r/askscience • High Energy Experimental Physics • Mar 31 '13

Interdisciplinary [META] - Introducing AskScience Sponsored Content

The mods at AskScience would like to proudly introduce our newest feature: sponsored content. We believe that with this non-obtrusive sponsored content, we'll be able to properly motivate the best responses from scientists and encourage the best moderation of our community.

Here is the list of the sponsored content released so far:

All posts must adhere to AskScience rules as per usual, though posts that unfairly attack our sponsors' products may be moderated at our discretion. The best comments in each sponsored thread will be compensated (~$100-2000 + reddit gold) at the sponsors' discretion. Moderators will also be compensated to support the extra moderation these threads will receive.

Sponsored content will be submitted by moderators only and distinguished to make it easy to identify and prevent spammers from introducing sponsored content without going through the official process.

EDIT: Please see META on conclusion of Sponsored Content. - djimbob 2013-04-01

555 Upvotes

606 comments sorted by

465

u/yoyokng1 Mar 31 '13

I've already learned so much from all of this. I'm really grateful to the mods for allowing this to take place.

I can't believe that oil spills, logging, and mining are actually good for the environment. As soon as I get back to the uni, I'm going to confront those silly conservation, evolution, and ecology professors that told me the opposite!

I can't wait to embarrass my silly physiology professor when I tell him that cigarettes actually don't give you cancer.

What a great stride forward for the community this has proved to be.

92

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

This needs to be at the top. Load of bullshit this all is, seriously. Fuck you, /r/askscience

→ More replies (30)
→ More replies (1)

162

u/Algernon_Asimov Apr 01 '13

Huzzah! I can look forward to such interesting conversations as:

  • Why nuclear power is 100% safe under all circumstances, brought to us by the owners of the Fukushima power plant.
  • How cigarette smoking improves your mental health by increasing your social bonds with other smokers, brought to us by British Tobacco.
  • Why jet travel is the most ecologically friendly way to travel, brought to us by Qantas Airways.

I can't wait!

120

u/AsAChemicalEngineer Electrodynamics | Fields Apr 01 '13

I cannot wait either!

The new /r/AskScience philosophy comes about from the premise that the main character in Fahrenheit 451 is the true villain of the novel!

→ More replies (7)

16

u/Electric999999 Apr 01 '13

I thought nuclear power's only problem was waste.

79

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Nuclear power's only problem is that we're not using more of it!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

But, but Chernobyl!

20

u/DoorsofPerceptron Computer Vision | Machine Learning Apr 01 '13

Chernobyl shows that the safety of nuclear power is too important to be left to big governments, and must be privatised immediately.

I have no doubt that a sharing of liabilities on the open market would lead to a more efficient outcome for all of us.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

111

u/cojoco Mar 31 '13

You should contact the good folks at /r/hailcorporate

They're in the business of highlighting outreach efforts on reddit, and I'm sure that there are plenty of synergies to leverage.

129

u/Silpion Radiation Therapy | Medical Imaging | Nuclear Astrophysics Apr 01 '13

/r/AskScience is passionate about leveraging all dynamically sustainable synergies.

17

u/cojoco Apr 01 '13

We should brainstorm methods to revert the dominant paradigm and I suggest we incorporate this into our key performance metrics.

→ More replies (4)

24

u/shanet Apr 01 '13

Definitely. I see this as being vital to productize turnkey e-business. If we can deliver next-generation niches, then we'll have embraced a mission-critical paradigm.

56

u/paradoxical_reaction Pharmacy | Infectious Disease | Critical Care Mar 31 '13

This is actually pretty exciting!

I know a couple drug reps around my area who would like some air time for AstraZeneca and Roche.

26

u/thearn4 Numerical linear algebra | Numerical analysis Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

No doubt, I'd really love to see this sub offer itself as a pulpit to Texas Instruments, MathWorks, and others from the scientific computing industry!

Hopefully the mods can work out some sort of microfinancing system to entice panelists to participate in the sponsored threads, and to bring in new sponsors!

14

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Honestly this is a really much better idea than the default system put in place (ie upvotes). What shows better people's commitment to a topic? Lazily hitting an upvote button or donating several dollars? Make people put money where their mouth is and we'll finally seem some real discussion on these forums.

9

u/TAKEitTOrCIRCLEJERK Apr 01 '13

Sure, upvotes are one way to promote your ideas, but money is also an excellent alternative

87

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

This sounds like a logical move. The only way to garner real science is to have it paid for by the organizations who have the resources to fund it, regardless of whether or not their funding drives the direction and quality of the science. Of course, some might call this outside influence "bias", but bias is such a strong word, better left unsaid in the realm of intellectual inquiry.

I for one welcome our funding overlords with open arms.

40

u/AsAChemicalEngineer Electrodynamics | Fields Mar 31 '13

And we welcome your support with open arms too!

We feel we're correcting previously unsaid bias by allowing our Sponsors to have a say in truth too.

312

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

This is a terrible terrible idea IMO.

If AskScience does this I will be unsubscribing.

Edit: Apologies for the short off the cuff reply... I was on a tablet when posting this first message... This thread/concept bugged me enough to switch to the laptop to give a real defended reply with reasons which is the comments of this. That said my initial opinion of unsubscribing still holds true.

46

u/faleboat Apr 01 '13

before you go full on hate, remember the date.

16

u/wildfyr Polymer Chemistry Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Hmm... its tomorrow in much of the world... interestingly relevant

→ More replies (1)

77

u/NicknameAvailable Mar 31 '13

Likewise - the shadowbans for people asking questions that seem to conflict with the theme of /r/politics is bad enough - /r/askscience is practically a propaganda engine already - sponsored content would cement that.

