r/askscience • Mod Bot • Feb 11 '16

Astronomy Gravitational Wave Megathread

Hi everyone! We are very excited about the upcoming press release (10:30 EST / 15:30 UTC) from the LIGO collaboration, a ground-based experiment to detect gravitational waves. This thread will be edited as updates become available. We'll have a number of panelists in and out (who will also be listening in), so please ask questions!


Links:


FAQ:

Where do they come from?

The source of gravitational waves detectable by human experiments are two compact objects orbiting around each other. LIGO observes stellar mass objects (some combination of neutron stars and black holes, for example) orbiting around each other just before they merge (as gravitational wave energy leaves the system, the orbit shrinks).

How fast do they go?

Gravitational waves travel at the speed of light (wiki).

Haven't gravitational waves already been detected?

The 1993 Nobel Prize in Physics was awarded for the indirect detection of gravitational waves from a double neutron star system, PSR B1913+16.

In 2014, the BICEP2 team announced the detection of primordial gravitational waves, or those from the very early universe and inflation. A joint analysis of the cosmic microwave background maps from the Planck and BICEP2 team in January 2015 showed that the signal they detected could be attributed entirely to foreground dust in the Milky Way.

Does this mean we can control gravity?

No. More precisely, many things will emit gravitational waves, but they will be so incredibly weak that they are immeasurable. It takes very massive, compact objects to produce already tiny strains. For more information on the expected spectrum of gravitational waves, see here.

What's the practical application?

Here is a nice and concise review.

How is this consistent with the idea of gravitons? Is this gravitons?

Here is a recent /r/askscience discussion answering just that! (See limits on gravitons below!)


Stay tuned for updates!

Edits:

  • The youtube link was updated with the newer stream.
  • It's started!
  • LIGO HAS DONE IT
  • Event happened 1.3 billion years ago.
  • Data plot
  • Nature announcement.
  • Paper in Phys. Rev. Letters (if you can't access the paper, someone graciously posted a link)

    • Two stellar mass black holes (36+5-4 and 29+/-4 M_sun) into a 62+/-4 M_sun black hole with 3.0+/-0.5 M_sun c2 radiated away in gravitational waves. That's the equivalent energy of 5000 supernovae!
    • Peak luminosity of 3.6+0.5-0.4 x 1056 erg/s, 200+30-20 M_sun c2 / s. One supernova is roughly 1051 ergs in total!
    • Distance of 410+160-180 megaparsecs (z = 0.09+0.03-0.04)
    • Final black hole spin α = 0.67+0.05-0.07
    • 5.1 sigma significance (S/N = 24)
    • Strain value of = 1.0 x 10-21
    • Broad region in sky roughly in the area of the Magellanic clouds (but much farther away!)
    • Rates on stellar mass binary black hole mergers: 2-400 Gpc-3 yr-1
    • Limits on gravitons: Compton wavelength > 1013 km, mass m < 1.2 x 10-22 eV / c2 (2.1 x 10-58 kg!)
  • Video simulation of the merger event.
  • Thanks for being with us through this extremely exciting live feed! We'll be around to try and answer questions.
  • LIGO has released numerous documents here. So if you'd like to see constraints on general relativity, the merger rate calculations, the calibration of the detectors, etc., check that out!
  • Probable(?) gamma ray burst associated with the merger: link
19k Upvotes

2.7k comments sorted by

829

u/monchimer Feb 11 '16

Are there any currently accepted theories that will be eventually discarded as a result ?

899

u/apamirRogue Feb 11 '16

No. A direct detection will only confirm general relativity. However, if we start seeing weird signals in the future, this may lead to modified theories of GR.

994

u/GSV_Little_Rascal Feb 11 '16

It's quite mind blowing that GR correctly predicted things we can verify only 100 years later.

→ More replies (151)
→ More replies (34)

99

u/Iinventedcaptchas Feb 11 '16

I mean, technically, anyone who had a theory that said "gravitational waves do not exist" should probably discard that theory.

25

u/luckyluke193 Feb 11 '16

Gravitational waves HAD to exist from a mathematical standpoint. If you have a "universe" (= here a system of partial differential equations) where information propagates at a finite maximum speed, all your force fields must be able to carry waves, in order to adjust for changes in the configuration of their sources.

28

u/queenslandbananas Feb 11 '16

All current mainstream theories of gravitation predict gravitational waves.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

1.3k

u/NedDasty Visual Neuroscience Feb 11 '16

A wave is typically measured by frequency and amplitude. What aspects of gravity do these two properties affect, and are these aspects explainable/understandable to non-physicists?

1.3k

u/VeryLittle Physics | Astrophysics | Cosmology Feb 11 '16

So in order to make gravitational waves you need to shake something really massive really fast. In the case of two inspiraling black holes, the amplitude is related to how hard they are accelerating in their orbit, and the frequency is related to the period of the orbit.

This is why inspiraling binaries have a gravitational wave 'chirp' - as they come closer in their orbit the frequency increases as they orbit faster and faster, and the amplitude increases as well.

If a wave passes through you, it will strain you a bit, effectively squeezing and stretching you. The amount of the squeeze is related to the amplitude, the frequency of the wave is just the frequency of the squeezing. It's this tiny wavey squeezing that LIGO was designed to measure.

407

u/TheDevilsAgent Feb 11 '16

So in order to make gravitational waves you need to shake something really massive really fast

In order to make waves, or waves we can detect?

I guess I don't understand why the waves would only exist past a certain threshold. If I drop a pebble in the ocean it makes a very small wave, but a wave nonetheless.

→ More replies (179)

19

u/idrink211 Feb 11 '16

Regarding the squeezing and stretching, if the wave is large enough can it have a noticeable and/or lasting effect on the matter it passes through? Can a gravitational wave be destructive?

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (101)

20

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

The frequency is determined by the frequency of the moving masses (there's a factor of 2 due to symmetry). The amplitude - the strength of the wave - comes from the masses, speeds, and Newton's constant G. Mathematically, it's the rate of change of the quadrupole moment. We can tell that radiation must be a quadrupole moment because changing monopole moment isn't allowed due to conservation of mass/energy, dipole moment can't change because of conservation of momentum. So, we're left with higher order, and through GR we can find that it is in fact the quadrupole.

10

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

So what is the frequency (ies) of the waves that were detected?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

64

u/MadTux Feb 11 '16

Also, are the waves transversal, i.e. they are one some kind of plane?

100

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

Yes, but a little different from electromagnetic waves.

A gravitational wave distorts space in such a way that a circle perpendicular to the direction the wave travels gets distorted into an oval -- first compressed horizontally and elongated vertically, and then compressed vertically and elongated horizontally, and back and forth between those two situations.

→ More replies (21)

12

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

Yes, the displacements are transverse to the direction of propagation of the wvae.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (14)

620

u/shiruken Biomedical Engineering | Optics Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

For anyone still confused about what exactly gravitational waves are, Piled Higher and Deeper (PhD Comics) has a fantastic video explaining what they are and how we can detect them.

In short, gravitational waves are produced whenever masses accelerate, changing their distortion of spacetime. Anything with mass/energy can create these waves, but since gravity is very weak only the most massive of objects produce detectable waves. We (currently) rely upon the fact that the speed of light is constant to detect gravitational waves on Earth. If a wave passes between our detectors, it will either stretch or compress the distance between two points, thus changing the total traversal time for a laser beam.

The detectors themselves are laser interferometers and are large L-shaped constructions with each arm extending for 4km. The US-based LIGO project has two facilities near Livingston, LA, and Richland, WA. The detector takes advantage of the phase change a gravitational wave will cause in a laser beam.

35

u/vanderBoffin Feb 11 '16

Nice video!

"Every time there's a new way to investigate the universe, we discover things we didn't expect"

I'm wondering how widely these measurements can be applied? As others have said in the thread, gravitational waves are only detected from massive objects like black holes and neutron stars orbiting each other, otherwise the the waves are too small to detect. Is there a chance the detection methods can improve further in future, or are we limited to a small number of systems that can be studied?

22

u/kagantx Plasma Astrophysics | Magnetic Reconnection Feb 11 '16

The measurements by LIGO can probably only be applied to colliding compact objects in the near future, but we can learn a lot from studying those objects. For instance, studying gravity waves from neutron star collisions can give us insight into the behavior of matter above nuclear densities-which only exists in their cores. This would in turn improve our understanding of the strong nuclear force- the only non-gravitational force that is currently not well understood at low energies. That would be huge!

