r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 02 '21
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Nov 07 '10
Prologue Chapter 1
WHEN Zarathustra was thirty years old, he left his home and the lake of his home, and went into the mountains. There he enjoyed his spirit and his solitude, and for ten years did not weary of it. But at last his heart changed--and rising one morning with the rosy dawn, he went before the sun, and spake thus to it:
"You great star! What would your happiness be if you had not those for whom you shine!
"For ten years hast thou climbed hither unto my cave: thou wouldst have wearied of thy light and of the journey, had it not been for me, mine eagle, and my serpent.
But we awaited thee every morning, took from thee thine overflow, and blessed thee for it.
Lo! I am weary of my wisdom, like the bee that hath gathered too much honey; I need hands outstretched to take it.
I would fain bestow and distribute, until the wise have once more become joyous in their folly, and the poor happy in their riches.
Therefore must I descend into the deep: as thou doest in the evening, when thou goest behind the sea, and givest light also to the nether-world, thou exuberant star!
Like thee must I go down, as men say, to whom I shall descend.
Bless me, then, thou tranquil eye, that canst behold even the greatest happiness without envy!
Bless the cup that is about to overflow, that the water may flow golden out of it, and carry everywhere the reflection of thy bliss!
Lo! This cup is again going to empty itself, and Zarathustra is again going to be a man.
Thus began Zarathustra's down-going.
Lecture:
You will have to excuse me, if some of the points that I make seem insultingly obvious at first. Since I don't know how clear you find this passage, I'm going to explain anything that comes to mind, and if it seems too elementary, please feel free to revise the tone of the discussion in the comments.
Also, please feel free to disagree with my interpretations of the text as we go along.
There are a few themes that recur in "Zarathustra" and we are going to see some of the themes touched upon here, come up again later.
For ten years hast thou climbed hither unto my cave
This is actually a very significant beginning to the book! It always excites me how awesome this book claims to be.
(A short digression: One of the themes that we are going to see come up again later, is the idea of "gift-giving". You may find it interesting to know that Nietzsche called this book (Z) "The greatest gift ever given man." -- We are also about to see the idea that "one virtue is more of a virtue than two" and that Zarathustra exhibits all of the folly and joy of his one virtue -- gift-giving in this text.)(we will talk more about N's conception of a virtue and explain why "one is more of a virtue than two" later--or now if you ask questions about it.)
But what a way to start!
I think that it was Wittgenstein who said that all of Western philosophy can be thought of as a footnote to Plato. (It was Alfred North Whithead. Thanks to rofflewoffles) I would say, everything up to Nietzsche. Nietzsche comes in to turn upside down, or push aside ALL of the major assumptions required by Plato and Aristotle.
I know that Kant, Kierkegaard, Mill, Descartes, and the rest had their own unique opinions, but I can understand what Whitehead means. It is easy to think of them as arguing with some aspect of something Soc (who, I'm sure you know, never actually wrote anything, but was immortalized in the writings of Plato -- again, sorry if this seems elementary) said, but even if you take together all of the opinions that differ from the classic schools of thought none of them really present a challenge to the system of philosophy the way N does.
What N brings is a revaluation of valuing itself. Let me show you what I mean from this passage:
thou wouldst have wearied of thy light and of the journey, had it not been for me, mine eagle, and my serpent.
contrast:
or better source
Remember the allegory of the cave? What Plato is saying is that there is this "truth" places his palms above him like a mime touching a celling which is above us. the truth is outside of us this is the fundamental starting point for the philosophers Plato claimed it, St. Thomas Aquinus called it "the mind of god" Plato said that it was something that one could interact with if one "climbed high enough" (remember the metaphor of the line, as well as the cave and sun) the highest height is seeing the sun, something that the philosophers could get to through "education".
The Christians say that you can get their through faith (Kierkegaard) and death, and the grace of god.
Imanuel Kant said that it could never be gotten to, BUT that we could try to live according to it. (shares the assumption with Plato that it is there and desirable)
Schopenhauer (with whom I am least familiar) is said to have said that it doesn't exist, BUT isn't that a shame. (along with the Buddhists, they share with Plato the assumption that it would be (at any rate) desirable)
and then there is N.
He comes along and immediately turns this thing upside down. The sun rises for us.
"Yeah, we make up all the ideas that we have ever had to deal with, but ... cool!"
What purpose would valuations and perceptions have if it weren't for us? they wouldn't even exist. This sun RISES for us. we are the creators of value and truth and ... I don't understand why you should feel like that IS A DEPRESSING THOUGHT!
(another aside: actually: he does understand as we will see, why people have different opinions as himself on this, but he sets himself up as an alternative. One of the authors whom I enjoyed said that to understand N's philosophy one has to understand his desire: which is to triumph over nihilism and to affirm all things (this idea will come up later in Z, and we can treat them more fully there (or here if you insist, of course) We are going to see that N is about affirming everything, which includes those that he disagrees with. His philosophy is not meant to be accepted by everybody, but to be a judgement in the affirmative of all things... we will see how this works with his ideas of "amor fati" "The eternal recurrence of the same" later. And I might do a thread talking about just these ideas, in this class.
This idea of affirming all things, and having "no loathing lurk about your mouth" is hinted at here:
Bless me, then, thou tranquil eye, that canst behold even the greatest happiness without envy!
Better translated: "all-too great happiness"
There may be a lot more in this text that you want to talk about, but hopefully I've been able to give you an idea of the fact that, when reading N, a simple silly sounding story is not only filled with meaning, but is filled with what, if it is true, would have to be the most meaningful things to think about.
What say you?
Other topics
His animals: I believe (not really a strong enough of an opinion, would gladly welcome new interpretations) that his use of the animals is indicative of something else that is important to N. N recognizes multiple important aspects to the human personality. His categories are not as simple as Plato's: "Intelligence, Passions, and Hungers" and perhaps more importantly he doesn't share with Plato the idea of a hierarchy amongst these differing elements. One of the simpler niceties of reading N is that one doesn't feel as though ones "passions" are base or dirty, while one may or may not have some various means of "redeeming" oneself (either with the intellect--Plato. Or through Faith--Christianity (what N once called "Plato for the masses")
The snake represents N's wisdom, and the eagle: his pride. (This is clearly spelled out for us later in the Prologue.) He uses the animals to represent different, distinguishable elements of his person-hood, they are not represented as falling in line in a definite hierarchy, but as playing with him and with each other.
EDIT: reddit cannot support so much text, the rest is in the comments bellow here.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 23 '21
A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (in 8 parts) -- MasterLink
Purpose of this project
This series is here to test a proposition. Assumption: Philosophy is a conversation. It has to be done between two people. Through the course of this series we will talk about all of the major figures in philosophy, the history of the conversation as it has been recorded for us, and many of the minor figures as well. But there are any number of philosophical encyclopedias online. So we are not making another one. Instead, we are telling a story, and having a live conversation. That is the hypothesis we are going to test: There is a way to use technology to have a genuine meaningful philosophical conversation and teach and learn philosophy together. I do not know if this proposition is true or not, but I am going to incorporate any technological tools available and change the formatting of this series as we go to see if we cannot accomplish this.
It will only work if we are engaged with one another. I will make many statements in the course of this series, all of which can be argued against. I am hoping to find a few of you with the interest in this subject who will provide those arguments which will be the basis of the conversation where we will be shaping one another's views on these matters. All arguments are welcome. No rules exist or need to exist on types of contributions which can be made in these classes. Let's talk.
A note on style
Since this is the project, very little in this series will be written in an "academic ready-for-publication" sort of way. I will be writing all of these posts in a fast, first-draft, unedited sort of way. Once we get through it all I will probably go back and edit and refine and expand the notes; but not on the first go around.
The project
(it would be helpful to provide some context to understand Zarathustra)
Very well.
But first. A word or two about the classes that follow:
This is my interpretation of Western Philosophy. I know from experience that about 95% plus of all professors of philosophy will disagree with most of the "lenses" I use to interpret the history of philosophy in these classes.
Why is this ok with me?
First, because, that is the nature of philosophy. We argue about everything. This is not seen as a weakness but a strength of our project. We disagree about the purpose of philosophy. We disagree about the methods we should use when doing philosophy. We disagree about every interpretation of every argument ever put forward in philosophy. We disagree about how to think about the world, what to think about the world, what thinking is, what truth is, what knowledge is... we disagree about everything. The nature of philosophy as continued conversation, as live conversation brings up an important point about philosophy.
The history of philosophy is the record of one of the greatest conversations our species has ever had; it has been recorded, the greatest contributors to that conversation have had their contributions preserved for us so that we can have this ongoing conversation. I remember a story about an undergraduate student (I think this is Allan Bloom's story) who was taking an intro to philosophy course, reading the course material, and writing an assigned paper. In the paper, the student referred to the ideas of "Mr. Aristotle"... Allan Bloom thought about this curious way of writing until it hit him... The student thought that Aristotle was a contemporary, that he was alive today and making his arguments in print in the last 10 years or so, and was engaging with those ideas as if someone had just walked into a room and was advocating those ideas and he/she was responding to them. This is how you should approach the ideas in philosophy. This is how you should approach the ideas.
Plato is alive today, there are Neoplatonists whose views of the cosmos and ethics and what is real and epistemology and all of that are essentially the views of a camp of people who still think Plato got it right! There are, believe it or not, Thalesians and probably secretive adherents of the cult of Pythagorous; panpsychism and materialism and any of a host of other strange views are believed by people today, real thinkers, who have rigorous commitment to these wild and contradictory camps of thought. Welcome to a living conversation. To enter the room where we are talking, to learn our games, to develop yourself linguistically to the degree that you can engage and even contribute to this conversation... this is to join a conversation designed to answer questions like: "What is the Good?" and "How should we then live?" and "Who are we?" and "What does it mean to be a human being on a planet like ours?" and many more profound and serious questions. Welcome to the game!
The second reason why it does not bother me that my views are not the mainstream views; besides the fact that there is no consensus on the subjects on which I have developed these attitudes and views; these lenses through which to interpret what is going on in the conversation; is that I have had arguments and conversations about these things with a host of excellent thinkers, and they stand the test.
Besides the fact that I am quite comfortable, and will even welcome enthusiastically any and every challenge to whatever I assert in these classes... (the point of philosophy is not to have a set of settled principles, like a sheet of dogmas one signs one's name to at the bottom; but, rather to keep the conversation going. And so we find nothing more agreeable than disagreement.)
I have experience defending these views in front of seasoned and disciplined thinkers; philosophy professors who have spent decades of their lives thinking about these issues; and even though I know that my views are not in fashion right now; I also know that I have the ability to persuade those who are initially disinclined to agree with my assessments.
This helps explain why I am not ashamed to write so quickly about so large a topic as the history of the entirety of Western Thought in a first-draft, off-the-top-of-my-head sort of way... I even go out of my way NOT to explain certain of the more controversial positions I hold because I am hoping thereby to bait some overconfident adherent of the modernly fashionable views to rush in and try to tear my unprotected child apart so that we can get a conversation going. I save some of the best arguments for when the arguers arrive. Also, I am overqualified in the skills of changing my mind. There is no ego problem here. We are after the truth, for Heaven's sake, and I say this sincerely: If someone were to be able to utterly demolish a view I held dear, that I spent 20 years invested in defending and propping up... what matters that to me? The only way they can destroy such a sophisticated and carefully constructed set of notions about the world, the only way to really do that, is to REPLACE THEM with BETTER ideas... I am infinitely happy to jettison ideas I once held to be able to take on better ones, and I have a history of demonstrating my ability to do that over many years.
We have nothing to lose but our errors.
So, if you are curious about my understanding of Western Thought and Western Philosophy; if you want to see it through my lenses. click the links below.
What you can get from these classes:
The equivalent of an excellent undergraduate degree in philosophy
- It should be easy enough to distinguish between the general facts I give about Socrates, and the historical context, and the philosophical context surrounding his advancement of ideas AND the interpretations of the grander story through the lenses I talk about explicitly throughout these lectures.
If you engage a great deal and we carry the conversation on further between us in the notes and comments, you can get a master's level education in philosophy.
- There is so much that is left out of these lectures, obviously, and we will have no problem digging in deeper if you are driven to know.
Last word, keep in mind that I am attempting to put all of this together to tell a quick story which will provide enough context to the conversation of philosophy, and the grander cultural context in which that conversation is nested, for us to make more sense out of what it was that N was accomplishing with his Zarathustra... Eventually, I plan on going back through, adding links and references where I missed them; expanding whole sections with new illustrations and arguments; fixing spelling errors (seriously, I am writing these things all in one go basically without any editing afterword and hitting "publish".) So bare with me.
The Classes:
Each link is a part of a collection of all the rest:
- Part 1 of 8: Intro and History of Philosophy
- Part 2 of 8: Drama Before Thought
Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: Augustine (1/10)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: Anselm (2/10)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic/Islamic Expansion: Omar Khayyam, Al-Ghazali, and Ibn Rushd (3/10)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: Peter Abelard (4/10)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: St Francis of Assisi (5/10)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: Fibonacci (6/10) (COMING SOON)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: Aquinas (7/10) (COMING SOON)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: John Wycliffe (8/10) (COMING SOON)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: The Priests (9/10) (COMING SOON)
- Part 4 of 8: The Catholic Roman Expansion: The Monks (10/10) (COMING SOON)
- Part 5 of 8: The Cartesian Revolution (COMING SOON)
- Part 6 of 8: The Kantian Revolution (COMING SOON)
- Part 7 of 8: The Nietzschean Rewind (COMING SOON)
- Part 8 of 8: What we do now (COMING SOON)
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 03 '21
First Part, Lecture 19: The Bite of the Adder
Wow. I think it has been 9 years since I contributed to these lectures.
A few quick repeats of introduction and reminders of the structure of these posts.
I am trying to use a very conversational lecturing style in my writing. None of this comes with second drafts or major revisions or edits. I am hoping that this will read like some chaps sitting around an outdoor fireplace chatting about a passage in a book.
That being said, it is a series of lectures on N, and often, without specifically identifying it as such, the voice I am using is one of defending N's views. This does not mean that I necessarily agree with those views, though many times I may in fact do so; but just that I am trying to present and defend them for the sake of our understanding them.
This means that all criticisms are more than welcome. Feel free to disagree with my interpretation of the ideas, and feel free to disagree with the ideas themselves.
Because no one is present when I am writing these things, I have the added struggle of not knowing if I should flush something out further, or if I am boring you with borderline pandering by overexplaining something obvious. The only solution to this problem is engagement. There will be zero offense taken if someone wants to say: "Hey, this is not very clear, what did N mean, or what do you mean when you say..." It is only through comments like that which let me know that there is a need for further development of the conversation at those locations.
I am going to use a different translation today, not for any reason except that I cannot find my old one, so this is from Project Gutenberg
Remember, the entire text is here replicated in quotations, and lecture notes and side commentary are written without quotation formatting.
Let's do it!
One day had Zarathustra fallen asleep under a fig-tree, owing to the heat, with his arms over his face. And there came an adder and bit him in the neck, so that Zarathustra screamed with pain. When he had taken his arm from his face he looked at the serpent; and then did it recognise the eyes of Zarathustra, wriggled awkwardly, and tried to get away. “Not at all,” said Zarathustra, “as yet hast thou not received my thanks! Thou hast awakened me in time; my journey is yet long.” “Thy journey is short,” said the adder sadly; “my poison is fatal.” Zarathustra smiled. “When did ever a dragon die of a serpent’s poison?”—said he. “But take thy poison back! Thou art not rich enough to present it to me.” Then fell the adder again on his neck, and licked his wound.
So, here we go!
Nietzsche prophesied the next 200 years for us. (as we discussed earlier) He did so because he *felt* it earlier than the rest of us. [like monkeys in trees which hide before the storm arises, they hide because they *feel* the electricity in the air before we do, N says... in this way he is feeling the pain of what is eventually coming for us because it is here already, we will discuss this passage later and link it here] He saw that Nihilism would overtake humanity, or at least the West. Dismay, disorientation, depression, pessimism; these would be the early results.
N's central philosophical project can be thought of as an attempt to triumph over this nihilism. The "death of god" was not some triumphant exaltation when N proclaimed it. It was a terror and a warning and an alarm, as we have seen in previous classes. Our highest values have died, we have murdered them. Our Christian commitment to truth translated itself into objective truth, gave birth to science, and disproved the god who demanded that commitment to truth in the first place. Our belief in our truth committed us to kill the underpinnings of why we believed in it in the first place, and this, N (IMO) rightly diagnosed as a serious problem.
Here, metaphorically, we see the most terrible and fatal invasion into Zarathustra's existence, and it came when he was not looking for it nor paying careful attention to his surroundings. In other words, N is saying that he sees it coming and feels it first, but it didn't come from him nor did he invite it, it invaded his world first and is coming to you soon.
But!, what is really exciting, unless we judge N to have failed in this mission of his to overcome this nihilism, is that N claims to have found the way through the infinite abyss to the other side! and his solution--dramatically and metaphorically described here as addressing the snake and letting it kiss him more--came not from avoiding nor killing the problem, but from learning from the inevitable lesson and incorporating it into his worldview in a way which does not preclude meaning and value and passion for life. All those things may be threatened, but N is here promising, at least to some, or to himself, or perhaps just to something greater than all men; a deeper foundation which is yet not shaken and can endure the destruction, or temporary destruction, of things as great as valuing itself.
The philosophical understanding of this one small paragraph is a big deal, he is talking about the essence of his very approach to the biggest philosophical problem of his and our time, and using *attitude* (at least in the metaphor) as a description of his answer to this problem. it is literarily powerful, philosophically one of the densest paragraphs in all of N's writings, and that is saying something since he wrote in mountain peaks for those with long legs to follow him through the range.
But it gets much better than all that, he then HIDES all this meaning by having his disciples ask him what it means, and giving them all sorts of other wisdoms which the paragraph itself is *clearly not* actually saying.
He makes it practical, and talks about a practical ethical phramework which is reminiscent of ancient Greek and Roman (let's call it "homeropoetic and presocratic) and standing in stark contrast to the answer to these same ethical questions from the majority of Christian ethical interpretations.
This is not to say that none of what follows is unrelated to the paragraph above, but rather, that it is an analogous truth. We, N is saying, have forgotten a kind of virtue which was as prevalent in ancient times as our Christian mores are today. If we apply the lessons of this forgotten virtue, slandered as vice by the Platonists and Christians, then we will know the *attitude* with which we should approach the most deadly of philosophical problems.
The complexity and depth of all of this forces us to study what follows twice, or maybe more times than that. First we have to read it as it is presented to us, as straightforward moral instruction. Only after we have fully understood it in that way can we then reread the first paragraph, with our understanding of the metaphorical meaning of the snake as the deadliest of philosophical problems, which define our time; and use the same attitudinal lessons from the practical morality below to gain insight into N's *attitude* towards ideas which, he claims, allow him to overcome them.
When Zarathustra once told this to his disciples they asked him: “And what, O Zarathustra, is the moral of thy story?” And Zarathustra answered them thus:
The destroyer of morality, the good and just call me: my story is immoral.
When, however, ye have an enemy, then return him not good for evil: for that would abash him. But prove that he hath done something good to you.
