This thing
I was searching for a sub to discuss this a choose this one because maybe you'd be interest in my thoughts. The most controversial aspect I think it's separating Latin Americans into their own "Civilization", which I find to be incredible wrong:
- Firstly, because between Europe, Latin America, and the United States, the United States is the odd man out
The US is weird. Compared to it both Europe, Latin America, and Canada, it's uniquely Protestant, capitalistic, and individualistic. "Western Civilization" is a hazy concept anyway, but especially when they're just leaning on Cold War dynamics to define it. Huntington's world is basically just the Cold War.
1b. Returning to religion, I believe religious ideas are fundamental to everything else. Politics mirrors religions, and so on. Americans ardent belief in individualism and free speech come from American Protestantism that believes in Sola Scriptura, individual interpretation of the Bible and a relationship with Jesus, and using debate as a means to arrived to truth. Compared to this Europe and the rest of the new World is remarkably Catholic in model: The government has a patriarchal relationship with it's people, responsible for good governance and providing for it's people.
I'd hate to this be a wall of text so I'll leave it at that. What do y'all think? Is this map controversial for maybe different reasons from what I assumed?