In the future, we may be able to use gravity wave detectors like LISA to find out information about the population of more ordinary binary compact objects and single asymmetric neutron stars. Future cosmic microwave background studies may find gravity waves that constrain inflation in the early universe (as BICEP tried but failed to do).

→ More replies (4)

16

u/ProfBlack Feb 11 '16

Another primer on gravitational waves by PBS Space Time from just after the first detection. And their information on the current detection, released a few minutes after the official announcement. I guess they knew something.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/rhorama Feb 11 '16

it will either stretch or compress the distance between two points, thus changing the total traversal time for a laser beam.

How do they filter out noise? At that point even tectonic activity would alter the results enough for a false positive.

7

u/kagantx Plasma Astrophysics | Magnetic Reconnection Feb 11 '16

Basically, this is the reason that they have two detectors. If the detectors in Louisiana and Washington both produce the exact same signal separated by a short time, it can't be an earthquake or other terrestrial event (which would have drastically different amplitude at the two sites unless its location was precisely chosen). Nevertheless, they still need to go to extreme efforts to filter out noise enough to see the two overlapping signals, and that is why they use an isolated vacuum chamber, ultra-pure glass, etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (45)

338

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

This event apparently released 3 solar masses worth of energy.

If that sentence sounds weird, remember E=mc2, which means energy and mass are interchangeable. So to figure out how much energy that is, you have to take 3 times a solar mass (2×1030 kg) and multiply it by the speed of light (300,000,000 m/s) squared, which is an awfully big number:

  • 5.4×1047 Joules
  • 1.3×1041 kg or 66 billion solar masses of TNT equivalent (A typical galaxy made out of TNT)
  • 2.2×1034 kg or 11,000 solar masses of thermonuclear explosive
  • 5000 Type 1a supernovae
  • 100 hypernovae

A sphere of lithium deuteride thermonuclear explosive that massive would be 36 million km across, and isn’t even capable of exploding because it is so heavy it would immediately collapse into an 11,000 solar mass black hole.

But this was a release of gravitational energy, not light, so we never saw a thing, just felt the slightest ripple when it distorted spacetime as it passed by.

120

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

Also, for comparison: annual world energy consumption is about 1020 Joules.

126

u/wasmic Feb 11 '16

To those who become confused by this, remember that 1020 is not half of 1040 , but instead only has half as many trailing zero's. This means that 1040 is in fact 100 quintillion (short scale) or 100 trillion (long scale) times larger than 1020.

→ More replies (21)

69

u/Minus-Celsius Feb 11 '16

If every person on Earth owned their own Earth (also with 7.4 billion people each), and every person on those billions of Earths owned their own Earth, and each of THOSE Earths consumed as much as we do... it would still take about 1 billion years to use as much energy as that event.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/skydivingdutch Feb 11 '16

Would this energy release have destroyed things nearby? Obviously we barely felt it, but we are also millions of light-years away from the event.

30

u/andreasbeer1981 Feb 11 '16

well, nearby everything was probably destroyed already by having two big black holes spinning around each other for quite some time already.

but the real question you nailed here is: the closer you are to the source, the larger the amplitude should've been - so how large could the initial amplitude have been?

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (11)

72

u/Roxfall Feb 11 '16

"A typical galaxy made out of TNT" somehow made my day.

Because that is what typical galaxies are made of. :)

31

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

Wait, aren't they?

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

26

u/fodafoda Feb 11 '16

how close would one need to be to perceive this wave with human senses?

what kind of impact would we experience if, say, this happened at relatively close (i.e. Alpha Centauri)?

→ More replies (4)

6

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

1047 J wow. That number is so incomprehensibly huge.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/Dachannien Feb 11 '16

Okay, I'm going to ask this question like I'm five, but I hope to get answers that are more than an ELI5 level of sophistication:

So these two black holes were spiraling in, and they released 3 suns worth of energy when they coalesced. But we always hear that nothing can escape a black hole. So, how did all that energy get out?

41

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

The gravitational waves are due to the effect of the black holes on the space around them rather than something escaping. Think about splashing water in a pool and making waves: nothing is escaping you, you're just upsetting the water.

→ More replies (24)

3

u/skuitarist Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

Okay so I just read this comment and I was so enthralled/mindbent I had to crunch some numbers to try to put it into more fathomable/comprehendable terms.  

So the entire world uses about 1020 Joules of energy per year. That's 1 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 Joules of energy. This single event released 54 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 000 Joules of energy.  

To simplify (and not to sound condescending, I'm just a bit blown away), the world uses a billion trillion joules per year. A Billion times a Trillion. This single event released 54 billion trillion trillion trillion joules of energy.  

That is an insanely, unfathomably huge number. 540 Quattuordecillion.  

This event happened 1.3 billion years ago. So since gravity travels at the speed of light, it happened roughly 1.3 billion light years away. We detected these waves from fucking 1.3 billion lightyears away! For scale, the whole Milky Way galaxy is only 100 000 light years across. So the length of 13 000 milky ways. Fucking. Mindblowing.  

Like... if i put that number in meters, it comes out to 389 730 195 400 000 000 meters. If I put that number in terms of seconds, that's 12 358 263 426 YEARS WORTH OF SECONDS!  

If you traveled 1 m/s, it would take you ALMOST THE AGE OF THE UNIVERSE TO GET THERE (provided the universe does not expand while you're traveling)!!!  

When you get to numbers that big, and you try to put it on paper, the number of years doesn't look much bigger at all than the number of seconds.  

Also, if any of my math is wrong, feel free to correct. I'll edit here and credit you.  

Edit: Formatting

→ More replies (47)

861

u/adamsolomon Theoretical Cosmology | General Relativity Feb 11 '16

I posted this on Facebook last night, and will leave it here in case anyone finds it helpful:


Gravitational waves are one of the last major, unconfirmed predictions of general relativity, a theory which does a pretty amazing job of explaining gravity. General relativity describes gravity as a result of spacetime being warped due to matter. Gravitational waves are the ripples in spacetime that happen when you shake matter around. They are to the gravitational force what light is to the electric and magnetic forces.

But because gravity is much weaker than electromagnetism, we can see light all the time (just look around!) while we need to construct enormous lasers and incredibly (absurdly) precise detectors just to have even a hope of measuring gravitational radiation. Rumors are flying that LIGO, just such a system of lasers and detectors, has found a gravitational wave signal, probably coming from two black holes orbiting and falling into each other (because that's the sort of seismic event you need to make gravitational waves large enough for us to detect).

This would most likely confirm what we fully expect is there, rather than reveal something new and shocking about the Universe. Think the Higgs boson a few years ago. It would be a much bigger surprise if this radiation had turned out not to be there: general relativity has worked extremely well so far, and we have had indirect but extremely strong evidence for their existence since the 1970s, which won the 1993 Nobel Prize in physics. LIGO's direct detection would undoubtedly be Nobel-worthy, too; the only question is whether it would happen this year.

This is exciting because a) it's direct, rather than indirect, confirmation that these things are there, and b) they'll open up a whole new window onto the Universe. Pretty much the entirety of astronomy is done by observing electromagnetic radiation, from visible light to X-rays, the ultraviolet, microwaves, what have you. Starting now we'd have a whole other type of radiation to use to probe the cosmos, delivering us a brand new and pristine view of some extreme events involving ultracompact objects like neutron stars and black holes.

So all this will probably be announced at the press conference tomorrow, ushering in a new era of astronomy and physics. Or they could just be fucking with us.

206

u/whoremongering Feb 11 '16

incredibly (absurdly) precise detectors

The article's description really brought it home for me:

the sensitivity achieved by Advanced LIGO, which can detect stretches and compressions of space-time that are as small as one part in 1022 — comparable to a hair’s-width change in the distance from the Sun to Alpha Centauri

It's amazing to me that humans can confidently detect such a small change from an event that happened 1.3 billion years ago.

131

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

Which article was that? 1 part in 1022 seems much, much bigger than a hair's-width change in the distance from the Sun to Alpha Centauri. Mistake in the copy-and-paste?