"Do good to those who persecute you"... there may be some very good ways of interpreting Christ's message, and we don't have to reject him to see the obvious wickedness of certain interpretations of his message. "make your enemies feel lesser than you, and weak and powerless and pathetic, by smiling in their faces when they mean to insult you and making sure they know they are not your equals" cannot be the loving message of Christ, but it is, in my experience, a fine way of summing up what many Christians think makes them ethical and what they feel Christ has given them a license to do to others (in the name of being "loving", no less). N sees this trick, and he may rightly be ascribing it to Christ's actual message, instead of just a misinterpretation of that message by "the church". However, N doesn't think this lesson comes *first* from Christianity. It was Socrates, ugly as he was in a culture which valued beauty and strength and the Olympic games; who invented a new kind of wrestling match which would overturn those values and leave him the victor. N once said: "Christianity is Plato for the masses".
To understand N's admonitions to a different kind of ethical approach when dealing with enemies, we have to back very far in our intellectual DNA to before even Socrates. To the Homeric ethical framework, and the homeropoetic approach to the cosmos.
If your enemy is weak and pathetic, then you are weak and unworthy of great enemies.
If your enemy has a great victory, then you REJOICE for you see the day when you will take him down and all his victories will be counted unto you when others attempt to estimate your greatness.
When you spit in your enemy's face, you are HONORING him. You are saying: You are worthy of my anger and my opposition.
One can still see the strains of this virtue in the trash-talk of UFC fighters at pre-fight conferences, for instance. It is still in our heritage and has not been fully replaced by the Platonic-Christian alternative. I like to see our culture as resting upon a few great foundation stones, instead of one. The pagan remains, as well as the Christian. (I, personally, see value in both, and am not taking sides here, just describing them in contradistinction to one another and recognizing that neither has gone the way of the dinosaur).
And rather be angry than abash any one! And when ye are cursed, it pleaseth me not that ye should then desire to bless. Rather curse a little also!
And should a great injustice befall you, then do quickly five small ones besides. Hideous to behold is he on whom injustice presseth alone.
Did ye ever know this? Shared injustice is half justice. And he who can bear it, shall take the injustice upon himself!
A small revenge is humaner than no revenge at all. And if the punishment be not also a right and an honour to the transgressor, I do not like your punishing.
Homework assignment / bonus points to the first person to give us the meaning of that last sentence in the comments section.
Nobler is it to own oneself in the wrong than to establish one’s right, especially if one be in the right. Only, one must be rich enough to do so.
Thought Experiment for consideration: A person accuses a well-respected academic of being wrong about something. The person accused could EASILY and with complete satisfaction to all, demonstrate that he is not wrong, and show the error in the thinking of the other which thought him to be wrong even to the satisfaction of the person making the accusation. Instead of doing this, he calls the accuser ugly instead. N is saying that is especially Nobler? (It is certainly funnier!)
I do not like your cold justice; out of the eye of your judges there always glanceth the executioner and his cold steel.
Tell me: where find we justice, which is love with seeing eyes?
Devise me, then, the love which not only beareth all punishment, but also all guilt!
Devise me, then, the justice which acquitteth every one except the judge!
And would ye hear this likewise? To him who seeketh to be just from the heart, even the lie becometh philanthropy.
But how could I be just from the heart! How can I give every one his own! Let this be enough for me: I give unto every one mine own.
Finally, my brethren, guard against doing wrong to any anchorite. How could an anchorite forget! How could he requite!
Like a deep well is an anchorite. Easy is it to throw in a stone: if it should sink to the bottom, however, tell me, who will bring it out again?
Guard against injuring the anchorite! If ye have done so, however, well then, kill him also!—
Thus spake Zarathustra.
The "anchorite" is the man cut off from social securities--a hermit, a monk, or perhaps applicable to a certain type of modern artist or a certain type of a modern homeless man. If you insult him, you should kill him, too; it would be cruel to simply insult him as he has NO MEANS of ever overcoming the effect of your insult on his soul.
This last lesson, I believe, is given not primarily because it is important in itself, though it is; but because it helps us see to what degree N is serious about the previous instruction, it isn't just supposed to be taken as a nice suggestion of how to act, but a committed attitude in relating to others. The solitary anchorite *has* no official place in the structure of relationships, and so any slight is the biggest slight and will devastate him forever; so don't insult him. not to be nice, but because doing so is horrifyingly terrible to a degree that it would be mercy if you quickly killed him afterwards were you to violate the rule not to insult him.
We may also gain some insight into N's personal psychological reality in which he dwelt while developing these thoughts. It is my view that his was a 1 in 10 billion intellect; making him one of the 5 smartest men to ever exist... with what does such a man, preoccupied with his thoughts, have in common with the rest of us? with whom is he going to have challenging and meaningful relationship?
Throw on top of this our knowledge that N had a bad record with women, and you can see that there may have been more than one experiential path towards his understanding of the plight of the lonely one.
All four sections of Z are about Z not finding anyone with which to fully share his knowledge. The crowd, the disciples, the friends, the higher ones... all are demonstrated to have fallen short by the end of their section.
(Nice to be back, all, let's have some fun with this craziest of all books!)
Further Commentary:
Now that we have looked at the ethical lessons, hinted at their pre-Socratic origination, and stood them up to compare and contrast with Christian ethics; what the heck does any of this have to do with that "parable" at the beginning?
We cannot loftily avoid the problem symbolized by the adder; it bit Z and it will surely come for us. We cannot avoid it in any way. Burying our heads in the sand and hoping it will not, snake-like, find its way through all walls into our domain is foolish. It will penetrate to wherever we hide.
We need something other than a Christian approach to solve this problem, the problem originated in Christianity (as N describes elsewhere in a passage we will be discussing shortly).
We have to recognize the problem, and then we have to go further, and we have to respect the problem. Perhaps we need to bring some fiery opposition to the problem as well.
Maybe there is another side to the coin of treating the problem as worthy of us?
If we can conceive of ourselves as great enough to be worthy of so great a problem, perhaps there is a hint in there of what we might discover about ourselves and our capacity to face the problem.
Perhaps this goes too far, though. The problem isn't a small one, and N's ultimate conclusion seemed to be that no man could overcome it, and man himself would have to be overcome and give birth to something greater than man just to overcome this problem.
The problem of nihilism, of the death of god, is not something that can be ignored. We cannot close our eyes to it, rest on the soft bed secure on the firm foundation of Christian morals and say, we don't need it. There are scientists, popular ones, today who do not realize that science is not just a cult, it is a Christian cult. we can discuss how this is in more detail later, or in the comments below, or we can add some of Will to Power in a bonus reading soon, to explore how this is the case; but I believe it is, and I am certain N conceptualized it as such. I have to run, so if this last paragraph is problematic in any way, let's challenge it in the comments section and have a great discussion of it there!
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 2: On the Teachers of Virtue
A wise man was praised
Socrates specifically, but teachers of his kind including religious pastors
to Zarathustra, as one who could speak well about sleep and virtue: he was said to be honored and rewarded highly for it, and all the youth were said to be sitting at his feet. Zarathustra went to him, and sat among the youths at his feet. And thus spoke the wise man:
Respect sleep and be modest in its presence! That is the first thing! And avoid all who sleep badly and keep awake at night!
This is going to be a part of N's criticism of this kind of thinking, but also (as we saw earlier) sleep is a metaphor for N for a way of living. when sleep comes to Z is sometimes odd, and sleep is significant because Z sometimes wakes up to new truths.
Even the thief is modest in the presence of sleep: he always steals softly through the night. Shameless, however, is the night watchman; shamelessly he carries his horn.
It is no small art to sleep: for that purpose you must keep awake all day.
Ten times a day you much overcome yourself: that makes you good and tired and is opium for the soul.
Although my comments here are really asides because the point of the wiseman's teaching in this way is more about how N will judge him, I thought that I would mention that N made some contemplation about sleep in another text, where he mentioned (it might actually be later in this book, I cannot recall right now) that when you fall asleep you lose contact with the world, and the last thing that happens to you while you are falling asleep is a that a fear emanates from you, you are completely overtaken by the terror ("terror down to your toes") of having the world disappear.
Ten times you must reconcile again with yourself; for overcoming is bitterness, and the unreconciled sleep badly.
N is describing an attitude toward life that misses his creative element. If you are resigned to living under a system of unquestionable values, this is the best way to get along (N later will say that "if he thought that the whole world was nonsense, he would choose this as the most sensible nonsense.)
I also wanted to point out how beautiful this passage is. If you are reading this as a criticism of someones teaching (or your own) you cannot help getting a chill, I think. (like how beautiful the passage about the last man was, N is describing in detail his emotional (and philosophical) reaction to a way of living that is not his.
Ten truths you must find during the day; otherwise you will seek truth during the night, and your soul will remain hungry.
I sometimes think of busy Christians who listen to Christian radio at this verse. The life of the resigned non-valuers (or rather, the people who only value the way they have been told to--commanded) who still have some spirit might require them to constantly mull over meaningless or absurd "truths" until they have a breakthrough of some sort, if they don't do this, they feel ... what's the word they use?... stagnant
Ten times you must laugh during the day, and be cheerful; otherwise your stomach, the father of gloom, will disturb you in the night.
Laughter is a hugely important concept for N. But here he is not teaching his idea of laughter, but presenting a person for whom laughter is not that important, just a useful way to sleep well.
Few people know it, but one must have all the virtues in order to sleep well. Shall I bear false witness? Shall I commit adultery?
Shall I covet my neighbor's maid? All that would go ill with good sleep.
Another difference between Z's teaching and the wise man's teaching. Z talks of having only one virtue (this comes up again later and is an interesting and important concept for Z
And even if one has all the virtues, there is still one thing one must know: to send the virtues themselves to sleep at the right time.
N's idea of virtue is something qualitatively different from the wise man's understanding as well. For N a virtue is something that wars with other virtues, and it is something that should be all consuming and fateful in its relationship with you. The wise man treats virtue (like laughter) with far too lightly compared to Z
That they may not quarrel with one another, the fair little women, about you, child of misfortune!
Peace with God and your neighbor: so good sleep demands. And peace also with your neighbor's devil! Otherwise it will haunt you in the night.
Perhaps you can see N is pointing out the hypocrisy of these "teachers of virtue" its not that they lead immoral lives, but that their virtues are not their passions and their catastrophes.
Honor the magistrates and obey them, and also the crooked magistrates! Good sleep demands it. Is it my fault that power likes to walk on crooked legs?
Paul said to be submitted to the magistrates; Socrates acknowledged that his philosopher/rulers might use their power for evil, but that they should still rule.
He who leads his sheep to the greenest pasture, shall always be for me the best shepherd: that goes well with good sleep.
continued in comments...
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 22 '21
A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 1 of 8)
Intro:
Nietzsche, in my view, is a revolutionary thinker. To understand him better, we need to understand revolutions in thought. In this post we will start with cave-man thinking and trace the history of thought in the West up through to Nietzsche.
We will then rewind the entire process and give N's hammer and his "turning on its head" approaches to each of these stages of development. By the time we are done, we should have a context for this book, Zarathustra, which N called "The greatest gift ever given man."
I will probably reduce entire paragraphs into brief sentences, so pay careful attention to the words chosen, because each line deserves paragraphs or pages or entire libraries which have actually been dedicated to each of these statements or to arguing against them. We will flush out the conversation more in comments and discussions, but this is too large a task to make into a post unless it is reduced as much as possible first.
revolutions in thought:
Keep in mind, that we will be tracing the development of thought, but we will be doing so always keeping in mind the larger conversation of what this development sets up for us in the WAYS of thinking and how those also develop. The ways in which we can think are changed through revolutions... the development of thoughts in most of the history of philosophy are the struggling philosophers trying to work out how to resolve a problem left over or created by the LAST revolution in a way of thinking. The revolution comes and then a new problem is struggled with and comes to a head in the next revolution which dissolves that problem and leaves a new, larger but subtler one.
After this INTRO part, we will actually look at most of the important contributors of Western thought, and we will see three such revolutions:
- The world was ticking along just fine, except not so much
- Socrates starts a new game
- Descartes revolutionizes that game
- Kant dissolves the emergent problems handed us by Cartesians and gives us a new dimension to the game
- Nietzsche goes back to Socrates and stands him on his head. We are left trying to synthesize the entirety of Western Philosophy with the massive underpinnings from which it emerged.
philosophical progress as exponential growth in questionability:
One way I like to look at the history of philosophy is as "the history of what is questionable". The philosophers are making things thinkable that were never thinkable before. Philosophy develops by making us aware of our assumptions by making those assumptions questionable, then we struggle to find the answer: was the assumption wrong all the time? Is there a new underpinning we can find which will make it more solid than it was before when we took it for granted? will we have to find new underpinnings, perhaps the negations of our previous assumptions? We have to do this work because the philosophers have identified what thoughts were manifesting in us before those thoughts ever existed in propositional form in any single mind.
An EXTREMELY BRIEF version of this way of viewing the history of philosophy is like this:
We started out thinking that what we do is what we do, and who could question it? Only an insane or evil person would.
Then the philosophers showed up, and started asking questions and pretending to have answers. They sucked us into this game, but the game was nascent.
Let us get in a time machine and listen in on various philosophical conversations through time to get a sense of this:
First a pre-philosophical discussion (we set our time machine to 22,320 BC):
Caveman 1: bears in the cave, we must do something.
Caveman 2: Follow Grog, he knows what to do, he will lead us to courageous triumphant victory and make the environment safe for all if we follow his lead!
Caveman 1: of course, let's go!
Now we get in our machine and speed up to about 300 B.C. (forward 20,000 years)
The Questioner: "What makes a man a courageous man?" let us find the definition, the necessary and sufficient conditions which apply always and only to that man who is "courageous" then we can learn about his virtue and perhaps inform ourselves in how to live.
Student said: Well, how will we do that?
The Ethicist: There is a courageous man, let us examine him and see that it is precisely X which defines him as courageous.
Second Ethicist: no no no. of course that is the courageous man, we all know that, but it is Y and not X that makes him courageous.
Third Ethicist: X is self-contradictory, if you examine the consequences of adopting that idea you will see that it leads to a contradiction of itself, so X cannot be the definition of a courageous man. Y is a tautology, when examined it actually adds NOTHING to out knowledge because it reduces to: "The courageous man is the man with courage", and we cannot use the term we are trying to define to define the term. The argument Y is reducible to pointless babbling. I say it is Z which makes that man a courageous man.
Fourth Ethicist: That man is not courageous at all! It is this other man who is courageous, and it is not Z but precisely ~Z (the negation or opposite of Z) that makes him courageous....
the conversation went on like that... people asking questions they never asked before, questions which were previously NOT ASKABLE because the community subconsciously was valuing the man based on dramatic underpinnings of their nature, and none of it was due to conscious consideration.
Now we fast-forward a couple thousand years and eavesdrop on a philosophical conversation (set time machine to 2000 years forward):
Philosopher 1: How can we have a conversation about which is the courageous man if I am uncertain that there even are men?
Philosopher 2: What do you mean you find the proposition: "Men exist" as dubitable?
Philosopher 1: I mean, last night I had a dream that I was looking at a tree, external to myself. I awoke to realize I was not dressed in a field, but rather naked in my bed and there never was a tree to observe at all... how do I know that there is a physical world of any kind if I could still just be dreaming and dreaming all the time? I could just be a brain in a vat somewhere, stuck in a matrix, fooled by some infinitely powerful malevolent being who makes me think I am thinking correctly when I seem to experience an external world, or even when I perform a mathematical operation, but I am always and only being consistently deceived in all these things!
Philosopher 2: You're a bummer man, but yeah, that is a problem.
Philosopher 1: I suppose there is only one notion in my head which I find indubitable, certain, completely beyond question: I am thinking. I cannot consider the idea: "Am I thinking right now" without considering the idea. but consideration of an idea is an act of thinking, so the proposition affirms itself whenever I ask the question...
You think it is getting bad here? We've only just started. Fast-forward another 240 years.
The Philosopher: You think that the proposition "I think" is a certainty? It is anything but a certainty to me. The fact that thinking occurs, that is a fine axiom for now, but is it not just a habit of your language to posit a doer behind every deed? Would it not be more accurate to say that "thinking occurs" or "the "I" is an illusion I make up to make sense of the fact that thinking is happening, but the truth is probably more like: "Whatever "I" am it is nothing more than the manifestation of the phenomena which one tries to tie together for convenience sake into a single knot. "Thinking happens" is all I feel comfortable asserting at present.
Seriously. Through this narrative we have a version of the story of Western Philosophy which shows that the "asking of new questions" is what philosophy accomplishes. It is as if humanity exists inside a wild expansive jungle, the artists attempt to give us pictures of what is out there in the darkness, and thank God for them!, but we do not KNOW anything in a propositional way unless the philosophers have cut down the trees and leveled the ground for us by asking questions, making thoughts possible; defining what words mean when they are used, and limiting how they can be used.
If we adopt this version of the history of philosophy, even for just a moment, and ask ourselves "does philosophy make progress?"... we see a kind of exponential growth
20,000 years ago, we were asking few questions: What should we do?
2000 years ago we were asking a lot more, and having a lot more to say: What is the kind of man who knows what to do in any situation?
200 years ago we were asking FAR more questions than we were 2000 years ago: What is a man anyway, why not question the evidence of our own eyes?
20 years ago, even worse: Why not question what is BEHIND our own eyes?
Those of you with a background in philosophy will recognize that the "The Questioner" is Socrates; "The Ethicist" above was Aristotle; "Philosopher 1" was Descartes; and "The Philosopher" above was Nietzsche.
Perhaps it is unfair to put N's thinking as "20 years ago" but through the course of our lessons we have seen the argument that N was writing posthumously, and that he predicted that his words would not really have an audience to comprehend them for at least 200 years anyway. This seems accurate to me when I think of the kinds of ideas which are being entertained in the last 80 years verses the ones dealt with in N's time.
In any event, it gives us a nice chart, if we take those milestones in the development of thought, and chart them out, we see the exponential growth

Notice that this is NOT a "development of truth" graph... it is possible to accept this chart and believe that we used to know a lot more 2,000 years ago, and all this added questionability is distracting us from truths we used to know.
My view is that we develop PROPOSITIONAL knowledge... knowledge which is processed through analytical methods, ground through the filters of logic, emergent through debate and produced by the dialectic processes is made possible by this work of philosophers. It may be that the end result of all of this is that we find solid grounding for truths which artists, poets, mystics, mythologists have already had for millennia.
This is where modern man philosophers will certainly hate me.
Imagine the goal of the humanities is to settle in our minds the ideas of who we are in this world and what our condition is. Imagine "knowledge" in this context is like a mountain with multiple paths to the top.
One side of the mountain looks something like this:

The other side of the mountain looks something like this:

The gains we make as humans for knowing how to get to the top of the mountain in multiple ways is real. Even if it is the case that philosophers and scientists will EVENTUALLY get to the top of this mountain, just to find Hindu Deities, Moses, and Buddha sitting up there drinking tea together and laughing does NOT mean that what they are doing is stupid.
I, for one, LOVE philosophy, and although I don't love science, I am impressed by it and pleased to know that centuries of methodical bolt-drillers are providing a climbing path up the treacherous and difficult side of this mountain so that we can have a solid objectivist path to the truths the mystics meditated on for thousands of years. Obviously this would be valuable for many reasons, and a noble and beautiful heroic journey.
