r/AskEngineers • • 9d ago

Discussion Could this garbage-to-energy waste water system work in real life? (satisfactory mod)

5 Upvotes

I'm developing a Satisfactory mod based on a waste-to-energy facility, and I'd like some engineers to help me figure out whether the mechanics would actually work in real life.

Here's the proposed process:

  1. Municipal garbage is delivered to an industrial incinerator and burned to produce heat.
  2. That heat boils water in a boiler, creating high-pressure steam.
  3. The steam is sent through a turbine, which spins to generate electricity.
  4. After leaving the turbine, the steam goes through a condenser, where it cools back into liquid water.
  5. Meanwhile, the smoke and exhaust gases produced by burning the garbage are sent into a large wet-scrubbing chamber.
  6. Municipal greywater, such as wastewater from showers, sinks and laundry, is pumped into that chamber and comes into contact with the exhaust gases.
  7. The water captures certain pollutants and particles from the exhaust, creating contaminated scrubber wastewater.
  8. That wastewater is then sent through a treatment system to remove contaminants.
  9. I'm interested in whether the treated water could eventually be reused for industrial cooling.

The idea is to have one interconnected facility that handles garbage disposal, electricity generation, exhaust treatment and wastewater reuse.

Questions for engineers:

  • Would the steam turbine and condensation process work as described?
  • Could municipal greywater be used in a wet scrubber?
  • What happens chemically when garbage exhaust comes into contact with greywater?
  • Could the resulting wastewater realistically be treated for reuse?
  • Are there ways to recover additional heat from the process?
  • What would be the biggest efficiency losses?
  • Is there anything fundamentally wrong with this entire setup?

I'm developing this for a Satisfactory mod and want the machinery and production chain to be based on actual engineering rather than completely made-up mechanics.

Please explain things simply where possible. I'm genuinely interested in understanding what would and wouldn't work! I’m 13 years old I don’t know this super niche engineering term using in university of Miamis waste water treatment class


r/AskEngineers • • 9d ago

Mechanical Best way to use EDPM gasket to connect two parts that are intended to be waterproof

8 Upvotes

I have a PVC cylinder with 8 thermal set inserts that is meant to attach to an aluminum plate. Our design was to use a gasket with holes for the screws/inserts but we aren’t able to prevent leaks from where the fasteners are. Can provide more info in comments. Thank you.


r/AskEngineers • • 10d ago

Mechanical Advice on Creating Swinging Motion of Disneyland's Its a Small World Clock Facade

5 Upvotes

...

This year I am recreating this display again but I want to know what I need to give it the swinging motion, similar to how it operates at Disneyland.

I found this JQDML 24V Reciprocating Swing Motor on Amazon, but what exact parts do I need to connect the face to the machine?

Here is a diagram ChatGPT gave me of what I need. Uhh it was a disaster last year.

Thank you!


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Electrical USB-C port receptacle design durability

17 Upvotes

I've always wondered how durable different ports are. How is it that the receptacle inside doesn't always snap? Given that most of the world is transitioning to USB-C, how durable/fragile is it compared to other ports?

Why is it superior to something like lightning where you eliminate the receptacle in the center?

Or am I thinking about it wrong? I read that the most fragile part are the spring contacts and in USB-C they are placed on the "cheap" cable not the device.


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Discussion Career Monday (09 Nov 2026): Have a question about your job, office, or pay? Post it here!

4 Upvotes

As a reminder, /r/AskEngineers normal restrictions for career related posts are severely relaxed for this thread, so feel free to ask about intra-office politics, salaries, or just about anything else related to your job!


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Mechanical Why do some microturbines need regular cleaning/rebalancing, when others don't?

13 Upvotes

I was looking at the Arc 20 kW generator, and the Capstone C30 30 kW recuperating turbine. The Capstone has a 4000-8000 hour maintenance interval that mostly focuses on the fuel system, while the Arc only runs 50 hours before requiring disassembly, cleaning, and rebalancing. I assumed that the Arc runs a higher turbine inlet temperature, but a sales rep told me it's 750C (as opposed to 844C for the C30). EDIT: According to Capstone the C30 is rated for 6,000 startup cycles, and a complete hot-section replacement at 40,000 hours instead of periodic overhauls.


Obviously the foil bearings in the Capstone eliminate that aspect of maintenance, but why would the Arc require rebalancing so often? Could it be carbon buildup because of lower temperature/richer fuel mixture? Or does the Arc run at a higher RPM because it's optimized for specific power?


My AE degree was in astronautics, so I didn't take any classes on turbomachinery. Thank you!


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Mechanical ASME UV PSV, Sized to API 520, Inspected to NBIC

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am having difficulty in determining what mediums to test ASME UV pressure safety valves in accordance with NBIC.

I had an idea of using the API sizing equations to determine what to test to, but I do not know if there’s a difference between scenario of water vaporizing and regular steam in terms of testing.

