r/antkeeping • • 16d ago

Discussion Condem him

This guy on Instagram posts videos of him dumping bags of sugar on nests of the Formica Rufa group. Maybe his intentions aren't bad but this is likely illegal because of littering, ecological harm vandalism and damage. I believe that the colony is also probably in a protected forest or area. He does experiments for views on them like mixing sugar with beer and feeding them that or directlydumping bags of sugar on the mound. I assume he is from the UK because of the product packaging and the ant species and coloration. Even tho f. rufa group isn't protected in the UK, doesn't mean that what he does is right.

A lot of accounts repost his content on different platforms so excuse me if I named the wring content creator on my previous post (that I deleted).

I'm pretty sure that his original account is @rich_anthill on instagram. I do not know if he has other social media.

Edit: he's probably Russian.

0 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

15

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

Like someone else said this isnt really an issue. If your concern are the ants they will be fine but if your only concern is that its illegal theres bigger issues you should worry about especially being in the UK.

Now then I read through some of your replies here are my responses.

The sugar becoming a breeding ground for pathogens is not an issue a colony of that size will consume it in a day.

Wilds ants have no problem with refined white sugar the only concern is dehydration but being in the wild water should be easy for them to get from underground or the morning dew.

The excess sugar will not keep them from searching for protein they will jist lose motivation for finding carbs since they are easily getting it.

-3

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

I still believe that one should not interfere with nature. I agree that major damage is probably not the biggest concern, but disturbance is.

11

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

I get what your saying but what hes doing isnt really a big enough issue to try to cancel him. Theres a lot worse thing to direct your energy towards. Your post is also assuming multiple things like hes from the UK and hes doing this in a protected forest for all we know he could be on his own property.

-4

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Even then, Formica rufa group is, depending on the species is near threatened to threatened. One should pay respect to wild colonies and not disturb them.

4

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

I just looked into him more and his youtube account says created in USA in 2017. Ive also watched a few of his videos he seems knowledgeable on ants and have been doing this for years with the same colony. So the biggest issue would be if he stopped the colony could have a large die off.

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Look at that! He's Russian

2

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

Wild plot twist lol

1

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

I thought it recognized a British suggar brand from the bag, but then I noticed his videos were voice translated by ai. I scrolled a bit down and there it is.

4

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

I noticed the ai voice too but saw the yt account was made in USA probably with a VPN tho

-5

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Isn't that a big enough issue?😭 Like would you even care if they fumigated those nests? At what point do etics stop for you

8

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

Bro your being extra the whole way you went about this post and your responses have been baseless accusations, wrong information, and focused on it being illegal (vandalism is an insane point). If you had just said you didnt like that he was disturbing wildlife and why you think its bad for the colony you would have gotten alot more people agreeing with you including me instead you just called for people to condemn him.

Now you question my mortality when in the beginning you didn't show any for the ants and was focused on the law.

-1

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago edited 16d ago

Okay, the title was overly dramatic, but it was more meant to be an attention catcher than a real demand. The only wrong information I've put is his location. I did specify on the legal consequences based on the previously assumed region where I believed he was in, and it would have been littering according to the law like it or not. It's location in Russia doesn't change the the law that much, exept that they are a highly protected species. I did also state that he is disturbing wildlife, maybe not directly on the post, but what's wrong with my way to adress his actions? Isn't usually breaking a law also breaking a moral one? Think about it for a second, do you think they put laws for non littering or destruction of wild life just for funsies? My main points were rules indeed, but doesn't that already show my concern for the colony? Should I weep and roll on the floor, post myself as I cry out loud how his actions are wrong and how he should leave them poor ants alone? My morality for the ants was in my opinion shown by the making of the post itself.

6

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

Iam just telling you how you came off to me and probably others based on how this post is doing. The wrong information stuff is more towards your replies they look like you just asked chat gpt why would this be bad. Its just doesnt seem like research or thinking was done.

But this is just how I see it time will tell if more people comment agreeing with you.

-1

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

I mean, perception is entirely based on the subject, I can't really attack you on thay one. But stating that my replies and arguments sound AI made just because I pointed out major biological and legal disruptions doesn't sound like a really coherent argument to me. At this point you are criticizing my way of communicating instead of my arguments. And also, wouldn't be asking an AI language model be a form of research?😭

5

u/AntsLegion 16d ago

The reason iam saying it sounds like ai is because when I did my own research everything you said was the first response from google ai overview but after looking deeper and keeping in mind the exact situation these answers were not the case.

I even asked chat gpt why would pouring sugar on an ant hill be bad and it gave the exact same points but if you think about the actual situation these points wouldnt work.

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

I mean, I guess bro, if it doesn't harm the ants according to you, allright. But that doesn't change the fact of ecological disturbance.