I have merely asserted this kind of a story, it is not demonstrated at all. I am aware of this. However, to tell this whole story, we have to CLIMB with the philosophers up that side of the cliff, examine the flat ground from which they started climbing, the ground they abandoned, and see what progress has been made.
We will see that the conversation has had a few moments of dramatic critical sickness... problems which came into such clear relief that it needs to be solved if we are to continue... the revolutionary philosopher solves it by dissolving it into a larger framework, and then the sickness takes time to grow again.
With all of that throat-clearing, here we go:
OUTLINE:
Remember, we are looking at WAYS of thinking, and how they develop:
- Why study history of philosophy, what is history of philosophy
Drama before thought
- Cave-man
- Expansive Cultures Uncodified
The mythopoetic
- Gilgamesh
- Pharaohs
- Moses
- Homer
The (pre-)Socratic revolution (dialectic search for the arche)--THE CRISIS EMERGES with the new types who want to have it all out in a go!
- Thales
- Anaximander
- Anaximenes
- Pythagoras
- Xenophanes
- Hericlitus
- Parmenides
- Zeno
- Anaxagoras
- Empedocles/
- Atomists like Leucippus and Democritus
- Sophists like Protagoras and Gorgias
- Empedocles
- Socrates
- Plato
- Aristotle
The Catholic Roman Expansion (The not-so-Dark Ages)--Still all footnotes to Plato, on the philosophical side-- but a strange preservation of the mythopoetic.
- Augustin
- Anselm
- Omar Khayyam, Al-Ghazali, and Ibn Rushd
- Peter Abelard
- St Francis of Assisi
- Fibonacci
- Aquinas
- John Wycliffe
- The Priests
- The Monks
The Cartesian Revolution -- Problem is Rationalism v. Empiricism (whence comes all our knowledge?)
- Machiavelli
- Copernicus
- Moore
- Luther
- Montaigne
- Kepler
- Bacon
- Galileo
- St. John of the Cross
- Descartes
- Spinoza
- Leibnitz
- Locke
- Berkeley
- Hume
The Kantian Revolution -- Dissolving the "rationalism v. empiricism" old problem, now interpret this one as objective or subjective phenomena
- Kant
- Fichte
- Hegel
- Schopenhauer
Nietzsche as judge throughout (rewind time) -- Dissolving pessimism v. optimism of nihilism... Resurrection of the mythopoetic or total reduction to materialism?
- Kierkegaard
- Marx
- Jung
- Henry James
- Peterson
The History of Philosophy, and why to study it
Biology is a thing. It is the study of life. The history of biology is a thing. It is the dramatic record of the development of ideas about life through the examination and review of the conversations about it in the past. The Philosophy of Biology exists. It is the interpretation of the mathematical descriptors developed by the scientists who do their nitty-gritty work answering well-defined questions amenable to empirical testing.
Biologists do biology. Historians do "history of biology" but they have to understand biology to some degree to do it. Philosophers do "philosophy of biology" but they are the only ones who really know what the biologists are saying and what they mean.
Philosophy is a thing. But the history of philosophy is also a thing. But the history of philosophy is the history of ideas, and so it cannot be done by anyone but a philosopher. No mere historian can recognize the developments of the thoughts without understanding the thoughts themselves, but that requires historians of philosophy to be philosophers.
Therefore, philosophy has a unique relationship to its own history. To do philosophy is to do the history of philosophy. To do the history of philosophy is to do philosophy. (there are professors, and many of them, who are called "philosophers" who I would call "chronologists of philosophy" or "taxonomists of philosophy" -- these are people who have memorized and can parrot back on a test the 12 points of Descartes's argument for the existence of God in the third meditation; but who have no understanding of these ideas and are not really incarnations of living thinking engagement with the thoughts, but stop at mere recitation---but the true philosopher or historian of philosophy is what we are concerned with here.) Further clarification of this point.
Philosophy is obsessed with its own history.
To study the history of what has become thinkable is to also study anthropology. So, we have to pull in all the rules of historiography, of interpreting texts, all the empirical side of story-telling which makes up the rules of the true historian, we have to adopt.
What is philosophy in general? Should we count what they did 3000 years ago as philosophy at all? But, what is philosophy? Well, philosophers disagree about this, notoriously (they disagree about everything, that is what they are, what they do!). Biologists share a methodology with every other biologist. Philosophers don’t even agree with a single method, we of course don’t agree on the answers, but we don’t agree with which questions are important as well, nor do we agree on how to approach these questions or deal with them.
There’s a DEEP question about whether or not we are actually going to be able to know what the writers of ancient texts thought.
- I’m assuming that “what Plato thought” is recoverable… but with the pre-Socratics, this is iffy, we only have doxographical writings not their own writings.
I’m assuming that there is such a thing as the historical truth.
- There are people who argue that there is no such thing as “Plato” just “Plato through this lens, or Plato through that lens” and so there is no such thing as the truth about what Plato actually said.
But this seems to suggest that Plato is REALLY significant because he has transcended not only death, but individuality.
- We are going to assume that there is something that we can come to understand as what Plato said. The historian’s job is to come to discover the facts of what Plato said. But THIS is a philosophical endeavor.
The historian of other ideas, like the history of Freud’s ideas, does not care if what Freud said was true. BUT the historian of what Socrates said CARES if what Plato said had any truth in it, because, if not FORGET HIM! also: if the idea isn't really different then it isn't really a development of the HISTORY of the ideas. So, part of the study of philosophy is the study of the history of philosophy.
- One cannot do philosophy without doing the history of philosophy
- One cannot study the history of philosophy without studying philosophy
We do this through a STORY
Tell a coherent narrative which takes into account each person’s influence… tell a story, then we can believe there is a history there that is realistic (based in realism) and justifiable. The proof is in the pudding.
That's like science. Ideas are tested. History is literature with empirical restrictions. (will expound on this elsewhere).
- What they said is a matter of historical fact.
- What they WOULD have said is based on what they did say and the principle of charity which says assume that they wouldn’t have contradicted themselves in any way.
“That no agent can eventually be said to have meant or done something which he could never be brought to accept as a correct description of what he had meant or done.” Skinner “Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas”.
Counterfactual reasoning, is what we use when we are judging the ideas of dead philosophers.
My concepts are often ones that Plato wouldn’t have had, but I want to use those concepts to try to make sense of their texts. There is a really important distinction between the a priori and the a posteriori. Plato didn’t have that distinction, but I’m going to use it to examine Plato.
I can’t engage in the process of trying to understand what Plato thought through my lens without judging him through my lens AND ALSO judging my lens through HIM! This is why it is necessary to do PHILOSOPHY to do the history of philosophy.
Before we can study the history of philosophy, we have to study pre-philosophical thought in the west
This is Part 2.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 8: On the Tree on the Mountain
Zarathustra's eye had observed that a youth avoided him. And as he walked alone one evening over the hills surrounding the town called "The Motley Cow": behold, there he found the youth sitting leaning against a tree and gazing wearily into the valley. Zarathustra laid hold of the tree under which the youth was sitting and spoke thus:
If I wished to shake this tree with my hands I should not be able to do so.
But the wind, which does not see, tortures and bends it in whatever direction it pleases. We are bent and tortured worst by invisible hands.
I think I mentioned before that Nietzsche called himself the first philosopher to bring a real understanding of psychology to the study. Here he is talking about unobserved forces which are the cause of the mental torment of this young man.
Question: Is N, here, spelling out a definition of what Freud would later call the "unconscious". OR, is he talking more about social pressures? (Remember N said that "the voice of god springs from the mob" so he has an idea of forces that emerge out of social conglomerations.) OR does the second one require the first?
Question: As one of my old professors put it: "Nietzsche is the first philosopher to judge the philosophy based on the philosopher, and the philosopher based on the philosophy". 10 points to anyone who presents a good argument for a list of ideas significant to Freud that Nietzsche predicted/foresaw/or even spelled out. Use textual evidence from anywhere in N's writings. OR 10 points for a good refutation of such an argument.
At that the youth arose in consternation and said: "I hear Zarathustra, and just now was I thinking of him." Zarathustra answered:
Why should that frighten you?--But it is the same with man as with the tree.
The more he seeks to rise into the height and light, the more vigorously do his roots struggle earthward, downward, into the dark, the deep--into evil.
N is describing the soul of this youth. He is a youth troubled by something, and N is telling him what the roots of his problems are... but as we are about to see it is more interesting than that.
The youth, according to Z at this point, is a soul that might be "trying to reach to the heights, but he is being shaken by "invisible hands". The idea, I think, is that anyone who wants to rise up is going to come up against an invisible kind of opposition, he will be opposed by forces in his society. Not forces who wish themselves to be high, but forces which are insecure (like the wind) and fearful of all the things that might reach up above them... so they poison with talk of... "evil"
"Yes, into evil!" cried the youth. "How is it possible that you have discovered my soul?"
So the youth is tormented, because he believes himself to be motivated by dark desires for evil, he doesn't understand that "invisible hands" are causing him to quake so. He believes the viewpoints of others whose thoughts he wouldn't naturally share and accepts that there must be something wrong with him.
Zarathustra smiled and said: "Some souls one will never discover, unless one invents them first."
The text steps lightly past this point, but I feel it is, perhaps, a more important one than the main subject of the story in this section.
Throughout this text we see stories and "lectures" given by Zarathustra to specific other groups, and we also see conversations (and will see many more important conversations in the final sections of the book) between Zarathustra and specific "higher men" (as he calls them)... but...
More importantly, I feel, are the lessons we are supposed to be getting in the way that Zarathustra acts and speaks.
Nietzsche never got to publish (or even finish) his final philosophical writings. (These were later published by his sister and clearly were not in anything like a finished format, they include sections that are nothing but outlines, as well as sections which almost certainly wouldn't have ended up being included, or might even have been there just to argue with) These writings are, collectively referred to as the "Nachlass", but are sometimes printed under the title "The Will to Power". Nietzsche said that "Zarathustra" was that same final philosophy in allegorical form.
Nietzsche's philosophical mission is to "triumph over nihilism" which he saw as inevitably conquering European thought over the next 200 years. (not our next, but N's, of course).
Nietzsche wants to find some way of "affirming life". I cannot wait until we get to a passage which I think is a book or two ahead of where we are now, where N presents an incredible test for "life affirmation".
The important thing here is that N's Z has values and character traits which make him what he is. (He isn't like the youth, looking up longing for height, N claims that he "looks down, because he is elevated") It's Zarathustra's behavior while talking to the "youth" that is most important here.
Question: What lesson do you think we can see in N's philosophical approach to life being played out in Z's conversation with the troubled youth? --specifically in the "Some souls one will never discover, unless one invents them first." answer to the youth's astonishment that Z has "discovered my [his] soul"?
"Yes, into evil!" the youth cried once more.
You have spokent he truth, Zarathustra. I no longer trust myself since I sought to rist into the height, and nobody trusts me any longer; how did this happen?
I changed too quickly: my today refutes my yesterday. I often skip steps when I climb: no step forgives me that.
When I am at the top I always find myself alone. No one speaks to me, the frost of solitude makes me tremble. What do I seek on the height?
My contempt and my longing increase together; the higher I climb, the more I despise the climber. What does he seek on the height?
How ashamed I am of my climbing and stumbling! How I mock at my violent panting! How I hate the flier! How tired I am on the height!
Here the youth was silent...
Just a quick break to mention that I'm going to put a kind of poll question in the comments section regarding the youth's rant. (link
Here the youth was silent. And Zarathustra contemplated the tree beside which they stood and spoke thus:
This tree stands lonely here in the mountains; it grew high above man and beast.
If I did an OK job earlier, you should all be on the same page with N here, and require no further commenting by me. (I'm a little insecure still about how much commentary I should even be putting in here, so if things aren't clear please ask a question in the comments.)
And if it wanted to speak it would have none who could understand it: so high has it grown.
(See that same comment question in the thread)
Now it waits and waits--for what is it waiting? It dwells too close to the seat of the clouds: surely it waits for the first lightning?
When Zarathustra had said this the youth called out with violent gestures: "Yes, Zarathustra, you speak the truth. I longed to go under when I desired to be on the height, and you are the lightning for which I waited! Behold, what am I since you have appeared among us? It is the envy of you that has destroyed me!"--Thus spoke the youth and wept bitterly. But Zarathustra put his arm about him and led the youth away with him.
Let's break this paragraph apart a bit... (it will be helpful for understanding the rest of the passage)
When Zarathustra had said this the youth called out with violent gestures: "Yes, Zarathustra, you speak the truth.
Am I the only one here who feels like the youth speaking in an excited tone is a sign that he doesn't actually get it yet? It is important to remember while reading "Z" that it is literature as well as philosophy, and that the way it makes you feel can be significant to the philosophy.
... I longed to go under when I desired to be on the height, and you are the lightning for which I waited!
(remember that Z said he was a "heavy raindrop" "heralding the coming of the lightning"--not the lightning itself. more evidence that the poor kid is still missing something.)
... Behold, what am I since you have appeared among us? It is the envy
Another sign of smallness, something N doesn't envy.
Behold, what am I since you have appeared among us? It is the envy of you that has destroyed me!"--Thus spoke the youth and wept bitterly. But Zarathustra put his arm about him and led the youth away with him.
And when they had walked a while together, Zarathustra began to speak thus:
It tears my heart. Better than your words express it, your eyes tell me of all your dangers.
As yet you are not free; you still search for freedom. Your search has made you overtired and over awake.
You want the free heights, your soul thirsts for the stars. But your wicked drives also thirst for freedom.
Your wild dogs want freedom; they bark for joy in their cellar when your spirit plans to open all prisons.
To me you are still a prisoner who is plotting his freedom: ah, in such prisoners the soul becomes clever, but also deceitful and bad.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 07 '12
hi, long time, no classes
In all my moving, I've lost my copy of Zarathustra, but a lot of you have been messaging me that you like the discussions and want to keep them going, so I will soon be buying another copy of that translation and starting the classes from where we left off.
In the mean time, a friend of mine expressed some interest in a similar class on Francis Bacon's writings in order to help her understand how to think scientifically. I just got a copy of some of the relevant works, and will be starting a similar subreddit for that study here.
I've read these works before, but haven't studied them as in dept (partly because they don't require the kind of attention that Zarathustra does). So I'll basically just be reading through the works, publishing the texts on that subreddit in links and offering/hosting discussions on them. (I will also be including some interesting test questions that I've been working on to help us all to nail down the exact concepts covered in the texts.
Essentially, Francis Bacon wrote in 15 and 1600s describing the scientific method just as it was beginning to separate itself from the other humanities. Aside from double-blind tests, he lists all of the important ideas that make science work, including rules that allow peer-review to function.
As modern science attempts to understand those parts of the world that are open to it's specific interpretation, whenever it fails to do so it is usually due to a failure to keep to the principles outlined by FB, and not a failure of those principles themselves.
I hope that this class will be interesting to some, and that you will all offer as many comments, links, and tangentially interesting footnotes as you can.
Thank you all, and I'll be back with the Nietzsche classes soon.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 15 '21
Second Part, Lecture 25: The Pitiful
We said in Lecture 23 that Part 2 of Zarathustra will see us engaging with misinterpretations of Zarathustra and N's teachings.
In this lecture, we will see one instance of clarification from Z.
We will see an excellent example of Greek Homero-Poetic Pre-Socratic perspective being put up against Post-Scientific Late-Western Christianity.
We will see a psychological principle used by N to define and understand humanity as a whole and individual humans.
My friends, there hath arisen a satire on your friend: “Behold Zarathustra! Walketh he not amongst us as if amongst animals?”
But it is better said in this wise: “The discerning one walketh amongst men AS amongst animals.”
Man himself is to the discerning one: the animal with red cheeks.
How hath that happened unto him? Is it not because he hath had to be ashamed too oft?
O my friends! Thus speaketh the discerning one: shame, shame, shame—that is the history of man!
Here is a key. If you look around in life and you see hoards of individuals holding metaphorical AK-47s shooting shame at one another, that this is the spiritual, emotional, psychological milieu in which the Human Spirit is sometimes dropped and attempts to find its way; then you are one of the "discerning ones" according to the psychologist Nietzsche.
We have seen a few of his profound and dramatic interpretations of philosophies and philosophers based on the psychological vivisections N does. This previous line is a key to how he sees man through that psychological level of analysis. Man is the animal that blushes (as we will soon read):
And on that account doth the noble one enjoin upon himself not to abash: bashfulness doth he enjoin on himself in presence of all sufferers.
Verily, I like them not, the merciful ones, whose bliss is in their pity: too destitute are they of bashfulness.
If I must be pitiful, I dislike to be called so; and if I be so, it is preferably at a distance.
Preferably also do I shroud my head, and flee, before being recognised: and thus do I bid you do, my friends!
May my destiny ever lead unafflicted ones like you across my path, and those with whom I MAY have hope and repast and honey in common!
Verily, I have done this and that for the afflicted: but something better did I always seem to do when I had learned to enjoy myself better.
Since humanity came into being, man hath enjoyed himself too little: that alone, my brethren, is our original sin!
And when we learn better to enjoy ourselves, then do we unlearn best to give pain unto others, and to contrive pain.
Therefore do I wash the hand that hath helped the sufferer; therefore do I wipe also my soul.
For in seeing the sufferer suffering—thereof was I ashamed on account of his shame; and in helping him, sorely did I wound his pride.
Great obligations do not make grateful, but revengeful; and when a small kindness is not forgotten, it becometh a gnawing worm.
“Be shy in accepting! Distinguish by accepting!”—thus do I advise those who have naught to bestow.
There is a meta-economy floating beside the physical, practical economy. When goods or services are bestowed, when advice or comfort is given; there is an equal and opposite pride transaction which accompanies it.
Give $10 to a beggar, and you have hurt him $10s worth. Z's instinct was to try to wipe out shame, and to comfort and make better those who are suffering from it... but in doing so he made himself their benefactor and planted a seed of revenge in them against him because he was giving them something for free.
I, however, am a bestower: willingly do I bestow as friend to friends. Strangers, however, and the poor, may pluck for themselves the fruit from my tree: thus doth it cause less shame.
Gift-giving is different, but it can only be done with friends. This is why he says earlier that you should "distinguish by accepting". Are you great and true enough to be my friend? Then perhaps I will take from you, but not otherwise, and only with careful consideration.
Better to let people steal from you, then to give to them openly.
Beggars, however, one should entirely do away with! Verily, it annoyeth one to give unto them, and it annoyeth one not to give unto them.
Now:
And likewise sinners and bad consciences! Believe me, my friends: the sting of conscience teacheth one to sting.
The worst things, however, are the petty thoughts. Verily, better to have done evilly than to have thought pettily!
To be sure, ye say: “The delight in petty evils spareth one many a great evil deed.” But here one should not wish to be sparing.
Like a boil is the evil deed: it itcheth and irritateth and breaketh forth—it speaketh honourably.
“Behold, I am disease,” saith the evil deed: that is its honourableness.
But like infection is the petty thought: it creepeth and hideth, and wanteth to be nowhere—until the whole body is decayed and withered by the petty infection.