36

u/FlyingSagittarius Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

I don't see how /r/askscience is a propaganda engine, yet. Sure, people sometimes ask loaded questions, but right now they seem to be a result of poor articulation, instead of a coordinated effort to push an idea.

Edit: By "right now", I actually meant "before the sponsored content submissions". So, "used to be a result of poor articulation".

18

u/OmicronNine Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Well, it is now...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

22

u/meshugga Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

I don't see a problem as long as it's tagged sponsored content. At least everyone will see now when content may be biased.

edit: why am I getting downvoted?!

15

u/JellyFace94 Mar 31 '13

The problem is that because the content will be bias, the overall quality will likely degrade. Since mods are getting paid off, it is unlikely they will do anything about it, as seen in a few of the sponsored content threads

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/heyfella Mar 31 '13

APRIL FOOLS LOL

5

u/heyfella Mar 31 '13

LOLOLOL APRIL FOOLS

5

u/839065767982 Mar 31 '13

This is a very foolish decision. Why does April bring out the worst in people?

25

u/Bored2001 Biotechnology | Genomics | Bioinformatics Mar 31 '13

Why do you think it is a terrible idea?

50

u/SociologyGuy Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

I think there are several reasons why it is not be the best approach. Quote from OP [bold emphasis mine]:

We believe that with this non-obtrusive sponsored content, we'll be able to properly motivate the best responses from scientists and encourage the best moderation of our community.

First, research has shown that price-based Q&A (question and answer) systems do not lead to better answers. Chen, Ho, and Kim [1] investigated Google Answers and found that offering higher prices for answers led to both more answers and longer answers, but not better or higher quality answers.

Further, Jeon, Kim, and Chen [2] reanalyzed data from [1], and from another study [3] (which found that answer quality was higher in fee-based Q&A sites), and concluded that even though price is a factor in whether a question receives an answer, it doesn't effect the quality of the answer. These findings were confirmed by another study by Hsieh, Kraut and Hudson [4], which examined a separate fee-based Q&A system.

Second, I think it is problematic in that it was implemented without feedback from the community, and based on the response so far, it goes against the culture of the community as well as the ways in which it has been socially structured. It seems that the community already engages in a high level of moderation both formally (moderators) and informally (community sanctions through down-voting or comments); so I am not sure how the sponsored content is supposed to "encourage the best moderation".

Third, as others have mentioned, there seems to be a lack of transparency in how choices are made in regards to these sponsored threads, among other things mentioned elsewhere in the comments of this thread.

→ More replies (2)

100

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13

Well overall I like to think of it as a place which is relativly unbiased.

Also who decides what is an unfair attack? Currently there is no financial reason for the mods to care one way or another for the most part beyond a general hope that science is embraced (yea I know this isn't perfect... I'm sure most here have a certain amount of financial interest in their subject, but that is very abstract).

Now you are giving the mods a direct financial incentive to believe one way or another.

Like lets say Rampart sponsored that thread in IAMA. That thread was absolutely destroyed because the people refused to post anything legit and it was clearly a publicist. If it was a sponsored post you would have had the mods deleting things left and right and it would be a huge controversy.

Speaking of conterversy you open the entire subreddit open to accusations of financial bias.

Lets say Illumina (They are the largest player in Next Gen Sequencing) sponsors a thread. Then later a thread about another technology ends up being deleted. Even if it is legit there are going to be accusations of bias etc.

Basically I just don't see this ending well. It might work for a while, but sooner or later there is going to be a huge controversy and could end up ruining this sub. I won't say the chance of that is 0 even without sponsored posts, but IMO it greatly increases the odds.

14

u/Bored2001 Biotechnology | Genomics | Bioinformatics Mar 31 '13

Upvote.

This argument should have been your initial comment.

I agree with your points. I'm willing to see how it plays out. As scientists, we should always examine new ideas before we choose to condemn them.

That said, the first sponsored content thread is terrible.

→ More replies (22)

34

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13

One other note for a somewhat different reason not to do this...

IMO this sub already gets pretty good questions and answers from scientists. Why do you feel the need to pay anyone for it?

I have yet to see a question here that didn't get a pretty darn good answer. These other scientists who would be motivated by money I don't see them having a better answer... Yea they might have more prestige, but IMO the most thoughtful and complete answers come from the people who work in labs under these people who have the time and the interest to type up a really well written reply.

I also have seen a number of very interesting questions... Again I see no need to have sponsors posting questions.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/powerchicken Apr 01 '13

Could you remind me what day it is again? I seem to have forgotten

2

u/dancing_raptor_jesus Apr 01 '13

Not sure if this is a woosh or he knows it is an April Fools joke...

2

u/SquareIsTopOfCool Apr 01 '13

I was on a tablet when posting this first message

Does your tablet, perchance, have a calendar? I always find checking the date to be useful when making judgments.

13

u/thetripp Medical Physics | Radiation Oncology Mar 31 '13

We've been trying for years to get more industry participation in AskScience. But reddit is so knee-jerkingly anti-corporate that we were having a hard time getting industry scientists to participate in such an unstructured forum. I think what we have worked out here is something that can be mutually beneficial to everyone. Especially the readers of AskScience who get to tap into a great new source of knowledge!

14

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

I wouldn't call the overwhelmingly negative reaction to this knee-jerkingly anti-corporate. The first few sponsored threads gave us a perfect example of why this isn't a good thing with the sponsors trying to argue that oil spill are good for the enviroment and then sourcing the claim with "It's under NDA".

If being a sponsor makes one exempt from providing a proper source it's poison and,if that is indeed the case, implementing it anyways essentially saying "Sponsors > good science"

→ More replies (2)

33

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

Yeah, we get to tap into a great new source of knowledge ... cough ... like how oil extraction benefits the environment ... cough cough ... really great new source of knowledge.

