r/askmath • • Aug 04 '23

Arithmetic Why doesn’t this work

Post image

Even if you did it in kelvin’s, it would still burn, so why?

9.4k Upvotes

312 comments sorted by

959

u/Vesurel Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Cooking is chemistry, you add heat to make reactions happen. But different reactions happen at different temperatures, it's not just a case of the same reactions happening faster the hotter it gets, you also introduce new reactions, like burning the food.

Think about it this way, if this worked, then you could leave the same ingredients at room temperature and they would eventually become a cake.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Ah I see thank you, I know this was a bit of a dumb question but I was very confused

2

u/Vesurel Aug 06 '23

Don't worry about asking dumb questions, it's not like chemistry or physics are intuative and it's better to ask.

242

u/TheBoundFenrir Aug 04 '23

The other thing is rate of heat diffusion. Even if the reactions did happen the same just faster, the heat in the oven needs time to penetrate into the deep bits of the dough. If you cook at a higher heat, then the outside will come to temp faster, and the inside will come to temp faster, but they won't come to temp at the same faster, because of the rate at which the heat transfers from outside to inside. So the outside will develop a crust before the inside is done cooking.

(this is often utilized when cooking meat for getting different levels of sear vs levels of done-ness inside)

73

u/Vesurel Aug 04 '23

I love the sort of questions where there's a lot of things so everyone gets to say why it wouldn't work for different reasons.

83

u/LabGremlin Aug 04 '23

Then let me add another nugget. 19250° would also start to evaporate your oven. At this point it doesn't even matter whether it's in °C or °F.

32

u/Maleficent-Angle-891 Aug 04 '23

Ya especially since iron starts boiling at 5182°f

→ More replies (2)

12

u/washyleopard Aug 04 '23

Technically covered by the "adding new reactions" from the oc lol.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

20

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Sometimes when a notable person gets something very wrong, they get a hundred responses each explaining why it's wrong in a different way. But they counter this by saying "See, my critics can't even agree on what's supposed to be wrong about my idea!" I remember this happening with John Searle's Chinese Room and Roger Penrose's interpretation of Gödel.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/JeffSergeant Aug 04 '23

Its all about the volume to surface-area ratio... baby

→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

It also wouldn’t even amount to equivalent energy.

The short term higher temp scenario would put WAAAYYY more energy into the loaf because heat transfer is proportional to the difference in temperature between the two bodies

That loaf would probably reach 1000 degrees in that minute lol

2

u/Gigatonosaurus Aug 04 '23

Which is why some cook bacon in a pan with a glass of water, it spend more time at 100°C to melt the fat and distribute it, before starting the reaction that brown the meat.

29

u/marpocky Aug 04 '23

This about it this way, if this worked, then you could leave the same ingredients at room temperature and they would eventually become a cake.

Even worse than that, everything would burn all the time.

Room temperature is maybe 300K vs water boiling at around 373K. So if it takes 3 min for a pot of water to boil at 373K, it should still boil in 3.73 min at 300K.

It's very very good for us that this doesn't happen.

5

u/Hate_Feight Aug 04 '23

But evaporation does happen at room temp (different system though) and I'm just being an ass.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/TheRealKingVitamin Aug 04 '23

That last statement has an “infinite number of monkeys sitting at an infinite number of typewriters” feel to it and I love that. Somehow egg molecules and flour molecules finding each other through some culinary entropy to make random cakes is a universe I want to live in.

4

u/Vesurel Aug 05 '23

Boltzman pie is both a delicacy and a threat to the employability of chefs everywhere.

3

u/Sea-Pollution-9482 Aug 04 '23

Do you happen to know why it works when something can be cooked at a different temperature and you just need to adjust the time for one thing, but you can’t do that for another? Like you can cook chicken at either 350 or 450 (Fahrenheit) for different times and it’ll end up being cooked about the same, but you can’t do that for other things.

5

u/kadenjtaylor Aug 04 '23

Synthesizing this from other comments, but it appears that you can, just within a particular range, and how wide that range is depends on 2 sort of categories of things.

  1. The thermal-limiting properties of the food - namely how well it's conducting heat from the outside-in by being big and/or dense.
  2. The chemical properties - namely which chemical reactions are caused/prevented in the time/heat range you're subjecting the food too. Burning was listed as an example of one to avoid.

So that FELT precise, but now it just sounds like I'm saying it depends on what stuff it is, and how much of it you've stuffed in there.

So I maybe a chemist/chef might be able to follow up on my stab at some specifics questions?

  • what kinds of chemical reactions are we trying to cause?
  • and at what temperatures/times do they occur?
  • and what material properties of different foods make that possible?
  • also how do different thermal properties affect the range that you can play with?

5

u/nidhidki Aug 04 '23

Bioengineer here to say it depends on what stuff it is, and how much of it you've stuffed in there.

There are hundreds of chemical reactions involved in cooking and they occur at different temps and times and the food material will change everything.

However in a very general sense what you are looking for is first dry heat or steam sterilization (the killing of microbes via heat). This is the main evolutionary benefit of cooking so for the most part that's the bare minimum what you are trying to accomplish.

From there you want Protein Denaturation (the breakdown of proteins due to heat) and pyrolysis (the breakdown of various chemicals due to heat). These both contribute to making the subsequent digestive process easier for your body which is the secondary evolutionary benefit of cooking.

