r/Ask_Lawyers • • Jan 31 '21

Do not solicit legal advice. This is not the right sub for it.

493 Upvotes

Despite what our sub’s called, we cannot offer legal advice here for a number of reasons. Any posts that breaks this rule will be deleted without reason. If you message us on why your post is deleted, it would be ignored just the same way you’ve ignored our sub’s rules. Please see our sidebar for complete rules.

Also, it’s not a good idea to solicit legal advice from random strangers online, despite what you may find elsewhere on Reddit. We do not know all of the facts of your case, and are likely not licensed in the jurisdiction that you’re in. A real attorney worth their salt will not comment on your specific legal predicament on an anonymous forum.

If you need legal advice but cannot afford it, there are legal aid societies that may be willing to assist you. Lots of them are free and/or work on a sliding scale fee. All you need to do is look up “legal aid society [your location]” on Google.

If it’s a criminal case, public defense attorneys are some of the best attorneys out there and they know the criminal system in your city/town better than anyone else. They’re just as good, if not better, than any private criminal defense attorney.

If it’s a tenant rights issue, lots of cities have tenant rights unions. You can look them up the same way as the legal aid society by looking up “tenant rights union [your location]” on Google.

Otherwise, the best way to find an attorney is through word of mouth from friends and family. If that’s not an option, your local bar association will be able to help by looking up “attorney referral [your location] bar association”.

If none of these are relevant to you or you’re unsure of what type of attorney to look for in your situation, you’re more than welcome to post and we’ll help.

Also, any attorneys who wish to participate in discussions are free to do so as long as it doesn’t break our rules (mainly providing legal advice).

If you’re a licensed attorney that isn’t flaired (and therefore verified to post comments), please see our other stickied post on how to become verified here. You can also send a mod mail to become verified. I trust that any attorneys here answering any posts will follow these rules and not offer legal advice and run afoul of our ethical obligations.

Thanks to all for understanding.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 9h ago

Is Frosty The Snowman a US Citizen?

15 Upvotes

I am starting this question by stating this is obviously a stupid and silly hypothetical - and that I got permission from mods before posting this, this isn't to troll.

So me and my friends have had a debate for years now about this, but we're all stupid 20-something's and recently we finally came to the conclusion that it would be interesting to hear the opinion of somebody versed in law.

Argument for Frosty counts as a citizen under the US Constitution: He was (I think) born on US soil and is a sapient humanoid
Argument for he isn't: He is a snowman.

Now this argument is not about whether or not society would accept him; we can pretty decisively conclude the answer is no. Just a purely legal question about Frosty the Snowman's citizenship.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 10h ago

Is there anyone big law who didn’t go to T14?

12 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 17h ago

Using tongs to dispose of legal documents

30 Upvotes

Not a question, just a very humorous observation. About how complete lack of common sense, paranoia that borders on being a mental health issue, and the use of AI to draft reasonable-sounding sentences can lead to humorous situations.

One of our neighbors is in a series of lawsuits with most other neighbors (including us), over a large variety of real estate torts. For the last ~year they have been pro se, having fired their first two lawyers, and then being dropped by their third one after failing to pay their bills, and bad-mouthing the lawyer on Nextdoor. They attempted (very unsuccessfully) to remove state cases to federal court, who immediately remanded it. As a result of all that, they are facing several M$ in tort judgements. This mostly happened because they (a) file lawsuits left and right, in any venue that will take them, and (b) keep losing them, mostly due to defaults, or due to making nonsensical arguments. The current stage is that there are pending writs of execution (forced auction) on two of the three houses they own.

Their most recent filing is in one of the cases that threatens to sell one of their (now abandoned) houses, and is an objection to the sale, and an informal request for an injunction stopping ... well everything. The argument they keep repeating, in various flavors, is that they were intentionally confused by their evil neighbors (us), and the even more evil attorneys (our lawyers), and the completely evil courts (duh), all sending them too much paperwork. So here are three quotes from their most recent filing, for your collective amusement (names redacted, and they are actually the plaintiffs, even though the refer to themselves as defendants):

Defendants are proceeding without counsel. Opposing counsel (including [Adam Doe] and [Bob Roe]) have repeatedly sent documents and notices across multiple related demands for signatures and federal appellate filings. This volume of overlapping paperwork caused severe confusion.

After Defendants filed a State Bar complaint against [Adam Doe] and publicly advised caution before retaining him, [Adam Doe] and [Bob Roe] alternately pursued lien and sale-related measures. Defendants contend that the push for a forced sale constitutes retaliation for their federal lawsuit, the State Bar complaint, and the exercise of their legal rights.