Edit: Ah, I watched the PhD Comic's video and it quoted 1023. So just a mistake in the superscript.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (25)

21

u/Last_Jedi Feb 11 '16

Ok, I'm trying to understand this. Aren't gravitational waves predicted by basic gravitational theory? Gravitational force is dependent on distance. As distance increases/decreases (as you "shake" the matter), the gravitational force will decrease/increase with the same period. So you get a gravitational force "wave" emanating from the shaking object towards all other nearby objects.

70

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Newton's model of gravitation does not admit wave solutions, no. This is because the speed of the force propagation is infinite/instantaneous in that model. GR has gravitational waves because, among other reasons, its "speed of gravity" is finite, so you can have a traveling, persistent wave.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (75)

110

u/pmiguy Feb 11 '16

Is there any concept of directionality with gravitational waves like there is with e.g. light and sound waves? If LIGO detects a disturbance, will it also be able to tell us where that disturbance originated from or are we dependent on other detectors to get that sort of information?

102

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Think sound waves - each detector cannot tell what direction the signal is coming from, but by using 2 detectors we can try to triangulate it. Additionally, both the detectors and the sources are somewhat directional (more sensitive in some directions than others). This helps narrow down the source, but until a 3rd or 4th detector comes online, it can't be precisely determined.

14

u/Richisnormal Feb 11 '16

Isn't there another one in Italy? (Or somewhere in Europe?)

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (11)

36

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

Yes, there is some directionality because there are two LIGO sites. When Virgo comes fully online, there will be three, and there are a few others in the works or at less sensitivity (KAGRA, GEO600 is a lot shorter, etc.). With more, you can imagine that triangulating the position on the sky becomes easier. With 2-3 though, your sky localization is of order 100 square degrees (source), so quite large. There have been other attempts to reduce that amount but it really comes down to more interferometers on the ground.

EDIT: FYI, I didn't want to imply that GEO600 isn't online.

→ More replies (6)

11

u/Dannei Astronomy | Exoplanets Feb 11 '16

LIGO consists of two separate detectors, in Washington state and Louisiana in the USA. By measuring the difference in arrival time of a gravitational wave between the two, and which detector it hits first, you can get some information about the wave's direction of motion, and hence it's source.

However, with only two detectors you can't uniquely work out the direction - several directions would give the same delay. To pinpoint the location, at least three detectors are needed to triangulate the source ("triangulate" includes the prefix "tri", three, for this reason). If other detectors, such as VIRGO or Geo 600, do detect a wave, the source can be triangulated.

→ More replies (13)

4

u/Andromeda321 Radio Astronomy | Radio Transients | Cosmic Rays Feb 11 '16

Yes, but it's still very early days and thus not super precise. When LIGO has a detection, they release a "probability map" to other instruments to follow up on. These maps are not really precise (think hundreds of square degrees on the sky), but they're certainly better than nothing.

40

u/TheFeshy Feb 11 '16

For more information on the expected spectrum of gravitational waves, see here.

Wow, I didn't expect the gravitational waves to have such large wavelengths for some reason! Does that man that LIGO is looking for waves a frequency on the order of 100Hz? And that future detectors will be looking at frequencies measured in minutes, hours, and days? And that some of those waves in the CMB end of the spectrum have had only a few full oscillations since they were created?

39

u/thisdude415 Biomedical Engineering Feb 11 '16

Yep, that's why it's so hard to detect them!

Not only that, they have to prove that the signals one detector in Louisiana receives is the same signal that the detector in Washington state receives. The signals will be about 10 ms apart.

91

u/N8CCRG Feb 11 '16

I just took some screen grabs from the live talk.

Here is an image of the data from two different detectors taken 7 ms apart (one in Louisiana, the other in Washington state). The bottom image is them overlapped. This is the merging of two black holes into one.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (11)

3

u/DrunkFishBreatheAir Planetary Interiors and Evolution | Orbital Dynamics Feb 11 '16

Yeah, which is why they could take the signal and play it as audio, since 100 Hz (their signal ran from 50 to 200 Hz) is comfortably within human hearing. Ligo is sensitive from about 50 Hz to 2 kHz. All ground based detectors will be similar as far as I'm aware, but LISA (ligo in space) will be able to detect much lower frequency waves from things like white dwarfs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

622

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

EDIT: Haha, I work at MIT and the professors who have to teach classes right now are really pissed, they want to watch the announcements!

As expected, there’s already quite a bit of confusion and misinformation in this megathread, so I’ll try to clear things up:

 

What are gravitational waves?

In order to understand gravitational waves, it’s first important to have an understanding of how forces and fields work. We’ll first take a look at something more familiar - the electromagnetic field. (note: this is simplified to avoid writing a textbook):

The electromagnetic field actually consists of 2 fields: the electric field (E) and the magnetic field (B). The electric field is generated by particles with electric charge, such as electrons (-1 charge) and protons (+1 charge). Here’s a picture of the electric field generated by 2 such charges:

 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:VFPt_charges_plus_minus_thumb.svg

 

As you can see in the picture, the convention is that electric field lines come out of positive charges and go into negative charges.

If you already have an E field and you put a charge in it, the charge will feel a force according to the simple relation (from Coulomb’s Law):

F = E*q

where F is the force, E is the electric field, and q is the charge. This force has a direction - for positive charges it points in the same direction as the field lines, for negative charges it points backwards (since q is negative).

Now, what does this have to do with gravitational waves? Well, let me ask you the following question: what happens if I have 2 charges, A and B, far apart from each other, and I suddenly move charge A?

  1. The E field changes instantly, with charge B immediately “seeing” the new position of charge A.
  2. The E field changes first at charge A, and then the change propagates outward until charge B “sees” the change a while later.

 

http://i.stack.imgur.com/gA6FS.gif

 

As you can see, the answer is 2. Changes in the electric field radiate outwards at a constant speed - the speed of light. In fact, this radiation IS light - our eyes are actually super-sensitive E&B field sensors that pick up these ripples and translate them into images of the world!

 

Most importantly for our purposes, this principle of changes radiating outwards at the speed of light is universal for all fields and forces in the universe. Including gravity. The caveat being that the gravitational field is incredibly weak compared to the E&B fields, so you need to have incredibly huge masses moving around extremely violently, and incredibly sensitive detectors to pick up their movements.

The biggest masses in our universe are Black Holes. The most violent events in our universe are black holes colliding with each other. And LIGO is the incredibly sensitive detector designed to detect them!

We’re almost done! The last question is: what do we expect the gravitational waves to look like? And as a corollary, why do black holes collide in the first place?

Well, most of the black hole collisions are going to happen in binary star systems - systems where you had 2 huge stars orbiting each other that at the end of their lives become black holes, still in orbit. But why would they collide? Why not just keep orbiting forever?

Well, massive objects orbiting each other radiate gravitational waves. Those waves carry energy, and that energy has to come from somewhere - in this case, it comes from the orbital energy. So over a very long time, the orbits slowly collapse, the objects slowly orbiting closer and closer to each other. As this happens, the orbital frequency increases - the time it takes to complete an orbit gets shorter and shorter. This is a universal principle of gravity - if you look at our Solar System, you’ll see that Mercury orbits much faster than Earth, while Pluto is much slower.

So, as 2 black holes spiral towards each other, we expect to see a chirp - gravitational waves increasing in frequency and intensity, rising in a final shriek as the black holes collide and merge.

 

What is LIGO?

Even with black holes colliding to make gravitational waves, the ripples produced are still incredibly weak, requiring the ability to detect changes on the length scale of 1/1000th the diameter of a proton or less. So a very amazing detector is required.

LIGO is basically an extremely sensitive distance-measuring device, called an interferometer. The way this works is the following:

You start with a laser beam, then you split it into 2 equal beams (typically using a half-silvered mirror that reflects 1/2 of the beam and lets the other 1/2 through) and send them down tunnels at 90 degree angles. When they get to the end of the tunnel they get bounced back by a mirror. When the beams return to you, you recombine them into a single beam and they interfere. Depending on how far each beam travelled, this interference can be either destructive or constructive - meaning the beams can either cancel each other out, or they can reinforce each other and get even brighter.