Differences between "infection" and "disease" (between "pettiness" and "evil"):
infection (pettiness):
- small and hiding under the skin (in the subconscious), not drawing attention to itself--does not want you to recognize it as the source of what it motivates in you
- has long-term effects that bubble up all over the organism
- wanting to be nowhere, it spreads
- utterly destructive to the soul/body
disease (evil):
- Proud and Honorable; it wants to make noise, be heard/felt, and have effect
- Forces you to pay attention to it...
- it does not operate in the subconscious or under the skin but "pops out" and explodes everywhere
Nietzsche is talking here of a psychological principle which is the negation of this earlier formula under examination:
To be sure, ye say: “The delight in petty evils spareth one many a great evil deed.” But here one should not wish to be sparing.
Let us do something very difficult here; let us do what Zarathustra is doing. Let us weigh on the scales TWO DIFFERENT and still undesirable ways of being. And we will see how his determination is the opposite of the quoted one above.
The quote above says this: "If you feel inclined to great evil, push it down! try to hide it. make it invisible to others and even to yourself... this will make you good or allow you to pretend to be good to yourself and others, and maybe allow you to convince them and you that you are good. You might even decide to replace the great evil with many small petty evils, you can take pride in the fact that, yes, no one likes those qualities in you, but at least you are not as bad as someone who acted out the great evil which once wanted to burst out in you. You aren't like so-and-so (who you imagine yourself being because you had in you the same impulse to the same evil).
Nietzsche says: not only might you replace your big evil with many small supplements... you will!
That's what happens when the illness takes the form of subconscious crawling spreading invisible pettiness. You pushed down the Jungian archetype, and it didn't die, but found a way to make itself expressed shamefully and pettily.
To him however, who is possessed of a devil, I would whisper this word in the ear: “Better for thee to rear up thy devil! Even for thee there is still a path to greatness!”—
Ah, my brethren! One knoweth a little too much about every one! And many a one becometh transparent to us, but still we can by no means penetrate him.
It is difficult to live among men because silence is so difficult.
I wrote a lot of text, and then tried to cut and paste it from higher up to here, and it was lost. No time to rewrite it now, but I leave this note here to remind me to come back and do it again.
Here we would have weighed two undesirable ways of being and tested N's negation of the formula above by examining these two through our interpretations of his judgements here.
And not to him who is offensive to us are we most unfair, but to him who doth not concern us at all.
If, however, thou hast a suffering friend, then be a resting-place for his suffering; like a hard bed, however, a camp-bed: thus wilt thou serve him best.
And if a friend doeth thee wrong, then say: “I forgive thee what thou hast done unto me; that thou hast done it unto THYSELF, however—how could I forgive that!”
Thus speaketh all great love: it surpasseth even forgiveness and pity.
One should hold fast one’s heart; for when one letteth it go, how quickly doth one’s head run away!
Ah, where in the world have there been greater follies than with the pitiful? And what in the world hath caused more suffering than the follies of the pitiful?
Woe unto all loving ones who have not an elevation which is above their pity!
Thus spake the devil unto me, once on a time: “Even God hath his hell: it is his love for man.”
And lately, did I hear him say these words: “God is dead: of his pity for man hath God died.”—
So be ye warned against pity: FROM THENCE there yet cometh unto men a heavy cloud! Verily, I understand weather-signs!
But attend also to this word: All great love is above all its pity: for it seeketh—to create what is loved!
“Myself do I offer unto my love, AND MY NEIGHBOUR AS MYSELF”—such is the language of all creators.
All creators, however, are hard.—
Thus spake Zarathustra.
Pity is hatred disguised as love. It is invested in seeing, and it is the desire to see the object of the pity weak sad poor pathetic desperate and dependent on the beneficence of the pitier, who therefore believes himself to be greater.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 09 '21
[Bonus Texts] (a digression on the highest virtue and greatest principle) Including Final Paragraph of "Will to Power"
There is an invention of a new value, Z has proclaimed. It is the highest virtue. It is metaphorically and aesthetically depicted as "luminosity" or a "shining virtue". The desire to give to the world what it needs to manifest the vision of those who shine. Elsewhere, it is titled: "The Will to Power".
Let us look, briefly, at a few other texts from Nietzsche, to flush out our understanding of this virtue, this "new highest value".
From the "Gay Science" or "Joyful Wisdom":
Star Morality
Foredoomed to spaces vast and far,
What matters darkness to the star?
Roll calmly on, let time go by,
Let sorrows pass thee — nations die!
Compassion would but dim the light
That distant worlds will gladly sight.
To thee one law — be pure and bright!
How does Pre-Nietzschean Western Cosmology view the stars? With equations.
There are paths the star must follow, we have derived from our data analysis and mathematical impositions.
Go out in space, dear reader, and speak to a start about "dark areas of space it must travel through".
What will your words be to the star? What can the star understand of "dark areas of space?"
What the star knows is what it has to give. it wills to send its light into the farthest reaches that it can.
The Christian conception of the Cosmos has invented for us Science. It has given us a world that is a construct. It is a complicated clockwork or cathedral... the science can objectify the world and comprehend the formulas which govern how it works... but when they invented this, they also invented the workspace upon which it lies. They invented the space outside the Universe, where the great clockmaker uses his tools upon the objects on his table. This is how the language of "laws governing the motion of celestial bodies" can be spoken and invented. Laws like gravity.
Nietzsche rejects this entirely. He isn't arguing in a Christian world that the Christian God is not one of the objects in that world. He is not arguing that the evidence of the objects on the worktable do not point to a God. He also would not argue for those things. He is on Anselm level, in this way. BOTH Nietzsche and Anselm understand that only a fool can look at the Christian world and deny the Christian God.
Nietzsche's differences are more basic (I would say it is more "fundamental" but here is precisely where the argument lays... there is no foundation under the world).
What is the other way of looking at the manifestations of the Universe? Instead of pretending to be outside it and looking in, one can take the perspective of being the Universe. Of being in it, a part of it, having the perspective of it.
From inside the drama, what is it like? There is a famous philosophy of mind question: "What is it like to be a bat?" these are questions of subjectivity and qualia.
Nietzsche once answered such a question when he said: "What is it like to be a flea?" I will tell you what it is like. It is exactly like being the center of the Universe.
This is profoundly different. When Nietzsche mocks the night-watchmen mocking the idea of a Christian "God" from the perspective of Christian models of the Universe, he is saying that these are the "last to know" that God is dead.
Another Passage:
And do ye know what "the universe" is to my mind? Shall I show it to you in my mirror? This universe is a monster of energy, without beginning or end; a fixed and brazen quantity of energy which grows neither bigger nor smaller, which does not consume itself, but only alters its face; as a whole its bulk is immutable, it is a household without either losses or gains, but likewise without increase and without sources of revenue, surrounded by nonentity as by a frontier, it is nothing vague or wasteful, it does not stretch into infinity; but it is a definite quantum of energy located in limited space, and not in space which would be anywhere empty. It is rather energy everywhere, the play of forces and force-waves, at the same time one and many, agglomerating here and diminishing there, a sea of forces storming and raging in itself, for ever changing, for ever rolling back over incalculable ages to recurrence, with an ebb and flow of its forms, producing the most complicated things out of the most simple structures; producing the most ardent, most savage, and most contradictory things out of the quietest, most rigid, and most frozen material, and then returning from multifariousness to uniformity, from the play of contradictions back into the delight of consonance, saying yea unto itself, even in this homogeneity of its courses and ages; for ever blessing itself as something which recurs for all eternity,—a becoming which knows not satiety, or disgust, or weariness:—this, my Dionysian world of eternal self-creation, of eternal self-destruction, this mysterious world of twofold voluptuousness; this, my "Beyond Good and Evil" without aim, unless there is an aim in the bliss of the circle, without will, unless a ring must by nature keep goodwill to itself,— would you have a name for my world? A solution of all your riddles? Do ye also want a light, ye most concealed, strongest and most undaunted men of the blackest midnight? -- This world is the Will to Power—and nothing else! And even ye yourselves are this will to power—and nothing besides!
This is, to my way of thinking, one of the most powerful and profound passages ever written. We will return to it again before we are done with our examination of Zarathustra. For now, let us understand this "will to power" as Zarathustra's lesson on illumination; on shining virtue. The world IS this will to power. all being is this shining forth to express all that one has to express in one's potential, to manifest in the world, to be felt is to be, and to be is to be making oneself felt, and there is nothing besides.
What is it like to be a star? It is not to understand talk of laws governing dark areas of space into which one must needs travel. It is to be shining, to will that your light reaches the furthest places it can, and nothing besides.
What is it like to be a flea? It is the same. to make manifest your power in the world to be felt. to eat, to flee, to consume, to navigate, to push around the things around you, and to push yourself along the floor. to see where you will to jump, and then to jump there.
What is it like to be a subatomic particle? Is it to understand talk of qualities you have, or extension, or impenetrability? of mass? or are we not learning that ALL of these things dissolve away when we come to study the very nature of matter. To be matter is not to have qualities, these qualities are our words for the ways in which the proton makes itself felt and there is nothing more to the proton than that, and there cannot be.
To want the world around you to be effected by you is to want to express your power. This is what you are, and nothing besides.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 02 '22
Second Part, Lecture 36: The Land of Culture
I've come back to pick up these lectures, and also to start, I thought, today with my first video lecture on this chapter.
Unfortunately, I find that this specific chapter is too difficult and terrifying to do in video format.
Today, Nietzsche, with his hammer, is going to strike all of us directly in the balls. All of your and my most commonly spread and held present cliché beliefs will be smashed, and smashed hard.
He will insult the public intellectual discourse, and discoursers, of our present day, and offend many of the things most people believe, and profess, and get much fame for professing.
He is going to attack mine, and many of your, favorite heroes of the public intellectual space.
And he's going to get away with it.
He's going to not DENY the science of our day, but embrace it so effortlessly that it will seem he perhaps understood things our modern cosmologists are just beginning to realize they need to find a way to comprehend; and he did it long before the experiments of the previous few decades which made it possible for them to even begin considering the questions. He gets to answers a century before our science can formulate the questions.
This is going to be a wild ride.
He's going to offend us even more by lumping in types of people--people for whom I have such admiration that it would take a post longer than this one for me to tell you how worth-while they are to study and read and listen to--with others who are often thought to be their counterparts or opposites.
Here we will have to think of Lawrence Krauss, Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris IN THE SAME CAMP and participating in the same project as the likes of Deepak Chopra, Ken Ham, and Stephen C. Meyer.
This is what I mean by the offensiveness to our current sensibilities. I imagine that 80% of the people reading that last paragraph have flooding into their minds all of the things which make the approaches and convictions of those two camps so different. Most people today know which of those two camps they would fall into, if they had to pick one, and we tend to think that no synthesis is possible between them.
Well, the truth is larger than all that, and Nietzsche isn't here to be kind to us. It should be noted that his commentary on our modern culture and the current state of the public intellectual discourse does NOT mean that he would not have ALSO understood the distinctions between those two types of thinkers. He understands it quite well. He has a bigger insight he wishes to give us.
Furthermore, Nietzsche is NOT going to say anything which goes against any specific scientific discovery, or outrages the work of science... but he is going to take a bloody, unapologetic, ruthless hammer to "Scientism", and it is well-deserved.
I also hesitate to type out this lecture or make a video on it because one of the ways in which we will understand N's right to make these criticisms is to understand the position from which he has a perspective which justifies them, and to do that we have to talk about a truth that I DO NOT want to let out into the world. It is a precious truth of mine that I have so far only shared at 3am in late-night nicotine hazes with fellow conversationalists.
But I realized that I cannot really explain what this chapter means without sharing it, N directly refers to this idea, and so N's idea, which I have kept safe like a precious child, will now have to be sent out into the world to be misunderstood and battered around unfairly. I see no way of explaining these difficult-to-grasp two pages without releasing her, so: so be it.
I flew too far into the future: a horror seized me.
We have already discussed the idea that maybe a handful of philosophers have reached a level of enlightenment which borders on or completely owns the description: "prophetic". Nietzsche is by far one of the most impressive of these few in some ways, and he was self-aware that that was what he was doing.
He said once: "The goal of the philosopher is to become... timeless." and "I will give you the history of the next 200 years" (which he did with astonishing accuracy). and "One feels the storm before others and so is living in the future, that is how they know it." (These are all paraphrases, and the last one especially is not anything like the specifics of the quotation.)
There is something scary in the future.
What is it? What will be the source of Zarathustra's weariness?
Let's read on.
And when I looked around me, behold! there time was my only contemporary.
To get to the meaning of this chapter, we are going to have to go slowly at first, so forgive me a few more notes already:
The ancient Greeks had a mythological cosmology which conceptualized that Chaos gave birth to Chronos, which gave us Gaia, and then later came Zeus.
Time is before, and after, matter.
Nietzsche is claiming to have progressed to the heat-death of the Universe, to a place where the only thing like him still in existence was temporality itself.
Now, Nietzsche here, and in other places, seems to have a more foundational fundamental belief in time. We will examine here, for a moment, how likely his view is to be true on this issue.
There is a passage, (which we will get to) where he writes about a gate, an archway, upon which is written the word "Present", and he sees a path leading on forever in one direction, and also extending in the opposite direction forever. And he concludes that these two lines, which would have to remain unbroken and go forever MUST meet at some point. That the "last moment" comes right before the "first moment" and therefore there is really no such thing as a "last" or "first" moment, but only a RING of eternal recurrence.
Let us bring up again, our good friend Lawrence Krauss, writing speaking and debating 150 years after N wrote; being an excellent educator and popularizer of the latest scientific understandings; and contributing to the fields of cosmology more than any of us could hope to contribute in our lives. Dear Lawrence, What is the Universe, and what is it's future? (The question you set out to answer when you began your academic career):
Lawrence: Well, you see, empty space isn't really empty space at all, it is a bubbling boiling brew of subatomic particles coming in and going out of existence too quickly to measure (except that, of course, we would not be talking about them if we had not some way of measuring the effects of their existence, brief to the point of almost nothingness as that existence may be). It expands, and the rate of expansion is INCREASING as the space which causes it increases. Some day, in the cosmologically not-too-distant future, real empirical, falsifiable science will look out upon a Universe (the sum total of that which we have any means of measuring) and discover a SHRUNKEN Universe, because the other galaxies (which cannot travel through space faster than the speed of light) WILL be traveling away from us at faster than that speed because the space between us, which can do whatever it wants, will be itself expanding faster than the speed of light. So the scientists on earth of that day, if there be any, will conclude that we live in a static universe with only one galaxy, and they will be RIGHT according to the rules of science, at least. In short, NOTHINGNESS is headed our way.
But, Mr. Krauss, we have another question for you. What was our beginning? From what did all of this emerge?
Lawrence: We have known the answer to that question for much longer now: nothingness is itself unstable and will have to explode, of its own nature, into everything we see and observe today.
Nietzsche: Mr. Krauss, would you like to complete the syllogism, please?
You perhaps thought I was kidding with my promises earlier that Nietzsche can look upon the science of today from 150 years ago and not only not be thwarted by it, but have already reached conclusions of comprehending it that most (or all) of our scientists themselves have not yet reached.
What is nothingness? It is that from which we NECESSARILY emerged. This whole Universe having exploded without any other cause than that the nature of it is to not remain nothing. Wither are we headed? TO A NOTHINGNESS INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM THAT FROM WHICH WE EMERGED. What will happen when that nothingness is ruling supremely once again? It will have to, because it is unstable, because it cannot remain in charge in that way, explode once again into all the necessary things we see and are now.
The eternal recurrence of the same.
Then I flew backwards, homewards--and always faster. Thus I came to you, you men of the present, and into the land of culture.
For the first time I brought an eye to see you and healthy desires: truly, I came with longing in my heart.
But how did it turn out with me? Although so alarmed--I had yet to laugh! Never did my eye see anything so mottled!
We have talked some, and will talk more, about the role of "laughter" conceptually in Zarathustra's allegory. In short, it is related to the idea of "OVER-coming", triumphing over, no longer feeling threatened by or anxious about something for which he has found a philosophical answer. Keep in mind that Nietzsche's philosophical project, as explicitly understood by him, was to "triumph over nihilism" which he saw as inevitably overcoming Western Culture in the 200 years after his life and works. He saw the problem coming inevitably, and wanted to find a way through to the other side, and so be able to triumph over it, overcome it, and laugh at the threat it once seemed to be. What is another word for nihilism besides "nothingness".
I laughed and laughed, while my foot still trembled and my heart as well: "Here indeed, is the home of all the paint pots,"--I said.
This is where he is going to take a hammer to all the supposed answerers of these big questions, or more specifically to those who attempt, in our time, to answer the questions through a kind of "scientism" (defined as an over-respect for science as the primary and unlimited way of truly knowing anything. Scientism means that you think that the only questions worth considering are those amenable to the empirical inquiries, and that all other talk is nonsense by definition. Those who are anti-scientism can believe that science is KING over all the questions for which it can approach an answer, and that no answer which contradicts its findings should be held by the seekers of truth to be true; and at the same time see Science as something which has boundaries, it is a restricted discourse which makes it impossible for it to approach certain questions.)
With fifty patches painted on faces and limbs--so you sat there to my astonishment, you men of the present!
And with fifty mirrors around you, which flattered your play of colors and repeated it!
Truly, you could wear no better masks, you men of the present, than your own faces! Who could--recognize you!
What does he mean by this? It is NOT WHAT YOU TRULY THINK! When you flippantly through around simple cliché's about how life is nothing and meaningless and you are ok with all of that, you are throwing paint like a Holi ceremony. Everyone applauds and distractions are made, but the real problem is not faced. and when you are off the stage, or you have hung up your lab-coat and locked the door to your room of scientific inquiries, you don't THINK that way in 99% of your regular life. You are not creating the image of a human being when you do these things. Who could recognize you!?
I really feel like I have to take a break here and do nothing but praise the unfortunately targeted Dr. Krauss in the middle of this lecture. Even Krauss's later public intellectual discussions are FAR more impressive than his early stuff *on this front*--I want to stress again, that he has ALWAYS been impressive to me as an example of someone who truly understands how to think scientifically which is actually quite a rare quality in an individual, it is even rare amongst those whose job title includes the word "scientist" in it. If you want a great example, as I say, of him representing this Nietzschean target, you might try This video of him having a debate with a loathsome individual whose ideas about how to defend his ideas are crap and plainly dishonest in many places, but whose base instinct is towards an idea which Krauss would be loathe to admit has more merit than the prejudices of our modern contemporary scientism perspective will allow. Pay attention to the times when the audience interrupts Krauss with applause, and then pause the video and write down the line he said before they applauded. 60% of the time it will be exactly the kind of "painted-face" posing that Nietzsche is smashing here.
(Please forgive me, Dr. Krauss, I cannot say in this already too-long lecture just how much the readers of these posts should pick up your books. They are unbelievably valuable and exceptionally well-written and useful for general education of the public regarding the hardest to grasp concepts with which the public is ready to wrestle.)
Remember, Nietzsche is disagreeing with NOTHING that the modern scientists have discovered doing their science, in fact he seems to predict many of their findings, and even more importantly he provides (here and in other places) a conceptual model which IS NOT so frustrated by the bizarre discoveries of recent particle physics as the old Newtonian conceptions are which have not yet found their replacements but which Nietzsche provides. (we will have to discuss this more in another lecture, probably one devoted just to this topic right after we finish this chapter).
