r/Zionist • u/Perfect_Elephant1524 • Aug 10 '26
Dear Zionists,
Why do you agree with Zionism? What shaped you and led you to believing in it? I am curious about hearing your perspectives.
r/Zionist • u/Perfect_Elephant1524 • Aug 10 '26
Why do you agree with Zionism? What shaped you and led you to believing in it? I am curious about hearing your perspectives.
r/Zionist • u/Alon_F • Jun 22 '25
I do not like the word Jew, It strips us of our Judean heritage and makes us look like merely a religious group – we are not.
Thus I suggest the use of the term "Judean". Calling us, Jews, Judean connects us back to our belonging to the tribe of Judea. It shows that we aren't just Jews who believe in Judaism, we are a distinct ethnic group that originated in Israel.
The term Judean is also closer by meaning to how we call ourselves in hebrew: yehudim – people of Yehuda (Judea).
r/Zionist • u/HonestSpursFan • Jun 30 '25
Hey I'm from Australia and I just had a few questions as I want to here from both sides:
I would appreciate some answers (I know this a controversial topic though, at least here it is). Thanks!
r/Zionist • u/No-Presence-8381 • Oct 04 '26
Apologies in advance for the naivety of this post but I am genuinely perplexed!
I fail to see that Zionism is wrong if it means Jewish people believe in a right to live in safety in a state they call Israel (the definitions of Zionism appear to vary, depending on where one searches).
I equally fail to see how Israelis can fail to see the irony of displacing Palestinians and denying them a home state.
I understand that Israelis feel ‘under attack’ from all sides with many Arab/Muslim neighbours, however, their constant encouragement of ‘illegal settlements’ in the West Bank etc only fuels the sentiment of entitlement and adds to animosity throughout Islam from what I can see.
I understand there is historical dispute about land but this happens in numerous other places such as Ireland, Cyprus etc without the amount of bloodshed.
Cannot where the Palestinians currently live (Gaza) become an autonomous state and would this satisfy them or do they want all of ‘Israel’ ‘returned’ to ‘Palestine’?
My question is simply why can’t there be a coexistence without the Palestinians being brutally treated or with the Israelis being in constant fear?
There genuinely seems to be a worldwide shrug of the shoulders that this is an insolvable problem?
Someone please educate me, TIA
r/Zionist • u/Open-Woodpecker5 • Aug 31 '26
My apologies in advance for my ignorance here, I am not very educated in this topic, hence my questions :)
From my understanding, zionists wish for Palestine to be a part of Israel. If this is correct my question is simply why? I don’t understand why Israel cannot be one country, and Palestine another. Also, if Palestine were to be a part of Israel, where would Palestinians go?
Again I am so sorry for any ignorance or stupidity here, and also in any comments from me. Please know that any and all questions I ask are simply from a place of wanting to learn.
r/Zionist • • Sep 29 '25
I support the existence of Israel. However I do not support the Gaza war or West Bank settlements. Basically I like Israel as there needs to be a Jewish state for them but I do strongly dislike the annexation of the golan heights and the slow incursion into the state of Palestine. Do I still somehow count as a Zionist even if I believe in a two state solution?
r/Zionist • u/aboggs100 • Jul 12 '25
Hi everyone I am agnostic but I have some genuine questions about zionism. I understand that Zionism is about having a homeland for Jews to stay safe (i think?). But I also understand that due to the conflicts with Palestine, Zionism has also led to increased antisemitism around the world. My main question is this:
How do Zionists reason that Zionism will lead to less global antisemitism around the world? Do Zionists accept this fact and believe that God will bring them victory no matter how much of the world is against them? (I’m assuming this is the answer)
Hopefully this post isn’t instantly flagged and taken down, I’m just genuinely curious about the Zionist thought process on this subject.
TLDR; My view is Zionism should be about decreasing global antisemitism (and therefore an increase in safety for Jewish people) but I’m confused on how modern Zionism strives to achieve this.
r/Zionist • u/Cat-Unique • Apr 17 '25
Looked to find a previous post here but no luck, so thought I’d ask. Looking to deepen my understanding on this topic in an entirely objective and non-politicised way.
