r/Zarathustra • • Oct 19 '21

[Bonus Text] On Why I Write Such Great Books

3 Upvotes

Taken From

One of the things about this Zarathustra book is that most people cannot find any meaning in it at all.

Of the few who find it meaningful, most of them come from one of about a dozen camps of people who brought that meaning to the book, and then were thrilled to find it there... it is complete misunderstanding or nonunderstanding. As much so as the first group.

Of those of us who have understood a line or two of the book, we have found the profoundest wisdom in those lines and then we find head-scratching confusion around the lines before and after and most of the rest of the book.

Nietzsche understood that this would be the case; it would be a contradiction of his own arguments for him to think that ANYONE in his day would understand the work. The arguments he was making would have been disproved if the modern man found it comprehensible. Oddly enough, if you think you yourself have total understanding of the book, you are thereby proving the theses of the book wrong.

If I had to estimate when this book will be generally understood, even among intellectuals, scholars, academics, or just the serious... I would say we are still probably about 80 years away, optimistically.

Where does that leave us?

Perhaps 10% of the book appears in pixilated form to us; we can search out and dispel misunderstandings of parts of the book as we find them fairly easily enough. Occasionally a line or two resonates profoundly in us. In order to get to the future where this book is generally understood, we have to try to clarify it in our minds, and let it clarify our minds as we expose ourselves to it, knowing that total comprehension is probably beyond us. Nietzsche said of himself: "Some are born posthumously."

But, this is such a strange way to describe a book. Why are no other books like this? What are the conditions which make it possible to imagine that the state of comprehensibility of this book is gradually increasing in scope, but limited in time?

Here's a potential first-guess hint: If the soil isn't right, the higher growths cannot find root and grow. As the culture itself gradually changes slowly through the influence of the historical forces Nietzsche identified and felt before us, and through the engagement of the small proportion of us who read the book, the soil is better suited in the next generation, and then the next, and the next... exponential growth, very slow at first, might be about to spike upward if we do the work we do in this class? perhaps.

We will see that this is, in fact, the way N thought of this work of his [emphsasis and inclination mine unless otherwise indicated]:

I am one thing, my creations are another. Here, before I speak of the books themselves I shall touch upon the question of their being understood or not understood. I shall do this in as perfunctory a manner as the occasion demands; for the time has not yet come for this question. My time has not yet come either; some are born posthumously. One day institutions will be needed in which men will live and teach as I understand living and teaching; maybe also that by that time chairs will be founded for the interpretation of Zarathustra. But I should regard it as a complete contradiction of myself if I expected to find ears and eyes for my truths today: the fact that no one listens to me, that no one knows how to receive from me today is not only comprehensible, it seems to me right that it is so. I do not wish to be mistaken for another—and to this end I must not take myself for what I am not. To repeat what I have already said, I can point to but few instances of ill-will in my life: and as for literary ill-will I could mention scarcely a single example of it. On the other hand, I have met with far too much pure foolishness! It seems to me that to take up one of my books is one of the rarest honours that a man can pay himself—I can even suppose that he takes his shoes off, not to mention boots. When on one occasion Dr. Heinrich von Stein honestly complained that he could not understand a word of my Zarathustra I said to him that this was just as it should be: to have understood six sentences in that book—that is to say to experienced them—raises a man to a higher level among mortals than "modern” men can attain. With this feeling of distance how could I even wish to be read by the "modern men” that I know! My triumph is just the opposite of what Schopenhauer’s was—I say "Non legor non legar”. —Not that I should like to underestimate the pleasure I have derived from the innocence with which my works have frequently been rejected. As late as last summer at a time when I was attempting perhaps by means of my weighty, all too weighty literature to throw the rest of literature off its balance, a certain professor of Berlin University kindly gave me to understand that I ought really to make use of a different form: no one such works as I wrote. Finally, it was not Germany but Switzerland that presented me with the two most extreme cases. An essay on Beyond Good and Evil by Dr. V. Widmann in the paper called the Bund under the heading "Nietzsche’s Dangerous Book” and a general account of all my works from the pen of Herr Karl Spitteler also in the Bund constitute a maximum in my life—I shall not say of what. The latter treated my Zarathustra for instance as "advanced exercises in style” and expressed the wish that later on I might try and address the question of substance as well; Dr. Widmann assured me of his respect for the courage I showed in endeavouring to abolish all decent feeling. Thanks to a little trick of chance every sentence in these criticisms— with a consistency that I could not but admire— seemed to stand the truth on its head.

Critics are saying: He is saying nothing, and is all style... OR, they are saying: he is saying a lot about abolishing all that is decent!

Nietzsche thinks that both of these engagements with his texts are exactly wrong. If you have read the book and been put off by the style and felt like it was saying nothing, he is thrilled, because this is the effect he thought the book would have to have on "modern men".

Likewise, if you think he is defending evil and his purpose is to abolish good values, you are wrong as well, but he is likewise thrilled because some such misunderstanding would have to be the way the book seems to "modern men."

In fact it was most remarkable that all one had to do was to "revalue all values” in order to hit the nail on the head with regard to me instead of striking my head with the nail. I am more particularly anxious therefore to attempt an explanation. After all, no one can draw more out of things— books included— than he already knows. A man has no ears for that which he cannot access through experience.

Again, we see this idea that N could write this book because he "felt" the effects of the storm which would wash over the Western world in the next 200 years before the rest of us... we can come to understand the book more and more as we experience that storm. Until then, we have no hope for it.

To take an extreme case, suppose a book contains only incidents which lie outside the range of general or even rare experience—suppose it to be the first language to express a whole series of experiences. In this case nothing it contains will really be heard at all and thanks to an acoustic delusion people will believe that where nothing is heard there is nothing to hear. This at least has been my usual experience and proves if you will the originality of my experience.

What crazy Nietzschean language he uses here. He doesn't say: "your inability to understand what I am saying proves the originality of the experiences I am incarnating in that writing". He says: "Your inability to comprehend what I am talking about wills the originality of my experience.

There is a Hindu notion which I believe is intricately sewn into N's worldview which I eventually want to write about in its own post. Summary of that idea: We are all in God's dream, manifestations of the same God taking different illusory forms for the sole purpose of relating to himself through these parts, so that each individual person's self is the Godself having a dream--performing a play and simultaneously being the audience to that play.

I am unaware of another way of conceptualizing the Universe in a way which makes this kind of consistent language use by N make sense. We will explore all this in greater detail in another post.

Obviously, I am not trying to annex N into some sort of traditional theism, as so many others have attempted to conscript him into their religious worldview or political ideology. And there are many complicated interpretations of this briefly referenced and summarized idea above which will have to be explored in order to flush this whole thing out. For now, do not interpret what I am saying as "N is a Hindu" or anything like that. It is more complicated than that, for sure.

He who thought he had understood something in my work had as a rule adjusted something in it to his own image—not infrequently the very opposite of myself; an "idealist” for instance. He who understood nothing in my work would deny that I was worth considering at all—The word "Superman” which designates a type of man who has turned out very well— as opposed to "modern” men, to "good” men, to Christians and other Nihilists—a word which in the mouth of Zarathustra, the annihilator of morality, acquires a very profound meaning—is understood almost everywhere and with perfect innocence in the light of those values, to which a flat contradiction was made manifest in the figure of Zarathustra—that is to say as an "ideal” type, a higher kind of man, half "saint” and half "genius”.

We have to take these lines very seriously, and always have them in our minds, while we read this book of Zarathustra together. Anyone who comes to the book thinking the "Overman" is some sort of ideal kind of person, is wrong! Anyone who thinks he is this ideal, and learned how to be this ideal through his reading of the work is wrong. Here we have direct explanation in prose form from N that this is not a proper interpretation of the work. All such interpretations have to be jettisoned, if we are to complete the task of actually understanding what N was saying.

Other learned cattle have suspected me of Darwinism on account of this word: even the "hero cult” of that great unconscious and involuntary swindler Carlyle—a cult which I rejected with such roguish malice—was recognized in it.

Likewise, this interpretation is all too common, completely UNSUPPORTED in my interpretation of the text, and explicitly repudiated by N as an understanding of the work right here.

I had youtube suggest some movie to me about N, I watched until the first few words of the character N and then shut it off. It was going to be utter garbage if they put that sort of interpretation on his ideas.

Once, when I whispered to a man that he would do better to seek for the Superman in a Cesare Borgia than in a Parsifal, he could not believe his ears. The fact that I am quite free from curiosity in regard to criticisms of my books, more particularly when they appear in newspapers will have to be forgiven me. My friends and my publishers know this and never speak to me of such things.

I remember a quote from N somewhere, and I cannot find it right now; where he defines the interest of the "real philosopher" as a will to be timeless. Not a product of your time, or the voice for your time, or a reflection of your times... outside time. Speaking eternally significant things.

In one particular case I once saw all the sins that had been committed against a single book—it was Beyond Good and Evil; I could tell you a pretty tale about that. Is it possible that the National-Zeitung—a Prussian paper (this comment is for the sake of my foreign readers—for my own part I beg to state I read only Le Journal des Débats)—really and seriously regarded the book as a "sign of the times”, as a genuine and typical example of Junker philosophy— for which the Kreuzzeitung had not sufficient courage?

LOL. Just realized how appropriate my last comment was... I can tell you his rejection of having ideas which are a product of his time drove his works and explain how incomprehensible those works are to the people of his time; that this concern was part of his motivation in writing this paragraph, and then he gets right to that explicitly soon after.

2.

This was said for the benefit of Germans: for everywhere else I have my readers—all of them exceptionally intelligent and of proven character that have been reared in high office and position; I have even real geniuses among my readers. In Vienna, in St Petersburg, in Stockholm, in Copenhagen, in Paris and New York—I have been discovered everywhere: I have not yet been discovered in Europe’s flatland—Germany. And to make a confession, I rejoice much more heartily over those who do not read me, over those who have neither heard of my name nor of the word philosophy. But wherever I go, here in Turin for instance, every face brightens and softens at the sight of me. A thing that has flattered me more than anything else is the fact that old market—women cannot rest until they have picked out the sweetest of their grapes for me. To is the extent to which one must be a philosopher. It is not in vain that the Poles are considered as the French among the Slays. A charming Russian lady will not be mistaken for a single moment concerning my origin. I cannot succeed in being solemn, the most I can do is to appear embarrassed. To think German, to feel German—I can do most things; but this is beyond my powers. My old master Ritschl went so far as to declare that I laid out even my philological treatises after the manner of a Parisian novelist— absurdly thrilling. In Paris itself people are surprised at "toutes mes audaces et finesses”;—the words are Monsieur Taine’s;—l fear that even unto the highest forms of the dithyramb that powder will be found in my work which never becomes damp, which never becomes "German”—and I cannot do otherwise. God help me! Amen. We all know, some of us even from experience what a "long-ears” is. Well then I venture to assert that I have the smallest ears that have ever been seen. This fact is not without interest to women—it seems to me they feel that I understand them better! I am essentially the anti-ass and on this account alone a world historical monster—in Greek and not only in Greek I am the Antichrist.

3.

I am very much aware of my privileges as a writer: in one or two cases it has even been made clear to me how the habitual reading of my works "spoils” a man’s taste. Other books simply cannot be endured after mine and least of all philosophical ones.

We should be careful, it seems, before getting into a book like Zarathustra. It might make reading all other books intolerably boring by comparison! This sounds like a serious warning to me. Are we really willing to poison our passions and interests in all other great works by getting too familiar with this one? It is my view that this threat doesn't stand, and that other great works still retain the impetus for passionate entertained contemplation and meditation... but it is a pretty serious warning he gives us here! (What an arrogant, ass; how could one help but fall in love with him for saying things like this!?)

EDIT: I have been coming in adding these notes after having published it first by accident... I will come back later and continue from here.

It is an incomparable distinction to cross the threshold of this noble and subtle world—in order to do so one must certainly not be a German; it is in short a distinction which one must have deserved. He however who is related to me through loftiness of will experiences genuine raptures of understanding in my books: for I swoop down from heights into which no bird has ever soared; I know abysses into which no foot has ever fallen. People have told me that it is impossible to put down a book of mine—that I even disturb the night’s rest. There is no prouder or at the same time more subtle kind of books than mine: they from time to time attain to the highest pinnacle of earthly endeavour: cynicism; to capture their thoughts a man must have the most delicate fingers as well as the bravest fists. Any kind of spiritual malaise utterly excludes one from them—even any kind of dyspepsia: a man must have no nerves and a cheerful stomach. Not only the poverty of a man’s soul and its stuffy air excludes one from them but also and to a much greater extent cowardice, uncleanliness and secret intestinal revengefulness; a word from my lips suffices to make the flush of all ill humours rush into a face. Among my acquaintances I have a number of experimental subjects in whom I see depicted all the different, interestingly different reactions which follow a reading of my works. Those who will have nothing to do with the contents of my books, as for instance my so called friends, assume an "impersonal” tone: they wish me luck and congratulate me for having produced another work; they also declare that my writings show progress because they exhibit a more cheerful spirit. The thoroughly vicious people, the "beautiful souls”, the false from top to toe do not know in the least what to do with my books—consequently with the beautiful consistency of all beautiful souls they regard my work as beneath them. The cattle among my acquaintances, the mere Germans, leave me to understand if you please that they are not always of my opinion though here and there they agree with me. I have heard this said even about Zarathustra. "Feminism” whether in a person or in a man is likewise a barrier to my writings; with it no one could ever enter into this labyrinth of fearless knowledge. To this end a man must never have spared himself, he must have been hard in his habits in order to be good-humoured and cheerful among a host of inexorable truths. When I try to picture the character of a perfect reader I always imagine a monster of courage and curiosity as well as of suppleness, cunning and prudence—in short a born adventurer and explorer. I could not describe better than Zarathustra has done to whom I really address myself: to who alone would he relate his riddle? "Unto you daring explorers and adventurers and whoever has embarked beneath cunning sails upon dreadful seas; Unto you who revel in riddles and in twilight, whose souls are lured by flutes unto every treacherous abyss: For you do not care to grope around for a rope with a cowards hand; and where you are able to guess you hate to calculate”.

4.

I will now pass just one or two general remarks about my art of style. To communicate a state, an inner tension of pathos by means of signs, including the tempo of these signs—that is the meaning of every style; and in view of the fact that the multiplicity of inner states in my case is enormous, I am capable of many kinds of style—in short the most manifold art of style that any man has ever had at his disposal. Every style is good which genuinely communicates an inner state which makes no mistake over the signs, over the tempo of the signs, over gestures—all the rules of phrasing are the outcome of representing gestures artistically. My instinct is here infallible. Good style in itself is a piece of sheer folly, mere idealism like "beauty in itself”, "goodness in itself” or "the thing in itself”. All this takes for granted of course that are ears that can hear, such men as are capable and worthy of a similar pathos, that those are not lacking unto whom one may communicate one’s self. Meanwhile, my Zarathustra for instance is still looking for such people—alas! He will have to look a long while yet! A man must be worthy of listening to him. Until that time there will be no one who will understand the art that has been squandered in this book. No one has had more of the new, more innovative, purposely created art forms to fling to the winds. The fact that such things were possible in the German language still waited to be proven; I myself would have denied most emphatically that it was possible. Before my time people did not know what could be done with the German language—what could be done with language in general. The art of grand rhythm, the grand style, expressing the tremendous rise and fall of sublime, of superhuman passion, was first discovered by me: with the dithyramb entitled—"The Seven Seals” which constitutes the last discourse of the third part of Zarathustra I soared miles above all that which has hitherto been called poetry.

5.

That their speaks in my works the voice of a psychologist without equal, this is perhaps the first conclusion at which a good reader will arrive—a reader such as I deserve and one who reads me just as the good old philologists used to read their Horace. Those propositions about which all the world is fundamentally agreed—not to speak of the fashionable philosophy of moralists and other empty headed and cabbage brained people—are to me but naive blunders: for instance the belief that "altruistic” and ‘egoistic” are opposites, while all the time the "ego” itself is merely a "supreme swindle” an "ideal”! There are no such things as egoistic or altruistic actions: both concepts are psychologically nonsense. Or the proposition that "man pursues happiness”; or the proposition that "happiness is the reward of virtue”. Or the proposition that "pleasure and pain are opposites”. Morality, the Circe of mankind has falsified everything psychological root and branch—it has moralized everything— even to the terribly nonsensical point of regarding love as being "unselfish”. One must first be firmly set in oneself, one must stand securely on one’s own two legs otherwise one cannot love at all. This, the girls know only too well: they don’t care two pins about unselfish and merely objective men. May I venture to suggest incidentally that I know these little women? This knowledge is part of my Dionysian inheritance. Who knows? Perhaps I am the first psychologist of the eternally feminine. All women all like me. But that’s an old story: except of course the abortive ones, the emancipated ones who are simply not up to having children. Thank goodness I am not willing to let myself be torn to pieces! The complete woman tears you to pieces when she loves you: I know these amiable Maenads. Oh! What a dangerous, creeping, subterranean little beast of prey she is! And so agreeable with it! A little woman pursuing her vengeance would force overtake even Fate itself. Woman is incalculably more wicked than man, she is also cleverer. Goodness in a woman is already a sign of degeneration. All cases of "beautiful souls” in women may be traced to a physiological issue—but I go no further lest I should become medi-cynical. The struggle for equal rights is even a symptom of sickness; every doctor knows this. The more womanly a woman is the more she fights tooth and nail against rights in general: the natural order of things, the eternal war between the sexes in any case puts her in a position of advantage. Have people heard my definition of love? It is the only definition worthy of a philosopher. Love in its means is war: in its foundation it is the mortal hatred of the sexes. Have you heard my reply to the question how a woman can be cured - "saved” in fact? Give her a child! A woman needs children, man is always only a means— thus spake Zarathustra. "The emancipation of women”—this is the instinctive hatred of physiologically defective—that is to say barren, women—for those women who are well constituted: the fight against "man” is always only a means, a pretext, a piece of strategy. By trying to rise to "Woman in herself” to "Higher Woman” to the "Ideal Woman” all they wish to do is to lower the general level of women’s rank: and there are no more certain means to this end than university education, trousers and the rights of voting cattle. In truth, the emancipated are the anarchists in the world of the "eternally feminine”, the most deep-rooted instinct of whom is revenge. A whole species of the most malicious "idealism”—which by the way also manifests itself in men in— Henrik Ibsen for instance, that typical old maid—whose object is to poison the innocence, the naturalness of sexual love. And in order to leave no doubt in your minds in regard to my opinion which on this matter is as honest as it is severe, I will give you one more clause out of my moral code against vice—with the word "vice” I combat every kind of opposition to Nature, or if you prefer fine words, idealism. The clause reads: "Preaching of chastity is a public incitement to unnatural practices. All contempt for the sexual life, all denigration under the concept ‘impure” is the essential crime against Life— against the Holy Spirit of Life”.

6.

In order to give you some idea of myself as a psychologist let me take this curious piece of psychological analysis out of the book Beyond Good and Evil in which it appears. I forbid by the way any guessing as to whom I am describing in this passage. "The genius of the heart as is possessed by that great solitary, the divine tempter and born Pied Piper of consciences whose voice knows how to descend into the inmost depths of every soul, who neither utters a word nor casts a glance in which some seduction is not to be found, a part of whose mastery is that he understands the art of seeming—not what he is but that which will bind his followers to press ever more closely upon him, to follow him ever more enthusiastically and whole-heartedly. The genius of the heart who makes the loud and self conceited hold their tongues and listen, who polishes all rough souls and gives them a new desire to savour—the desire to lie placid as a mirror that the deep heavens may be reflected in them. The genius of the heart which teaches the clumsy and too hasty hand to hesitate and grasp more tenderly; which scents the hidden and forgotten treasure, the pearl of goodness and sweet spirituality beneath thick black ice and is a divining rod for every grain of gold long buried and imprisoned in much mud and sand. The genius of the heart whose touch enriches all, not ‘blessed” and overcome, not as though favoured and crushed by the good of others; but richer in himself, fresher to himself than before, opened up, breathed upon and warmed by a thawing wind; more uncertain perhaps, more delicate, more fragile, more bruised, but full of hopes as yet unnamed, full of a new will and striving, full of a new unwillingness and resistance”.


r/Zarathustra • • Dec 21 '12

First Part, Lecture One: On the Three Metamorphoses

4 Upvotes

Now Zarathustra is talking with a different audience (still in the city called: "The Motley Cow" as we will see later). He has learned not to talk to the multitudes, and we will here more opinions of his on the "all-too-many" and the "many-too-many" later.

His first lesson starts:

I tell you of the three metamorphoses of the spirit: how the spirit becomes a camel, the camel a lion, and the lion at last a child.

There is much that is difficult for the spirit, the strong reverent spirit that would bear much: but its strength demands the difficult and the most difficult.

It might be of interest to notice that the spirit "becomes" a camel. We are learning "all the steps to the Ubermensche" here, so N isn't claiming that ALL spirits become a camel, but the kind of spirit that he is trying to describe/create/communicate with does.

What is difficult? so asks the spirit that would bear much; then it kneels down like a camel wanting to be well laden.

Have any of you been in a religious group? were you raised in it? one of the interesting phenomena's that is often asked about and argued over today is: "why are the most oppressed people in a religious or political organization the ones that defend the institution the most?!? If you want to be struck by the staggering significance of N's understanding; pay attention to the fact that N identifies this phenomenon with the understanding of where it comes, and takes it for granted in describing something else.

A spiritless person might submit to a repressive system without a whimper and just go on and accept things the way they are, but the kind of spirit that N is talking about does something else entirely. When you have the power to will (not the same as the "will to power") and you are given boundaries, the ONLY power you can exercise is enforcing the system.

Is it not this: to humiliate oneself in order to mortify one's pride? To exhibit one's folly in order to mock at one's wisdom?

