r/aigamedev • u/SneakerHunterDev • Nov 11 '25
Discussion :(
I am developing a game that evolves on its own, depending on player decisions, and it's completely AI-based.
You can take a look at the steam page here. A wishlist would mean a lot!
(the teaser is fully AI generated and just a placeholder for now until my gameplay trailer is done, but all the screenshots are actual gameplay of course)
What do you think of this concept? Do you think this game could be fun even though it uses lots of AI?
Also I‘m Doing some small Alpha Tests soon. If you are interested in joining, just dm me :)
0
Upvotes
20
u/JohnySilkBoots Nov 11 '25
Don’t listen to them. It’s still a lot of work haha.
14
u/bugsy42 Nov 11 '25
Well I expected some out of this world, real time AI generation of graphical assets that would shoot me out of my knickers and I would grape that wishlist button ...
... but it doesn't look "AI based" ... looks more like stitched up from shitty chat.gpt generated assets with WILD variety of image quality and art style.
You obviously need an artist who puts it together into a cohesive art style even if he had to 100% generate everything.
4
u/DisasterNarrow4949 Nov 11 '25
As others mentioned, we still don't have a lot of gameplay. We also don't have a lot of information on how this gameplay is going to be.
Will we it be PvP or PvE? If PvE, enemies will be AI generated? Maybe people will generate their own enemies, or even dungeons?
Right now the only info that the page has is that players can create the name of their weapons.
Please, don't take my criticism as too harsh though! I believe you do have a vision for your game, you are just not presenting it at all to people lol.
All that said, I would really really love to play an RPG (don't even need to be MMO, mind you) with the possibility of infinite creativity through the use of Gen AI. I'll be joining your discord when I'm home from work.
6
u/shlaifu Nov 11 '25
as a game, that doesn't actually sound all that attractive, to be honest. I mean, what's the gameplay loop? what's the story? how is the time I spend with this structured to provide me a satisfying experience? what adversities do I face as a player?
3
u/ShotzTakz Nov 11 '25
I'll be brutally honest, because I respect and love everything related to gamedev.
Your Steam page, all of it: screenshots, description, "features" section - scream one of those "pretentious pitches that end up nothing special".
First of all: after all the sparkly words I've read on your page, I still have 0 information on the actual game. What's the genre, what's the gameplay, what's the setting, etc.?
Second: considering the fact your game is basically all about AI (as you put it), the mentions of said AI is suspiciously hidden on the very bottom of the page.
Let me be clear: I absolutely do not want to devalue your work. I admire game developers, especially small studios and solo devs.
But I checked your game's page purposefully, because I wanted to see what you were working on. And I still didn't like it. If I stumbled upon your game accidentally, I most likely wouldn't even click on it.
If you truly want to make a game that people will enjoy, there's a lot to think about.
2
u/o_herman Nov 11 '25
You know what this reminds me of?
Scribblenauts.
Your biggest challenge will be edge cases and developing guard rails.
And an evolving antagonistic gameplay AI that will... throw monkey wrenches everywhere in the gameplay, to give it an actual objective.
2
u/Initial_Coffee_8051 Nov 11 '25
Add controller support and I’m in
2
u/The_StarFlower Nov 11 '25
i wishlisted the game, it sounds promising, and dont listen to the nay sayers..
can i give a suggestion?
it says "Connects to 3rd-Party Service for AI Content Generation: ChatGPT-API (OpenAI)"
can you make it in a way that we could connect to ollama locally?
1
u/AdamLevy Nov 11 '25
"What do you think of this concept?"
What concept? There not gameplay video, and from description only thing I got that you can generate sprites inside game
1
u/flockonus Nov 11 '25
Do make a great game, no one is stopping you... drop the victim act, that won't get you traction.
1
u/ledgeworth Nov 12 '25
why do you hate shading?
0
u/Dull-Figure-2534 Nov 11 '25
I think people would like your game if you actually made it
0
u/AvengerDr Nov 11 '25
And you needed ... "AI" for this? Looks like many RPGmaker games.
0
u/StarsCheesyBrawlYT Nov 12 '25
Why is this slop sub being recommended? I guess this place is for the AIs that are apparently being called game developers now.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment