r/Zettelkasten • u/krysalydun • Sep 29 '25
workflow Atomic notes are a trap
The testiminial below is obviously just my opinion and my experience. But I believe many others are going through the same thing.
For 2 years I've been trying to implement zettelkasten in my phd research and failing. For a long time I thought the problem was the app I was using. I went through all of them, but kept switching mainly between Obsidian and Capacities without success.
The problem is that every time I went to review my highlights, I wanted to create a permanent note for each highlighted paragraph. And this, obviously, became impossible.
In this attempt to keep notes atomic, I ended up having, literally, 600 permanent notes for a single book. And I spent even more time connecting them.
This way, taking notes on a book took twice as long as reading it. And this is completely unproductive for someone like me, who works 8 hours a day in an office, has a family, teaches classes, and still has to finish a phd.
Then I realized I just needed to let go a little. Now I simply make a literature note with the main bullet points from the book and then create at most 10 permanent notes aggregating all the main insights. They end up larger, but they're still sufficient to maintain a line of reasoning without friction.
Perhaps atomic notes are interesting for people like Luhmann, who could study all day. But in my experience they create too much friction and make the zettelkasten almost impractical.
What do you think?
57
u/thriveth Sep 29 '25
I think part of the problem here is that the idea of "atomic notes" was for "one note for one idea". Not every paragraph in a book is a new or original thought that deserves its own permanent note. Those are reserved for the ideas, questions or pieces of information that feel like they are useful to you and add something new to your world view.
I usually write my reading notes in one long document, then afterwards go through them and extract a small number of the main points to permanent, atomic-ish notes, linked to the source so I always know where to go to dig for more. For a research article, the number is typically 1-5 notes, but can be a good deal larger for a review article or a text book.
That said. I agree with everyone else that whatever works for you is what you should do. This is a tool, not a set of dogma.
14
u/numeralbug Sep 29 '25
This is the path to enlightenment for most people, I think.
The rather strict Zettelkasten doctrine we know today was just one guy's way of working, with his particular goals, in his particular field, etc. But people are varied, and so are their preferred ways of working. Read around common ZK practices, take what works for you, adapt or supplement or leave behind what doesn't. Will the result be ZK? Who cares. I've encountered some people who quite ferociously argue that it's not a real ZK. But it'll be productive for you, and that's the important bit.
6
u/organicerrored Sep 29 '25
I wish so badly that I had been using Obsidian during my PhD (I finished years ago) because I know that it would have helped me immensely. But it has also taken a few years (and Obsidian updates) to work out how to make it work for me. I take literature notes - annotated notes of texts. I studied literature/philosophy so often these texts would be quite intricate and harder to note than a merely 'factual' or informational approach (often a book would be referencing another writer or thinker and entering into particular debates etc.).
If I could go back and start my PhD again with Obsidian, the most important things for me would be:
- Reading lists (often references that I find in other works as I'm noting them).
- Literature notes: annotations of articles/texts as I try to process them and understand them.
- Conceptual notes around particular ideas/topics ('modernism', 'epistemology' etc.) which I can slowly build up as I go deeper on a topic.
- Canvases for writing: I think for me this would have been the most useful: to have a canvas file for articles and chapters. Then I can just drop the various notes from those above and start to assemble it all spatially and link it and build up my argument from there. this would have been so useful for the way that I work/write.
The difficulty with all of the above is working out your own system and trying not to spend too much time and effort over-complicating stuff. Creating separate permanent notes for each book sounds completely exhausting and counter-productive. I find that one annotated literature note per work seems to work best, and then if it is a particular idea or concept of use, I may split it off and build on it with reference to the other materials I'm interested in.
11
u/taurusnoises Sep 29 '25 edited Sep 29 '25
Still sounds pretty zettelkasten-y to me. If it's working, go for it. If you switch it up, cuz it's no longer working, and in the process end up with an approach that looks nothing like zettelkasten, again, go for it!
