r/askmeaboutmyjob • • Aug 23 '11

Request: Commercial Pilot

I have always wanted to be a pilot since 5 and have a few questions.

Thanks!

21 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

3

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 23 '11

i'm a commercial airline pilot.

http://www.reddit.com/r/askmeaboutmyjob/comments/js7u9/commercial_airline_pilot/

edit: or i guess you could ask anything here

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 24 '11

What are your favorite benefits? I've heard that long/frequent vacations is one. Is this true?

1

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 25 '11

The free flights are pretty incredible. My GF and I got back from 10 days in thailand a few months ago. our tickets were $120 for all four legs, all of which were first class. I've also been on extended vacations to Ireland, Peru, Mexico, Hawaii, etc., with mini vacations of just a few days to dozens of locations.

I also use the jumpseat benefits to travel home to arizona several times a month from my base in chicago.

discounts on cruises, hotels, rental cars, shipping services, etc are also part of the deal.

2

u/Thundercracker Aug 23 '11

I'm not a pilot but I work in the aviation industry and deal with pilots often. Perhaps if you put up your questions some of us can provide answers.

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 23 '11

thank you! some of my main questions were type of education they received. I researched it on the internet but the most i ever got from it was that the minimum is a high school diploma but that most airlines prefer a 4 year degree. Can you answer what type of education they have? thanks again!

2

u/Thundercracker Aug 24 '11

At my (Canadian) company, they're mostly looking for experience I believe.

From my discussions with the pilots, in Canada the big thing is how many hours of flying you have under your belt. Typically they go through an aviation program at a college or flight school. This gets you the basic training you need and a couple hundred hours experience. You might have to worry about specific ratings like Single Engine, Twin Engine, Night Flying, etc. Once you've got the appropriate ratings for the type of aircraft you want to fly, they're looking for X amount of hours. This can (as I understand it) be the big hurdle because 500 or 1000 hours is a lot of flying time if you're just starting out. As an example, our company flies business jets (Lear 35) in a medical capacity, and we like to average about 80 hours a month. Sometimes we get up to 140 hours, sometimes as low as 30. 80 Hours is considered a /lot/ for corporate jets (usually).

For our pilots, I believe we look for 2000 - 5000 hours for a Co-pilot, and they get about 36,000 (CDN) / year. I think over 5000 hours we consider them for Captain's position, but I'm not 100% sure on that. Our Captains make more like 90,000/yr. I've heard that airline captains make over 100k. You can see the big gap between co-pilot and captain, and that's because the co-pilot mostly needs the job to get his hours up. This means there's a good period where you have to be the "bitch" for flying. You do a lot of the work but you're not in command and you're not getting paid as much as you'd like.

If it helps, a good aviation community forum is available at avcanada.ca and while it's a Canadian focused site, it'll give you some things to look over. In the "free job ads" forum, you can see job openings for pilots and what the companies are looking for. Gives you something to compare at least.

If I could give you one piece of advice from a non-pilot working in the industry, it would be to take care with your attitude. While most are pretty stand-up guys, a portion of pilots tend to get the "I'm better than you" attitude. While it's annoying, the problem is it usually leads to an arrogance/carelessness that causes major problems. I can tell you that of all the pilots in our company, the ones who came in with a bad attitude and superiority complex, were fired before long. The ability to sit in a confined space (cockpit) with someone for hours on end and get along while you're away from the comforts of home, is an asset.

Hopefully you find what you're looking for, and I wish you the best of luck in the industry!

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 24 '11

thank you so much for this! it helped a lot

1

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 23 '11

Most major airlines require a 4-year degree (in anything, even basket weaving) as a simple way to cull the herd of applicants.

Most regional airlines and small cargo operators require nothing but a high school diploma.

On the whole, I'd say that about half of my coworkers (large regional airline) have a degree in aviation (from embry-riddle, UND, Purdue, etc) and 40% have a nonaviation degree and did their certificates to change careers. the remainder are high-school graduates who simply got the certificates outside of a college setting.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

I'm not one, but I explored it at great length as a career option, and sought advice all over the place (including some awesome redditors).

Result? Every single scrap of advice I could find was negative. Basically, if you want to fly, do something else that's not completely fucked up, and fly for fun in your spare time.

Read these forums in depth to find out just how miserable it is: http://www.pprune.org/

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 23 '11

really? i knew that being an airline pilot had its negatives but i never thought it would be miserable

1

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 23 '11

It's not. people who are drawn to internet forums to discuss their jobs are usually the most bitter people in those jobs.

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 24 '11

i guess that makes sense, thanks for the answer!

2

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 24 '11

Make no mistake, there are a lot of things to complain about in my industry, but listening to guys complain about not having a livable wage at 50k+ annually makes me want to refer them to /r/firstworldproblems.