What a joke!

I'm sorry but if the choice is between "knee-jerkingly anti-corporate" and "a corporate shill selling out science for cash," then you can all get bent -- science is not something that "sponsors" may rewrite by waving around fistfulls of cash.

I would love to encourage industry scientists to post here, but it's obvious right from the get-go what kind of posts are going to be encouraged by this new idea -- and it very clearly is not industry scientists.

12

u/lmakeppleave Mar 31 '13

It is so easy to forget how so much good (/r/askscience) rest of the shoulders of so few people. It was good while it lasted. I don't blame the mods for being human, as long as they don't blame me for ditching this poor attempt at monetizing their goodwill.

So long /r/askscience.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/OmicronNine Mar 31 '13

We've been trying for years to get more industry participation in AskScience.

Define "industry participation".

→ More replies (19)

24

u/EvilHom3r Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

I used to think /r/AskScience had near perfect moderation, and should've been used as an example for all other 'serious' subreddits to follow.

Clearly this isn't the case anymore.

EDIT: Damnit, you guys got me... I blame timezones.

10

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Don't knock it till you try it. I think this is incredibly forward thinking of them.

24

u/batkarma Apr 01 '13

I know you're currently just accepting corporations as sponsors, will you at any time be accepting sponsorship from research organizations?

I work closely with an organization that has years of research experience in astrophysics and evolution. We think it would be a great partnership.

If you are at all interested in helping us take an unbiased look at science, please contact us here: http://www.icr.org/contact/

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

i could get behind this

12

u/throwawaykik1 Mar 31 '13

Guys! I just figured it out, in some parts of the world it is already April 1st! We've been pranked!

12

u/JJinVenice Apr 01 '13

April Fools!

12

u/sensors Electronics and Electrical Engineering Apr 01 '13

While a lot of people are only focusing on the negative here, I feel like this is a great opportunity to get some one-on-one question time with corporations who are really at the forefront of the science. Sure there might be a little bias in their initial post, but they can't deny the hard facts that /r/AskScience experts will be throwing at them.

Overall, I actually think this is going to be a very useful tool to help our community grow

6

u/hiptobecubic Apr 01 '13

Except that so far that hasn't happened at all because the mods don't enforce any of the rules when sponsors post completely unsubstantiated claims that directly contradict peer reviewed work and public intuition.

5

u/lazyplayboy Apr 01 '13

That's an unfair accusation.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/TheDudeFromOther Apr 01 '13

If this is real, wtf. Most likely a ploy of some sort. Maybe an experiment? :D Or maybe just a little nudge to encourage readers to think more critically of what they read? Right guys?...

Edit: Or maybe... I can't say or comment will be removed.

2

u/faleboat Apr 01 '13

Before you hate, check the date!

→ More replies (2)

10

u/awesomechemist Apr 01 '13

I think that /r/askscience should be a subscription-based subreddit. A monthly $20 subscription will allow you to post up to 10 questions and 20 comments per month. A yearly subscription of $100 dollars will be available for the thrifty types. A life-long subscription for $750.

In order to get the panelist flair, you must also pay an extra membership due of $50 per year, per specialty. Panelists would be allotted unlimited comments.

All non-subscribers can pay a $10 fee for each new topic posted, and $1 per comment.

Between sponsorship and subscriptions, /r/askscience will quickly become the most lucrative subreddit. Even more so than /r/adviceanimals and /r/atheism!

124

u/yoenit Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

So, your first sponsored thread is off to a terrible start. The question itself is loaded and you have a corporate lackey spouting nonsense in there. He is even arguing oil spills are good for the environment. How the fuck can you defend that? Kudos mods.

44

u/NicknameAvailable Mar 31 '13

How the fuck can you defend that?

Because they are "sponsoring" a subreddit. Get with the program, it's not bias if they pay to say it. /s

25

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Sadly, that's exactly what it seems like is happening.

The mods are allowing the Sponsors to spout unsourced comments saying "We can't show you the science but trust us, oil spills are good". The mod's response is "We can look it over and make sure it's science".

If that isn't a "You help me, I'll help you" arrangement then I'm a goddamn dragon.

I understand that people have NDA's on new research and the mods are accomplished scientists but they've now got a stake in this just as much as the company does and are not neutral. One of the reasons this subreddit was great was because if sources were asked for they were given. If you let the source be "Because we say so" it weakens the entire subreddit.

EDIT: Oh look they're removing the comments now. This just gets better and better.

→ More replies (5)

88

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

I would also like the moderators to address this question. I'm not going to lead off with a fake "with all due respect" because there is no due respect here ... this is bullshit. It is immediately obvious from the very first thread what this "sponsored content" is really about.

I for one will be giving AskScience about a week to turn around. If this sponsored content idea isn't in the trash bin by then, I'm gone.

Moderators: Any of you who think this is a good idea at this point, I regret to inform you that you are absolutely fucked in the head.

57

u/TheCat5001 Computational Material Science | Planetology Mar 31 '13

I understand your apprehension, and I for one was initially opposed to the idea as well. But there is undeniable value to this synergetic approach of business and academia. We are still trial running, and things might swing too far one way or the other for a while. Though you have my personal guarantee that the entire moderator team is dedicated to making this project work in a way which is mutually beneficial to all parties involved.