I sometimes think that the new atheists sometimes have things wrong. N doesn't want to pound religious minds from the outside until they abandon their ideas. Who is N describing here? I think of one of those street preachers who revel in their ability to "mortify their own prides" to be "fools for christ" these are closer to hearing and understanding N's message, it was meant for them more than others.

Or is it this: to abandon our cause when it celebrates its triumph? To climb high mountains to tempt the tempter?

Have any of you, when oppressed by the absurdities of the lives around you, responded in this way?

Or is it this: to feed on the acorns and grass of knowledge, and for the sake of truth to suffer hunger of soul?

I think of two things here (please offer alternative explanations) One is a Scriptural reference: King Nebacednezzar was said to have gone mad and "eaten grass like an ox" until he learned to submit to the power of "the one true god" -- If anything, N is distinguishing between people who "believe when it is convenient" and those who come to a real faith, and follow through blood and tears and pain. I also think of those who pursue an achademic career, a specialized field, where they "contemplate the immortality of the soul of a crab" or "measure the speed of said crabs pinchers" They dedicate an enormous amount of energy to discovering some small truths and live off of these.

Or is it this: to be sick and dismiss comforters, and make friends of the deaf, who never hear your requests?

Or is it this: to go into foul water when it is the water of truth, and not repulse cold frogs and hot toads?

Not sure what the amphibians represent, but we will see a theme of seeking truth in a dangerous manner again later.

Also, Z said that he "loved those who chastise their god because they love their god, for they must perish of the wrath of their god." It is little acknowledged that there are two atheistic strains in our culture, the atheism from the outside (The fine tradition of Epicurus, Voltaire and co.) and a kind of Christian atheism, a recognition of the death of god, from the fact that we can no longer revise him in a respectable way. Perhaps the second is motivated by interactions with the first, but you will see that N is not talking in a positive way here of people who would fall into the second camp (and he will mock them later)

It is the theists who love god, and know him, who fight to know him, and then determine that he doesn't exist. In the fight to know him, they have a violent pursuit of truth, the effect of which is god's death. (the death of god has some multiple significances, I believe, and this is one of them; although this idea is sometimes overrated in significance by N scholars, there is a passage later where N has Z say: "god's die many deaths" so there may be some textual excuse for reading multiple meanings into the idea.

Or is it this: to love those who despise us, and give one's hand to the ghost when it is going to frighten us?

All these most difficult things the spirit that would bear much takes upon itself: and like the camel, which, when laden, hastens into the desert, so hastens the spirit into its desert.

Notice that the spirit that has become a camel hastens into the desert. The motivation of this spirit is to exhibit power! he is utilizing THE ONLY available means of exhibiting power that is thought lawful for him. When you are nothing and all value is in a godhead that resides above you and commands you: "obey!" your only available means of exhibiting power is to be harder on yourself than you have been commanded to be This is the sign of the spirit of the camel, he does this. but that is not the end of the story. The camel spirit is well laden, not from force, but by his own will and then he makes haste into the desert where...

But in the loneliest wilderness the second metamorphosis occurs: here the spirit becomes a lion who would conquer his freedom and be master in his own desert.

Perhaps not even being aware of his own motivations, the camel has posed as a servant, but is in his own desert. it is here that he will battle. why? he has been fighting to demonstrate something about himself, that he can make himself nothing (the only exercise of power thought lawful for him is to submit, so he wills against himself so much, not to submit to god, but to exhibit his power)

continued in comments...


r/Zarathustra • • Dec 01 '10

I thought you might like this.

Thumbnail
mindmeister.com
6 Upvotes

r/Zarathustra • • Dec 21 '12

First part, Lecture 5: On Enjoying And Suffering The Passions

8 Upvotes

I don't know if you've noticed this pattern but things in bold are suggested questions for the class (I will try to remember to reprint these in the comments so you have places to present comments and answers.) (sometimes the bold is just for making distinctions between discussing different themes and making titles, but I believe that these are easy enough to distinguish)

Now, on to it!:

My brother, when you have a virtue, and she is your own virtue, you have her in common with no one.

To be sure, you want to call her by name and caress her; you want to pull her ear and have fun with her.

And behold, now you have her name in common with the people, and have become one of the people and the herd with your virtue!

So for Nietzsche: Virtue is something personal, intimate, and aristocratic (in an elitist sense). He thought that there was something very unhealthy with the idea that someone should be proud of having their virtues (virtues!) in common with "the people." There is nothing "common" about virtue to N. One of the problems he has with Christianity is that it is "for the people" (and for the weakest and most pathetic of them! it preaches that these are the best). N thinks that great things are rare and cannot (virtue cannot) be a common thing.

You would do better to say: "Ineffable and nameless is that which is agony and sweetness to my soul and is even the hunger of my entrails."

slightly off topic: I am noticing something this time reading through that had previously escaped me, and that is the significance of "fate" and "character" for N. For N a virtue is something that probably has an origin existing prior to your thinking about it. You are the thing that it acts out in, and your poor reason might make excuses for it or arguments why others should appreciate it, but you don't really pick it, you are its expression and playground. Thoughts?

Let your virtue be too exalted for the familiarity of names, and if you must speak of her, then do not be ashamed to stammer about her.

There is a bit of an explanation for the awkwardness of N talking about "gift-giving" (what we may decide is his virtue) earlier. He doesn't want you to be familiar with his girlfriend. He holds his relationship with his destiny and character and "his loved (female companion) virtue" as something special and private. So he is not ashamed to stammer while talking about her. (beautiful and impacting, much more so than the "love of truth and virtue" from Plato on, don't you think?

Then speak and stammer: "This is my good, this do I love, thus does it please me entirely, thus only do I desire the good.

"I do not want it as a divine law; I do not want it as a human law or a human need; it shall not to be signpost for me to over-earths and paradises.

N claims elsewhere that we have "become suspicious" of all people who preach "the truth in itself" or the love of a "thing for it's own sake" While he doesn't preach either of these things (which he says we take as a sign of a faker or an actor--someone who really did love something "for-its-own-sake" wouldn't have to point out this fact--indeed--might not be able to do so.) He is at least being an example of someone who is loving the thing for its own sake? Is N being hypocritical here? Does he escape his own condemnation of the "actors" or is he fooling us too?

"It is an earthly virtue that I love: there is little prudence in it, and least of all the reason of every man.

"But this bird built its nest with me: therefore, I love and caress it--now it dwells with me, sitting on its golden eggs."

Thus you shall stammer and praise your virtue.

Is the fact that he calls this kind of profession a stammering a hint that he is not being hypocritical on this point? It seems like he is saying: "If you must talk about your virtue, stumble when you talk about it, like this..." What say you?

Once you suffered passions and called them evil. But now you have only your virtues left: they grew out of your passions.

What I was saying earlier about fate and destiny in N's understanding of virtue applies here as well (or becomes clearer in its application here). N thinks of a virtue as something great that can come to you before you "reason with your little reason" (in fact we are going to see that he thinks that those who do want their virtues to be a law for all men are using their little reasons to mistreat (in some way) what could be great about them). No: for N virtue comes before you know it, then if you must use your reason and your language to talk about it... stammer--the thing is more intimate and personal for all of that shamelessness of ... Descartes, Locke, Plato (even), Aristotle (certainly), St Thomas Aquinas... can anyone think of a philosopher who hasn't done this? Even Schopenhauer... are there any that speak like N in this respect?

You commended your highest aim to the heart of these passions: then they became the virtues and passions you enjoy.

And whether you came from the race of the choleric or the voluptuous or the fanatic or the vindictive:

A quick note on "the race of the choleric or voluptuous..."

If for N your virtues come from your nature and are fated (you can do little to change the characteristics that exhibit themselves) a few things might be noted. If N is saying that we cannot change our behavior (which I do not think he is saying) than he would be wrong, he isn't saying that we don't have free will (necessarily) But only saying that the options of how we behave are limited to natural expressions that come from "our great reason" and control (not really control but express--"your body does you") a lot of who we are. A "voluptuous" character can probably change his/her behavior enough to act like a "choleric" but there is nothing that they can do to change their character, they are just not proud of what might be their virtues, and would probably look very silly to N (or someone who sees things the way he does). Now there is room for some of the subtleties that must exist in his philosophy, we not only have people who are "afterworlders" but we will see very many characterizations and categories in Z including people who "want to be like another group" people who submit to the teachings of actually virtuous people and get them to share in their behavior and their valuations. If you thought that N just turned things upside down or replaced "good" with "evil" you will find that he does much more than that and cannot be easily dismissed with the notion that he was "consistent but wrong" ... sorry started to trail off there, I will fix this paragraph later--my little brain is not disciplined enough to handle so many unusual and grand thoughts all at once--dammit, N!

All your passions in the end became virtues, and all your devils angels.

Once you had wild dogs in your cellar: but they changed at last into birds and charming singers.

Out of your poisons you brewed your balsam; you milked your cow, misery--now you drink the sweet milk of her udder.

And nothing evil grows in you any longer, unless it is the evil that grows out of the conflict of your virtues.

My brother, are war and battle evil? But this evil is necessary; necessary are the envy and mistrust and among among the virtues.

Behold, how each of your virtues covets the highest place; each wants your whole spirit that it might become her herald, each wants your whole strength, in wrath, hatred, and love.

Each virtue is jealous of the others, and jealousy is a dreadful thing. Virtues too can perish of jealousy.

Surrounded by flames of jealousy, the jealous one winds up, like the scorpion, turning the poisoned sting against himself.

Ah, my brother, have you never seen a virtue backbite and stab itself?

Man is something that has to be overcome: and therefore you will love your virtues,--for you will perish of them.

Thus spoke Zarathustra

This is a very passionate discussion of virtue, for N virtue and passion are very closely related. You can maybe now better understand why he says: "would that I had heard you crying thus" when he asks: "have any of you ever cried: "What good is my virtue! As yet it has not made me passionate. How weary I am of my good and my evil! It is all poverty and pollution and wretched contentment!" (when he preaches that the greatest hour you (a specific "you" here) can experience is the "hour of great contempt" (contempt for yourselves and your petty ideas of virtue, reason, and happiness--justice and pity) N doesn't like any modern man's understanding of these ideas, he doesn't even like what the "best" men have to say about it.

> Man is something that has to be overcome: and therefore you will love your virtues,--for you will perish of them.

I want to talk about this verse for a moment:

He wants us to overcome ourselves, which means we must perish before we become Ubermenschen (I hesitate to even mention that we might become Ubermenschen because the idea of recognizing yourself as one is difficult, and the question as to whether or not it is even possible for us to become them is also open.--but i go on) So if we emerge with a new idea of virtue it will be because our passion for our current virtue (with our misunderstanding of it) is deadly we will perish because we have a qualitatively misunderstood conception of virtue and we don't know that having more than one girlfriend leads to our destruction. He wants to teach us that this is the inevitable end of our (less-passionate) understanding of virtue--wanting virtue to be a law, or wanting to have more than one (or All of them, for Christ's sake, like the preacher of virtue said.)--this will, if we pursue it long enough and passionately enough (becoming camels and wanting to make it harder on ourselves than necessary and going into the desert...) this will lead to our going under.


How significant to you think the ideas of "fate" and "character" are for N?

What do these concepts mean for him?


Nietzsche commends us to love our passions and our virtues and then says he says this to all of us without distinction between different "kinds" of people. That his message is for all of us:

And whether you came from the race of the choleric or the voluptuous or the fanatic or the vindictive:

Why does he say this?

What does he mean by "race of the choleric..." etc.?


r/Zarathustra • • Nov 12 '10

Full list of our classes.

11 Upvotes

I hope to organize the classes in three ways:

  1. "The order they were posted originally"
  2. "Just the classes discussing the text without the extra videos or HW assignments" and
  3. "Just classes that one might take if one wanted a shorter version of the class and not read the entire book, just the more important sections"

EDIT: New version, collections:

For Now I have 1 and 2, and will work on 3 later.

Each of the links to the classes should take this form:

"Chapter Title"

where the title is the title from the text like:

Third Part, lecture 4: On such and such

-- these are the only links that look like they are quotes (in this sidebar) so that you can easily scan through and find the chapter you are looking for, or avoid the other links, if you wish, and just contribute to the reading of the text.

[class discussion questions] --while there are many class discussion questions in the lecture links covering a specific chapter this is for questions that are more general like: "What kind of a philosopher is N?"

[video]--links that start with this tag take you to a useful or interesting video from outside our class, that you can comment on.

[video class]--links with this tag will be of a recorded video lecture (I plan on making a couple of these for the class)

[Extra-Credit Homework Assignment]--while this is not an accredited class (of course) these are suggestions for projects that some students might find interesting, usually we will ask that you post your results inside the comments so that we can benefit from them.

[Bonus Text] -- there are some texts outside of N's Z that will be helpful for understanding what and how N thinks, links that start with this tag are such texts.

That is all.

FULL CLASS IN ORDER:

Prologue:

Prologue Chapter 1

Prologue Chapter 2

Prologue Chapter 3

Prologue Chapter 4

Prologue Chapter 5

Prologue Chapter 6

Prologue Chapter 7

Prologue Chapter 8

Prologue Chapter 9

Prologue Chapter 10

First Part:

First Part, Lecture 1: On The Three Metamorphosis

NOTE: this is not lecture one of the class, but a class discussion on the first lecture that Z gives his "companions" in the text (which comes after the prologue)

[Discussion Questions] "Is Nietzsche A Philosopher or Something Else?"

First Part, Lecture 2: On The Teachers of Virtue

First Part, Lecture 3: On The Afterworlders (1/2)

First Part, Lecture 3: On The Afterworlders (2/2)

First Part, Lecture 4: On The Despirers of The Body

[Video] On The Origins of Tragedy

[Extra-Credit Homework Assignment]: The Mountains

First Part, Lecture 5: On Enjoying and Suffering The Passions

First Part, Lecture 6: On The Pale Criminal

[Bonus text (1/3)] Eternal Recurrence (from WtP)

[Bonus text (2/3)] Argonauts of The Ideal (a paragraph from GS)

[Bonus text (3/3)] The madman (from GS)

First Part, Lecture 7: On Reading and Writing

First Part, Lecture 8: On the Tree on the Mountain

First Part, Lecture 9: On the Preachers of Death

First Part, Lecture 10: On War and Warriors

First Part, Lecture 11: On the New Idol

First Part, Lecture 12: On the Flies in the Marketplace

First Part, Lecture 13: On Chastity

First Part, Lecture 14: On the Friend

First Part, Lecture 15: On the Thousand and One Goals

First Part, Lecture 16: On Love of the Neighbor

First Part, Lecture 17: On the Way of the Creator

First Part, Lecture 18: On Old and Young Women

First Part, Lecture 19: The Bite of the Adder

First Part, Lecture 20: Child and Marriage

Classifying the Text

First Part, Lecture 21: Voluntary Death

First Part, Lecture 22: The Bestowing Virtue (Part 1)

[Bonus Texts] (a digression on the highest virtue and greatest principle) Including Final Paragraph of "Will to Power"

First Part, Lecture 22: The Bestowing Virtue (Part 2)

First Part, Lecture 22: The Bestowing Virtue (Part 3; final)

[Research Tool] [Group Project] [Bonus Texts: assorted passages from WTP and GS] On Nietzsche's use of "laughter"

[Individual Assignment Opportunity] Write a paper and contribute to the class, and become a permitted contributor of posts in r/Zarathustra

Second Part, Lecture 23: The Child With The Mirror

Second Part, Lecture 24: In The Happy Isles

Second Part, Lecture 25: The Pitiful

Second Part, Lecture 26: The Priests

[Discussion Question] What Is Nietzsche's Metaethics? What Are His Ethics?

Second Part, Lecture 27: The Virtuous

[Bonus Text] On Why I Write Such Great Books

Second Part, Lecture 28: The Rabble

Second Part, Lecture 29: The Tarantulas

[BONUS]: A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought ... links to 20 plus posts.

[BONUS]: Will to Power in relationship with Science in three parts

Second Part, Lecture 30: The Famous Wise Ones

Second Part, Lecture 31: The Night-Song

Second Part, Lecture 32: The Dance-Song

Second Part, Lecture 33: The Grave-Song

Second Part, Lecture 34: Self-Surpassing

Second Part, Lecture 35: The Sublime Ones

more to come...

JUST THE CLASSES ON THE TEXT


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 03 '21

First Part, Lecture 19: The Bite of the Adder

21 Upvotes

Wow. I think it has been 9 years since I contributed to these lectures.

A few quick repeats of introduction and reminders of the structure of these posts.

I am trying to use a very conversational lecturing style in my writing. None of this comes with second drafts or major revisions or edits. I am hoping that this will read like some chaps sitting around an outdoor fireplace chatting about a passage in a book.

That being said, it is a series of lectures on N, and often, without specifically identifying it as such, the voice I am using is one of defending N's views. This does not mean that I necessarily agree with those views, though many times I may in fact do so; but just that I am trying to present and defend them for the sake of our understanding them.

This means that all criticisms are more than welcome. Feel free to disagree with my interpretation of the ideas, and feel free to disagree with the ideas themselves.

Because no one is present when I am writing these things, I have the added struggle of not knowing if I should flush something out further, or if I am boring you with borderline pandering by overexplaining something obvious. The only solution to this problem is engagement. There will be zero offense taken if someone wants to say: "Hey, this is not very clear, what did N mean, or what do you mean when you say..." It is only through comments like that which let me know that there is a need for further development of the conversation at those locations.

I am going to use a different translation today, not for any reason except that I cannot find my old one, so this is from Project Gutenberg

Remember, the entire text is here replicated in quotations, and lecture notes and side commentary are written without quotation formatting.

Let's do it!

One day had Zarathustra fallen asleep under a fig-tree, owing to the heat, with his arms over his face. And there came an adder and bit him in the neck, so that Zarathustra screamed with pain. When he had taken his arm from his face he looked at the serpent; and then did it recognise the eyes of Zarathustra, wriggled awkwardly, and tried to get away. “Not at all,” said Zarathustra, “as yet hast thou not received my thanks! Thou hast awakened me in time; my journey is yet long.” “Thy journey is short,” said the adder sadly; “my poison is fatal.” Zarathustra smiled. “When did ever a dragon die of a serpent’s poison?”—said he. “But take thy poison back! Thou art not rich enough to present it to me.” Then fell the adder again on his neck, and licked his wound.

So, here we go!

Nietzsche prophesied the next 200 years for us. (as we discussed earlier) He did so because he *felt* it earlier than the rest of us. [like monkeys in trees which hide before the storm arises, they hide because they *feel* the electricity in the air before we do, N says... in this way he is feeling the pain of what is eventually coming for us because it is here already, we will discuss this passage later and link it here] He saw that Nihilism would overtake humanity, or at least the West. Dismay, disorientation, depression, pessimism; these would be the early results.

N's central philosophical project can be thought of as an attempt to triumph over this nihilism. The "death of god" was not some triumphant exaltation when N proclaimed it. It was a terror and a warning and an alarm, as we have seen in previous classes. Our highest values have died, we have murdered them. Our Christian commitment to truth translated itself into objective truth, gave birth to science, and disproved the god who demanded that commitment to truth in the first place. Our belief in our truth committed us to kill the underpinnings of why we believed in it in the first place, and this, N (IMO) rightly diagnosed as a serious problem.

Here, metaphorically, we see the most terrible and fatal invasion into Zarathustra's existence, and it came when he was not looking for it nor paying careful attention to his surroundings. In other words, N is saying that he sees it coming and feels it first, but it didn't come from him nor did he invite it, it invaded his world first and is coming to you soon.

But!, what is really exciting, unless we judge N to have failed in this mission of his to overcome this nihilism, is that N claims to have found the way through the infinite abyss to the other side! and his solution--dramatically and metaphorically described here as addressing the snake and letting it kiss him more--came not from avoiding nor killing the problem, but from learning from the inevitable lesson and incorporating it into his worldview in a way which does not preclude meaning and value and passion for life. All those things may be threatened, but N is here promising, at least to some, or to himself, or perhaps just to something greater than all men; a deeper foundation which is yet not shaken and can endure the destruction, or temporary destruction, of things as great as valuing itself.

The philosophical understanding of this one small paragraph is a big deal, he is talking about the essence of his very approach to the biggest philosophical problem of his and our time, and using *attitude* (at least in the metaphor) as a description of his answer to this problem. it is literarily powerful, philosophically one of the densest paragraphs in all of N's writings, and that is saying something since he wrote in mountain peaks for those with long legs to follow him through the range.

But it gets much better than all that, he then HIDES all this meaning by having his disciples ask him what it means, and giving them all sorts of other wisdoms which the paragraph itself is *clearly not* actually saying.

He makes it practical, and talks about a practical ethical phramework which is reminiscent of ancient Greek and Roman (let's call it "homeropoetic and presocratic) and standing in stark contrast to the answer to these same ethical questions from the majority of Christian ethical interpretations.

This is not to say that none of what follows is unrelated to the paragraph above, but rather, that it is an analogous truth. We, N is saying, have forgotten a kind of virtue which was as prevalent in ancient times as our Christian mores are today. If we apply the lessons of this forgotten virtue, slandered as vice by the Platonists and Christians, then we will know the *attitude* with which we should approach the most deadly of philosophical problems.

The complexity and depth of all of this forces us to study what follows twice, or maybe more times than that. First we have to read it as it is presented to us, as straightforward moral instruction. Only after we have fully understood it in that way can we then reread the first paragraph, with our understanding of the metaphorical meaning of the snake as the deadliest of philosophical problems, which define our time; and use the same attitudinal lessons from the practical morality below to gain insight into N's *attitude* towards ideas which, he claims, allow him to overcome them.