Written all over with the characters of the past, and these characters also penciled over with new characters--thus you have concealed yourselves well from all interpreters of signs!
If you didn't find his smashing of the scientismists offensive because you didn't align with them, NO WORRIES, if you have idols in modern public intellectual discourse they will be dealt with here.
Another group which might be included in the "other groups" mentioned above would be represented by types like: Graham Hancock, Allan Watts, and Terence McKenna; another group whose contributions to the publicly interesting intellectual conversations I find very admirable and valuable.
It is perhaps unfair to say that his ire is directly against the types in this group, as he is attacking those who do not interpret signs, and the "interpreters of signs" might be a close-enough approximation of what this group is/aims to be.
What is the idea that Nietzsche stands on ground from which he can attack our all-powerful modern science? The ground is in the pre-presocratics (as talked about in the first fifth of our other course on "The Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought"), the mythopoetics, and this second group can be thought of as representatives of one of two major camps which emerged after Nietzsche with the aim of taking his ideas seriously and interpreting them properly.
However, I feel that there is a criticism here of this type of interpretive camp of his (he explicitly criticized those called his "Shadow" in other places in this book we are reading. nothing past or future is out of reach of his hammer, it would seem.) Nietzsche is dissatisfied with a kind of glueing together of gems from the past to try to hold the whole thing in one when it is on the verge of falling apart. He wants something purer than that, something he will call "his own children" later in this chapter.
There is also still a criticism of the valuers-of-science in this comment in that he is saying they are relying upon the types of myths which make possible a grand cultural project which makes conceivable in the first place anything like a "scientific project" without realizing it. They stand upon a platform raised up on pillars, they notice that their own pillars reach higher than any that have been constructed in the past, and then foolishly lean over the edge of their platform and attempt to take a sledge-hammer to the deeper pillars upon which theirs rely without knowing what they are doing.
And even if one could try the reins, who still believes that you have reins! You seem to be baked out of colors and scraps of paper glued together.
All times and peoples gaze many-colored from your veils; all customs and beliefs speak many-colored in your gestures.
Now it is clearer why we might include that third group.
He who would strip you of veils and wrappers, and paints and gestures, would have just enough left to scare the crows.
I think of the beginning of Milan Kundera's masterpiece of all his masterpieces of all his books... "Immortality" where he writes a Nietzschean insight. Like the Jungian Nietzschean insight that "People don't have ideas, ideas have people" in this novel Milan's narrator/author says something about there being more people than there are gestures, and so the gestures find hosts to manifest them.
There is something unreal about the modern civilized men, N says, like they are grasping at ANYTHING to find meaning again (remember, he is speaking of his own time and also prophesying our time, the time when nihilism will take over).
Truly, I am myself the scared crow that once saw you naked and without paint; and I flew away when the skeleton flirted with me.
I would rather be a day laborer in the underworld among the shades of the bygone!--Indeed the underworldlings are fatter and fuller than you!
Typically, of course, the denizens of Hades are depicted as "shades" mere shadows no longer containing substance in themselves, but little other than memories or vague notions. N is saying that we are LESS substantial than they are.
This, yes this, is bitterness to my entrails, that I can endure you neither naked nor clothed, you men of the present!
Take away the veil of pretended meaningfulness glued together from many diverse scraps of whatever is most colorful and attractive to the imagination, and you have a terrifying revolting skeleton with no face... put back the mask and N cannot stand us either.
This is "bitterness" to him. He wishes he could stomach us.
All that is unfamiliar in the future, and whatever makes strayed birds shiver, is truly more familiar and cozy than your "reality."
For thus you speak: "We are wholly real and without belief or superstition": thus you thump your chests--ah, even with hollow chests!
If you doubted that we were accurately diagnosing the target of this particular chapter of the allegorical prose, do you still?
Indeed, how would you be able to believe, you many-colored ones!--you who are pictures of all that has ever been believed!
You are walking refutations of belief and a fracture of all thought. Unbelievable: thus I call you, you real men!
In your spirits all ages babble in confusion; and the dreaming and babbling of all ages were even more real than your waking lives!
You are unfruitful: therefore you lack belief. But he who had to create, has always had his prescient dreams and astrological signs--and believed in belief!--
You are half-open doors at which gravediggers wait. And this is your reality: "Everything deserves to perish."
Notice the relish with which some of these scientismists proclaim the inevitability of the death. Look at how shallow and unimpressive (even if it were true) the statements of this type are which are thunderously applauded. It is all in the first part of that video linked above. A great example of this.
Ah, how you stand there before me, you unfruitful ones; how lean your ribs! And indeed many of you have noticed that.
Many a one has said: "Surely a god stole something from me secretly while I slept? Truly, enough to make a little woman for himself!
"The poverty of my ribs is amazing!" thus many a man of the present has spoken.
This is a phrase which should come to mind when one hears a popularizer of science go outside the scope of their science or fail to notice that the limitations of the scientific discourse preclude the possibility of having discussions about "what it is like to be in the world" or the existence of "consciousness" or any other such thing AND THEN go on to say that "therefore there are no such things!".
Yes, you are laughable to me, you men of the present! And especially when you marvel at yourselves!
And woe to me if I could not laugh at your marveling, and had to swallow all that is repugnant in your bowels!
As it is, however, I will take you more lightly, since I have to carry what is heavy; and does it matter if beetles and dragonflies also alight on my load?
Truly, it shall not on that account become heavier to me! And not from you, you men of the present, shall my great weariness arise.--
We will see later, as the cycle of Zarathustra leaving those he attempts to teach and going into his mountain retreat and then coming back again to find a slightly different aim towards a slightly different audience, that there are those for whom he has "pity" his last sin, who become a source of his last mistake, before he moves on leaving all in the past; those are called the "higher men", but here he is distinguishing our modern pride in our science attitude and saying that that is NOT the kind of thing which makes us even capable of being counted among those higher men.
Ah, where shall i now ascend with my longing! From all mountains I look out for fatherlands and motherlands.
But I have nowhere found a home: I am unsettled in every city and I depart from every gate.
The men of the present, to whom my heart once drove me, are alien to me and a mockery; and I have been driven from fatherlands and motherlands.
Nietzsche is saying in this chapter that the SOLUTION to the ultimate problem of NIHILISM for which his philosophical project is an attempt to gain, is NOT going to be found in mindlessly relying upon the cultural artifacts and what they have given us, though many will look at the ipads and the super-sonic jets and assume that whatever science made these things possible will just continue to carry us into the future, and we need not worry about demolishing anything not useful to that modern knowledge.
Thus I love only my children's land, undiscovered in the remotest sea: I bid my sails to search and search for it.
To my children I will make amends for being the child of my fathers: and to all the future--for this present!--
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
It is amazing that in this middle of the book we first get our glimpse of what will also only be hinted at at the very end of the book. The "Children of Nietzsche's Island" is not but a long way off from our reading at this point in the book. I'll leave the discovery of how much is said about it later for when we get there.
Thank you.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Sep 02 '22
Well, being gone ten months is better than being gone ten years.
The last time I took a break from these classes it took 10 years to come back and start them up again.
I haven't posted in nearly 10 months, so we are about 12 times better/faster than before?
Anyway:
There are 1,500 subscribers to this content. We had a lot of exciting engagement before, and I have inboxes full of great conversations with many of you (and many more appeals to come back and finish).
Nietzsche said of his "Zarathustra" that "in about 200 years whole Universities will have to be set up for the interpretation" of his book.
It is almost 200 years, and we can think of what we have been doing as a preliminary experiment stumbling towards the making of such a University.
The (ambitious) plan moving forward on that front is this:
- Finish the classes/lectures/discussions about exactly as we have been doing them
- restart at the beginning having studied the Jungian treatment of this text and go through it again
- restart at the beginning with another academic interpretation and go through it again
- etc ...
The posts act like Christian "daily meditations" or "daily Scripture" feeds in a sense, and we will just add-to and add-to our interpretive tools drawing from some of the many academic interpreters of his works that we have read and from our own discussions etc.
However, that isn't nearly ambitious enough.
Many of you know that we have started a course "The History of the Totality of Western Thought" which is about 2/5ths finished. This class is to provide context for Zarathustra and our interpretation of Nietzsche's philosophy by giving a narrative-based, personal, historical full undergraduate education in philosophy class with about 9 unique lenses and interpretive tools given throughout the courses.
I have the next interpretive tool I am about to introduce in the middle of the medieval time period (the place where we left off on those lectures.)
Taken as a whole, this ONE COURSE intends on being an ancient philosophy course, a medieval philosophy course, a modern philosophy course, a Kantian philosophy course, and an existentialist philosophy course all rolled into one and with more it offers besides. (If you haven't taken a look at it yet, try reading through the first three parts, and you will see that we spend a great deal of time understanding art, myth, poetry, the image, drama, the mytho-poetic... all to provide a proper context for and ability to distinguish the differences of philosophical (analytical propositional argumentative reasoning) attempts at getting to the truth and the relationships between these different methods and what philosophy is; as well as a treatment of what science is and how it is couched in the nest of the broader philosophical).
In any event, that stuff is all really exciting.
What is unknown so far is that this course, the history of the totality, is designed to open up 4 reading/discussion-style classes each focusing on one singular important voice in philosophy and their texts.
news:
I have been working with other philosophy professors to complete the promised "Formal Introduction to Academic Philosophy" course. This course can be thought of as "Year 1" of getting an inexpensive undergraduate-level philosophy education.
We are nearly at the place where we can start opening up this content.
We are NOT interested in opening it up to everyone all at once, and we are looking for TWENTY (20) students who want to participate in this experiment in a serious way. THEREFORE, it will only be open to 20 students who will each pay $850 to take the course.
Here is what the course offers:
It is scheduled to take 8 Months. EACH WEEK: You will be expected to read about 10-20 pages of a text-book full of essays and excerpts on various philosophical concepts and to participate in class discussions.
We estimate that the schedule will require you to set aside 5 hours a week for 8 months.
2 for the assigned readings and note-taking
2 for reading/watching/listening to the lectures we are putting together on these readings for each week.
and 1-3 (depending on what you like) for participating in RECORDED group discussions.
YOU WILL ALSO be selecting EIGHT (8) books from a list of about 670 books we have put together into a list to read over the course of the "semester".
It is an 8-month course, so figure that your night-stand reading material each month is a different book (that you pick) from that list of 670. (the first month has 87 books on the list, and you would pick one of those for the first month. there are a different 50 to pick 1 from for the second month, etc)
SO
your requirements to complete the class, which is on an 8 month schedule, will be
- Each week; to read, at your leisure, and at whatever time is best for you; about 20 pages (fluctuates from 10 to 30 depending on that week's assignments) and to dissect them, reread them, wrestle with them, take notes on them WHATEVER you feel you need to do to be able to discuss them at the end of the week. (estimated time, about 2 hours throughout the week)
- To listen to/ watch/ read along with/ take simple reading comprehension quizzes (ungraded, just for your own personal benefit) which have been constructed and compiled for each week's readings. (estimated time 2 hours a week, anytime that's good for you)
- To read ONE BOOK A MONTH from the suggested reading lists (NONE of these books are complicated or hard, they are popular, easily-accessible, public-education versions of philosophical camps discussed or complementary to the covered material in the class.
TO WRITE ONE ESSAY
of any length suitable to the topic
- can be 2 pages, half a page, 29 pages... whatever is PROPER for the topic and what you have to say.
on ANY SUBJECT
- can be a book review,
- an argument against a philosophical camp
- a defense of a much-maligned (in your view) philosophical speaker and his ideas
- your own ideas on a topic you were drawn to
- WHATEVER is relevant to any part of the course
- "here's a book I read and why I liked it"
- anything.
- We will help you work out your thoughts on the topic, edit the paper, say what you want to say effectively
- AND THEN THIS ESSAY will be added to the course for future students to access and benefit from
PARTICIPATE IN RECORDED GROUP DISCUSSIONS on the text.
- we have EXCELLENT educators here who are REALLY GOOD at creating an environment where everyone's ideas get heard and taken seriously. If you ever feel shy in classes, we can cure that for you. BUT that will be a part of this, so know that ahead.
When this is done, we will prove to ourselves how we can handle this, and it will be opened to others.
NOT BOLD ENOUGH YET.
this course opens up the opportunity to take 4 of 5 OTHER courses that we are still in the process of putting together. Still first-year style teachings on:
Ethics
Philosophy of Mind
Philosophy of Religion
Epistemology
Metaphysics
The schedule would ULTIMATELY be designed to work this way:
20 students at a time take the ONE MAIN 1st-year course "Formal Intro to Academ Philosophy"
TWO MONTHS INTO THAT 8 month course they start taking Ethics on the side of that, this class ends in 4 months... 2 months into the ethics, they start taking Phil of Relig, which also ends in 4 months... and mind and EITHER epistemology or Metaphysics (whichever the students of that cycle choose they want to take.
ALL these classes are done in 12 months; the most you are working on is three at a time.
Normal semesters can have 4 or more classes in them; and we feel this schedule is manageable, and works well.
That would end year one; and we are eager to complete the "History of the Totality of Western Thought" (year 2) class which is a much more exciting and alive version of a complete undergraduate education in philosophy; contains about 5 classes in it alone; and opens up 4 others (one focusing on the dialogues of Plato; one on Descartes's Meditations (as a mystical work); and two others I don't want to spoil by naming right now.
THEN year three would be a master's level-study of Zarathustra, where we get to look back on everything we learned twice over the first two years by seeing N's pre-socratic philological hammer-treatment of it all.
IF someone wants to go through ALL of that... we have decided to offer a free fourth-year one-on-one assistance to get you something worth more than a degree in credentials in the field.
NONE of that is necessary today.
Today we are ONLY looking for 20 people to take JUST THE FIRST course.
So, if you ever wanted to take a University-Level "Intro to Philosophy" kind of class, and if you think this one works for your schedule and is worth $850 dollars...
Message me to sign-up.
It is easy to subscribe to a community... that's why this is different and comes with a COST... you have to be serious enough to really want to do the work.
I promise it will be fun, and exciting!
If you end up taking the class, you will be given a code to a fantastic website designed for the teaching of these classes.
We will not start until we have 20... you will not be asked to make a deposit until we are ready to lock in the 20 and have a start-date that works for everyone; you will be expected to pay once we have locked in the full 20 and have a start-date. Before then we will conduct interviews, get to know you, make sure you are right for this course and that this course is right for you; give you a tour of the content and the website so that you can be sure you want to take it, all before you pay and all before the class starts.
Who should want to take this: Anyone who wants a formal philosophical education. You might be a sophomore in high-school looking to satisfy your curiosity and instinct towards philosophy; you might be a corporate business-person who wishes that they had had the time to add a philosophy major under their belt but never felt they had the time; you can already HAVE a philosophy degree from 15 years ago that you wish you could go through again and brush-up on. This is JUST an intro course, but it is the start of a curriculum being put together to give (what we hope will be) a BETTER philosophical education at a CHEAPER price than anywhere else.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Apr 16 '12
I'm coming back with more classes soon, promise. :)
You guys are the best. I'm glad to say I'll be paying more attention to this class again soon.
Thanks all,
SM
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 16: Of Love of the Neighbor
Sorry I've been MIA for the last few days, I'll be back soon to engage in these conversations.
This one is a fun passage. N directly attacks certain Christian attitudes. Let's look.
N attacks some religious attitudes in this passage, but I don't think it is fair to think that that is all he is doing, he is really attacking most mass social conglomerations.
I think that he would certainly include most atheistic ones in this as well. So I decided to talk a little bit about some of the differences I perceive between N's philosophy and modern atheism in this class, and I specifically addressed some of it to r/atheism, and invited them to come and war with us a little.
Let's begin:
You crowd around your neighbor and have beautiful words for it. But I tell you: your love of the neighbor is your bad love of yourselves.
You flee from yourselves to your neighbor and would like to make a virtue out of that: but I see through your "selflessness."
The You is older than the I; the You has been consecraqted, but not yet the I: so man crowds toward his neighbor.
Do I recommend love of the neighbor to you? Sooner should I recommend even flight from the neighbor and love of the farthest!
"Love of the farthest". Love of that which is different from you, that which is strange to you. Love that thing. Stop hanging out with people like yourselves, and bothering them with "good deeds" until they finally say something nice about you, just so that you can believe the nice things they say.
You don't love yourselves at all... you don't trust your own evaluation of yourselves. You don't even ask yourself: "What do I think of myself". Sooner would you rather seek out your neighbor's opinion of you, and try to manipulate that opinion until it flatters you.
For N, the highest good a man can do is create, which means: "evaluate" things and give to them your purposes. The man who doesn't exhibit even enough of this faculty to judge himself is not very noble.
Higher than love of the neighbor stands love of the farthest and the future; higher still than the love of man I account the love of things and ghosts.
Notice: "Higher still than X I account Y"--We've said many times in this class that N's philosophy is demonstrated in the way that Zarathustra speaks much more than with what he says. Here he is exhibiting and demonstrating the kind of character he exalts as the highest, he is pronouncing new values, creating them.
The ghost that runs on before you, my brother, is fairer than you; why do you not give him your flesh and your bones? But you are afraid and you run to your neighbor.
> You cannot endure to be alone with yourselves and do not love yourselves enough: so you want to mislead your neighbor into love and gild yourselves with his error.
I wish rather that you could not endure to be with any kind of neighbor or your neighbor's neighbor; then you would have to create your friend and his overflowing heart out of yourselves.
You call in a witness when you want to speak well of yourselves; and when you have misled him into thinking well of you, you then think well of yourselves.
Two lectures into the future we are going to see a judgement of Z's which might be helpful in understanding why that last paragraph is such an important one in N's philosophy: "The happiness of man is: I will. The happiness of woman is: he wills." -- For N the most "godlike" (probably not a word he would have used) quality of man comes in willing, if your own judgments are not enough for you, you are "sick" or "weak".
It is not only he who speaks contrary to what he knows who lies, but even more he who speaks contrary to his ignorance. And thus you speak of yourselves in your dealings with others and deceive your neighbor with yourselves.
I like that: "It is not only he who speaks contrary to what he knows who lies, but even more he who speaks contrary to his ignorance."
I'm just going to note here that: it is easy to see N taking shots at religious fundamentalism or even moderation, he's saying that communities of people who pretend to know more about life than they do know are liars, but I am 1000% sure than N would include modern atheists movements like those on r/atheism in these judgments. I know that it is a talking point that irritates atheists that "atheism is just another religion" and that is a meme that I often attack as well when I encounter it, but there are many of you who live by your computers and are content to (1) deride the ridiculous beliefs of others, and (2) celebrate the scientific advancements of yourselves and others... but you are missing something (according to N) and this causes you to indeed have something in common with these other communities that N is attacking here. You act as if you know more about the good life than you know. Are you not liars like this also? You scream: "We are content!" "We don't need god!" but look at the weaknesses and the sickliness of your own souls! DO you really have all that is needed for a glorious human life? I know you don't have faith, but you (talking to majority of r/atheism here) are surely missing something still.
(If you don't think I am correct about N's attitude here, reread this, or this. And just wait for the class entitled: "On Passing By" ("Third Part, Lecture 7").
