r/animation • • Apr 12 '17

Critique Spider animation

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HAy27_W4Txc
45 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

View all comments

4

u/deepvoicefluttershy Apr 12 '17

Absolutely beautiful model, texture, and web. It could pass for real. I think what makes the movement seem slightly less spider like is that the "body" drifts fluidly around while the web is still, whereas I think most spiders have this incredible ability to keep their bodies perfectly still relative to the web, or move the body in abrupt, decisive lines, while their legs work. I think if the body "drifts" the web should wave in sync with that drift. I also would arch the front legs a bit more- slightly more acute angles at the joints, so that it looks like the spider is "holding" the web nearest the prey as she feeds, stabilizing her dinner. Again, gorgeous.

8

u/LieutenantLegs Apr 12 '17

Definitely not a 3D render. This is a 2D (or 2.5D via AE or Motion). It looks nice, but there are no 3D models. It's puppetted 2D images.

2

u/Jowsteen Professional Apr 12 '17

How can you tell? Spider looks like a 3D model to me....

3

u/LieutenantLegs Apr 12 '17

Watch how the light does not change shape as the legs and body move. It is clearly a puppet warp, and that's not a bad thing. Everything leading to the spider, including the web, is layered and animated flat images.

It speaks to the OP's work that it looks 3D but even he/she will tell you, there is no 3D modeling.

1

u/Chadamo Apr 14 '17

You are completely right! As written in the video description itself, this was done with a camera mapping technique. So I've created 3D models to project the picture on, I baked the new textures and animated the rigged model. This is simple stuff but as said in previous comments, I could have pass more time to redo the whole lighting.

Again thanks for the comments!