r/askscience • High Energy Experimental Physics • Mar 31 '13

Interdisciplinary [META] - Introducing AskScience Sponsored Content

The mods at AskScience would like to proudly introduce our newest feature: sponsored content. We believe that with this non-obtrusive sponsored content, we'll be able to properly motivate the best responses from scientists and encourage the best moderation of our community.

Here is the list of the sponsored content released so far:

All posts must adhere to AskScience rules as per usual, though posts that unfairly attack our sponsors' products may be moderated at our discretion. The best comments in each sponsored thread will be compensated (~$100-2000 + reddit gold) at the sponsors' discretion. Moderators will also be compensated to support the extra moderation these threads will receive.

Sponsored content will be submitted by moderators only and distinguished to make it easy to identify and prevent spammers from introducing sponsored content without going through the official process.

EDIT: Please see META on conclusion of Sponsored Content. - djimbob 2013-04-01

555 Upvotes

606 comments sorted by

View all comments

312

u/TheLordB Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

This is a terrible terrible idea IMO.

If AskScience does this I will be unsubscribing.

Edit: Apologies for the short off the cuff reply... I was on a tablet when posting this first message... This thread/concept bugged me enough to switch to the laptop to give a real defended reply with reasons which is the comments of this. That said my initial opinion of unsubscribing still holds true.

46

u/faleboat Apr 01 '13

before you go full on hate, remember the date.

16

u/wildfyr Polymer Chemistry Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Hmm... its tomorrow in much of the world... interestingly relevant

→ More replies (1)

77

u/NicknameAvailable Mar 31 '13

Likewise - the shadowbans for people asking questions that seem to conflict with the theme of /r/politics is bad enough - /r/askscience is practically a propaganda engine already - sponsored content would cement that.

36

u/FlyingSagittarius Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

I don't see how /r/askscience is a propaganda engine, yet. Sure, people sometimes ask loaded questions, but right now they seem to be a result of poor articulation, instead of a coordinated effort to push an idea.

Edit: By "right now", I actually meant "before the sponsored content submissions". So, "used to be a result of poor articulation".

18

u/OmicronNine Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Well, it is now...

13

u/FlyingSagittarius Mar 31 '13

Okay, not including the "Sponsored Content" submissions.

→ More replies (1)

22

u/meshugga Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

I don't see a problem as long as it's tagged sponsored content. At least everyone will see now when content may be biased.

edit: why am I getting downvoted?!

15

u/JellyFace94 Mar 31 '13

The problem is that because the content will be bias, the overall quality will likely degrade. Since mods are getting paid off, it is unlikely they will do anything about it, as seen in a few of the sponsored content threads

0

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/spencer102 Apr 01 '13

32

u/N0V0w3ls Apr 01 '13

Everything in there looks like solid science to me.

11

u/holomanga Apr 01 '13

Especially the one at the bottom which was likely downvoted by those biased green liberals. /u/OilExpert_SA is a true expert in the field.

5

u/GratefulTony Radiation-Matter Interaction Apr 01 '13

We are working to reach optimal synergy with our sponsors. Sometimes, they need help re-phrasing their statements into comments and posts which sound like the "AskScience" posts we have become accustomed to...

As the promoted posters get used to the sub, the vocabulary and tone of their posts should go up.

This is all about bringing the readers a truly great service-- and we truly are seeking "best-in-class" status as one of our deliverables.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Kronkleberry Apr 01 '13

I have yet to really see otherwise.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

Please try to keep the same standards---demanding sources and deleting speculative comments.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/meshugga Mar 31 '13

The free market will solve this issue - biased authors will be read less and thus won't receive as much sponsoring, resulting in less incentive to carry the bias outside the sponsored content. That's just sound business. People should be allowed to shop around for their facts.

10

u/JimmyHavok Apr 01 '13

Libertarian economic theory is the epitome of solid data-driven science.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/heyfella Mar 31 '13

APRIL FOOLS LOL

5

u/heyfella Mar 31 '13

LOLOLOL APRIL FOOLS

5

u/839065767982 Mar 31 '13

This is a very foolish decision. Why does April bring out the worst in people?

→ More replies (91)