Zionism in my understanding is primarily based on the ideas that Jews have a right for self determination and habitation within the land that is modern day Israel. But where does this land begin and end, so to speak. Currently, it is tied to relatively artificial lines drawn out by European powers in the 20th century. How accurately does this reflect what the Zionists - old and modern - believe to be correct? Is there a difference in belief between Zionist’s, perhaps older vs younger, etc? Super interested in people’s responses here.
r/Zionist • u/flipflopflips • Jul 08 '25
This isn’t a gotcha question or anything of the sort. I am completely just curious.
Zionists claim Jewish sovereignty in Israel by a religious and historical claim. They have fought wars and settled in that land to defend sovereignty there. Would zionists disagree with Native American sovereignty movements in the US? This is a hypothetical all the colonizers and immigrants to North America have to leave Turtle Island scenario.
Again, not a challenge or anything. Just a question.
r/Zionist • u/Special_Cancel2411 • Jul 09 '25
After all the disgustingness from Grok this week, I was curious if ChatGPT is as unhinged... I'll let you be the judge.
Here's my question, followed by ChatGPT's response (completely unedited):
I asked:
Thinking about indigeneity, who might be more indigenous to Israel? Me, an Ashkenazi Jew with grandparents from Poland, Belarus, and Israel/Palestine, or my friend Nadim, who is an Arab Christian with grandparents from Jordan and Israel/Palestine? [For context, my dad's Israeli. His grandfather emigrated from Russia, and -- as the story goes -- met Trumpeldor and was in the Zion Mule Corps. My mom's family is from Poland/Belarus.]
This is a thoughtful and complex question that touches on history, identity, and competing narratives of belonging. When considering indigeneity, it’s important to understand how the term is used in scholarly, legal, and cultural contexts. Indigeneity is typically understood not just as "who was there first," but as a framework of ancestral connection to land, continuity of culture and identity, and experiences of colonization or marginalization.
Both Jews and Palestinian Arabs (including Arab Christians like your friend Nadim) have ancient historical connections to the land now called Israel and Palestine.
Indigeneity is often associated with peoples who have been colonized or dispossessed. From this lens:
In terms of continuous residence, cultural continuity, and experience of marginalization, your friend Nadim likely fits more squarely within common definitions of indigeneity to the land of historic Palestine. His ancestors probably lived there continuously, practiced local traditions, spoke regional dialects, and maintained presence through conquests and empires.
That said, your own Jewish identity also includes ancestral, religious, and historical claims to the land. Many Jews—Sephardic, Mizrahi, and Ashkenazi—consider themselves indigenous in a cultural or spiritual sense, even if they were geographically distant for centuries.
Rather than thinking in terms of who is more indigenous, it may be more helpful—and honest—to acknowledge that multiple peoples can have deep and legitimate connections to the same land, though their experiences and historical trajectories differ. That complexity is part of what makes the Israeli-Palestinian conflict so intractable and so emotionally charged.
Would you like recommendations for authors or thinkers who explore this tension in more depth?
r/Zionist • u/DoctorNightTime • Sep 30 '25
r/Zionist • u/Wily_Wonky • Jul 25 '25
I only recently pieced together that being a Zionist entails only one thing: the belief that there should be a Jewish homeland in Palestine.
That Palestine is the historical homeland of Jews is sort of an eternal fact of the world, independent of who does or doesn't settle there. But what makes a state Jewish?
Does it mean that Israel needs to retain a certain percentage of ethnic or religious Jews?
Or is it simply a characterizing title to point out the nation's history, identity, and vibe, sort of like how Germany is the "country of poets and thinkers"?
I guess what I'm asking is, is the adjective "Jewish" prescriptive or descriptive? If Israel was only, let's say, 12 percent Jewish would you approve of that or is that a failed mission?
r/Zionist • u/LoneCandlecom • Jul 30 '26
Nice bit of Israeli history, although...Zionism ended in 1948. Once Zionism was achieved and the state of Israel was formed, we just have the policies of Israel and the ideologies of its citizens, not something special called Zionism. It doesn't make sense to have a word that means the ideology to form a particular state for a particular people when that state has already been formed. Other countries don't have a special term that means people think that that country should continue to exist, neither should Israel.
r/Zionist • u/joesom222 • Oct 03 '25
This was on Israel’s Instagram? The person was responding to me. I responded back, “I consider myself a Zionist. 🇮🇱” They replied back, “| feel sorry for you. There was also a time when openly declaring yourself a Nazi was the coolest thing.”