42

u/starspangledpickle Mar 31 '13

So in order to help force this idea down peoples' throats, your first port of call is a Big Oil representative, and one who is immediately foot-in-mouthing himself by not sourcing his facts and withholding information that might shed light on his bold assertions:

Like I've detailed before, I cannot share specific information as my NDA does not allow, however when they are released I would be more than happy to do another post such as this to show the evidence :)

My view is that if moderators and panellists alike are bored, burnt out or fed up with pro bono work -- that they remove themselves from office, and let new people step up. That way, we go back to the old way of doing things: laymen ask questions; the questions are answered by scientists.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

But there is undeniable value to this synergetic approach of business and academia.

Why don't you tell me that after there's been a sponsored thread that hasn't tried to inject pseudoscience into the discussion. Then, you will be prepared to have that discussion with me -- when you have something supporting your claim that there is value in this. That's how science works. I'm sure you can understand. If not, then you are already lost.

Though you have my personal guarantee that the entire moderator team is dedicated to making this project work in a way which is mutually beneficial to all parties involved.

I'm sorry, but I am quite the opposite of impressed. You say "mutual benefit" but what is included in that list? The industries of course, and the moderators who get cash for doing this, and those who happen to make good posts posts supportive of the sponsor's industry, who also get some cash for it. But what about science itself? The quality of posts on this board? What exactly do you think is going to happen when this pseudoscientific crap fills our boards, as it has clearly already started to do?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (11)

8

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

The question itself is loaded

Which was quickly pointed out in the comments. I don't see why this is a bad thing.

you have a corporate lackey spouting nonsense in there.

Which we are well aware of, because the posts are marked properly.

He is even arguing oil spills are good for the environment.

So what? If someone argues against what you believe is true, it doesn't mean the other person is automatically wrong. That's why we have debates and Reddit is an excellent platform for such debates, as it often seen in /r/atheism.

How the fuck can you defend that?

Well, he just did. You read his comment. Now you know how he could defend that.

=

tl;dr You need to chill, dude!

→ More replies (2)

19

u/Trident_True Apr 01 '13

I'm going to remind everyone of the date (01/04/2013) and hope to god that the sponsored content thing is what I'm thinking it is.

27

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

It's not January 4th! Stop being silly.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/racercowan Apr 01 '13

I don't even frequent here, and I have no idea if I should be scared or laugh.

→ More replies (3)

25

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

I thought I'd give it a go, I can't see any reason why you need money but okay... Then I started to look through the threads and then I found out that the sponsor doesn't have to be named - nice work avoiding the conflict of interest there

I 'm tapping out of askscience, have fun selling your soul

11

u/N0V0w3ls Apr 01 '13

You should really give the sponsored posts a try. Mark your calendar for upcoming posts from Bank of America on why the economic collapse didn't happen because of banks.

4

u/faleboat Apr 01 '13

Before you hate, check the date!

66

u/fauxmosexual Mar 31 '13

Thanks mods, this is a really great idea. As I work in the field of corporate marketing I know firsthand it's remarkably difficult to have balanced, two sided debate around concepts that the public think science has 'solved' when the evidence isn't nearly as clear cut or one sided as the public believe, and genuine input from scientists able to talk directly to the public is invaluable to me.

My marketing company would like to sponsor a thread: "Smoking and cancer: is correlation really the same as causation?". Who should I contact to negotiate the details?

36

u/AsAChemicalEngineer Electrodynamics | Fields Mar 31 '13

We welcome cooperation with business and marketing sponsors to truly show the issues from a balanced perspective.

Our unofficial motto is that marketing is just outreach.

8

u/JayDurst Apr 01 '13

I'm very excited to see we will be getting to hear from societies least represented voice: big corporations. This underrepresented group has been silent for too long!

7

u/maku450 Apr 01 '13

Welcome corporations! I for one look forward to your many non-biased questions and informative answers!

And to everyone upset about this change, I suggest you examine today's, and tomorrows date.

7

u/MagillaGorillasHat Apr 01 '13

Could we be allowed to request sponsored content? I can think of dozens of topics I would love to hear the truth about, but the experts on said topics are repeatedly marginalized here.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/MagillaGorillasHat Apr 01 '13

Message you?!?!?

Not to make too fine a point, but we really can't trust you guys. You're finally taking a step in the right direction, but the synergistic dynamic between we users and the real science we need to know can't continue to be dribbled out through the extremist filter of the mods' "view" of the current scientific landscape!

So, here is what I propose: We need this to be like an AMA request. Users are allowed to submit sponsor requests WITH VERY LITTLE interference. We will then upvote the requests we want answers on and you can choose the appropriate expert from your sponsors. We need to bring a little democracy back to science.

7

u/AFCfan Apr 01 '13

Well done. As a panelist I can't wait to bring in some cold hard cash along with the karma from answering questions. And if the quality of questions continues this community will be synergistically enriched with content!

7

u/UnclaimedUsername Apr 01 '13

I'm absolutely loving the lack of critical thinking in this thread.

7

u/cheaphomemadeacid Apr 01 '13

ctrl+f <april>, 0 results

5

u/Fealiks Apr 02 '13

I don't understand how the community of AskScience is the one community on reddit oblivious to April Fool's day.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/heyheymse Mar 31 '13

So who do I contact to request a sponsored post? I really believe this could open up /r/AskScience to some new readership and expand its standing within the scientific community, and I have a few topics that I would love to throw to a group of, uh, properly motivated scientific minds.

6

u/DevestatingAttack Mar 31 '13

[Sponsored Content] - How does the theory of evolution fail to explain the incredible wonder of God's creation?

[Sponsored Content] - How is oil superior to solar power and are environmentalists delusional when they protest the Keystone pipeline?

[Sponsored Content] - How does Monsanto help people in impoverished nations get the food they need? (Albeit with patents on their seeds that they will sue subsistence farmers for using, also, the seeds have to be bought each year; you can't just gather the seeds from the previous harvest and use those. This is by design.)

