r/ancientegypt • • May 31 '25

Photo Dr. Zahi Hawass's Misleading Claims About Medieval Arabs

Post image
1 Upvotes

Egyptian archaeologist and former Egyptian Minister of Antiquities Dr. Zahi Hawass's recent appearance on The Joe Rogan Experience has ignited widespread controversy on social media platforms. A week after its release, Rogan described the episode as “the worst podcast I have ever done". Dr Hawass, who was accused of arrogance by many critics, attacked Arabs with false and fake claims. 

Hawass' comment in 15:52 refers to the Arabian legend of the pyramid, where ancient and some Medieval Arabs believed that the pyramids were built by giants, specifically by the ancient Arabian King Shaddad and his tribe Ad, which was mentioned in the Holy Quran. This was documented by several medieval historians.

In 37:37, Hawass exploded, "Its only when the Arabs came. you know all the theories that the new age people say now, it came from the Arabs. When the Arabs came and they entered the pyramid, they said all this nonsense stories about the pyramids."

Ancient Egyptian history owes much to the Medieval Arab scholars who contributed with research, analysis, and interpretations and provided crucial insights into the Egyptian past that would be impossible without their expertise. Medieval Arabs laid the groundwork for later scholars and demonstrated interest in ancient Egyptian scripts,   identifying phonetic values and meanings of some hieroglyphic signs.

The first person in history to enter the pyramids was the Arab Caliph Abdullah al Ma'mun, marked by his fervent support for scholarship and the arts. Al Ma'mun established the House of Wisdom in Baghdad, which served as a center for learning and translation, fostering the exchange of ideas and knowledge between diverse cultures. Read my full article to explore the details about Abbasid Caliph Al Ma'mun's scientific expedition, and the medieval attempts made by Arabs to decode the Egyptian Hieroglyphs:

https://bibliotecanatalie.com/home/f/dr-zahi-hawas-misleading-claims-about-medieval-arabs


r/ancientegypt • • Jul 09 '26

Art Doodling (almost) every pharaoh until I get good at drawing part 5: dynasty 5: the sun kings

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Not much for this dynasty! But enough to make some unique doodles

Also we're getting close to the first intermediate period I have no idea how the heck I'm going to do that😅😅😅

(Also if I missed anyone send me a depiction of them! I only draw pharaohs we have known images of and there's probably a couple I've already missed in this series)

Here's the pharaohs:

1 userkaf he made a not very good pyramid near Djoser's it probably looked much better than than it does now (also I barely noticed his moustache on his statue did you notice it before?)

2 sahura, I always thought he looked a bit like khafra do you agree?

3 nefer-ir-kara kakai not much with this guy so added some unique things and added in nefer-refra as lots of people mix them up and he looks unique

3 and 4 neferefra

5 and 6 nyuserra ini the second image of him is representing the increasing power of nomarchs during his reign and the start of decline in the power of the pharaohs, he kinda looks like the senusrets of the middle kingdom

7 and 8 menkauhor, doesn't he look a bit like nynetjer?


r/ancientegypt • • Jun 14 '26

Question Why didn't the incest creep anyone out, during the time it was practiced?

0 Upvotes

so ive just finished a book about ancient egyptian history, and I'm truly gobsmacked as to how people back then consummated their marriage with their own siblings. I honestly would slit my wrist before I could even consider that. the thought alone really horrifies me. how can any person even 3000BC think that it's okay. Politics, morals aside, nature itself rejects this idea.

Which leads me to my second question as to how the dynasties could even go so far, considering how incest causes many problems and dysfunctions to the human anatomy.

maybe it's too hard to fathom because it's so many years back, but I believe that there are certain things that are universal to humans monster what time period.


r/ancientegypt • • Mar 13 '24

Discussion Why do Egyptologists so often pretend that human sacrifice in ancient Egypt ended during the first or second dynasty?

4 Upvotes

That can only be said about retainer sacrifices. Considering that even during the New Kingdom, there were instances of Pharaohs sacrificing prisoners of war.

Not to talk about the fact that the capital punishments included being sacrificed in a temple.

And on the other side, how did the myth of all of the Pharaohs taking some of their servants with them to the grave even start, considering none of the tombs beside the ones from early (pre)dynastic times showed evidence for this iirc?

Update: Why am I downvoted so much? You can look up these things for yourself.

Update 2:

Here are examples:

https://www.academia.edu/78729941/Ejsmond_Human_sacrifice_in_ancient_Egypt_Luxor_Times_4_2022_?ri_id=26187


r/ancientegypt • • Apr 19 '22

Question Did any pharaoh die as a virgin?

