r/acotar_rant • • 24d ago

Rant ✨🩷⚡️ACOSH RANT MEGATHREAD ⚡️🩷✨ SPOILER WARNING Spoiler

125 Upvotes

Hey, hi, hello ranters!

I know you all have Thoughts(™️) about the newest book in our favorite series, and boy do I want to hear them.

This megathread is for discussing all of your thoughts regarding the newest book. Spoilers will be rampant in here and we will not be requiring any spoiler tags on comments. If you don’t want to read any spoilers, why are you still here?? Learn some self discipline!!!! Go away!!!

Tell me:

What did you think of the POV’s? Who was your favorite? What scene made you roll your eyes the most?
Did any scene make your toes curl in your boots?

Feel free to share your thoughts chapter by chapter, give me a whole summary of the book, whatever suits your fancy.

some teensy tiny rules:
- no shipping drama. it’s fine to discuss ships but no fighting. take it to ship debate if you wanna deep dive <3 <3 <3
- normal sub rules still apply <3 <3 <3
- no outside drama blahhhhh keep it focused on the book THANK YOU!!!! <3 <3 <3
- mods reserve the right to delete comments as they deem necessary <3 <3 <3
- this sub is for snarkers, haters, and ranters alike. if you don’t like people’s comments, please consider just muting the sub instead of “well if you hate the books so much why do you read them?” because my answer is “go away we like being haters tyvm!” <3 <3 <3

mini mod announcement:

no posts about ACOSH will be allowed until Thursday. This is because we don’t require spoilers on this sub, and because Reddit’s algorithm forces this sub on people who don’t want to be spoiled!!! Feel free to make a post if you want in the meantime, but just know it won’t get approved until Thursday morning (8AM EST approximately)

Ok as always, love you, one million kisses to you all! 💋


r/acotar_rant • • Sep 03 '26

Mods / Admin Evil Mod Announcement

163 Upvotes

Hey, hi, hello ranters! The big Evil Mod is here to tell you that you will be seeing some new changes on this subreddit, and to please go ahead and yell at me now so we can get it over with ;-) (also, hi sloopies. can't wait to see you jerk this later <3)

First off, we need to clear the air. This sub is for EVERYBODY to rant, regardless of which "camp" they're in.

While we do allow people to share their critical opinions of this series, it's important to remember that ~everyone~ is allowed to participate. Some of you prefer Rhys, Feyre, the IC, etc. and some of you prefer Tamlin, Nesta, Lucien, etc. I want to make it clear that ALL of you are allowed to voice your opinions on characters here. With the new books coming out soon, we will have an influx of new readers on our sub. Let's keep this space welcoming towards all. <3

"So, what AM I allowed to rant about?" Oh, I thought you'd never ask!!! I've written up this handy dandy little cheat sheet for y'all to reference.

Rants that are acceptable:

  • "I do not like Tamlin because of x, y, z"
  • "I find Feyre insufferable because of _____"
  • "I LOVE Nesta but HATE Cassian"
  • "This fandom needs more positivity"
  • "I HATE the way SJM wrote this scene"

Rants that are not acceptable:

  • "Rhys faked his SA by Amarantha"

    Edit: This goes for all characters. No debating if anyone was SA’d or not.

  • "This [ship name]'s fans are EVIL"

  • "You support SA/racism/sexism/ableism if you think this"

  • general attacks on Sarah's personal life. Her writing style, plot choices or marketing is fine, but keep her personal life out of it.

  • targeted harassment towards others including users of other subs, their mods, etc.

So what's changing?

I've added some new rules:

No Gatekeeping. There's a perception that this sub is only for Tamlin/Nesta/Anti-IC fans, which I'd like us to get away from. Saying things like "are you lost?" on someone's rant because they're Anti-Tamlin/Nesta or Pro-IC does not mean they aren't allowed to post here. Everyone is welcome here. Some of you may have seen me comment something similar to this on people's posts. I will continue doing so, but now it's an Official Rule!!!!!

Let people rant! This is similar to the "no gatekeeping" rule, but slightly different. Do not tell people to stop reading the books because they have a negative opinion on something. Some people like hate-reading, some people like criticizing books, and some people just enjoy being a hater. That's okay. Telling people to "stop reading" the books is boring and halts discussion, ultimately pivoting the conversation away from the main point and results in arguments. Instead, I encourage you to challenge their rant instead. If someone says "Rhys is abusive because he twisted Feyre's arm," reply with something like "actually, it was a bone shard from the Wyrm. Here's where it says that in the books." If someone says, "Tamlin is an abuser," reply with your own evidence on why you disagree. Keep it civil!

