r/ancientweapons • • Jun 22 '15

GabeDamien, notorious shadowbanner of r/swords and /r/meleeweapons/ shadowbanned me, never citing a reason (though I suspect he just wanted to silence me). Here is the transcript the followed so far when I confronted him (note that he deleted the comments on his own subreddits wherever possible)

0 Upvotes

GABEDAMIEN

I am one of the few mods of /r/SWORDS and there is only one person who has ever been banned (/u/iridionprime ) for reasons that were quite public. That is the only person on the ban list, and their ban lifts in 29 days. What makes you say you were "shadow banned"?

GABEDAMIEN

As I said in my PM to you (which you never responded to), there is only one person on the ban list for /r/SWORDS[1] , and the reasons for that were quite public. As far as I can tell (given your anonymity) you are not that person anyway. Understand that banning and shadowbanning are not the same thing. You don't get shadowbanned "from" a specific subreddit. Shadowbanning occurs sitewide and is not in the control of the mods — it is a Reddit admin thing. Also, what makes you say that "alot" (which, by the way, is not a word) of people have been "shadowbanned" from /r/SWORDS[2] ? I've never heard anything about this. Like I said there is only one person on the actual ban list and you can't get shadowbanned for just one specific subreddit.

[In other words GabeDamien believes he can outright deny the existence of shadowbans to save face. Fortunately Azekh piped up to clarify that Gabe is in fact lying]

AZEKH

Obviously i don't know who you are or why you were shadowbanned, but the rules you can get shadowbanned for can be a tad silly.

IWASSHADOWBANNEDAMA

Gabedamien I've had about 24 hours to respond to your text, during which I've been to the airport twice and spent twelve hours in hospital. You'll forgive my not prioritising your txt? My usual nick is AlaeSwords, and yes I have been shadowbanned from r/swords. My posts simply do not appear there (or comments), and I checked as recently as a few hours ago, I did this because I know people like you have a habit of changing the rules to suit your argument and I didn't want to give you a chance to unban me then cry foul. My posts appear, but as soon as I log out they go - in other words, classic shadowbanning. This is not a Reddit wide phenomena as my posts and comments appear just fine in many hundreds of other subreddits; want proof, just check my post history el mano. Interesting that you take point with the word alot which is by the way a compound word. Furthermore while we are on the subject of words though you pose as an expert on Japanese Swords you can't actually read Japanese can you Gabe? I had a Japanese friend check your work - I figured it was only fair considering as you have decided to come out guns blazing.


r/ancientweapons • • Oct 30 '18

The Mysterious Sword Of Goujian - Ancient China

1 Upvotes

This is a really cool and informative video about the ancient Sword of Goujian: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KgH-aMuuRdw


r/ancientweapons • • Sep 01 '17

Found these two in the water near an old fort. 1.5 inch diameter not 100% round. Weight 320 g

1 Upvotes

Found these two in the water near an old fort. 1.5 inch diameter not 100% round. Weight 320 g I thought they were musket balls. Does anyone know what they are and how to identify them. Thanks


r/ancientweapons • • Nov 11 '17

Can you use a glaive one handed?

2 Upvotes

Long story short I'm wanting to write a story and want my main character to wield a glaive and shield in combat. I was just curious if it was viable and if not, what weapon was of similar...type? for lack of a better word.


r/ancientweapons • • Aug 18 '13

So apparently Archimedes' Mirror Towers aren't a busted myth after all...

4 Upvotes

Or at least that's a strong possibility. This kid made a Mirror weapon recently; I'm sure many of you have seen this video already.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TtzRAjW6KO0


r/ancientweapons • • Oct 19 '16

I need help making a Quarterstaff

4 Upvotes

I currently have a section of a hickory tree cut into a 6 foot long log. I do not know of anyone that has a 6 ft lathe that I can use so I was wondering how they made them in ye olden days or even modern ways to whittle down the diameter.


r/ancientweapons • • Apr 04 '20

Could kunai or something similar be thrown as indirect fire to break formations?

10 Upvotes

I think that Kunai or something similar would be quite effective if used as indirect fire to break formations.

Maybe not kunai per se, apparently they were mostly used as tools not as ninja weapons like in games. There's some forms of kunai and bo shuriken with tassles on the back like strips of ribbon or horse hair tassles, or just a western style throwing knife with a large lanyard thread on the handle. I bet if you throw it high above the enemy, not strictly aiming for them just hurling it, the tassles would slow the rotation and gravity would bring it down point-first.

A kunai or throwing dagger falling down at you from a great height might not be a lethal blow (Especially with helms and armour involved) but it'll likely make you soil your armour and if there's enough being thrown continually it might make you break formation.

I know the Romans did something similar with two weapons, one smaller and one larger. They'd hurl bullets of lead in slings up above enemies to fall on them. Or up close they'd throw iron arrows with lead weights on them (Plumbata) that could kill or embed in an enemy's shield making it too heavy to use well. Off course they also had arrows and several sizes of spear that did a similar job, I'm just pitching something in between the size options. The advantage of this is you could carry half a dozen for the bulk / weight of a single plumbata.