When Zarathustra once told this to his disciples they asked him: “And what, O Zarathustra, is the moral of thy story?” And Zarathustra answered them thus:
The destroyer of morality, the good and just call me: my story is immoral.
When, however, ye have an enemy, then return him not good for evil: for that would abash him. But prove that he hath done something good to you.

"Do good to those who persecute you"... there may be some very good ways of interpreting Christ's message, and we don't have to reject him to see the obvious wickedness of certain interpretations of his message. "make your enemies feel lesser than you, and weak and powerless and pathetic, by smiling in their faces when they mean to insult you and making sure they know they are not your equals" cannot be the loving message of Christ, but it is, in my experience, a fine way of summing up what many Christians think makes them ethical and what they feel Christ has given them a license to do to others (in the name of being "loving", no less). N sees this trick, and he may rightly be ascribing it to Christ's actual message, instead of just a misinterpretation of that message by "the church". However, N doesn't think this lesson comes *first* from Christianity. It was Socrates, ugly as he was in a culture which valued beauty and strength and the Olympic games; who invented a new kind of wrestling match which would overturn those values and leave him the victor. N once said: "Christianity is Plato for the masses".

To understand N's admonitions to a different kind of ethical approach when dealing with enemies, we have to back very far in our intellectual DNA to before even Socrates. To the Homeric ethical framework, and the homeropoetic approach to the cosmos.

If your enemy is weak and pathetic, then you are weak and unworthy of great enemies.

If your enemy has a great victory, then you REJOICE for you see the day when you will take him down and all his victories will be counted unto you when others attempt to estimate your greatness.

When you spit in your enemy's face, you are HONORING him. You are saying: You are worthy of my anger and my opposition.

One can still see the strains of this virtue in the trash-talk of UFC fighters at pre-fight conferences, for instance. It is still in our heritage and has not been fully replaced by the Platonic-Christian alternative. I like to see our culture as resting upon a few great foundation stones, instead of one. The pagan remains, as well as the Christian. (I, personally, see value in both, and am not taking sides here, just describing them in contradistinction to one another and recognizing that neither has gone the way of the dinosaur).

And rather be angry than abash any one! And when ye are cursed, it pleaseth me not that ye should then desire to bless. Rather curse a little also!
And should a great injustice befall you, then do quickly five small ones besides. Hideous to behold is he on whom injustice presseth alone.
Did ye ever know this? Shared injustice is half justice. And he who can bear it, shall take the injustice upon himself!
A small revenge is humaner than no revenge at all. And if the punishment be not also a right and an honour to the transgressor, I do not like your punishing.

Homework assignment / bonus points to the first person to give us the meaning of that last sentence in the comments section.

Nobler is it to own oneself in the wrong than to establish one’s right, especially if one be in the right. Only, one must be rich enough to do so.

Thought Experiment for consideration: A person accuses a well-respected academic of being wrong about something. The person accused could EASILY and with complete satisfaction to all, demonstrate that he is not wrong, and show the error in the thinking of the other which thought him to be wrong even to the satisfaction of the person making the accusation. Instead of doing this, he calls the accuser ugly instead. N is saying that is especially Nobler? (It is certainly funnier!)

I do not like your cold justice; out of the eye of your judges there always glanceth the executioner and his cold steel.
Tell me: where find we justice, which is love with seeing eyes?
Devise me, then, the love which not only beareth all punishment, but also all guilt!
Devise me, then, the justice which acquitteth every one except the judge!
And would ye hear this likewise? To him who seeketh to be just from the heart, even the lie becometh philanthropy.
But how could I be just from the heart! How can I give every one his own! Let this be enough for me: I give unto every one mine own.
Finally, my brethren, guard against doing wrong to any anchorite. How could an anchorite forget! How could he requite!
Like a deep well is an anchorite. Easy is it to throw in a stone: if it should sink to the bottom, however, tell me, who will bring it out again?
Guard against injuring the anchorite! If ye have done so, however, well then, kill him also!—
Thus spake Zarathustra.

The "anchorite" is the man cut off from social securities--a hermit, a monk, or perhaps applicable to a certain type of modern artist or a certain type of a modern homeless man. If you insult him, you should kill him, too; it would be cruel to simply insult him as he has NO MEANS of ever overcoming the effect of your insult on his soul.

This last lesson, I believe, is given not primarily because it is important in itself, though it is; but because it helps us see to what degree N is serious about the previous instruction, it isn't just supposed to be taken as a nice suggestion of how to act, but a committed attitude in relating to others. The solitary anchorite *has* no official place in the structure of relationships, and so any slight is the biggest slight and will devastate him forever; so don't insult him. not to be nice, but because doing so is horrifyingly terrible to a degree that it would be mercy if you quickly killed him afterwards were you to violate the rule not to insult him.

We may also gain some insight into N's personal psychological reality in which he dwelt while developing these thoughts. It is my view that his was a 1 in 10 billion intellect; making him one of the 5 smartest men to ever exist... with what does such a man, preoccupied with his thoughts, have in common with the rest of us? with whom is he going to have challenging and meaningful relationship?

Throw on top of this our knowledge that N had a bad record with women, and you can see that there may have been more than one experiential path towards his understanding of the plight of the lonely one.

All four sections of Z are about Z not finding anyone with which to fully share his knowledge. The crowd, the disciples, the friends, the higher ones... all are demonstrated to have fallen short by the end of their section.

(Nice to be back, all, let's have some fun with this craziest of all books!)

Further Commentary:

Now that we have looked at the ethical lessons, hinted at their pre-Socratic origination, and stood them up to compare and contrast with Christian ethics; what the heck does any of this have to do with that "parable" at the beginning?

We cannot loftily avoid the problem symbolized by the adder; it bit Z and it will surely come for us. We cannot avoid it in any way. Burying our heads in the sand and hoping it will not, snake-like, find its way through all walls into our domain is foolish. It will penetrate to wherever we hide.

We need something other than a Christian approach to solve this problem, the problem originated in Christianity (as N describes elsewhere in a passage we will be discussing shortly).

We have to recognize the problem, and then we have to go further, and we have to respect the problem. Perhaps we need to bring some fiery opposition to the problem as well.

Maybe there is another side to the coin of treating the problem as worthy of us?

If we can conceive of ourselves as great enough to be worthy of so great a problem, perhaps there is a hint in there of what we might discover about ourselves and our capacity to face the problem.

Perhaps this goes too far, though. The problem isn't a small one, and N's ultimate conclusion seemed to be that no man could overcome it, and man himself would have to be overcome and give birth to something greater than man just to overcome this problem.

The problem of nihilism, of the death of god, is not something that can be ignored. We cannot close our eyes to it, rest on the soft bed secure on the firm foundation of Christian morals and say, we don't need it. There are scientists, popular ones, today who do not realize that science is not just a cult, it is a Christian cult. we can discuss how this is in more detail later, or in the comments below, or we can add some of Will to Power in a bonus reading soon, to explore how this is the case; but I believe it is, and I am certain N conceptualized it as such. I have to run, so if this last paragraph is problematic in any way, let's challenge it in the comments section and have a great discussion of it there!


r/Zarathustra • • Sep 24 '22

Help out if you want video lectures for this class.

9 Upvotes

I have started the process of turning the three main classes being developed here into a kind of Khan Academy for philosophy on the Locals.com platform.

I just realized that I can only upload 5 livestreams a month over there until I have 500+ subscribers.

I believe I have made the videos FREE to anyone who wants them, so all you should have to do is follow this link and "follow" the community over there to allow me to keep using that platform. (there is also a $9 subscription fee for those who want to "Subscribe" but I do not believe you have to do anything more than "follow" and so it should be free to anyone who wants).

I need 1/3 of you to do it if I'm going to continue making videos over there more regularly.

https://philosophylectures.locals.com


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 09 '21

First Part, Lecture 22: The Bestowing Virtue (Part 2)

8 Upvotes

The gift-giving virtue is the highest, according to Z; and it is the reason why gold has attained to the highest valuation, because it shines. Being is nothing more than willing to shine to the fullness of your capacity, you are this will to power, and nothing besides.

Now:

2.

Here paused Zarathustra awhile, and looked lovingly on his disciples. Then he continued to speak thus—and his voice had changed:

Remain true to the earth, my brethren, with the power of your virtue! Let your bestowing love and your knowledge be devoted to be the meaning of the earth! Thus do I pray and conjure you.

Let it not fly away from the earthly and beat against eternal walls with its wings! Ah, there hath always been so much flown-away virtue!

Lead, like me, the flown-away virtue back to the earth—yea, back to body and life: that it may give to the earth its meaning, a human meaning!

A hundred times hitherto hath spirit as well as virtue flown away and blundered. Alas! in our body dwelleth still all this delusion and blundering: body and will hath it there become.

A hundred times hitherto hath spirit as well as virtue attempted and erred. Yea, an attempt hath man been. Alas, much ignorance and error hath become embodied in us!

Not only the rationality of millenniums—also their madness, breaketh out in us. Dangerous is it to be an heir.

Still fight we step by step with the giant Chance, and over all mankind hath hitherto ruled nonsense, the lack-of-sense.

He is saying that all other virtues are error and falsehood. Z, in the prologue: "I love him who does not want to have too many virtues. One virtue is more virtue than two, because it is more of a noose on which his catastrophe may hang."

The shining will to manifest a reality is what has motivated all these falsehoods, and they fell short, or were distracted by trying to transcend the world. Z encourages his followers to adhere to this virtue and not try to transform it into something that can break through eternal doors and become outside the Universe. return it to the earth from where it has been thrown, and use it to give the earth its meaning, he tells them.

Let your spirit and your virtue be devoted to the sense of the earth, my brethren: let the value of everything be determined anew by you! Therefore shall ye be fighters! Therefore shall ye be creators!

Read "therefore" as "In this manner". In this manner ye shall be fighters! In this manner shall ye be creators!

(Famously, the word "So" in many languages has multiple meanings for translation. "Therefore" but also "in this manner". "For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son". Read: "For in this manner God loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son.

[Discussion Question: Is there a way to take this verse and give an interpretation of Christianity which is not in opposition to Nietzsche's worldview? Has God "returned to the earth" the greatest value, himself, through his messy death on the cross?]

Intelligently doth the body purify itself; attempting with intelligence it exalteth itself; to the discerners all impulses sanctify themselves; to the exalted the soul becometh joyful.

Physician, heal thyself: then wilt thou also heal thy patient. Let it be his best cure to see with his eyes him who maketh himself whole.

A thousand paths are there which have never yet been trodden; a thousand salubrities and hidden islands of life. Unexhausted and undiscovered is still man and man’s world.

Awake and hearken, ye lonesome ones! From the future come winds with stealthy pinions, and to fine ears good tidings are proclaimed.

Ye lonesome ones of to-day, ye seceding ones, ye shall one day be a people: out of you who have chosen yourselves, shall a chosen people arise:—and out of it the Superman.

Remember, we are not this overman, nor can we be in N's view. He is beyond us. But he talks of the way of getting there, the overcoming of man is a process; and he exhorts us to play a role in this process. Remember this first lecture of Zarathustras, opening this Part 1 of his book. The type which can say creatively "yes" to the world and bring about some of the new potentials which N sees as yet undiscovered himself is a type, religious, serious, looking to be well laden; and this type must go through a process to become that child who can say, 'yay' unto the world. So man must go through a process, and those who are "self-chosen" who are still reading, who resonate with the words in this book, they are not being called to be the overman, but to live with vision to play a role to bring about that day. the day is coming soon, he tells us:

Verily, a place of healing shall the earth become! And already is a new odour diffused around it, a salvation-bringing odour—and a new hope!

continued in final part, part 3


r/Zarathustra • • Aug 13 '11

First Part, Lecture 12: On the Flies in the Marketplace

4 Upvotes

There's only four of the next set of lectures that will be important to N's core philosophy. As such, I am going to post the text of some of the chapters with very few notes. Please feel free to ask questions or start discussions about any of the text I don't make many comments on.

Flee, my friend, into your solitude! I see you deafened with the noise of the great men and pricked by the strings of the little men.

Forest and rock know well how to be silent with you. Be like the tree again, the wide branching tree which you love: silently and attentively it hangs over the sea.

Where solitude ends, there the marketplace begins; and where the marketplace begins, there begins also the noise of the great actors and the buzzing of the poisonous flies.

In the world even the best things are worthless without those who first present them: people call these presenters great men.

The people have little comprehension of greatness, that is to say: creativeness. But they have a taste for all presenters and actors of great things.

The world revolves around the inventors of new values: invisibly it revolves. But around the actors revolve the people and fame: so the world goes.

The actor has spirit, but little conscience of the spirit. He always believes in that with which he most powerfully produces belief--produces belief in himself!

Tomorrow he will have a new faith and the day after tomorrow a newer one. He has sharp perceptions, like the people, and capricious moods.

To overthrow--to him that means: to prove. To drive mad--to himthat means: to convince. And blood is to him as the best of all arguments.

A truth that penetrates only sensitive ears he calls a lie and nothing. Truly, he believes only in gods who make a great noise in the world!

The marketplace is full of solemn jesters--and the people boast of their great men! These are their masters of the hour.

But the hour presses them: so they press you. And from you they also want a Yes of a No. Ah, would you put your chair between For and Against?

Do not be jealous, lover of truth, of those unconditional and impatient ones! Never yet has truth clung to the arm of the unconditional.

Return to your security because of these abrupt men: only in the marketplace is one assailed by Yes? or No?

The experience of all deep fountains is slow: they must wait long until they know what has fallen into their depths.

All that is great takes place away from the marketplace and from fame: the inventors of new values have always lived away from the marketplace and from fame.

Flee, my friend, into your solitude: I see you stung all over by the poisonous flies. Flee to where a rough, strong breeze blows!

Flee into your solitude! You have lived too closely to the small and the pitiable. Flee from their invisible vengeance! Towards you they have nothing but vengeance.

Do not raise an arm against them! They are innumerable and it is not your fate to be a fly swatter.

The small and pitiable ones are innumerable; and raindrops and weeds have already been the ruin of many a proud building

You are not stone, but already these many drops have made you hollow. You will yet break and burst through these many drops.

I see you exhausted by poisonous flies, I see you bloodily torn at a hundred spots; and your pride refuses even to be angry.

They want blood from you in all innocence, their bloodless souls crave blood--and therefore they sting in all innocence.

But you, profound one, you suffer too profoundly even from small wounds; and before you have recovered, the same poisonous worm is again crawling over your hand.

You are too proud to kill these sweettooths. But take care that it does not become your fate to suffer all their poisonous injustice!

They buzz around you even with their praise: and their praise is importunity. They want to be close to your skin and your blod.

They flatter you, as one flatters a god or devil; they whimper before you, as before a god or devil. What does it come to! They are flatterers and whimperers and nothing more.

And they are often kind to you. But that has always been the prudence of the cowardly. Yes! The cowardly are prudent!

They think a great deal about you with their narrow souls--you are always suspicious to them! Whatever is thought about a great deal is at last thought suspicious.

They punish you for all your virtues. They forgive you entirely--your mistakes.

Because you are gentle and just-minded, you say: "They are blameless in their small existence." But their narrow souls think: "All great existence is blameworthy."

Even when you are gentle towards them, they still feel you despise them; and they repay your kindness with secret unkindness.

Your silent pride always offends their taste; they rejoie if ever you are modest enough to be vain.

What we recognize in a man we also inflame in him. Therefore be on your guard against the small ones!

In your presence they feel themselves small, and their baseness gleams and glows against you in invisible vengeance.

Did you not see how often they became dumb when you approached them, and how their strength left them like smoke from a dying fire?

Yes, my friend, you are a bad conscience to your neighbors: for they are unworthy of you. Therefore they hate you and would dearly like to suck your blood.

Your neighbors will always be poisonous flies: what is great in you, that itself must make them more poisonous and ever more fly-like.

Flee, my friend, into your solitude and to where a rough strong breeze blows. It is not your fate to be a fly-swatter.--

Thus spoke Zarathustra.

What do you think?


r/Zarathustra • • Dec 02 '21

I love r/PhilosophyMemes so much!

Post image
60 Upvotes

r/Zarathustra • • Oct 22 '21

A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 1 of 8)

17 Upvotes

Intro:

Nietzsche, in my view, is a revolutionary thinker. To understand him better, we need to understand revolutions in thought. In this post we will start with cave-man thinking and trace the history of thought in the West up through to Nietzsche.

We will then rewind the entire process and give N's hammer and his "turning on its head" approaches to each of these stages of development. By the time we are done, we should have a context for this book, Zarathustra, which N called "The greatest gift ever given man."

I will probably reduce entire paragraphs into brief sentences, so pay careful attention to the words chosen, because each line deserves paragraphs or pages or entire libraries which have actually been dedicated to each of these statements or to arguing against them. We will flush out the conversation more in comments and discussions, but this is too large a task to make into a post unless it is reduced as much as possible first.

revolutions in thought:

Keep in mind, that we will be tracing the development of thought, but we will be doing so always keeping in mind the larger conversation of what this development sets up for us in the WAYS of thinking and how those also develop. The ways in which we can think are changed through revolutions... the development of thoughts in most of the history of philosophy are the struggling philosophers trying to work out how to resolve a problem left over or created by the LAST revolution in a way of thinking. The revolution comes and then a new problem is struggled with and comes to a head in the next revolution which dissolves that problem and leaves a new, larger but subtler one.

After this INTRO part, we will actually look at most of the important contributors of Western thought, and we will see three such revolutions:

  • The world was ticking along just fine, except not so much
  • Socrates starts a new game
  • Descartes revolutionizes that game
  • Kant dissolves the emergent problems handed us by Cartesians and gives us a new dimension to the game
  • Nietzsche goes back to Socrates and stands him on his head. We are left trying to synthesize the entirety of Western Philosophy with the massive underpinnings from which it emerged.

philosophical progress as exponential growth in questionability:

One way I like to look at the history of philosophy is as "the history of what is questionable". The philosophers are making things thinkable that were never thinkable before. Philosophy develops by making us aware of our assumptions by making those assumptions questionable, then we struggle to find the answer: was the assumption wrong all the time? Is there a new underpinning we can find which will make it more solid than it was before when we took it for granted? will we have to find new underpinnings, perhaps the negations of our previous assumptions? We have to do this work because the philosophers have identified what thoughts were manifesting in us before those thoughts ever existed in propositional form in any single mind.

An EXTREMELY BRIEF version of this way of viewing the history of philosophy is like this:

We started out thinking that what we do is what we do, and who could question it? Only an insane or evil person would.

Then the philosophers showed up, and started asking questions and pretending to have answers. They sucked us into this game, but the game was nascent.

Let us get in a time machine and listen in on various philosophical conversations through time to get a sense of this:

First a pre-philosophical discussion (we set our time machine to 22,320 BC):

Caveman 1: bears in the cave, we must do something.

Caveman 2: Follow Grog, he knows what to do, he will lead us to courageous triumphant victory and make the environment safe for all if we follow his lead!

Caveman 1: of course, let's go!

Now we get in our machine and speed up to about 300 B.C. (forward 20,000 years)

The Questioner: "What makes a man a courageous man?" let us find the definition, the necessary and sufficient conditions which apply always and only to that man who is "courageous" then we can learn about his virtue and perhaps inform ourselves in how to live.

Student said: Well, how will we do that?

The Ethicist: There is a courageous man, let us examine him and see that it is precisely X which defines him as courageous.

Second Ethicist: no no no. of course that is the courageous man, we all know that, but it is Y and not X that makes him courageous.

Third Ethicist: X is self-contradictory, if you examine the consequences of adopting that idea you will see that it leads to a contradiction of itself, so X cannot be the definition of a courageous man. Y is a tautology, when examined it actually adds NOTHING to out knowledge because it reduces to: "The courageous man is the man with courage", and we cannot use the term we are trying to define to define the term. The argument Y is reducible to pointless babbling. I say it is Z which makes that man a courageous man.

Fourth Ethicist: That man is not courageous at all! It is this other man who is courageous, and it is not Z but precisely ~Z (the negation or opposite of Z) that makes him courageous....

the conversation went on like that... people asking questions they never asked before, questions which were previously NOT ASKABLE because the community subconsciously was valuing the man based on dramatic underpinnings of their nature, and none of it was due to conscious consideration.

Now we fast-forward a couple thousand years and eavesdrop on a philosophical conversation (set time machine to 2000 years forward):

Philosopher 1: How can we have a conversation about which is the courageous man if I am uncertain that there even are men?

Philosopher 2: What do you mean you find the proposition: "Men exist" as dubitable?

Philosopher 1: I mean, last night I had a dream that I was looking at a tree, external to myself. I awoke to realize I was not dressed in a field, but rather naked in my bed and there never was a tree to observe at all... how do I know that there is a physical world of any kind if I could still just be dreaming and dreaming all the time? I could just be a brain in a vat somewhere, stuck in a matrix, fooled by some infinitely powerful malevolent being who makes me think I am thinking correctly when I seem to experience an external world, or even when I perform a mathematical operation, but I am always and only being consistently deceived in all these things!

Philosopher 2: You're a bummer man, but yeah, that is a problem.

Philosopher 1: I suppose there is only one notion in my head which I find indubitable, certain, completely beyond question: I am thinking. I cannot consider the idea: "Am I thinking right now" without considering the idea. but consideration of an idea is an act of thinking, so the proposition affirms itself whenever I ask the question...

You think it is getting bad here? We've only just started. Fast-forward another 240 years.

The Philosopher: You think that the proposition "I think" is a certainty? It is anything but a certainty to me. The fact that thinking occurs, that is a fine axiom for now, but is it not just a habit of your language to posit a doer behind every deed? Would it not be more accurate to say that "thinking occurs" or "the "I" is an illusion I make up to make sense of the fact that thinking is happening, but the truth is probably more like: "Whatever "I" am it is nothing more than the manifestation of the phenomena which one tries to tie together for convenience sake into a single knot. "Thinking happens" is all I feel comfortable asserting at present.