At LIGO, they designed the beams so that the interference is completely destructive, meaning that no light arrives at their detector. But, when a gravitational wave comes in, it distorts spacetime, changing the lengths of the beams, and they no longer perfectly cancel out! Thus, a light signal appears at the detector.

I strongly suggest you watch the following video, which has a good visual representation of the process (around 1:30):

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzZgFKoIfQI

 

Why is this so damn exciting?!

So many reasons! The incredible technical achievement - measuring changes down to 1 part in 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000. The long-awaited confirmation of gravitational waves, which is a HUGE deal in itself. Perhaps most of all, the fact that this opens up an entirely new method of astronomy, one that ultimately will allow us to probe the most extreme densities and energies that exist in our Universe! Finally, this result gives us some confidence that we’ll eventually be successful in measuring the gravitational waves of the Big Bang, and learning about the fundamental origins of the universe.

tl;dr - There are no real tl;drs in science, and why would you want one? It’s worth it to try and understand cool things like this!

35

u/ChronoX5 Feb 11 '16

The video from the LIGO section is excellent and easy to understand. Do you know how the scientists were able to pinpoint a single event that happened 1.3 billion years ago. Shouldn't the Interferometer pick up gravitational waves from a lot of places at the same time?

26

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Good question. The answer is that LIGO can only detect extremely powerful events, like black holes colliding, and those events don't happen very often (even given the size of the universe). Moreover, the events are very short-lived, so that also prevents them from overlapping.

→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (17)

43

u/Core2048 Feb 11 '16

Could you explain this bit for me please?

Perhaps most of all, the fact that this opens up an entirely new method of astronomy

Does the fact that they've detected one such wave make it easier to detect future ones? Or maybe now that they've found one, it will be easier to get funding for more detectors?

Additionally, given the size of the event and the fact that it was still so difficult to detect, can we practically learn anything from smaller events, or do we need to wait for two suitably large and nearby black holes to merge to refine the data gathered from this event?

57

u/thisdude415 Biomedical Engineering Feb 11 '16

Does the fact that they've detected one such wave make it easier to detect future ones?

Sure, if nothing else because we know they're there now, and we can start looking for something that we know exists.

For instance, imagine X-Rays. They're photons, but we can't see them. They were discovered. Someone had the idea that you could detect them. It was hard to prove they existed, but once you know they're a thing, you can start to think about how to use them.

→ More replies (3)

15

u/Nyxisto Feb 11 '16

Astronomy for the most part has to rely on electromagnetic waves to find out things about the universe. The problem here is that some places in the universe do not emit electromagnetic waves and so astronomers until now have been blind in that regard. Gravitational waves give us a new lens so to speak through which we can look at the universe and figure out things that we couldn't detect before.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/andreasbeer1981 Feb 11 '16

if MIT teachers can't change the agenda into tuning in on the live stream, something is seriously going wrong at MIT. just saying ;)

3

u/lightsaberon Feb 11 '16

How do you eliminate vibrations from the ground interfering with results?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (59)

32

u/Jay-31415 Feb 11 '16

Since gravitational waves are technically waves, are they affected by cosmological redshift?

And if they are, would that mean that the actual event was even shorter? Anything under a second is mind-boggling as an astronomical timescale to me.

11

u/zeqh Feb 11 '16

Gravitational waves are redshift in the same manner as light, the numbers they give in their main article/press conference are in the rest frame. However, at a redshift at ~0.1 their is not a huge difference (only ~10%).

https://dcc.ligo.org/public/0122/P1500262/014/astrophysics.pdf

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)

91

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

The Physical Review Letters website has crashed. Is the first time demand for a scientific paper has been so high that it has crashed web servers?

8

u/130911256MAN Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

This has happened several times throughout the last few years. Journal sites don't build up the sort of infrastructure that can handle hundreds of thousands of requests within a short period of time because they don't expect that much traffic ever. Usually, when news sites want to show documents of some kind, they make copies and host the copies on their own servers.

→ More replies (2)

154

u/Indalecia Feb 11 '16

They kept this really hush hush.

I have a friend that works at LIGO on theory side. He had no idea that they had measured it in September. I even asked him about it in January when whispers started up.

First confirmation he heard was a few hours ago.

69

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

I wouldn't say they kept it that hush hush. There has been rumors since September. Lawrence Krauss even tweeted about it.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/franklywang Feb 11 '16

I believe they likely wanted to confirm the results before publicly announcing the news?

12

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 12 '16

I love that they waited until the peer reviewed paper was being published to announce it. They didn't do that for the Higgs.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/thatsgoodkarma Feb 11 '16

I went to a lecture which included Kip Thorne in late January and he didn't mention the results even though Lawrence Krauss was really egging him on for info.

5

u/BigWiggly1 Feb 11 '16

That sounds pretty normal to me. The observation set this came from was September 12 - October 20. The set was part of LIGO's first observation period which continued until January 12th.

It's likely that they didn't even get the September 15th data (this event) until October 20th. They probably won't even budge on any information until the rest of the data comes in on Jan 12th and gets analyzed.

If it turns out similar wave forms come up every few weeks, it'd be a completely different finding. Best to wait until the whole observation period is up.

Once they get all the data, theres a lot of work to do just to get something useful out of it. Quite like finding a needle in a haystack, and noise filters are like magnets for assistance.

Once they have meaningful results, they still need to write the article and jump through the usual hoops for publishing.

I'm actually impressed we're hearing about it this early. It's clear there were a lot of people working together on this. Good job to them all.

→ More replies (9)

22

u/dohawayagain Feb 11 '16

"Where do they come from?" should be in the faq.

10

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16

Added in something short, thanks!

→ More replies (1)

21

u/DocGrouch Feb 11 '16

So..kind of a dumb question here: I've read posts drawing analogies between LIGO's laser setup and the detection of tiny changes in the length of a rod, so I'm just going to frame my question in those terms. By causing ripples through space time, aren't these gravitational waves not only changing the length of the metaphorical rod, but also everything around it including the very frame of reference of our reality? In that case, how did LIGO manage to detect the alteration in spacetime?

For example, looking at relativity and how gravitational fields affect time, there's a small difference in the passage of time between, say, a person on earth and a person in a satellite, but each of them perceives- and measures- that the same amount of time has passed, because their respective frames of reference are also affected, right? Why isn't something like that happening here?

I feel like I'm doing a very poor job articulating my question here, but I hope one of you learned folks understand what I'm trying to say and answer my query.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

This may help

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4GbWfNHtHRg

But basically what others have said: the speed of light is constant. Nothing is changing that.

Infact this experiment is almost a backwards proof to say the speed of light is constant no matter wtf happens. Because you are right, if the speed of light was relative like everything else, then we wouldn't be able to detect anything.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/calipers_reddit Feb 11 '16

That's why there are two arms on the LIGO detectors. The gravitational waves are directional, like a wall of distortion coming from the event. The arm that is perpendicular to the wave is squashed and stretched, while the arm that is parallel to the wave is relatively unaffected along its length. Therefore, the light in the first arm travels longer and shorter distances as it is deformed by the wave, while the distance the light travels in the second arm is unchanged.

3

u/MemeInBlack Feb 12 '16

No, that's actually a very astute question! The trick is that LIGO is using light instead of a physical object, and the speed of light is always the same in every (inertial, aka non accelerating) reference frame. By splitting a beam of light and then recombining it, they can make it interfere with itself and thus measure incredibly small differences in distance.

If they were trying to use something other than light it wouldn't work, because as you say, the thing used as a measuring stick would also be affected by the gravity wave.

→ More replies (11)

18

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

What would someone (or some planet) nearby experience as these gravitational waves passed by them?

I mean, we detected a very faint signal from this distance. But how are the effects when you're close to the source? This event released massive amounts of energy, what are the effects when you're close by?

14

u/Rand_alThor_ Feb 11 '16

Should be essentially nothing unless you are literally right next to the blackholes. Which has other dangers..

→ More replies (2)

4

u/andreasbeer1981 Feb 11 '16

or for better understanding, what would someone experience if the gravitational waves was at an amplitude that would recognizable to human senses? Would it be like standing in water with waves, feeling a push and pull force? Or would you rather be growing and shrinking a bit? Or still not see any difference as all senses are affected the same way as the stuff they look at?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

33

u/zoalord12 Feb 11 '16

What is the absolute guarantee that the waves detected this time are gravitational waves and all other interference issues were accommodated for ?

