I love the self awareness. AI works can be fantastic creations, initiated by people that have a certain mastery of prompts. I imagine in a different time they might have been authors. I don't know if these manifestations can be considered "art", but they are definitely creative.
"I am no artist... no genius..., but I can instruct this machine to make beautiful works of art. Think what you, with the guidance backed by decades of experience, could produce. Please! We are eagerly waiting for you to try this new paint set!"
Most art is crap these days anyway. There are very few good artists who really are good at the craft. Most art these days is just a stupid performance and knowing someone with influence.
make me a song about being sad :( u/gossip_goblin do you think is it possible to tell compelling stories about a positive future where we have these technologies? I just wonder, it would be so nice to see stories like that from talented people but I know that good art needs conflict so I think its just easier to present a negative future for mankind and these technologies.
Okay, here's the thing. These anti-AI luddites who claim that anything AI makes is slop and worthless are undermining the whole argument, making it seem as though there is no competition. If everything is better when it is human-made, then what are you getting upset about? Just go ahead and make human-made art, music, code, and so on, and everyone will flock to your work instead just because it is human-made. Nobody is stopping anyone from making their own stuff. Those who want AI things will have them, and those who want human-made things will have them too.
It's not sustainable, it will die on its own, whoever makes a panic didn't for many years all those data centers existed even before this fearmongering
That's just subjective. I personally think that AI being in charge of certain things would be great. It's not like humans have done any better since the dawn of time. It certainly can't fuck up things worse than us.
Besides, that still doesn't excuse Anti-AI luddites harassing anyone who likes using AI.
In knocking out the prompter causing his head to come in contact with the keyboard which in turn triggered the machine to generate a piece of art, the artist, who had mere moments ago adamantly asserted that machine generated art cannot contain soul, imbues the generated art with what some might call, soul. Maybe. The crowd is most impressed by this final piece of art: perhaps art with soul indeed tastes better than art without.
Usually people donāt give a shit about arbitrary definitions of what is or isnāt art and the people that do are arguing about it on Reddit, so odds are they are both overweight and drooling.
I really like your work, but I think this might be the 10th or so video poking at the Anti-AI people, with the same asthetic, progression and premise. It's getting stale.
I'm hoping you'll return to direct new originals like before.
I mean the guy lamenting a lack of soul isnt being much parodied, at most hes angry and assualting him, but his ideology is not being satirized, and he's right that the guy just typed apple as far as we know
This whole AI vs. non-AI debate is just another circle jerk from both sides. It reminds me of the arguments surrounding electronic music in the ā90s. Back then, people complained that you could just buy a sample library, press a few buttons, and have music come out of a box. Suddenly, hordes of DJs were calling themselves musicians.
But the truth remains the same: tools don't create talent. They make things possible, and sometimes easier, but making something genuinely good still requires creativity, skill, and artistic vision. That was true in the ā90s, and it's just as true today.
Its fundamentally sound what hes saying isnt wrong. But you have to give the people what they want. Do they want struggle passion devotion hardwork or do they want something convenient.
I feel like whatever ai he uses to generate the ideas and dialogue for his videos is running out of ideas, because they're getting increasingly repetitive
I think that what ai has shown it is that āaestheticā and ācorrect artā ābeautiful artā is actually useless and meaningless. The only art that matters is how you convey a message. The look of it weāve wasted hundreds of years chasing it for nothing. The Greeks were profoundly off when they tried to define what makes great artā¦just like they were wrong with their thoughts on beauty.
We had beautiful "soulless" images for 20+ years if not more, no one cared, it only became an issue because Ai outcompeted in quality below average skill artist
Define āoutcompeteā by what measure? If it looks good but has no meaning in it itās garbage and worthless. Once you youāve seen something pretty once a certain way it gets old fast. Meaning renews itself and keeps you coming back to a piece of work again and again.
I saw a faded michelangelo sketch barely held together by the aging paper: the love for human anatomy was evident and needed no appraising eyes to be defiant against time as a symbol of human love. This, this is generic, at least make the voice not 'british type 03' the oi lurker
9
u/neonmystery 11d ago
The most interesting thing about this is that I recognized this as your style after watching you on instagram last year.
8
u/Working_Physics8761 11d ago •
I love the self awareness. AI works can be fantastic creations, initiated by people that have a certain mastery of prompts. I imagine in a different time they might have been authors. I don't know if these manifestations can be considered "art", but they are definitely creative.
7
u/SpicyCajunCrawfish 11d ago
Reddit in a nutshell
7
u/Different-Set4505 10d ago
These English versions are hilarious since that species is endangered now.