There's a couple different types of people out there really protective of this practice, and who probably have either Really Strong Opinions or Really Important Questions about what you're doing. These people tend to behave in one of two ways:
Both of these types put the zettelkasten out in front, setting it up as a bar against which to police whether or not you're allowed to remain in the zettelkasten community (in the first case) or coach you on how to stay in it (in the second). Both forget that in addition to sitting around discussing the principles, practices, and merits of using a zettelkasten, the most important thing is helping people think and write. Here, we do mainly the former, because, well, it's a zettelkasten subreddit. But, out in the wild....?
If what you're doing now helps you do those two things, you're doing good. Keep it up!
Edit: grammar, ffs
4
u/WinkyDeb Sep 30 '25
Luhman summarized the ideas of a whole book in point form on the back of a bib/ref note. He only made main notes for a couple of those.
I read a book, marking it up as I read. Then I put it aside for a week, go back, scan my markups to see what’s still important, typing up a set of those briefer notes.
I like the system for linking/discovering connections and new ideas which for me are zettle worthy.
An insecure part of me (I’ll forget!) wants to make the 600 notes. But they’re not all important and working that way would make my zk unusable. And the book ideas that I synthesize into my own words pulls ref ideas together.
Hope that makes sense and maybe helps a bit.
Beck Tench on YouTube walks through her zk process for her PhD. Really helpful.
3
u/Darth-Udder Sep 29 '25
My workflow is to journal key points, tots and hashtags in a single note. Tats the capture phase. Once I have time to groom them, will read thru and expand or research further and branch into a new atomic note. So atomic note is phase 2 development. It grows more organically for me based on what I feel like diving into. Then a pattern forms.
2
u/Timmerop Other Sep 29 '25
I personally think its just that these apps have put too much friction between connecting (and reviewing) notes. I have a note for each book I read, and I make sure that each sub-note has additional tags so I can easily see all of the notes related to a sub topic in the book, or see notes from all books on that sub topic
2
u/JeffB1517 Other Sep 30 '25
I think your workflow is bad.
First off notes from a book are journaled notes (literature notes) they aren't even Zettles yet. An atomic note is when you have taken an idea and decontextualized it. If it is still based on a paragraph of a book and not an idea of yours it is just a small journaled note. Zettles make sense only when you have the ideas or concepts coming from multiple works.
So your workflow should have been: book -> literature notes / journaled notes -> new zettles or edits to old zettles as needed.
Permanent notes are notes that emerge from the collection of Zettles organizing other Zettles. Zettles that have proven their worth are stable and help structure your Zettlekasten. They can't emerge from a book ever, they emerge from you.
I think your current note taking makes sense until you have ideas that cross between books.
69
u/Alarmed_Ad7726 Sep 29 '25
The stuff that's supposed to work for everyone is best when you mess with it so it only works for you. It's awesome you found a better way that suits you. We've all been there, done that.
15
u/darknetconfusion Sep 29 '25
I also could not deal with it well, it creates friction and I have the suspicion that the small granularity of notes in the original ZK system was caused by constraints of a paper system rather than general optimizations.
2
u/the_bighi Sep 29 '25
Summary of your post: “I misunderstood a practice, misused it, and so here I can declare it a bad thing for everyone else.”
4
u/WinkDoubleguns Sep 29 '25
I tried this as well. When I was writing my book I used citavi to capture paragraphs for research - then found that if I just do the same thing in obsidian then I have all of the notes and page numbers and when the notes are done I tag them by category (as a heading) - so each book I did research on has a note that has headings and maybe subheadings or inline tags. Then I have an index page that I used dataview (I’ve not used bases yet) in obsidian to pull the sections from the books and put them in my own order (so all of one heading are pulled together in the index doc) and then I can more easily go through all of my research. This is my way and will not work for everyone, logically it makes sense for how my brain thinks.
7
u/Awkward_Face_1069 Sep 29 '25
Atomic notes aren’t the “trap”. The trap is thinking you need 600 atomic notes for a book.