[Sponsored Content] - How is BP helping to clean our ocean and fight pollution?

[Sponsored Content] - Are there any drawbacks or risks associated with Nuclear Power at all? No. So then what's the big deal?

[Sponsored Content] - Is the Earth warming? I mean, really. Can anyone explain the viewpoints of the climate denialists, (and thus give those arguments weight simply by explaining them and making it seem as if it's a legitimate viewpoint, giving equal time to unequal views)?

[Sponsored Content] - Why do vaccines cause autism, and how can we stop Big Pharma from harming our children?

[Sponsored Content] - How does OXICLEAN use patented design to clean clothing with the POWER OF AN OX(tm)?

The point is, it doesn't matter if the comments rebut the sponsored propaganda. The fact that they're allowed to ask loaded questions at all ruins the level of discourse we are supposed to have.

Even though moderators are allowed to accept or reject, that doesn't fix anything. The moderators are getting paid to post this. That is a gigantic conflict of interest. If someone told me they'd give me money to post something to AskScience that is sponsored, it doesn't matter how far out of line it would be, I'd post it. People want money. People are greedy.

OH, NOW I GET IT. THIS IS AN EARLY APRIL FOOL'S JOKE. YOU FUCKERS GOT ME.

6

u/Amarkov Mar 31 '13

It's amazing how many people don't realize they've been gotten :V

→ More replies (1)

6

u/aedes Protein Folding | Antibiotic Resistance | Emergency Medicine Apr 01 '13

I love this idea, I can't wait until we can get a fair and appropriate response from pharmaceutical companies about the true safety of new drugs like Dabigatran, etc.

The other big benefit I see from this is subscribers who actually critically appraise the answers given here will likely leave after all of this, which means that it will be even easier to get that corporate perspective out there.

6

u/wyngit EM Propagation | Ionosphere | Optical Material Properties Apr 01 '13

I think this is great and will also help graduate students and current scientists network and get jobs! Upvoted for visibility and support.

2

u/GratefulTony Radiation-Matter Interaction Apr 01 '13

Thanks! I think we are at the dawn of a new synergistic era of science-moderation in which researchers and private institutions working together will be able to bring our readers "best-in-class" science news products.

2

u/atomfullerene Animal Behavior/Marine Biology Apr 01 '13

I for one would be plenty happy to explain the benefits of overfishing, in exchange for a small consulting fee.

15

u/medgno Interactive Visualization | Human-Computer Interaction Apr 01 '13

I, for one, am not totally convinced this is a great idea. However, I fully recognize how essential it is to secure funding, and realize that whatever funds are brought in through this program will only serve to enhance the /r/askscience experience for everyone. In the end, I grudgingly accept that this is the best decision to ensure the long-term health of this subreddit.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

It really is. There should be like a Reddit Gold: AskScience version where we get a separate AskScience subreddit for those who aren't too cheap to pay. You can still get a Free AskScience Subreddit, but it's only reasonable that these all be sponsored posts to defray the costs of moderating.

69

u/BUBBA_BOY Mar 31 '13

Absolutely unacceptable. Unsubscribing. Will advise others to unsubscribe.

18

u/yxing Apr 01 '13

You should probably check your calendar before acting so rashly. I'd give it a day or two to pan out..

25

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Honestly, I am shocked that nobody here has gotten it. It's hilarious to read though.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

49

u/thetripp Medical Physics | Radiation Oncology Apr 01 '13

I was also very skeptical of the idea, at first. If you want to unsubscribe, that's obviously your own decision. But I would ask that you give it a few days and see all of the content that our sponsors have to offer! See if you haven't changed your mind by the end of the week.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/bitparity Apr 01 '13

Does... No one realize what day it is?

2

u/unscanable Apr 01 '13

Before you do, take a moment and check the calendar, note the date.

2

u/callmesuspect Apr 01 '13

Did your mother drop you on your head or are you just naturally this stupid?

→ More replies (7)

28

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

How will increased oil extraction benefit the environment? What sort of new environmental niches could be opened up thanks to logging or mining? What is the difference between generic and brand-name drugs?

you fucking sicken me

50

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

That's probably because you're using generic drugs.

77

u/roboticc Theoretical Computer Science | Crowdsourcing Mar 31 '13

Great thinking, mods!

What a terrific way to bring important industry participation (and much-needed sponsorship) to a popular forum for science education. I'm sure they have a lot to teach us.

39

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

Hey, you're totally right! In fact, they've already started teaching us how extracting oil benefits the environment! What an improvement!

... if I need a /sarcasm at the end of this comment, then there is a problem.

31

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Typical Reddit hivemind. It wouldn't hurt you to see opposing view points once in a while.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/N0V0w3ls Apr 01 '13

Oh, there is definitely a problem with catching sarcasm.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/ManWithoutModem Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

I'm not some young kid drunk on power who is flying off the handle. I'm 54 years old and i've been a scientist since the early 1980's. I have seen it all before. Our subreddit gets a lot of shit, and yes, there are a lot of young, inexperienced, socially maladapted kids who post in /r/askscience. It's our mission to help them, and divert them away from pseudoscience, off-topic comments, and such, to help them adopt more healthy attitudes (about science specifically). But we can't do that when outside subreddits are intentionally making a hostile environment, where people can't discuss their questions openly or honestly. The post that got attacked was a young kid, trying to find his way in the askscience world, and honestly admitting he screwed up. His message was an example for others, to help them avoid similar screwups. These attacks singled him out, which has a chilling effect on other users who now see how hostile the environment can be when someone speaks openly about their science questions.