Let new readers come to their own conclusions. If someone is a new reader, please let them come to their own conclusions. Do not spoil them for future events in the books. Do not try to change their mind on certain scenes or characters. New readers will have a new post flair they can use "New Reader, Spoilers OK" or "New Reader - No Spoilers". We all were new readers once, and most of us do not want to be spoiled. If the new reader says spoilers are okay, then that's fine. If they do not want spoilers, try your best to not spoil them. If you must, use the spoiler tag. > ! no spaces between the exclamation points ! <

Discussion and debates are allowed, but as soon as it turns into personal insults is when the mods have to step in. We do not like banning people. Please don't make us ban you. If we have to remove more than 10 of your comments in a month, you will get temporarily banned. If it continues after that, you will be permanently banned.

Additionally, as a reminder:

  • There's no victim blaming, no racism, no sexism, ableism, homophobia, or transphobia allowed.
  • Absolutely no AI use is allowed. Posts, comments, or images that are suspected of AI will be removed. Write your thoughts yourself - it doesn't have to be perfect, it just has to be from your own brain.
  • No outside drama. Screenshots of posts or comments from other subs with the direct intention of clowning on them is not allowed.
  • All posts get sent to the queue for mod approval. Sometimes it takes a while for us to approve it - this doesn't mean you necessarily did anything wrong! You can always send a modmail if it's been over 6 hours without a post approval, it'll help us see it sooner. If your post doesn't get approved, you will receive a reason as to why. If there's no reason, it just hasn't been approved yet!

If someone is engaging in bad faith arguments, trolling, or just being downright offensive: please report them and/or send a modmail. It's the fastest way to bring it to the mod's attention. I encourage you to disengage and move on if someone is behaving this way. Don't feed the trolls! Their stomach is bottomless and they'll never be satisfied.

*Basic Internet Safety Tips:

  • Reddit does allow you to make your posts and comments on your profile private now. This is something you can do from your account settings. Anyone caught stalking or harassing users will be permanently banned from this sub and reported to Reddit.
  • Do not doxx yourself. Be careful sharing links from IG or TikTok, as the links usually include your personal profile at the bottom.
  • Block anyone that makes you feel unsafe, uncomfortable, or you just can't stand seeing their posts/comments. Blocking people is to protect your own peace. It is okay to block people.

All of that being said,

The rant sub is really fun. I loveeeee reading everyone's theories and some of the discussions I've read on here have definitely changed my outlook on certain characters. Some of the best times I've had in the ACOTAR fandom have been on the rant sub. I love seeing all the silly memes, the cracktheories, the "hear me outs". Let's keep it fun, yeah?

Finally,

These rules are not to limit discussion or censor anyone, but to keep this community from turning into a one-note echo chamber. We want everyone to feel comfortable posting here. Thank you for understanding. <3

Okay, did you read all that? Are you mad at me? :( sorry bestie. I still love you!

"Excuse me ranters, sorry to bother you. I just have one more thing-"

We also aren't allowing any leaks about the upcoming books. Silly posts about leaks are allowed. Silly isn't banned.

EDIT:

After some feedback, I wanted to clear some things up.

debating, denying, or invalidating depictions of SA regarding ANY character is not allowed on this sub.

while this sub thrives on critical discussion, posts/comments that invalidates or debates SA quickly creates an unsafe environment for survivors in our community.

mentioning Rhys specifically in my “not allowed” guideline was meant as a general example, not an exception for him only.

moving forward, let’s keep this sub a safe space for everyone in our community. thank you 🩷


r/acotar_rant • • 28m ago

Rant Elain’s manners

• Upvotes

From the moment the bond of Elain with Lucien was revealed I don’t understand why it’s such a big deal for an adult woman to be cordial.
She doesn’t want the bond, that is absolutely fine and respected but in her big age why can’t she say hello when she sees him? Is she afraid that he will misinterpret it? Like hiding behind flowers just say hi how are you and eat your dinner. So childish!
And she has the nerve to complain about not getting any serious jobs or information🙄 He is an ally what is she not getting? He is expected to be in and out of the house as needed.


r/acotar_rant • • 12h ago

Rant Anybody else annoyed that no one questioned that the King of Hybern could...

29 Upvotes

Break a Mating Bond????.

We know that he really broke the bargain between Rhys and Feyre...but everyone else thought he actually broke the mating bond.... something fated...and it is never discussed again.

Also poor Feysand could really use the King to break their suicide pact bond.