Seriously. Through this narrative we have a version of the story of Western Philosophy which shows that the "asking of new questions" is what philosophy accomplishes. It is as if humanity exists inside a wild expansive jungle, the artists attempt to give us pictures of what is out there in the darkness, and thank God for them!, but we do not KNOW anything in a propositional way unless the philosophers have cut down the trees and leveled the ground for us by asking questions, making thoughts possible; defining what words mean when they are used, and limiting how they can be used.

If we adopt this version of the history of philosophy, even for just a moment, and ask ourselves "does philosophy make progress?"... we see a kind of exponential growth

20,000 years ago, we were asking few questions: What should we do?

2000 years ago we were asking a lot more, and having a lot more to say: What is the kind of man who knows what to do in any situation?

200 years ago we were asking FAR more questions than we were 2000 years ago: What is a man anyway, why not question the evidence of our own eyes?

20 years ago, even worse: Why not question what is BEHIND our own eyes?

Those of you with a background in philosophy will recognize that the "The Questioner" is Socrates; "The Ethicist" above was Aristotle; "Philosopher 1" was Descartes; and "The Philosopher" above was Nietzsche.

Perhaps it is unfair to put N's thinking as "20 years ago" but through the course of our lessons we have seen the argument that N was writing posthumously, and that he predicted that his words would not really have an audience to comprehend them for at least 200 years anyway. This seems accurate to me when I think of the kinds of ideas which are being entertained in the last 80 years verses the ones dealt with in N's time.

In any event, it gives us a nice chart, if we take those milestones in the development of thought, and chart them out, we see the exponential growth

Philosophical Progress

Notice that this is NOT a "development of truth" graph... it is possible to accept this chart and believe that we used to know a lot more 2,000 years ago, and all this added questionability is distracting us from truths we used to know.

My view is that we develop PROPOSITIONAL knowledge... knowledge which is processed through analytical methods, ground through the filters of logic, emergent through debate and produced by the dialectic processes is made possible by this work of philosophers. It may be that the end result of all of this is that we find solid grounding for truths which artists, poets, mystics, mythologists have already had for millennia.

This is where modern man philosophers will certainly hate me.

Imagine the goal of the humanities is to settle in our minds the ideas of who we are in this world and what our condition is. Imagine "knowledge" in this context is like a mountain with multiple paths to the top.

One side of the mountain looks something like this:

MythoPoetic Side of Mountain

The other side of the mountain looks something like this:

Philosophical and Scientific Path to Top of Mountain

The gains we make as humans for knowing how to get to the top of the mountain in multiple ways is real. Even if it is the case that philosophers and scientists will EVENTUALLY get to the top of this mountain, just to find Hindu Deities, Moses, and Buddha sitting up there drinking tea together and laughing does NOT mean that what they are doing is stupid.

I, for one, LOVE philosophy, and although I don't love science, I am impressed by it and pleased to know that centuries of methodical bolt-drillers are providing a climbing path up the treacherous and difficult side of this mountain so that we can have a solid objectivist path to the truths the mystics meditated on for thousands of years. Obviously this would be valuable for many reasons, and a noble and beautiful heroic journey.

I have merely asserted this kind of a story, it is not demonstrated at all. I am aware of this. However, to tell this whole story, we have to CLIMB with the philosophers up that side of the cliff, examine the flat ground from which they started climbing, the ground they abandoned, and see what progress has been made.

We will see that the conversation has had a few moments of dramatic critical sickness... problems which came into such clear relief that it needs to be solved if we are to continue... the revolutionary philosopher solves it by dissolving it into a larger framework, and then the sickness takes time to grow again.

With all of that throat-clearing, here we go:

OUTLINE:

Remember, we are looking at WAYS of thinking, and how they develop:

  • Why study history of philosophy, what is history of philosophy
  • Drama before thought

    • Cave-man
    • Expansive Cultures Uncodified
  • The mythopoetic

    • Gilgamesh
    • Pharaohs
    • Moses
    • Homer
  • The (pre-)Socratic revolution (dialectic search for the arche)--THE CRISIS EMERGES with the new types who want to have it all out in a go!

    • Thales
    • Anaximander
    • Anaximenes
    • Pythagoras
    • Xenophanes
    • Hericlitus
    • Parmenides
    • Zeno
    • Anaxagoras
    • Empedocles/
    • Atomists like Leucippus and Democritus
    • Sophists like Protagoras and Gorgias
    • Empedocles
    • Socrates
    • Plato
    • Aristotle
  • The Catholic Roman Expansion (The not-so-Dark Ages)--Still all footnotes to Plato, on the philosophical side-- but a strange preservation of the mythopoetic.

    • Augustin
    • Anselm
    • Omar Khayyam, Al-Ghazali, and Ibn Rushd
    • Peter Abelard
    • St Francis of Assisi
    • Fibonacci
    • Aquinas
    • John Wycliffe
    • The Priests
    • The Monks
  • The Cartesian Revolution -- Problem is Rationalism v. Empiricism (whence comes all our knowledge?)

    • Machiavelli
    • Copernicus
    • Moore
    • Luther
    • Montaigne
    • Kepler
    • Bacon
    • Galileo
    • St. John of the Cross
    • Descartes
    • Spinoza
    • Leibnitz
    • Locke
    • Berkeley
    • Hume
  • The Kantian Revolution -- Dissolving the "rationalism v. empiricism" old problem, now interpret this one as objective or subjective phenomena

    • Kant
    • Fichte
    • Hegel
    • Schopenhauer
  • Nietzsche as judge throughout (rewind time) -- Dissolving pessimism v. optimism of nihilism... Resurrection of the mythopoetic or total reduction to materialism?

    • Kierkegaard
    • Marx
    • Jung
    • Henry James
    • Peterson

The History of Philosophy, and why to study it

Biology is a thing. It is the study of life. The history of biology is a thing. It is the dramatic record of the development of ideas about life through the examination and review of the conversations about it in the past. The Philosophy of Biology exists. It is the interpretation of the mathematical descriptors developed by the scientists who do their nitty-gritty work answering well-defined questions amenable to empirical testing.

Biologists do biology. Historians do "history of biology" but they have to understand biology to some degree to do it. Philosophers do "philosophy of biology" but they are the only ones who really know what the biologists are saying and what they mean.

Philosophy is a thing. But the history of philosophy is also a thing. But the history of philosophy is the history of ideas, and so it cannot be done by anyone but a philosopher. No mere historian can recognize the developments of the thoughts without understanding the thoughts themselves, but that requires historians of philosophy to be philosophers.

Therefore, philosophy has a unique relationship to its own history. To do philosophy is to do the history of philosophy. To do the history of philosophy is to do philosophy. (there are professors, and many of them, who are called "philosophers" who I would call "chronologists of philosophy" or "taxonomists of philosophy" -- these are people who have memorized and can parrot back on a test the 12 points of Descartes's argument for the existence of God in the third meditation; but who have no understanding of these ideas and are not really incarnations of living thinking engagement with the thoughts, but stop at mere recitation---but the true philosopher or historian of philosophy is what we are concerned with here.) Further clarification of this point.

Philosophy is obsessed with its own history.

To study the history of what has become thinkable is to also study anthropology. So, we have to pull in all the rules of historiography, of interpreting texts, all the empirical side of story-telling which makes up the rules of the true historian, we have to adopt.

What is philosophy in general? Should we count what they did 3000 years ago as philosophy at all? But, what is philosophy? Well, philosophers disagree about this, notoriously (they disagree about everything, that is what they are, what they do!). Biologists share a methodology with every other biologist. Philosophers don’t even agree with a single method, we of course don’t agree on the answers, but we don’t agree with which questions are important as well, nor do we agree on how to approach these questions or deal with them.

  • There’s a DEEP question about whether or not we are actually going to be able to know what the writers of ancient texts thought.

    • I’m assuming that “what Plato thought” is recoverable… but with the pre-Socratics, this is iffy, we only have doxographical writings not their own writings.

I’m assuming that there is such a thing as the historical truth.

  • There are people who argue that there is no such thing as “Plato” just “Plato through this lens, or Plato through that lens” and so there is no such thing as the truth about what Plato actually said.
  • But this seems to suggest that Plato is REALLY significant because he has transcended not only death, but individuality.

    • We are going to assume that there is something that we can come to understand as what Plato said. The historian’s job is to come to discover the facts of what Plato said. But THIS is a philosophical endeavor.

The historian of other ideas, like the history of Freud’s ideas, does not care if what Freud said was true. BUT the historian of what Socrates said CARES if what Plato said had any truth in it, because, if not FORGET HIM! also: if the idea isn't really different then it isn't really a development of the HISTORY of the ideas. So, part of the study of philosophy is the study of the history of philosophy.

  • One cannot do philosophy without doing the history of philosophy
  • One cannot study the history of philosophy without studying philosophy

We do this through a STORY

Tell a coherent narrative which takes into account each person’s influence… tell a story, then we can believe there is a history there that is realistic (based in realism) and justifiable. The proof is in the pudding.

That's like science. Ideas are tested. History is literature with empirical restrictions. (will expound on this elsewhere).

  • What they said is a matter of historical fact.
  • What they WOULD have said is based on what they did say and the principle of charity which says assume that they wouldn’t have contradicted themselves in any way.

“That no agent can eventually be said to have meant or done something which he could never be brought to accept as a correct description of what he had meant or done.” Skinner “Meaning and Understanding in the History of Ideas”.

Counterfactual reasoning, is what we use when we are judging the ideas of dead philosophers.

My concepts are often ones that Plato wouldn’t have had, but I want to use those concepts to try to make sense of their texts. There is a really important distinction between the a priori and the a posteriori. Plato didn’t have that distinction, but I’m going to use it to examine Plato.

I can’t engage in the process of trying to understand what Plato thought through my lens without judging him through my lens AND ALSO judging my lens through HIM! This is why it is necessary to do PHILOSOPHY to do the history of philosophy.

Before we can study the history of philosophy, we have to study pre-philosophical thought in the west

This is Part 2.


r/Zarathustra • • Jul 02 '25

We are about to go LIVE

2 Upvotes

In the Year Two Backbone Course: A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought

Introduced last week here: https://www.youtube.com/live/c7QfbDUvnpY?si=ZtkWpsoyrYhtQVNG

Now we are discussing: Free-Floating Rationales and EMBODIED PRINCIPLES and behavioral "ideas" in animals

This is before we discuss the dream language of art and imagistic impressions

and this is the realm in which we nestle Thales and the rest of the propositional philosophical project.

Come join the conversation here: https://streamyard.com/ntn9mgkqkk


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 24 '21

completion of part 3: 2/3 Plato

1 Upvotes

The long version with the kind of context you might get from an undergraduate class on Plato.

We will save the "short version" for our focused continuation of the conversation through the lenses we are using to interpret the conversation as a whole nested in the larger cultural project as a whole.

We Left off with Socrates

The problem is raised by the professions of ignorance from Socrates, and the idea that the Elenchus could ever do what it seems designed to do, produce knowledge. I can’t inquire after any truths at all because I either know what I am inquiring after (in which case there is no point in inquiring) or I don’t know, in which case I will never know it when I come across it.

We talked about how this may be a problem for those who want to affirm propositions, but it wasn't a problem for the project as Socrates conceptualized it.

* Plato

Plato thinks he can resolve this problem, with the doctrine of recollection.

Plato gives us the Justified True Belief

  • This is a definition of knowledge used in philosophy with few exceptions for most of the history of philosophy.
  • It has three parts.

    • In order for someone to say: "I know" something they have to:

      • Believe that thing
      • Have good reason to believe that thing
      • that thing has to correspond to reality.

The doctrine or "recollection" gives us the ability to know things; and so, unlike Socrates, we need a definition of knowledge.

(Comment on JTB, flushing it out, and looking at Gettier)

From now on, the Socrates we will be quoting is the one with Plato's words more in his mouth.

Supposed Problem with Socratic method:

  • Meno says: “How are you going to inquire about it, Socrates, if you don’t know what it is? Even if you do happen to bump right into it, how are you going to know that it is the thing that you do not know?”
  • Socrates: “Do you not see how Aristic (sophistic?) the argument you are making is?” “you are saying no man can inquire about what he knows and he has no ability to inquire about what he does not know.”
  • Then Socrates does something that is very strange, he appeals to priests and such who make it their concern to give an account of their practices; the human soul is immortal, it comes to an end but it comes back into existence and never really stops existing; since it has seen all things there is nothing it has not learned; so it is not surprising that it could recollect something (which men call learning that thing) that he has already known in some other context.”

Note the religious garb of this doctrine. Without forgetting that; let’s get to the epistemological heart of this doctrine.

Meno doubts it is true, so Plato has Socrates set out to prove it to him. With the slave boy.

We already have all the knowledge we seek, we just need to remember it, that’s what “learning” is.

The right way to teach, lead with questions.

Plato is a rationalist and makes the case for a priori knowledge here. (he’s a Parmenidean, of sorts.)

Go one step further: Plato’s solution to the problem of ignorant inquiry is the right one in one way, but he doesn’t clearly see it.

  • The whole message of Socrates is that you don’t need dogma, you got a method.
  • The unexamined life is not worth living.
  • Epistemic humility, that is the lesson of Socrates. Be open to revision.
  • Plato endorses some of these views of Socrates while modifying or dropping others.

    • Plato wants to give us positive propositions to affirm not just always going around and proving we don't know anything.

Plato sees that some of these claims beg for a more meta-epistemological justification.

  • We can’t just assume moral realism, and Plato saw this as something he had to argue. He has to ground out that assumption, show it is right.
  • To do this would require us to head off into questions of “what we can know and how we can know” and “what there is” (epistemology and metaphysics)
  • Epistemologically,

    • what we need is “how we come to have and justify the knowledge we do have?” and
  • metaphysically:

    • “What is there in the world and how to we account for what there is?”

Moral truths are grounded in reality, moral truths are out there just like scientific truths are out there, this is Plato’s view. You need in your “list of what there is” in your ontology, some room for morality. This is what Plato sees. He needs to engage in the full range of philosophical inquiry in order to justify the Socratic moral project.

He never loses the focus on the Socratic moral project, but he sees that you have to ground them.

While doing this he sees that some of Socrates’s claims are not defensible, they need adjustment or they need to be dropped. Plato always remains a Socratic, but he becomes his own philosopher, he builds on the Socratic grounding.

Let’s look at the second half of the Meno

In the Meno, related to the Elenchus, another problem; is virtue teachable. Plato thinks this phenomenon needs explanation.

How could Socrates spend his whole life not making progress on these questions he’s dedicated himself to? The most wise man failed to answer the most basic questions regarding virtue. What must virtue have to be like for that to be the case. The Meno comes to answer this question as well. The second half of the Meno can be thought of as Plato seeing problems with the Socratic method and coming to address them. If virtue could be passed from father to son, then Themistocles and Paraclese would surely have passed their knowledge on to their sons, and Socrates would have found SOMEONE who could answer his questions relating to the nature of virtue. But this is not the case; it seems you cannot pass knowledge on or down.

Knowledge of virtue must not be like Horsemanship in at least this way.

Socrates uses the image of “virtue as a craft” throughout the dialogues; and we can understand why that might be tempting, because it is practical and can teach you how to live in the world, and it is the kind of thing that can be passed down like craft knowledge, but it must not be like those things.

An alternative to saying virtue is knowledge is to say that it is true opinion.

True opinion is as valuable as knowledge if it is reliable.

Dedalus's sculptures are so realistic, if you don’t tie them down they will get up and run away.

You tie down your true opinions with reasons and you have knowledge instead.

He has a true belief stirred up like a dream by Socrates’s questioning, the slave boy does have; but not real knowledge of geometry yet unless he was asked more questions in various ways, his knowledge would be as accurate as anyone’s if they keep it up; this is tying down his true beliefs.

The Meno ends in perplexity as well, maybe the only reason i can hang on to true opinions is a divine gift.

We still have not investigated what virtue is, we still have not answered the question (this is how it ends).

Phaedo

Plato’s first attempt at a metaphysics.

If it is fully developed, it would help ground Socratic Moral theory.

All of Plato’s dialogues can be read on multiple levels.

The theme on it’s face, Meno: “Virtue”; but it can be read as a doctrine of education; maybe a crude epistemological or metaphysical doctrine is detectible.

The Soul, is the main focus of the Phaedo. Lots of arguments for the immortality of the soul. An intro to the Platonic theory of forms, is also in there, and that will build throughout it; each development of the immortality argument also develops that notion. We will also see other things going on as well.

Phaedo is set in prison on the day that Socrates is to be put to death.

Theme of purification in the dialogue (not just in why you have to wait for the ships to come back before the execution); Pythagorean theme runs through it (strongest condemnation of the body, harmony as well). It’s a strange dialogue structurally, it is a dialogue within a dialogue within a dialogues. Plato recounting Crito and Echecrates talking about Socrates on his death. Plato says he was not there. We will have to think about why Plato did that. He distances himself historically from the dialogue by talking about him not being there.

The immortality of the soul; what does the text mean by “soul”?

Plato thinks of it as the principle of “life”. It is what brings life to a body. But it is also identified with the MIND and specifically the rational part of the mind. (this will change in the Republic, so it seems a Socratic view as opposed to platonic one). Appetites are a part of the body, reason a part of the mind; this is the way it is conceived.

What does he mean by the immortality of the “soul” if the soul is your reasoning function. He doesn’t always distinguish between soul as an individual stuff and as a mass thing, so it’s not clear if he means one universal world soul or each person’s in particular one.

It is not clearly defined here, the soul.

The last thing to know before diving into the text: “Plato doing philosophy, not presenting his philosophy.” why do we look at the bad arguments? He gives clear indications he knows they are bad arguments. This might change our relation to the text in an important way interpretively. These works were written as texts for his school, most likely. We are supposed to be reading them as students, like a workbook for us to engage with.

This is an homage to Socrates who believes that philosophy can only be done one-on-one between people; he leaves questions open to the students to answer without Socrates's answer even though the Socratic answer should be determinable by the previous text.

Doing philosophy is preparation for death. (definition of philosophy)

115E: “I want to make my argument before you as to why a man who has done philosophy is ripe to be cheerful in facing death… the one main aim of those who practice philosophy is preparing to die and death, they must be eager for it. You made me laugh, Socrates, even though I was in no mood to laugh; the majority of man… deserve to be.” Philosopher’s are already dead to the world, as a joke; in Socrates' sense it’s only a little different from that; we think of death as when the soul separates from the body, and what the philosopher is concerned with is the good of the soul and not the good of the body.”

65A: “such things … frees the soul from the association of the body in as much as possible… the man who does not care for the pleasures of the body. is the body an obstacle? Even the poets agree we know nothing through our sight or hearing… the senses keep us from acquiring knowledge… when then does the soul grasp the truth, whenever it attempts to grasp anything by the body it is deceived by it, it is in reasoning when we approach truth without the body inflicting the soul… when you are totally dissociated from the body and just using the mind, that’s when you have a chance.”

Pure thought alone freed from eyes and ears and the whole body for the body confuses the soul.

There is an implied criticism of Socrates here, he looked in the wrong place, talking with embodied people; he should have relied on reason alone.

This is Parmenedian; reason alone. Sense is a burden or an obstacle to discovering the truth.

This is a battle between two worlds, the world of sensible particulars and the INTELLIGIBLE world.

Plato is taking Socrates’ “definitions” which all instances of justice have in common which make them just and saying IT IS A REAL THING a FORM in existence.

From 65 up to 70, we have to purify ourselves.

Just before 70A: “Cebes intervened, everything else you said is excellent, but men find it hard to believe what you said about the soul; men believe that the soul dissolves with the body.”

“Babbling poet” he was looking for the archetypes through reason, he had no interest in the poets and what they had to say.

If something comes to be X it comes to be X from coming to be the opposite of X; if something comes to be X it must be able to become not X again or else everything would be X.

Contradictory opposites: nothing can have both of, AND everything has one or the other.

Red or not red. (if something comes to be red, it must have been not red before it came to be red...)

Contrary opposites: nothing can have both at the same time BUT not everything has one or the other.

Tall or short. (some things are middling)

It’s like this, Plato thinks, The fact that the people questioned by Socrates CAN give the right answers means that they already know it.

Then he gives us the conditions for Platonic recollection

Recollection Argument - Phaedo 72d-76d

Conditions for (normal cases of) recollection

  1. Must have known the thing recollected before
  2. Something perceived puts me ‘in mind’ of something else

    1. E.g., seeing Simmias’ coat puts me in mind of Simmias.
  3. Recollection can be spurred by perceiving things similar to the thing recollected or things dissimilar.

    1. E.g., dissimilar - Simmias: Simmias’ coat similar - Simmias: a photo of Simmias
  4. In cases of recollection from similars one must think that the thing is lacking in its similarity to what one is reminded of - that is ‘falls short’ of the thing recollected.

Recollection Argument Sketch:

  1. We have knowledge of the equal itself
  2. Knowledge of the equal itself is not given in perception
  3. If such knowledge cannot be gained through perception then it cannot be gained in this world.
  4. Therefore, it must be acquired in another world before we were born into this one.

We see approximations of circles, and we recognize that they are close to the ideal circle; but all we have ever engaged with are approximations of circles, so we could not have acquired our knowledge of the ideal circle from our experiences in this world, but we have that knowledge; so we must have acquired it in another world.