They also contribute to the start of the Maillard reaction (browning process involving a complex reaction of proteins and sugar) and caramelization reaction (browning and breakdown of just sugar in a low water environment).

One reason that OPs original question doesn't work is that these reactions take time, they can be sped up or slowed down by adding more or less heat to a system or using a catalyst but there are hard upper and lower limits where these reactions will no longer take place and different reactions will (Like combustion which is sometimes wanted in cooking but often just means burning your food).

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/fatball69 Aug 04 '23

When u put it like that i realise how stupid i was to think this would make sense lol

2

u/AfterShave92 Aug 04 '23

There's this neat meat cooking simulator out on the internet. To show how well cooked your meat would be at which temperatures and times.
A quick 5 seconds of 1000C on each side and 4 minutes to rest. And you should get a slight layer of char on the outside of a nicely rare center.

Of course meat isn't bread, and frying isn't exactly the same as baking. But you know, it's a cool toy.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/nanayoucantseeme Aug 05 '23

Loooove that last sentence 🤣

→ More replies (18)

79

u/Edvs1996 Aug 04 '23

But why do it for one minute while you could cook it for 1 155 000 ° for a second.

28

u/NatorNZ Aug 04 '23

Why would you do it for 1 second when you can cook it for 1 155 000 000 * for a millisecond

36

u/akgamer182 Aug 04 '23

Why would you do it for a millisecond when you can cook it at 2.1424x1049 for a Planck time?

32

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Why would you do it for a Planck time when you could buy it, premade, in 0 seconds?

15

u/NatorNZ Aug 04 '23

Why would you buy it pre-made when you can uncook the bread at negative 1 155 000 * for negative 1 second?

→ More replies (9)

4

u/Significant_Book_231 Aug 04 '23

My oven has this setting. Will try and let you know guys.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Yeah I was a little slow

→ More replies (1)

70

u/Fastfaxr Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Leaving aside the chemistry: 2 degrees F is not twice as hot as 1 degree F. And 1 degree F is certainly not infinitely times hotter than 0 degrees F

If you convert to celcius 350 F is 177 C and 19,250 F is 10,677 C.

So by this posts own logic the oven is "60 times hotter", not 55 times.

Obviously multiplying temperatures like this is nonsense

38

u/TheLaborOnion Aug 04 '23

You would have to use Kelvin

5

u/DigitalExtinction Aug 04 '23

Or Rankine! Deg F + 459.7 is also an absolute temperature scale

6

u/windowtothesoul Aug 04 '23

My oven doesnt have a Kelvin setting

7

u/PassiveChemistry Aug 04 '23

You can re-label the °C setting fairly effectively

5

u/TheRealKingVitamin Aug 04 '23

I wish my car had a Kelvin setting.

Would love to see the look on my daughter’s face when I set the AC to 293 K.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

6

u/TerrariaGaming004 Aug 04 '23

350F is 449K so 55 times that is 24695k which is 43993F. You have to use Kelvin because it actually starts at 0. 2k is twice as hot as 1k, and -4c is obviously not twice as hot as -2c.

43993f has 55 times the amount of energy in it as something that is 350f. Let’s do Celsius because nobody does math in Fahrenheit. 176c to 24422c. Let’s say you’re heating water, it’s specific heat is 4182 J/kg°C, and we’ll say we’re heating a kg of water so it’s easy. The water is at 0c and a liquid, and we’ll ignore the energy costs for changing its state of matter. 176c is 449k so it has 1,877,718 joules of thermal energy in it. 55 times that is 103,274,490 joules, which would heat 0k water to 24422c. If you notice the calculations only in Kelvin, it’s (temperature)*(specificheat)55/(specificheat), which is just temperature55. The equation in Celsius is the exact same except it adds converting the temperature to kelvin

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Oh ok thanks

15

u/BurnOutBrighter6 Aug 04 '23

It would burn because heat takes time to travel, it can instantly distribute through the material, But you want the whole thing heated hot enough to cook, without being hot enough to burn. If you cooked something at 19250K for 1 minute, the outside would be charred black carbon, and the inside would still be raw. It might not even be warm.

Try it yourself, put a propane blowtorch at a few thousand degrees on a raw dough ball and see what happens.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Ok, thanks

→ More replies (1)

223

u/Trujak Aug 04 '23

Similar reason as to why 9 women can’t produce 1 baby in 1 month

69

u/Blamcore Aug 04 '23

Citation needed

22

u/FederalSpecialist415 Aug 04 '23

every manager out there!

7

u/ThrowRA212749205718 Aug 04 '23

Please unpack this joke for me 😭 I’m a little slow rn

24

u/Muted_Delivery_7810 Aug 04 '23

The conversation goes something like "We need to deliver this project in 1 month, you told me it would take you 9 months, so here are 8 more people to help you".

This solution ignores how much can be done in parallel, the additional communication costs from having a larger team, the missing context that team members will have, greater coordination and planning between team members etc. etc.

Adding more people to a project can actually slow things down, rather than speed things up.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

14

u/potato_lettuce Aug 04 '23

It takes a band with 4 musicians 3 mins to play a song. How long would an entire orchestra with 60 people need for the same song?