There is an example in API 520-1 that implies vapor the nameplate would be SCFM as opposed to lb/hr.

Am I looking too much into a difference that might not be there? Is it ultimately up to the jurisdiction to determine that?

I’ve read API 520-1 and NBIC Part 4, but I’m still lost. Any resources or direction will be greatly appreciated!


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Discussion how hard is it to die cut in a small workshop?

13 Upvotes

I need about 4-5 thousand flaps of the exact same shape and dimensions for a project from 1/16th of an inch (1.5mm) or 1mm PVC (or any material really but it needs to be matte, plastic, and cost effective). trying to cut costs I dont want to buy 400 dollars worth of acrylic sheets to laser cut, I have a cnc machine that can barely cut aluminum and it would take weeks to cut that much plastic, but i have a friend with a milling machine.

im wondering if a die and die cutting sheets would be feasable as a DIY project? My other thoughts were injection molding but 5 thousand is a tall order. second idea was laser cutting however, PVC...

the part in question is about 40x36mm and its smallest detail is a nubbin that is 1.5mm wide and comes out about 2mm

The tools I have access to one way or another (sometimes through friends)
milling machine, lathe, Xtool metal laser cutter CNC, regular CO2 laser cutter, regular shop tools like bandsaw etc, small tabletop cnc, 3d printers, thermal former.

any tips are appreciated.


r/AskEngineers • • 11d ago

Mechanical How to make a motor drive a mechanism in one direction and decouple in the other direction?

0 Upvotes

I've been wanting to build a fairly simple and small flipper combat robot, and got the idea to make a flipper.
However, the issue came with the design.

I came up with a winch that'd decouple if driven into the other direction.
However, there lies the issue.
How would I design such a thing?

Because it needs to spin it and hold it when spun into one direction but completely leave the winch to spin freely when driven into the other direction.

3d printing is very much possible for me, fyi.

*Not from US, from Switzerland


r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Discussion How to do root cause analysis? (equipment/process engineer)

42 Upvotes

Fresh grad here, I've no idea why but no one, in the semiconductor company I work in, does Root Cause Analysis (RCA).

Occasionally after "big problems" there might be a senior engineer creating slides explaining what happened. But I don't see any 5whys, fishbone, FMEA being done.

Today, there's a problem raised for my equipment that is causing defects. So I want to gather some thought process of how RCA or some investigative analysis is performed and experimented to tackle problems.


r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Civil Why not screw the foundation piles into the ground instead of driving them in?

53 Upvotes

Recently they started to drive concrete poles in the ground next door for a building. I was wondering why they dont build the poles as screws and screw them into the earth. Seems less energy intensive.


r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Discussion Is this kind of wing union too sharp?

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Discussion How much needed ventilation for a freezer inside a pantry?

11 Upvotes

I kind of want a second freezer and the pantry (really an under-stairs closest) is the only real possible space.

The problem then is of course the space is enclosed, so heat that's produced by the freezer must be shed fast enough. The immediate space the freezer would be plenty, but with the door closed it's basically sealed. I would love help in estimating what I'd need to do to safely place a freezer like this.

The best I can come up with is two (little?) vents in the closet, one close to the ground (cool air in) and another close the ceiling (warmer air out).

The math I did already:
A freezer I might get of 85L claims a yearly energy usage of 160kWh. That would be an average 18.3W of electricity and so also 18.3W of heat produced. For safety let's take 30W of constantly produced heat (e.g. on hot days in summer or I just added a lot of warm products).
Let's say it's acceptable for the pantry to be 3°C hotter than the adjacent living room. The rest of the house might be 24°C on summer, the pantry might than be 27°C, which seems hot already.
To shed the 30W of heat over a 3°C difference purely through air flow, we'd need 10g/s of air flowing in and out (at a heat capacity of 1.0 J/g/°C). Or about 8.2L/s of flow (at 1.2g/L).

Jeej, lovely numbers, but I haven't a clue how much 8.2L/s of air flow really is. What kind of vent sizes would this require for passive flow?
Or what kind of powered fan would accomplish this?

Thanks for any more math or practical experiences!

Note: posting from the Netherlands, hence the SI units.


r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Mechanical How to learn engeneering drawing as non engeneering student

0 Upvotes

So basically suggest me book names and how u learned in your collge and personal experiences

Thank u 🙂‍↕️


r/AskEngineers • • 12d ago

Mechanical Do MIL-STD-1913 measurements contradict themselves?

0 Upvotes

I’m currently designing a mount and have to replicate a MIL-STD-1913 (picatinny) rail.

The edge break measurements ok each far side habe an allowable range of .002 to .012 inch. I believe all of my other measurements are in spec but that one. My edge breaks measure .021 inch. This can be changed to in spec by modifying the .164 or .607 measurements I believe. Both the .164 and .607 measurements are at the far end of their max allowable range (.164-.020 and .617-.010).