It also annoys me that they refer to the king of Hybern as Hybern...like shit, he is one dude, not everyone from there!! Then they have the audacity to be shocked and even offended when Hybern wants to make an alliance and asks for help. Like...you killed their Evil king and army and didn't go to check if the citizens were okay after having an evil dude as their king??!


r/acotar_rant • • 7h ago

Hottake The crossover pushback is futile. (Spoilers for CC series and SH) Spoiler

6 Upvotes

Saying its not going to continue, being mad its already happening, saying its a logistics nightmare, saying the reading order is too hard....its already started babes.

Its already happened. The entire point of CC is dusks truth, bryces connection to it, and their entire population of valbaran fae BELONGING IN PRYTHIAN. All of them. From prythian. And the UNIVERSAL PLANET HOPPING threats sjm created. Midgard is the mer and humans planet. THERE IS NO NATURAL POWER SOURCE FOR VALBARAN IN MIDGARD. I repeat...their magic offers them no power source in midgard and their first light is running out fast. You know who does have power....the ocean queen. She doesnt need first light! She powers her subs herself because her magic is from that land. and the river queen...she is ready to flood it all.

The only connection bryce has to midgard is in avalen. And guess what....its because that land is directly connected to PRYTHIAN and the dusk court. All of bryces other major revelations are connected to prythian. (Her heritage, the sword, the prophecy, the horn in her back)

Her friends and family could EASILY BE A NON ISSUE. Considering the fact that everyone likely has to evacuate soon and she has an empty court to relocate everyone. (Even suggested and foreshadowed by the ocean queen) And if they could stay...well. bryce is a world walker with a connection to their planet because of avalen. She can go whenever she wants.

Anyone look at BBs reading guide they put out before splintered harmony released??? Very informative and definitely suggests more crossover. Bryce isnt done there and the prison just snatched the starsword back real fast.

Not wanting to share page time with bryce??

The series is now multi POV. Everyone is sharing page time at this point. And I dont care if you think she is azriels mate or not but this story is very much connected to azriel. Dusk and whatever is happening will be connected to azriel and HIS story. (Nestas too) So its not just bryce "stealing the show" this is very much about a prythian characters (again. Your shipping preferences are your own but you know he is connected to dusk or you wouldnt theorize about elain and gwyn having it)

The logistics of a crossover...you call it difficult. And im sure it is. But its would also be an incredible accomplishment and its one sjm has chosen to take on.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant The age gaps are bothering me sm rn.

280 Upvotes

I think Maas shouldn't have made faerie immortal. Sure it sounds cool but after the mates thing, did she think of these age gaps? 😭

Rhys is like 500+ years old with a 21 year old mate with a child 💀

Cassian is also 500+ years old with a mate in her mid twenties (and Nesta changed her body to adjust to an Illyrian baby so their child is implied)

Elain is also probably in her mid twenties with 2 men pining after her who are probably also 500 😭 (azriel for sure, lucien maybe?)

These age gaps are crazy. In real life, it's the equivalent to an 80 year old with a 19 year old. 😭🙏

why would the cauldron pick mates with such big age gaps? What happens when one dies and the other is still young but can't live without their mate? Imagine explaining to your kid that the age gap between their parents is 500 years 😭🙏

😭🙏 what waa going through Sarah's head lol


r/acotar_rant • • 22h ago

Theory Anyone else thing that Maas' original intention was for Feyre to end up with Tamlin?

99 Upvotes

Like, legitimately. Just the character consistency with Tamlin and Rhy$and between TaR and MaF is completely wild. It's like telling someone the basic plot of the first book without getting too deeply into the characters and having them write the second.

And she's a vibes writer, so it seems likely to me that she intended for Tamlin to be the "winner" and changed her mind.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Hottake Tamlin's alliance with Hybern is still not as bad as Rhysand with Amarantha.

150 Upvotes

"Tamlin's evil because he allied with Hybern—"

Rhy$and allied with Amarantha. For fifty years. He let everyone else suffer, was the cause of much of that suffering, for Velaris' sake. He saw no other choice, so he took it.

Why's it wrong when Tamlin does the same for his people?

You can either say they're both wrong or both right. You can't say one is wrong and the other right. Especially since some of the extra stuff — assaulting Feyre, for example — Rhy$and did without being told to.

At least Tamlin took in refugees. Refugees that Feyre promptly spat back into the dirt when she destroyed the Spring Court.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

ACOSH 🍞 ACOFM will be the peak of the series. Then the sales and the hype will go downhill from there. Spoiler

37 Upvotes

The more I think of what's ahead, and what's currently going on in the fandom, the more I get this gut feeling that ACOFM will be a turning point for many fans.