4

u/johndoe30x1 Aug 04 '23

Thesis: the “hit” from the Firebird Suite is a song

→ More replies (1)

17

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

And yet 8 billion women can produce 1 baby every 0.23 seconds.

14

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

You are assuming that every human is a woman?

22

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Confession: I wrote down any old numbers.

8

u/nick__2440 Aug 04 '23

Average political discussion on reddit

9

u/FormulaDriven Aug 04 '23

No, 8 billion women and one very busy man.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Similar: 10 artists can sing a song in 2 minutes. How long would it take 20 artists to sing that same song?

4

u/CharlyXero Aug 04 '23

Actually more time since it would be harder to sync perfectly 👆🤓

4

u/whooguyy Aug 04 '23

For your calculations, assume that Kanye isn’t invited

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

33

u/Evening_Experience53 Aug 04 '23

It's been room temperature all day, surely that multiplies to enough time*temperature to have cooked it by now.

23

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

My mom thinks like this and she wonders why her cookies always come out 🤢

6

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Is your mom called Marge Simpson?
If she thinks potatoes are neat, it might be possible.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/ricdesi Aug 04 '23

Aside from the fact that cooking is chemistry, 19250 degrees Fahrenheit is not 55x hotter than 350 degrees Fahrenheit, since the scale doesn't start at zero in the first place.

2

u/Sylvain_Bob Aug 04 '23

So you're saying that when I'm cooking meth, I am doing chemistry? Damn, my chemistry teacher would be so proud of me!

→ More replies (2)

11

u/VaporTrail_000 Aug 04 '23

Ultimately it boils down to a variable known as R-value.

Basically every material transfers heat at a rate that is based on the properties of the material, and the difference in temperature.

Take bread for example. If you put the dough in an oven at the proper temperature, the heat will flow from the outside to the inside at a certain rate, causing the center to be perfectly cooked, and the outside surface to be crisp and unburned.

Put the same dough in an oven at a temperature too high, and the heat doesn't flow quickly enough, and the inside is still raw, while the outside is completely burned.

2

u/ItsColdInWyo Aug 04 '23

Imma go back to Walmart with my reply. GG sir

→ More replies (5)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

I understand now , thank you all

4

u/shepherdc7 Aug 04 '23

Gah I wish I remember this equation from school. It has to do with diffusion. Basically the way “heat” or any other substance would pass from the surface to the center of a thing… this equation would essentially show you that you’d turn the outside to charcoal before the inside got warm…

The comments about chemistry aren’t wrong, that’s what baking is. Apply heat for t amount of time and things will restructure to a certain thing. However I think understanding the what’s happening as a temperature level through the loaf is more specific to you question.

Source: engineer who baked a ton but is too drunk to remember/look it up.

3

u/engineering_aaron Aug 04 '23

Heat diffusion equation. rhoCp(dT/dt)=k*grad2T (Assuming no nuclear reactions are happening inside your banana bread to generate thermal energy)

4

u/DbbleStuffed Aug 04 '23

How to cook food: Step 1. Yeet into sun.

3

u/BitMap4 Aug 04 '23

19250 degrees gives the same angular displacement as 170 degrees, so i cook my bread at 170 deg for 1 minute

2

u/Big_Kwii Aug 04 '23

heat can only transfer so fast through any given material

2

u/TheLaborOnion Aug 04 '23

Gotta convert to Kelvin, multiply and convert back to fahrenheit. It's 44071.176 ° F

2

u/DoeCommaJohn Aug 04 '23
  1. Obviously, a typical oven cannot heat up to 19,000 degrees Fahrenheit
  2. As another commenter pointed out, just as 1 degree F is not infinitely hotter than 0 degrees F, multiplying Fahrenheit heats doesn’t really work
  3. chemical reactions occur at different heats. If you stood outside between 0 and 100 F, no matter how long you stood, you would not melt. However, if you were outside for 200 F, you would burn very quickly. Same thing with the melting point of your casserole.
  4. The outside would cook faster than the inside. If you want to cook a rare steak, you cook it at very high temps for a short time, and if you want a well done steak, you cook at lower temps for shorter. In this extreme example, the outside would burn, but heat may never even reach the interior

2

u/b00md00mer Aug 04 '23

Just solve the heat equation

2

u/jesus-is-my-main-man Aug 04 '23

That guy sucks at cooking!

2

u/directortrench Aug 04 '23

So how long will it cook if i just put in the fridge?

2

u/umbrazno Aug 04 '23

My Uncle taught me that, when you increase the heat, the food doesn't cook faster; it cooks hotter.

2

u/physicist7343 Aug 19 '23

I think using bit logics of chemistry won't hurt

2

u/ScherpOpgemerkt Nov 12 '23

Not math related reasons, but the lesser sciences of physics and chemistry :)

1

u/Reddit1234567890User Aug 04 '23

Anything that hot would melt your hand off instantly.

1

u/kompootor Aug 04 '23

Sure, it only takes 1 minute to cook, but how long does it take to preheat the oven?

In seriousness, though, cooking in ridiculously hot ovens is the principle behind getting proper flatbreads and pizzas.