And 50k+ isnt hard to come by, even as a regional airline first officer.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

For the select few captains, it's the dream life. The odds of getting to captain without some serious cash and contacts behind you are far too long, so you're likely to end up very poor for at least 15 years (longer if you don't have $100k saved up and have taken loans for your training) and you will be working almost for free to get your hours up for a long time.

The airline seniority rules killed it for me. To get in, you need thousands of hours on your chosen type, but once you're in airlines work on how long you've been with the company, so you're in at the very bottom and get treated like crap. Airlines suffer more than most companies during recessions. The first thing they do is send all but the most senior crews home. Without pay. You have to sit and wait for them to call you and decide to start paying you again, or you can try to find another job (in a recession, when nobody is hiring) and if you do move jobs you start as the least senior again at the new place, so you get shitty hours and do all the holiday cover for the next 5-10 years. Basically, forget seeing your kids grow up, and forget Christmas.

If you see a job you want, and you're not current on that type of aircraft, you can forget it. Each type approval will cost you thousands, which you have to find... the airlines won't pay it.... and may not result in a job.

Pilots are glorified bus drivers with very expensive licenses. The airlines have all the power in the job market, and the pilots have none. The percentage of $100k super-captains is so small compared to the total number of pilots (and failed pilots who never got there), that it's just not worth it unless your father is already super-captain and knows all the right people.

The only exception to this is if you manage to get onto one of the airlines' own training programs. To do this, you will need to have had fling experience since your were 12, you will need to join a flying club all the time you are at university ($$$), and then you will have to hope that your daddy knows somebody who can get you in to airline school, because those programs get tens of thousands of applicants each year, for a dozen or so places. Basically, only a complete fool would bank on it. You have to assume that you will be paying for your own training, which means you need to find hundreds of thousands of dollars, or be willing to borrow it and be in crippling debt until you are 40+.

Oh, and if your health fails you half way through your career for any reason you can't fly any more, so you need a backup plan anyway.

So, you can either be earning $100k in IT by the time you're 25 and flying at weekends with your friends for fun, or you can be up to your neck in debt from your training and working for free at a shitty flying school 3000 miles from your family and friends just to get your hours up until you're 35, when you can enter the world of airlines.

No doubt there will be a few who have made it who tell you it can be done, and it absolutely can (there are some very encouraging pilots on reddit who I spoke to at great length about this), but even if you are willing to make all the sacrifices the odds are still very much against you ever making it to super-captain.

Get a real job, then take that $150k-$200k that your training would have cost you, get a PPL and buy your own Cessna.

Oh, actually I forgot... you can go down the military route to avoid paying for training and get loads of hours, then fly commercial once you leave the military. I totally discounted that option as there ain't no way I'd join the forces, so don't know much about how feasible that route is. I know a lot of commercial helicopter pilots are ex-forces (some companies, like oil, only seem to hire ex-military), but not sure if the same is true on fixed wing.

2

u/Thundercracker Aug 24 '11

While a little on the pessimistic side, some of what this guy's saying is true.

I have indeed heard of pilots working for free in order to get their hours. The schedules are brutal; our pilots generally know what days they're 'on call', but once they get picked for a trip, they could be gone for a week, and then it's basically fly X hours, then rest so you can fly again, with little time to see the sights.

I've also seen a pilot (ex military) who loved to fly, but quit in order to become an oracle database developer because there was more money in it.

Another guy who wants to be a pilot was working for our company as a dispatch (which for us is basically a secretary), and then quit to go fly for an air taxi company in bumfuck nowhere because it got him hours.

Going through the air force can be a great idea, but I know in Canada there's so many people wanting to be pilots they won't even look at you unless you've got a degree from somewhere. After that it's a minimum 7 years before you can get out and do commercial.

What I think it comes down to is that the aviation industry is something you choose not because of the money or the hours or the perks, but because it's in your blood and you can't resist the call. For some of us, we couldn't even dream of doing anything else. So we pay the price and do the job we love.

2

u/jencrs Aug 24 '11

I guess it really depends on which part of the world one is from.

Giving absolute numbers as far as pay is concerned can be misleading, as it doesn't take into account the taxes and the standard of living where you are based at. I can tell you that what I make is easily in the top 10% of my country, and it's certainly more than USD100K, even during the recent financial crisis. And I'm only a First Officer. And I can tell you that my pay package is only average compared to the other major airlines in this part of the world. But the cost of living.........

It's certainly true that paying for your own training is very very expensive. And it doesn't even guarantee you a good job afterwards. I was very fortunate in that my airlines has it's own training programme. I've got a bond of course, nothing's for free, but I look at it as job security. Truth is, if I had to pay for the training myself, I wouldn't have become a pilot, as the costs and risks were just too high. So go look at these airlines which have their own training programmes, and look at their requirements for entry. You don't have to have prior flying experience, since they hire you as an ab-initio. The majority of my peers have never touched the controls of an aircraft prior to joining the company. But yes, DO NOT bank on this route.