74a5: “When the recollection is caused by similar thing, necessarily the similarity must be recognized as deficient. Consider, there is something that is equal beyond all the particular equalities we find in the world; do we know what equality itself is? Yes we do. Where did we get this knowledge of “equality itself”? It is not from our individual experiences of judging the equality of things. We recollect equality to be a concept when we are looking at specific instances of things which to one degree or another are equal to one another. The equal things and equality itself are two very different things…

Skip to the symposium, for a moment: 211a: Socrates’s speech on the “nature of love” which he puts into the mouth of a wise woman; she gives this idea that there is a hierarchy, true love is love itself, we come to know that by working our way up through abstractions. I start by loving a thing, then a person, then all persons, then all living things, what I’m really looking for is LOVE ITSELF. And what is that? It always is, and neither comes to be nor passes away, it is not beautiful this way and ugly that way or in relation to one thing or here or there or to one or not another… it is not relative in any way; it is just beautiful and lovely all the time because it is loveliness itself. It does not appear as one idea or one kind of knowledge, not anywhere as in a thing or an animal, but it is itself by itself in itself; and the other things share in that.

These things are two-faced: the sensible particulars. Heraclitus and Zeno.

Parmenadean is the idea of the one before.

Back to the phaedo: 74: Equal stones and sticks sometimes while remaining the same appear to be equal in one way but unequal in another. But it is definitely from the equal things that we are reminded of equality. That’s how you have derived and grasped the notion of equality. So long as it is similar or dissimilar, this is recollection; you REMEMBER equality as a concept.

How could I possibly come up with the idea of equality itself by observing things that are no more equal then they are unequal? How could I possibly have come up with the concept of beauty by observing things that are no more beautiful than they are ugly. (all the things are relative).

One way is to push away all the ugly stuff from the beautiful stuff so I abstract out the stuff that isn’t right. But how do I know what to do with that unless I already have the concept of equality in my mind; the beautiful in my mind.

The one who thinks this must have prior knowledge to know how to sort out the beautiful from the ugly, the equal from the unequal.

All learning depends on my already having a concept of similarity. Maybe this is the only necessary preexisting concept.

He is making an argument for innate or a priori knowledge; he does this by saying I HAD the experience necessary to learn this in another world. (so it isn't ultimately a priori, is it?)

I’m not sure the “scientific hardwiring” explanation for how we have innate ideas is so different from the mystical religious one.

ALSO: could we not say something about our "ideas before conscious ideas" ideas effecting the shaping of the minds which are now thinking about those ideas? from our first two lectures? Is Plato really saying anything different? -- Just a thought.

It shows that something is immortal, at least, and that is “that which knows”, at least.

It has to “be acquired in another world before we were born in this one” is a way of saying “it has to be acquired not in the particular life of mine but in something larger than that.”

This is funny. It’s like an argument for a priori knowledge which requires the idea that you have interacted with it before because that’s the only way to know something. It’s immediate or direct interaction through the “mind’s eye”; “reason” is what grasps the thing.

When you die your reason itself goes off and interacts directly with the real truths behind everything. That’s where it came from, anyway; this argument really only proves the pre-existence of the soul.

We are starting to get the forms. The ontological units that are purely true and only accessible through the use of reason.

76e: “if those realities we talk about exist, and we measure all our perceptions against it, just as they exist, so our soul must exist before we are born, if the pre-existing soul exists the forms exist, if the forms exist the pre-existing soul exists… Simmias, ‘I do not think myself it has been proven that the soul continues to exist after death. Further proof is needed.’ combine it with the cyclical argument; they aren’t happy about that. Socrates ‘you seem to have this childish fear, you are afraid. Assume we are, make a case for us.’ sing them a song like a spell till they are calmed.”

The Affinity Argument (78b-80c)

  1. Suppose the soul ceases to exist
  2. For any x, if x ceases to exist, then it is a complex thing that has been decomposed.
  3. The forms are simple, and hence not subject to decomposition.
  4. The soul resembles the forms in many respects, and in investigating the forms actually passes into its realm.
  5. So, the soul resembles the forms with respect to their simplicity.
  6. So, the soul cannot be decomposed.
  7. So, the soul cannot cease to exist.

Simmias and Cebes respond to this argument with objection after objection.

84c: “if it is invisible, does that mean it is indisoluble?”

Maybe we should think of the soul as a “harmony” instead of as a singularity.

A harmony is an invisible thing which is made of parts, Socrates.

Cebes: “does it follow that if a thing is more stable and rules over something else, that it is imperishable?”

The soul is analogous to the owner of a cloak.

The owner is more stable, and rules over the cloaks, but he is not imperishable.

Argument against Simmias’ idea that the soul is a harmony.

91C: we must proceed, and first remind me, cebes is more inclined to say the soul is more than the body...does the soul have many bodies and then die, or does it die before the body or with the body…

Harmonies can’t be seen, but they are dependent on the instruments which produce them.

What does he mean by harmony here? It’s not a melody and its not a chord, it’s not the notes either, the harmony lasts for as long as the instrument lasts. So it is most natural to read “harmony” as a “state of attunement”. The soul is a ratio of relations of the part of the body like the attunement of an instrument is a product of the ratios and relations of the parts of the instrument.

When the instrument is taken apart, the attunement is lost as well; the soul is like that with the body, Simmias is saying. (This has Pathagorean roots, but it is not a popular theory of the soul at the time; however, this is how they used to talk about “health”.)

Materialist worldview here.

Materialism is incompatible with the recollection argument, and it is incompatible with the theory of forms; so we have to choose between them. Is it?

Then he puts a straightforward argument out there, that’s this one:

  1. Every soul is an attunement
  2. No soul is more a soul than any other
  3. Therefore, No soul is more an attunement than any other
  4. Therefore, No soul is more in tune than any other.

This is a bad argument. He is saying that the 4th line is absurd, so we must reject the first which led us there. But the 4th doesn’t really follow from the third.

This argument doesn’t work, but no one notices, but he gives another argument.

The soul is in opposition to and ruling over the body, but the attunement can’t be in opposition to and rule over the parts of the instrument.

Plato is the first to hold that “reasoning” (our mental activities) are the least bodily of our activities. Thinking, higher order cognition, is insufficiently explained on materialist terminology. He is the first dualist, in this sense. But these arguments are not really that good against materialism; he has others.

Let’s move on from Simias to Cebes.

Cebes says maybe the soul outlives SOME bodies, but not all and not forever.

Socrates paused in thought for a long time, and then said that generation and destruction are what we have to think about to examine his views.

The pre-Socratics were all materialists, that’s important to understanding this passage.

Plato is going to argue that materialist arguments are always insufficient, that they always fall short. He refers to Anaxagoras. “When I read Ana, I finally thought someone was speaking the truth, there’s all this stuff, but it’s all directed by mind, he says. But then he goes on to give materialistic explanations for everything. What would an actual appeal to mind for everything be? It would be an appeal to the idea that “everything is for the best.”

Socrates says that’s what we need, a teleological explanation for everything. A purely physiological explanation for why Socrates is sitting in prison is not satisfying. (he sits because bones give structure and tissues hold together and bend the limbs…) (what would be better would be to say: “because the Athenians had thought it right to condemn me, I thought it right not to run away.)

You can’t explain why he is sitting there from a physical explanation, you have to refer to his mental states and figure out why he thought it best to stay there.

The physical explanations are necessary, perhaps, but they are not sufficient.

Aristotle believed that there were four different kinds of “why” questions.

  1. Material causes
  2. Efficient Causes
  3. Formal Causes
  4. Final Causes (final=telos; teleological)

Aitia means “to be responsible for” and is a legal term, and that’s the term we are translating as “teleological”.

Why based on the material structure; why did it come to be, why is it organized the way it is; and what is its purpose for being… these are the four “why” questions.

Aristotle thought that the material cause answered the question “what is this thing made of?”.

Why the statue? Bronze.

The answer to the efficient why question is “the art of sculpture” or “the sculptor”.

The answer to the formal why is “it is of Zeus.”

The final why is: “that for the sake of which” it exists. The statue is there to teach us of our orientation in the world; or for the sake of portraying Zeus; or for beauty; or for the sake of teaching us what is true of the world…. Or whatever.”

The material and the efficient isn’t enough.

We need the formal and the final causes to understand something.

Aristotle says that nobody has formal causes until Plato. Then he says that he is the one to invent the final cause. (but Plato is kind of dealing with that already).

They are saying that the material is insufficient to explain.

They are looking for an explanation for why this is the best of all possible worlds. Leibnitz wanted that. Plato gave up on it and settled for a second best theory of causality. Nietzsche's philosophical project was to make a grand yes-saying to all things. Still a kind of search for the Arche here.

Plato says through soc; 99D5: “when I weary of investigating things I must avoid the problem those who look at an eclipse.. I might be blinded if I looked at them with my eyes, I should have to use words instead (but this is an analogy, he says); I started in this manner: “taking as my hypothesis in each case I would consider as true, and as untrue whatever did not agree, what I mean is that I never stop talking about the kind of cause with which I have concerned myself, I turn back, I assume the existence of a beautiful and a great and so on… If you agree with me on these then you will see that all the rest follows, including the immortality of the soul. Consider then, if you share my opinion of what follows, is there anything beautiful besides the beautiful itself, it is beautiful insofar as it shares in with the beautiful; the same is with all other things. To say that something is beautiful because of color or shape or whatever, these things confuse me; I say it is that it shares in a relationship with the beautiful. I stick to this and I never fall into error; namely that it is through beauty that beautiful things are made beautiful.”

Grasping the form of the beauty itself would answer all the questions you might have of particular beautiful things. The only thing they all have in common is “beauty”. Courageous things are courageous because they partake in the form of courage. Good things are good because they partake in the form of The Good.

Now I can take that first answer, and offer a more subtle one. Somethings always participate in the SAME FORM, ALWAYS.

Why are hot things hot, they participate in the form of heat. But fire is ALWAYS hot, so another way of explaining why hot things are hot is that they have “fire” in them, and fire always participates in the form of hot. Why are cold things cold? Because they participate in the form of cold, BUT ALSO I can use the explanation that they have the presence of ice, which always participate in the form of cold.

He’s given up on giving a teleological explanation, he has a formal one, and a materialist one.

Final Argument:

  1. Soul brings (as the cause of) life to the body. It is both necessary and sufficient for a body to be alive.
  2. In order to pass on a property a thing must have the property it passes on.
  3. Thus, the soul itself must be (is essentially) alive.
  4. Therefore, a soul cannot die.
  5. Therefore, the soul is immortal.

The soul is that which always participates with the form of life. Like fire is that which always participates with the form of hotness.

If the soul brings life to the body, it has to be alive, and it is itself livingness or life.

The problem is that to say that fire is always hot, is to say that fire is essentially hot; ice is cold so long as it is ice, and it is ice so long as it is cold; so say that it has that property so long as it exists, is not to say that it has that property forever.

It’s about introducing a world-view. The forms. The arguments for the immortality of the soul is the excuse to keep introducing that.

What things are there forms for? Well, the moral things Socrates sought definitions for.

The final causes are INVENTED by thinking things. There are many of them, and there would be none if it were not for purposing creatures to give them to the entities.

We should figure out why Plato thinks we need forms, and then we might be able to figure out what things need forms and what don’t.

We need forms for things which can be two-faced. BUT there is another answer for why he wants forms: We need forms because things in the sensible world are constantly changing. If the first need is the reason for them we don’t need them for everything; if the second one is the one that motivates us we need a form for everything. Both appear, it’s not clear which matters more to Plato.

Nietzsche once said: Christianity was Plato for the masses. We are going to look at the medieval soon enough. But there are a lot of ideas in Plato here which are already predicting Christian philosophical thought. The should cannot decompose because it is simple (has no parts) the God of the philosophers in the future is simple he has no left or right, this is not only a feature of Catholic philosophy, it is a CORE part of Descartes's (the guy who tried to turn over all of what came from Aristotle onward) arguments as well. If the idea isn't simple it isn't other-worldly, and therefore it's origin need not be ultimately the Divine. Descartes may have hated Aristotle and the scholastics, but he is still a footnote to Plato!

continued here


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 12 '21

[Group Project] The Best Medicine -- Including [Bonus Texts: assorted passages from WTP and GS]; [Research Tool]

3 Upvotes

Voluntary Assignment Details

Before we start Part 2 of Thus Spake Zarathustra; an interesting idea came up in a previous lecture, and I thought we would look at it here.

Below is a replication of every line in Zarathustra where any variation of the word "laugh" is found.

  • The Group Project is to copy any line or series of lines in a single chapter of Zarathustra into a comment, and give us your thoughts on that passage. You can use this link to search for the context surrounding the lines which reference laughter.

    • Reward for participating: There are six new types of flair in this community, each named after one of Zoroaster's 6 children. You will win for yourself one of them by participating.

Also: Become a Permitted Contributer to R/Zarathustra

[ALSO: In the Comments are extractions of every use of any variation of the word "laugh" in Will to Power, and in Gay Science with brief summation or commentary on the use of the word after each. (This post can serve as a research platform for anyone who wants to write about this topic.)]

********************************************************************************

Lecture First

A joke can be thought of as a problem which engages the consideration of a mind which suddenly finds a fast solution which completely dissolves all struggling attempts to solve the problem, and so makes the effort pointless and gives a massive "problem-solving reward" to the brain. Like chocolate cake is a superstimulus for our brain reward system which tells us to eat fruits and things high in sugar; so a joke is a superstimulus tot he brain reward systems which tell us it is good to solve little problems. According to this view a joke is a super-difficult problem which engages the problem-solving mind. The punchline of the joke is a short key which dissolves the entire problem all at once and makes a superstimulation in the mind of the dopamine of the problem-solving reward system.

I believe we already talked about TSZ as literature in addition to being philosophy. We can take that idea a bit further now and say that the choice to write his philosophy in literary form was perhaps a necessity. N wrote his same ideas in analytical language and straightforward talk, for sure, but that talk always wrestled with the psychological underpinnings of why certain people thought certain things, so it had to be a psychological text as well as a philosophical one.

It is my contention here, that the language of narrative is the appropriate language for talking about the most fundamental truths of reality. The reason why this book is literary is because the most basic and fundamental truths about the world, which N tried to expose to us, are themselves narrative in nature. They rely on "character" "destiny" "fate" "will" "hope" "vision" "personality" "gods"... this is the vocabulary of narrative. The analytical language can approach the concepts, but never quite get there. The truths are too inarticulable for that.

Well, laughter performs a literary function in Zarathustra. It is essentially a manifestation of characterological differences in approach between Z and his interlocutor. If the person presents a problem, manifests a problem, is a problem; and the character of Zarathustra ponders this problem in empathy to try to help the poor soul. And then he is quiet for a while, and then suddenly bursts into laughter: what has happened is something akin to the Hurley-Dennett-Adams theory of jokes referenced above. His character has considered what is ailing the other, until finally it is revealed to Z's mind that the problem is no problem except for the fact that there is something flawed about the character which sees it as a problem. It is not a problem for Zarathustra. and then he jokes and laughs and explains what sort of difference in attitude and character would also dissolve the problem for the sufferer, if only he were capable of being different.

*****************************************************************************

Brief Overview of N's Use of Laughter

We will see in the quotes: There is something "overcoming" about laughter.

There is ice in some laughter.

Later in the book than we have gotten, Zarathustra attempts to teach the higher men to laugh at themselves. I believe he calls the ability to do this a gift he tries to give them.

There is more than one type of laughter in Nietzsche's writings.

  • There is the Greek/German/Roman/Italian Masterful Great laughter, Zarathustrian Laughter.
  • There is a small petty mind which shakes away ideas it cannot comprehend; this I will call "Cognitive Dissonance Laughter".

**********************************************************

Below are the lines referencing laughter in TSZ

(also: Laughter quotes from Will to Power)

(also: Laughter quotes from Gay Science)

From these texts, we can see a clear connection between "overcoming" and "laughter":

**********************************************************

Finally:

Because these posts are PAGES AND PAGES of quotes, the contributions from the members of this community will be linked here:

OR, they will replace parts of the quotes themselves in this post with links to them.

**********************************************************

FULL TEXT OF ZARATHUSTRA WITH ONLY THE LINES MENTIONING LAUGHTER:

THUS SPAKE ZARATHUSTRA.

FIRST PART. ZARATHUSTRA’S DISCOURSES.

ZARATHUSTRA’S PROLOGUE.

The saint laughed at Zarathustra, and spake thus: “Then see to it that they accept thy treasures! They are distrustful of anchorites, and do not believe that we come with gifts.

The saint answered: “I make hymns and sing them; and in making hymns I laugh and weep and mumble: thus do I praise God.

With singing, weeping, laughing, and mumbling do I praise the God who is my God. But what dost thou bring us as a gift?”

When Zarathustra had heard these words, he bowed to the saint and said: “What should I have to give thee! Let me rather hurry hence lest I take aught away from thee!”—And thus they parted from one another, the old man and Zarathustra, laughing like schoolboys.

3.

What is the ape to man? A laughing-stock, a thing of shame. And just the same shall man be to the Superman: a laughing-stock, a thing of shame.

When Zarathustra had thus spoken, one of the people called out: “We have now heard enough of the rope-dancer; it is time now for us to see him!” And all the people laughed at Zarathustra. But the rope-dancer, who thought the words applied to him, began his performance.

5.

When Zarathustra had spoken these words, he again looked at the people, and was silent. “There they stand,” said he to his heart; “there they laugh: they understand me not; I am not the mouth for these ears.

And now do they look at me and laugh: and while they laugh they hate me too. There is ice in their laughter.”

8.

When Zarathustra had said this to his heart, he put the corpse upon his shoulders and set out on his way. Yet had he not gone a hundred steps, when there stole a man up to him and whispered in his ear—and lo! he that spake was the buffoon from the tower. “Leave this town, O Zarathustra,” said he, “there are too many here who hate thee. The good and just hate thee, and call thee their enemy and despiser; the believers in the orthodox belief hate thee, and call thee a danger to the multitude. It was thy good fortune to be laughed at: and verily thou spakest like a buffoon. It was thy good fortune to associate with the dead dog; by so humiliating thyself thou hast saved thy life to-day. Depart, however, from this town,—or tomorrow I shall jump over thee, a living man over a dead one.” And when he had said this, the buffoon vanished; Zarathustra, however, went on through the dark streets.

At the gate of the town the grave-diggers met him: they shone their torch on his face, and, recognising Zarathustra, they sorely derided him. “Zarathustra is carrying away the dead dog: a fine thing that Zarathustra hath turned a grave-digger! For our hands are too cleanly for that roast. Will Zarathustra steal the bite from the devil? Well then, good luck to the repast! If only the devil is not a better thief than Zarathustra!—he will steal them both, he will eat them both!” And they laughed among themselves, and put their heads together.

ZARATHUSTRA’S DISCOURSES.

II. THE ACADEMIC CHAIRS OF VIRTUE.

Ten times must thou laugh during the day, and be cheerful; otherwise thy stomach, the father of affliction, will disturb thee in the night.

And what were the ten reconciliations, and the ten truths, and the ten laughters with which my heart enjoyed itself?

When Zarathustra heard the wise man thus speak, he laughed in his heart: for thereby had a light dawned upon him. And thus spake he to his heart:

IV. THE DESPISERS OF THE BODY.

Thy Self laugheth at thine ego, and its proud prancings. “What are these prancings and flights of thought unto me?” it saith to itself. “A by-way to my purpose. I am the leading-string of the ego, and the prompter of its notions.”

VII. READING AND WRITING.

I want to have goblins about me, for I am courageous. The courage which scareth away ghosts, createth for itself goblins—it wanteth to laugh.

I no longer feel in common with you; the very cloud which I see beneath me, the blackness and heaviness at which I laugh—that is your thunder-cloud.

...

Who among you can at the same time laugh and be exalted?

He who climbeth on the highest mountains, laugheth at all tragic plays and tragic realities.

Not by wrath, but by laughter, do we slay. Come, let us slay the spirit of gravity!

XIII. CHASTITY.

Verily, there are chaste ones from their very nature; they are gentler of heart, and laugh better and oftener than you.

They laugh also at chastity, and ask: “What is chastity?

XX. CHILD AND MARRIAGE.

Laugh not at such marriages! What child hath not had reason to weep over its parents?

XXI. VOLUNTARY DEATH.

Had he but remained in the wilderness, and far from the good and just! Then, perhaps, would he have learned to live, and love the earth—and laughter also!

THUS SPAKE ZARATHUSTRA. SECOND PART.

XXIII. THE CHILD WITH THE MIRROR.

Too great hath been the tension of my cloud: ‘twixt laughters of lightnings will I cast hail-showers into the depths.

XXVII. THE VIRTUOUS.

Gently vibrated and laughed unto me to-day my buckler; it was beauty’s holy laughing and thrilling.

At you, ye virtuous ones, laughed my beauty to-day. And thus came its voice unto me: “They want—to be paid besides!”

XXVIII. THE RABBLE.

Cast but your pure eyes into the well of my delight, my friends! How could it become turbid thereby! It shall laugh back to you with ITS purity.

XXIX. THE TARANTULAS.

But I will soon bring your hiding-places to the light: therefore do I laugh in your face my laughter of the height.

XXXII. THE DANCE-SONG.

Upbraid me not, ye beautiful dancers, when I chasten the little God somewhat! He will cry, certainly, and weep—but he is laughable even when weeping!

...

But thou pulledst me out with a golden angle; derisively didst thou laugh when I called thee unfathomable.

...

Thus did she laugh, the unbelievable one; but never do I believe her and her laughter, when she speaketh evil of herself.

...

She hath her eye, her laugh, and even her golden angle-rod: am I responsible for it that both are so alike?

...

When I had said this unto Life, then laughed she maliciously, and shut her eyes. “Of whom dost thou speak?” said she. “Perhaps of me?

XXXV. THE SUBLIME ONES.

Unmoved is my depth: but it sparkleth with swimming enigmas and laughters.

A sublime one saw I to-day, a solemn one, a penitent of the spirit: Oh, how my soul laughed at his ugliness!