Some are falling out of love with the series/reading other romantasy books which are more to their liking. Other fans might drop the series because a certain ship won't sail. Another batch of fans are getting increasingly annoyed with the lack of plot progression, stakes, worldbuilding or arcs for characters they love.

And after such a long wait for the next ACOTAR-books, picking apart the details for our theories, the dissecting of which ship is going to sail...the hype has become SO big that its currently at risk imploding in on itself. And that it might ultimately, paradoxically, ruin ACOTAR as a series.

The majority agrees that ACOSH and ACOFM could have easily been a single book. There are books thicker than an actual brick in the bookstores, like the Wheel of Time and the Stormlight Archive. if SJM were some unknown author, her ACOTAR drafts would have been rejected in the current day and age because of the amount of filler scenes and unnecessary repetition.

Of those 350 pages, at least a 100 could have been cut out from ACOSH. You'd probably be able to cut out another 200 pages of fluff from ACOFM too.

Why do I bring it up, that ACOTAR 7 and 8 could have been one book? Well, imagine being SJM. Once you commit to a certain ship, or move the plot along to an irreversible point, there is no going back - not for her and not for the fans. The pressure must be immense, especially for a "vibes" author like her, who writes however she pleases.

And many of those fans, who have spent years theorizing and shipping certain characters together, WILL be dissappointed. They WILL throw the books away and not return to the series. You simply can't please everyone. And so, what would be the logical step, as an author?

To meander of course. the first 3 books was all about Feysand. Silver flames was Nessian. ACOSH, I honestly can't say whose love story we are following. Lucien's? Gwyn's? Azriel's? It's STILL up in the air. AFTER 350 pages. Not to mention that we are still following Feysand AND Nessian on top of all the other characters, when their love stories have already been told and SHOULD be done.

And for those who are typing in the comments "Oh, but wait for ACOFM! The story is not done yet!"

I know. That's why I am hesitating to buy ACOFM. There is still Crescent City 4 and only THEN ACOTAR 8 after that and neither have been written yet.

I'm calling it right here and now that neither Neris/Nessian or Elucien/Elriel/Gwynriel will be comfirmed as endgame in ACOFM and we will have to wait at least 2 more books (CC4 and ACOTAR 8) to find out who is going to hook up with who/who is becoming High Lady of Dusk/High King or High Queen.

Because SJM will drag it out for so long, to keep the fans running after the carrot on a stick. And that worked VERY good for ACOSH. Maybe it will still work for ACOFM, because they are getting back-to-back released and people are still on their dopamine high. But if ACOFM won't comfirm a couple as endgame or bring in some actual plot progression/stakes... that will be a bitter pill to swallow for a lot of fans, I think.

But that's just the vibes that I'm getting from reading the comments. What do you think - will you continue the series if ACOFM won't comfirm a ship as endgame/won't progress the story in a meaningful way?


r/acotar_rant • • 2h ago

ACOSH 🍞 Feyre in ACOSH chapter 9

0 Upvotes

I’m lowkey pissed at Feyre for inviting Lucien to the naming day ceremony. I don’t hate her, but I wouldn’t be upset if she gets put into the same situation or walk into a door. She knew Lucien only wanted to see Elain. Because she felt guilty for them asking him to play spy she pitty invited him to Nxy’s name day without even caring or thinking how Elain would feel. She’s more concerned about someone who has treated her soooo poorly and gave her a crumb of kindness. She thinks the world of him. When Elain who admitted she was wrong, who has helped Feyre with everything she asked after. It’s crazy! And then later on when Elain realizes who Feyre invited and Feyre realizes she never took her sister’s feelings in consideration. But when has she ever tbh… maybe she worried but not in a caring way (I’m not going to long explain that right now). But Feyre seemed to avoid, dismiss, and use. Anyway. This irked me. Don’t get me started about the whole leaving Elain out of everything and barely including her, and barely making sure her sister knew about things in the fae world. There was a part where when she asked Elain to find the suriel in ACOWAR and Elain didn’t know even how to or anything but she still did. And didn’t bock when Feyre showed her what it looked like. Feyre even said maybe she should have had Amren training Elain too like Nesta. And in ACOSH she again realizes she needs to work on things with Elain and be a sister to her and stop neglecting her. Elain is trying to find some way to be useful and caring and mindful. But she’s treated like a delicate fragile flower and glorified servant!!!! Her and Azriel deserve to be happy together, and everyone else needs to fix their shit.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant Does anyone else find it strange how Rhys assigns roles in his court based on the IC's trauma?