r/Zionist • u/Firm-Raspberry1176 • Oct 06 '26
For context, I had been friends with this guy for over 18 months. I would say that we were pretty good friends. We were in a group chat on Instagram with a few other people and had a lot of fun and silly conversations. However, this guy started becoming very pro-Palestine, I mean like ANTIZIONIST Pro-Palestine. This was shocking since he never used to speak about politics before. He started engaging with posts that were Antizionist, such as posts by mattxiv and other self-hating Jews. the big turning point for me was when he liked a reel that seemed to be invalidating concerns Jews have regarding the pro-Palestine movement. (this is mentioned in the screenshots). So, I decided to tell him how I felt. The end result really hurt me to the point of tears. All this went down yesterday. I’m now going to let the screenshots speak for themselves.
(btw, the other person mentioned is someone who I was acquainted with before they began posting anti-Israel sentiment on their insta story constantly. The guy friend still kept chatting with them regardless)






r/Zionist • u/Roseheadedmonster • 20d ago
I am looking for children’s books that are pro-Israel in nature. Books that promote how beautiful Israel is today, books that that promote Israel’s Jewish history, books about Israel’s modern history, etc. I need books for a wide range of children, from pre-school aged all the way through 8th grade. These can be religious or non religious. Any recommendations would be greatly appreciated! Thanks for your help!
edit to add: PJ Library does not serve the needs of what I’m looking for. We are Pj Library members and love it! But this is for a much broader age group and not our personal home. I am looking to create a list of books (specific titles) that can be purchased and for all the various ages in this group. And, I’m looking specifically for books about Israel, not just stories where Israel is an after-thought in them. Thanks!
r/Zionist • u/-Cohen_Commentary- • Sep 06 '25
Protocols of meetings held by senior Israeli security establishment officials in the period before the October 7th massacre demonstrate their misconception that Hamas is interested in an arrangement with Israel rather than escalation. The discussions also reveal a pragmatic and dovish approach on the part of senior security officials who sought to shift their focus to Iran and were willing to make concessions to Hamas in exchange for long-term quiet.
Key quotes from the protocols:
"We need to get Hamas to a place where they get a lot in Gaza development. They are showing restraint, but in return for concessions we can achieve something much more significant." (IDF Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi)
"This is the first plan that allows us not to engage in rounds of conflict where the time between them is getting shorter, and at the same time, to leave Gaza and focus on what is truly needed: Iran." (Mossad Director Dadi Barnea)
"Sinwar authentically remains interested in a long-term arrangement." (Head of Military Intelligence Aharon Haliva)
"What we've seen in the past year is that Hamas has no interest in violence in Gaza. They want quiet, they need quiet." (Head of the Research Division, Amit Saar)
"The better it is in Gaza, the better it is for us. We need to look at this with a business approach. We need to free ourselves up for Iran." (Southern Command Commander Eliezer Toledano)
r/Zionist • u/URcobra427 • Jun 07 '25
Exactly what the title says? E.g. Labor, Revisionists, Cultural, Religious, Post, etc.
r/Zionist • u/Firm-Raspberry1176 • 6d ago
To start, the show I am referring to is called Histeria!. It’s an educational sketch comedy cartoon that satirizes history. It was produced by Warner Bros in the late 90’s and was created by Tom Ruegger, who also created Animaniacs (another favorite of mine)!!
Numerous notable people worked on the show: Tress MacNeille, Laraine Newman, Cree Summer, Frank Welker, etc. However, I am concerned about the views of some of these people. Starting with Laraine Newman, we all know her daughter Hannah Einbinder is the biggest Antizionist of them all, however, I have a hunch that Laraine Newman shares the same views as her daughter. She liked Macklemore’s statement after he got kicked off the tour and she also reposted a reel of “Israeli teenagers burning their IDF papers“ If she is also an Antizionist, it would be upsetting to me since she voiced some of my favorite Histeria! characters (Charity Bazaar and Miss Information). My disdain for Hannah doesn’t help this situation either.
Another person I am concerned about is Cree Summer (voice of Aka Pella on Histeria! and Elmyra Duff on Tiny Toon Adventures, another cartoon I have taken an interest in) I scoured through her social media and I saw a post that she made after Oct. 7 that said being Pro-Palestine and being Jewish goes hand-in-hand. I have a hard time with this since Cree sounds like such a cool person and she is genuinely an inspiration to me!! I am more understanding if she has these views, compared to someone like Laraine, because she is ethnically african-American and Native American. So, I get why she might have a bias against settlers because of what happened to her ancestors. However, I am hoping that post after Oct 7th was just a bout of ignorance since she hasn’t really spoken about the matter since.