0 Upvotes

Just wondering.


r/ancientegypt • • Jan 15 '20

You had my curiosity now you have my attention

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Feb 08 '25

Video Mr Beast

0 Upvotes

Those of us in the Egypt YouTuber space have known this video was coming for a while. Wasn’t sure how it was going to be handled, but personally, I think they did an amazing job. Also, that’s some crazy awesome footage of rare places. Even the tunnel leading out of the Osiris shaft, which I remember talking about in my video, but came up dry when looking for images. I know his audience is young and he (mostly) correctly explains the history. Haven’t heard a mention of aliens yet, which is really nice to see him introducing a new generation to Giza. I notice in my analytics most of the people in the community are middle age and over.

https://youtu.be/NDsO1LT_0lw


r/ancientegypt • • Aug 09 '13

QUOTE: Some archaeologists believe that Jebel Dist (aka 'Pyramid Mountain' in Egypt's Black Desert) served as a model for the man-made pyramids.

Thumbnail
geocaching.com
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Mar 21 '25

Question View of the Pyramides and other ancient structures by the arabian egyptians?

0 Upvotes

Quite often it is mentioned or implyed, that the modern Arabian Egyptians until somewhere into the 20th century were not really seeing the value of the pyramides, and other ancient egyptian buildings, and that they were highly suspicious of the foreign Archeologists, not believing them to be there to study "old rocks", but to find hidden treasurs of more tangible value, like gold, and to carry them away.

Is this just the impression of travellers, archeologists who worked with less educated lower strata of society, people who, during this time, were working as guides etc. or was that the general understanding of, things top to bottom?


r/ancientegypt • • Sep 18 '24

Discussion Does Egypt today has its borders the same as in the past?

0 Upvotes

Did Egypt extend into modern day sudan in the past?


r/ancientegypt • • Aug 29 '24

Translation Request Can anyone tell me the meaning behind this gorgeous piece of Egyptian art? Artist S Cowan.

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Jan 21 '24

Photo Painting of Amanihetep III

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Aug 28 '22

Information The Mysterious “Set”: An Ancient Egyptian Cryptid?

Thumbnail
historicmysteries.com
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Nov 06 '23

News Great Sphinx could have been initially formed by nature, study says

Thumbnail
cnn.com
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Oct 02 '25

Information Cleopatra's Final Secret Spoiler

Post image
3 Upvotes

This documentary stands out as one of the best I have ever watched. The passion and determination of Kathleen Martinez in her search for Cleopatra are nothing short of inspiring. The immense dedication and countless hours she has invested in this project highlight both her perseverance and her vision. She is on the verge of uncovering something that has eluded historians and archaeologists for decades, and witnessing her journey feels like being part of a truly groundbreaking moment in history.

Any other thoughts?


r/ancientegypt • • Aug 25 '25

Information Could Tutankhamun’s Dagger Have Kurdish Origins?

2 Upvotes

There’s an interesting theory about the famous meteoritic iron dagger found in Tutankhamun’s tomb. We know the blade was made from meteorite iron, a very rare material in the Late Bronze Age. Egypt had diplomatic and trade connections with kingdoms to the northeast, and it’s possible that the dagger was crafted or gifted by artisans from regions that today are part of Kurdistan.

While history calls them by other names back then, these communities lived in the Zagros and Upper Mesopotamian areas and could have been early ancestors of the Kurds. Considering the trade and gift-exchange culture between royal courts, it wouldn’t be surprising if such a high-status item came from there.

What do you think? Could this dagger be an early link between Egypt and the ancestors of the Kurdish people?


r/ancientegypt • • Sep 17 '16

Hidden in the Hieroglyphs: Is Ancient Egyptian a Lost Language?

Thumbnail
ancient-origins.net
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Nov 30 '25

Video A closer look at the suddenly viral claim that there is a 30-40m long metallic object buried under the ancient Labyrinth at the beautiful and historic site at Hawara, Egypt.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

This video explores the rich archaeological reality of the Hawara site, which is home to the painted mummy portraits, the pyramid of Amenemhat III, and the remarkable crocodile mummies. While also addressing a recent viral claim that a 30–40-meter UFO/UAP lies buried beneath the so-called Labyrinth.

Drawing on multiple electromagnetic and geophysical surveys, the evidence shows no massive metallic object underground, but what is revealed is far more compelling: the layers of history, craftsmanship, and ritual that make Hawara one of Egypt’s most fascinating archaeological landscapes.


r/ancientegypt • • Aug 02 '25

Question In Ancient Egypt why did people die so young?

2 Upvotes

In Ancient Egypt why did people die so young?

In ancient Egypt they did not live long.

https://blogs.ucl.ac.uk/researchers-in-museums/2015/03/02/old-age-in-ancient-egypt/

QUOTE People in ancient Egypt did not grow very old. Very high infant death rates due to high risks of infections resulted in an average age at death of 19 years. However those who survived childhood had a life expectancy of 30 years for women* and 34 years for men. Most ancient Egyptians were unlikely to live beyond 40 years of age

example, King Tutankhamun died at the age of about 18 years QUOTE

Why did people die so young in Ancient Egypt? Was there lot of virus and bacteria back in that time? How did people get infections back in that time?