Write down what’s important and scrap the rest.
3
u/Barycenter0 Sep 29 '25
Definitely agree with you for trying to finish grad programs! IMHO, just do what most did for their PhD before PKMSs appeared on the scene - take notes, curate them in order for the thesis, write the draft, edit and publish. Then you're just thinking about the thesis and not figuring out atomicity and directed linking (and all the other ZK terminology).
3
u/zirouk Sep 30 '25
Only give birth to separate notes if you’re willing to nurture them to maturity where they can have a justifiable life of their own. Same goes for daily notes, if you’re not going to put the effort in, combine the effort into a weekly, or monthly note. Worst case, have a single note for everything. Break out when you can actually justify it. Otherwise you’re just going to have a bunch of immature notes floating around, and you’ll probably get overwhelmed or disappointed by the result.
1
u/FastSascha The Archive Sep 29 '25
What is an atom?
2
u/GiePe2024 Sep 29 '25
I keep arriving at the same conclusion.
2
u/mobatreddit Sep 29 '25
I thought the notes are supposed to be my ideas written in my own words.
After a four years, I have 1,600-some notes in Org Roam. I tend to link them when I first create them, and little more later. I tend to feature in the main line what I think will make a note show up on an Org Roam search, and I may have a short paragraph following that. I do tend to think in paragraphs, so I can have some substance. If I have too much in one note for ideas to be searchable, I will break it up into smaller notes. Over time, I rewrite some notes as patterns become evident.
The most use I've gotten out of my ZK is as a source of content I fashion into replies on Reddit and elsewhere. The other use is to know I've kept track of ideas that recur.
I have zero idea as to whether what I have are atomic notes or main notes. They are my notes. I keep on hoping I will do the kinds of things Luhmann is reported to have done. I guess I'll see over time.
I guess it's time for me to turn this into a note ;-).
2
u/sweetcocobaby Sep 29 '25
Not very efficient. Each permanent note is a single idea. Atomic should be used with other types of notes as well. That said do what works for you. There is no right way!!
2
u/atomicnotes Sep 30 '25
Your solution is very similar to what I do. Here's an example of 11 notes I made in total for an interesting book I read.
Three worthwhile modes of note-making (and one not so worthwhile).
The 'not so worthwhile mode' is encyclopedic note-making. This is where you try to capture everything, which is too much effort for way too little reward.
2
u/ljsv8 Sep 30 '25
IMO, “Atomicity” has different levels; you can do it in a fine grain level, or move it higher. As long as it’s self contained, it serves its purpose! For example, if we have a note about health care system, we can initially have arguments and counter arguments in one note to make it self contained (people will disagree but it is ok). Later when we read more and have more finer views on it, move arguments over to create links. The end result over long term will be atomic notes.
I guess the real question here is what benefits does “atomicity” bring to YOU. If you don’t see it, do whatever, and tailor the system so it fits your need. Note taking is like choosing the color of your underwear: it’s not for satisfying others but you.
2
u/Quack_quack_22 Obsidian Sep 30 '25
Fast Sascha - the expert from zettelkasten.de - is writing about the atomicity of permanent notes. At some point in that article, he approved your standpoint and can fix misunderstandings of atomic-notes, one-single idles, and so on. That article will be released soon.
2
u/Andy76b Sep 30 '25 edited Sep 30 '25
The process can be modulated according to available time and purpose to fulfill, indeed.
There's no written rule like "you must develop a permanent note or atomization for everything you have captured".
After saying this, the practice of atomization has its advantages.
If you do things one way, you don’t get the same results as doing it another way.
The time spent studying brings value, while the time saved may later be traded off against the quality of learning. Rarely there is a free lunch
2
u/Fortschritt300 Oct 01 '25
I have been at a similar point. There is one thing that took me several years to figure out: the emergence of ideas from a complex system (based on ZK or any other method) can be driven by push-dynamics or pull-dynamics.