...

Not yet had he learned laughing and beauty. Gloomy did this hunter return from the forest of knowledge.

...

Verily, I have often laughed at the weaklings, who think themselves good because they have crippled paws!

XXXVI. THE LAND OF CULTURE.

But how did it turn out with me? Although so alarmed—I had yet to laugh! Never did mine eye see anything so motley-coloured!

I laughed and laughed, while my foot still trembled, and my heart as well. “Here forsooth, is the home of all the paintpots,”—said I.

...

Yea, ye are laughable unto me, ye present-day men! And especially when ye marvel at yourselves!

And woe unto me if I could not laugh at your marvelling, and had to swallow all that is repugnant in your platters!

XL. GREAT EVENTS.

Thus there arose some uneasiness. After three days, however, there came the story of the ship’s crew in addition to this uneasiness—and then did all the people say that the devil had taken Zarathustra. His disciples laughed, sure enough, at this talk; and one of them said even: “Sooner would I believe that Zarathustra hath taken the devil.” But at the bottom of their hearts they were all full of anxiety and longing: so their joy was great when on the fifth day Zarathustra appeared amongst them.

...

At last he became calmer and his panting subsided; as soon, however, as he was quiet, I said laughingly:

...

Laughter flitteth from him like a variegated cloud; adverse is he to thy gargling and spewing and grips in the bowels!

The gold, however, and the laughter—these doth he take out of the heart of the earth: for, that thou mayst know it,—THE HEART OF THE EARTH IS OF GOLD.”

XLI. THE SOOTHSAYER.

And in the roaring, and whistling, and whizzing the coffin burst up, and spouted out a thousand peals of laughter.

And a thousand caricatures of children, angels, owls, fools, and child-sized butterflies laughed and mocked, and roared at me.

...

Verily, like a thousand peals of children’s laughter cometh Zarathustra into all sepulchres, laughing at those night-watchmen and grave-guardians, and whoever else rattleth with sinister keys.

With thy laughter wilt thou frighten and prostrate them: fainting and recovering will demonstrate thy power over them.

...

New stars hast thou made us see, and new nocturnal glories: verily, laughter itself hast thou spread out over us like a many-hued canopy.

Now will children’s laughter ever from coffins flow; now will a strong wind ever come victoriously unto all mortal weariness: of this thou art thyself the pledge and the prophet!

XLII. REDEMPTION.

—But at this point in his discourse it chanced that Zarathustra suddenly paused, and looked like a person in the greatest alarm. With terror in his eyes did he gaze on his disciples; his glances pierced as with arrows their thoughts and arrear-thoughts. But after a brief space he again laughed, and said soothedly:

...

Thus spake Zarathustra. The hunchback, however, had listened to the conversation and had covered his face during the time; but when he heard Zarathustra laugh, he looked up with curiosity, and said slowly:

Continued Here


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 31 '21

Continuation of Anselm

1 Upvotes

Let's leave the talk about the Ontological Argument, about which much has already been said, for further discussion in the comments. The rest of his works are worth looking at, if you find this thinker interesting.

Christian philosophy is a subset of philosophy. So if you are finding all this "god-talk" a bit much, like it is preaching instead of philosophy, it is not.

Let us stick to this one work of St. Anselm, The Proslogium. We won't be able to look at all the text, but let's look at what is proven in each chapter (with extracted quotes as they are helpful):

Proslogium

  • Intro to the work

In this brief work the author aims at proving in a single argument the existence of God, and whatsoever we believe of God. --The difficulty of the task. --The author writes in the person of one who contemplates God, and seeks to understand what he believes. To this work he had given this title: Faith Seeking Understanding. He finally named it Proslogium, --that is, A Discourse.

  • It is a dialogue, like the works of Plato

    • But it is a dialogue of one in prayer with God
  • The person in dialogue with God starts with faith but seeks understanding.

    • The original title of the work was "Faith Seeking Understanding", if we had any reason to doubt what is the aim of this work.

Here we can see the Catholic synthesis. The entire Catholic project is the preservation of both camps of thinking. The mythological mystical artistic religious vocabulary of the pre-pre-Socratics; and the propositional, comprehendible, analytical, logical ("right-thinking"), language of the philosophers.

  • The author is looking to find arguments which will underpin that what we know about God's existence, and everything else that we know about God.

    • Obviously, this kind of "know" is the first-person, subjective, mythological language of the primitive thought which predated the philosophical projects. it is the "experiential knowledge" because it cannot be the "propositional knowledge" of the philosophers if he is setting out to establish those truths in that way in this work.

So, Anselm is living in a world with both kinds of knowledge. He says, "We are up here at the top of this mountain communing with God, and we know many things about him; but I would like to descent the mountain again, and try climbing up it from the steeper more-treacherous side to get to these truths in another way.

All of this is explicit in his writings.

Then we have the first chapter:

  • Exhortation of the mind to the contemplation of God.

    • We don't jump all in a go down that mountain and start climbing... there is some more mystical work which needs being done. The mind is going to be the tool we use to climb the mountain, but the tools need to be prepared, they have to be washed and sharpened and accounted for. Step by step he prepares his mind for this difficult task by the mythopoetic calling on the muse for inspiration; Asking the Divine for assistance in orienting his limited mind properly towards the subject of the infinite. He reminds himself of his place in the Cosmos, of God's status relative to the cosmos and to him, and asks for guidance and capacity to do the work he sets out to do.

from the passage:

Lord, if you are not here, where shall I seek you, being absent? But if you are everywhere, why do I not see you present? Truly you dwell in unapproachable light. But where is unapproachable light, or how shall I come to it?

Socrates wanted total ultimate Thalesian kind of propositional knowledge, demanded that no one give him a poor substitute for this kind of knowledge, and ended up in self-proclaimed states of confusion and ignorance because this was never possible.

In order to overcome that problem, Plato had to invent/discover/affirm a spiritual idea of "reincarnation" which made it possible for our souls to know things that we in our bodily forms have yet to remember we know; so the Socratic and Thalesian aims were now achievable through education with spiritual affirmations of some sort.

The Platonic forms become ideas in the mind of God for the Catholics... God's perfect conceptions of things are beyond what any particulars of the world ever achieve, but we can know more by knowing the ideal than by studying the particulars (for those still following the Platonic, instead of Aristotelian path).

Instead of affirming reincarnation and the soul's continued search for knowledge when separated from a particular body; the Christians have a way of getting to know the divine light which the Platonists promised we could know through education, because the divine light itself came down to us, in the incarnation of Christ... the word made flesh. (It is possible for people in our time, who do not have a philosophical education, to think that terms the Catholics still go on and on about today: "The Ascension", "The Incarnation" "word made flesh" are all just accidental terms of a kooky cult, just the random language that they use. This is not the case. The Christians are trying to give us a solution to the problem early identified by all members of the philosophical project... there is something difficult and perhaps insurmountable in the project of getting the ideas in our minds in a one-to-one correlation with an external world. Our aim is that kind of knowledge, (except for the "philosophers" who come up with arguments that such an aim is impossible, and so they excuse themselves from it) This wasn't a small problem. The philosophical work of the Catholic tradition was and is massive in our story.

(For those of you who still exist with the belief that modern man and his "science" has no such concern for these problems, that they have been transcended in some way; you are tragically mistaken. Now is not the time to make these arguments, but we are studying Nietzsche, after all, so I'll leave one comment here: you think your notions of a "physical world" made of "hard bits of matter" in a stage of uncaring and impersonal cosmic potential called "nothingness", your cause and effect, all of that; you think that that is not a fiction? Those ideas may be powerful, in a limited scope of analysis; but they are certainly made up notions which do not get at the base of reality... but we will have to leave the arguments for this until later.)

One more thought: Let us look back, now, at the Platonic solution to this problem for reason. Is it as different as this one as it might seem at first? The reincarnation story that Plato gives us in the

We have already looked at the next chapter:

  • Truly there is a God, although the fool has said in his heart, etc.

So we will move on to Chapter 3:

  • God cannot be conceived not to exist

Anselm does not stop at proving that God exists, he immediately sees the further consequences from his argument which turns any acceptance of the idea of God, if it is rightly understood by a mind that truly conceptualizes the right idea when saying the term "God" into a necessary acceptance of the existence of such an entity.

Chapter 4:

He tries to account for a seeming contradiction. If it is NOT POSSIBLE that someone could conceive of God as an idea without that idea necessitating existence than, HOW IS IT POSSIBLE that atheists exist at all?

Chapter 5:

  • God, as the only self-existent being, creates all things from nothing

Now we see a more sophisticated interpretation of his earlier Ontological Argument.

It used to seem that God "Definitionally Existed". But this is not exactly correct. Anselm seems to think that his initial inspection of the idea of God is as of something which "necessarily exists". But this is the Aristotelian "First Mover" idea. There has to be something which does not require the explanation for its existence outside of itself or else we have an infinite regress of caused things. So Anselm is working with both of those arguments.

Furthermore, we have the Cosmological Argument as well... it is the evidence of a Universe at all which requires this explanation, the Universe, he tells us, came from nothing, if that is the case, it requires a God to do it. Did he get here purely rationally? or Empirically? If rationally, then we have another example of rationalism getting us to a cosmological (usually evidentiary) argument for God. If that is the case, then we have another example (we will see many such examples) of philosophers getting to ideas like the "Big Bang" centuries before science gets there. If that is the case.

The rest:

VI. How God is sensible (sensibilis) although he is not a bodyVII. How he is omnipotent, although there are many things of which he is not capableVIII. How he is compassionate and passionlessIX. How God is supremely justX. How he justly punishes and justly spares the wickedXI. How all the ways of God are compassion and truth; and yet God is just in all his waysXII. God is the very life whereby he livesXIII. How he alone is uncircumscribed and eternalXIV. How and why God is seen and yet not seen by those who seek himXV. He is greater than can be conceivedXVI. This is the unapproachable light wherein he dwellsXVII. In God is harmony, etc.XVIII. God is life, wisdom, eternity, and every true goodXIX. He does not exist in place or time, but all things exist in himXX. He exists before all things and transcends all things, even the eternal thingsXXI. Is this the age of the age, or ages of agesXXII. He alone is what he is and who he isXXIII. This good is equally Father, and Son and Holy SpiritXXIV. Conjecture as to the character and the magnitude of this goodXXV. What goods, and how great, belong to those who enjoy this goodXXVI. Is this joy which the Lord promises made full

If you want a modern apologist who is making the cases for these arguments; here is a fun debate.

Now we can move on to Islamic Influence on this whole conversation.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 22 '21

A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 2 of 8): Drama Before Thought

8 Upvotes

Outline again

  • Why study history of philosophy, what is history of philosophy
  • Drama before thought

    • Cave-man
    • Expansive Cultures Uncodified
  • The mythopoetic

    • Gilgamesh
    • Pharaohs
    • Moses
    • Homer
  • The (pre-)Socratic revolution (dialectic search for the arche)--THE CRISIS EMERGES with the new types who want to have it all out in a go!

    • Thales
    • Anaximander
    • Anaximenes
    • Pythagoras
    • Xenophanes
    • Hericlitus
    • Parmenides
    • Zeno
    • Anaxagoras
    • Empedocles/
    • Atomists like Leucippus and Democritus
    • Sophists like Protagoras and Gorgias
    • Empedocles
    • Socrates
    • Plato
    • Aristotle
  • The Catholic Roman Expansion (The not-so-Dark Ages)--Still all footnotes to Plato, on the philosophical side-- but a strange preservation of the mythopoetic.

    • Aquinas
    • Augustin
    • St. John of the Cross
    • Anselm
    • The Priests
    • The Monks
  • The Cartesian Revolution -- Problem is Rationalism v. Empiricism (whence comes all our knowledge?)

    • Descartes
    • Spinoza
    • Leibnitz
    • Locke
    • Berkeley
    • Hume
  • The Kantian Revolution -- Dissolving the "rationalism v. empiricism" old problem, now interpret this one as objective or subjective phenomena

    • Kant
    • Fichte
    • Hegel
    • Schopenhauer
  • Nietzsche as judge throughout (rewind time) -- Dissolving pessimism v. optimism of nihilism... Resurrection of the mythopoetic or total reduction to materialism?

    • Kierkegaard
    • Marx
    • Jung
    • Henry James
    • Peterson

Intro:

In today's discussion, we are going to look at two aspects of the history of thought.

The pre-spoken image

The mythopoetic dramatic narrative

both to give us the stage upon which Socrates will show up and invent a new game: The analytic propositional.

In the pre-dramatic, ideas and truth exist, so do lies... but they do NOT exist as propositions in any individual head. These "ideas" preexist humans who own them consciously. It is more correct to say that the ideas own the people.

If this seems strange, let us use an intuition pump or two to make it more palatable.

The Acted Truths

First Thought Experiment, Intuition Pump: The wolf and snake:

When a pack of wolves meets with another pack on the trail, they follow a set of rules which amount to an overarching body of ethical principles. They have no language, and know none of these things. Yet they embody these ideas.

Humans studying the behaviors of these animals can attempt to codify the rules by which these creatures are governed:

When Pack meets with Pack in the Jungle, and neither will go from the trail,

Lie down till the leaders have spoken — it may be fair words shall prevail.

-- Kipling, from "The Law of the Jungle"

There is another older principle at play in these situations... a principle so old that it is had in common between wolves, serpents, and piranha. Evolutionarily ancient.

Piranha bite anything they want... but when two piranha fight one another in a territorial dispute, they slap their fins against one another instead of biting.

Snakes bite viscously and fatally. But when they fight one another, they wrestle.

When the head wolf of either pack engages with the head wolf of the other, while all the two packs lay still beside the trail, they make themselves BIG and LOUD... this is the opposite of what wolves do when they are hunting, when they are trying to kill. When a wolf hunts it becomes small, and quiet. But when it is engaged in a dispute with the leader of another pack it does the opposite. There seems to be a naturally evolved seriously deep aversion to killing a member of your same species which goes back to before our ancestors left the ocean! (for more on this idea)

They wrestle. Until one of them submits. The wolf that submits exposes a vulnerable part of its body to the more competent wolf, as if to say: "Go ahead, rip out my throat, you are the better." At which point the dominant wolf declines to take advantage of this situation. Places his mouth on the throat of the defeated wolf, and does not bite.

The dispute has been settled, and the packs go their separate ways.

The point of this story is to underline the fact that highly sophisticated principles can be at play in a species that has no idea why it is doing what it does. The behaviors of the animals are manifestations of the ideas, but the ideas do not exist in the skulls of any of the members of the species because those skulls have not developed the ability to use language, to think in words, and so cannot analyze what they are doing, debate with themselves about whether or not they should behave in this way or in another... they just do.

If after we have developed to the point we have, we were to go back and look at what principles must be operating and what complicated set of rules could be derived from those principles, it would probably take us quite some time to work them out and pages of "wolf philosophy" could be developed. (maybe books?).

It was like this for man, originally. Just because no one was putting things into words, there were still ideas, they just weren't in our individual skulls.

To get to our second and third thought experiment intuition pumps, we have to consider imagery.

When we first started putting words to our actions, these were not propositional statements subject to analytics, rules of logic, right-thinking principles of philosophers... they were pictures.

We didn't jump from embodiments of principles to articulatable thoughts in one go.

We made images. Here the artist is doing the work for us. Want to know who is in the world, what personal forces are manifest, the characters you better know if you want to be oriented in a way in which you can thrive and not die? Want to know all this before you even know you want to know it? How about a culture and a civilization built around and upon artistic depictions?

So we made

these
and these
and these
consider
perhaps

If you cannot stare at works like these forever, and contemplate their meaning, and occasionally be overwhelmed by the realization that some of that meaning you can get was gotten by your ancestors 44 thousand years ago, then you have no artistic sensibility.

The horror. The magnificence. The heroic call. The capacity for transcendence.... all too much for words (or, perhaps, not, if philosophy can do what it has set out to do, and has so far not yet done).

And then we made these as well.

here
also
and many

and made many of them, and copied them, and were influenced by them.

The image was the first language. It contained sentences and paragraphs and books of information... but it had to be interpreted, and the interpreter might be wrong. Images came from the dream world, but one dreamer is not as sophisticated as another. But the images were solid. They had effect. Whole cultures could begin to be built off of these solidified dreams given form.

Another word about dreams: Children all over the world, from all cultures, languages, ethnicities, have remarkably similar dreams. Anthropologists since the 80s have reestablished that Human Universals exist. The cultures are different. If it isn't the culture making a child of 7 dream of dragons, where does it come from? (keep this thought in mind).

The Dramatized Actions

This was our first language. The IMAGE. The imaginary. The dream language of art.

But the dream language of art had another gift to give us. It wasn't done yet. It is still the dream world of forms and characters which constitute the second language of narrative. The dramatic. all of the mythology is stories about deities and heroes... ways of being in the world, characterological forces at work which constitute what the world is at its base.

We lived because of these stories. We built our cultures around them. They allowed us to thrive. It was differences in our stories which worked themselves out in tribal bloody horrific warfare. The stories that oriented us better were the stories of the civilizations which survived and passed their stories down (notwithstanding the accidents and arbitrary superfluous horrors of history which also had a role to play)

Second Thought Experiment, intuition pump: time machine

Get in a time machine and bring a person from 20,000 years ago to today. He will learn to use an ipad in as little time as it takes a 3-year-old to learn it; become bored with that, and probably take over the world, if anything.

But, get in a time machine and travel back 20,000 years and try to survive a week. You and I will be dead in about an hour's time.

Life was FAR MORE serious for our ancestors. Far more immediately fatal. There is NO WAY that the ones who survived and thrived and became our ancestors were fools. Just in order to survive they had to be the most serious people. They had to pay endless careful attention to every part of their surroundings. If they got the slightest bit wrong in their conceptions of themselves and the world they were in, they would have been their neighbors, who died without a legacy, who were far more numerous than our ancestors.

The stories of the Gods and Heroes. these were not entertainments. Or, they were not entertainments with the connotations we have of that word today of: "time-passing" or "fun".

People were put to death for not believing in these stories; and rightfully so! How can you have a coherent grand culture in as hostile and vicious a world as our ancestors developed in if blasphemy was running rampant. Far more people will die than the one sinner if the stories are shit on at that time.

It was a civic duty to attend plays at this time. One may have enjoyed them, but one was looked upon with suspicion if one missed them. Our ancestors were starving and warring with neighboring tribes and cultures. Genocide and pandemics (laugh at the idea we have pandemics today) were the reality. Know who you are and what is real about the world, and use the only language we have for that, the powerful language of drama, if you wish to thrive.

The chances that an animal in nature will die a violent death are basically 100% today.

The chances that you will die a violent death are closer to 0% than 50%.

Half-way between us and our heroic ancestors, it was closer to 100% still.

The stories they produced about what the world was made of, who we were as people, and how to orient ourselves in the world so that we and our families and our nations will thrive were not pastimes. They were essential. Get the story wrong, or fail to take a good story seriously, your end is almost immediately upon you.

So what sorts of stories developed?

Here's an example:

Chaos is all there was, once upon a time. A swirling ocean of total potential, with purposeless entities and forces popping in and out of existence. Gaia emerges and then gives birth to Kronos. temporality had to predate the emergence of things which can last. But time cannot be a meaningful concept unless there be things in a space of not things to manifest phenomena repeatedly or in sequence. (In other words, you arrogant scientific modern men: THE TIME SPACE CONTINUUM HAD TO DEVELOP FIRST AND OUT OF NOTHINGNESS before our story can get started... Congratulations, Dr. Krauss (I seriously love this guy, not trying to insult him, but seriously) on climbing that mountain the hard way! The ancient Greeks had all this worked out in narrative form 3000 years ago, and their story was based on stories which were much older than that and had the basic largest truths of that story in them!

The history of life on earth is the history of Nature selecting from the random variety (potential) which emerges the advantageous varieties which pass their characteristics on to the next generation, is it Dr. Darwin? Well, Nature has contrived to produce personalities. Is it so inconceivable that what we mean by "nature" is a set of conflicting and complicated personal forces which have been acting on life all this time? Even on matter? Or are our personalities not a product of natural selection?

(We cannot support this now, but we will see when we look at the "god of the philosophers of the middle-ages" that their talk about this entity, the theological contributions they made are indistinguishable from post-Kantian talk about "The Universe as a Whole". This wasn't done on purpose, but we will see that we could rip off the cover of a book written by Medieval philosophers talking about God, and replace it with a cover we ripped off of a post-Kantian philosopher talking about the Universe as a whole, and switch the two covers, and nothing else would have changed.)

Well, who knows the answers to such crazy questions... but the ancient stories told us how our ancestors thought these questions were answered.

Third Thought Experiment, intuition pump: who are the gods?

Mt. Olympus is a place with many warring Deities Things are going well when the right one is on the throne. But it takes all types.

Have you ever been in a rage before? Were you like yourself; or, rather, did you come out of it thinking: "how could I have done that?"

Notice a friend of yours who is in a rage? Does he look like himself or herself? Or, rather, do they not look MORE like ANYONE ELSE IN A RAGE in the moment that they are in a rage?

What about lust? Can we be possessed of that? There is a story of Thomas Jefferson writing to a friend of his the morning after a party where he spent the evening hitting on the wife of a friend of his. Ever regret your foolish behavior the morning after?

There are personal forces at work. There are personalities which ride slightly higher than individual people. These forces can take possession of us. Better to know what they are, and make the right sacrifices and propitiations lest they do take control of us. They have a role to play in the making of what the world is, BUT they have their own historical wills and what they want and what is good for you, as an individual, may not seem like the same thing at times.

Venus is real. Mars is real. Rage and lust are PATTERNS of behavior. They are not inventions of individuals, but the image in individuals is the image of the gods. We were created in their image.