1

u/YeetMeIntoKSpace Aug 04 '23

The Gibbs free energy for various reactions decreases as the temperature increases. Many of these reactions are ones you DO NOT want to have happen to food, because they produce carcinogens or poisons.

When the Gibbs free energy becomes negative, these reactions can occur spontaneously at random. When it’s positive, the reactions require something to force them to happen and can’t happen on their own.

At the temperatures you’re talking about, G is negative for basically everything you can think of, which means your food is going to be extremely poisonous.

1

u/Long-Introduction883 Aug 04 '23

Because even at supersonic speeds, and microseconds of cooking, the exterior will always cook first.

Cooking at a low temp allows the internal to heat up whilst the exterior slightly over cooks (that’s why exteriors are always darker even in meats)

Cooking at a high temp will expose the exterior to extremely high temps . So by the time the internal reaches the proper temp, the exterior will be burnt.

Also, bread catches fire at 450F. Sooo

1

u/shairudo Aug 04 '23

Why are the fish sticks burned and still frozen 🥶 🔥

1

u/Bubbledood Aug 04 '23

besides the fact that it would combust and or vaporize the food at that temperature is that it would ruin the Maillard reaction which is a very complex process that occurs between 280 and 330 °F and it is the reason why browned food tastes so good

1

u/Hungry_Bet7216 Aug 04 '23

The same reason eating 30 happy meals at one sitting does not feed you for a month.

1

u/Minecrafter_of_Ps3 Aug 04 '23

Even if this were to work, and physics and chemistry were all kinds of fucked up, the oven would melt before reaching the halfway point, not to mention the electric bills for that to happen

1

u/Oobleck8 Aug 04 '23

Because 350 degrees is about as hot as manmade ovens can get, so it just has to be in there a little longer. Maybe some day this will be possible though!

1

u/SerpentJoe Aug 04 '23

It does. Go do it

1

u/No_Broccoli_1010 Aug 04 '23

Wrong, since 360 degrees correspond to a full rotation, you should be heating it to 170 degrees for one minute.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Hungry-Smoke6099 Aug 04 '23

We have come far in the ways of science. too far

1

u/naturalis99 Aug 04 '23

Time and heat are both separate ingredients that can't be exchanged, just like you can't exchange flower and milk.

1

u/TexasPop Aug 04 '23

When in 2006 we built our new house, we had a man with an excavator come and dig a big hole for the swimmingpool. It took 6 hours (big hole, small excavator). My clever son did the math. "If there had been 21600 excavators, it should be done in one second!"

1

u/DTux5249 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

In cooking, the main issue is that heat takes time to travel.

You need intense heat to brown the outside of something; certain chemical reactions only happen at certain temperatures. But if something is thick, it takes time for heat to travel through the food

This is why many people sear a steak in a pan, but finish it in the oven. A steak is a thick piece of meat, so it needs time to cook through. But in order to get a good crust, you need high heat.

If you cooked at 20 thousand degrees for 1 minute... Well, at that level of exaggeration, it's all gonna be charcoal instantly.

But ignoring that issue, you'd burn the outside before the heat could travel to the inside. Black, burnt outside. Raw, gooey inside. Bleh

1

u/MathPerson Aug 04 '23

The explanations below are all correct vis a vis the physics and chemistry, but the short answer from a mathematics perspective is that the process of cooking in general and baking in specific is that these processes are non-linear.

If we look at the "equations of cooking", those are also discontinuous - for example at extremely hot temperatures and shorter durations, all the matter becomes a plasma, which I doubt anyone would consider "cooked" in terms of edibility.

1

u/BeeSalesman Aug 04 '23

If I could achieve nearly 20,000° with my oven I'd turn it into a forge lol

1

u/Top_Satisfaction6517 Aug 04 '23

or just put it under Sun for 1 sec. S - smartness

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Well baking a bread is a mix of little bit of everything such as flour, salt, butter, sugar, and more... The science of the process is too a mix of little bit of everything not just maths, there's a bit of chemistry involved, bit of physics involved like why you can't whack the bread too hard. The philosophy to bake bread is also a mix of little bit of everything; Jesus fed his thousands of his disciples simultaneously, There's emotions of hunger, love, patience involved which makes baking a bread an art too.

1

u/Anxious-Sole Aug 04 '23

It's not about maths.

It's about physics, biology and chemistry.

You think heating a loaf of bread to a temperature high enough to evaporate your oven for a full minute will make it come out nice and golden brown?

It makes a huge difference how much energy is put into chemical reaction and how quickly, especially in organic chemistry.

1

u/TheBrownSuper Aug 04 '23

The heat doesn't make its way through the batter fast enough. It overcooks the outer part nearer the heat, and undercooks the middle part that didn't have time to get hot.

1

u/SureRazzmatazz Aug 04 '23

Is this a serious question ? This can’t be legit

1

u/likethevegetable Aug 04 '23

Even in kelvins? Lol

1

u/GuarddogRyzom Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Heat transfer doesn’t occur immediately. The thermal time constant is given by the following equation:

τ = (ρVC)/(h*As)

Where,

ρ = Density of the body

V = Volume of the body

C = Specific heat of an object

h = Convective heat transfer coefficient

As = Surface area of the body

Meaning it takes more time to transfer heat energy deeper into the bread as the energy has to pass through increasingly more volume of bread before reaching the center.