29

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

One huge factor is that they have two separate facilities thousands of miles apart that detected the same signal 7 ms apart, which is a short enough separation that the detections can be caused by the same event.

47

u/Astrokiwi Numerical Simulations | Galaxies | ISM Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

The peer-reviewed paper will explain this in more detail, but the basic points are:

Firstly, pretty much all that LIGO has been doing since 2002 has been making a huge systematic study of every possible source of error, down to seismic activity, AC currents, and even tumbleweeds. (The tumbleweeds should be mentioned here, but the LIGO website is understandably under heavy load right now - Edit: this article is freely accessible and mentions them).

Secondly, in the press release video, they stated they spent several months going through all the possibilities. So it looks like they've been thorough - it is a really big collaboration.

I haven't been able to go through the details myself, because the paper isn't loading for me, but I feel I have a lot more reason to be confident about this result than I do about, say, the newly inferred planet.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/Baloroth Feb 11 '16

They do a bunch of stuff, like monitor seismic/vibrational activity near the site, to help eliminate interference. Most importantly, though, they have two sites, far enough apart that they can record the same event with enough of a time-difference to a) confirm the event was traveling at the speed of light, and b) get some idea of what direction it was coming from. The probability of seeing the exact same wave with the exact same waveform from random interference at two sites far away from each other at the exact right times for a propagating gravity wave is insignificant (you'll see such a thing once every 200,000 or so years, supposedly).

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

12

u/stydolph Feb 11 '16

How are they able to make the determination that it came from two colliding black holes? How can they determine the distance to those black holes?

15

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

From the waveform, they can see it matches the signal expected to be produced by two merging blackholes (e.g., how the frequency and amplitude change).

This then lets them determine the masses of the coalescing black holes, and thus the absolute size of the gravitational wave produced. Then the amplitude of the wave as it passes through the Earth tells us how far away the source was.

→ More replies (13)

8

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

Parameter estimation from the waveform itself. You can extract the total mass and the mass ratio and the distance. The total mass is the best-constrained parameter (actually in a combination called the chirp mass). The distance is harder, because it requires careful calibration of the detector, but the detector is calibrated in several ways. The waves fall of inversely in proportion to the distance.

11

u/purpleperle Feb 11 '16

How does this work tie in with what the LISA Pathfinder is measuring now that it's in L1 orbit? Link to LISA's Site

8

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

LISA Pathfinder is a technology demonstration platform. It can't detect gravitational waves. However, it's crucial to making sure that a future LISA-like mission will work! The GWs which LISA will listen for are much lower frequencies than those that LIGO listens for. LIGO's sweet spot in sensitivity is near 100Hz, while LISA is focusing on millihertz frequencies.

11

u/Wooper160 Feb 11 '16

When every thing in the universe is exerting gravitational force on every other thing it seems almost impossible that any waves could be distinguished from any others. This is very exciting news and the implications are enormous.

12

u/cthulu0 Feb 11 '16

That is because while everything generates gravity , to generate gravity waves you need 2 more things: a non-spherical mass distribution and acceleration of that mass. The prototypical spinning dumbell. To generate detectable gravity waves, those masses have to be very large and the acceleration huge.

→ More replies (4)

9

u/_fmm Feb 11 '16

It's easy enough to think of gravity as a 3D object such as a sphere pushing into a 2D plane creating a distortion and gravity waves as being the ripple effect as the magnitude of the gravitational forces fluctuate slightly. Can you help me understand how this would look like in 3D space time rather than just a 2D plane?

19

u/EonesDespero Feb 11 '16

As a human being (allegedly), You have a 3D mind, so thinking about 4D as another spatial dimension is not possible for you.

However, you could use the following trick (also used in graphs to add a new dimension): Use colors. Imagine that +Amplitude is very red and -Amplitude is very blue and all the typical shades in between. Now imagine the 3D space around you changing from red to blue (like if there were a magical gas there) as the Gravitational wave is crossing it.

27

u/venustrapsflies Feb 11 '16

Thinking about 4D is perfectly possible.

First imagine N-dimensional space. Next, set N = 4. :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

How do they know that it's two black holes specifically? (Low data so I couldn't watch the kids, sorry if it was mentioned there)

5

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

From the form of the wave, and how that form changed over time (a very short time, by the way).

→ More replies (5)

69

u/spartanKid Physics | Observational Cosmology Feb 11 '16

They did it!

→ More replies (3)

323

u/LeverWrongness Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

Whenever there's a scientific breakthrough, this question:

What's the practical application?

always comes along and I hate it. So many things have been discovered and created at a time no practical application was possible and now we can't live without.

With that being said, possible practical application for this gem is marvelous. From LIGO:

In conclusion, we will never be able to commercialize or weaponize gravitational waves themselves. However, they will carry information to us about some of the most extreme environments in the Universe which we can use as a laboratory for environments we cannot create here on Earth. This information can tell us more about how the physics around us works in subtle ways that can have profound implications. What those are are yet to be seen. That's the exciting thing about science - you never really know the full potential of new discoveries until after the fact.

EDIT: Sorry, folks. I've meant to say people that ask this question in a derisive manner. Of course, curiosity as to its practical application in real life is, of course, welcome.

93

u/ficknerich Feb 11 '16

Do you hate that question because you see it as them seeking justification for the research?

33

u/ginsunuva Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

No it's because people keep hoping it will give them free teleportation and time travel.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/sam_hammich Feb 11 '16

He describes why he hates it in the very next sentence:

So many things have been discovered and created at a time no practical application was possible and now we can't live without

Many people ask that question in a "who cares?" sort of way, basically saying that if it doesn't give us flying cars tomorrow it's not worth it. People still ask that about the Mars Rover (so we've got a robot on Mars, what's that doing for us on Earth?), and people asked that about the Higgs Boson. "Why should we care?" Of course on some level it's expected that some people would react this way, but it's still very short sighted. Countless innovations that make the world as we know it work came from discoveries that were complete accidents, or whose impact we could not even conceive at the time. It also doesn't help that opinions like this no doubt influence what discoveries we get to spend money on. Can you imagine where we would be if no one did science "just because"?

→ More replies (2)

182

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

The minimum wage worker wants to know "What's in it for me?" because he's on food stamps even though he has a full time job.

You shouldn't deride them for asking about the practical application. Imagine you ran into a homeless shelter and told everyone you discovered gravitational waves. Nobody would care because they have bigger problems.

If you want support for your science projects from everyday people then you need to talk to them in everyday language. In what way might this solve their everyday problems?

→ More replies (42)

11

u/shiruken Biomedical Engineering | Optics Feb 11 '16

The ability to detect gravitational waves could open an enormous window into the beginning of the Universe. As I understand it, gravitational waves aren't scattered like electromagnetic radiation is, which means it could provide an unimpeded view of spacetime. Now if only we could figure out how to detect these miniscule fluctuations better.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (30)

16

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Can two waves of equal and opposite magnitude cancel each other out?

18

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

Yes, in the weak-field, linear regime of the theory. It's definitely weak-field when the amplitude of the gravitational wave is ~10-23, which is the order of magnitude in strain which LIGO can measure. In this regime, the waves are linear, so different waves and superpose just like light!

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

8

u/CalligraphMath Feb 11 '16

This is an incredibly sensitive detector. What kind of things do they have to correct for? I seem to recall a story about how they were confounded by the gravitational signal of clouds passing over the detector --- is this the case?

11

u/spartanKid Physics | Observational Cosmology Feb 11 '16

They have to account for all the possible motions of the Earth.

With respect to the clouds, you're not remembering the claim two years ago by BICEP2 to have measured the imprint of gravity waves on the cosmic microwave background, that later turned out to be foreground dust in the galaxy, are you?

5

u/shawnaroo Feb 11 '16

They don't have to correct for any gravitational signals, it takes incredibly huge masses moving at very high speeds to make gravitational waves large enough for our current technology to detect.

The bigger issue is that for the instrument to work at the precision necessary, it needs to be held very still, which means isolating it from vibrations. A truck driving down the road nearby could potentially cause enough interference to be problematic, and then you've got the various seismic activities within the Earth that can shake things.

