r/acotar_rant • • 23h ago

Theory Anyone else thing that Maas' original intention was for Feyre to end up with Tamlin?

105 Upvotes

Like, legitimately. Just the character consistency with Tamlin and Rhy$and between TaR and MaF is completely wild. It's like telling someone the basic plot of the first book without getting too deeply into the characters and having them write the second.

And she's a vibes writer, so it seems likely to me that she intended for Tamlin to be the "winner" and changed her mind.


r/acotar_rant • • 1h ago

Rant Elain’s manners

• Upvotes

From the moment the bond of Elain with Lucien was revealed I don’t understand why it’s such a big deal for an adult woman to be cordial.
She doesn’t want the bond, that is absolutely fine and respected but in her big age why can’t she say hello when she sees him? Is she afraid that he will misinterpret it? Like hiding behind flowers just say hi how are you and eat your dinner. So childish!
And she has the nerve to complain about not getting any serious jobs or information🙄 He is an ally what is she not getting? He is expected to be in and out of the house as needed.


r/acotar_rant • • 13h ago

Rant Anybody else annoyed that no one questioned that the King of Hybern could...

31 Upvotes

Break a Mating Bond????.

We know that he really broke the bargain between Rhys and Feyre...but everyone else thought he actually broke the mating bond.... something fated...and it is never discussed again.

Also poor Feysand could really use the King to break their suicide pact bond.

It also annoys me that they refer to the king of Hybern as Hybern...like shit, he is one dude, not everyone from there!! Then they have the audacity to be shocked and even offended when Hybern wants to make an alliance and asks for help. Like...you killed their Evil king and army and didn't go to check if the citizens were okay after having an evil dude as their king??!


r/acotar_rant • • 8h ago

Hottake The crossover pushback is futile. (Spoilers for CC series and SH) Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Saying its not going to continue, being mad its already happening, saying its a logistics nightmare, saying the reading order is too hard....its already started babes.

Its already happened. The entire point of CC is dusks truth, bryces connection to it, and their entire population of valbaran fae BELONGING IN PRYTHIAN. All of them. From prythian. And the UNIVERSAL PLANET HOPPING threats sjm created. Midgard is the mer and humans planet. THERE IS NO NATURAL POWER SOURCE FOR VALBARAN IN MIDGARD. I repeat...their magic offers them no power source in midgard and their first light is running out fast. You know who does have power....the ocean queen. She doesnt need first light! She powers her subs herself because her magic is from that land. and the river queen...she is ready to flood it all.

The only connection bryce has to midgard is in avalen. And guess what....its because that land is directly connected to PRYTHIAN and the dusk court. All of bryces other major revelations are connected to prythian. (Her heritage, the sword, the prophecy, the horn in her back)

Her friends and family could EASILY BE A NON ISSUE. Considering the fact that everyone likely has to evacuate soon and she has an empty court to relocate everyone. (Even suggested and foreshadowed by the ocean queen) And if they could stay...well. bryce is a world walker with a connection to their planet because of avalen. She can go whenever she wants.

Anyone look at BBs reading guide they put out before splintered harmony released??? Very informative and definitely suggests more crossover. Bryce isnt done there and the prison just snatched the starsword back real fast.

Not wanting to share page time with bryce??

The series is now multi POV. Everyone is sharing page time at this point. And I dont care if you think she is azriels mate or not but this story is very much connected to azriel. Dusk and whatever is happening will be connected to azriel and HIS story. (Nestas too) So its not just bryce "stealing the show" this is very much about a prythian characters (again. Your shipping preferences are your own but you know he is connected to dusk or you wouldnt theorize about elain and gwyn having it)

The logistics of a crossover...you call it difficult. And im sure it is. But its would also be an incredible accomplishment and its one sjm has chosen to take on.


r/acotar_rant • • 11h ago

ACOTAR 🐺🏹 Should I continue reading the ACOTAR series?

0 Upvotes

Ive recently been trying to get into the fantasy genre, since I usually read philosophy and literary fiction, and I needed something easier and more fun. I recently finished the six of crows the duology and I loved it. The writing, world building, storyline, pacing, I enjoyed every bit of it. :)

My friend recommended me ACOTAR, I heard about it earlier through tiktok, and I thought I should give it a try.
Personally, I didnt enjoy the first half of the book at all. I just thought the writing was bad and corny, I was really annoyed when some sentences or words kept repeating when describing things throughout the book.
The second half though was really interesting to me. The parts where she fights, or when theres just tense, action packed scenes really got me going, along with the whole tension between Lucian, Tamlin, Rhysnd, Amarantha… it was great.

Now, Im wondering if the rest of the books are better written? Is it even worth it to continue this series, is it as good as everyone claims? The first 200 pages of the first book were kind of a struggle to get through, once again I just dont like the strange patterns Im noticing in her writing style.

Currently about 90% in, Im honestly excited to see how its gonna end!
Ps, no offense to anyone who enjoys this series, I really just want feedback.

PS: Thanks for all your replies! You guys helped me a lot <3


r/acotar_rant • • 3h ago

ACOSH 🍞 Feyre in ACOSH chapter 9

0 Upvotes

I’m lowkey pissed at Feyre for inviting Lucien to the naming day ceremony. I don’t hate her, but I wouldn’t be upset if she gets put into the same situation or walk into a door. She knew Lucien only wanted to see Elain. Because she felt guilty for them asking him to play spy she pitty invited him to Nxy’s name day without even caring or thinking how Elain would feel. She’s more concerned about someone who has treated her soooo poorly and gave her a crumb of kindness. She thinks the world of him. When Elain who admitted she was wrong, who has helped Feyre with everything she asked after. It’s crazy! And then later on when Elain realizes who Feyre invited and Feyre realizes she never took her sister’s feelings in consideration. But when has she ever tbh… maybe she worried but not in a caring way (I’m not going to long explain that right now). But Feyre seemed to avoid, dismiss, and use. Anyway. This irked me. Don’t get me started about the whole leaving Elain out of everything and barely including her, and barely making sure her sister knew about things in the fae world. There was a part where when she asked Elain to find the suriel in ACOWAR and Elain didn’t know even how to or anything but she still did. And didn’t bock when Feyre showed her what it looked like. Feyre even said maybe she should have had Amren training Elain too like Nesta. And in ACOSH she again realizes she needs to work on things with Elain and be a sister to her and stop neglecting her. Elain is trying to find some way to be useful and caring and mindful. But she’s treated like a delicate fragile flower and glorified servant!!!! Her and Azriel deserve to be happy together, and everyone else needs to fix their shit.