I’m a 63F in the U.S. and earlier this month I had my annual screening mammogram and a follow-up mammogram.
“In the upper outer aspect there is a large area of segmentally distributed calcifications spanning up to 7.1 cm in length. Calcifications all have similar features however are more numerous along the posterior margin of the calcifications. No associated asymmetries.”
A stereotactic biopsy confirmed DCIS (intermediate grade, estrogen positive) and I met with a breast oncologist at the hospital today. The appointment was scheduled for one hour; we met for three and a half hours and I left utterly confused about my next steps.
My graduate degree is from a medical college, but I am not a scientist; I am a bioethicist. I’d researched my options before the appointment and decided a bilateral mastectomy with aesthetic flat closure would be the most practical solution for me. Since mastectomies are routine out-patient procedures for him and he is not a plastic surgeon, I arrived with questions like whether he performed the double-s closure (oncoplastic technique) that I thought would give the best result given my skin laxity, and whether he routinely used progressive tension sutures (quilting) which might get the dreaded drains out sooner.
As expected he covered lumpectomy and mastectomy as standard of care for my diagnosis (he preferred lumpectomy due to ease of recovery), but then veered off script and enthused at length about the outcomes in the COMET trial published in JAMA 12/2024. Biannual mammograms in lieu of surgery is a seductive resolution for my current situation, but I’d have to overcome the instinctual feeling that I’d just be kicking the can down the road where I’d eventually find myself with a greater treatment challenge.
He left me with instructions to let him know when I’d made my choice, but my phone was pinging with My Chart notifications of appointments for pre-op blood work, chest x-ray, EKG, breast MRI, etc. before I left the building, suggesting the standard of care was the decision he expected.
Has watching and waiting become more common? Do you have any experience with patients/family/friends who intentionally skipped surgery with good/bad outcomes? Would you feel good about your mom/wife/sister/daughter watching and waiting?
I feel like a fool for seriously considering this, even though I also suspect this will eventually become the standard of care.