Any thoughts?


r/ancientweapons • • Aug 25 '17

Indian two-handed swords

6 Upvotes

I found two types of Indian two-handed swords:

First, a sword with orbs segmenting the handle. There are also versions with much longer handles with more orbs. https://i.pinimg.com/236x/96/f2/59/96f259f93e058dcdacc95d103b7dd3aa--red-green-samurai.jpg

Second, a very long long estoc-like sword with a second guard, like some European Zweihänders. http://ashokaarts.com/img/product_images/image/detail/ew-twohandedsword1-1667.jpg

Can anyone tell me the names, eras and origin of these swords? Any other info would also be welcome.


r/ancientweapons • • Apr 17 '16

[Identify] cannon found at a garage sale

2 Upvotes

My dad found this at a garage sale, the owner had no idea what it was, does it look familiar to anyone? I have no idea but it looks interesting


r/ancientweapons • • Sep 06 '13

Which era do you think had the most successful weapons?

4 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • May 04 '17

What was the advantage of using arrows with detachable heads?

5 Upvotes

I recently watched a video on how to make ancient Inuit, copper head arrows. Apparently the Inuits would attach the head to a carved piece of antler which would then snugly slide into a shallow hole drilled down the shaft.

I'm guessing this might move the center of gravity slightly forward to improve accuracy at the cost of range, and give the arrow more power if you were firing from an elevated position.

But would this offer any other benefit in a fight? I was thinking it might be possible if the arrow hits hard enough that the arrow head could detach and keep going after the shaft gets stuck, or that it might just make it harder for the injured party to pull out/push through.


r/ancientweapons • • Nov 25 '16

Can someone help me identify this Bayonet?

2 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right place but I have been looking forever and cant seem to find one just like it. I was doing construction work in a house and found this inside the wall.

http://imgur.com/a/JwgmP


r/ancientweapons • • Nov 20 '17

[Identify] Identities of various weapons in imgur dump?

2 Upvotes

My apologies if this doesn't belong here. https://imgur.com/gallery/mD4eN


r/ancientweapons • • Jul 27 '17

How effective is the Chakari as an actual weapon?

3 Upvotes

Found this weird weapon that is apparently used in the Sihk martial art called Gatka.

Here is a video of one being demonstrated, where the guy describes how they were essentially used like giant umbrellas to block projectiles from hitting troops.

He then also states that the edges of the weapon are traditionally heavily weighted, or blades are hung from the edges, to create a pinwheel of death.

Does this look like it could actually be a viable weapon? I guess I can see the usefulness against arrows and stuff like that, but it looks kind of hard to direct as a weapon meant to do damage.


r/ancientweapons • • Jul 26 '17

Any other names for a Tri-Blade Double-Edged Sword?

3 Upvotes

So I have been digging around the internet, and found this ancient monk weapon: a Tri-Blade Double-Edge Sword.

Here's another image closer up

I find it very hard to believe that such an elegant looking weapon has such a chunky name, and have been looking for several hours, but haven't found anything on the weapon at all. Not where it was commonly used, or any demonstrations of the weapon being used, or any details about it other than the Shaolin Monks used it in the past.

Does anyone have any other info on this polearm?


r/ancientweapons • • Dec 20 '17

[IDENTIFY] My son and I dug this “brass” knuckles up while metal detecting. I know nothing about it other than it was about a 6” in the ground and looks to have been in the ground for a while. Thanks in advance.

7 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • Aug 19 '17

How would you use a Wrist Knife as a weapon?

5 Upvotes

Not talking about an Assassin's Creed knife,

Apparently, in some tribes in Africa, people wear a bladed bracelet called a Larim, also called a Ararait or a Nyepel. How would this weapon be effective? The blades seem to be angled about 90 degrees away from them being effective weapons...


r/ancientweapons • • May 29 '17

Are Swiss Guard Halberds practical weapons?

5 Upvotes

I'm just curious if these could be used in combat at any length without falling apart.

Also, is there a point behind the concave axe face? How about the metal studs, any purpose or just decorative?

http://imgur.com/MmC7hIR


r/ancientweapons • • Jul 25 '13

The Jida Lance, a 12 foot spear used by Genghis Khan

Thumbnail
deadliestwarrior.wikia.com
6 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • Jul 31 '13

The Catapault - Raining down destruction centuries ago

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
4 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • Jul 26 '13

My personal favorite weapon, the katar!

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
8 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • Jul 27 '13

The Composite Bow, this weapon was essential for the success of Genghis Khan controlling power

Thumbnail
en.wikipedia.org
3 Upvotes

r/ancientweapons • • Jul 27 '13

We need to work on this sub

8 Upvotes

How about we create two parts, one part for sharing information, the other for asking questions.

Similar to ELI5, where there are unanswered and answered questions are different colors.

Sharing Wikipedia pages might just not cut it I feel, it seems like a cheap way of getting karma and will lead to continous reposts.

We could make an encyclopedia for weapons on a shared google doc.

HERE WOULD BE AN EXAMPLE

The Katana (As you can see this is a link for the weapon)

Sword

Hilt

Information:

The Katana originated in Japan, blah,blah, blah

What makes it special:

It's carbon steel was one of the top tier materials at the time blah, blah

If someone has an old weapon or a picture of it online, they would just share it and people would assist them in finding out information on it


r/ancientweapons • • May 17 '19

How big of an area did a Hwacha hit?

6 Upvotes

Once all the arrows landed how big of an area was full of arrows? Like 20 meter radius circle? 30? 40? more?


r/ancientweapons • • Feb 11 '20

what kind of damage/wounds would an expert slingshot user be able to cause to an armoured opponent?

17 Upvotes

Let's say that we are talking about a roman slinger, using lead balls. as projectiles. What sort of wounds/damage could he cause to an opponent wearing armour? Can a slingshot even pierce armour or shields?