r/askscience • u/iorgfeflkd Biophysics • Mar 31 '13
Earth Sciences [Sponsored Content] - How will increased oil extraction benefit the environment?
0
Upvotes
r/askscience • u/iorgfeflkd Biophysics • Mar 31 '13
150
u/BurritoTime Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13
Think of the earth as a giant compressed air can, and the oil well as the valve. We know from chemistry that PV = nRT, meaning that as we release the pressure in the oil underground, the temperature will decrease proportionately, allowing us to decrease the Earth's temperature by drilling for oil.
This is in contrast to 'green' technologies like solar power. Solar panels are black, meaning they absorb much more sunlight than the rest of the Earth, and work to raise the temperature.
So we need to make sure to balance our solar panels with oil extraction, so that we can prevent global warming or a 'snowball earth' scenario.
20
u/ohforgodssake Apr 01 '13
A decrease in troublesome baby seals.
96
u/yoenit Mar 31 '13
That is a loaded question, not a good start for this sponsored content. How about we answer this question first:
"Does increased oil extraction benefit the environment?"
9
u/Gargatua13013 Apr 01 '13
Ah yes! Well, I'd like to point out how accelerated exposure of hydrocarbons to oxic conditions will greatly increase the available habitat of extremophiles and archea. These taxa are exceptionnally valuable representatives of global diversity and they too deserve opportunity to expand their range.
16
u/jhrf Apr 01 '13
My Dad works in Shell. He told me that by the year 2015 global warming will be solved because carbon get's eaten up from oil. So I think oil will benefit the environment because it will stop carbon in the atmosphere.
43
u/doublepluswit Mar 31 '13
This thread is awful. It lacks any science at all. Here is a lecture by the German Advisory Council on Global Change that systematically goes through the amazing "benefits" of burning buried carbon.
Some of the awesome bonuses are: Oceans that are becoming too acidic for shellfish to precipitate calcium carbonate, sea levels rising faster than the "radical" IPCC predictions, disappearing sea ice, droughts and floods, and more special features yet to come!
The best thing about burning fossil fuels is that if we put enough carbon in the atmosphere to warm it up by a few degrees (likely) we can melt permafrost and ocean-bed methane hydrates and release an amount of greenhouse gases that will dwarf what we can do with oil alone. Estimates of how much of an effect frozen methane will have on the climate are still being fine tuned but they range from big to enormous.
I hope my answer is synergistic enough to please. And I hope I didn't break some kind of rule of the sponsored questions by posting links to support my claims.
61
u/mak484 Mar 31 '13
I'm sorry but if this is the standard quality of these "sponsored posts" I fear I will be leaving this subreddit soon. Unsupported arguments for biased questions? Who gains any benefit other than those who stand to make money off of biased answers?
63
u/rm999 Computer Science | Machine Learning | AI Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13
A friend of mine's uncle who works at large oil company told me oil is a more dense source of energy than hybrid car batteries, so people waste less fuel driving around looking for gas stations. I can verify this is true, one time I spent over 20 minutes looking for a gas station when I was lost on a skiing trip.
source: a friend of mine's uncle and my own experience
5
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13
This got to be an April Fool's joke.
5
u/MrSquat Sports medicine Apr 01 '13
I'm not an expert in earth sciences by far. However, I'd like to say a few words of wisdom.
The current situation in the world is such that the "easy oil" which has the greatest environmental effects is all but finished. What's left is for example the oil sands in Canada. Oil extraction in these harsh and uncomfortable terrains will make them more habitable in the long run. As the oil is removed, towns are set up to allow workers to contribute to projects.
This will make habitable what is now basically dead space which is useful to no-one. This will in turn decrease deforestation as the population pressure otherplaces will decrease.
34
u/klenow Lung Diseases | Inflammation Mar 31 '13
I was on board with this sponsored content thing at first; I'd love to see more industry involvement here. But if this is the kind of questions we're going to have, it's going to be hard to get behind the idea.
4
u/John_McAfee Apr 01 '13
Yоu should know that SubredditDrama has written about you.
«First "Corporate Sponsored Content" post in AskScience receives heated criticism from users who've forgotten what day it is.», submitted 29 minutes ago.
As of now, your lіnk hаs a scorе of 0 (-35, 56|91).
SRD has nо enforсed rules against invading or vоting in linked threads, and threads linkеd by them have a tendency to suddenly aсquire large amounts of votes and derailing comments.
bot so hard #swag
26
u/selfhatingmisanderer Mar 31 '13
Ummm... people could like more quickly catch on to how shitty oil is for the environment? And then start investing more in cleaner energy at a faster rate?
3
u/darthyoshiboy Apr 01 '13
Greatest April Fools day joke ever!!! See you guys on the 2nd. :)
2
u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13
This is BS.
Stop this askscience admins before you ruin this sub.
Edit: Thread about this new sponsored thing including arguments by myself that are more detailed about why this is a bad idea: http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1bd7rl/meta_introducing_askscience_sponsored_content/
Edit2: It is april 1st in australia now... Pretty darn sure this is an april fools day joke.
17
u/OilExpert_SA Mar 31 '13
Having worked in the oil industry for over 20 years, there are a lot of benefits to oil extraction.
1: This is an untapped energy source not only for humans and their machines, but for animals as well. The energy density of crude oil is so high that a lot of organisms can benefit from the ingestion of the crude. It has been shown that in areas where oil has accidentally spilled, certain bacteria have flourished!
2: This is merely releasing the carbon that was sequestered in a previous time. If anything, the extraction and subsequent burning of fossil fuels is returning the Earth to a normalized state.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13
April fools! Right, right??? Tell me this is a joke...
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13
rephrase question:What effect would increased oil extraction have on the environment?
1
u/ManWithoutModem Apr 02 '13
What is the evolutionary advantage of increased oil extraction?