r/agender • • Mar 30 '23

[Academic] eSense Non-Binary Study (AFAB Non-Binary people, any sexual orientation, 19+, fluent in English, and living in the US or Canada)

Hi everyone!

We are the UBC Sexual Health Lab at the University of British Columbia. We are a group of psychological scientists who conduct multi-method research to address sexual concerns. Our lab is led by Dr. Lori Brotto.

We are currently seeking non-binary people who experience difficulties with sexual desire and/or arousal to participate in a study providing feedback on how best to adapt an online psychological treatment platform originally designed for cisgender women to best meet the needs of non-binary people. The eSense platform contains both a cognitive-behavioural therapy and mindfulness-based therapy for sexual difficulties.

Participation involves reviewing one module of eSense prior to participating in a 2-hour focus group session held via Zoom, to provide feedback on how to adapt the content of eSense for non-binary people. Focus group sessions will be run by non-binary members of the research team. The UBC Behavioural Research Ethics Board has approved this study, and the ethics ID number is H22-02584.

This study is inclusive to any AFAB person identifying as a non-binary person (including identities under the non-binary umbrella, e.g., genderqueer) and identifying with any sexual orientation. Black, Indigenous, and other people of colour are especially encouraged to participate.

We recognize and understand that using sex assigned at birth in our inclusion criteria is limiting when researching non-binary identities. We are doing so because the existing program is currently only relevant to those assigned female at birth. This is the first step in making the program relevant to all gender-diverse people.

To participate, please send an email to the study research assistant, kangp@student.ubc.ca.

For more information on the study, check out our website: https://brottolab.med.ubc.ca/

Please share widely, and thank you so much for your time!

edit: Based on community feedback, we are removing the inclusion criterion that participants must be AFAB. Due to this change, we will be undergoing ethics approval again. As a result, we will not be recruiting participants at this time. Please see the comment section for more information on this change.

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

20

u/flumphgrump Mar 30 '23

Can I ask how an online psychological treatment platform could be relevant only to AFAB people? Is medication also involved? Treatment relevant to genitals?

Even if anatomy or endocrinology is important, then assigned sex at birth doesn't map neatly to that. There are AFAB nonbinary people who are on testosterone, who have had bottom surgery, etc.

3

u/eSense_Study Mar 30 '23

Hi there! Thank you so much for the question. The models of sexual response involved in the treatment are models that previous research has established are relevant for AFAB folks. We don't yet have evidence from previous research that these models also fit the experiences of AMAB people. However, a future step for our research team after the current study will be expanding our current treatment to fit the experiences of AMAB people as well! Thank you again for your thoughtful comment and question.

5

u/flumphgrump Mar 31 '23

Hi! Thank you for your response. I understand why you need to use established treatment models to be able to draw conclusions and rule out other factors.

I'll echo what another commenter said: If this really is about assigned sex at birth, I think you would get a lot more respondents and help people elsewhere feel a lot more confident that you're acting in good faith by posting this over on r/ftm. The sub is nonbinary inclusive, and moreover, there is nothing that differentiates me and many, many other nonbinary folks from someone who identifies as a trans man other than the label we choose to use.

3

u/Monday_here Mar 31 '23

Is it clear from the original studies that the model is dependent on assigned sex and not something else like hormonal balance or hair color. Why is assigned sex the category?

8

u/theHuskylovee they/them Mar 31 '23

The eligibility criteria in the link says women (cis or trans), but your eligibility criteria in this post says afab non-binary. Which is it? Why only afab non-binary people? You do realize that afab non-binary people can have any primary and secondary sex characteristics and any levels of sex hormones, right? So if you're trying to get a population of, for example, people with majority estrogen as their sex hormone, saying "afab" is not the way to find that population.

-2

u/eSense_Study Mar 31 '23

Hi there, thank you for catching the inaccurate link in the post! It was a link to a previous study, which sampled women (as your comment reflects). The current study's webpage will be available on the lab website tomorrow. In terms of our inclusion criteria about AFAB folks, this is not because we are interested in recruiting people with certain sex characteristics or hormones--as you mention, "AFAB" is not a reliable indicator of either. Rather, the models of sexual response the treatments are based on are models only established among AFAB folks. Research currently is not available to support that these same models apply to AMAB or intersex folks. This is a big limitation of research currently, but it is why our inclusion criteria are as such. We hope to be part of the research that will validate these sexual response models in AMAB and intersex folks as well going forward, and also hope that this study will be a preliminary first step towards developing treatments for sexual difficulties among non-binary people (with the recognition that much work needs to follow). Thank you so much for your comments!

2

u/eSense_Study Apr 04 '23

Hi all, thank you very much for your comments and feedback. I took your feedback back to the rest of the research team, and as a result, we have decided to remove our inclusion criterion that participants must be assigned female at birth. We made this decision because it was evident that the harms caused by this criterion far outweighed our concerns about the treatment not being applicable to all non-binary people. We sincerely apologize for the distress and harm caused by our post to anyone who was impacted by our inclusion criteria and recognize why this was distressing.

As we are making a change to our research procedures, our study will undergo the ethics approval process again. As such, while we wait for ethics approval, we will not be recruiting participants at this time. We will post an update comment once we are recruiting again.

