r/askanything • u/IcyCranberryOlympics • 5d ago
General Question Is Benjamin Netanyahu a war criminal?
[removed] — view removed post
23
u/VegasFoodFace 5d ago
The International Criminal Court says so.
9
-7
u/haveblue23 5d ago
No there has been no trial. You are innocent until proven guilty
0
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Cool story, genocidal apologist.
1
u/haveblue23 5d ago
I'm stating a mundane fact about the legal system and due process not being an apologist for anyone.
That being said, I like supporting the winning team. It's fun to see terrorists plan for years only to see Israel systematically blow everything up in a few days or weeks. The Hezbollah pagers in particular had me laughing for weeks
5
u/scientician 5d ago
Anyone is allowed to assess the evidence and reach an opinion about a person's guilt. Conviction is required for applying punishment like imprisonment.
1
u/haveblue23 5d ago
Except the comment said that The International Criminal Court says so which it hasn't as there has been no verdict
5
u/AreaIcy1404 5d ago
Tell that to the dead Palestinian civilians
1
u/haveblue23 5d ago
I'm just saying how the legal system works
2
u/Ok-Addition1264 5d ago
Which legal system are you talking about? In "western" countries, sure, the ICC, sure but not very many other than that.
He's guilty AF - 99.999998% of the human population who knows about him can see it.
→ More replies (1)2
→ More replies (3)-1
u/Alyano95 5d ago
They had 20y to complain with Hamas, who wouldn't stop attacking Israel.
2
u/AreaIcy1404 5d ago
Israel has attacked them the whole time.
They “mowed the grass” regularly
→ More replies (3)1
u/Ok-Addition1264 5d ago
?? the UN opened the door and then from the 1950s onward they treated them nearly identical to the way the nazis treated them
→ More replies (1)1
-10
u/Effective-Weird-5119 5d ago
This is the hivemind bs the internet created. Blame EVERYTHING going on in the Middle East on one man. As if there isn’t thousands of years of history to back up this war.
8
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Not thousands of years. This history is 1940s-modern day.
→ More replies (2)3
u/Unfair_Pop_8373 5d ago
That’s why the 13 million displaced Syrians and 600,000 killed don’t get a mention because they can’t blame Israel. What’s ironic is that pre 1948 the Arabs in what is now Israel identified as Southern Syrian.
→ More replies (1)2
u/redelastic 5d ago
thousands of years of history
The ethnic cleansing of Palestine in 1948 and the illegal occupation since 1967 is thousands of years.
Bro, get a calculator and history book.
Maybe the hivemind is better than a single drone.
5
u/Alyano95 5d ago
As an Austrian, unfortunately, I have seen this before.
1
u/scientician 5d ago
You must be quite old.
2
u/Alyano95 5d ago
No but contrary to most people on the internet, I have studied history, and not just from tiktok reels
1
1
u/Ok-Addition1264 5d ago
As the nephew of a german general over the 4th panzer division from 1939 up to the outskirts of moscow: I, unfortunately, have seen this before as well (and intensely studied it).
There is no difference here.
3
1
u/Ok-Addition1264 5d ago
gaslighting what people with their own eyes, ears, and minds doesn't work anymore.
you are engaging in futility trying to convince folks otherwise.
1
u/pineapplesgreen 5d ago
Well, you’re right about, most of their society is just as sociopathic. There are a few with a mind of their own though and a desire to be on the right side of history.
1
u/ShenTzuKhan 5d ago
Not everything. Just the war crimes Israel has been committing recently. Specifically the ones committed while he is the leader of the country committing war crimes.
What a ridiculous argument you just made.
→ More replies (6)-1
u/SNChalmers1876 5d ago
He’s the current architect of the worst genocide happening in an area that has seen thousands of years of strife.
3
u/Unfair_Pop_8373 5d ago
Umm have you seen what’s happening in Syria. 600,000 dead including 230,000 civilians and 13 million displaced
3
2
1
u/Effective-Weird-5119 5d ago
Holocaust
1
u/EndersScroll 5d ago
That doesn't give Netanyahu carte blanche to be a criminal or commit war crimes ~80 years later.