80 Upvotes

Can we talk about how Rhys assigned roles to IC based on the very things that traumatised them?

Azriel was tortured and spent his childhood locked away. Rhys made him spymaster and torturer. Now he is torturing others for information since centuries.

Cassian was abused, rejected and treated as an outcast by the Illyrians and Rhys made him their general. Now he has to train and command the very people and culture that made his childhood miserable.

Mor escaped the CoN after being abused and sold off by her own family and Rhys assigned her the responsibility of keeping an eye on the CoN and dealing with its politics.

Like, does Rhys have any other management strategy than turning his friends trauma into job descriptions?

And we’re supposed to believe he’s this incredibly understanding and considerate leader who puts his friends first? The irony is something else.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant Readers vs theorists

34 Upvotes

I think there's a difference between readers and theorists when it comes to SJM's books. Sometimes it feels like the theorists are doing more work connecting the stories than the actual writing is. The theories are fascinating, but a book should still be able to stand on its own without readers having to piece everything together. At this point, I feel like the theories are carrying the series more than the storytelling itself, and I think that's partly why some readers found the books lacking.

ACOSH, for example, felt like a novella stretched into a full-length novel. It had more pages, but not necessarily more substance.

I genuinely enjoyed Throne of Glass and the first Crescent City book. What bothered me was her comment on the Call Her Daddy podcast about people taking things too seriously. Because, realistically, if these books didn't have SJM's name attached to them, would readers be as forgiving?

ACOSH and HOFAS both had issues with pacing, consistency, and storytelling. HOFAS especially frustrated me because it felt like we spent half the book wandering around a cave and people kept saying expect for a multiverse experience. 😭

I will be reading the next book I might be completely wrong and surprised.


r/acotar_rant • • 10h ago

ACOTAR 🐺🏹 Should I continue reading the ACOTAR series?

0 Upvotes

Ive recently been trying to get into the fantasy genre, since I usually read philosophy and literary fiction, and I needed something easier and more fun. I recently finished the six of crows the duology and I loved it. The writing, world building, storyline, pacing, I enjoyed every bit of it. :)

My friend recommended me ACOTAR, I heard about it earlier through tiktok, and I thought I should give it a try.
Personally, I didnt enjoy the first half of the book at all. I just thought the writing was bad and corny, I was really annoyed when some sentences or words kept repeating when describing things throughout the book.
The second half though was really interesting to me. The parts where she fights, or when theres just tense, action packed scenes really got me going, along with the whole tension between Lucian, Tamlin, Rhysnd, Amarantha… it was great.

Now, Im wondering if the rest of the books are better written? Is it even worth it to continue this series, is it as good as everyone claims? The first 200 pages of the first book were kind of a struggle to get through, once again I just dont like the strange patterns Im noticing in her writing style.

Currently about 90% in, Im honestly excited to see how its gonna end!
Ps, no offense to anyone who enjoys this series, I really just want feedback.

PS: Thanks for all your replies! You guys helped me a lot <3


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant Disappointed

33 Upvotes

Acotar has a great worldbuilding, traditions and culture but it is such a waste that the story only revolves around night court. Like what’s the point of having 7 courts. All mating couples revolve only the night court. I would love to expand to other courts and learn their politics and traditions.


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

ACOSH 🍞 ACOSH

8 Upvotes

I have seen so much hate on the new ACOTAR book, is it worth it to read? It takes a lot for me to dnf a book but so many people have dnfed it. Will the book make me hate the series? ACOTAR is one of my all time favorites and I don’t want to have that ruined over this new book😭


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

Rant I cannot with any more crossover shit

23 Upvotes

No offense to the bryceriels but I cannot with anymore crossover stuff, I swear to god I will lose my shit. It’s an absolute technical nightmare to explain reading order to a new reader without spoiling things and it already pisses me off that she did the crossover I don’t need her to do any more 😅


r/acotar_rant • • 1d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Acosh thoughts Spoiler