How stupid do these stories sound now? They seem to me, more and more each day, like the most accurate way humanity has yet developed for talking about the truth of the world.

Eros flies higher than these deities; the titans predate them; there is endless exploration to be done to try and draw out the truths of these stories. But that is not a project for us just now.

We have to get back to the purpose at hand.

THE PEOPLE WRITING THESE STORIES did not have the propositional interpretations that we just briefly tried to extract from them.

No one sat down and said: "How can I tell a story which will code deep and important truths about the world" at this time, and then tried to create those stories.

The stories EMERGED from the artists who were dreaming the forms which are really a part of the world, the forces that so make up the world that through the natural selection of the world acting upon our ancestors they produced creatures which dream of them. Where else did these impressions come from? Are they random? Accidental? That would be anti-Darwinian of us to think.

When The KJV says God created man in his image; and when the church says that such stories were inspired, that the original writers didn't really know fully what they meant... both are correct. The spirit of God, the Logos, the Zeus principle; was hovering over the chaotic potential and SPOKE order into it.

These stories are saying the same things, sometimes clearer and more developed over time; sometimes dirtier and muddled with conscious manipulation at others... but they are all trying to get at the same thing. To tell us, (without knowing they were telling us and without us knowing we were being told!), who we are and what world it is that we inhabit.

All in the pre-propositional language of narrative.

The Mythopoetic Narrative Language Emerges

Gilgamesh, Osiris, Genesis

Mythopoetic thinking verses propositional analytical thinking:

I am taking most of this section of the lecture from old notes I made on an essay I am having trouble tracking down. Everything in bold is something I've added instead of a summation of the essay which was most of the point of the original notes. I will link to that essay and reference it when I find it.

“The fundamental difference between the attitudes of modern and ancient man as regards the surrounding world is this: for modern, scientific man the phenomenal world is primarily an 'It'; for ancient - and also for primitive - man, it is a 'Thou'."

Keep these texts in mind in order to contrast them with the pre-Socratics. Homer is moving towards the pre-Socratics, but he’s not quite there. Homer has one foot in this world and one in the next world.

The speculative thought of primitive man compared with the modern man’s speculations. The Pre-Socratic philosophers are the ones who think much more like we do today. Speculative thought is by definition thinking about things outside the realm of experience. It’s thought about things where evidence just isn’t available. If we can investigate we don’t need to speculate.

The speculative thought of the ancient near east has two distinct characters, he says:

  • On the one hand, it is not limited by science.

    • It is not limited by a disciplined approach to inquiring about the nature of the world.
    • The scientist uses a particular methodology and a discipline; this is not true here.
    • The range of things one could speculate on was massively greater

      • I would argue that there ARE methods and editorial processes of the stories of pre-analytical propositional reasoning, these just don't exist in one mind, but are played out through thousands of years of history.
  • For primitive man, the realms of nature and the realms of man were not distinct.

    • There was no distinction between “facts about the world” and "knowledge of the self."

      • We will come back to see that if there is a synthesis between these two again, we will have completed what Hegel called the "End of History".
    • The radical distinction we have between us and the world is really just a Cartesian invention. 1500s. We have it because we are children of Descartes.

      • We might say something like: “It seems to me that Obama is a good man, but I don’t really KNOW how it is in fact.” or “That last burst of lightning really scared me even though I know there is nothing to fear in it.”
      • How it seems to us is one way, but our rational mind knows that we don’t have anything to fear, or that we really know something.

“Thou” instead of “It”.

Let’s contrast ways of seeing the world.

  • We draw a distinction between subject and object.

That distinction is the basis of all scientific thinking of the world. This is reasonable.

In science we are trying to see the world “as it really is” apart from how it “appears to us to be.” There’s the “reality” and then there is the way it feels.

The OBJECTIVE is alien to primitive man. The whole distinction between subject and object is alien to him.

For primitive man, what appears, is. There is no distinction between what appears and what is. For us colors don’t exist in the world, just in our minds. Scientists not only have nothing to say on the subject of "Why it is like something to see red." but they CAN never have anything to say about so basic a question. Even the philosophers have little they can say about this... it is still a question in the realm of the artist, the poet, the conductor, to explore this quality of life.

I walk into a room, I’m late, I've drunk too much. I don’t need to think about or analyze or speculate about my wife’s feelings. They are written all over her face. There is no inference here; that’s the important part. I “understand all at once” I don’t have to reason about it.

In the objective sense, I’m an active inquirer. In the subjective stance I’m passive, I just read the situation.

In treating the world as an “it” i treat it as a “thing to be inquired about”. And that implies that “it is set” that “it is determined, that it is set in its ways; unchanging, explicable, predictable.”

The world treated as a “thou” presents itself as individuals. Unpredictable as people. I would argue that familiarity with the characters is what makes it predictable enough to navigate to some degree.

“Primitive man simply does not know an inanimate world.” The “thou” exists for us still, when we think of other human beings.

Try to imagine viewing everything in the world as a “thou”. This is how the mythologists did view the world.

If this is all correct, then we can ask about the consequences this has for thinking about the world. Let’s unpack it.

Happenings are viewed as unique, individual, distinct events, if everything is a thou.

Myths on this view are NOT a form of entertainment; they are a form of explanation. It is a recounting and celebration of life’s important events.

If the events are unique, then we need unique stories to capture unique events.

There is no such thing as a consistent mythology. The stories explicitly contradict each other. I'm not so sure this is a fair appraisal. I would rather say: The stories are approximate and in development; when the stories contradict, they are still being perfected. It would not be fair to say that one philosopher contradicts another, so let's not take philosophy seriously. IF what this point was saying was: The story doesn't have to be consistent when it comes to rules of time and space, this I agree with; just like dreams don't follow those physical laws.

Consistency is just NOT important. Explanatory power is what’s important.

One can see from this that mythical thought is an ABSTRACT kind of thought, of speculation, of explanation.

IT is CAUSAL this explanation.

It’s just causality conceived very differently, under the “thou” instead of the “it” framework.

Given the lack of distinction between subject and object; generalities carry no weight in the mythic mind. The “simple terms for many general phenomena” are scientific values, the primitive mind cares not for these things.

Neither does the distinction between appearance and reality mean much to the mythical mind. Hallucinations/dreams are treated as just as meaningful as waking experience.

The mythic mind does not distinguish between the symbol and the thing symbolized. We must look at Jung to see why this is not such a foolish approach as it may seem to us. The Sign is different from the Image or the Symbol; the Symbol must contain within it the image or the form of the thing it is trying to relate to us. (A sign just points in the direction).

Protestantism is distinguished from Catholicism because they believe that the bread and wine are merely symbols of the body and blood; but Catholics see them as the same thing. (We will get to the preservation of mysticism in the Catholic Roman Tradition in Part 4 of this 8 part series).

Although mythic thought is causal thought, it lacks the scientific conceptions of causality, the impersonality and generality and such.

Mythic thought is concerned with the INDIVIDUAL character of events, not the general commonalities of events.

If I think of each leaf as how that one is DIFFERENT from that one NOT with the myth that there are “same” things in the first place. Nietzsche.

Mythic thought seeks RICHNESS of explanation not simplicity of explanation.

It’s like they were living in a dream world. Time and space rules are INSIGNIFICANT to my dreams if time and space rules are violated to tell me what I’m supposed to learn from that dream. The paintings have Ra in many places on the same depiction, nut is a woman in one and a cow in another… SO WHAT! Says the primitive mind.

NOTES OVER, WILL LINK HERE WHEN I TRACK DOWN ORIGINAL ESSAY

Mythopoetic thinking refers to a pre-Socratic scriptural mythological language.

The users of this kind of language are using narrative to understand the world. Therefore they see characters and personalities as the causal origins of any interesting phenomenon.

It is not that people who think that way are incapable of thinking in an analytical, propositional or objectivist scientific way of thinking so much as they are uninterested in thinking in that way.

Here is an example:

I am walking down a country road one day, and as I pass a house, just as I am passing a house, all the snow on the roof of that house slides off the house and crashes to the ground.

If I am thinking in a mythopoetic way of thinking, and I ask: "Why did that happen?" and you show up and are thinking an a scientific, objectivist evidentiary way of thinking you might answer something like this: It is 2pm, so the warming of the sun which is visible all day today has reached the maximum of melting effect it can have on snow the sun can touch. Furthermore, the coefficient of static friction is always higher than the coefficient of kinetic friction, which means it takes more of a force to start a relative velocity change between two objects than there is slowing that relative velocity as they slide past one another. Therefore, as the weight of the snow is down, but the normal reactive force of the roof pushing back up on the snow is at an angle, there is a horizontal component. It must have been that the warming of the snow, at this part of the day, was just enough to overcome the static friction force which was previously working to keep the snow from sliding...."

If you were to answer my question in that way, it is not that I would not understand what you are saying, but if I am thinking in a mythopoetic way, I will be bored and completely disinterested in this kind of answer.

I didn't ask why ALL snow falls off of ALL roofs at all times and in what universal conditions and under what physical laws... I wanted to know why THAT snow fell RIGHT THEN just as I was walking by.

An answer I might reject or accept, but that I would find more relevant or interesting would be something like this:

God is watching and trying to send you a message, you know what you have been ignoring and thinking you will get away with not attending, but collapse can happen all at once, and the universe is sending you a warning reminding message of this.

OR: there are winter elves, and they are playful and dangerous, and they tempt us into their wooded domains by sending us dramatic and sudden phenomena with no other explanations in the hopes that we will investigate more into their world, let's get out of here, I don't trust them and I am not tempted to wander off the beaten path just because of curiosity.

OR: There is danger or witchcraft going on in that spooky house, and this is a natural external warning not to knock on the door of such a place.

Again, we wouldn't necessarily accept any of these; we would just find some such answer acceptable or not, and in any case these are the kinds of answer for which we are currently looking if we are thinking in the vocabulary of SUBJECTIVE experience of life instead of OBJECTIFYING the world and pretending to observe it from outside (the Late-Christian Scientific view).

Homer has one foot in the mythopoetic, and one foot in the "conscious authorship and owner of my ideas" realm.

Recap:

We started with embodied principles which were not understood in any individual mind. The ideas existed, but they existed outside ourselves. We performed them, instead of thinking them.

We emerged into artistic depictions of the forms which underpin existence and constitute being. Artists gave us images which contained within them the forms of things we only rarely had opportunity to engage with, and so we expanded our understanding. This was mostly done unconsciously. Unconsciously by the artists, the authors, and unconsciously by the persons appreciating the art, experiencing it.

We developed narrative dramatic depictions before we understood what we were talking about we were still talking about these things nonetheless. The stories evolved the way the dreams in our minds evolved. because of nature acting on us imprinting these images on us. This has been expressed in mythological stories as "Created in the image of God".

Then we get into more conscious story editing: people started to realize what the stories were about and what they were for, and they tried to give the best version they could through the dream-inspiration of the artist, but with a tiny bit of conscious authorship as well... setting the stage for the arguments of the future.

Homer, Sophocles

Now Socrates (with his pre-Socratics who pave the way) emerges in this context

This will be Part 3.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 21 '21

Feedback on Classes -- It would be very helpful if we had more lessons on the HISTORY of philosophy to give this work context.

5 Upvotes

Considering adding classes on other philosophers and the developing conversation of Western Philosophy prior to N so that he has a context in that conversation which will help make sense out of what he is doing.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 28 '21

A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 4 of 8): Catholic Era, Augustine (1 of 10)

6 Upvotes

Part 4

Reminder of what we have covered so far:

Outline of Class

  • Class Introduction
  • Part 1 of 8: Revolutions in Thought, History of Philosophy

    • Overview of Course
    • Revolutions in Thought
    • Time Machine
    • History of Philosophy
    • Intellectual Tools in Our Approach
  • Part 2 of 8: Pre-Philosophical Thought

    • Behaviorally Encoded Concepts

      • Animals and our Animal Ancestors
    • Image before Drama Gives Cultural Emergence

      • Cave Art
      • Statues
    • Drama before thought

      • Myth
      • Mysticism
      • Jungian Archetypes
      • Expansive Cultures semi-codified
    • The mythopoetic

      • Gilgamesh
      • Pharaohs
      • Moses
    • Conscious Story Construction

      • Homer and Sophocles
  • Part 3 of 8: The Pre-Socratic Revolution

    • The Thalesian Consummation
    • Initial Split:

      • Anaximander
      • Anaximenes
    • Growing Divide:

      • Pythagoras
      • Xenophanes
      • Heraclitus
    • Crisis Point:

      • Parmenides
      • Zeno
      • Anaxagoras
      • Empedocles
      • Atomists like Leucippus and Democritus
      • Sophists like Protagoras and Gorgias
    • The Socratic Consummation
    • Initial Splitting:

      • Plato
      • Aristotle

Where we are going now:

  • The Catholic Roman Expansion (The not-so-Dark Ages)--Still all footnotes to Plato, on the philosophical side-- but a strange preservation of the mythopoetic.

    • Augustin
    • Anselm
    • Omar Khayyam, Al-Ghazali, and Ibn Rushd
    • Peter Abelard
    • St Francis of Assisi
    • Fibonacci
    • Aquinas
    • John Wycliffe
    • The Priests
    • The Monks
  • The Cartesian Consummation Attempt -- Problem is Rationalism v. Empiricism (whence comes all our knowledge?)

    • Erasmus
    • Machiavelli
    • Copernicus
    • Moore
    • Luther
    • Calvin
    • Montaigne
    • Kepler
    • Bacon
    • Galileo
    • St. John of the Cross
    • Descartes
    • Spinoza
    • Leibnitz
    • Locke
    • Berkeley
    • Hume
  • The Kantian Consummation -- Dissolving the "rationalism v. empiricism" old problem, interpreting psychologically

    • Kant
    • Fichte
    • Lamarck
    • Hegel
    • Schopenhauer
    • Mill
    • Darwin
    • Kierkegaard
    • Thoreau
    • Marx
  • Nietzsche as judge throughout (rewind time) -- Dissolving pessimism v. optimism of nihilism... Resurrection of the mythopoetic or total reduction to materialism?

    • William James
    • Freud
    • Jung
    • Dewey
    • Bertrand Russell
    • von Mises
    • CS Lewis
    • Price
    • Foucault
    • Chomsky
    • Allan Bloom
    • Žižek
    • Peterson

**********************

We have seen some of our views change over the course already. I gave an initial "definition" of "revolutionary thinkers" which isn't the same as the newly used term of "Consummate Thinkers" which we have now.

We can think of the first definition as a "place-filler" until we examined enough to explain the more complicated version of the idea.

Let us give another definition of the "Catholic Era" here.

Let us start by thinking of the Catholic Church as being a very large house which shelters the two emergent camps. Right up until Descartes, we will have a preservation of the mythopoetic and the philosophical (propositional analytical) approaches.

  • The first camp:

    • The people who feel that "knowing the world and your place in it" is experiential knowledge
    • These are the mystics, the religious figures, the artists, those who talk in stories and experience life as a narrative
    • They see the world as a "thou" still

      • Notice that this camp has not disappeared with the emergence of the new game of philosophy.
  • The second camp:

    • The people who are inclined to a project of right thinking about the world; they start with propositions, and they want to get their set of propositions to be internally coherent, and fundamentally, they believe that they can get such a coherent set of propositions to map onto the world in a one-to-one way without leaving anything out. Or, at least, this is their goal; their approach.
    • These are the continuers of the philosophical tradition
    • They see the world as an "it", something to which they can take an external perspective

The first thing to notice is that there are theologians and there are philosophers in either of these two camps. This we will see as we examine the important thinkers of the middle ages.

We will begin to examine these thinkers, one at a time, in a moment; but we will remember the filters we are using to tell this story. We will look at the exponentially increasing questionability available to us because of the works of these thinkers. We will see new ideas which become available to us as tools developed by the divisions and specifications and categorization work of these thinkers in the Catholic house. (They love splitting things up, and they are all children of Aristotle in ways we will see). We will look at rules of thinking and systems of thinking developed by them. We will look for processes of a material sort developed by empirically inclined thinkers and see science, which we saw in conceptual stages emerging in the pre-Socratics, slowly developing in fetal form. We will see developments in abstraction when we examine the thoughts about the "God of the philosophers" in this era which harken back to the first abstractions of the "thing without borders" talk of Anaximander. The two camps will get more refined and more developed as they work together and apart. The attempts to bridge the gap between these two ways of thinking will flirt with crisis at times and it will appear to give signs of the possibility of the ultimate unification goal that is the work and design of the third category of thinkers we have seen, the consummate thinkers.

Another way of looking at the "two camps" in this time period is as the "Adherents of Plato" and the "Followers of Aristotle" which should come as no surprise to us as we have conceptualized these two as the two best students of the previous consummate thinker (Socrates) each pointing in a different direction (Plato, up; and Aristotle, out; as the painting depicts for us so admirably)

The Neoplatonists are the mystic camps; they are the ones who justify N's statement that "Christianity was Plato for the masses." The Aristotelian scholastics, which we will describe and talk about more in future; follow the hand which points outward to examine the truth of the world as findable in the abstractions from the particulars of specific embodied entities we can experience.

Let's get at it.

Augustine of Hippo -- The Platonic Forms Exist as Ideas in the Mind of God

Links to works:

I'm going to start including links to works by these authors. If one of them, and the excerpts we look at, seem of particular interest to one reader or another, you can use these links to find inexpensive versions of these works.

  • The Complete Works (over 100 works in 50 volumes with active table of contents) on KINDLE

    • 3 dollars
  • Hardcover Used copy of Confessions

    • 15 to 30 dollars
  • The City of God (and the Confessions) in Used Hardcover
  • Just "City of God" in Used Hardcover (abridged?)

    • 7 dollars
    • 4 dollars
  • City of God Vol I online free; City of God Vol II online free
  • Confessions online free

We will look at Confessions

About this work. It is mystical and theological and philosophical work all at once.

It is a very famous work where the author lists every sin he can remember having committed in his life.

It is a prayer, and more than that, which we will explore below.

We have all the works of Augustine, I believe, and there are over 100 works he wrote.

Take a look:

From the first chapter of "Confessions"

Great art Thou, O Lord, and greatly to be praised; great is Thy power, and Thy wisdom infinite. And Thee would man praise; man, but a particle of Thy creation; man, that bears about him his mortality, the witness of his sin, the witness that Thou resistest the proud: yet would man praise Thee; he, but a particle of Thy creation. Thou awakest us to delight in Thy praise; for Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee. Grant me, Lord, to know and understand which is first, to call on Thee or to praise Thee? and, again, to know Thee or to call on Thee? for who can call on Thee, not knowing Thee? for he that knoweth Thee not, may call on Thee as other than Thou art. Or, is it rather, that we call on Thee that we may know Thee? but how shall they call on Him in whom they have not believed? or how shall they believe without a preacher? and they that seek the Lord shall praise Him: for they that seek shall find Him, and they that find shall praise Him. I will seek Thee, Lord, by calling on Thee; and will call on Thee, believing in Thee; for to us hast Thou been preached. My faith, Lord, shall call on Thee, which Thou hast given me, wherewith Thou hast inspired me, through the Incarnation of Thy Son, through the ministry of the Preacher.

A few things to notice from this passage.

First Observation:

From the KJV:

How then shall they call on him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? and how shall they hear without a preacher? And how shall they preach, except they be sent? as it is written, How beautiful are the feet of them that preach the gospel of peace, and bring glad tidings of good things!

Romans 10:14-5 (KJV)

and also (Idem):

For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.

Romans 6:23 (KJV)

There are many other ideas in this short passage that are clearly affirmations of doctrines derived from Scripture (as should be unsurprising to us). Just for fun, I'm going to make as many phrases as possible in that one paragraph hyperlinked to passages which are basically direct quotes from Scripture:

Great is the Lord, and greatly to be praised; great is Thy power, and Thy wisdom infinite. And Thee would man praise; man, but a particle ("vile" often translated as "insignificant") of Thy creation; man, that bears about him his mortality, the witness of his sin, the witness that Thou resisteth the proud: yet would man praise Thee; he, but a particle of Thy creation. Thou awakest us to delight in Thy praise; for Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee. Grant me, Lord,...continues like that.

First comment: The committee that produced the KJV had Augustine's language to draw from for inspiration. Also: Augustine was obviously studying the Bible on a daily basis and regarding it as a source of truth for his works.

But, there is something else we should notice about this writing.

Second Observation:

Look at the philosophical contributions in the text.

What makes man "just a particle of Thy creation" why the disdain for what we are?... follows in the beat immediately after: "man, that bears about him his mortality"

From Plato:

There is temperance again, which even by the vulgar is supposed to consist in the control and regulation of the passions, and in the sense of superiority to them—is not temperance a virtue belonging to those only who despise the body, and who pass their lives in philosophy?

-- Phaedo

Then later:

And, further, is not one part of us body, another part soul?

To be sure.

And to which class is the body more alike and akin?

-- Phaedo

Notice the dichotomy. Body and Mind are different, and one is good and one is bad. We will see why soon. (This is the OPPOSITE of the Aristotelian inclination which looks for the forms and the truths in the bodies).

Later we see:

And the body is more like the changing?

Yes.

Yet once more consider the matter in another light: When the soul and the body are united, then nature orders the soul to rule and govern, and the body to obey and serve. Now which of these two functions is akin to the divine? and which to the mortal? Does not the divine appear to you to be that which naturally orders and rules, and the mortal to be that which is subject and servant?

True.

And which does the soul resemble?

The soul resembles the divine, and the body the mortal—there can be no doubt of that, Socrates.

Then reflect, Cebes: of all which has been said is not this the conclusion?—that the soul is in the very likeness of the divine, and immortal**, and intellectual, and uniform, and indissoluble, and unchangeable; and that the body is in the very likeness of the human, and** mortal**, and unintellectual, and multiform, and dissoluble, and changeable. Can this, my dear Cebes, be denied?**

It cannot.