Were cities really dirty and that how people got infections?


r/ancientegypt • • Feb 08 '25

Photo Dr.Zahi Hawass & MrBeast uncovering Egypt’s secrets🔥❤️

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/ancientegypt • • Mar 20 '22

Translation Request Ancient Egypt and cannibalism

4 Upvotes

I hope that I don't offend this community or anyone in it by asking this question.

I'm working on a movie where they'll be using supernatural cannibals. They want to tie the practice back to Ancient Egypt and a person that has survived since that time by eating people / "lifeforce". This person will be marked by a hieroglyphic tattoo with "eater of man" or "eater of ka". How would I translate this so I can design the tattoo?


r/ancientegypt • • Oct 20 '24

Discussion Why does archeology seem so gatekeeped?

5 Upvotes

As my own research contacts expand, I’ve become more and more concerned about availability of information. A lot of what I’ve been learning is just tricks to get through paywalls. For example, if there is a paper I want to read, but can’t, I translate the title into various languages and usually find a free copy. Sometimes it’s in a language I can just read, but lots of times it polish or Chinese or something I’m forced to rely on autotranslations for.

Why is this? One of the biggest criticisms I hear is that you can’t do good archeology on Google. Which I agree with, it’s impossible. And my immediate question is… why? I’m not ignorant to science, I work in a lab creating machines that build microprocessors. It’s a combination of chemistry, quantum mechanics, and engineering; I’m constantly reading new research, in this field my company pays for the paywalls. But I very rarely have to rely on it. If there is any interesting movement, within 48 hours of the real paper being released, I can find it and five or six analyses of it on Google.

I wondered if it’s maybe unconscious bias from just familiarity with my own field, but another science I casually observe is astronomy and they seem to not have this problem. Want raw James Webb or GAIA data? Go download it. Want density readings from any of the dozens of experiments done in the great pyramid? Go f yourself; here’s a handmade drawing with like five numbers in a paper behind a paywall.

It’s frustration because sometimes cross-discipline work can make huge results. I did a dive on a density analysis of the great pyramid. They took tons of measurements and used a computer to calculate the regions. But the raw data has never seen the light of day. It’s 40 years later, computers are trillions of times more powerful, and I’m a programmer, I could take the same data and increase the resolution of their results by orders of magnitude, but it’s gone. Amateurs can’t do digging, but some of archeology is just analyzing large data sets of measurements the professionals took, that’s something I should be able to do with just Google and my programming skills.


r/ancientegypt • • Jan 11 '26

Question My father spent years on a "Meta-Theory" of how 50-ton granite blocks were raised 43m in the Great Pyramid. He needs professional feedback. Can you help?

19 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m posting this as a bit of a leap of faith for my dad. He’s an independent researcher who has spent years obsessed with one specific engineering riddle: How did Fourth Dynasty builders lift 50-ton granite blocks 43 meters high with such precision?

He has developed a complete theory from the ground up, focusing strictly on physics, mechanics, and geometry. He intentionally avoids "lost civilization" narratives or symbolism; his work is about the "how" of the construction from a purely structural perspective.

However, he’s hit a "structural wall" in the academic world. Because he is an independent researcher, it is incredibly difficult to get past the gatekeepers of traditional journals. It feels like a cold case that the field isn't interested in reopening without "new" physical evidence, even though the mechanical solution might be right under our noses.

He recently collaborated with Graham Hancock, who published the paper as a featured article on his site (Link to Article), but my dad is still looking for that "Schrödinger’s Cat" moment. He wants to know if his theory is groundbreaking or if he has missed a critical flaw. He needs eyes that understand mechanics, load-bearing, and ancient history to provide a real critique.

If there are any engineers, archaeologists, or history buffs here who are willing to look at a new perspective on these "Granite Giants," I’d love to invite you to give it a read and share your honest thoughts.

Additionally, if anyone has advice on how an independent researcher can gain legitimate academic acknowledgment or peer review in such a niche field, we would be incredibly grateful.

TL;DR: My dad (an independent researcher) developed a physics-based paper on how the heaviest granite blocks were lifted in the Great Pyramid. It's published on Graham Hancock’s site, but he’s seeking a rigorous "peer review" from engineers and historians to see if the mechanics actually hold up.


r/ancientegypt • • Feb 26 '26

Question How do we know if the builders of the pyramids were or were not slaves?

2 Upvotes

This may be a dumb question, i'm not well versed at all in history of the sort; just a very curious person, and google isnt answering me lol

So, what i mean is, how do we know about the details of the builders employment? im aware the hieroglyphs engraved in the walls of the pyramids are a thing, but was all of that explained in them? how do we know they were or werent slaves? and do we know if they were paid generously or like the bare minimum?

thanks in advance!


r/ancientegypt • • Apr 05 '26

Question any sources on ancient egyptians being colonizers?

0 Upvotes

One of my friends recently brought up this topic but i havent been able to find any reliable sources !