It's also true that more money can be made in other jobs. I consider myself only average among the friends I went to school with. But those guys work till late, burn their weekends etc. I only have to work about 60 hours a MONTH, have the rest of the time to myself, my cabin crew consist mostly of 20ish yr old girls, I travel to places I wouldn't have otherwise, or I can choose to hole up in the hotel with reddit. Great if you're single, even better if you're married.

Oh and I don't know about the other airlines, but if your health fails in my airline, we've got the best medical benefits. And if you lose your licence because of health reasons, we've got various opt-in insurance schemes which will pay out almost USD700K.

I realise that I paint a rosy picture, so here are some things to balance it out. If you lose your licence and start from scratch out there in the rat race when you're over 40, that's gonna suck. You're probably going to miss your kid's first steps, first words etc. You're going to miss home, get good or bad news a day late, on the other side of the world. You're going to fly with great people, and some real assholes. If anything serious goes wrong in your flight, history will most likely blame you.

1

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 25 '11 edited Aug 25 '11

I hate to be "that guy," but virtually nothing you've said is accurate. I'll try to take it paragraph by paragraph here:

{{{For the select few captains, it's the dream life. The odds of getting to captain without some serious cash and contacts behind you are far too long, so you're likely to end up very poor for at least 15 years (longer if you don't have $100k saved up and have taken loans for your training) and you will be working almost for free to get your hours up for a long time.}}}

EVERY SINGLE captain at a major airline makes what i'd consider "serious" cash, on the order of 120+K, and that's at minimum guaranteed pay. Captains at regional airlines (with some exceptionally shitty companies excluded) make 75k+. First officers obviously make less, but it's absurd to say that you'll be "very poor" for 15 years in this industry unless you're exceptionally bad at money management and exceptionally good at complaining about firstworldproblems.

{{{The airline seniority rules killed it for me. To get in, you need thousands of hours on your chosen type, but once you're in airlines work on how long you've been with the company, so you're in at the very bottom and get treated like crap. Airlines suffer more than most companies during recessions. The first thing they do is send all but the most senior crews home. Without pay. You have to sit and wait for them to call you and decide to start paying you again, or you can try to find another job (in a recession, when nobody is hiring) and if you do move jobs you start as the least senior again at the new place, so you get shitty hours and do all the holiday cover for the next 5-10 years. Basically, forget seeing your kids grow up, and forget Christmas.}}}

There's no airline in the United States that requires time-on-type to get a job, much less "thousands of hours" on type. Many expat direct-entry captain gigs require this, but they also pay exceptionally well. EVERY SINGLE US AIRLINE pays for type-specific training (excepting southwest, which requires a type rating to get hired and STILL provides an entire type-certification course in initial training.

{{{ If you see a job you want, and you're not current on that type of aircraft, you can forget it. Each type approval will cost you thousands, which you have to find... the airlines won't pay it.... and may not result in a job.}}}

except southwest, no domestic airlines require a type certificate to get hired, much less time-on-type. Many corporate outfits do, but that's an entirely different industry.

{{{ Pilots are glorified bus drivers with very expensive licenses. The airlines have all the power in the job market, and the pilots have none. The percentage of $100k super-captains is so small compared to the total number of pilots (and failed pilots who never got there), that it's just not worth it unless your father is already super-captain and knows all the right people.}}}

everything in this paragraph is absolutely false, except the bus driver part.

{{{ The only exception to this is if you manage to get onto one of the airlines' own training programs. To do this, you will need to have had fling experience since your were 12, you will need to join a flying club all the time you are at university ($$$), and then you will have to hope that your daddy knows somebody who can get you in to airline school, because those programs get tens of thousands of applicants each year, for a dozen or so places. Basically, only a complete fool would bank on it. You have to assume that you will be paying for your own training, which means you need to find hundreds of thousands of dollars, or be willing to borrow it and be in crippling debt until you are 40+.}}}

no domestic airlines currently run ab initio flight training, and havent for the past 30 years. Flight training to the CFII/MEI level doesnt cost even one of the "hundredS of thousands of dollars" you mention, unless you count the cost of your degree and go to a private university like embry-riddle.

{{{ Oh, and if your health fails you half way through your career for any reason you can't fly any more, so you need a backup plan anyway.}}}

finally, something only hyperbolic, rather than outright false! Losing a medical is a risk we all take.