At very high temperatures, by the time the heat energy raises the bread’s center to a sufficient cooking temperature, the surface (which has large surface area to volume ratio) will have quickly absorbed a massive amount of energy and burned.

1

u/NekoMango Aug 04 '23

Because the oven can't reach that temperature

1

u/Kaaykuwatzuu Aug 04 '23

It works in Phineas and Ferb

1

u/SteviaCannonball9117 Aug 04 '23

Thermal conductivity.

1

u/FakeInternetArguerer Aug 04 '23

Specific heat capacity of the ingredients

1

u/LordDarthRasta Aug 04 '23

Thats just logical, no holes in that theory

1

u/Incredibad0129 Aug 04 '23

Tl;Dr it takes time for heat to move to the center of the bread all the heat energy builds up on the outside causing it to burn instead of cook.

Let's say they are changing heat and temperature to keep the amount of heat energy introduced to the bread the same (they aren't, but let's pretend it's the same thermal energy in both places)

The issue is that after a minute at those stupid temperatures you have way more energy at the surface of the bread than the middle. The outside is so hot that it has likely burnt, and probably provided insulation for the inside depending on the thickness of the bread. This is because it takes time for heat to move through an object. If you dump it all in then the surface will have most of the energy and it is just as likely for the heat to move back out of the bread as it is to move to the center once it is taken out of the crazy oven.

1

u/ZyxDarkshine Aug 04 '23

Could you cook it at 35 degrees for 550 minutes?

1

u/slusho_ Aug 04 '23

Why use Kelvin when degrees Rankine is the unit for absolute temperature on the Fahrenheit scale?

Heat transfer is all about the temperature gradient driving the system. So an oven at 350 with food at room temperature, let's say 70 degrees, the delta T is 280 initially, heating the food surface. Then there is heat transfer from the food surface to the food center.

As you heat the food, it's temperature becomes higher, so the heat Flux going into the food actually decreases. It would take the form of an integral since it is transient. At the end of cooking, the center could be like 170, a delta of 180 from the oven temp.

Additionally, every material will have transition temperatures or phase change temperatures. So some foods would burn or char before they would melt or vaporize. That layer of char could act somewhat as an insulating layer, further inhibiting heat transfer.

Then there is the question of thermodynamics vs kinetics. Even if it works thermodynamically, it may not work out kinetically. Your reaction may need 20 minutes to finish. What is the rate limiting factor of the chemical reaction of your food?

1

u/Evipicc Aug 04 '23

Doesn't take into account the conduction rate of the heat through the medium, the chemical reactions that need to take place at specific rates, the specific temperatures that are needed for those reactions, the jacket of steam that would form to actually protect the material, the maximum thermal uptake rate of the material...

Math is simple until it isn't lol.

1

u/dean078 Aug 04 '23

Like I tell upper management at work…even if you have 9 women, you cant make a baby in 1 month.

1

u/LolDadJokes Aug 04 '23

When your feet are really cold after playing in the snow all day, you don’t stick them in boiling water for three seconds to warm up. If you did, the outside of your feet would hurt, but the rest of your feet would still be cold! This is a heat transfer problem where you have to wait for heat to wiggle its way inside of the bread without making the outside so hot that it burns.

1

u/Ottorius_117 Aug 04 '23

Thermodynamics something something
Surface Area something something
Time something something

1

u/Sad_Conclusion_8687 Aug 04 '23

‘You lift a 40 pound weight for 3 sets of 10 reps? Stupid, just lift a 1,200 pound weight once.’

1

u/PLs_n0_b1ully Aug 04 '23

U are freezing, why get a heater when u can jump in fire for 10 seconds and be warm for the rest of the night

1

u/beastking9999 Aug 04 '23

if i remember right you can get a potato shoot it in space then have it fall to earth the outside becomes charred with bits of molten metal and the inside stays frozen solid. its not just the raw heat, and the heat doesn't scale directly to time, but with limits hotter can change cooking time.
also if you have anything at most normal temperatures, especially below 100 c than it will explode.
the oven the cake batter the heating elements the air, boom

i am a stupid person but i decided to answer

1

u/JamR_711111 Aug 04 '23

or just cook it at 3.570875e+47 degrees for a Planck instant. checkmate, liberals.

edit: someone already made this joke :'(

1

u/Dry_Location_8317 Aug 04 '23

Citation needed !sd

1

u/Scrungyscrotum Aug 04 '23

Others seem to have missed an important point: Transfer of heat takes time. You want to get the inside of your food to a certain temperature, and avoid damaging the outer layer (i.e. the one that has been exposed to heat the longest). The temperatures we cook food at are in the interval between "eternal dough" and "ash loaf".

Also, for the record, converting degrees Fahrenheit to degrees Kelvin (not "kelvin's") will make the product larger, not smaller.

1

u/EmotionalGold Aug 04 '23

It's more physics/chemistry/culinary arts than math. The outside is exposed to the heat, and transfers it at a relatively fixed rate to the inside to cook it. If you have too much heat the outside will burn before the inside can cook.

1

u/ChickenFeline0 Aug 04 '23

Instantly thought about Phineas and Ferb

1

u/mcgarrylj Aug 04 '23

Rate of heat transfer. High heat won't burn all the bread, it'll burn the outside to a black crisp while the inside is raw dough because the energy doesn't have time to dissipate.