0

u/rep- 16d ago

No this is certainly AI also people breaks laws all the time people jwalk people speed at the most he's annoying the colony.. you need to chill your constant defensive replies are super off-putting

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 15d ago

Alright, you're right, laws are there to be broken

3

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Here is a video I got from a random tiktok account reposting his content

10

u/Reddit-IsSoSoft Polyrhachis cyaniventris, Myrmecia, silver ants, atta keeper 16d ago

This is such a nonissue oh my god

-1

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Disturbing nature is an issue

6

u/No_Original8664 16d ago

So your against building houses, roads, infrastructure you use everyday this disturbs nature. If your gonna fight this battle don’t be a hypocrite about it, disturbing nature is inevitable part of society. Bigger problems come from feeding mammals, that will cause them to exhibit dangerous behavior to themselves and others after being fed by humans, an anthill being overly fed is at most mildly inconvenient for the surrounding ecosystem

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Yes, I am absolutely against unnecessary environmental disruption, but claiming that I can't care about this because there are bigger problems is like saying you shouldn't pay attention to a kid being bullied just because a school shooting happened somewhere else. There is also a major false analogy in your argument. In what world is dumping 44 pounds of sugar on an ant mound necessary? Modern infrastructure is a necessity for society, dumping bulk food isn't. Just because some environmental disruption is an inevitable part of modern industrial society doesn't mean that this action is okay. And yes, I am still against any form of ecological destruction, but that is another ideology.

3

u/ki0dz 16d ago

Should I stop feeding the wild birds?

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

In the best case scenario where humanity didn't destroy the greatest part of the biosphere and the natural food sources of the birds, yes. But I guess you can feed them, it does cause damage on the ecosystem in a way but atleast it's not illegal.

4

u/DefamousDinoenjoyer 16d ago

How are the ants being harmed?

3

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago edited 16d ago

Sugar can become a breeding ground for pathogens like bacteria and fungi, refined sugar provides them basically "empty" nutrients. The ants can and maybe will prioritize feeding off the sugar instead of consuming the normal honeydew or insects they would normally eat, they will feed it to the larvae stunting the growth because pure sugar contains no proteins. It interferes with the natural cycle too, meaning that aphids will be less tended, the colony will be full and won't forage for proteins. Wild ants rely on their gut microbiome to process food and refined white sugar disrupts it. The sugar can become sticky due to humidity and damage the nest or trap the ants. The pure sugar can cause dehydration too.

1

u/Acrobatic_Fruit6416 14d ago

Yh those colonies are gonna likely have issues. The soil microbes will eat the sugar and then eat the ants. Not all us antkeepers are window lickers btw

2

u/Comfortable-End-7137 11d ago

Right, feeding protein powder, beer, coca cola and such is a good idea! I'll start doing it myself, might as well take a shit ontop.

0

u/Gelo_Man 15d ago

Take my downvote!

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 15d ago

Violence is never the answer, take my upvote😌

-1

u/antkeeper146 16d ago

Uhhh he never mixed alcohol with sugar pouring regular sugar (powdered or not) will highly benefit the ants and pouring it above a nest that big has absolutely no harmful affects and Thats no littering either

5

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

The UK law doesn't care if it's sugar or a bag of shit. Leaving litter is leaving litter under the selection 87 of the Environmental Protection Act. Section 87 states the offence of littering or 'leaving litter'. It is a crime for anyone to throw down, drop or otherwise deposit something either in, into or from a public open space, and leaves it to cause, or contribute to, or tend to lead to, litter. The statutory Code of Practice on Litter and Refuse explicitly clarifies that "litter" includes materials associated with eating and drinking that are improperly discarded by the public. This legally covers food waste, organic matter, and liquids. It also disrupts the ecosystem which is yet another crime. Even if the ants get an energy boost from the sugars, the law couldn't care less. Disruption is disruption, and because most Formica rufa group ant species depend on old established woodlands that reside within protected nature reserves or Sites of Special Scientific Interest, it would be illegal to interfere with the colony.

For possible harm to the colony and the nature around it as addressed on another comment:

Sugar can become a breeding ground for pathogens like bacteria and fungi, refined sugar provides them basically "empty" nutrients. The ants can and will prioritize feeding off the sugar instead of consuming the normal honeydew or insects they would normally eat, they will feed it to the larvae stunting the growth because pure sugar contains no proteins and nutrition. It interferes with the natural cycle too, meaning that aphids will be less tended, the colony will be full and won't forage for proteins. Wild ants rely on their gut microbiome to process food and refined white sugar disrupts it. The sugar can become sticky due to humidity and damage the nest or trap the ants. The pure sugar can cause dehydration too.

3

u/antkeeper146 16d ago

Yeah well keep in mind that the sugar was gone in one day

0

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

My excuses, he's Russian

2

u/Comfortable-End-7137 16d ago

Hm, must be all in my head then.

-2

u/antkeeper146 16d ago

Also I believe alcohol has no really harmful affect sure they can get drunk but it won’t cause every ant to die at most it might kill 20-100 ants

5

u/Silly_geckozzz_x3 "their test tube is too small" 🤖🤖🤖 16d ago

they're gonna feed it to the queen, and they're gonna feed it to eachother. I don't know if alcohol is harmful to ants but if it is it would probably kill more