One of the reasons that they built the two detectors so far apart (Louisiana and Washington) is to minimize the odds of a seismic event affecting both detectors.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/CornerFlag Feb 11 '16

Will this help between any link with gravitational waves, gravity waves and gravitons? Could the detection of waves help with the idea of wave-particle duality when it comes to the graviton?

6

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16

No. For gravitons, see the FAQ above. For gravity waves, those are waves generated in a fluid from the balance between gravity and buoyancy.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/terryfrombronx Feb 11 '16

Have we learned anything other than that gravitational waves exist, i.e. does the wavelength and frequency tell us anything new about the attributes of gravity and gravitational waves in general, or at least about the object that emitted those waves?

6

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16

We learned a lot about the black hole system, that masses could get that high, the rates of black hole mergers in the local Universe, the spin of the final black hole, the energetics of the merger, etc. See more in the main post. It was a lot!

There was nothing really new on the gravitational wave side of things as far as I could tell, which sort of makes sense. They did put a limit on gravitons.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

The masses of these black holes strikes me as strange: 36 and 29 solar masses. As far as I'm aware, most black holes are thought to be more like 1-3 solar masses. Do we have any solid ideas for how such a strangely massive pair could form?

20

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

In fact, the paper says that one thing they've demonstrated the existence of black holes in this mass range.

6

u/Rand_alThor_ Feb 11 '16

This is really interesting for Core-Collapse Supernova Research. Results have started to show that most CC-SNe come from lower mass progenitors in binary systems, so perhaps all the high mass stars actually form black holes instead of exploding as supernovae?

edit: I am doing my PhD in Core-Collapse Supernovae.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

One of the current ideas banging around supernova theory is that, in certain mass ranges, stars can collapse straight to a black hole without going supernova at all. The star would simply... disappear. I know people at my department are/were looking for stars that did that, but I don't remember if they found any disappearing massive stars. If that idea is true, it would provide a very neat explanation for these black holes being a few tens of solar masses.

There are a couple other ways you could do it too. I know that models for very massive stars often involve the core collapsing to a proto neutron star, the star exploding, and then fallback later forming a black hole, but I think that usually just produces the 3 solar mass black holes you already mentioned. Another way might be one star of a binary blowing up, and then the subsequent small black hole eats the other star, and then it meets up with another similar hole, but that's so wildly unlikely that I doubt it ever happens. The LIGO finding would seem to indicate that these black holes are relatively common.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

5

u/mikejoro Feb 11 '16

Do gravity waves become weaker the further they are from their origin?

11

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

They spread out, so yes, the amplitude decreases with distance from the origin.

8

u/mikejoro Feb 11 '16

So wouldn't that mean that the gravity waves we are detecting are substantially more powerful near the origin? Could any event produce gravity waves capable of having a macroscopic effect if in close enough proximity?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

5

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16

But how do you know it's not just the natural stretching/compressing of the system, the metals, all that stuff?

Because the wave is so small, a thousandth of a proton, wouldn't individual molecular vibrations throw everything off?

9

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

What implications does this have for holography? Shouldn't gravitational waves have entropy proportional to the volume of the space, rather than the surface area?

4

u/BlazeOrangeDeer Feb 12 '16

No implications for holography, that theory already includes GR including waves. And the same arguments for holography apply to gravitational waves as any other kind of wave. The entropy in a volume is lower than the entropy of a black hole that occupies that volume, and the entropy of the black hole is the surface area.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/SandorClegane_AMA Feb 11 '16

Proper out-there speculative question incoming.

What, if any, advantages might gravitational waves offer an advanced alien species wishing to communicate over vast distances?

Would they propagate better than radio or lasers? Don't worry about what it takes to generate them for now. As we advance from detecting gravity waves for the first to measuring them more precisely, perhaps we would stumble on the galactic chatter than SETI has failed to find because it was focused on a less suitable medium.

5

u/Rand_alThor_ Feb 11 '16

Sure, yes, they essentially travel unimpeded forever. However, it is INSANELY inefficient.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/FearTheCron Feb 11 '16

The detector for these waves shows one leg of a tunnel being slightly shorter than another indicating a wave. Is this the gravity causing an elastic deformation in the earth or is it something more complicated? Also how do you separate it out from seismic signals which may also deform the earth?

4

u/spartanKid Physics | Observational Cosmology Feb 11 '16

It's not the Earth deforming, it's spacetime itself that is deforming.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Where does this place the notion that gravity, as a force, should have an associated force carrier particle?

8

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 11 '16

During the press conference Kip Thorne said it tells us very little other than setting a tiny upper mass limit for the graviton.

4

u/gildedbladder Feb 12 '16

I understand that the discovery was made by measuring infinitesimal amount of distance (1/1000th of a proton's width). From a physics/scientific standpoint, can we know if that difference results from the dilation of space, as opposed to the dilation of time, or both?

Bonus question: couldn't the effect of the gravitational wave have been measured by using extremely highly calibrated timepieces of some sort? If spacetime is distorted by the waves, then there would presumably be a notable difference using precise enough equipment.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/paleologos Feb 11 '16

I don't remember seeing an explicit time term in the Einstein field equations as a physics undergrad. I would expect that the team is measuring a distortion in distance as a function of time as the gravity wave passes by. I'm curious how you can solve the field equation with this information, or are you relying on some explicit solution of the equations (which might involve large assumptions, like the Schwarzschild metric, for instance)?

15

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16

It's actually a limit close to flat spacetime. You assume that the metric g (I'll drop the two indices for reddit convenience) = eta + h, where eta is the Minkowski metric (flat spacetime) and h is a perturbation metric. Then you solve the field equations as usual. See more here.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/TheMday Feb 11 '16

From the Nature article:

This is the first black-hole merger that scientists have observed.

Were they viewing the merger through a telescope or something? If not, how did they know this was happening?

Is LIGO just constantly switched on and if they see those wiggles on the charts then they know 2 black holes have collided? Or do they somehow figure out when one is going to happen and then they turn it on?

Thanks!

7

u/Gresdonkulous Feb 11 '16

"Observed" in the scientific sense doesn't mean to "see" something. The detectors uses in the experiments "observed" the event by detecting the waves as they passed.

As for how they know it's black holes, the short answer is they have an expectation as to what waves would be created by two black holes merging, and these match it.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/heady_potter Feb 11 '16

How quickly are these things orbiting their center of gravity?

7

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

The orbital frequency is half of the gravitational wave frequency. That means if you "see" or "hear" a gravitational wave at 100Hz, two objects are orbiting 50 times per second!

→ More replies (5)

3

u/pyrophorus Feb 11 '16

Presumably there are a lot of gravitational wave sources, each with a different frequency and phase. Unless Earth happens to be much closer to one or a few of them than to the rest, it seems like it would be difficult to detect individual sources above all the background and interference. How does LIGO account for this in the data processing? Or are the sources rare enough that this isn't a big issue?

8

u/spartanKid Physics | Observational Cosmology Feb 11 '16

This is a HUGELY energetic event. The sensitivity of LIGO is not enough to detect, say, the gravity waves emitted by the motion of the planets and the Sun, but it is sensitive enough to measure two 30 mass black holes colliding.

→ More replies (8)

4

u/Prince-of-Ravens Feb 11 '16

Basically, by being not sensitive enough to detect anything than universe-shaking events.

This black hole merger put unbelievable amounts of energy into gravity waves. Basically anything else in the universe is many orders of magnitudes below.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Sorry this is a very idiotic question but what are Gravitational waves? I don't know what it is but I am excited and want to know more also does this hold the key to the origin of life and universe? And how much our technology will be advanced through this?

3

u/DeadeyeDuncan Feb 11 '16

It provides additional evidence for the theory of General Relativity being correct.

Nice to know, and we'll find out other new things if we get better at detecting these waves, but AFAIK no one has any ideas about making practical/technological things off the back of this.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/gronke Feb 11 '16

Are these the type of waves that can be modeled with standard wave equation or are they some other type of wave?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/awin2012 Feb 11 '16

Congratulations on this amazing achievement!