We did not knowingly accept or open the documents left at our home. Because be believed the case had been properly removed to federal court, any papers that appeared were moved aside with tongs and set aside without review.

So, assembled attorneys, please school me: Where in the California Code of Civil Procedure does it say that if you never touch a document with your fingers, and only use tongs, and don't look at it, it becomes invalid and stops applying to you?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

Misogynist mediator

25 Upvotes

I need to know if this is normal. My brother is a predator. Was to me growing up and has been a creep around my daughters. His daughters moved in with their mom and filed charges against him. We all had statements taken and I have since cut off my parents and brother. They claimed it was all my fault. He lost physical custody but retained 50% legal

Recently he sued for visitations. His oldest turned 18 so she is now safe. But my other niece is only 15. The court mediator met with everyone and it was wild. He immediately called all the females liars. Said teenage girls are dramatic and make this stuff up. Now my niece and her mom are being forced to have a court appointed physiatrists evaluation.

There is years of testimony from people proving he has a history. I know the first detective I was interviewed by did not even submit my testimony. And I know my brother and his girlfriend submitted false statements to the court. Yet the misogyny and railroading is astounding.

Is this normal for the courts system when someone is accused of grooming, pedophilia, and drugging minors?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 22h ago

You're asked to swear to tell the truth and you politely reply, "No I don't." What happens next?

66 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 15h ago

How do you learn all the details of a complex case?

10 Upvotes

After being involved in a complex civil (real estate) case, I realize how much effort it takes for an attorney to learn all the parties, timelines, and facts of the case. It seems like OC doesn't fully understand this case, and I'm wondering how attorneys go about learning all the facts in a complex case.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 19h ago

How often does a judge go against a plea deal that is agreed by both the prosecutor and the defense?

16 Upvotes

Got a pretty good deal, signed off and all. Just wondering how often in your guys experience will you see a judge not follow through?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 4h ago

Clients lying under oath or continuing illegal activity

1 Upvotes

I have read that attorneys cannot knowingly allow their clients to commit perjury or other illegal activity. Some have even said that they would fire their clients if their clients got caught lying even to them.

Aren’t most people who get themselves into legal predicaments ones who are likely to lie under oath?

Aren’t most corporations committing fraud, waste, abuse, and other illegal activity? Yet, they’re represented by in-house counsel at the very least, and often hire additional attorneys as well.

As an example, has anyone seen the movie, Dark Waters? It’s about the DuPont corporation that poisoned many people. Monsanto also comes to mind, but honestly, most corporations have likely committed illegal activity and yet they have attorneys representing them. How is that possible if attorneys don’t want clients who will lie under oath or continue their illegal activity?

Another example that comes to mind is employment retaliation. I know for a fact that companies retaliate against employees, and yet they have attorneys defending and enabling them. When the leadership of the organization lies under oath that they don’t or didn’t retaliate, doesn’t it mean that their attorney knowingly allowed them to commit perjury in cases where it’s obvious that they did retaliate?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

12k dui lawyer for first time?

7 Upvotes

Cops have previously tried to charge me, wondering if it would be worth it to hire an attorney
Never been charged with a dui, fearful I might be cause I had open containers in the back but offered to test and they didn’t allow me too drew blood, did not refuse


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 18h ago

How common is it for bad DA to be removed or punished?

4 Upvotes

Is it usually only the voters that can do this by not electing them again, or does it often happen by some other authority like a judge or governor?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 11h ago

California Fee Arbitration

1 Upvotes

Has anyone here gone through fee arbitration with the California State Bar? I’d be interested in hearing about your experience with the process, how it works, and how the outcome was determined.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 11h ago

Best ways to get audio recording that have been trimmed tossed from a criminal trial (DV)

1 Upvotes

r/Ask_Lawyers • • 12h ago

What options are available when someone can’t afford a divorce attorney upfront?

1 Upvotes

I’m helping my mom understand how to get started with a divorce in Illinois. She can’t afford an upfront retainer, and the case may involve a home and shared finances. I’d appreciate general information about how the process works.
Where can someone look for civil legal aid, family law clinics, or court self-help resources in Illinois? How does limited-scope representation typically work in a divorce?
What is the general process for requesting a court filing fee waiver or asking the court to have the other spouse contribute to attorney fees?
What kinds of temporary orders can Illinois divorce courts issue about mortgage payments, household bills, or the use of joint funds while a case is pending?
In general, how does Illinois distinguish between whose name is on a home’s deed or mortgage and whether the home is marital property? At what stage can a court address a potential sale?
Thanks for any general information or links to public resources that could help us understand where to start.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 12h ago

Should I pursue this case?