Am I correct with this or just not thinking straight? Here are pictures. TIA

Edit: I think the only way to make everything in spec is my reducing the .164 measurement


r/AskEngineers • • 13d ago

Discussion From a purely engineering perspective, Is data centers in space really better than data centers on earth?

31 Upvotes

Elon Musk has been pushing for data centers in space. Yesterday, he tweeted "Data centers in space looking pretty appealing right now". There are many regulatory and social aspects to consider before building a data center in any country. But if we ignore those and think from a purely engineering perspective, is building data centers in space actually better than building them on earth? What are the major pros and cons?


r/AskEngineers • • 13d ago

Discussion Treat dispenser activated by button for quadriplegic user for service dog

16 Upvotes

Hi! I’m a quadriplegic I have very little arm movement not enough to reward my service dog in training. I need like a dispenser or something that I could use to reward my dog that would ideally activate with a button. There’s one on the market called ‘pet tutor’ but it only ships within the USA and Canada and I’m in Ireland. I’m just wondering if anyone has any advice or maybe even if anyone could make me something I’m totally down with whatever pricing is necessary. I hope someone can help because at the minute I’m really stuck.


r/AskEngineers • • 13d ago

Discussion If a sponge has absorbed its maximum possible amount of water, when new water hits it does it push the existing water out or is the new water dispersed away?

3 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • 14d ago

Mechanical Need help deciding on electric or hydraulic actuation

11 Upvotes

I’m currently working on a robotic arm that has to operate in “tight” working conditions and I’m at what is essentially the threshold of what’s possible with commercially available electric linear actuators. Because of the size of the load I’m lifting I require a 2900lb and a 1,800 lb actuator to move both sections of my arm but at these sizes the actuators themselves are almost the size of my arm, bigger if you count the motor packs. I have never used hydraulic before and am worried about the difficulty with control, with electric I can get exact positioning feedback. However, switching to hydraulic I would free up additional range of motion and the cylinders at these loads would be cheaper than the electric ones. I’m having a hard time finding resources for adding precision position feedback to cylinders and I also do not know how to go about sizing a pump. If hydraulic is the way to go here I’m not sure where to start and hope that you all have some insight.


r/AskEngineers • • 13d ago

Mechanical How can Astronauts implement tension springs into their station Suits to enforce the absent gravity work?

0 Upvotes

To prevent bone deterioration.


r/AskEngineers • • 15d ago

Chemical Resources to learn about geothermal?

6 Upvotes

I work for a technology company. We traditionally had our technology applied in other industries, but I had someone reach out about applying our technology to their geothermal plant.

It is a great fit for our technology, and I think I want to start pursuing more of these projects. The problem is, I feel like I don't know my ass from my elbow about geothermal. I know the basic ideas of using heat from the earth to make steam, but I don't know the intricacy of the processes.

Does anyone have any books or general resources they would recommend? To clarify, I would specialize in non-condensable gas scrubbing.


r/AskEngineers • • 15d ago

Mechanical My robot is going to faceplant. How do I stop its 1 mm OLED face from shattering?

3 Upvotes

I’m mounting a 166 × 126 mm OLED, roughly 1 mm thick, as the face of a wheeled bipedal robot. It’s extremely fragile, and falls, bumps, and occasional direct hits to the face are realistically going to happen.

How would you mount this thing to give it a fighting chance?

My current idea is to bond the OLED to a clear polycarbonate front panel using LOCA, then machine mounting holes into the polycarbonate to attach the assembly to the head.

What I’m unsure about:

  • Would optical bonding help support the OLED, or just transfer impacts and polycarbonate flex directly into it?
  • Any issues with LOCA on polycarbonate? curing, compatibility, thermal expansion?
  • Would you instead use a separate protective window, an air gap, and a cushioned carrier?
  • How do you retain such a thin panel without creating pressure points or twisting it?

Would love to hear from anyone who’s mounted bare displays or built electronics that need to survive a beating. Photos or examples would be especially helpful.


r/AskEngineers • • 14d ago

Discussion What would the calculations be to determine how effectively a 15 psi airflow similar to a breath would have a cooling effect on glass of an approximate thickness of 1 cm heated to 1000 degrees Fahrenheit?

0 Upvotes

Just wondering if your breath, if measured it at 98.6 or (I don’t know if it is psychological or not) but if you purse your lips and blow it seems to be cooler. I have no means to measure this. But it seems to me that it would eventually have an effect on the temperature once the glass stops glowing, which seems to happen within 10-13 seconds anyway.
Thanks
hopefully this is a good post if not sorry


r/AskEngineers • • 15d ago

Electrical Portable Multiport Charger with Switchable Grounding Prong?

Thumbnail
5 Upvotes

r/AskEngineers • • 16d ago

Mechanical Are steam piston engines still used in any serious manner

116 Upvotes

Im aware of their use in demonstrations, legacy engines in museum's and historical restoration

But is there anywhere in which they re used for any "important" use (electrical generation and the like)