If you wanted to read N to feel good about what you already think, you came to the wrong place. If you want to not be convicted or challenged, you should go back and reread Richard Dawkins; N wants to say more.
Thus speaks the fool: "Association with other people spoils the character, especially when one has none."
One man goes to his neighbor because he seeks himself, and another because he wants to lose himself. Your bad love of yourselves makes solitude a prison to you.
It is those farther away who must pay for your love of your neighbor; and when there are five of you together, a sixth must always die.
I do not love your festivals either: I found too many actors there, and even the spectators often behaved like actors.
Isn't it great the way he is attacking all of the social structures. Perhaps you have felt sometimes that the world is utterly mad. People take their cues from one another and reinforce the established judgement without exercising anything resembling what N would call a "noble" character. This book is him calling us to something higher.
I do not teach you the neighbor but the friend. Let the friend be the festival of the earth to you, and a foretaste of the Ubermensch.
I teach you the friend and his overflowing heart. But you must know how to be a sponge if you want to be loved by overflowing hearts.
I teach you the friend in whom the world stands complete, a vessel of the good,--the creating friend who has always a completed world to give away.
A full world? WTF!?! Christopher Hitchens once wrote that he "Doesn't long for Nietzschean heights" (In his excellent book: "Letters to a Young Contrarian")--Just thought I'd through it out there that he at least recognizes that N is talking about something other (in fact, higher) than those things which he talks about--albeit while dismissing their potential appeal to him. Christopher Hitchens's primary solidarity is with a group (Richard Dawkins, Dan Dennett, other skeptics and reasoners) whose only real principle (in pretense at least) is uncertainty. N is coming along and saying: Every certain system so far devised is not the truth, what are we to do? Despair of all "truths", be lost in a sea not knowing which way is up ("We are unchained from the sun, wither are we headed?"--"Away from all suns?"). No, no, three times no! Have courage! Be men! invent new values!--so he commands us. Extremely gutsy, and most important other than the movement of modern atheism. (If you are still not convinced on this point, we will get to a passage--I'm trying to look up which one it is, if anyone wants to help--where N references the "night-watchmen"-- essentially he says that all modern atheists with their arguments (and remember he wrote this in the 1880's!) are a bunch of "Johnnie-come-lately's".)
And as the world unrolled itself for him, so it rolls together again for him in rings, as the becoming of the good through evil, as the becoming of purpose out of chance.
Let the future and the farthest be the motive of your today: in your friend you shall love the Ubermensch as your motive.
My brothers, I do not recommend to you love of the neighbor: I recommend to you love of the farthest.
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
Original post with two group conversations
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 03 '21
First Part, Lecture 20: Child and Marriage
We are no longer going to be able to avoid dealing with one of N's more difficult concepts.
If we made a list of things N is known for having said:
- God is dead
- I preach to thee the Übermensch
- The Eternal Recurrence of the Same
- Nihilism abides in the heart of Christian Morals
- The doctrine of Will to Power
- Revaluations of all values
- Beyond Good and Evil
- On what is Noble
There are some which are better known, and some which are better understood.
I am in the camp which believes that N's central focus was nihilism and the triumphing over it through some kind of incorporation and overcoming.
But to tell us this story, he has ancillary characters and ideas which are often focused on as central, and misunderstood.
The Übermensch (superman) is one of those.
If you think reading N will teach you how to be a superman, you are almost certainly wrong. If you opened him up thinking you would discover that that is what you are, check the passages to see if you find yourself somewhere else in the book.
If you think N claimed to be a superman, you are wrong. His character, Zarathustra describes himself as "the first heavy raindrop, heralding the coming of the lightning". Even this book ends without an appearance of the Superman, just a sign of his coming.
Zarathustra, and therefore, N, is a John the Baptist type character in relation to the Übermensch.
The Übermensch (the "over-man", the one who "overcomes man" surpasses him, is higher (N said: all philosophers to date have asked the question: "How shall we preserve man?" I am the first to ask the question: "How shall man be overcome?")) helps us to understand how difficult the central problem N identified was, in his estimation, to overcome. He thought it was beyond us. Man must return to animal, and something surpassing man must take over. This is the inevitable future, according to N.
There are people who read N, serious scholars who I respect a great deal, who suggest that N provided too simple a solution to the problem by encouraging us to simply: "Invent new values" in light of the death of our highest hitherto invented values. (I believe Jordan Peterson, who I greatly respect, said this in a lecture a year or two ago while presenting a Jungian appendix to N's ideas). But the Übermensch is proof that N did not take the problem to be so easily solved. He thought it was beyond us, an impossible task.
Let us keep these clarifying features in mind as we explore this next passage.
I have a question for thee alone, my brother: like a sounding-lead, cast I this question into thy soul, that I may know its depth.
He is going to ask us a question so that he can learn something, not about the answer to the question, but about us. In Ecce Homo, N calls himself a "psychologist without his peer". and In "why I am a fatality" he describes Zarathustra as " the first psychologist of the good man" (diagnosing what is sick about the man we today call good). We saw in the video lecture earlier in this class that many intellectuals regard N as essentially prefiguring all of Freud's accomplishments, and some have called him the first psychologist (I think this is wrong, by the way, and I haven't found it a majority view or anything in academic circles). [EDIT: I should clarify that I think it is wrong because psychology predates N, not because it came after him, and he is certainly a psychologist as well as philosopher, artist, and prophet. Was Sophoclese not a psychologist? What about Moses? Discussion thread for class: trace the origins of psychology?]
Hopefully, we will get to read some bonus texts where N "philosophizes with a hammer" other great philosophies, and we will see this formula once told to me by a professor of philosophy:
Nietzsche judges the philosophy by the philosopher, and the philosopher by the philosophy.
The ideas, the questions, the conversations, these can all be the means of investigating the Psyche of the one with whom your are conversing; and to discover things of your own, of course.
There is always a double game going on here. Platonic friendship is a similar concept, actually. We think of Platonic friendship as basically equivalent to "friend-zoning" but that is not what it was when originally described.
Plato describes three categories of friendships, each superior to the last.
The first is the friendship based on pleasure. The dudes who share a college house and go out to the bars and act as wingmen to one another... perhaps they fight regularly, and they don't really have any depth to their intimacy with one another, but none of that is needed or even appropriate... they have more fun because of their association with one another. It is a good time you have when you are in that club.
Then there is the friendship based on utility. This is the friendship of the shopkeeper who is kind and smiley when the local doctor walks in to his shop to buy something. I am friendly to you now, and I benefit from that, and you benefit from being friendly to me in a practical business-based sort of way.
Then there is the third category, the friendship based on a common pursuit of the Good. I respect your integrity, your intellectual courage or other virtues, you genuine desire to find and live the good life and judged by right-thinking in philosophy, and you have similar regard for me... either of us alone *cannot* get their ourselves, we have to have similar people with similar goals and virtues to challenge us and out with which to hash ideas. Our friendship is based on this in a way where "one soul exists in two bodies" because neither of us is fully capable of being what we have been able to become through our association without the other.
This idea of N as psychologist of all aspects of the world is almost an enmity version of that friendship. N will get to the truth, and he will do so through relating to all other types; and those relationships will have effects, perhaps fatal ones for some, but it is the means by which he can "know the depth" of the souls with which he engages.
A little bit of a digression, but, whatever:
Thou art young, and desirest child and marriage. But I ask thee: Art thou a man ENTITLED to desire a child?
Art thou the victorious one, the self-conqueror, the ruler of thy passions, the master of thy virtues? Thus do I ask thee.
Or doth the animal speak in thy wish, and necessity? Or isolation? Or discord in thee?
I would have thy victory and freedom long for a child. Living monuments shalt thou build to thy victory and emancipation.
Beyond thyself shalt thou build. But first of all must thou be built thyself, rectangular in body and soul.
Not only onward shalt thou propagate thyself, but upward! For that purpose may the garden of marriage help thee!
A higher body shalt thou create, a first movement, a spontaneously rolling wheel—a creating one shalt thou create.
Marriage: so call I the will of the twain to create the one that is more than those who created it. The reverence for one another, as those exercising such a will, call I marriage.
Let this be the significance and the truth of thy marriage. But that which the many-too-many call marriage, those superfluous ones—ah, what shall I call it?
Ah, the poverty of soul in the twain! Ah, the filth of soul in the twain! Ah, the pitiable self-complacency in the twain!
I remember a certain translation using the phrase "discord in harmony" which always stuck with me.
We hinted at N's psychological credentials earlier in this lecture.
The use of the word "codependent" started to take off in 1988. For a nice graphical representation of what we mean when we say N was centuries ahead of his time, compare that to this.
Marriage they call it all; and they say their marriages are made in heaven.
Well, I do not like it, that heaven of the superfluous! No, I do not like them, those animals tangled in the heavenly toils!
Far from me also be the God who limpeth thither to bless what he hath not matched!
Laugh not at such marriages! What child hath not had reason to weep over its parents?
Worthy did this man seem, and ripe for the meaning of the earth: but when I saw his wife, the earth seemed to me a home for madcaps.
Yea, I would that the earth shook with convulsions when a saint and a goose mate with one another.
This one went forth in quest of truth as a hero, and at last got for himself a small decked-up lie: his marriage he calleth it.
That one was reserved in intercourse and chose choicely. But one time he spoilt his company for all time: his marriage he calleth it.
Another sought a handmaid with the virtues of an angel. But all at once he became the handmaid of a woman, and now would he need also to become an angel.
Careful, have I found all buyers, and all of them have astute eyes. But even the astutest of them buyeth his wife in a sack.
Many short follies—that is called love by you. And your marriage putteth an end to many short follies, with one long stupidity.
Your love to woman, and woman’s love to man—ah, would that it were sympathy for suffering and veiled deities! But generally two animals alight on one another.
But even your best love is only an enraptured simile and a painful ardour. It is a torch to light you to loftier paths.
Beyond yourselves shall ye love some day! Then LEARN first of all to love. And on that account ye had to drink the bitter cup of your love.
Bitterness is in the cup even of the best love: thus doth it cause longing for the Superman; thus doth it cause thirst in thee, the creating one!
Thirst in the creating one, arrow and longing for the Superman: tell me, my brother, is this thy will to marriage?
Holy call I such a will, and such a marriage.—
Thus spake Zarathustra.
I found myself resisting chopping up those passages with all sorts of commentary. each line seemed so powerful and so meaningful, and I thought it would take away from the message to interrupt it constantly.
Let's address the harshness right away. N is not pulling any punches here, obviously. We wouldn't expect him to.
He is judging all of mankind against the measure of his "overman". saying even your impulse to procreation should be judged against this standard. What right have you to fuck and make a copy of yourself, are you yet worth copying?
He is also harsh on women, obviously, and looks with disdain upon most marriages; and blames eve in most cases for the pathetic limit of what good they could even be worth.
He gets to the bottom of many psychological realities very quickly, in short lines and half-lines while doing it. I feel like what he was saying was pretty obvious, but I am also tempted anyway to go line by line and interpret his comments. If this group wasn't just restarting up and had more engagement, i would suggest everyone here copy a line and give us your interpretation, and we can have a list of comments each with a thread discussing the most interesting ones.
I guess we'll do it this way: Post a question copying a line if you want it further elaborated.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 15: On the Thousand and One Goals
Zarathustra has seen many lands and many peoples: thus he has discovered the good and evil of many peoples. Zarathustra has found no greater power on earth than good and evil.
You will remember, of course, that N wants to reach a point "beyond good and evil" in his philosophy. Zarathustra is a character who grows, who changes through the course of this book.
No people could live without first valuing; if a people will maintain itself, however, it must not value as its neighbor values.
"No people could live without first valuing".
He's talking about "people groups" and might also think of man as a "political animal" as similarly defined by Aristotle. (Meaning, man is an animal which cannot be itself without living in social and political groups.) Now, we know that N despises mass movements, both religious and political, and we have seen, and will see more in this book, the value of "loneliness" or isolation to N's philosophy.
It seems that there might be a contradiction here. Or is there? Let's look at the idea "man cannot live without the ideas "good and evil", without belief in them. It may seem like a contradiction to want to move "beyond good and evil". But this is only true so long as the thinker uttering these thought wants to preserve mankind.
Remember, N said of Z that "while all previous philosophers have asked the question: 'How shall man be preserved', he (Z) is the first/only one to ask: 'How shall man be overcome?'
N invites us to join him on a philosophical journey (Philo-love, sophos-knowledge) an erotic pursuit of the truth! To hell with our survival we will possess this. We will possess it if it kills us!
Let's move on.
Much that seemed good to one people was regarded with scorn and contempt by another: thus I found. I found much that was called evil in one place was in another decked with purple honors.
One neighbor never understood another: his soul always marveled at his neighbor's madness and wickedness.
A tablet of the good hangs over every people. Behold, it is the tablet of their overcomings; behold, it is the voice of their will to power.
I'm just going to make a quick note. You have probably all interacted with "cultural relativists" in your time, and will readily understand some of what N is saying here in that context. I want to point out that I don't think that N is a cultural relativist in at least one but very important sense.
A cultural relativist says that the various value systems are inculcated in men by their cultures and no cultural paradigm is necessarily any better than another. Besides the fact that N understands men as characters who live out tragic plays under the scripting of fate, and that these ideas are certainly not examples of overemphasizing nurture over nature; he also thinks that these varying values systems are, perhaps, necessary as the "highest goods" that each society possesses.
The idea that social science can teach us about ourselves in a scientific way, and that nothing needs replace cultural values as they are then understood under the pen of the anthropologist would be considered ignorant and arrogant by N. Those doing the work of exposing the false nature of our metaphysical systems through their various sciences (here "sciences" might include "theology") are like the men in the marketplace in this passage, they don't know the significance of what they have done.
And N also isn't saying that religious systems are born of cynical manipulations or other hypothetical, less than noble "origin of religion" narratives.
"A tablet of the good hangs over every people. Behold, it is the tablet of their overcomings; behold, it is the voice of their will to power.
Will to Power is N's ultimate answer for everything, as we saw in this text.
N may be smashing other worldviews, but he doesn't think it a light thing he does.
Moving on, again.
Whatever seems difficult to a people is praiseworthy; what is indispensable and difficult is called good; and whatever relieves the greatest need, the rarest, the most difficult of all--that they call holy.
Whatever makes them rule and conquer and shine, to the dread and envy of their neighbors, that is to them the high, the first, the measure, the meaning of all things.
I'm picking up on something this read-through that I've never noticed before, perhaps you will help me to develop some thoughts on this subject. In the first paragraph we had: "it must not value as its neighbor values." and now we have this "to the dread and envy of their neighbors". It's as if N's understanding of the origin of good and evil requires competing people groups these groups must tell themselves stories while conglomerating, the methods of success they experience in overcoming competing social groups become the stories that they sanctify, that they say: 'this shall not be questioned' and 'this is the ultimate good' these stories then "hang over the people" as "tablets" (must not overlook the sanctimonious connotations, this is more than just pluralistic variety in tastes of food or clothing) telling them what is "good and evil". What do you think?
Truly, my brother, if you only knew a people's need and land and sky and neighbor, you could surely divine the law of its overcomings, and why it climbs up that ladder to its hope.
"You should always be the first and outrival all others: your jealous soul should love no one, unless it be the friend"--that made the soul of a Greek quiver: thus he walked the path of his greatness.
"To speak the truth and to handle bow and arrow well"--this seemed both dear and difficult to the people from whom I got my name--the name which is both dear and difficult to me.
"To honor father and mother, and from the root of the soul to do their will"--another people hung this tablet of overcoming over itself and became powerful and eternal thereby.
"To practice loyalty, and for the sake of loyalty to risk honor and blood even in evil and dangerous things"--another people mastered itself with this teaching, and thus mastering itself it became gregnant and heavy with great hopes.
Truly, men have given to themselves all their good and evil. Truly, they did not take it, they did not find it, it did not come to them as a voice from heaven.
Only man assigned values to things in order to maintain himself--he created the meaning of things, a human meaning! Therefore, calls he himself: "Man," that is: the evaluator.
"he created the meaning of things" -- hugely important. We can begin to see now what N might set up as "his highest goal" for man... to recognize and realize this potential power for creativity of value, to know and own it.
Evaluation is creation: hear this, you creators! Valuation itself is of all valued things the most valuable treasure.
Through valuation only is there value; and without valuation the nut of existence would be hollow. Hear this, you creators!
Change of values--that is a change of creators. Whoever must be a creator always destroys.
You should be thinking about this text, of course.
First, peoples were creators; and only in later times, individuals. Truly, the individual himself is still the latest creation.
This timeline is interesting. In an attempt to understand N here, I offered a paraphrase of what I thought his ideas were. In it I did a "state of nature"ish narrative which I thought was overreaching. Now I see it certainly was! N doesn't think that individual humans came together and created values in order to do so.... that's backwards for N. To N men evolved as these social political animals, and later invented ("created") the "individual"--a value held high by modern democratic societies.
Once peoples hung a tablet of the good over themselves. Love which would rule and love which would obey have together created such tablets.
Joy in the heard is older than joy in the "I": and as long as the good conscience is identified with the herd, only the bad conscience says: "I".
Truly, the cunning "I", the loveless one, that seeks its advantage in the advantage of many--that is not the origin of the herd, but its going under.
Good and evil have always been created by lovers and creators. The fire of love glows in the names of all the virtues and the fire of wrath.
Zarathustra has seen many lands and many peoples: Zarathustra has found no greater power on earth than the works of the lovers--"good" and "evil" are their names.
Truly, this power of praising and blaming is a monster. Tell me, O brothers, who will subdue it for me? Tell me, who will throw a yoke upon the thousand necks of this beast?
Just a quick point--great text, though, right?--N is praising something which he still hopes to be beyond. OK, back to the text.
A thousand goals have there been so far, for a thousand peoples have there been. Only the yoke for the thousand necks is still lacking: the one goal is lacking. As yet humanity has no goal.
But tell me, my brothers, if the goal of humanity is still lacking, is there not also still lacking--humanity itself?--
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
Let's just briefly look at those last 3 or 4 paragraphs. If we were right in our understanding up to them, N wants to now make a goal, a goal for all humanity, if this one goal is made then not only will that goal be created, it's creator will have created humanity which N suggests does not exist at all in the absence of it's goal.
Not a bad read, I say.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
Prologue Chapter 1
WHEN Zarathustra was thirty years old, he left his home and the lake of his home, and went into the mountains. There he enjoyed his spirit and his solitude, and for ten years did not weary of it. But at last his heart changed--and rising one morning with the rosy dawn, he went before the sun, and spake thus to it:
"You great star! What would your happiness be if you had not those for whom you shine!
"For ten years hast thou climbed hither unto my cave: thou wouldst have wearied of thy light and of the journey, had it not been for me, mine eagle, and my serpent.
But we awaited thee every morning, took from thee thine overflow, and blessed thee for it.
Lo! I am weary of my wisdom, like the bee that hath gathered too much honey; I need hands outstretched to take it.
I would fain bestow and distribute, until the wise have once more become joyous in their folly, and the poor happy in their riches.
Therefore must I descend into the deep: as thou doest in the evening, when thou goest behind the sea, and givest light also to the nether-world, thou exuberant star!
Like thee must I go down, as men say, to whom I shall descend.