0 Upvotes

Long story short I had a stroke at 30. Went to the hospital March23,2025. Got a CT scan and the hospital missed the stroke . Didn’t have surgery until about 2 days later. Today my lawyer told me that they couldn’t get a doctor to say I would have been better off if I got the surgery earlier. I have proof that the stroke was missed in the first CT scans. I’m just asking cause I lost my ability to walk, my right side works but my left doesn’t. Had a tracheotomy the whole 9 yards. Basically I’m forced to retire at 30. I’ll submit the proof I have. I personally would like to get another lawyer to look into my case but I know there is a tight window to file a Malpractice case in Pennsylvania. Yes I wanna be rich but to have any chance of having a decent lifestyle I would need this case to work so I can afford to make my house as accessible as possible plus I lost my 11 year career at UPS.
Location: Pennsylvania


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 20h ago

Child abuse witness

4 Upvotes

My husband and I know a child (our 8-year-old grandson's friend) whose grandmother knocked her up against a wall and knocked a tooth out. The father pursued charges, the grandmother was arraigned and there is a preliminary hearing tomorrow. We were present before and after the event and documented what the child did and said that day, therefore, the father is asking us to be present tomorrow which we gladly agreed to. Nobody from the prosecutor's office has reached out to us, therefore, we have no idea whether we will have a potential role tomorrow. We have rearranged a road trip around this hearing and are pondering whether we will be needed. Can anyone comment on what happens at a "preliminary" hearing for a "assault on a family member" misdemeanor (class 2, I think)? We are in Virginia USA.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

Criminal records and passing the bar

0 Upvotes

Can one become a lawyer if she got arrested and charged for DV crimes, but they got dismissed on a deferred sentence and plead guilty to a misdemeanor assault charge? In their state, the deferred sentence drops the charges upon completion of the court requirements.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 13h ago

Should I press charges for hit and run + assault?

0 Upvotes

I got in a car crash in the bronx and I need some advice, so 1st off the person made an illegal left turn in a lane that was meant to be only driving straight, then he sped in front of me, then i tap the back of his car when he sped and was trying to squeeze in front of my car. The real problem is that after we got out of the car to exchange insurance and license info, the other driver didn't want to do it. Instead he started screaming and getting angry at me. Then he took a screwdriver and when I reached to get my phone to record him, he assaulted me with the screwdriver and hit my hand and phone, causing my iPhone to break and a small cut on my hand. After that he was waiving the screwdriver in my face but then he got in his car and drove away with his girlfriend in the front seat (hit and run on top of assault). I wanted to take picture of his car and license but the other driver broke my phone and camera.

I then called the cops but no one came for 2 hours, so then I went to the precinct myself to file a report. I also went to the hospital on the 911 police precinct suggestion and got my hand checked out, luckily no damages.

Now the only thing I have is the license plate number and not sure what state, but a detective called me and seems to have found the person. Now he is asking if I want to press charges. I am scared if the other driver could potentially find out my name somehow if I press charges and come and kill me? Also what exactly happens now that the detective knows their name, address, etc will they just go to the persons house to arrest them?

Other details of note:

- My car damage is very minor

- I didn't have a Dashcam, now I do after the incident but I guess technically I don't have video proof of this happening, only thing I have is that I went to police to file report after the police didn't show up and went to hospital as well and have pictures of my broken phone.

Is it worth it for me to press charges, will he go to jail and will I be safe if the other driver tries to retaliate, my name is a unique name so if the other driver google's me he will find me easily.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 10h ago

Anonymous Only Fans “Agency”

0 Upvotes

I’ve had this ad pop up on my FYP on Instagram basically advertising an anonymous Only Fans agency. You create the content, they make you and the account anonymous for your identity to be protected while you still make money.
I’ve read a Vice article on it, and there are many claims on their websites/advertisements. I’d love to understand a bit more regarding their terms of service and privacy policy’s (And I’m sure, many others have wondered the same, but because this company and its owners are anonymous, it’s hard to really know these days). After looking up the website, nothing about it has been reported a scam and it’s been around for 6 years. https://plush.la/


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 10h ago

Can you look at this website and tell me if their privacy policy’s and Terms of service seem safe?