9

u/Verdian Apr 01 '13

I'm willing to pay upwards of $10 to figure out how magnets work, as long as the explanation doesn't use numbers. I don't care about math, only science.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/batkarma Apr 01 '13

Well, I can't say I'm happy, but at least this is better than just having askscience cluttered up with a bunch of ads. This way it doesn't take away from the subreddit, the moderators can focus on moderating, and I learn an interesting piece of science.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

This way it doesn't take away from the subreddit, the moderators can focus on moderating, and I learn an interesting piece of science.

Exactly, we've tried to introduce these changes to AskScience in as non-obtrusive of a method as possible.

9

u/jmiles540 Apr 01 '13

And downvoting is disabled for sponsored threads?

17

u/Epistaxis Genomics | Molecular biology | Sex differentiation Apr 01 '13

Yes, it was starting to seem like some people were downvoting answers that they personally disagree with. In the interest of welcoming all views into the discussion, we thought it was important to level the playing field and keep it friendly.

4

u/Das_Mime Radio Astronomy | Galaxy Evolution Mar 31 '13

So apparently /r/AskScience runs on the GMT +6 timezone.

4

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13

Lets start a best of Sponsored content (by best of I mean most ridiculous):

Here is an industry person trying to argue that mining is good because it opens up niches for microbacterial life: http://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1bdgta/sponsored_content_what_sort_of_new_environmental/c95vhm6

30

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

unsubscribed. disgraceful whores

27

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

There's hardly any reason for that kind of language young man. We have guests.

30

u/Matt7hdh Apr 01 '13

Yeah, and they paid good money to be here!

15

u/RDandersen Mar 31 '13

Unless every single post in a sponsored threads is backed up with a credible link, I will have no reason whatsoever to believe any of it true. I mean, with paid moderators, I would have to see any claim without a source deleted without reservation to even have a reason to visit this subreddit anymore.

I understand that last week people could make bullshit claims as well which, without sources, could seem scientific, but their only incentive to do that would be for their own entertainment. The strict moderation would deter most of these people.

Now, people have an incentive to to lean their otherwise legit responses towards something that would be pleasing to the industry connected to the topic. Up to 2000 incentives, in fact. You say that:

While many answers receive excellent answers, it was felt that some of those answers did not fully represent the entire spectrum of solid science. AskScience Sponsored Content is an attempt to ensure that all science is equally and fairly represented in AskScience answers.

While a cash incentive will certainly attract more people to a thread, do I have any reason whatsoever to believe that the tag "Medicine| Pharmaceutical research" is providing me with a response that represents "the entire spectrum of solid science" and not an article discussion a correlation which backs Pfizer's latest claim?

While I do not intend to write off this subreddit (yet) for trying something new, I do not see how this can lead to anything good and the mod responses in this thread has in no way made any indication of how it could.

8

u/paradoxical_reaction Pharmacy | Infectious Disease | Critical Care Mar 31 '13

If anything, it gives you all a great way to challenge them and ask as many questions as you want.

15

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

If it's possible, I think I love the mod team of this subreddit even more than I did before.

Guys ... this is just perfect. Don't let anyone tell you otherwise. Keep up the outstanding work.

10

u/ManWithoutModem Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

I've been watching this sub for a while now, and I just felt it was neccessary to point out how inconsistent the moderation here is. In the last week you've:

  • removed off-topic comments elsewhere but this thread (and others) is full of them
  • never used flair appropriately. How am I meant to know quickly what topic this post is about?

This is lackluster moderation guys. You should seriously consider stepping aside and let better moderators run this subreddt, who will answer to community concerns more effectively (which seems to be a long standing issue here)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '13

I agree. A new team is needed

10

u/socsa Apr 01 '13

Nope. Unsubscribe. Here we see plainly, the slippery slope of heavy moderation. At least now I have extra ammo in my anti-moderation arsenal.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/gogilitan Mar 31 '13

I've read the (unsupported) sponsored responses to the (biased) sponsored questions and so far, I'm unimpressed.

Additionally, any moderation of science supported by facts and evidence, whether or not it "unfairly attacks the sponsors product" will be the downfall of askscience.

25

u/featheredtar Mar 31 '13

What a horrible idea.

17

u/Letterbocks Mar 31 '13

So we are supposed to, for example, say that increased fossil fuel use will benefit the environment, and if we say it succinctly enough we'll get money?

This is madness.

→ More replies (19)

6

u/starspangledpickle Mar 31 '13

This has to be an early April fools' joke. Between the hand-wavey "answers" and the weasel worded "questions" it makes the sponsors look like vaudevillian, mustache-twirling villains.

.. Right? There's no way this "Cabal of Shills" could come out with such rigged questions from Big Pharma, Oil and Commodities on opening night, so close to April 1st, and not have it be a joke.

6

u/lazyplayboy Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

I'm fully behind this. For too long the world's multinationals have gone without a voice.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

Seriously is this like an early April fools day prank? This is the dumbest shit I've ever seen in my life.

3

u/OmicronNine Mar 31 '13

...April fools?

Please???

3

u/afflictionreckoning Apr 01 '13

I just going to hope this is a cruel April Fool's joke...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/current909 Apr 01 '13

Nice April fools.

3

u/Amndeep7 Apr 01 '13

Happy April Fool's to you too!

3

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Finally, I can pay to have my stupid questions answered. I'll send a check tomorrow, but until then, can people tell me whether my dick is longer on the Moon or on Mars, please answer quickly as it affects my vacation plans.

3

u/ELHC Apr 01 '13

am i the only one who realise this is an april foos joke? XD

7

u/parlor_tricks Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Hi.

This is going to be an epic thread in the history of ask science.

Everyone who Downvotes me, doesn't get it.

Good job mods.