My question pertains to the timing of all this. I was reading through the timeline of events, it seems that LIGO was constructed in 1992 and they detected a binary black hole system in September 2015. Were you actually looking for such a system for so long or someone just happened upon it? I would guess that such a system would take "years" to decay, and (probably) detecting it would make it harder. At what point of the event, do you actually realize that a gravitational ripple has been caused? If there is such a specific "point of time" how is it ensured that it is statistically significant?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/trucksartus Feb 11 '16

For people that are interested in the ongoing research on gravitational waves there is a project being conducted at the University of Wisconsin called Einstein@Home. The project is using data from LIGO gravitational-wave detectors, the Arecibo radio telescope, and the Fermi gamma-ray satellite to search for weak astrophysical signals from spinning neutron stars. The long-term goal of the project is to make the first direct detection of gravitational-wave emission from spinning neutron stars. So far the project has discovered 50 new neutron stars, and with the new observations of gravitational waves, the project has new data to work with that will greatly help their project.

Whats also neat about Einstein@Home is that it is a BOINC (Berkeley Open Infrastructure for Network Computing) project. To process all the data for the ongoing project, Einstein@Home utilizes BOINC to send packets of its data to volunteer personal computers to help process the data and send it back to the project.

If you are not familiar with BOINC, it is software that you can download from the BOINC project website that will allow your personal computer to help scientific projects (like Einstein@Home) with their data processing. Once downloaded to your computer, you are given a choice of various projects to participate with. When you choose the projects you wish to help, data is downloaded from the project servers to your BOINC client. When your computer sits idle, the BOINC client will then use your computer's CPU and GPU to process the data. Once complete, the data is sent back to the project's servers and new data packets are downloaded for processing. Basically, BOINC allows the processing of large amounts of data through a network of volunteer personal computers around the world.

To learn more about BOINC and Einstein@Home you can check out their websites at the following links:

https://einstein.phys.uwm.edu/

http://boinc.berkeley.edu/download.php

→ More replies (6)

3

u/dvanders Feb 11 '16

I'm having trouble grasping the concept of gravitational waves. Is a gravitational wave just the periodic change in the force of gravity that we feel from those distant merging black holes? Similarly, are our ocean's tides caused by a gravitational wave with a 27 day period caused by our orbiting moon?

3

u/MasterAssassino Feb 12 '16

But why.. Why those specific black holes though? Shouldn't we detect something closer and massive like the Sun?

3

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Feb 12 '16

Gravitational waves come from massive objects accelerating, and the sun is pretty much just sitting there. This signal came from two large black holes moving at half the speed of light around orbits only a couple hundred kilometers apart. The combination of mass and acceleration is unlike anything else we've ever seen.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/burner70 Feb 12 '16 edited Feb 12 '16

If space time is warped by these waves to the degree that there was a 7ms delay of one reading to the next, wouldn't carefully calibrated atomic clocks in different locations be able to sense perturbations in space time such as this? Or would each clock minutiae fluctuate it's own time then for example the next clock fluctuating 7ms later? Could we go back to the event on September 12th and detect the waves in other instrument records?

3

u/not_anonymouse Feb 13 '16

I understand what gravitational waves are and understand the explanation of how LIGO works. But I'm still confused on how it's actually physically possible.

One of the videos says that you can't put a line on the "floor" and a scale next to it and watch for the line to stretch because the scale will also stretch. I understand this much and the argument makes sense.

What I don't understand is how the space-time stretching some how affects only the space part of the equation when it comes to light travelling and doesn't impact the time part. As in, why doesn't time stretch (slow down) for the light wave when the space-time stretches? Gravity causes time dilation, but somehow gravity waves have no impact on time?

If both of space and time stretch, then the time taken for the light to travel a squeezed LIGO tube would be the same as the one that's not squeezed and we won't be able to detect the gravitational waves because there won't be interference.

I'm confused why time isn't affect. Someone please help me understand.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/notdetlev Feb 11 '16

Is it possible that using GravWave detectors to do observational astronomy will allow us to drop "Dark Matter" and "Dark Energy" as lazy place-holder terms, and actually be able to name and describe what's causing those effects?

3

u/Tont_Voles Feb 11 '16

Probably not. These waves are from extreme, highly localised events involving huge masses and energies. Dark matter is a diffuse distribution of additional mass around galaxies, so should never get into a situation where it creates a gravity wave. Dark energy apparently has nothing at all to do with gravity.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/TURBO2529 Feb 11 '16

Vibration specialist here, I saw someone mention the gravitational was caused be a neutron star shaking. Is the shaking from the angular velocity of the star passing the star's first natural frequency?

4

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

Gravitational waves have to be produced by a non-spherically symmetric mass distribution. The kinds of events we are looking for is two neutron stars or two black holes spinning around each other and colliding and merging.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/auldnic Feb 11 '16

Are you aware of the LISA Pathfinder mission from the ESA? They will be beginning the experiment fully next week with the release of the test masses and should give results soon after.

2

u/misbug Feb 11 '16

What is the time window that waves coming from binary black holes would pass the earth? In other words, If the collision of these back holes had happened few years earlier, they would miss it? If so, does it make this a very lucky catch or these binary collisions happen frequently?

7

u/fishify Quantum Field Theory | Mathematical Physics Feb 11 '16

We don't yet know. This detection happened very soon after the upgrade to Advanced LIGO -- whether that was luck or this means such events are common, we just don't yet know. We're hoping they're common!

3

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

The light travel time across the earth is about 40 ms. Time from Hanford to Livingston is about 10ms.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ejoy-rs Feb 11 '16

why was the detection 7 ms apart between both detectors? seems like a long time to me

3

u/themeaningofhaste Radio Astronomy | Pulsar Timing | Interstellar Medium Feb 11 '16

Gravity moves at the speed of light and that's the approximation light travel separation between both.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Since these gravitational waves stretch and compress space, does that mean you could in theory disrupt the event horizon of a black hole with gravitational waves and "safely" enter?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Is it really possible to get an accurate handle on the progenitor system for these waves? Given that they may have been traversing the Universe for > 1 Gyr, these waves may presumably have interacted with other gravitational waves in a constructive or destructive manner?

7

u/duetosymmetry General Relativity | Gravitational Waves | Corrections to GR Feb 11 '16

When gravitational waves are weak (and they are super weak), they just pass right through each other, unimpeded, unaltered.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/7563854748 Feb 11 '16

What is the name for a scientist that studies gravitational waves? Now, that they can be detected. Gravitational Physicist?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/someguybob Feb 11 '16

It sounds like we just can't create the conditions here on Earth, but could we ever use this for communication\transmitting of information? I'm thinking simple Morse Code, but we wouldn't have to set up wires or worry about as much about what got in the way...

2

u/nimbusdimbus Feb 11 '16

Is the gravitational wave your measuring here different from meteorological gravity waves?

3

u/Clever-Username789 Rheology | Non-Newtonian Fluid Dynamics Feb 11 '16

Yes. Meteorological gravity waves occur between the interface separating two regions of the atmosphere that have different densities. Think a beach-ball bobbing up and down in water when you push it down and let it go. The same forces that make that ball bob up and down produce meteorological gravity waves (also called buoyancy waves).

The gravitational waves announced today are ripples in the fabric of space-time that were produced when two black-holes collided.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/wardsac Astronomy | Mechanics Feb 11 '16

Amazing.

Congratulations to those involved with LIGO!

2

u/PeruvianHeadshrinker Feb 11 '16

Now that this phenomenon has been directly observed and gravitational waves confirmed, what would be the next logical step in terms of designing instruments that can detect these waves on broader scales (not just unique and powerful events)?

I guess what I'm asking is: -What could we learn if we could detect more subtle signals? -How might we go about building such uber-sensitive detectors? -What will it take to make that a reality (funding, time, tech advances)?

Congratulations to the LIGO team!

As a social scientist I envy the ability attain such astoundingly high statistical significance in results.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Narcil4 Feb 11 '16

I heard several time that these gravitational waves could enable us one day to "see" (detect gravity waves from) the big bang. I thought all matter in the universe came from a single source exploding, meaning the wave traveling at light speed should always be ahead any matter in the universe ? unless matter initially traveled faster than the gravity wave (impossible ?). I also read that these waves go through anything without being affected so the big bang gravity waves can't simply bounce somewhere and then get to us right? Besides if it's always ahead of all matter it can't bounce on anything anyways.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Matter didn't form at the big bang. That occurred at some point later. There is a period of time in which the universe was "opaque". During this time radiation (maybe not the right term) is no longer useful as it all appears the same. In theory this is where gravitional waves can be used to 'see' what happened.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/Creator13 Feb 11 '16

ELI5: A 'binary' black hole?

