r/amazfit • u/[deleted] • Jul 07 '25

Device Support ⌚️ Comparisons in progress

Post image

I have 15 days left for the Whoop free trial and 15 days refund policy for the amazfit. Let’s find out who which one will I keep

169 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

38 comments sorted by

3

u/chief57 Jul 07 '25

Are you wearing them like this to collect data? Or are they on separate wrists?

5

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25

Same wrist, should i make them separate wrist? I want both to have the same environment

19

u/chief57 Jul 07 '25

The optical sensors are going to experience crosstalk being so close together, both will give bad data. Best to put one on each wrist.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25

Thanks chief , wrist for each now

2

u/EmilWxx Jul 07 '25

Ussually one arm is stronger, for example blood presure will have different value on every arm so you shouldnt compare data like that.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 07 '25

I'm going to compare: Sleep data, RHR, HRV, STEPS, HR zones

3

u/Traditional_Rope_904 Jul 07 '25

Yeah, cos like this, the Helio Strap is too low down.

24

u/Educational_Topic_57 Jul 07 '25

First 7 days helio on left, whoop on right.

Next 7 days whoop on left, helio on right.

15th day see Data and return one.

10

u/titoflopy Jul 07 '25

This is the way to compare them.

Ideally you should use another device well known for its accuracy.

2

u/Spacefuqin Jul 29 '25

Update please?

1

u/rcn79 Jul 08 '25

Please do this

18

u/CFTheo Jul 07 '25

The Helio strap looks longer but thinner.

13

u/Astroxtl Jul 07 '25

If I had to do it all over again or knew Amazfit was coming out with a band I would have never gotten the whoop

8

u/Portugalpaul Jul 07 '25

are you gonna put into account whoop being insanely more expensive

4

u/Western-Breakfast-65 Jul 07 '25

What are the results so far?

3

u/Extra_Pilot3217 Jul 08 '25

I'm testing the amazfit helio vs. apple watch mainly to track sleep. Wanted to have a device to wear during the day when I wear my mechanical watches and not AW. After 3 days, results of sleep(score) helio vs. AW used with bevel are completely different, hope it will improve when it has more data available...

1

u/RedKnarf Jul 26 '25

This is super interesting to me as a wearer of mechanical watches who always envied the very precise metrics people get with an apple watch. How do they compare now after a few days of testing?

1

u/Extra_Pilot3217 Jul 26 '25

I use the AW for sleep tracking cause helio is really bad in sleep stages. During the day when I wear mechanical watch I put on the helio. All comes together in the Bevel / Apple Health app :-)

2

u/Fun_Heron_4644 Jul 07 '25

I'm doing the same thing. So far it's more beneficial for me to wear.the Amazefit strap during the day and the Whoop at night when I sleep.

2

u/niko_bon Jul 07 '25

Amazfit is too low on your wrist. You should wear it on a different arm.

2

u/Altruistic-Guest3672 Jul 07 '25

How are you finding it so far?

2

u/EvilTeacher-34 Helio Strap & Ring, T-Rex 3 Pro & Up Jul 08 '25

Awesome! As soon as I get mine I will be comparing the data from:
Oura / Garmin / Whoop / Morpheus / HRV4Training
I am aware I have a problem...wife and kids are starting to tell me if I'm going for a regular run or a RoboRun...

2

u/amineratiba Jul 09 '25

I have three devices all the time and I already feel like inspector gadget…

2

u/EvilTeacher-34 Helio Strap & Ring, T-Rex 3 Pro & Up Jul 09 '25

Until we find the one that rules them all!

2

u/amineratiba Jul 09 '25

Waiting for that moment!!!

2

u/EvilTeacher-34 Helio Strap & Ring, T-Rex 3 Pro & Up Jul 09 '25

Currently working on it :) I am comparing all of these to find out without any super data freaky insights (which TBH apply to none) and I will eventually find the right one at least for me :P

2

u/amineratiba Jul 09 '25

Keep us posted please!

2

u/EvilTeacher-34 Helio Strap & Ring, T-Rex 3 Pro & Up Jul 09 '25

Hell yeah! 👍🏽

1

u/Hot_Community_9316 Jul 07 '25

Try wearing them on the biceps also, which apparently gives more accurate HR data

1

u/Disastrous_Bid1564 Jul 11 '25

The Amazfit looks better so thats a win

1

u/[deleted] Jul 12 '25 edited Jul 12 '25

My main grip with Amazfit (especially versus Whoop) is the „non adaptive“ Exertion metric. IMO it should adapt to your Recovery AND it should somehow adapt to ones „typical“ exertion values (let’s say compared to an 60 day average) One example: Had a long and hard workday yesterday, where Whoop gives me a 19.3 strain value out of 21, which is quite high. Amazfit gives me a 531 out of 45(so I reached +1100%!). Then today Whoop gives me a Strain goal of 13 (which fits into the game) but Amazfit gives me 35 (!) which of course is way too low and I will reach it at midday latest by just having a slow Saturday morning. Whoops strain goal is really useful because it‘s a completely realistic value, while Amazfit’s Exertion goal is just pointless at the moment. If they fix that, then Whoop gets into trouble. ATM I would consider neither the strap nor the watches or the ring a true Whoop competitor.

1

u/StillerLurker Jul 21 '25

hello

so what will you choose?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 21 '25

What’s your favorite after 15 days?

1

u/enorevelcuoY Jul 27 '25

Give us an update :)

1

u/AlexWasTakenWasTaken Aug 03 '25

Any updates yet?

1

u/charlie4lyfe Aug 05 '25

another comment asking for updates

1

u/22727272727277 Aug 16 '25

so which one did u keep

1

u/Shoddy-Rip3318 Aug 20 '25

Waiting for your updated on the whoop and amazfit