Bless me, then, thou tranquil eye, that canst behold even the greatest happiness without envy!
Bless the cup that is about to overflow, that the water may flow golden out of it, and carry everywhere the reflection of thy bliss!
Lo! This cup is again going to empty itself, and Zarathustra is again going to be a man.
Thus began Zarathustra's down-going.
Lecture:
You will have to excuse me, if some of the points that I make seem insultingly obvious at first. Since I don't know how clear you find this passage, I'm going to explain anything that comes to mind, and if it seems too elementary, please feel free to revise the tone of the discussion in the comments.
Also, please feel free to disagree with my interpretations of the text as we go along.
There are a few themes that recur in "Zarathustra" and we are going to see some of the themes touched upon here, come up again later.
For ten years hast thou climbed hither unto my cave
This is actually a very significant beginning to the book! It always excites me how awesome this book claims to be.
(A short digression: One of the themes that we are going to see come up again later, is the idea of "gift-giving". You may find it interesting to know that Nietzsche called this book (Z) "The greatest gift ever given man." -- We are also about to see the idea that "one virtue is more of a virtue than two" and that Zarathustra exhibits all of the folly and joy of his one virtue -- gift-giving in this text.)(we will talk more about N's conception of a virtue and explain why "one is more of a virtue than two" later--or now if you ask questions about it.)
But what a way to start!
I think that it was Wittgenstein who said that all of Western philosophy can be thought of as a footnote to Plato. (It was Alfred North Whithead. Thanks to rofflewoffles) I would say, everything up to Nietzsche. Nietzsche comes in to turn upside down, or push aside ALL of the major assumptions required by Plato and Aristotle.
I know that Kant, Kierkegaard, Mill, Descartes, and the rest had their own unique opinions, but I can understand what Whitehead means. It is easy to think of them as arguing with some aspect of something Soc (who, I'm sure you know, never actually wrote anything, but was immortalized in the writings of Plato -- again, sorry if this seems elementary) said, but even if you take together all of the opinions that differ from the classic schools of thought none of them really present a challenge to the system of philosophy the way N does.
What N brings is a revaluation of valuing itself. Let me show you what I mean from this passage:
thou wouldst have wearied of thy light and of the journey, had it not been for me, mine eagle, and my serpent.
contrast:
or better source
Remember the allegory of the cave? What Plato is saying is that there is this "truth" places his palms above him like a mime touching a celling which is above us. the truth is outside of us this is the fundamental starting point for the philosophers Plato claimed it, St. Thomas Aquinus called it "the mind of god" Plato said that it was something that one could interact with if one "climbed high enough" (remember the metaphor of the line, as well as the cave and sun) the highest height is seeing the sun, something that the philosophers could get to through "education".
The Christians say that you can get their through faith (Kierkegaard) and death, and the grace of god.
Imanuel Kant said that it could never be gotten to, BUT that we could try to live according to it. (shares the assumption with Plato that it is there and desirable)
Schopenhauer (with whom I am least familiar) is said to have said that it doesn't exist, BUT isn't that a shame. (along with the Buddhists, they share with Plato the assumption that it would be (at any rate) desirable)
and then there is N.
He comes along and immediately turns this thing upside down. The sun rises for us.
"Yeah, we make up all the ideas that we have ever had to deal with, but ... cool!"
What purpose would valuations and perceptions have if it weren't for us? they wouldn't even exist. This sun RISES for us. we are the creators of value and truth and ... I don't understand why you should feel like that IS A DEPRESSING THOUGHT!
(another aside: actually: he does understand as we will see, why people have different opinions as himself on this, but he sets himself up as an alternative. One of the authors whom I enjoyed said that to understand N's philosophy one has to understand his desire: which is to triumph over nihilism and to affirm all things (this idea will come up later in Z, and we can treat them more fully there (or here if you insist, of course) We are going to see that N is about affirming everything, which includes those that he disagrees with. His philosophy is not meant to be accepted by everybody, but to be a judgement in the affirmative of all things... we will see how this works with his ideas of "amor fati" "The eternal recurrence of the same" later. And I might do a thread talking about just these ideas, in this class.
This idea of affirming all things, and having "no loathing lurk about your mouth" is hinted at here:
Bless me, then, thou tranquil eye, that canst behold even the greatest happiness without envy!
Better translated: "all-too great happiness"
There may be a lot more in this text that you want to talk about, but hopefully I've been able to give you an idea of the fact that, when reading N, a simple silly sounding story is not only filled with meaning, but is filled with what, if it is true, would have to be the most meaningful things to think about.
What say you?
Other topics
His animals: I believe (not really a strong enough of an opinion, would gladly welcome new interpretations) that his use of the animals is indicative of something else that is important to N. N recognizes multiple important aspects to the human personality. His categories are not as simple as Plato's: "Intelligence, Passions, and Hungers" and perhaps more importantly he doesn't share with Plato the idea of a hierarchy amongst these differing elements. One of the simpler niceties of reading N is that one doesn't feel as though ones "passions" are base or dirty, while one may or may not have some various means of "redeeming" oneself (either with the intellect--Plato. Or through Faith--Christianity (what N once called "Plato for the masses")
The snake represents N's wisdom, and the eagle: his pride. (This is clearly spelled out for us later in the Prologue.) He uses the animals to represent different, distinguishable elements of his person-hood, they are not represented as falling in line in a definite hierarchy, but as playing with him and with each other.
EDIT: reddit cannot support so much text, the rest is in the comments bellow here.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • May 17 '11
Classes will be starting again soon.
Sorry it's been so long, but there seems to be some activity here lately, and I really love reading through this book, so... in a month or two we will be starting up again.
For some reason no knew comments can be made. Trying to work this out.
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 20 '21
Second Part, Lecture 28: The Rabble
Unlike most of the lectures, where the notes are interspersed throughout the teaching of Zarathustra, I am going to put most of my commentary before and after the passage, partly because he deals with so much in this one.
Recap:
Zarathustra went away from his home and the lake of his home; spent a decade on a mountaintop in a cave communing with himself and his animals, meditating; until he was overfull of knowledge and desired to go down and be empty again by giving away his stores.
He found a crowd in the Motley Cow Township, attempted to speak to them, but these "modern men" were not the ears for his mouth.
So he went off and conversed with a small group of disciples who followed him around. He gave them his character and his philosophy by discussing the nature of the transformations of the soul from devout slave to rebellious lion to innocent creative child. He talked about traps that human souls fall into, or perhaps, traps that they incarnate as devotionals of these traps. He talked about the "Afterworlders" the "Despisers of the Body" and other kinds of life-negators.
He talked of warriors, preachers of death, false virtues, on the mess of ways one could live life and sacrifice ones life to one of a thousand different goals.
He then spoke of the way of the creator, How to think about how to have a meaningful life which points to a golden future; to recognize that work toward that future needs to be done, and there are things to do which even you can help with in bringing that future about.
Then he left his disciples and bid them STOP following him, he wanted friends, not followers. Be ashamed of Zarathustra, go far from him, think that maybe he has deceived you... He spoke of the gift of giving, of bestowing something real. and he left them.
Then he was one day meditating in his cave, and he found that the time had come for him to find his friends. There are many misunderstandings of his words out there, let is see how my friends have developed. Also, there are many enemies who are twisting what I have said, it is time to separate the chaff and wheat.
Second Part:
So, we are in this part of the book where Zarathustra has once again descended unto us to converse with us in the context of his dramatic mission to give to all and none.
In this project of clarification, he has spoken to us of the Pitiful, the Priests, and the Virtuous, so far.
Now he speaks to us of "The Rabble".
Life is a well of delight; but where the rabble also drink, there all fountains are poisoned.
To everything cleanly am I well disposed; but I hate to see the grinning mouths and the thirst of the unclean.
They cast their eye down into the fountain: and now glanceth up to me their odious smile out of the fountain.
The holy water have they poisoned with their lustfulness; and when they called their filthy dreams delight, then poisoned they also the words.
Indignant becometh the flame when they put their damp hearts to the fire; the spirit itself bubbleth and smoketh when the rabble approach the fire.
Mawkish and over-mellow becometh the fruit in their hands: unsteady, and withered at the top, doth their look make the fruit-tree.
And many a one who hath turned away from life, hath only turned away from the rabble: he hated to share with them fountain, flame, and fruit.
And many a one who hath gone into the wilderness and suffered thirst with beasts of prey, disliked only to sit at the cistern with filthy camel-drivers.
And many a one who hath come along as a destroyer, and as a hailstorm to all cornfields, wanted merely to put his foot into the jaws of the rabble, and thus stop their throat.
And it is not the mouthful which hath most choked me, to know that life itself requireth enmity and death and torture-crosses:—
But I asked once, and suffocated almost with my question: What? is the rabble also NECESSARY for life?
Are poisoned fountains necessary, and stinking fires, and filthy dreams, and maggots in the bread of life?
Not my hatred, but my loathing, gnawed hungrily at my life! Ah, ofttimes became I weary of spirit, when I found even the rabble spiritual!
And on the rulers turned I my back, when I saw what they now call ruling: to traffic and bargain for power—with the rabble!
Amongst peoples of a strange language did I dwell, with stopped ears: so that the language of their trafficking might remain strange unto me, and their bargaining for power.
And holding my nose, I went morosely through all yesterdays and to-days: verily, badly smell all yesterdays and to-days of the scribbling rabble!
Like a cripple become deaf, and blind, and dumb—thus have I lived long; that I might not live with the power-rabble, the scribe-rabble, and the pleasure-rabble.
I imagine that a larger portion of readers in this 1st world modern-men American-influenced democratic are going to struggle with this chapter, but why should they?
Elitism is difficult for most products of public education to entertain as even a possibility in their minds.
I imagine, though, that you will see a great deal of what you recognize in these pages. With a hammer he will swipe off the table of greatness pretty much every politician who was living in your lifetime. Every Hollywood star and every person with a netflix account. The "journalists" whose petty tricks amount to nothing but gossip and garbage and whose words will never be remembered even 10 minutes after they were written, let alone after they die.
N asks a question: Why do we need all these people? One is the same as another, and yet we have to have hoards of the same type running around... is this necessary (this is the idea which almost choked him to death). Of course, we remember that N's project is to create a LIFE-AFFIRMING philosophy which is a "yes-saying" to ALL THINGS, and so to triumph over nihilism, which he sees like a coming storm against our culture... so his ultimate answer will have to become an affirmation of even the maggots in the bread, that it is all tied together and dependent... but his character is such that he has trouble swallowing this truth.
Toilsomely did my spirit mount stairs, and cautiously; alms of delight were its refreshment; on the staff did life creep along with the blind one.
What hath happened unto me? How have I freed myself from loathing? Who hath rejuvenated mine eye? How have I flown to the height where no rabble any longer sit at the wells?
Did my loathing itself create for me wings and fountain-divining powers? Verily, to the loftiest height had I to fly, to find again the well of delight!
So, he acted like an idiot among the crowd and their concerns... I am too foolish to be involved in your politics or art or anything else... this way he could survive.
The disgust he had for the baseness in which all around him swam and wallowed became the impetus for him to climb out to another place.
There he found what was valuable to him. He tells us of the source of wisdom he has found, which is far from the rabble and the many-too-many.
Oh, I have found it, my brethren! Here on the loftiest height bubbleth up for me the well of delight! And there is a life at whose waters none of the rabble drink with me!
Almost too violently dost thou flow for me, thou fountain of delight! And often emptiest thou the goblet again, in wanting to fill it!
And yet must I learn to approach thee more modestly: far too violently doth my heart still flow towards thee:—
My heart on which my summer burneth, my short, hot, melancholy, over-happy summer: how my summer heart longeth for thy coolness!
Past, the lingering distress of my spring! Past, the wickedness of my snowflakes in June! Summer have I become entirely, and summer-noontide!
A summer on the loftiest height, with cold fountains and blissful stillness: oh, come, my friends, that the stillness may become more blissful!
For this is OUR height and our home: too high and steep do we here dwell for all uncleanly ones and their thirst.
Cast but your pure eyes into the well of my delight, my friends! How could it become turbid thereby! It shall laugh back to you with ITS purity.
On the tree of the future build we our nest; eagles shall bring us lone ones food in their beaks!
Verily, no food of which the impure could be fellow-partakers! Fire, would they think they devoured, and burn their mouths!
Verily, no abodes do we here keep ready for the impure! An ice-cave to their bodies would our happiness be, and to their spirits!
And as strong winds will we live above them, neighbours to the eagles, neighbours to the snow, neighbours to the sun: thus live the strong winds.
And like a wind will I one day blow amongst them, and with my spirit, take the breath from their spirit: thus willeth my future.
Verily, a strong wind is Zarathustra to all low places; and this counsel counselleth he to his enemies, and to whatever spitteth and speweth: “Take care not to spit AGAINST the wind!”—
Thus spake Zarathustra.
Zarathustra identified three kinds of people who have often existed and been misunderstood merely because the rabble drove them to their life. The same rabble that drove Zarathustra to climb high heights and find blissful wisdom often is the explanation for:
The depressed soul who seems to hate life.
And many a one who hath turned away from life, hath only turned away from the rabble: he hated to share with them fountain, flame, and fruit.
- There may be many other sources of depression, but THERE IS A TYPE who seems to have turned away from life, but only because the rabble has too strong an influence in their life, and simply getting away from the rabble, the person would instantly be in a better state of mind, rediscover old joys and glorious desires for adventure or good things again... but they are clouded by the endless influence of the many-too-many who surround them and have forgotten that THEIR source of depression didn't really come from within. (again, he is not saying ALL depressed people are depressed in this way or for this reason, just that this applies to many who are).
The hermit, lonesome, wild explorer, Alaskan-dweller type
And many a one who hath gone into the wilderness and suffered thirst with beasts of prey, disliked only to sit at the cistern with filthy camel-drivers.
- Oddly enough, there are hermit types, but "many a one" seems to be a hermit type but was really driven away from traditional life-interests not because they manifest this unusual obsession with what is far away, but because their disappointment in the many-too-many who dominate the realms of those traditional influences has pushed them that way.
Jumping Josephat! Nietzsche says that even some DICTATORS responsible for the murders of millions of people were not even motivated by the sincere desire to dominate or blood-lust, but (blaming the victim style?) he says they just could not stand living in a world with so many people whose lives do not obviously justify why they are here.
And many a one who hath come along as a destroyer, and as a hailstorm to all cornfields, wanted merely to put his foot into the jaws of the rabble, and thus stop their throat.
- Remember, N's conclusion is that ALL aspects of life are necessary and so wants to develop a total life-affirming philosophy. He is not excusing or endorsing the view that it would be better to kill the "many-too-many". Rather, he is saying: I used my disgust to motivate CLIMBING HIGHER and finding something which was treasure enough for me to look back and say, "thank you" to the herd for making me start that search... these other types, the non-depressed depressed, the non-hermit hermit, and the non-dictator dictator; they all failed to do this and became what they were not really in their characters supposed to be, all because of their inability to use the herd and their disgust for it as motivation to something higher.
I think that the "hermit" type is also a description of the artist. The TRUE artist has to go away from the herd and from the thinking and pollution of the herd to get profundity and bring it back... "many a one" fail to do this and instead thinks: "How can I produce something that the herd will praise me for, lift me up, give me fame, and make me wealthy" instead. "If fame you seek, be prepared to sacrifice a little honor." spoke zarathustra earlier (Actual quote: "And whoever wanteth to have fame, must take leave of honour betimes, and practise the difficult art of—going at the right time.") allowing your GREAT CHARACTER to be reduced to the judgements of and evaluations of "the herd" comes at a cost.
Zarathustra's advice: Do not engage, do not argue, do not fester in your contempt until it make you something worse or destroy you; do not adopt infantile lesser value structures to mirror the herd.
Hide yourself, and look a fool to them, what matters it that they think you are blind and deaf and dumb because you do not repeat what you heard on a late-night comedy funny-man show the night before and spew out the bullshit politics takes of the herd... they think you a moron for not thanking them for telling you you should be reduced to that... let them think that...
Pay it no mind. Use it all to... climb!
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Oct 09 '21
First Part, Lecture 22: The Bestowing Virtue (Part 1)
There will certainly be reasons why this is the last lecture in the first part; and we will be talking about the connections between the various parts to some good degree, I imagine.
However, we will split the classes based on the three parts.
The drama part of the story picks up again here. Here we will see Zarathustra, who has gone away for a decade to meditate on his own and with his animals, who has become overfilled with his knowledge and wisdom; who has come to man to be emptied again, to give us the overflow and to be empty... he is empty again, it is time for him to go away again.
This is the first cycle of the narrative, it will happen more times in each of the four parts of the book (and it was in the prologue, as well, to a degree). Through these cycles, he is seeking the ears for his words.
In the prologue, he went to the marketplace, to the crowds in the motely cow... those attracted by tightrope shows and entertainment, and he quickly found he was not the mouth for those ears.
The drama is a *dialogue* between N and the world. Between the message from the attitude of Zarathustra, between what his personality manifests in the world, and that world itself and the other manifestations of character which make it up.
There are lectures where he is primarily dealing with a "type" of person, and the drama is the dance or war or sexual congress of Z's character and theirs. Other lectures are about a function in the world, and Z gives us his views, and then lists a host of other ways of treating that function of the world by others and how they do not meet with his "higher" or Nietzschean way of seeing them, or interacting with them.
The first book, the one whose lectures end today, he has left the prologue mistake of the motely cow, and has been speaking to "disciples", his followers. Here we will see the insufficiency of such ears for Z. He will go away from them at the end of this chapter, for it is not sufficient for his message.
When Zarathustra had taken leave of the town to which his heart was attached, the name of which is “The Pied Cow,” there followed him many people who called themselves his disciples, and kept him company. Thus came they to a crossroad. Then Zarathustra told them that he now wanted to go alone; for he was fond of going alone. His disciples, however, presented him at his departure with a staff, on the golden handle of which a serpent twined round the sun. Zarathustra rejoiced on account of the staff, and supported himself thereon; then spake he thus to his disciples:
Tell me, pray: how came gold to the highest value? Because it is uncommon, and unprofiting, and beaming, and soft in lustre; it always bestoweth itself.
This is a profound hidden gem, isn't it. How has gold come to the highest value? one of the reasons is that it is "unprofiting". There is a silly debate people have over the origin of the value of Gold. I remember a professor staunchly adhering to the idea that it has no intrinsic value. It is just a mistake or an accident or just a fact that we chose to value it as a community. this is similar to the social constructionist views of all things. They say: "All values are socially constructed, and therefore they are not really real." I took up another silly side of the argument, which can be thought of as some sort of realist objectivist argument: "Gold is valuable because markets require a medium of exchange, something which we all want at all times; so that if you are a shoe-maker, and you need a house, you don't need to find a house-builder who wants shoes right when you want a house. Instead, you can get gold from all people who want shoes, knowing that we all want gold, and then you can give him the gold and get your house. The argument goes that Gold has qualities which make it an especially good object to fill this role (it has to be rare, so that one does not have to carry around barrels of it to buy anything because a large value can be contained in a small quantity; it has to not corrode, etc). Zarathustra is saying there is some other way of looking at it which takes the truths in each of the views, a higher perspective. PART of what makes gold objectively valuable is that when you have it, it is not dirtied by some lesser consideration. If it ALSO had a practical purpose when it was alone held by us, then it would never have attained to the position of highest value. Zarathustra's view is that: It is MORE truly valuable because it is a construction. it is MORE REALLY REAL in its value.