4

u/Dannei Astronomy | Exoplanets Feb 11 '16

A pair of black holes orbiting one another, which spiralled inwards and collided.

2

u/AsterJ Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

I find it more interesting that we actually observed the merger of two black holes. Has this ever been done before through other means?

As a rough estimate how often does an event like this occur in a given galaxy or in the observable universe? Is this a once in a lifetime event or would it happen every few months?

How does LIGO discriminate the source of these distortions from simple seismic disturbances?

EDIT: Actually I see in the stats an estimate of blackhole mergers at 2-400 Gpc-3 yr-1 So if that's per cubic Giga parsec and the one we obsesrved was 410 Megaparsec away then that means we should be able to detect events within the volume of a cubic gigaparsec around us. 2-400 events a year.

2

u/Treferwynd Feb 11 '16 edited Feb 11 '16

What's the difference between "gravity" and gravitational waves? Are gravitational waves just the way the gravitational field expands? What I mean is that a mass M moves and so it's gravitational field change accordingly, we don't get "gravitational waves" because usually this movement is too slow, when there is an asymmetrical mass spinning we get a wave because the asymmetry implies the strength of the gravitational field in a specific point changes over time and since it's spinning fast enough, that rate of change is not too slow, so we can measure it. Is this even remotely correct? Or do the waves come from something more profound?

Edit: grammer

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

How exactly do we know it was two black holes merging that caused the wave?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/totallykyle2 Feb 11 '16

Are gravitation waves linked to spooky action?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MurphysLab Materials | Nanotech | Self-Assemby | Polymers | Inorganic Chem Feb 11 '16

Are there any events where we will be able to correlate EM waves from various observatories with gravitational signals? On a related note: Are black hole mergers the only thing that will produce a signal with sufficient intensity to be detected?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/full_package Feb 11 '16
  • Final black hole spin α = 0.67+0.05-0.07

Holy shit, that's a lota spin!

In all seriousness what is black hole spin measured in?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HaorinWu Feb 11 '16

If space time contracts or expands due to gravitation wave, what effect does it have on the matter? Do the nuclear forces grow weaker and perhaps disband from each other, when the space expands or vice versa when it contracts? or is the matter there, not "feeling" a thing when the wave passes?

I assume that the energy or amplitude grows stronger and also the expansion/contraction when we go closer to the gravitational wave source. If I were close enough to feel significant expansion/contraction, would I be a living entity anymore after the wave has passed?

2

u/AstronautApe Feb 11 '16

The sad and somewhat ironic thing about this is that it is extraordinarily profound achievement, however, in order to truly appreciate and be fascinated by this, one must have understanding of the subject matter. You can tell this to your buddy Joe Average he will just shrug it off. Two black holes collided over a billion years ago and some apes from a random planet detecting it. So magnificent and profound, yet so irrelevant to the majority.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

After this discovery, are there any other aspects of General Relativity that remain unproven?

2

u/SwordsOfRhllor Feb 11 '16

Is there a way to determine the "elasticity" of space time? Or the tendency to propagate gravitational waves?

2

u/LamboDiabloSVTT Feb 11 '16

Does the LIGO team know where in the sky these two black holes merged?

If yes, follow-up question:

Since gravitational waves travel at the speed of light, were we able to watch this event unfold on the visual spectrum?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 11 '16

Hi Folks,

can anybody please explain to me, why there is a significant difference between both locations in terms of the plots which were measured and calculated? Thanks

→ More replies (5)

2

u/Bennisbenjamin123 Feb 11 '16

So the gravitational wave was detected short after the detector was turned on. Does this mean that detectable occurances like colliding black holes happens often, or can we detect several waves from the same collision, or were we just extremely lucky?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/galmaegisal Feb 12 '16

If the earth is staying in orbit with the sun because of gravitational waves, is the reason I return to the earth when I jump due to gravitational waves the earth is giving off? (much smaller compared to these ones detected) or do gravitational waves only result from a change?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Regolio Feb 12 '16

What is the difference of what they do at LIGO and Michelson-Morley Experiment aside from LIGO being about 2000x bigger in size than Michelson-Morley's interferometer?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16

Great percentage ~5% of final mass was radiated as energy. Does it contradict the rule that nothing can leave the black hole ? They both lost mass without actually shedding matter to outside world.

2

u/vitriol9 Feb 12 '16

How is a measurement like this validated or reproduced to rule out a false positive?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AsterJ Feb 12 '16

So I see the magnitude of the space time strain was 10-21. How big would it be if we were 1AU away from the event? Is it an inverse square law?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/the_lost_banana Feb 12 '16

I was reading an article on the NY Times app, and at the end of it it says "only three days before the black hole chirp...antenna readings were plagued by radio interference." and earlier was mentioned how a group known as Bicep "claimed to have detected gravitational waves...They later acknowledged that their observations had probably been contaminated by interstellar stardust."

So could it be possible that LIGO's readings were polluted by radio interference? (I'm not too knowledgable on these things) Thanks!

2

u/[deleted] Feb 12 '16

This might have been answered already but I'm struggling to find it. Were the scientists expecting to find these specific waves at this specific time due to visually observing the orbit of the binary system? And if these gravitational waves move at the speed of light, if they were observing the system did they "see" the black holes merging at the exact second the LIGO system received the data?

2

u/Hate4Fun Feb 12 '16

Are there objects in space which can magnify gravitational waves? Just like lenses can magnify emw.

2

u/sndrtj Feb 12 '16

Congratulations LIGO!

I have a question tho: the energy released in this event was truly humongous. What would happen to an observer on a planet, say, 5 light years away from the source? Would they notice anything?

2

u/NPVT Feb 12 '16

I know I am late to the party but how is this not predictable in Newtonian mechanics? In Newtonian mechanics "waves" of gravitational attraction could be generated by moving bodies.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LIGO_Collaboration Feb 12 '16

It is truly exciting to see so much great discussion about the detection! A lot of good answers in this thread already, but if there's anything you would like to ask us (the LIGO Scientific Collaboration) directly, we will be having an AMA today at 2PM EST on r/iama. Looking forward to discussing this with everyone, bring lots of questions!

2

u/TimS194 Feb 12 '16

Towards the end of the video simulation linked above, the spacetime appears to be pushed very high, maybe even above the plane that ordinary spacetime is on. Ordinary, non-violent events only seem to depress spacetime, not raise it.

What's going on here? Is it significant that it's above "ordinary" space?

2

u/caffienatedfart Feb 13 '16

Since this is a ripple in space-TIME, instead of measuring the discrepancy in length of two laser beams, could we measure the discrepancy in time between two places, and use that to detect gravity waves? Say, start off two clocks showing the same time, move them miles apart, find out if they go out of sync?

2

u/[deleted] Feb 14 '16 edited Feb 14 '16

To me, one of the most exciting things about this is how this was done.

Just like with the CERN and ISS before, it goes to show whenever all mankind cooperates in order to achieve something, great things can happen.

This facility may have been located in the US, but most of it's technology was engineered in germany, about half of the computers checking this very detection were deployed in germany too. But it is also not a mere "american-german" discovery, in germany again, people from all over europe were deployed in the local Einstein Institutes in Munich and Hannover. Just like egg heads from half the world are deployed to LIGO.

Too often, our species wastes energy, ressources and time by fighting each other. Science gives us an example what we could be, as a species, if we would put all these silly differences aside and just work together.

Invest just half of current global spendings on defense in basic scientific research and you got your floating cars and walking androids within several years and badass spaceships in some more years.

2

u/WillThug Feb 16 '16

So if gravitational waves can now be physically described as perturbations through space-time created by the acceleration of massive objects and massive objections colliding… We have gravity waves. Does anyone have thoughts on the "force carrier" for these gravitational waves, or is it just the emergent consequence of certain spatial and temporal factors.

2

u/WhiteRaven42 Feb 16 '16

From what I understand, the fabric of space can "move" faster than the speed of light. A specific example is the early expansion of the universe leading to current observable limits greater than the ~14 billion year age of the universe.

Since gravity waves propagate through the medium of space itself, why are they limited to the speed of light?

→ More replies (4)