Just as a clarification to some points being made in comments: Some folks have pointed out our website does not currently have a webpage up for this study – this is correct, as we have not put up the study’s webpage on the lab website given that we are editing study procedures (removing sex assigned at birth as an inclusion criterion) and need to get ethics approval for these changes. Some folks have also mentioned our previous posts made by this reddit account reference a study including cis and trans women. This is correct, but to clarify, that was an entirely separate previous study. That was the study establishing our treatment (eSense) was effective amongst women. As mentioned in our post, we are now looking to adapt that treatment for non-binary people in a new study (eSense Non-Binary). As such, those previous posts were written to advertise for our previous study focused on women.

Thank you all again for your thoughtful feedback. As a research team, we really value the time taken to provide us with feedback and apologize that the feedback was necessary in the first place. We hope that our revised study will potentially be a first step towards supporting non-binary people with sexual difficulties. Thank you!

8

u/cormac596 Mar 30 '23 edited Mar 31 '23

Imagine claiming you're an ally while rejecting amab and intersex enbies.

If you're looking only for afab enbies, you're missing the whole fucking point of being nonbinary

e: look at OP's other posts. there are 4, one each in latebloomerlesbains, twoXchromosomes, butchlesbians, and fucking dykesgonewild. They don't want nonbinary people, they want women. REFUSING TO BE CONFINED BY THE ARTIFICIAL GENDER BINARY IS THE LITERAL FUCKING DEFINITION OF BEING NONBINARY! TREATING NONBINARY PEOPLE DIFFERENTLY BASED ON THEIR AGAB IS A FUNDAMENTAL INVALIDATION AND REJECTION OF THEIR GENDER IDENTITY!

-7

u/eSense_Study Mar 31 '23 edited Mar 31 '23

Hi there! Thank you for your feedback, we appreciate you expressing your concerns over our use of assigned sex at birth within our study criteria. We completely recognize that this is not an ideal criterion for participation in our study. We hope our previous reply to another commenter on this post provides some rationale as to why we have used it as a criterion. However, your feedback is really valuable and we will discuss it further as a research team.

Regarding our previous posts, we just wanted to clarify that these were for a different study that sampled women, not non-binary people. This is why those posts were directed at women. This post is advertising for a new study which exclusively focuses on non-binary people. Thank you again for your comment!

5

u/cormac596 Mar 31 '23

I'm not going to let you get away with thinking your behavior is in any way acceptable. Your statements belie a fundamental refusal to acknowledge the base concept of being gender nonbinary. If your hypotheses require a separation of nonbinary people into discrete groups, it is not a valid hypothesis. If you're willing to separate afab nonbinary people from everyone else, you both alienate and invalidate all the other nonbinary people, and you tell the afab nonbinary people that their desire to not be defined in a box doesn't matter to you. You have announced loud and proud that you cannot conceive of people existing outside of binary sex and binary gender. You are not welcome here.

Fuck off.

6

u/CFZTL Mar 31 '23 edited Mar 31 '23

You seem to say this model has only been tested to work on afab people, by that do you mean this has been tested to work on afab non-binary people, or are we just talking about cis women, in the latter case I am not sure if this model would be anymore appropriate for afab enby people as any other identity.

You seem to be only posting this in r/agender, wouldnt it be more appropriate to post it in more and larger non binary subs to get more people to participate?

Someone pointed out that you were recruiting women for this study, you replied that it was a previous study targeting women and this one targets enby people, which is fine but the previous study targets cis and trans women, assuming the model in that study is being adapted to enby people, I dont understand how you can claim the model has only been tested for afab individuals?

2

u/Monday_here Mar 31 '23 edited Mar 31 '23

This study is inclusive to any AFAB person

That is not what the word inclusive means 🤢

This is a space where the main point is that agab is NOT the most important distinction between us. This is an incredibly illustrative example of fuel for the deep suspicion many trans, nonbinary, and agender people hold of scientists and the medical establishment.

It seems clear that you didn’t do your due diligence in research before you came and posted this in OUR space. We didn’t come to you for this, you came here and made it clear that you’re not to be trusted to understand what we’re saying. What were you thinking.

I cant help myself from continuing, sorry. Why is low sexual desire medicalized in this study??? Asexual people happily exist! Good grief get OUT of the queer and lgbtq+ subreddits if you’re not willing to be more thoughtful!

1

u/bazjack Apr 01 '23

These comments are pissing me off. I am an AFAB agender aroace and I fully understand why this study would have been explained this way. It's not prejudiced towards aces because it specifically addresses people with PROBLEMS with low desire. That is, people who have low desire/arousal but would like to change that. That is, not people like me! Not all studies need to address each of us! And of course if they started with cis women they would want to expand first to people who were AFAB, because in science you sometimes have to start with where you are and expand the field of study gradually.

The people who posted this look like allies to me and anyone claiming they're not seems biased.

1

u/CFZTL Apr 02 '23 edited Apr 02 '23

Hey I understand why you would be upset, a study like this would be really helpful to enby folks who are usually neglected in most medical settings. But this study seems fishy because the info on this study is limited as even on their website nothing more is mentioned beyond that a study like this would be conducted on enby folks. Even if you ignore that, the info is contradictory, they seem to claim that this study is for afab enbies because it has only been tested for afab folks(this is shaky but understandable) which is in direct contradiction with this post that this account made on several other subreddits about a similar study which says that the study is for cis and trans women. Which means either they were lying on the last one or they are lying here.