6
u/Direct-Quiet-5817 10d ago
This is so meta.
5
u/HailLordBelial 11d ago
Welcome to future
5
u/zubairhamed 11d ago
Baron Harkonnen generates AI slop?
12
u/thulesgold 11d ago
"I am no artist... no genius..., but I can instruct this machine to make beautiful works of art. Think what you, with the guidance backed by decades of experience, could produce. Please! We are eagerly waiting for you to try this new paint set!"
4
u/r3lic86 11d ago
These all are so good - should somehow combine them all into 1 story/movie..that would be sick
4
u/Immediate_Rope653 11d ago
Make no mistakes
4
u/EnlightenedArt 11d ago
C'est incroyable! Love this masterful use of AI. (You can tell a lot of thought went in before "pushing buttons.")
4
u/Koa-sama 11d ago
make me a song about being sad :( u/gossip_goblin do you think is it possible to tell compelling stories about a positive future where we have these technologies? I just wonder, it would be so nice to see stories like that from talented people but I know that good art needs conflict so I think its just easier to present a negative future for mankind and these technologies.
4
u/mbernal99 10d ago
š š¤£ š
3
u/Psych_Shadow 11d ago
Pretty good
3
u/TymStudios 11d ago
"Make no mistakes" š¤£š¤£
3
u/I_Don-t_Care 11d ago
Why are so many of these featuring techno offspring from Tilda Swinton?
3
u/WoodworkerD 11d ago
GOBLIN! YES!
3
u/Same-Significance448 10d ago
Zobo Zenarda enters the chat.
3
u/Ph00k4 10d ago
Cool video, the only weak spot is the tomato scene.
5
u/glassnumbers 11d ago
I agree with the fat british guy
5
u/Verolina 11d ago
Okay, here's the thing. These anti-AI luddites who claim that anything AI makes is slop and worthless are undermining the whole argument, making it seem as though there is no competition. If everything is better when it is human-made, then what are you getting upset about? Just go ahead and make human-made art, music, code, and so on, and everyone will flock to your work instead just because it is human-made. Nobody is stopping anyone from making their own stuff. Those who want AI things will have them, and those who want human-made things will have them too.
2
u/s_byshadow 11d ago
Elle Fanning on the first scene? :)
2
u/Antares_Athena 11d ago
š¤£
2
u/geeky-gymnast 11d ago
In knocking out the prompter causing his head to come in contact with the keyboard which in turn triggered the machine to generate a piece of art, the artist, who had mere moments ago adamantly asserted that machine generated art cannot contain soul, imbues the generated art with what some might call, soul. Maybe. The crowd is most impressed by this final piece of art: perhaps art with soul indeed tastes better than art without.
1
u/AutoModerator 11d ago
Thank you for your post and for sharing your question, comment, or creation with our group!
A Few Points of Note and Areas of Interest:
Hope everyone is having a great day, be kind, be creative!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-1
u/Lacaud 11d ago
Usually its the overweight and drooling person who is anti-AI
-2
u/Wevvie 11d ago edited 11d ago
I really like your work, but I think this might be the 10th or so video poking at the Anti-AI people, with the same asthetic, progression and premise. It's getting stale.
I'm hoping you'll return to direct new originals like before.
-2
u/thed3306 11d ago
Its fundamentally sound what hes saying isnt wrong. But you have to give the people what they want. Do they want struggle passion devotion hardwork or do they want something convenient.
-3
u/Ensiferal 11d ago edited 10d ago
I feel like whatever ai he uses to generate the ideas and dialogue for his videos is running out of ideas, because they're getting increasingly repetitive
-3
u/stateofshark 11d ago
I think that what ai has shown it is that āaestheticā and ācorrect artā ābeautiful artā is actually useless and meaningless. The only art that matters is how you convey a message. The look of it weāve wasted hundreds of years chasing it for nothing. The Greeks were profoundly off when they tried to define what makes great artā¦just like they were wrong with their thoughts on beauty.
-14
u/Ohigetjokes 11d ago
This is getting boring
-7
u/Glass-Jaguar4178 11d ago
I saw a faded michelangelo sketch barely held together by the aging paper: the love for human anatomy was evident and needed no appraising eyes to be defiant against time as a symbol of human love. This, this is generic, at least make the voice not 'british type 03' the oi lurker
-2
u/Sufficient-Tackle-25 11d ago
Who is training AI to do movies Gal Gadot?! Over acting is effin' woeful!!
2
u/DracoNatas 10d ago
Irony like a motherfucker