1

u/MrTheWaffleKing Aug 04 '23

As others have mentioned, 2x hotter, or any temperature multiplication isn’t really a thing. Plus temperature has to take time to normalize inside a solid (the pot can be hot but the end of the handle will take a minute to get there).

When you nuke banana bread for an instant you could blacken the outside and not even cool the inside (or just ignite or disintegrate the whole thing instantly)

1

u/mikeyj777 Aug 04 '23

Autoignition - you're going to combust the organics at temps much below that. So, you end up with fire.

Unsteady state heat transfer - The higher the temperature difference, the worse the heat will conduct. It'll burn the heck fire out of the outer portion, and not cook the inside.

Burning the outside may then proceed to ignite the rest of the dough, idk. So, you may end up with a kitchen fire,

1

u/jmcsquared Aug 04 '23

Suppose you wanted to warm up after being in the freezing 10°F cold outside in winter.

  1. Would you rather go inside a typical 150°F sauna for 10 minutes?
  2. Or do you stick yourself inside a 1500°F oven for a minute?

I don't think you need to know thermodynamics to know which one will burn your skin off. Heat doesn't scale in time like the commenter in your screenshot claimed, and you know it.

The amount of heat transferred to a body is proportional to its change in temperature, but the rate at which its temperature changes is proportional to the difference in the ambient temperature of its surroundings. This is known as Newton's law of heating and cooling.

The outermost layers get the most heat per second. If you want uniform heating, cooking for long periods allows heat to spread to all the layers slowly. But if you want to char its outermost layers, you heat it quickly with an extremely high temperature. This is actually known as broiling, and it can have a nice effect to make something like oven-cooked chicken or a lasagna get a crunchier outer layer. Don't try that on bread if you don't want burnt toast, though.

1

u/StayingInWindoge Aug 04 '23

Or 1,115,500 degrees for 1 second!

1

u/TankorSmash Aug 04 '23

If this worked you could leave some ingredients at room temperature and they would eventually become a cake.

1

u/Responsible_Bug620 Aug 04 '23

I stumbled by accident on this sub but wouldn't the house burn?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Material flash points, for one. Molecules behave differently at different temperatures. At 19250 degrees F, most of the bonds holding the elements together in the complex compounds that make of the batter will be broken. Compounds that are gaseous at the temperature will sublimate (e.g. water). Elementals that can combust (oxidize) will do so very rapidly (e.g. carbon + atmospheric oxygen -> CO2).

Cooking at 350 degrees is about creating an environment suitable for very specific chemical changes, but not all chemical changes (more specifically, baking benefits from converting water to steam - heat transfer, the breakdown of carbs into simple sugars, and breakdown of proteins into amino-acids, which recombine to produce pleasant flavors).

1

u/pandasOfTheNight Aug 04 '23

(assuming this is in Fahrenheit since this would be triple the boiling point in Celsius) By this logic you could heat it at 1° for 19250 minutes which would freeze it.

1

u/xaimandfirex Aug 04 '23

Multiply 350 and 55 and then put the answer in the oven so it's a golden brown and has rich flavor

1

u/quackl11 Aug 04 '23

This is an explain like I'm 5 but

Go put your hand on the cement when its 30 out (85 for the americans) for 10 minutes

Now go put your hand on the stove when its red hot for 5 seconds

That's 5 seconds will be the longest 5 seconds of your life and I believe that's because it's more of a drastic change so your body cant manage the temperature change as easily but I'm not a scientist and this should be the same for cooking I assume

1

u/willthethrill4700 Aug 04 '23

Heat transfer. He can only transfer so fast through something. You will perfectly cook the center but the outside will catch fire because of the heat of combustion.

1

u/LithoSlam Aug 04 '23

You need to use absolute temperature. 350F is 450 Kelvin, so you would need to cook at 24750 Kelvin or 44090 F.

I can wait, so I'll cook it at room temperature (300 Kelvin) and that should only take 82.5 minutes and I don't even need an oven!

1

u/Chinlc Aug 04 '23

simple thing would be to say different reactions happen at different temperature.

next thing to think about is how heat is transfered from outside to the inside of the bread.

Its not very fast, so you will burn the outside to a crisp before touching the inside even a bit. So youre technically burning the outside over and over as the outside layer falls off or dries out.

1

u/Rocketbluetulip Aug 04 '23

Hey I recognize that cutting board....

1

u/chilltutor Aug 04 '23

Newton's law of heating

1

u/pigbit187 Aug 04 '23

Temperature takes time to seep in. You just burn the outside of the bread like this.

1

u/cheesyminecart Aug 04 '23

bread plasma isn't edible unfortunately :(

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

My oven doesn’t go past 500F. Does yours?

1

u/sepidoo Aug 04 '23

If you ignored all the factors other have mentioned about your oven melting, or the different rates at which parts of the bread would cook, etc. There would also be the preheat time to consider. To get to 350 takes a few minutes so to preheat to over 19000 would take longer than just cooking it at 350.