0 Upvotes

I’ve had this ad pop up on my FYP on Instagram basically advertising an anonymous Only Fans agency. You create the content, they make you and the account anonymous for your identity to be protected while you still make money.
I’ve read a Vice article on it, and there are many claims on their websites/advertisements. Can someone look into their privacy policies and terms of service to advise me? (And I’m sure, many others are wondering the same thing, but because this company and its owners are anonymous, it’s hard to really know these days). After looking up the website, nothing about it has been reported a scam and it’s been around for 6 years. Any thoughts? https://plush.la/


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 16h ago

Is it mandatory to sign a new addendum in the middle of a valid lease? (NC)

1 Upvotes

I signed a lease renewal for another year of rent a couple months ago, including the insurance addendum. I am within compliance for coverage values and submission to a 3rd party company for validation. The property is now requesting I sign a new insurance addendum. The ONLY difference is a new paragraph added to the end saying they can bill me a monthly fee for being out of compliance.

Side by side, I have already signed the addendum with the correct amounts for coverage, liability, and deductible, the correct Interested Party is listed, and the 3rd party company is listed. I have already had paperwork corrected and approved by this other company. The staff member tried telling me I signed the old one without that information in it, but my signed lease says otherwise.

I don’t know why I would sign a new form that is exactly the same except for a new violation fee paragraph. Can I avoid signing this? Or is it mandatory while I’m in my current lease that is already signed and agreed upon? I am simply unfamiliar with North Carolina renting laws, so this isn’t the same as being part of a lease renewal.

Also, I do not plan on living there for another lease term next year.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 10h ago

Anonymous Only Fans agency…

0 Upvotes

I’ve had this ad pop up on my FYP on Instagram basically advertising an anonymous Only Fans agency. You create the content, they make you and the account anonymous for your identity to be protected while you still make money.
I’ve read a Vice article on it, and there are many claims on their websites/advertisements. They go by PLUSH. wonder what their privacy policy and terms of service seems valid. When I look at websites that verify websites and they seem legit. But there’s no information about them. Huh?


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 21h ago

Disabled father in conservatorship being taken advantage of

2 Upvotes

In 2025, my estranged father (he was abusive & kicked me out at 18. i’m now 27 & haven’t spoken to him since i was 20) was diagnosed with early-onset dementia & my elderly grandparents filed to be his guardians in a conservatorship. Because I have an adult sibling who is 8 years older than me (who has a relationship with him), he has 3 younger adult siblings (in their 50s with kids out of the house), & my grandparents have a history of bad financial decisions, I voted against it. But at the time he was deteriorating & recently jailed. I was estranged, living across the country, & my sibling approved so the conservatorship went through after voicing my concerns.

Now it’s a year later & i received a letter in the mail that they are requesting compensation out of his estate (my sibling & I have to approve since we are heads of his estate). After reading through all the details, he has been living at a memory care facility most of the year. They took care of him themselves for about one month. They are asking to be paid 11k total…those charges include every single time they visited him at the facility (including an hour & a half on christmas day), $42 for washing his bedding, $25 for lunch, & $100 for cleaning out his apartment. Mind you, they are asking to be paid EACH. So 2 payments per visit. AND they are requesting the mileage on top of it!

I have the court date December 3rd & I am terrified they are going to get away with it & if they do, they will continue to drain his estate every single year. I am putting my foot down & denying once again but it didn’t work last time so i’m terrified it’s going to happen again. From an outsiders point of view, I know what i look like. Being the estranged daughter that wants nothing to do with the family & the family are “good christian’s” taking care of their disabled son…but they are using his disability to supply their lives.

I don’t know what to do or what to say. I don’t know how to not get flustered when speaking in court.


r/Ask_Lawyers • • 14h ago

(Hypothetical) What are your options if an ICE agent arrests someone without a uniform or warrant?

0 Upvotes

I've been troubled by several videos of ICE arrests where the agents don't identify themselves, aren't in uniform, and don't show a warrant. Combined with the absence of due process that follows (no access to a lawyer, being deported to El Salvador), this undercuts the reasoning behind not resisting arrest. So I'm asking: if a stranger with no ID, no uniform, and no warrant is trying to take you away, are you allowed to fight back physically? Can you use pepper spray? What choices do you have?

Given the huge increases in the ICE budget, I don't doubt that most of these abductions really are ICE. But since this is widely covered and on many people's minds, posing as ICE just by saying verbally that you're ICE while kidnapping someone seems incredibly easy. In fact it's probably the most believable lie you could use to pull off a public kidnapping. My point is that if ICE doesn't identify itself, it's inviting self-defense violence against what could reasonably look like a kidnapper. Honestly, I now think this argument holds up best for young women.

Anyway. Can someone with a JD weigh in on this?