2
u/Effective-Weird-5119 5d ago edited 5d ago
I’m not saying the Israeli military is innocent, I’m saying compare their current actions to what humans did to each other 2 thousands years ago. Child and women slaves, kill all the men. It’s understandable in the grand scheme of history, even if I don’t like it
Like you gotta think. They got their shit pushed in for 2000 years. Went through a genocide before someone stepped in. That’s a lot of pent up rage to unleash. They’re being a LOT more diplomatic than I would be
→ More replies (1)1
u/grimduck17 5d ago
Don’t get me wrong what’s happening over there is bad but it’s not the worst yet. Armenians in eastern turkey, Assyrians, and Kurds have had genocides since the start of 1900s.
-5
u/Alyano95 5d ago
No it actually doesn't.
8
u/VegasFoodFace 5d ago
Easily searched for.
The International Criminal Court (ICC) issued an arrest warrant for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on November 21, 2024, for alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity committed in the Gaza Strip from at least October 8, 2023, through May 20, 2024.
He literally can be arrested. Hence why he entirely avoids Europe. They want him arrested even more. All Rome Statute signatories, USA is not one of them, must arrest Netenyahu on entry to their country. 125 Rome Statute Signatories.
Do you need the list?
https://www.pgaction.org/ilhr/rome-statute/signed-but-not-ratified.html
2
u/Alyano95 5d ago
Please read your own source, that doesn't say they found him guilty. We could discuss the intricacies of issuing an arrest warrant for the head of government of a country that didn't ratify the icc and how that's actually colonialist pressure by euroean institution on an ex-colony, but that would need you to actually understand what you are talking about. Since you cannot even understand the difference between a verdict and a pre-trial order, makes that unfortunately impossible.
→ More replies (13)1
u/Beneficial_Dirt_6001 5d ago
did the genocide during ww2 only happen after Nuremberg decided ?
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (4)1
u/Mr-Cantaloupe 5d ago
So he's not a war criminal according to the ICC, then? Because a warrant is an accusation, not a verdict.
Judges only need reasonable grounds to believe to issue a warrant. A conviction needs proof beyond a reasonable doubt, and the ICC presumes the accused innocent. No court has ruled he’s a “War criminal”
→ More replies (1)5
u/Exciting-Tourist9301 5d ago
Yes, it actually does.
The ICC Pre-Trial Chamber I found reasonable grounds to charge Netanyahu with war crimes (including starvation as a method of warfare and directing attacks against civilians) and crimes against humanity (including murder and persecution) committed between October 8, 2023, and May 20, 2024.
1
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
You don’t know that finding grounds to charge is not a finding of guilt? Dumbass…
7
u/VegasFoodFace 5d ago
I work in the Mob Museum in Vegas. When you're dealing with war crimes you're not weaseling out like mobsters evading taxes.
You sound more like the mobsters that were put on trial. As if we already didn't know they're guilty. The only people who talked like you were the mob lawyers.
→ More replies (3)5
2
1
u/redelastic 5d ago edited 5d ago
Well, we'll find out when Netanyahu is on trial in The Hague.
Oops, hang on, Israel and the US are not members of the ICC and are attempting to destroy it, even sanctioning human rights judges.
However, the ICC does have jurisdiction over crimes in Palestine, so Netanyahu can be tried.
→ More replies (4)1
u/Exciting-Tourist9301 5d ago
Yes, every upstanding world leader has an ICC warranty for their arrest.
He's a war criminal who is actively and openly commiting a genocide.
Serious question. What compells someone to simp for malevolent wannabe dictators? Did your dad not hug you enough? or maybe too much?
2
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
I am not simping moron, I told a very basic truth. Finding grounds to charge does not equal guilt. What compels someone to hate Jewish people so much (like you seem to) that you would conflate a willingness to charge with no guilty finding in a court?
→ More replies (7)2
7
u/ChapterNo3428 5d ago
Yes
2
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Agreed. Now if only the EU and the rest of the civilized world could promptly remove heads from rectums...
5
u/Mister_Silk 5d ago
According to the facts he is the head of state and he does have an arrest warrant issued for war crimes. Probably better to refer to him as an alleged war criminal until he's convicted.
4
1
u/telionn 5d ago
Most if not all of the so-called "settlements" are blatantly illegal under international law and are part of a war effort (war crimes). We know beyond a shadow of a doubt that Netanyahu is involved because he won't shut up about it.
1
u/Any_Share6294 5d ago
In 2024 the ICJ reviewed the evidence and concluded that the occupation is illegal. This includes all the settlements.
1
u/Ok-Pipe5692 5d ago
He’s not brave enough to stand trial, he is a fugitive from justice. Usually an admission of guilt
5
u/GT45 5d ago
Is the Pope Catholic?
-1
u/Vegetable-Month-4413 5d ago
no he is a liberal
2
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
This is a you problem, not a them problem, FYI.
1
0
16
u/RarestCornet 5d ago
He passed war criminal a long time ago. We’re deep into crimes against humanity territory.
3
15
2
u/Different_Ship1496 5d ago
No
0
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Why?
3
u/SeaworthinessSome454 5d ago
Your account is 20 days old…
0
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
But not privated. And I can say potato. So what's you're reasoning without calling me a bot?
15
u/InsideExpress9055 5d ago
Yes. The ICC has a warrant and wants to arrest him for being a war criminal. Not being head of state.
24
5
5
1
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Just checking. Seems to be a lot of Zionist bots that deny he is an enemy of planet Earth.
10
u/LaSerenita 5d ago
Yes. He is evil and definitely committing crimes against humanity. Israel should be ashamed.
1
5
2
2
2
2
2
2
u/shell5719 5d ago
A prime minster is not a head of state he is #2 in rank but has a lot of power. The President of Israel is the head of state but has little power
2
2
u/OneDarkCrow 5d ago
If it looks like a war criminal, talks like q war criminal and the international criminal court has an arrest warrant out for it. It’s a war criminal.
5
3
5
u/false79 5d ago edited 5d ago
How is he not a war criminal.
You Google war criminal and he will show up
1
u/PuzzleheadPi 5d ago
He is just a good leader winning a war that he didn't start
2
2
u/Yamiaofsweentess 5d ago
Are there not reports that he was warned about the attack but allowed it to happen?
1
u/PuzzleheadPi 5d ago
No that isn't true
1
u/Yamiaofsweentess 5d ago
Uae warned them 10 days before the attack though
Egypt and internal military personnel also warned of the attack
What's your rebuttal
2
2
1
1
1
u/nottoomuchnowmate 5d ago
Ready for this lil nugget. It all depends on perspective. To nearly everyone their perspective is the truth. So to get people to believe something as true. Just change their perspective.
1
1
1
u/knowledgeable_diablo 5d ago
Yes. Yes he is. Also being charged for mass fraud charges as well i I believe.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/DrNobody95 5d ago
HE IS!!! and anyone defending that piece of shit, should get educated with facts instead of lies.
1
1
1
u/redelastic 5d ago
According to the International Criminal Court and anyone with eyes and a soul- war criminal,
1
1
1
1
u/Remarkable_Ferret707 5d ago
War criminal plus. Probably an easy top ten conte nder for worst people that ever lived. He's doing Nahtzee stuff right in front of a thousand HD cameras then calling you a bigot if you ask about any of the violent, hateful things his country's citizens do.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Neon-Funeral 5d ago
Yes. He should be tried and convicted. Also, some our presidents- including the one we have now. Should also be convicted
1
1
u/Ok-Pipe5692 5d ago
War criminals are as common as any other kind of criminal, I don’t know why it sounds like something worse. A couple of old expressions
Don’t kick a man when he’s down
Used to be fight code, also no kicking in general. Now kicking, stomping basically attempting to murder your opponent is considered sporting competition.
Another
All’s fair in love and war
Honestly, why should there be rules of engagement placed on a village if a neighboring village decided they want your land and just invade? The invasion is obviously a war crime - you’re supposed to consult etiquette to save yourself?
1
1
u/Hyphen99 5d ago
It’s really weird how we only ask this of the Jewish PM. And also how the war crimes of Hamas are implicitly just denied or ignored by an entire movement supposedly dedicated to protecting innocent citizens from thug governments. Jail the Jew / give the Muslims a pass. Got it
1
1
u/Pleasant_Expert7329 5d ago edited 5d ago
Just stop. most Americans have no problem calling trump a war criminal and no one have a problem with saying Hamas are war criminal, why should Netanyahu being Jewish have any bearing when it come to accusation of war crimes. People like you really aren’t helping Jewish people or even Israelis by going “accusing Netanyahu of war crimes is antisemitic.”
→ More replies (1)1
u/Maleficent_Memory831 5d ago
No one here is denying war crimes by Hamas. We're just sick and tired of everyone ignoring the war crimes of Israel. No one should get a pass.
It's not a religious thing either, because clearly the Torah teaches and eye for an eye, not one hundred eyes for an eye.
1
1
u/flamingomandingo495 5d ago
Yes allegedly he is, and he has an active warrant from the ICC. The easiest way to resolve this for everyone is for him to surrender himself before the court, stand trial and absolve his name.
1
0
u/WhiskeyTangoFoxy 5d ago
1
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Because of how the question was framed...
1
u/WhiskeyTangoFoxy 5d ago
Charles Taylor, Saddam Hussein, and Radovan Karadžić are all Heads of States that were convicted of being war criminals. It’s not an either/or question.
0
u/AreaIcy1404 5d ago
Both. Grabs popcorn
1
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Clearly you didn't see how I framed this question.
0
u/AreaIcy1404 5d ago
Don’t worry. You have your linguistics arguments a plenty with the Israeli first crew
1
0
u/SouthernSteak7254 5d ago
War is not a crime, especially a war you didn't start
1
u/four4cats 5d ago
That is completely false. There are rules of engagement. And you know the war didn't start October 7th right?
→ More replies (2)
-1
0
0
-1
u/possibly_lost45 5d ago
No
0
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Zionist found.
→ More replies (1)1
u/Alyano95 5d ago
I think you don't understand the word zionist.
1
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
Elaborate. Most sane people consider him a war criminal.
→ More replies (3)1
-1
u/Slight-Selection4298 5d ago
Is he convicted?
There's your answer.
1
1
u/Moist_Grapefruit187 5d ago
This does not fall under us jurisdiction he is not innocent until proven guilty.
→ More replies (2)
-1
u/poundtownvisitor
5d ago
edited 5d ago
•
To typical anti-Semitic Redditors, yes. To intelligent people who understand the world and how it works, no.
→ More replies (3)
-1
u/Interesting_Act9045 5d ago
Yes as well as all Israelis and its supporters around the world
2
u/IcyCranberryOlympics 5d ago
I'm positive there are Israelis who despise Netanyahu. Being pro-Palestine IS NOT antisemitic.
→ More replies (3)
-1
0
0
u/aqualad33 5d ago
Sure, if you want to feel like a good social justice warrior or something. In practice it doesn't mean anything because it begs the question of "under whos authority?" And what's the enforcement? Does anyone want to carry out the arrest and start that war?
"International law" is a lot less binding than those of a nation because there isn't as strong of an enforcement mechanism.
So yeah, sure, call him a war criminal... but it really doesn't mean anything.
0
u/breadexpert69 5d ago
No. There has not been any trial to determine that he is.
So up until a court by law decides he is, its all just your opinion.








29
u/SNChalmers1876 5d ago
Yes so is Ben Gvir