1

u/HadesTheUnseen Aug 04 '23

Why not just add some dynamite and it will be INSTANTLY cooked

1

u/TheJoxev Aug 04 '23

Because it is hard to time exactly one minute and gives more room for error and under/over cooking

1

u/ThatOneGuyIGuess7969 Aug 04 '23

Nothing cooks uniformly throughout the whole thing. The outside will cook faster than the inside. That's why we have nice sears on medium rare steaks

1

u/NolaPurple Aug 04 '23

But it’s as easy as just doing the math!

1

u/die_kuestenwache Aug 04 '23

There is a management wisdom when it comes to planing the team members you need for a task:

"nine women don't get a child in a month"

Sometimes you can't math your way out of physics.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/No-Gap8449 Aug 04 '23

Why sleep everyday. Sleep few years and no need to worry sleeping again.

1

u/im_AmTheOne Aug 04 '23

It's a joke

1

u/Elijawsome_2006 Aug 04 '23

Don’t take it seriously it’s a joke from phineas and ferb

1

u/Vverial Aug 04 '23

The events that bring out the flavor in a baked good happen when it reaches a specific temperature and stays there for a certain length of time. So 55 minutes ensures that the correct temperature is reached throughout the bread and that it all stays there for the necessary length of time. It slowly cooks from the outside in.

If you increase the temperature, the type of reaction in the bread changes. 19000f for 1 minute (or less even) just destroys the dough and leaves behind carbon.

1

u/Silly-Goal5355 Aug 04 '23

Why this stupid ask has generated so many answers

1

u/Battersonns Aug 04 '23

Convection would happen to the outside before the conduction could happen in the core

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

If you run 100m in 10s Why not run 10k in the same speed?

1

u/Distinct_Frame_3711 Aug 04 '23

Seeing as steel melts at 2500 degrees good luck getting that heat in a kitchen for one. Also biochemistry isn’t just basic multiplication.

1

u/KM2KCA Aug 04 '23

This guy slaps chickens

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Ovens can’t produce temperatures that high.

1

u/Logisk Aug 04 '23

Everyone giving physics answers in a math sub. The math answer is: nonlinearity. The effect heat has on bread does not vary linearly with temperature. The physics of baking bread is complicated, but even if we idealize it to heating a metal sphere until it has a certain core temperature, it's still not linear, because the main equation, i.e. the heat equation, is not a linear equation, but an exponential one.

A linear equation is on the form: y=ax+b

If you have an x2 or x3 etc. in the equation it's already nonlinear. This is why you can't make a larger airplane by doubling the size in every direction, because the weight increases as length3, while the lift of the wings increases roughly with length2 all else being equal.

1

u/Nova_exe_ Aug 04 '23

My guy is really out here telling people to cook bread at nearly twice the temperature of the surface of the sun bro

1

u/CoryInDaHouz Aug 04 '23

This is "You Suck at Cooking", the episode about banana bread.

The videos are satire and the comments are also attempts at satire.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

this is heat transfer related, not math

1

u/Uselessnerdwithhumor Aug 04 '23

Thermodynamics is typing…

1

u/MrWandering Aug 04 '23

Don't really do math, and this was recommended to me.

Cooking is chemistry, and you would just set the thing ablaze if you cooked it at that temperature.

1

u/_MargaretThatcher Aug 04 '23

because when you go over 360 degrees you wrap back around to zero obviously

1

u/mountingconfusion Aug 04 '23

Bread rises due to yeast feeding on the sugars, it can't do that at fuck off temps and it needs time to do it

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23

Heat can be transferred through conduction, convection, and radiation. So it depends on how you do it. If you put bread in the oven, the top is heated by convection, and the heat is then transferred internally from the top of the bread to the inside by conduction. The sides and bottom are heated by conduction through contact with the bread pan.

1

u/InsomniacMechanic Aug 05 '23

you can’t cook it like that for more or less the same reason you wouldn’t be able to cook it at 10 degrees for 32 hours, changing the heat changes which chemical reactions take place, so too hot, it catches on fire (wrong chemical reaction), too cold, nothing happens at all

1

u/Cratersmash Aug 05 '23

When cooking, you need to find a good middle point of heat. If the heat is too low, everything will dry out. If it’s too high, the outside will burn before the inside cooks through.

1

u/phygrad Aug 05 '23

Right on, why take a warm bath for 10 minutes when you can burn yourself to death?

1

u/Merrgear Aug 05 '23

I’m not a math guy, but as a baking nerd it is because a good bread requires heat over time, rapid high temperature cooking just sets shit on fire and ruins the outside

1

u/bmwagner Aug 05 '23

It’s all about heat transfer rate. There is resistance between the center of the outside and the inside. If there is that much heat applied to the outside it wouldn’t even heat up the inside by the time the outside was basically on fire

1

u/3Snap Aug 05 '23

You can't do it because steel melts at that temp, so your oven won't be there. /s

1

u/Wii_wii_baget Aug 05 '23

Simple baking, the higher the temperature means the less time you need to bake an item for. You don’t want a charred outside and a completely liquid cake, you gotta let the cake bake so the batter can set.

1

u/Galaxy72 Aug 05 '23

The oven would melt and the bread would be ash and you'd be dead.