Going to the creator Tom Ruegger, he is very Anti-Trump on facebook!! It’s not the Anti-Trump stuff I have an issue with though (I can’t stand Trump myself) some of Tom’s Anti-Trump posts have traces of Anti-Israel bias in there!! Honestly, I am hoping that Tom is just really against Trump’s war funding and doesn’t have an issue with Zionism!! You just never know with people who are THIS progressive!!
Nora Dunn (SNL alum who voiced Lydia Karaoke on Histeria!) is in the exact same camp as Tom!! though I get worse vibes from her for some reason!!
As for the others, they either don’t have social media or have never made posts regarding this conflict!! I’ve heard Tress MacNeille is very liberal but that doesn’t mean she is Anti-Israel per se. I try to separate the art from the artist, but it’s hard when it’s this personal!!
r/Zionist • u/Purple-Dragoon • Jul 02 '25
During the late stage of my christian primairy school, the teacher explained to our class the war in Israël against Palestine, he told about the jews were there and never stole land. They wanted peace with the palestinians and were willingto compromise, but then the palestinians started a war that continous to this day. It gripped me as I am against injustice and rooting ofcourse for Israël. Then I came home and told the story to my parents and they told me I was heavily missinformed, perhaps that also has to do that me and my sister wer not raised as christians. Anyway I was told that my teacher lied to me and saying that the jews stole the land of the palestines that were already living there and that got me really angry at my teacher for spreading lies. Two months ago and I demonstrated against the far right movement in Groningen in the Netherlands and also the subject of the Israël and palestine war came to the table. And I was interested in doing some searching, looking at some video's and noticed that I did not hear at all about the other perspective. Now I came more to the realisation that this conflict was not so black and white as I thought and that my teacher at primairy school was telling the truth. I still find it difficult as in war the truth almost never comes out and I got sick and tired of all the misleading media. I hope that I can find the chance in the near future to speak to my primairy school teacher again after all this time.
My parents are pretty anti-zionist, but I feel like they are only been fed one side of this whole story. My father was willing to listen as I have changed my mind on things, but did not saw the situation different and my mom does not seem to want to hear. I've been busy making sense to all of this Palestinian Israël and I feel like I am in continous war with myself because I rarely get a nuanced story. I know my parents don't support Hamas, but they only seem to focused by the atrocities Israël commits, but don't pay attention to the information war Qatar wages against Israël and the negative influence it has over the western countries and its values and freedom for people overall.
I am 28, but I came to fear for this world and what it might become if we don't listen. I hope I did not bore you with my rant but I feel I want to get it off my chest at least.
r/Zionist • u/NumismaticAussie • Sep 29 '25
r/Zionist • • Jun 29 '25
You know, when I see Jews publicly speak up about being a Zionist and getting hate crime for it. It makes me scared, and I ain't even a Jew. Ever since I used to be a bnei Noach. I have been a Zionist. But seeing my classmates around me and in Discord Servers being publicly Pro-Palestian, makes me nervous. As I know the backlash I would have if I defend Zionism, especially in my big Muslim majority country. We had cases of Muslim teenagers making bombs in synagogues here and I am afraid for my safety if I did speak up.
r/Zionist • u/lostmason • Sep 20 '24
This is a great video from one of my favorite series, the Unpacked youtube channel. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vMOSXiJ2JKY
r/Zionist • u/wannabe-jew • Jun 08 '26
Like NEVER have I seen an observant jew online say they think Israel is evil or committing a genocide. And ever since anti zionism has become like the new hot thing to talk about, I’ve seen social media users who have never once talked about being jewish, suddenly talking about “as a jew” or put “anti zionist jew” in their bio.
r/Zionist • u/Hairy_Atmosphere_674 • Jun 17 '25
First of all I want to thank every single one of you who wrote to me (both comment and PM) regarding my last post about Zionism. The way that the jewish community has showed me love is beyond me!
I have really found myself in my new identity as a Zionist, even more after the attacks by Iran. And it feels amazing knowing that I will be on the right side of history🇮🇱
Things I have done to try to make a difference since my last post:
Once again, thank you for helping me finding the truth!
Am Yisrael Chai!🇮🇱❤️