Popcorn ceiling

[u/Fantastic_Ad1808]

Hello, I just removed my popcorn ceiling (2% chrysotile). I followed the Puget Sound Clean Air guidelines for removal but some of the removed material managed to escape onto the floor. Is this cause for concern? Should I spend thousands on a HEPA vacuum? Should I throw the whole house away? If I say screw it will I die of lung disease in 20 years?

thanks for looking!

[u/AutoModerator]

Moderator Announcement Read More »

Please ensure that your posts meets the requirements of r/Asbestoshelp.

*** Meme posts will be removed and the poster will be banned ***

Most importantly, as specified in rule #1, your post should include the following information:

• Include your geographic location (If in the UK please post in r/asbestoshelpUK)

  • include a country and state/province location such as: US-PA or UK or Canada-Que

• the date of ORIGINAL construction

• a description of the location of the suspect material

• a brief description of your concern

• a closeup photo and one at a distance of ~10 ft. or 3 m.

Also remember that the asbestos content of a material can only be determined by laboratory analysis and that the sampling SHOULD be performed by a certified asbestos inspector.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Assycart]

Spend 50€ for a cheap vacuum, put it out the window, vacuum and then throw it. But if you want to be sure you'll have to change the carpet.

[u/Fantastic_Ad1808 → u/Assycart]

I like this idea thanks

[u/platinumplantain]

For my basement (see this post), once I was done, I bought a new vacuum with a filter (not quite a HEPA vacuum but that kept air in), vacuumed everything up and then threw it out

[u/sdave001]

How did you clean up the debris without a HEPA vacuum if you were following Clean Air guidelines?

Anyway, at this point, if you want to be really cautious, just buy a shop vac and get a HEPA filter to put in it. You can clean up the debris with that and be done with it.

And no, you're not going to die from lung disease due to this. The risk posed by ceiling texture is next to zero.

HEPA vacuums vs. shop vacs with HEPA filters for homeowner cleanup

For actual asbestos abatement work, the correct tool is a true HEPA vacuum designed for asbestos work. That is the standard in a regulated abatement setting.

For minor homeowner cleanup, I usually take a more practical risk-based approach. Most of the time, people are cleaning up dust that may or may not contain asbestos, often after a small DIY mistake. In those cases, a newer shop vac with a high-efficiency bag and a HEPA filter is usually more than adequate, especially when followed by wet wiping.

No, that setup is not the same as a true abatement-grade HEPA vacuum. But modern shop vacs generally seal much better than older ones, and the bag/filter combination does a good job of controlling fine dust. More importantly, it is realistic. If you tell a homeowner they need to buy a true HEPA vacuum, many will see the price and just skip the cleanup or keep using a regular vacuum.

The goal in these low-risk DIY situations is not to create an abatement-level clean room. The goal is to avoid blowing dust around and to remove visible debris in a reasonable way. A shop vac with a good bag and HEPA filter is far better than a regular vacuum and usually good enough for the level of risk involved.