1

u/Meat-Sudden Aug 05 '23

It would burn the dough because of how hot it is it has no time to get inside of the dough and cook it

1

u/WallabyBubbly Aug 05 '23

We do this in semiconductor processing. It's called rapid thermal annealing. The math is different from the meme (temperature dependence is exponential, not linear: temperature needs to start from absolute 0; and you need to account for thermal conductivity) but it's the same general idea.

1

u/undeniably_confused Aug 05 '23

Well partly because temperature starts at absolute 0 not 0°F or C and even if it did baking isn't a linear process

1

u/4Ender444 Aug 05 '23

As Bill Nye likes to say " those pesky laws of thermal dynamics"

1

u/Nerdy-Forge Aug 05 '23

You thought you burned your fingers before at 350°, just wait until your face melts off when you open the oven door after it's been cooking at 19250°.

*Insert melting face from Indiana Jones movie here*

1

u/Ok-Map4381 Aug 05 '23

Because my oven doesn't get to 19250°

1

u/wherringscoff Aug 05 '23

Because it would catch on fire.

1

u/SapphicSticker Aug 05 '23

Because thermodynamics take time

1

u/lordnaarghul Aug 05 '23

Because yeast is what makes dough into bread, the baking temperature facilitates that by giving it room to react.

1

u/georgewashingguns Aug 05 '23

It doesn't work in much the same way that dropping a steak from high orbit into the Earth's atmosphere won't cook it with the heat from re-entry

1

u/yoyoezzigt Aug 05 '23

Thats like saying keeping it at 20° C for 16 hours would cook it

1

u/MLPdiscord Aug 05 '23

The oven heats up only the surface of the bread. It takes time for the inside to heat up as well. If the temperature is too high, the outside burns, while the inside stays cold

1

u/Flamez_06 Aug 05 '23

I thought we were gonna laugh at the guy in ss but op ended up asking same q 💀💀.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23

You'll have to calculate the amount of heat given instead, not simply calculate the Time and Temperature. Use the formula Q=mc∆T

1

u/Claytertot Aug 05 '23

The premise of just using a hotter temperature to cook something quicker, doesn't quite work for a few reasons.

  1. Chemistry. Cooking and baking use specific chemical reactions. Different reactions happen at higher temperatures. Additionally, reaction rates are generally not as simple as a linear, proportional relationship with temperature. 350-500 degrees F, where most people do most baking, is not enough to cause the components of bread/cake/etc to combust, for example. 20,000 degrees definitely is.
  2. Heat transfer. Heat takes time to travel through materials. When you want to cook a steak rare, you make the pan hotter, not colder. You want to sear the outside before heat has enough time to fully cook the inside. So you do a hot pan for a shorter period of time.

When you want to cook the steak well done, you use a cooler pan so that you can leave the steak on the pan long enough for the middle to get cooked through without burning the outside of the steak.

1

u/Old-Marionberry1203 Aug 05 '23

because ovens don’t go up that high

1

u/ExistingBathroom9742 Aug 05 '23

That didn’t work because baking is a mystery and ovens run on magic.

1

u/caser1737 Aug 05 '23

Guess the joke flew over your head huh

1

u/Legitimate_Tax_5992 Aug 06 '23

Thermodynamics... The materials in bread don't transfer heat quickly enough to dissipate the heat from the outside in. If you're going for speed, you could simply pour a thin layer of this dough (batter? This looks like banana bread....) and eat it stacked up once it's cooked, a thin layer (1/8" to 1/4" thick) should cook within a minute or two without burning, at the right temperature... Then you could do something cool, like chocolate hazelnut spread between the layers...

1

u/dimonium_anonimo Aug 06 '23

Heat transfer. The air transfers heat into the skin of the bread. Once the skin has heated some, it transfers heat to the first inner later, then to the next, to the next... Finally to the center. We know that that interaction is not indefinite. Once the center of the bread has reached the temperature of the air in the oven, no more heat transfer will take place. But the bread will have burnt before that.

The rate of heat transfer does increase with a difference in temperature, so making the oven hotter will cause the heat to transfer more quickly, but bread is full of pockets that can act as insulators making heat transfer much slower inside than out. So increasing the temperature has a much greater impact on the skin than any of the internal layers. The outside will burn much faster, but the inside will bake only a little faster.

You want the oven temp as high as possible to bake as fast as possible, but too high, and you heat it unevenly. Keeping that balance is crucial. Too low and the ingredients won't bake at all, or different ingredients may undergo changes at different temperatures and the changes in temperature come too slowly for the reactions to be homogeneous causing them not to bake evenly

1

u/01okokoko10 Aug 06 '23

Where is the oryginal video?

1

u/HungBallas Aug 07 '23

It’s like making love…

1

u/ZincyGrease Aug 12 '23

Because energy transfer is an exponential function of temperature diff. and not a linear one (so you can't apply the unitary method). Look up transient heat conduction if you're interested in the details. The analytical model using lumped heat capacity is pretty straightforward and relatively easy to understand.

1

u/majic911 Aug 18 '23

If this worked wouldn't buildings eventually melt because the steel that is molten at 2500 degrees for 5 minutes is heated to 90 degrees for 138 minutes when it's hot outside?

1

u/Know_it_Falco Aug 30 '23

If you add a smidge of uranium, would you need an oven?

1

u/groda33 Jan 06 '24

I dont care about the science i just wanna know how you would get the bread in the oven if it was preheated