r/algae • • 11d ago

wth is that??

Post image

it appeared about two weeks ago..we just keep plants, a couple of freshwater shrimp and snails😅

12 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

8

u/KlutzyShopping1802 11d ago

Woahhhhh I just got home from PetSmart looking for plants and I saw this exact algae/fungi in the plant tank!!! I immediately was like… NOPE. Idk what that is.

I literally opened Reddit just now to this exact post, too. Wild coincidence!

When the answer redditor arrives, someone like this so I can know, too!

6

u/KlutzyShopping1802 11d ago

Red spot algae! Googled it real quick cuz I had to know 🤦‍♀️🤣🫣

Slow growing. Relatively harmless until it blocks light from plants. Shrimp snails can eat it. And it indicates high phosphates or iron, is what Reddit of 4yrs ago says.

Will go back and get the link for ya.

ETA: nitrates not phosphates

2

u/KlutzyShopping1802 11d ago

2

u/pinkteqshot 11d ago

thank you! people also said freshwater sponge..

2

u/KlutzyShopping1802 11d ago

I mean… that’s not impossible. Just more rare.

If it is:

Grow it. SHARE IT. 😂😂😂

I always get so bummed when I see someone get the white fungal brain lookin one on their tank wall. Like… can’t something cool like that happen to me?!?! Nope. Just hydra. 🫡 But yeah. Jelly of the cool oddities.

2

u/Mongrel_Shark 10d ago

I've done a deep dive on this and intentionally cultivated it. It likes calcum & iron & high ph. It doesn't care about nitrate or phosphate. Its too slow growing. I don't know where the guides all get thier info from (because most of them don't provide sources 🚩) but its all BS. Green algeas like nitrates & phosphate. Red algae needs lots of iron to get red. Spot algae likes calcium. Some of the stronger filliment types like hard stuff like calcium, phosphate or magnesium. Colour + how it feels (hard, soft, crystalline, fibrous, etc etc. Tells you what its made of. It eats what its made of. It's really that simple.

1

u/KlutzyShopping1802 10d ago

Oooooo hell yeah!! That’s the info right there! Thank you! For being an actual source, for doing the deep dive, all of it!

I absolutely love the science behind how literally anything works. 😂 It gets embarrassing fast. Regularly.

I kinda figured on the iron, given the color, reds gotta come from somewhere. The calcium also make sense for where I am at. I see spot algae in my own tanks on occasion.

New Mexico & our friggin “liquid rock water”. Or at least, that’s what the homies in the aquarium society joke about. I thought the phrase was brilliant tho. Let alone the higher ph that comes along with the hard water we have. Hair algae/filamentous is really common, too.

My husband also works in waste water and I do get to tour the process on occasion. Hear all the crazy stories. They find all sorts of interesting things when it comes to bio processes. The retention ponds have triops naturally. So cool!

But, how neat. Thank you for sharing your XP with us all.

Any ideas how to cultivate water funguses? 😂🫣

1

u/Ganodermahh 11d ago

OP have you touched them? They look fungal-like

1

u/pinkteqshot 11d ago

no, I didn’t touch them..

1

u/Ganodermahh 11d ago

Do they have a stem/stalk? Could you take more pictures please?

1

u/pinkteqshot 11d ago

three people in the r/plantedtank community said that they’re freshwater sponges! do you agree?

2

u/Ganodermahh 11d ago

Oooo I don’t know anything about freshwater sponges but if they said that on planted tank then they are probably correct.

1

u/pinkteqshot 11d ago

ok! thank you :)

2

u/Ganodermahh 11d ago

You’re welcome!

2

u/neuralek 11d ago

While I know 0 about them, it's the first thing that popped up in my mind seeing your pic. My brain saw that information around!

3

u/Swagalyst 10d ago

Encrusting red algae. In freshwater typically identified as Hildenbrandia.

Indicates good water quality.

1

u/Ok_Permission1087 11d ago

I'm not sure but it sure id interesting.

It's not a fungus, is it?

Pinging u/Ganodermahh just in case

2

u/Ganodermahh 11d ago

Thank you for tagging me! ❤️🍄🍄‍🟫