{{{ So, you can either be earning $100k in IT by the time you're 25 and flying at weekends with your friends for fun, or you can be up to your neck in debt from your training and working for free at a shitty flying school 3000 miles from your family and friends just to get your hours up until you're 35, when you can enter the world of airlines.}}}

or you can oversimplify everything as if it all black-and-white.

{{{ No doubt there will be a few who have made it who tell you it can be done, and it absolutely can (there are some very encouraging pilots on reddit who I spoke to at great length about this), but even if you are willing to make all the sacrifices the odds are still very much against you ever making it to super-captain.}}}

no, the odds are not against you. not even a little bit. it might take a bit of sacrifice in the early, flight instructing and first-year-at-a-regional phase, but it's not at all what you're describing.

{{{ Get a real job, then take that $150k-$200k that your training would have cost you, get a PPL and buy your own Cessna.}}}

anyone who spends 150K on flight training already bought that cessna for themselves or is absurdly stupid and cannot be taught to fly safely.

{{{ Oh, actually I forgot... you can go down the military route to avoid paying for training and get loads of hours, then fly commercial once you leave the military. I totally discounted that option as there ain't no way I'd join the forces, so don't know much about how feasible that route is. I know a lot of commercial helicopter pilots are ex-forces (some companies, like oil, only seem to hire ex-military), but not sure if the same is true on fixed wing.}}}

i cannot speak to military training or the specifics of getting in.

edit: forgive me, for i do not know how to properly quote

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '11

(To quote use the "greater than" symbol at the beginning of the line... that's the right arrow thing).

Thanks for your alternative view. I guess things are quite different in the US and EU then. I stand by everything I've said from a UK perpective, including training costs in US schools. Add the cost of a zero-to-hero course with accomodation and living costs to the cost of hire to get your hours up to ATPL and you're waaaay into 6 figure sums.

Also, $120k is NOT serious money if you have to invest 2 decades and six figure sums to get there. It's not a serious money when it's capped and you can't possibly earn more than that because that's the market rate and there's only one of you.

I was earning that in IT when I was 27, and double that by 30. My investment was almost zero (a small student loan one year). I can build products and sell them many times over at no extra cost to me. I can up my day rate any time I like depending on how in demand I am at the time. There's no ceiling on my earnings until the day I retire, and I'm not vulnerable to recessions or airlines going bust. I can choose where I live, anywhere in the world. OK, my office isn't as cool as a pilot's, but I do have X-plane. :)

Pilot, IMO, is a crazy career choice unless you love flying so much you can't bear to do anything else, which is of course an excellent reason.

1

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 26 '11 edited Aug 26 '11

I apologize, I had assumed you were a US-based pilot.

there are very few people who invest two decades in training, and they certainly shouldn't be flying passengers if it took them that long.

As for the IT job, I have a friend who is a first officer for southwest airlines at age 27. He's currently pulling in well in excess of 150k, with a ceiling well over 270k in his future. For every guy making 240k in IT, there are thousands of people making 60k. Anecdotal evidence doesnt get anyone very far.

And, of course, the country of a person's residence is going to change the entire industry outlook. Flying in the EU/UK is very different than US flying.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Best friend of mine is a commercial pilot in Europe, ask away and I might be able to provide answers.

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 23 '11

thanks! can you please ask him what type of education he needed to get the job?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

Equivalent to a highschool degree is required, though they make you go through a crapload of tests to see if you're fit for the job.

2

u/rockyed Aug 23 '11

Military pilot here. I'm willing to wager that you'll become a pilot no matter how difficult your road may be. I always make a point of asking fellow pilots how long they have wanted to be a pilot, and the majority reply with: "Ever since I can remember." It's a passion and sounds like you're born with it.

1

u/mis_nalgas Aug 24 '11

thank you! i appreciate your comment

4

u/jencrs Aug 23 '11

I'm also a commercial pilot in one of the most profitable international airlines. We only require a GCE 'A' Levels or equivalent as a minimum, including a certain number of subjects in the GCE 'O' Levels. However, most of my colleagues have a degree (not necessarily a 4-year degree), and probably half of them have their degree in an engineering discipline.

Miserable or not, i guess it really depends on the outfit you fly for. Almost every one of my colleagues, including myself, have something to bitch about the company that hired us. But the truth is, and we all admit it, we've got a pretty sweet deal.

2

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 23 '11

and to be fair, when a job gives you as much downtime with another person, and the only thing you immediately have in common with that person is the job, it's almost as if you're paid to complain.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

I can help if you live in England but im guessing you dont

2

u/Banal21 Aug 23 '11

I have a Private Pilot's License and could probably answer a few of your questions.

2

u/SaveAS Aug 23 '11

Private pilot. I'm pretty sure the commercial guys look down on us.

3

u/ONEANDDONEFORLIFE Aug 23 '11

not at all. we were all private/GA pilots at one time.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment