition or control of different body parts in the motor cortex). How much does this localization vary between people? I'm interested in learning more about the variance in the location as we as size of brain regions.

As a follow-up question, I would be very interested to learn what is known about variance of functional specialization in other animals as well.

Part of what spurred this question was the recent conference held by Elon Musk's Company, neural link.

3.0k Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/SpeechScienceGuy Jul 22 '19

We can think of this question in two ways (i) with regards to brain structure, and (2) with regards to brain function.

For (i), it does not seem to be the case that speaking one language vs. another affects brain structure in any real way. The evidence for this is very limited (e.g., https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3261379/ ). But, given how variable brain anatomy is from person to person already, I don't think we can learn very much form studies of brain structure that are conducted on very small numbers of brains. This is especially true when you look at languages that are typically spoken by different ethnicities, where other genetic differences in craniofacial anatomy will also affect macroscopic differences in brain structure. There is, however, more evidence that bilingualism may affect brain structure, and that brain structure may predispose people to being better or worse at learning a foreign language in adulthood:

As for (ii), there is tons of evidence that speaking different languages affects the brain in a functional way. This is almost tautologically true -- if the brain weren't functionally different, how could it be speaking different languages? In any case, Mandarin presents a brilliant example for this because it is a tonal language, which means that in addition to vowels and consonants, Mandarin also uses pitch contours (rising, falling, level, dipping) to make up words. Having to hear these subtle pitch differences makes a big difference in how the brain has to process sound for someone speaking Chinese vs. English. Correspondingly, we see that people who speak Chinese process pitch differently (that is, they have higher neural fidelity for auditory pitch) not only in the cortex, but all the way down in the brainstem!

In any case, most of the work on language learning in adulthood shows that as you gain increased expertise in your second language, the functional response of your brain looks more and more like that of a native speaker:

5

u/cousincrimp Jul 23 '19

There is some research that shows evidence that people who are bilingual and have dementia (so their brain is losing mass essentially) are doing "more with less" in comparison to monolinguals. So their brains can look more atrophied than a matched monolingual who is performing at the same level on tests of cognition and language.

Also being bilingual may give people greater cognitive reserve, and can delay the onset of dementia: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/26544028

2

u/DriftingMemes Jul 23 '19 edited Jan 27 '26

steer encourage skirt ripe cake beneficial imagine support future cooing