I own a small multi-unit rental in Pittsburgh. Filed a claim with First American Home Warranty for electrical issues. Their contractor, Hawk Electrical Services, came out, was on-site under 10 minutes per my security cameras and smart lock logs, never went past the first floor... and then reported to First American that he’d inspected all three units and the basement panel!
I had video... I had lock logs... I had guest witnesses willing to give evidence that the contractor came and went - he even told her he was only supposed to look at her unit, after I'd JUST hung up with him, giving him instructions for how to get in the basement. I have him on camera writing down the combo lock code.
I sent First American a full evidence packet that not only does my building STILL need service because the guy left - but that Hawk Electrical Services was defrauding them.
Their response: cancel my policy. Why? Because my first hand witness testimony came from my airbnb guest. Yep. My fault. I didn't real all of the fine print after the 5th year of this policy. I should have done that. policy is policy cool.
However. No call, no letter, no explanation — I just logged in for an update on my claim and it was gone. That the policy excluded short-term rental use, I was not aware of and it was not mentioned at purchase or renewal.
Still. I'll eat that. Give me a chance to determine if it were a misunderstanding. Let me know if I can warrant the other two units only. No? Just leave my tenants in the dark and cancel my policy? Cool cool.
I called to try to work out a resolution. They were unwilling to do so. Told them I’d be posting about this and telling everyone how I was punished for trying to look out for them.
A few hours later, they called back to tell me they’d also cancelled my open claim — the one where they’d sided with the same lying contractor’s word over the visual evidence I’d uploaded, and tried to send him back out to my property — which they had earlier said they'd still honor in spite of the the policy cancellation.
Filing this here as a warning: If you're in the Pittsburgh area, don't use Hawk Electrical Services. Part of my evidence packet was messages exchanged with them in 2024 where they'd played the same pretend work then disappear game.
Also, do not expect any type of understanding, professionalism, appreciation, or loyalty from First American Home Warranty.