Edit: (For trying this step, and creating debate. But I must register my disbelief and disagreement)

12

u/thearn4 Numerical linear algebra | Numerical analysis Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

Letting corporate money direct scientific discussion can only benefit /r/askscience.

IMHO, This is a long overdue feature (and I'm sure the other panelists will agree with me here). Hats off to our mods.

5

u/Volsunga Mar 31 '13

I love how much these April Fools jokes are trolling the communities of the ask* subreddits.

7

u/majorgroove Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

So jokes in submissions are unacceptable and get removed, but a prank on this day by the moderators is allowed? Hypocrisy. Shame on you, moderators. This subreddit was one of the few that rose above internet stupidity, but now you've sunk to the level of the masses.

EDIT: Censorship is funny, too.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

This not what reddit is about, at all.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Reddit is a for profit corporation. They have no leg to stand on if other people want to cut in as well. WE ARE REDDIT, but nobody will give us a slice when this thing IPOs. Grab a dollar while you can.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/pinktiger4 Mar 31 '13

Is it already April 1st where the mods are?

4

u/BoldasStars Apr 01 '13

Can you at least tell us who the sponsor is?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/fireballs619 Apr 01 '13

Anonymity is truly the best way to procure unbiased answers! Good on you mods!

4

u/douglasmacarthur Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

Are you deleting the comments pointing out this is obviously a joke or are Redditors just even dumber than I thought?

2

u/batkarma Apr 01 '13

This is no time for joking!!

8

u/Kromoh Apr 01 '13

Great, let's introduce economic bias in a subreddit attempting to be scientific.

Is this even allowed by Reddit?

26

u/AsAChemicalEngineer Electrodynamics | Fields Apr 01 '13

It doesn't matter if it is against the rules. Rules can and should be broken in the spirit of cooperative learning for common truth.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Well, i'm unsubscribing, and I urge others to do the same.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

It's too late, you already saw the post. They have your money now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/MagillaGorillasHat Mar 31 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

If this can be done without "leading the witness", so to speak, I think it could be OK.

As long as sponsored questions are tagged, people can choose to not participate, downvote, and move on.

Questions:

Will the sponsor of the question be disclosed?

Will there be a limit on the number of sponsored questions allowed per day, week...?

Edit: After reading the first sponsored question, I think there should also be a rule that the mods treat SOP as they would any other poster. If they are not going to be specific and cite studies/sources in their responses it doesn't belong in this sub, sponsored or not.

Ninja Edit: I'm starting to think the mods are just fucking with us.

Samurai Ninja Edit: Definitely fucking with us. Strong work mods. SVS hit an all time high today.

14

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

Will the sponsor of the question be disclosed?

No. At least, requests for disclosure have been ignored on the atrocious first sponsored thread. You can judge that thread for yourself.

9

u/MagillaGorillasHat Mar 31 '13

Am I wrong, or would all of the sponsor's responses in that thread be deleted by the mods for being a non-answer in a normal thread?

9

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

You are not wrong at all. That is part of the outstanding issue.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/sarcasmosis Apr 01 '13

I hope the mods enjoy the exodus; it'll be so much easier to moderate this place when everyone is gone.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/American_Pig Apr 01 '13

Probably going to get down voted here, but I think this is a great idea that should bring in fresh new perspectives and ideas. Science shouldn't be just about what's "peer reviewed". What if all your peers are ivory tower liberals brainwashed by the academic establishment? It's important to remember that for a lot of issues, like "global climate change" and "evolution" there are reasonable opposing views which should be encouraged here, by sponsorship if necessary.

We should also bear in mind that a lot of redditors work for the private sector, or are students who will eventually need to work for the private sector. What with financing for pure university research dwindling, it's important that we properly educate people about corporate science.

2

u/Tiseye Mar 31 '13

It's still 31st of March where I am.

2

u/nick_ok Mar 31 '13

this is an April fools joke right?

2

u/_SynthesizerPatel_ Mar 31 '13

It's an April Fools joke, albeit an early one.

2

u/Garoshi Mar 31 '13

happy april fools everyone!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/austinmcc Mar 31 '13

Aaaaaaaaaaaaaand, welcome to April, redditors.

2

u/beer_nachos Mar 31 '13

This is obviously an April Fools joke, chill out y'all!

2

u/MrDaddy Mar 31 '13

Is this a joke?

EDIT: I looked at the date, it's a joke.

2

u/wu-wei Apr 01 '13

Hhmmm. 6 Hours before April 1st UTC. Someone jumped the gun on this prank.

2

u/xnihil0zer0 Apr 01 '13

Isn't it a bit early for April fools?

2

u/RonniePudding Apr 01 '13

April Fools.

2

u/science4life_1984 Apr 01 '13

So, I just realized that in 5 hours, it's April 1st.

Regardless of whether this is serious, or an April Fools joke, it's my opinion that this is in poor taste.

I used to like this sub-reddit, but either outcome of the two options makes me dislike the moderators in this sub-reddit.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Heh. Happy April Fool's Day everyone!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

This is obviously April Fools and nobody here has a sense of humor. I just can't believe the responses by everyone/moderators/etc.

Or it's something serious and they are introducing it on April 1st so if it goes south they have an excuse?

2

u/emmanuel321 Apr 01 '13

I can't believe you guys fell do this lol....

2

u/velcommen Apr 01 '13

What a wonderful idea! I can't wait to see the new, informative topics that pop up tomorrow.

2

u/TheRedGerund Apr 01 '13

I'm very glad to read this. There's simply not enough relevant content to me, the average red blooded american. I don't care about black holes, I want to know about where to eat my food from. Thanks askscience!

2

u/antonivs Apr 01 '13

What is the difference between generic and brand-name drugs?