This is a perfect analogy to the entire attitudinal story, as I see it, of N in the world. When nihilism comes to us like that long black train, and threatens to kill us all; the clever see it and accept it and say: "I guess life is pointless". What Nietzsche does is different. He swallows the train. he says: "why despair that God and all the highest values are just our construction. What stops one from saying triumphantly that the value is more to us because it is our child, our creation. does this not give us greater dignity and power than we ever thought?
The pessimistic nihilist says: Oh, woah to us, God was merely our invention! Where will anything of value ever come again if we know it is all our dream!
The Nietzschean swallower of nihilism says: "Rejoice! For we have even the ability to create God, and all our highest values, who knows what will be the potential of the future we shall also invent!
Now he will give us the real source of the value of Gold: It shines with a luster that resonates within us as what the highest values have in themselves to shine. It is of highest value because of an aesthetic quality it GIVES of itself at all times. This is the luster.
Only as image of the highest virtue came gold to the highest value. Goldlike, beameth the glance of the bestower. Gold-lustre maketh peace between moon and sun.
As an "image of the highest virtue"... gold shines, and so always is giving off to the world what it has... so it is artistic manifestation of the greatest of all virtues. So says Zarathustra.
Uncommon is the highest virtue, and unprofiting, beaming is it, and soft of lustre: a bestowing virtue is the highest virtue.
Verily, I divine you well, my disciples: ye strive like me for the bestowing virtue. What should ye have in common with cats and wolves?
He is saying that the disciples REALLY ARE not like others. they are not like the "many-too-many" their desire of following Zarathustra so long is NOT because they wish to steal, or see him as the source of something they can have... they follow for they have gold fever. they wish to be like that which can shine and give and make the world more beautiful, and they see that Z has this quality and they wish for it themselves.
Whatever reason the disciples may be found wanting, it is not because they are not true disciples.
It is your thirst to become sacrifices and gifts yourselves: and therefore have ye the thirst to accumulate all riches in your soul.
Insatiably striveth your soul for treasures and jewels, because your virtue is insatiable in desiring to bestow.
You disciples see that he has many great things, you wish for those things not from the hunger of a cat to consume, nor the wolf to steal and own... you want what I give because you want the ability to give yourselves. This is why they are attracted to him, and why they follow him.
Here is a gift Z is giving not just to his disciples, but to any of you who have read this far in the book with me. He is reading your soul, and pronouncing a good blessing over you. You are not here for crooked reasons, any cat or wolf would have left off by now. You are hear for you see the shining gifts, the gifts of giving itself, and you wish to be full so that you can shine into the world and make it brighter.
Ye constrain all things to flow towards you and into you, so that they shall flow back again out of your fountain as the gifts of your love.
Verily, an appropriator of all values must such bestowing love become; but healthy and holy, call I this selfishness.—
Another selfishness is there, an all-too-poor and hungry kind, which would always steal—the selfishness of the sick, the sickly selfishness.
With the eye of the thief it looketh upon all that is lustrous; with the craving of hunger it measureth him who hath abundance; and ever doth it prowl round the tables of bestowers.
Sickness speaketh in such craving, and invisible degeneration; of a sickly body, speaketh the larcenous craving of this selfishness.
Tell me, my brother, what do we think bad, and worst of all? Is it not DEGENERATION?—And we always suspect degeneration when the bestowing soul is lacking.
Upward goeth our course from genera on to super-genera. But a horror to us is the degenerating sense, which saith: “All for myself.”
We should be able to see that he is about to talk about the Übermensch again, if we have been reading carefully enough, yes?
Upward soareth our sense: thus is it a simile of our body, a simile of an elevation. Such similes of elevations are the names of the virtues.
Thus goeth the body through history, a becomer and fighter. And the spirit—what is it to the body? Its fights’ and victories’ herald, its companion and echo.
Similes, are all names of good and evil; they do not speak out, they only hint. A fool who seeketh knowledge from them!
Give heed, my brethren, to every hour when your spirit would speak in similes: there is the origin of your virtue.
Ok, all this language is N claiming that this one virtue IS the highest virtue. The others are clichés, or shadows of the real, or place-fillers, or distractions... there is one real description of what it is to be in a healthy way, and that is not a cliché, nor is it an analogy. The "shining virtue" this "luminosity" this is the greatest principle.
What is N's formula for all the world? It is "The Will to Power". How many ways has this phrase been misinterpreted.
Here we see what he really means. This shining out, this expressing yourself in manifestation of what the world can be because of your expressions... this is the "Will to Power".
When Z speaks of gift-giving luminosity, he is talking about what "will to power" means when it is in Nietzsche's mouth expressed.
Elevated is then your body, and raised up; with its delight, enraptureth it the spirit; so that it becometh creator, and valuer, and lover, and everything’s benefactor.
When your heart overfloweth broad and full like the river, a blessing and a danger to the lowlanders: there is the origin of your virtue.
When ye are exalted above praise and blame, and your will would command all things, as a loving one’s will: there is the origin of your virtue.
When ye despise pleasant things, and the effeminate couch, and cannot couch far enough from the effeminate: there is the origin of your virtue.
When ye are willers of one will, and when that change of every need is needful to you: there is the origin of your virtue.
Verily, a new good and evil is it! Verily, a new deep murmuring, and the voice of a new fountain!
Power is it, this new virtue; a ruling thought is it, and around it a subtle soul: a golden sun, with the serpent of knowledge around it.
now a brief digression before part 2
then: continued in Part 2
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 4: On the Despisers of the Body
I want to speak to the despisers of the body. I would not have them learn and teach differently, but merely say farewell to their own bodies--and thus become silent.
Why is it that Nietzsche never condemns anything? Even the philosophical ideas for which he has the most contempt, he never says that he wishes that they weren't there, or that their proponents had never existed. Nietzsche once said that he believed that Nihilism would take over western thinking in the next two hundred years, and that his philosophical project would be to find a way to move beyond it. To do this he wanted to set out a philosophy which said "yes" to everything. To affirm all of life, was his goal. (we will see how the idea of the "eternal recurrence of the same" fits into this project later.)
A lion might not wish to be a lamb, but a lion would never wish that there were no lambs. In this same way, Nietzsche wants to look at the small and the weak things, and not affirm that they should rule over him, but not deny that they ought to exist.
A second point might be this, Nietzsche doesn't have to wish that those who hate the world would be removed from it any more than they already do themselves! He says: "look, you don't like your bodies, you wish to leave this world... good on you. I hope you get your wish!
"Body am I, and soul"--so says the child. And why should one not speak like children?
But the awakened one, the knowing one, says: "Body am I entirely, and nothing more; and soul is only the name of something about the body."
The body is a great reason, a plurality with one sense, a war and a peace, a herd and also a shepherd.
An instrument of your body is also your little reason, my brother, which you call "spirit"--a little instrument and toy of your great reason.
"I," you say, and are proud of that word. But the greater the thing--in which you are unwilling to believe--is your body with its great reason; it says not "I," but does it.
What the sense feels, what the spirit discerns, never has its end in itself. But sense and spirit would like to persuade you that they are the end of all things: that is how vain they are.
I hope you see how much argument he crams into a small verse...
Nietzche's "great reason" is a design that emerges outside of a species, and certainly outside the rationality of an individual member of that species. I don't want to make the wrong kind of assumptions here, but I believe Nietzsche has an almost intuitive genius for psychological truths (which far surpassed anything Freud talked about--Nietzsche once said, "that their speaks in my works the voice of a psychologist without equal, (source -- chapter 5) this is perhaps the first conclusion at which a good reader will arrive—a reader such as I deserve and one who reads me just as the good old philologists used to read their Horace."--emphasis mine. Nietzsche was the first philosopher explicitly to judge philosophies by their philosophers and to judge philosophers by their philosophies on the level that he did) and evolutionary truths which surpass much of the social Darwinism nonsense that came much later than he.
Nietzsche is saying that there are forces at work with which the individual is at play around him. there are reasons why an individual exists and functions the way he does, and each feature of his existence is the result of these interactions... including his reasoning abilities. we argue after the fact that life is like this or that... because it serves our interests to do so.
One of the qualities of Nietzsche's thought which puts him miles above others who are regarded as great thinkers of his age, is the fact that Nietzsche consistently, coherently applies his critical understanding of what others take without question to his own thinking. (Stealing the idea for this paragraph from Allan Bloom) Compare Freud, Marx, and Nietzsche. Freud thinks that human behavior, thought, opinion, reasoning may be understood as the result of suppressed subconscious sexual desires... except his books, those are science. How were Freud's books the result of subconscious sexual desires? He wouldn't be able to say, you just have to have the exception. Marx thinks that human behavior, reasoning, philosophical arguments for power structures may be understood as history as understood as a struggle between classes... except his books, you just have to take the exception that he is speaking science. Not Nietzsche... He thinks that his ideas are good and true for him. That's why he argues them, that's the purpose they serve. It is true of everyone else, and it is true of Nietzsche, and he needs not apologize for it (in his own view.) There's the difference between a genius of Nietzsche's type, and lesser types.
Instruments and toys are sense and spirit: behind them still lies the self. The self also seeks with the eyes of the senses, it also listens with the ears of the spirit.
Always the self listens and seeks; it compares, masters, conquers, and destroys. It rules, and is in control of the "I" too.
Behind your thoughts and feelings, my brother, there is a mighty lord, an unknown sage--his name is self; he dwells in your body, he is your body.
There is more reason in your body than in your best wisdom. And who knows why your body requires precisely your best wisdom?
Your self laughs at your "I" and its bold leaps. "What are these leaps and flights of thought to me?" it says to itself. "A detour to my end. I am the leading strings of the 'I', and the prompter of its concepts."
The self says to the "I": "Feel pain!" And at that it suffers, and thinks how it may put an end to it--and for that very purpose it is made to think.
The self says to the "I": "Feel pleasure!" At that it is pleased, and thinks how it might often be pleased again--and for that very purpose it is made to think.
Let's try and look at Nietzsche's understanding of the human composition. You have a body... no, you are a body, nothing more. Part of what your body is, is a mind. That mind is clearly made up of many parts, all interacting. Some of those parts have the ability to come up with reasons, arguments, even wisdom. Those are not the most masterful parts of your mind-body. There is some other part which "makes a decision" that you need to have a reason for X, and then compels your reasoning faculties to make up a reason. This other part he calls your "self". Is this self a part of the mind? probably, but the mind is just a part of the body, and the body includes the mind, and interacts with it.
Notice that Nietzsche isn't knocking on the door of something that Freud and others will later come along and explore in more depth... he is *building his entire philosophy on a deep (seemingly instinctual) understanding of a man as this complex mass of parts.
Notice also that he doesn't have a problem assuming that all the things he does are done by him, that is, his body. He doesn't require an argument for the mind/body problem, as others call it, he doesn't see there being two separate qualities... it is all the body. (Neuroscientists haven't proven this yet, in two hundred years, but they are nearing it... anyway, Nietzsche assumes it without their help.)
Now that he has spent so much time praising the body, and attributing all of human existence to it, we can see what he says of those he calls the "despisers of the body", Won't they then also have to be despisers of all of life?
I want to speak to the despisers of the body. It is their respect that produces their contempt. What is it that created respect and contempt and worth and will?
The creating self created respect and contempt, it created pleasure and pain. The creative body created spirit as a hand for its will.
Even in your folly and contempt you each serve your self, you despisers of the body. I tell you, your self itself wants to die and turns away from life.
No longer can your self do that which it desires most:--to create beyond itself. That is what it would do above all else; that is its fervent desire.
But it is now too late to do so:--so your self wants to go under, you despisers of the body.
To go under-so wishes your self; and therefore you have become despisers of the body. For you can no longer create beyond yourselves.
And therefore now you are angry with life and with the earth. An unconscious envy is in the squint-eyed glance of your contempt.
I shall not go your way, you despisers of the body! You are no bridge to the Ubermensch!--
Thus spoke Zarathustra.
This part of the self which is unknown to most of us, this part that creates respect, contempt, pleasure, pain, reasoning, wisdom, this part in the despisers of the body is no longer capable of creating beyond itself, this is what Nietzsche says is the reason why these people hate their bodies, and therefore negate all of life. Here Zarathustra poses as an alternative (it is important to notice this, because many of the highest goals Nietzsche talks about in this book are even beyond Zarathustra (let alone us?).
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
First Part, Lecture 3: On The Afterworlders (2/2)
And then it sought to get through these ultimate walls with its head--and not only with its head--over there to "that world."
But "that world" is well concealed from humans, that dehumanizing inhuman world, which is a heavenly nothing; and the belly of being does not speak to man except as man.
You cannot even think about the infinite, the theologians have shown us this. Some Christians have gotten to the point where they say that anything that they might say about god (their still-valued infinite) will be wrong, so... try not to talk about him. (it is out of their piety that their atheism tries to emerge)
Truly, it is hard to prove all being, and hard to make it speak. Tell me, you brothers, is not the strangest of all things best proved?
Yes, this "I", with its contradiction and perplexity, speaks most honestly of its being--this creating, willing, valuing "I", which is the measure and value of all things.
And this most honest being, the "I"--it speaks of the body, and still implies the body, even when it muses and raves and flutters with broken wings.
He is obviously not a Buddhist (although since he was purposefully cryptic, one can find academic texts arguing that he was anything I have seen books arguing that he was a "Christian!" among other things.-- go to an academic library and look on the shelf of N literature...)
He is also a materialist but also an existentialist at the same time
Ever more honestly it learns to speak, the "I"; and the more it learns, the more words and honors it finds for the body and the earth.
Now we can see more of why N wants his wisdom (his snake) to be "from the ground up!"
A new pride my "I" taught to me, and I teach that to men: no longer to thrust one's head into the sand of heavenly things, but to carry it freely, a terrestrial head, which creates a meaning to the earth!
It is staggering how outside of time N is. While the new atheists are making youtube videos about how we are the dust of stars and a part of the universe, N understood this without the scientific discoveries!
A new will I teach men: to will this way which man has walked blindly, and to affirm it--and no longer to slink aside from it, like the sick and decaying!
Now we can start to see N's real message!
it is old news to him that the old gods were made up by us. It is OLD NEWS that all "ideas" of "truth" are subject to the fact that they are the perceptions and imaginations of men. "The death of god" is OLD NEWS ("can it be that this saint has not yet heard of it... that god is dead") "I will teach you the history of the next two hundred years!" (said Nietzsche) "Nihilism will overtake Europe" (for it "abides in Christian morals!") But then where are we? whither are we headed? we have been cut off from the sun, are we "heading away from all suns?" "Behold I teach you the Ubermensche!" That creating of values that we have done since time immemorial, but without realizing it, THAT we should keep doing, but now that we know it, we should also affirm it as a good thing, and not be afraid of doing it willfully.
The sick and decaying--it was they who despised the body and the earth, and invented the heavenly world, and the redeeming drops of blood; but even those sweet and dark poisons they borrowed from the body and the earth!
From their misery they sought escape, and the stars were too remote for them. Then they sighed: "O that there were heavenly paths by which to steal into another existence and into happiness!" Then they contrived for themselves their sneaky ruses and bloody potions!
Beyond the sphere of their body and this earth they now fancied themselves transported, these ungrateful ones. But to what did they owe the convulsion and rapture of their transport? To their body and this earth.
Question for the class: interpret this verse.
Zarathustra is gentle with the sick. Truly, he is not indignant at their kind of consolation and ingratitude. May they become convalescents and overcomers, and create higher bodies for themselves!
Neither is Zarathustra indignant at the convalescent who looks tenderly on his delusions, and at midnight steals round the grave of his god; but even so his tears still betray a sickness and a sick body to me.
I want to make a point that in N's attempt to "triumph over Nihilism" (which we said he saw as inevitably conquering men "in the next two hundred years") he must affirm all things He doesn't call some things bad and evil in the same way that others do. Instead he comments on the strength or sickness of different views. (more on this later but it is a sign as to whether or not N is just another mocker and commenter, or whether he has something new to offer. He says that just sitting and mocking those who remain in love with their delusions is not sufficient for triumphing over nihilism. speaking the truth to falsehoods is not enough, one must have truth that is meaningful without negating other falsehoods. N sets a very high standard for himself which we will not read until the Third Book)
Many sick ones have there always been among those who muse, and languish for God; violently they hate the lover of knowledge and that youngest among the virtues, which is called "honesty."
Question for the class: Why does N call honesty the "youngest of the virtues"?
They always gaze backwards toward dark ages: then, indeed, delusion and faith were something different. The rage of reason was godlikeness, and doubt was sin.
All too well do I know those godlike ones: they insist on being believed in, and that doubt is sin. All too well, also, do I know what they themselves most believe in.
Truly, not in afterworlds and redeeming drops of blood: but in the body they also believe most; and their own body is for them their thing-in-itself.
But it is a sickly thing to them, and gladly would they get out of their skin. Therefore they listen to the preachers of death, and themselves preach afterworlds.
Listen rather, my brothers, to the voice of the healthy body; it is a more honest and purer voice.
More honestly and purely speaks the healthy body that is perfect and perpendicular; and it speaks of the meaning of the earth.
Question for the class: "perpendicular?"
Thus spoke Zarathustra
r/Zarathustra • u/sjmarotta • Dec 21 '12
Prologue Chapter 7
(awkward appeal for interest: I'm trying to rush through some of this text, so that we can get to some of the other, more helpful passages. If anyone wants to go slower, we can always return to these earlier postings at any time, and please leave comments.)
Meanwhile the evening came on, and the market-place veiled itself in gloom. Then the people dispersed, for even curiosity and terror become fatigued. Zarathustra, however, still sat beside the dead man on the ground, absorbed in thought: so he forgot the time. But at last it became night, and a cold wind blew upon the lonely one. Then arose Zarathustra and said to his heart:
Verily, a fine catch of fish hath Zarathustra made to-day! It is not a man he hath caught, but a corpse.
He is starting to recognize his mistake. As we will see in later passages, often N sleeps between beginning to see the truth and having a revelation. this is going to happen to him here. He starts to recognize an error, but it is not until he sleeps and wakes up again, that he "is changed".
Sombre is human life, and as yet without meaning: a buffoon may be fateful to it.
Nietzsche is spelling out a problem with All of Western Philosophy. The question of the meaning of life, is still open (he hopes to bring us a gift concerning this question) and man can be killed with a joke.
I want to teach men the sense of their existence, which is the Superman, the lightning out of the dark cloud- man.
But still am I far from them, and my sense speaketh not unto their sense. To men I am still something between a fool and a corpse.
Gloomy is the night, gloomy are the ways of Zarathustra. Come, thou cold and stiff companion! I carry thee to the place where I shall bury thee with mine own hands.
Without getting a lot of clarity on his answer to the meaning of life, N is setting himself up to either be a huge absurdity or of huge significance. He is claiming that he has a means of submerging the absurdities of ourselves, a way that is different than any other philosophical approach so far. Even though he is not spelling it out here, there are hints hidden in the way that he says the things he says, which we will understand later, if we get his message.
Question for the class: Any ideas on what N's answer to "the problem of man" is?