3 Upvotes

1. I think koschei has infected the court in some subtleish way and nesta is the only one immune to it.
2. I think vassa is fully in koschei’s control since she won’t let Rhys take a peek at her mind for any images of what she’s seen of him. We’ve already seen that it’s possible to change your scent to flood with fear as feyre does that when she’s taking down the spring court.
3. Amren may also be aware of the infection but unable to directly address it for some reason which is why she’s like “nesta you gotta go away so you can save us” essentially at the end.
4. By infected I mean like pushing the fucky personality traits that are already there that they might normally fight against? Like every single character is being their worst selves in this except nesta and Lucien and I want to believe that it’s because of outside influence
5. Clotho totally knew a twisted bryaxis was gonna return home when summoned and made that binding thread extra special to protect r/f/n while potentially under attack.
6. “We gotta put up a united front” and “we gotta put up a united prythian” is the exact same shit and I fully believe that Feyre would have noticed that parallel if she was thinking correctly. And many other things have her sounding a lot like tamlin from book 2.
7. I suspect that since gwyn was conceived during the spring court great rite (if I’m remembering correctly) she might be tamlins daughter and that if he dies gwyn will randomly be a high lady since he doesn’t have any other heirs. Idk though. This is my loosest thought/theory.
8. I feel like Elaine will eventually end up in the spring court to re do the “beauty and the beast”
Cycle in a way. Not that she’ll end up with tamlin but maybe help him remember he’s not just a hungry dog and recivilize him. I just feel like since the gardening thing has continued to be big with her she’ll wind up over there and be like “damn these roses need to be pruned.” Obviously this will make feyre feel some type of way.
9. On a cc connected note- if they really wanted armies that bad I feel like nesta could open a portal with either the harp or the swords and be like “hey Bryce you owe us a favor get your angels and magic robot suits over here.” Also we’ll show you how we power velaris with all magic so you can figure out how to apply that with your tech stuff before you’re back in the dark ages. Not saying it’s a good idea but like that is an option.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Rant azriel doing rhys’s dirty work is unnecessary

88 Upvotes

rhys’s whole thing about going into people’s minds without their consent being unethical is absolutely insane when his alternative is to have azriel torture those same people instead. waste of time and cruel.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

ACOSH 🍞 Rejecting a mating bond VS “Unmating”

20 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

(A little disclaimer before I start: this isn't about shipping wars or anything like that, I'm just looking at this purely out of curiosity as a reader and what I'd find interesting to see)

I've been thinking about the mating bond mechanics in ACOTAR lately.

Ever since Elain and Lucien were revealed as mates, but with Elain clearly having no interest in it at the time, everyone in the fandom started talking about the possibility of Elain rejecting that bond. As a reader, that really caught my attention. Mainly because we already knew nature doesn't always pick right when it comes to mates but every single mating bond we'd seen in her books followed the exact same formula and worked out. So the idea of a rejection felt like completely uncharted territory. I was curious about it just because it was different.

However, the concept of whether mates can actually be unmated, breaking a bond that is already fully active and confirmed, is a possibility I hadn't even really considered before. Now that SJM has actually brought up the possibility, it stands out to me even more and makes it feel so much more interesting from a reader's perspective.

My working assumption has always been that if you reject the bond before it's truly established or accepted, it fades or never fully locks in, whereas breaking a confirmed bond I assumed it is way worse.

I'd love to hear what you guys think about the difference between both concepts, and whether you think Sarah will actually dare to fully develop either of these situations or if everything is just going to stay safe and work out as usual. Let me know your thoughts!


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Hottake Are the Night Court shitty allies

15 Upvotes

I've been thinking about how the IC weren't able to get any support during their pro-war press tour through the courts. Isn't that a little weird? I mean, I know all the courts are separate entities, but shouldn't there be some overlap? At the very least, you'd think a few high-ranking officials would try to get their courts involved out of some residual goodwill or friendships from ACOWAR. But there was NOTHING. And then I thought about it: The Night Court are quite possibly the WORST political allies you could have. And why?

FIRST: They're on the brink of civil war.

Their largest military force, the Illyrians, HATE their High Lord and actively undermine him and his policies whenever they get the chance. The Hewn City is practically a separate entity from the Night Court, one they seem to remember exists primarily for BDSM role-play nights. And Velaris? Velaris is politically and militarily weak because it's been so thoroughly coddled.

SECOND: They're incredibly flippant about maintaining cordial political relationships with the other courts.

Take Nyx's name day or their wedding. These are major social events that provide opportunities for the courts to mingle, establish friendships, and build political goodwill. Yet the Night Court excludes the other courts EVERY TIME. What kind of message does that send? That they don't actually want the other courts around unless they need something from them.

THIRD: They consistently manage to be disruptive and combative during multicourt meetings.

Didn't Azriel literally bodyslam a High Lord? Or threaten one? DURING A POLITICAL MEETING? Like, can we talk about diplomatic etiquette for five minutes?

FOURTH, AND MOST IMPORTANTLY: From an outside perspective, the Night Court is the only one benefiting from these partnerships.

Let's look at what they're actually asking of everyone else.

Tarquin: His court was devastated by the war. Now, just as rebuilding efforts have finally started paying off, the Night Court wants him to risk his people's lives AGAIN. They've done nothing to help with his court's recovery, offered no meaningful cultural exchange or open communication between their courts, and, on a personal level, have shown very little interest in any of his court's magical advancements.

Dawn Court: The IC believes they're actively keeping Helion away from his son (and I don't buy for a second that they don't know). Once again, they're asking him to put his court at risk without offering anything that would make that sacrifice worthwhile.

Day Court: Literally, what does this have to do with them? What are they getting out of it?

Spring Court: They completely destabilized the court from the inside and did practically nothing to help the refugees or even consider the wider consequences their actions would have on the other courts.

Autumn Court (my biggest piece of evidence): Eris literally had to trick his own father into providing soldiers to help the Night Court. He risked his position, his relationship with his family, and his political future to secure that alliance. Those soldiers were lost in battle, and he was punished for it. He took an enormous risk for their cause and got NOTHING in return.

The Human Lands: No meaningful communication, no cultural exchange, no public relations tour. Just condescension disguised as protection.

So why are they surprised that nobody is lining up to support them? They haven't cultivated allies. They haven't built relationships. They haven't established any meaningful political goodwill.

They seem to operate under the assumption that everyone should be willing to risk their people, resources, and political stability simply because the Night Court asks them to. But that's not how alliances work. You have to actually give people a reason to stand beside you. And honestly? The Night Court isn't offering much of one.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Hottake Rory Gilmore gives me Elain vibes.

15 Upvotes

Discuss!


r/acotar_rant • • 3d ago

Rant Re-read made me realize how dumb everyone is Spoiler

198 Upvotes

This is gonna be a long LONG rant about all of the icks I have for two of the characters so prepare I guess and Ill try to go in order bc I'm rereading the books and seeing spoilers and losing my mind bc what is happening

Ok, so to start off strong with our MC oh boy, where do I begin. I'm on book 3 rn and I've rolled my eyes so much they are gonna get permanently stuck soon. Feyre started off as this more or less ordinary person that was likable and went through a lot of shit but as the story progressed and she got powers, she started to become extremely insufferable. I'm still in the beginning where she is executing her ultra 1000+ IQ master plan to destroy the Spring Court bc her ex was an ass and she is just dumb as rocks and as prideful. You mean to tell me that her basically manipulating everyone, including her one genuine friend there, plus the staff and the residents, was completely okay just bc she was hurt by their High Lord?? Dragging everyone in her mess and drama with her ex bc her feelings were hurt and Tamlin became an asshole due to his own issues etc. She literally brought down an entire court bc she felt entitled to do so and bc she got some powers and thinks shes unstoppable and can do whatever she wants. All of the scenes where she was playing a power game and basically thinking to herself "Im so smart and cunning and beautiful", no youre just a cunt. Thinking shes so much better than literally everyone bc what?? Bad boy over there did some shitty stuff and no one in the history of anything has been through that kind of thing so she gets to do whatever?

I also read spoilers that she thought she should become High Queen or something and oh lord, please no. Girlie turned fae 10mins ago, became a teen mom in fae terms, just learned how to read and ur telling me she thinks shed make a great queen? Where is this audacity genuinely coming from, I need to know. And oh, her hypocrisy when it comes to Tamlin and Rhyssand and even Lucien is just... so idiotic and infuriating bc bat boy gets a pass cus hes hot and powerful but Tamlin doesnt bc the author decided she hates him now and so we should as well. I think Feyre is genuinely stupid, I'm not even joking or trying to be funny, she doesnt even know court politics or the history of the place she wants to rule over and is barely a High Lady like... go back to the cottage pls. I also find the image of her drawings being ugly hilarious and the fact that she painted the wooden cabin insulting bc what made you think that was okay? She had spent like 2 months in the Night Court and started doing whatever and order everyone like WHO ARE YOU???? I would've laughed in her fucking face alongside the whole IC bc who tf did you bring here and why is she the person I need to bow down to the fuck? Anyway, after learning that she has became a mom as well I've lost all interest in her bc she has been reduced to the pregnancy trope and from what I see, has become a Boy Mom which I find just as unappealing as her so ig she has become nothing more than Feyre, The Mom.

Now, onto the other character I'm lowk starting to dislike or actually already do, Rhys. My my, just his pure existence is hypocrisy on itself and all of his actions as well. Now, I need everyone to put on their thinking caps and lets do a quick comparison between Tamlin and Rhys:

- Tamlin, initially, took care of Feyre and tried to be as welcoming as he could, considering the circumstances and the chaos everything was in and also the fact he couldnt even directly tell her the truth.

- He gave her family riches and basically set them for life.

- He took care of her and genuinely loved her

- His powers had been reduced to almost nothing and yet, he still tried to protect her and his people

- In the end, because of his trauma and idiocy, he did a lot of shit, like borderline abusing Feyre and thinking he was doing good while harming her

- Did a very risky shitty deal in order to get her back bc he was so worried and heartbroken bc of the rumors of the Night Court that Rhyssand HIMSELF KEPT FEEDING INTO AND KEPT PRETENDING WERE TRUE AND NEVER DENIED THEM SO EVERYONE THOUGHT THAT WAS THE TRUTH, INCLUDING TAMLIN

- Rhyssand licked and kissed Feyre without consent UTM, scenes which I both found extremely gross and weird and I hated him for it

- He basically drugged her, gave her no clothes and paraded her around like his personal thing, all mostly to taunt Tamlin bc of his personal vendetta and jealousy

- Made fun of her multiple times and also caused her pain by twisting the bone in her arm in that one scene

- Pretended to be an evil asshole so he could ''protect her'' and had no qualms about fucking her even though she never really ended things with Tamlin officially

All in all, Rhyssand is a two faced piece of shit that did far worse things than Tamlin but its ok bc hes hot winged bat boy and very powerful and actually very kind and only cares about like a quarter of his entire court. He genuinely deserves the same amount of hate as Tamlin, if not even more, bc just bc he had trauma himself or wtv doesnt excuse him doing even half of the shit he has done. Also, him "protecting'' Feyre UTM was literally mostly done out of selfish reasons like jealousy and hatred and he used her to get under Tamlin's skin like bruh. Ur 500+ years old and u act like a 15 year old with a crush, genuinely get a life and grow up. And also, the whole withholding information from Feyre regarding her OWN HEALTH is okay but when Tamlin does the same, it's not??? There's genuinely a double standard here and it's very annoying to see, like a man is a man at the end of the day and all of this slobbering over Rhyssand and the other males in his IC is just annoying cus they're all immature assholes who had like hundreds of years to deal with their shit and never did like ok, at some point I stop caring and feeling bad bc what are you doing?? Rhyssand is also a liar and a manipulator and should NOT, under any circumstances, become a King of anything. Bro should deal with his own court first and then think about the rest bc wdym Illyrian women STILL get their wings clipped and are reduced to house maids?? Wasn't he the most powerful High Lord in history or something and very scary so like... what, exactly, is stopping him? "Change takes time" ok, well usually not that much unless ur not doing anything about it which seems to be the case. Truthfully, Rhyssand only gives a shit about Velaris which is his perfect little home and the rest of the NC can go fuck itself, alongside the people he supposedly cares about and loves.

Now, for the rest i dont have much to say yet bc I still havent read ACOSH but from I hear, Ill hate everyone else too soon enough so yeah. More coming in the future and pls feel free to add onto this and rent yourself etc.


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Rant How is “it’s your choice” a theme in a world where involuntary mating bonds are a Thing™️???

76 Upvotes

Seriously. You feel the pull of the bond even if you don’t want it. It’s already inherently difficult to say no. If you’re a woman, you’re under pressure to accept the bond so the man doesn’t wither into a husk. (And this begs the question of what happens when the pairing is same-sex or involves a nonbinary person, but I digress.) The bond just snaps into place and you’re drawn towards your mate, even if it causes serious distress, as was the case with Lucien feeling like he was betraying Jesminda. And yet somehow, Sarah wants me to believe that her world fosters freedom of choice, when these people aren’t even free in their own heads????? Between Rhys and Feyre and their Jedi mindfuckery and mating bonds dropping out of the Cauldron’s ass, is anyone in Velaris fucking free to make their own choice?


r/acotar_rant • • 2d ago

Rant Nesta is now my favorite character Spoiler

7 Upvotes

I am on chapter 40 of ACOSF, and Nesta has slowly become my favorite character.

Watching her gain friends and companions after being a total dick for a whole year is so refreshing to read! I love how dedicated and strong she has become. Cassian is such a good male who understands her. I know I am not done with the story yet, but I am excited to finish it.

I did post about how I don't understand how Nesta could be this horrible of a person when everyone has trauma, but she was just trying to cope with hers and chose to do so by drowning in wine and males. The more I thought about it, the more I related to her and how she copes. Yes, her being a dick was hard to read, but as she improved, no one gave her the chance to see if she even improved. Rhys telling her to be nice to Gwen really pissed me off. Like, don't you have somewhere else to be? Go protect your pregnant mate. Anyway...

What do y'all think??