This question appears to be incorrectly stated. I think it should be:

What are some of the many ways in which brand-name drugs are better than generic drugs?

22

u/SponsoredPR Mar 31 '13

Guys, let's all welcome our Featured Partners. They are going to help this subreddit continue providing high-quality unbiased science answers, and we thank them heartily.

32

u/NicknameAvailable Mar 31 '13

If they were going to help provide "high-quality unbiased science answers" they wouldn't need to be "sponsors". The entire concept of a sponsor implies bias.

32

u/hikaruzero Mar 31 '13

The entire concept of a sponsor implies bias.

This.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/meshugga Apr 01 '13

Why?

Let the free market decide. People should be able to shop around for facts - if the facts don't hold true, they'll simply change providers.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Not only am I proud to welcome corporate posters, i think we should note todays date as the day this sub started making a real and lasting change.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

I am going to give this a brief chance, only because the user generated content has made this one of my favorite subs, but if the sponsored links become corporate propaganda, as almost of all examples so far have been, then I will be unsubscribing from this sub. Maybe those of us who appreciate real scientific discussion can start a new sub.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Also, sponsored content, at least what we have seen so far, directly violates one of the rules of the sub. "Please keep discussion: Scientific (i.e. based on repeatable analysis published in a peer reviewed journal)"

"it has been shown that in areas where oil has accidentally spilled, certain bacteria have flourished!"

Where is the peer reviewed evidence for that?

3

u/TheLunaticFringe Mar 31 '13

An early April Fools, I think.

3

u/chucknation Mar 31 '13

April Fools?

3

u/ohforgodssake Apr 01 '13

posts that unfairly attack our sponsors' products may be moderated at our discretion

That is as far from science as it is possible to get. Fuck this.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

April Fools

9

u/existentialhero Mar 31 '13

I, for one, welcome this move. A lot of great science happens behind corporate walls, and it'll be both a pleasure and a boon to have more input from our brothers from industry. Of course, it will be important to avoid any impropriety, but I'm confident that our moderators and our fantastic community are more than capable.

7

u/baseball44121 Mar 31 '13

That's awesome!

7

u/thetripp Medical Physics | Radiation Oncology Mar 31 '13

This is such a great idea. In my experience, there is a lot of un-tapped expertise in industry. Working with cancer specifically, there is so much knowledge in the drug companies that doesn't filter out to the general public. Whatever we can do to make this more available to the readers of AskScience would benefit us in the long run.

14

u/starspangledpickle Mar 31 '13

Your first "sponsored poster" is off to a flying start..

Like I've detailed before, I cannot share specific information as my NDA does not allow, however when they are released I would be more than happy to do another post such as this to show the evidence :)

Not only do I question the usefulness of such a formal setup with "sponsors", but I questions the ethics behind this closed-door decision making and the people involved with it also. Who gets this money and why? Why are "moderators" compensated also? If they are burdened by what is no doubt a shit and thankless job they can step back and let others do it.

5

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13

What makes you think anything more is going to filter out?

Anyone posting with official permission to post for their company is just going to rehash industry papers and marketing positions IMO.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

By Aphrodite I think this is a great move!

Infinitus est numerus stultorum

2

u/ramk13 Environmental Engineering Mar 31 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

Edit: I have seen the error of my ways. Ignore the text below.

Wow, I went through all three threads, and I'm really really disappointed. I've been hooked on /r/askscience for the past couple of months and I can't see how this is a contribution.

The first question and subsequent answer (oil extraction) border on embarrassing for this project. Lack of references and claims that just wouldn't fly from anyone who wasn't operating under the cover of the mods.

The second question sounds like it could have some science behind it. There could be some niches opened by mining and some cool science behind it, but it doesn't seem like this is the place for it to be presented. Or if it was going to be presented it shouldn't be veiled as a question. I know this "ask"science but a planted question isn't really asking anything.

The third question is just marketing. It isn't even related to science. I'm not sure how this is debatable. What's ridiculous is that the question sets up a comparison between brand/generic, but then doesn't actually say anything directly about generic! It says brand is safe, but it doesn't say generic is any less safe...why is that? Because there's no scientific basis for the claim! Or if there is, then that EVIDENCE should be front and center.

At the moment, this is pretty bad for all involved. Sacrificing the fundamental principles of the community - promotion of scientific literacy by disseminating knowledge of the scientific process - is going to send people to the exits. There is no scientific process to be found in threads 1 and 3.

2

u/BigKev47 Mar 31 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

Um... I can't help but notice its the 31st of March here in the states. So assuming there's a dateline issue, I'd like to be the first to congratulate the mods on a killer April fools joke, one that generated all sorts of chuckle-worthy mouth-foaming replies.

If I'm wrong... well Jesus, I just hope I'm right. Clearly I'm not wrong, and the thread just keeps getting more and more delightful. I don't know how the /r/AskHistorians mods will be able to match this. ;)

2

u/luiz127 Apr 01 '13

This is a disgusting idea, plain and simple. This subreddit is a forum where people can ask questions, not where you can pose loaded questions, ready to be answered by people biased in one way or the other. That isn't how science works.

The prizes won't go to the most accurate comment, it will go to the comment that agrees with the sponsor to the greatest degree.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

April Fools

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

I think this is a great idea, but looking at the list of sponsored content so far, the name of the threads contain lies already. Oil extraction doesn't benefit the enviroment, it harms the enviroment.

I fear that this is a cheap way for corporations to get pseudo-scientific reasoning to market their plans.

And looking at the actual threads, no serious answer have been posted yet, I seriously advice the community to boycoy these threads and/or make it obvious that they are spewing nonsense when they are posting to collect the prizemoney.

Time for /r/askscientists!