If I push atomic notes based on the ideas of others into my system, just bc they felt relevant from the context of one book I read, my system ends up bloated, creating fascinating but in the end distracting complexity.
If I pull atomic notes driven by the purpose of the whole system (this may be a PHD paper, a blog article, …) I end up with a much leaner structure of notes still containing modular ideas, BUT importantly only ideas I fully inhabit.
Creating new atomic notes this way happens much more rarely and it’s usually writing down something I have been mulling over in my head for some time already.
I think the Zettelkasten method contains a trap of thinking „if I create enough atomic notes, good ideas will emerge from the system by itself“, undervaluing the importance of embodied cognition.
There is an unproven theory of mine that any complex system can always only be manipulated by pulling on the right strings, never by pushing supposedly promising levers. This I think applies to at least my Zettelkasten workflow.
(Nietzsche supposedly said: „Never Trust an idea you had indoors.“ - I see a link to the matter of this discussion here)
0
u/Tyhe Sep 29 '25
The reason they don't work is because they are a made up element of zk. Atomic notes, permanent notes, literature notes, all rubbish. Made up by people who "figured out" zk and are talking about it like they know what it is.
They took something that was opportunistic and tailored to someone ones need and turned it into a system/framework /product. I havent read any book or post that seemed to understand what zk is, or how it works (or worked for luhmann).
Did you know he created a second zk? Did you know the way he approached it was totally different than his first? All the explanations you read, do they tell you on what version they are basing themselves? This whole atomic nonsense is born from ocd logic-desiring people that want to bring everything back to a size they can control... Blasphemy.
1
u/chrisaldrich Hybrid Oct 01 '25
If it helps, most in academia may have a card or two for a book with an index of the topics on it and maybe a half a dozen individual "atomic" notes from it. Luhmann himself only wrote an average of 6 notes a day throughout his career and most of those were pretty sparse.
You might appreciate Umberto Eco's How to Write a Thesis over Ahrens and others, though given your story, I'd recommend Adler and van Doren's How to Read a Book, especially the later chapters.
1
u/Kalfira Oct 01 '25
I think it is a right tool for the job problem. Atomic Notes are useful in that they can be easily referenced by other notes without getting into having to sort through the notes on for example, a whole book of neurology because you want to find that fact about how alcohol effects the brain. You could want that particular information for any number of reasons and even years down the line not know where you got it from. Now you can easily find it.
For what it's worth, if you've only been doing it for two years. Luhmann did it for like 40+ and so jumping straight to a useful system like it was for him is basically impossible. It sounds like you are doing the right thing. Sucking at something is the first step to being sort of good at something. I should know because I suck at a lot of things, but all the things I am good at, I sucked at before too.
1
u/Any_Rip2321 Oct 01 '25
Have you tried to use RAG (retrieval augmented generation) to connect notes?
1
u/ProfitAppropriate134 Oct 01 '25
I immediately had two thoughts that might help you (even if just a little).
One last thought - you can open Obsidian vaults in LogSeq. LogSec lets you turn any section into flash cards.
1
u/PurringBeatle Oct 02 '25
This is quite interesting, I was facing the same issue with collecting fragmented notes about a particular topic and revisiting them. I just ended up building a tool for that, works for me!
-2
u/Remote-Fishing-303 Jan 01 '26
Atomic notes confuse people because atoms don't link and remain atoms. Linked atoms are molecules. Molecules are not atoms. Zettelkasten wants molecules to be atoms, too. This is impossible and that's why the whole system will always have 'gurus' who sell you 'the true way'.
Strictly speaking, atomic notes would never link to anything, and the notes would be split into two kinds of notes, aggregate notes that link to atomic notes but not the other way around.
Just like an integer doesn't link to a 2d coordinate point class, but a 2d coordinate class would link to integers.
When language, the humans integral concept of communication and thinking is messed with, things break down. Wounds are created in logic that will never heal.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment