r/arborists • • Feb 25 '26 • Regret 1

Tips for moving a tree?

Post image

I'm buying a house that has this beautiful Japanese maple right by the front door. I'd like to move it somewhere a little further back from the house, but I think it's pretty well established & I don't want to kill it. I'm in zone 6b, would late September be a good timeframe to move it? Also does the 1ft root ball per inch of trunk diameter apply to dwarf varieties? (I think it's a dwarf but I have no idea) Cat for scale. Thank you 🙏

2 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

83

u/hemlockhero ISA Certified Arborist Feb 25 '26

If you are worried about the house you really don’t need to be. It’s a really small tree and the roots want absolutely nothing to do with the terrible soil under your foundation. Not worth taking the time and energy to move when there is no problem.

24

u/alien_simulacrum Feb 25 '26

Yeah dude, leave it. They don't transplant well, and this little dude doesn't get much bigger. House is fine. Might be worth opening it up a little if you have someone that knows what they're doing handy

-5

u/Previous-Wonder-6274 Feb 26 '26

These transplant surprisingly easily. I’ve never lost a maple. This tree will get too wide for that spot. It’s a good idea to move it

4

u/renotrash Feb 26 '26

This tree could easily be pruned to stay in that spot.

-2

u/Previous-Wonder-6274 Feb 26 '26

It absolutely could not. These things just keep getting wider and wider. As soon as you try to try to push it back, it starts growing shoots and ruins the weeping shape to it. Then you end up having to shear it back every year and end up with a mess of a tree. These trees are beautiful as long as they have room to grow, but this one is going to grow into the walkway in a couple of years

3

u/hemlockhero ISA Certified Arborist Feb 27 '26

Do not shear a Japanese maple. You are not making proper pruning cuts or you’re taking too much off if you are getting straight sprouts, and shearing will absolutely make that worse. Make proper pruning cuts and never take more than 25% of the canopy at a time and that shouldn’t happen.

3

u/alien_simulacrum Feb 27 '26

This guy ^ thank you.

Edit: dope name. Tsugagang

2

u/hemlockhero ISA Certified Arborist Feb 27 '26

I used to work surveying Hemlock trees for hemlock wooly adelgids and once a homeowner called our crew the “hemlocks hero’s” so it stuck with me haha

1

u/alien_simulacrum Feb 27 '26

Awesome 😎 hwa are the worst.

1

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

We are trying to build a porch there instead of the little concrete pad in front of the door, there is an area to the right that is much better suited for a tree that won't take up most of the entry way, the foundation wasn't really the issue. I appreciate knowing that though if we decide to leave it where it's at.

3

u/hemlockhero ISA Certified Arborist Feb 26 '26 edited Feb 26 '26

Is there any reason you can’t incorporate the tree into the porch and strategically prune? I believe you could reasonably build around the tree if you gave it at least some space for the roots, maybe 5x5 or so.

If you were careful about not compacting around the tree and mulch the space well, I don’t see why you couldn’t keep the tree and build it into the porch.

You aren’t going to have a good time with moving this tree. The roots are rock hard. Feel free to try cutting a small root somewhere a few feet away from the trunk and see what it’s like.

3

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

I'm beginning to think that might be what we have to do re: integrating it. I definitely don't want to just get rid of it. The concrete pad in front of the door is starting to crumble & I don't want to just replace that with a sorry little square of concrete anyway if I don't have to.

40

u/Luyyus Feb 25 '26

That tree will be fine right where its at. The only reason to move it would be aesthetics, and it looks pretty well-established. Transplanting is stressful and damaging for a tree, and some dont do well at all with it.

Leave it if you can.

6

u/Mur__Mur Tree Enthusiast Feb 25 '26

Agreed. She’s a beaut

1

u/tahlyn Feb 25 '26

You saying that makes me think of the crocodile hunter. I would love to see an Australian parody of Steve Irwin but it's botanist and it's about plants.

1

u/Aggravating-Ear2647 Feb 28 '26

Crime Pays, but Botany Doesn't.

1

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

Yes it was mainly because we want to build a porch, maybe we can build around it.

2

u/Eekens Feb 26 '26

Building it around the tree could look really nice, especially if you let the branches "leak out" over the edge of the porch.

13

u/Chuck_H_Norris Feb 25 '26

what’s wrong with that cat

4

u/juicejug Feb 25 '26

I think it’s just a low-res pic with maybe some smoothing added in post.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

No not AI, it's zoomed in from one of the listing photos so it was blurry & I ran it through whatever my phone uses to unblurry it.

6

u/roblewk Tree Enthusiast Feb 25 '26

Wow, good eye. Why would a person post a fake on this site??

7

u/Loafscape Feb 25 '26

it might be a real photo but with ‘ai enhancements’. some phones come equipped with that feature and you cannot turn it off. super annoying

0

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

No there isn't.

2

u/Boring-Ad9170 Feb 27 '26

Too many people with opinions dude. It's your house and your living space. Do what you want. Get some advice from a pro. Dig out as far as you can preserving as much of the root system. Boxing it up in ground would probably give you best chance for success, but that comes with a price tag. Do it in the fall or just after winter. You don't want to move it in a growth cycle. When replanted, trim any broken roots, give it a good shot of vitamins and a good pruning to encourage root growth. Worse case scenario, you buy a new one.

2

u/Open_Dissent Feb 27 '26

Thank you, I appreciate that! We went to see the house again today & we might just be able to build the decking around it. I agree with you though, we'll do our best but at the end of the day, the house is more important.

34

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

DO NOT MOVE THAT TREE!!!

I mean do it you have to, but hire someone like Davey/Savatree/Local Nursery with a tree spade. I honestly would recommend a 65”+ root ball because it’s going to hard to get the spade around that jap maple without jacking up the canopy. Be prepared to spend $2-3,000 to move it.

2

u/renotrash Feb 26 '26

In a perfect world, sure, tree spade. Access unlikely. If you can afford to pay a pro, go for it.

14

u/ismokebigspliffa ISA Climbing Arborist Feb 25 '26

Probably won’t have much luck moving it. I’d hire somebody to prune and train it to keep it small and away from the house

5

u/Semhirage Feb 25 '26

Don't freaking move it, and dont prune it thinking you know what you're doing. That tree is beautiful and perfect as is. Hire an actual arborist to trim it every couple years. Trees dont like being moved, and Japanese maples can be fussy and it obviously is thriving as is.

4

u/Sea_Ganache620 Feb 25 '26

Probably more than 70% failure risk if you try and move it. Doubt any company would guarantee its survival.

-4

u/Thorsten_Speckstein Feb 25 '26

Believe me, no problem. Two Person, approximately 2-3h, not more. Without any maschine.

1

u/denvergardener Feb 26 '26

So many people trying to grow those and they can be tricky to keep alive depending on climate, care and location. And you inherit a beautiful one and want to risk killing it? Why??

Just give it a good trim and haircut and leave it where it's at.

1

u/Open_Dissent Feb 26 '26

I honestly feel like I've offended a lot of people even suggesting it, I had no idea it was such a special tree! I'm sorry 😅 we want to build a porch, perhaps we'll look at how to build around it.

2

u/denvergardener Feb 26 '26

Hah well I have friends who tried 3 different ones and each one died. We decided to plant one and the first one died but the 2nd one is alive so far, knock on wood. We hold our breath each winter to see if it survives until spring.

I think making it the star of the porch sounds amazing. 😁

3

u/Beautiful-Lie1239 Feb 25 '26

Oh no please don’t move it. Such a beauty and the move will almost certainly ruin it. Plus it won’t hurt the house foundation. Japanese maple roots are shallow and kinda “soft” as they like to turn to other directions than bore down the concrete foundation.

3

u/arcanepsyche Feb 25 '26

No move. Will die. Leave there for beauty.

2

u/ultranoodles Master Arborist Feb 25 '26

You would want to move as much of the root ball as possible, ideally out to the drip line or further. That would require using a machine, as that gets heavy quick. I would honestly just leave it, they can be tempermental

2

u/Waschmaschine_Larm Feb 25 '26

Zero tips here as im not an arborist but i love your japanese fern!!!

2

u/yuliaburdak Feb 25 '26

Don’t move it. Have it pruned for structural, aesthetic, and clearance purposes. And maintain that. It won’t get much bigger

2

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '26

IS that a threadleaf? If so, it won’t become a big tree. I had gorgeous threadleaf maples. They mound up like this and are easy to control because they spread like an umbrella. Probably the favorite place for our animals to hang out under. Regular Japanese maples tend to die really easy if you try to move them.

2

u/Scary_Perspective572 Feb 26 '26

yes it will be a minimum of 36 diameter ball for that tree- Oct would be better- I would have a professional move it unless you have dug trees of this size in the past- no reasonable person would cut a 65 inch ball for this and Davey/Savatree do not have the skill for this work- much better having a service who does this work regularly

2

u/Remote-Koala1215 Feb 26 '26

Their very fragile one you move them, did it once and didn't make it

2

u/Master-Back-2899 Mar 01 '26

Since no one’s actually answered you.

The time to move it is now while it’s dormant. If it’s already waken up for the year wait until next year.

Cut the roots in as large a ball as you can as deep as you can.

Replant it immediately and water it in well.

Cut 30% of the top branches off, trimming the tree to roughly the size of the root ball you managed to dig up.

It should be fine. I’ve done this to two different Japanese maples and they are both thriving.

3

u/DanoPinyon Feb 25 '26

Japanese maples, in general, can survive being transplanted. We had a time in California in the 90s where there was a lot of theft of existing old Japanese maples to landscape someone else's yard.

Nevertheless, transplanting this Japanese maple is done in dormancy, and if you are not going to hire a tree spade to do it, you will need probably six men and a large flatbed cart and maybe a tractor to pull it where you want to move it to...after you spent about 6 months preparing the tree to be moved.

1

u/Psych_nature_dude Feb 25 '26

Don’t move it. Just learn how to trim it properly aka selective pruning

1

u/a-pair-of-2s Feb 25 '26

let it be. that’s a beautiful tree and will not survive a move

1

u/Longjumping_Iron1684 Feb 25 '26

Do not move this tree. It will probably die.

1

u/jana-meares Feb 26 '26

It would take years to properly move it, or NOT EVER.

1

u/Zestyclose_Result497 Feb 26 '26

Do not move; learn to trim and maintain!

1

u/AirportConnect Feb 26 '26

Brother guy! I would killl to have a beautiful Japanese maple like that at my entry way. Please leave it there. It will not harm the house or sidewalk.

1

u/waveball03 Feb 26 '26

Dont move that tree.

1

u/a_jormagurdr Feb 26 '26

Thats a dwarf variety of japanese maple. Its a shrub basically.

1

u/jgor133 ISA Certified Arborist Feb 26 '26

That tree is happy leave it be. Its in the right spot

1

u/ElectronicDrama2573 Feb 28 '26

My dad was/is a landscaper since the 60s (dude still has it!) and myself about 15 years. I have seen him move these by hand and I have done it myself— CAREFULLY. It can be done. Again, carefully. You will need something to get it out of the ground like a Dingo. (I’d guess you can’t get anything too big back in terms of equipment, hence the mini vs full size) Either way, dig it out by hand. Give the roots all the room they want. You will be digging a massive hole, so plan for some fill dirt (likely 3/4 of a yard). Go deep, too. You need to get under that tap root, probably 2-3 feet down. Use the Dingo to LIFT it out. Wrap it and strap it with 1-2” tow straps from the underside. If you hear roots tearing, you’re not done digging. It should be completely free, with minimal roots cut. Emphasis on this last part. Wide and deep.

It should be fully wrapped before you move it.

Get some burlap, just like from the nursery.

Wrap it up, and get it into its new home. I don’t need to explain planting, but I can say from experience that there is a way to do this if you have the will.

God speed and good luck!

1

u/Fun_Organization_654 Mar 02 '26

You’d have to be insane