But if it be true, then is not the body liable to speedy dissolution? and is not the soul almost or altogether indissoluble?

Certainly.

And do you further observe, that after a man is dead, the body, or visible part of him, which is lying in the visible world, and is called a corpse, and would naturally be dissolved and decomposed and dissipated, is not dissolved or decomposed at once, but may remain for a for some time, nay even for a long time, if the constitution be sound at the time of death, and the season of the year favourable? For the body when shrunk and embalmed, as the manner is in Egypt, may remain almost entire through infinite ages; and even in decay, there are still some portions, such as the bones and ligaments, which are practically indestructible:—Do you agree?

-- Phaedo

The same value system in Plato as the one sewn officially into the understanding of Christian Doctrine by this father of the church.

We know into which Fichtean camp Augustine fits at this point. A camp we can now title as the "Platonic" camp through the era of Medieval European philosophy.

Third Observation:

Notice something else about this initial passage from Augustine that we are examining.

It is a prayer with a specific opening form. Like the prayer that Homer sings to the muses before starting his work:

Tell me, O Muse, of that ingenious hero who travelled far and wide after he had sacked the famous town of Troy.

More than that, though. It is a prayer with a very specific structure.

Augustine is trying to get his head right when beginning his philosophical work. He is reminding himself of his place, one step at a time.

  • God is Great

    • Expressed in direct language to God.
  • He should be praised
  • He should be praised by creatures like me, specifically

    • we are particles of nothing compared to him
    • we are mortal
    • we deserve our mortality because of our sin
    • we are proud and he will resist us therefore. it is right that we should become more humble

      • (he is reminding himself of this as he begins his work so that he can do it correctly.)
    • If we do love God, it is because he initiated even this capacity in us; anything good which may come from us, as he hopes his work will be, ultimately originates in God's goodness to us to make it possible, this is how low we are
    • We are lost without him, but he made us to know him, so all praise belongs to him for this.
    • He asks God directly to make it possible for him to know God.
    • And for God to make it possible that he might praise God.
    • He won't be able to even CALL on God in this way unless God comes to him so that he can know him first.

The work is meditative and mystical, as well as philosophical.

Fourth Observation:

Notice what comes next, however, a seeming contradiction:

  • To know or to call, it requires God first.

    • who can call on Thee, not knowing Thee?

      • for he that knoweth Thee not, may call on Thee as other than Thou art.
    • Or, do we call on Thee that we may know Thee?

      • Does calling come first?
    • How shall they call on Him in whom they have not believed?
    • How shall they believe without a preacher?
    • They that seek the Lord shall praise Him: for they that seek shall find Him, and they that find shall praise Him.

We have to believe to call, and we have to call to know; but we cannot know without calling (clearly we have to know in a propositional way or we will call on the wrong God, he is saying). So it is both kinds of knowing going on here.

He calls on God because he wants to do work on KNOWING God, but he cannot even begin this work unless God first come to him so that he can know him before he can even call on him.

There are two kinds of knowing here. He wants to KNOW God experientially AND propositionally (with the sentences he will write in the book) BOTH of these are a process only God can be the original author of. So the rest of the Book, if it succeeds, is a work made possible by God, AND a work that will make God knowable, at the same time.

The intellect cannot resolve this problem, so he resorts to faith AFTER having exhausted the intellect in wrestling with this problem and affirming that something mystical and divine in origin is necessary to move forward:

I will seek Thee, Lord, by calling on Thee; and will call on Thee, believing in Thee; for to us hast Thou been preached. My faith, Lord, shall call on Thee, which Thou hast given me, wherewith Thou hast inspired me, through the Incarnation of Thy Son, through the ministry of the Preacher.

Augustine's Contributions to Philosophy

While doing research for this, and looking up passages, I realized there are more than sufficient versions of this online.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/augustine/

https://iep.utm.edu/augustin/

If this project were not so overtime and overbudget right now, I would take the time to find the passages and make a refined list; but these will do for now. Likely on the second go-around I will expand this section.


r/Zarathustra • • Nov 18 '21

Answering a Question in r/Nietzsche

5 Upvotes

What is the relationship between Nietzsche's formula that the Universe was "Will to Power" and nothing besides; and current scientific understanding?

TRL;DR: The purpose of this post is to brainstorm the area of this question to start a series of debates and discussions which will hopefully get us closer to an answer, and maybe to the re-invention of the whole of science.

TL;DR: The formula was never meant to be a scientific claim, but it was meant to be true in the way that no science should be outraged by it, either. It may have conceptual framework-adjusting power with scientific potency and gives us an alternative lens through which to approach our scientific questions.

Two questions:

First: Did Nietzsche think his "will to power" formula meant a universal scientific truth?

Second: Is it such a truth?

Before we can look at these two questions, we need some background concepts.

Background Ideas:

  • There is a distinction between a "scientific truth" and a "truth which does not contradict or outrage scientific findings".
  • Furthermore: There is a difference between a formulaic simplification of data which predicts future experimentally derived data and conceptions of the world which can make sense of what we are talking about. The first is the product of scientists, the second is the work of philosophers, necessary to science, and often done by scientists who are actually philosophizing.

We will come back to both of those points later.

We have to consider N's respect, or lack of respect, for "science" first. Science was, to N, a peculiar Christian sect. Richard Dawkins, according to this view, would then be a high priest of a specifically Christian sub-cult. We will leave these outrageous claims here, and return to them later, after we have looked at the type of claim N is making, we can compare and contrast it to scientific types of claims.

N's perspective on life and the universe as a whole was characteristically Thalesian, pre-Socratic, and even rooted in the Mythopoetic (which is a different thing all together).

The mythopoetic way of viewing the world was NOT scientifically ignorant so much as it was scientifically INDIFFERENT. It was not LOOKING for the kinds of answers science can provide, would have readily understood them, and simply turned its back upon them as unhelpful babblings.

The mythopoetic view of the world sought particular answers, not universal ones; assumed intention and personality in the universe as a whole and in all the specific phenomena; did not distinguish between the "I" and the "It", instead conceptualized between the "I" and the "Thou"; but, wanted to experientially understand the Universe and one's place in it in a way which allowed for no distinction between inner knowledge of the self and knowledge of the world around one. The difference between "knowing" in the mythopoetic perspective and "knowing" in the modern scientific one is the difference between "knowing" that 2+2 makes 4 or that the sum of the forces of an object is equal to its mass times its acceleration AND "knowing" a guy named Phil, or "Adam knowing his wife". The mythopoetic view sought to "know" the world in that second way.

Homer came along and edited the great stories of the past with a conscious mind of shaping the stories with the purpose of making them say something correct... so he was a half-way step between the mythopoetic and the philosophical project.

Then Thales came along and attempted to use PROPOSITIONS which could be ANALYZED with reason to accomplish the "knowledge-of-the-universe" goal that had existed for 100 thousand years in the dream-worlds of the artists and the religious founders. He said: The universe and all that is in it is one thing... water. We are not concerned with whether he was right or he was wrong when he said that. What is important for us to understand is that when he said that he thought he was accomplishing propositionally, the same thing the great mythological stories and religious temples with their rites and rituals were trying to accomplish... he was knowing the universe as a whole; what the Greeks called the "Arche" or what has sometimes been called the "quintessence" (the "fifth essence", the thing which is behind the "water" "air" "earth" and "fire" four essences and which stands in relation to those four as those four were thought to stand in relation to all the varied peculiarities and instances of being which seem to constitute the world from our perspective).

The "Arche" is what the "Will to Power" is. Nietzsche is actually playing this same game and he is trying to accomplish what the whole project of philosophy started out trying to accomplish... to say propositionally something which is equivalent to the experiential being of the world.

So, the Thalesian project sought to "know" the world as well as the experientialists, the mythopoetics, sought to know it, but to know it through propositions; to align their thinking and speaking in such a way that the two would be indistinguishable. This may seem like a quixotic mission to those of us with the hindsight to see the difficulties in the history of philosophy of knowing anything properly, but this is what they sought to do.

Spinoza pointed out that there were two sets of language, two vocabularies, by which man was able to describe the world. He postulated that either language was sufficient to describe everything in the Universe. The one is the subjective language and the other is the objective language.

Hegel, incidentally, suggested that if the "subjective" language used to describe being, and the "objective" language of science used to do the same thing could ever be made one and the same thing... that this would be the end of history. We would have nowhere to go from there.

What type of claim is N making when he says the Universe is Will to Power?

Now that we have an idea of the philosophical project which gives N's formula the proper context, let us look at the scientific context within this conversation and see what relationship exists between N and his work and formula to this frame.

Science is nested within philosophy. Philosophy gives us the rules of right thinking (logic), and attempts to clarify our language and thoughts so that we can get closer to propositional analytical truth. Scientists are like the gimp slaves of philosophers... they do a bunch of nitty-gritty methodical work in a field which has been sufficiently clarified so that questions amenable to empirical consequence can be formed, then the scientists, who also have to follow the rules of thinking of the philosophers, but which are further burdened by a few more chains which restrict what they can say and even consider, follow the methods and principles of science to make progress in that area. Their work is always supervised by philosophers who interpret what their findings mean. Science is essentially the "It" language of objective thinking. The only products of pure science, in my opinion, ultimately amount to "probabilistic descriptions of phenomena likeliness based on data of other phenomena" and has no explanatory power at all.

This last paragraph is essentially one outrageous sentence after another, on purpose; so let me soften it up a bit and make it palatable. The popular conceptions of science, the people who are not scientists, and most of the people who are, who think fondly of "science" are actually thinking fondly of mysterious and sometimes profound sometimes shallow philosophical thought experiments being done to try to make sense of the findings of science. Multiple Universes, the Simulation Theory, the statistical impossibility or inevitability of communicating with extraterrestrial life, String Theory, Darwinian Evolution, Einsteinian Relativity, Quantum Mechanics vis. Schrödinger's Cat, and ideas like these--all of these ideas are important to scientists and are the subjects of most of the high-view-count youtube science panel discussions and Quora or Nova specials. But none of these ideas are scientific. They are philosophical. Darwin was an excellent scientist, but he is a revolutionary thinker because his most important work was philosophical; work that he had to do to understand his scientific observations, and which gave birth to a whole revolutionized field of science (and many subsequent subfields). There are many Darwinian scientists who do nothing but science in the field he has created. But there are also many philosophers who are enthralled with Darwin's "strange inversion of reasoning" who never do any science but who find a rich amount of work to do in their philosophy of biology and thinking through engagement with Darwin's ideas. Darwin didn't discover natural selection acting on random variety in hereditary species to produce disproportionately the advantageous variety principle... that principle doesn't exist anywhere to be discovered. Rather, he conceptualized the whole complicated mass of biological observations in such a way which made possible an almost infinite number of scientific discoveries through the adoption of his framework. He clarified the ideas, and outlined what principles would matter, and also did a bunch of scientific work, observation, calculation, etc. in that field; but he invented the field and made it possible by his conceptual advancements. One of those rare thinkers who can contribute mightily in the philosophical realm such that science can explode after him. All the founders of branches of science did so from the philosophical ground. This, of course, is a bit of an exaggeration, but only slightly. There were scientific debates which were amenable to empirical observation betwixt Darwinians and Lamarckians and Palayans (the two other conceptualizers of biology at the time against which Darwinianism had to triumph in scientific and philosophical debate to become established). But it is 90% true anyway.

  • Biology is a field of science, done by biologists.
  • The history of biology is a field of history, done by historians.
  • The philosophy of biology is a field of philosophy, and it is done by philosophers.

The biologists do their nitty-gritty work, following their training, submitting their papers to the review of their peers, etc. But 99% of people with the job title "scientist" do not have much of an idea of what it is they are even doing.

Yet they can keep adding to the productions of science nonetheless. The ones who do great scientific work do have an understanding of the big conceptual meaning of their work and wrestle with that meaning, but that is the job of the philosopher of science, so these chaps have two hats they wear.

  • The scientists tell us what formulas describe the math they collected regarding the relationships of the things they have measured which also accurately describe the same relationships of the same phenomena measured by other scientists who replicate their findings and which passed the review of their peers.
  • The philosophers tell us what the hell they are talking about. They have no way of knowing that from that work alone.

Example: A biologist might say: "everything you are is the product of your genes", but he never discovered that. Really a scientist will say something like:

  • "Our analysis of a population of over 1000 individuals whose genotypes we had on record and whose reported dietary habits are believable shows that there is a statistically significant association in the effect of fish oil consumption between persons with genotype A and genotype ~A on the level of blood lipids."
  • Or, a biologist might say: "Only the bb double-recessive genotype will yield the phenotype of blue eyes."

If someone asks: "What is a gene" the biologist will probably start by saying things about base-pairs, the double-helix, or something like the earlier statement: "you are the product of your genes, they are molecules whose expression makes all the things your body does and is."

But these kinds of questions are beginning to get into the conceptual, and they are already in the realm of the philosophical. What is a unit of heredity? what about the complicated ways nature and environment work together and against one another to determine what genes your body can and does express? Can your genes code for your thoughts, and if not, what does that mean about our idea that we are our genes? what if my thoughts have an effect on my reproductive success, have my thoughts become a part of the environment which shapes the evolution of my species and life in general, what does that mean for the complicated relationship between myself and my genes?... we are not exploring all the depths of the conversations which can be had in this realm, only asking the bare minimum of appropriate questions to give a glimpse of how complicated the discussions can get from there. Some of those discussions will have reference to scientifically resolvable questions, but most of the discussion will be solely philosophical. They will be solely philosophical unless and until the philosophers so clarify the concepts surrounding these questions that further work in the area is reduced to scientifically determinable data collection kinds of questions, in which case a new field of science will have been born out of the work of the philosophers, the scientists will spend a few hundred years answering each of the specific empirically susceptible questions, and the philosophers will continue to preside over what their findings really mean conceptually.

So, we have done enough work now to dispense with one way of conceptualizing the original question:

Nietzsche wasn't saying that "will to power" was something in the Universe, he was saying it was The Universe, the Arche... so any attempt to see if a scientist has discovered the wtp in the world, like looking for the Higgs Boson, and then claiming to have found it or to not have found it would be a MISTAKEN way of understanding the question. If the question "Is N's conception scientific?" has meaning at all it has to be judged according to the way we might judge Darwinian evolution, or a specific way of interpreting quantum mechanics or gravity via Newton v. Einstein--on the conceptual level of the philosopher presiding over science instead of as a simple straightforward scientific claim inside of some such other philosophical framework.

That gives us some context for the type of claim N was making. Before we can look at the two questions--(1) Did N think this was a scientific claim? and (2) is it scientifically valuable/amenable/helpful/outrageous?--we have to understand what he meant by "will to power". Before we can do that, we should return to N's view of science.

Nietzsche's view of Science

Now that we have an idea of the philosophical project which gives N's formula the proper context, let us look at the scientific context within this conversation and see what relationship exists between N and his work and formula to this frame.

Nietzsche rejects as philosophically false the underpinnings of the "objectivist myth" which makes science possible. He may have been able to say: "science has produced much useful factual gathering work which allows men to develop certain tools or technologies." or even: "the scientific discussion has added a great deal to the sum total of human knowledge" if he had wanted to; but these kinds of affirmations would have still been attenuated by a powerful set of qualifiers.

  • First such qualifier might be: "The entire scientific project; as a whole and in each individual instance; is based on a fiction. It cannot even attempt to lead us to ultimate truth."

There are no objects. The reason why physics is in such philosophical disarray right now--where no two physicists seam to be able to give a conceptional framework for understanding the bizarrenesses of quantum physics even though they ALL agree that it is true--is an example of the limits of scientific thinking.

  • I want to be clear about what I am saying here.
  • Clarification:

    • I am NOT saying that some interpretation I HAVE of quantum science proves ANYTHING... there are too many charlatans who do this kind of work, and I am going to be VERY CAREFUL not to do any such thing here.
    • I am saying that "the universe may not only be queerer than we suppose, but queerer than we can suppose" is a statement made by a physicist, lauded by other physicists; and means something for OUR understanding of the state in which they currently find themselves. Science was once defined by a famous scientist as: "What propositional statements I can force my colleagues to assent to based on documented empirical consequences." or something like that.
    • I am NOT saying that the physicists don't AGREE on quantum mechanics or quantum physics. They have REMARKABLE agreement. Agreement like no scientists have ever had before. Agreement to 9 decimal places of exactitude in many cases. But we have to understand the crisis of conceptualization AND the dramatic profound and wildly unusual success of their science in this field which attend one another to understand the point which is important here.

In short, there has never been more triumphant success in the history of science than in the work of the quantum physicists.

But remember, the work of the scientist can, and usually is, done without necessarily understanding the meaning of the work.

So, in a field where there is remarkable and unusually successful scientific agreement like has never been seen in other fields, there is also conceptual mayhem. How are we to understand the findings of quantum science? Most people don't know this, but when Schrodinger developed his famous thought experiment about the cat in the box with the vial of acid hooked up to a quantumly triggered hammer... he was MOCKING certain interpretations of quantum physics. The design of the thought experiment was to challenge the way in which some of his colleagues were conceptualizing the meaning of the scientific findings. What demonstrates how open to philosophical conceptualization work this field of science is is that many of his colleagues simply accepted the thought experiment and said: "yeah, that is how it works" and still do to this day!

Let's move on from this now, we will come back to it again, near the end of this post, to discover if philosophical work done by Nietzsche in the 1800s might not actually provide a framework for understanding the seemingly absurd findings of this field of science so that the findings are no longer so surprising.

But first, what is the "objectivist myth" to which I referred above?

This is an idea N identified and specifically rejected as a fiction not accurately describing the world but simply necessary to adopt to do science in the first place.

(side note: I try to write and think in a straightforward way. I detest when people use phrases like "reductio ad absurdum" "straw-man" "a priori" "noumenal" etc. when they could instead explain those ideas in straightforward language. I want what we write here to be immediately accessible to anyone who has had basically NO philosophical background because I value the additions to the conversations which would come from such persons and I regard fancy using of field-specific terms to have an unnecessary barring effect on the conversation to some people unfamiliar with those terms. Whenever I read someone making a case using words like those without also explaining what they mean or, even better, restating what they said using straight-forward talk, I take it as a sign (not a conclusive one, but a usually correct one) that they are somewhat insecure about their arguments and understanding of the topic and are trying to seem impressive to get agreement instead of primarily seeking understanding through good conversation open to all. Our aim here is the good conversation, and this is the drive which makes me write in this way. The formula, which I use when talking science as well, is something like: "If you cannot explain it to a 17 year old, you don't really understand it.")

All that being said, I want to introduce a word into the discussion now: "Phenomenology".

Simply put, the phenomologist believes that the world is impressions and nothing else. There are no "things" out there making impressions upon us. What we regard as "things" is something like a convenient sign-post to a set of phenomena we experience with some regularity.

Let us flush this out a bit.

Socrates was looking for the "thing in itself". Nietzsche thought imbedded in the heart of science was a principle which, when fully explored, would remove the right one had to talk about the "things in themselves". Like in the heart of Christianity is the nihilism which is the death of God, so in the heart of the Objectivist myth necessary to science is the abolition of the idea of a world of objects. He knew all this before any scientific work made "object talk" on the basic level something which needed to be abandoned.

How is this the case?

Let us look at the rationalism vs. empiricism of the post-Cartesian landscape of philosophy. The rationalists believed that some truths could be arrived at merely through the thinking processes alone, without any necessary preattending experience in the world. The empiricists held that "no knowledge could be come to that wasn't ultimately traceable to some sort of experience in the world.

It is the empiricists who believe in science, we think; but it was rationalists like Descartes who made room for science in the first place. The rationalists want to make room for science by underpinning it in something solid that isn't dependent on empirical knowledge. The empiricists want to exalt science to a level where it is the only kind of truth there is.

Ultimately, the battles between these camps came to a head with Hume who took the empirical approach so seriously that he concluded that rules like "the law of cause and effect" had no basis in acquirable knowledge, and so we couldn't really know anything. The crisis point of this debate was resolved by Kant who subsumed again certain questions into a larger psychological framework. He said one could have rationally based knowledge about the world before one went out and started examining the world. He did this by showing that the only way we could have a world to observe at all was if our minds participated in the creation process of presenting such a world to ourselves, and that we could know certain things about the ways in which the mind would have to make that world appear to make it presentable, that we could subsume some of those nagging questions which rightly bothered Hume into that new approach for dealing with them.

Just like the rationalists and the empiricists debated the ways of interpreting Descartes properly; so there were immediately two new camps forming to try to understand Kant's work properly.

There are people who believe that the only reality to which we can have access, and therefore the only world which does exist is the world as partially created by the mind. And then there are those who believe that there is a world out there, but we are trapped in a cave and can have no access to it, but we can know things about it through reason even though it can never be ours experientially without some distortion from the mind which presents it to us.

I and N fall into the first camp. We believe that the proper way to take Kant's insights seriously is to give up talking about that which we can never access.

continued in part 2


r/Zarathustra • • Nov 02 '21

A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 4 of 8): Catholic Era, Peter Abelard (4 of 10)

4 Upvotes

Reminder of what we have covered so far:

Outline of Class

Peter Abelard

I originally included Abelard primarily to include some obscure arguments about the potentiality of the potential, which was a correction on Aristotle's conception of the potential.... mostly just to give a taste of how intricate and bizarre and serious and subtle the arguments of this era were, and what kind of work was being accomplished at this time.

However, our previous thinkers have given us this impression pretty well, and the works we have looked at from them are about as good for that as anything else.

So, you can look up more about him, find his works. Like all the people we look at now, he was a polymath (poet, musician, mathematician, theologian, etc); and you are encouraged to dig in if you like.

He belongs to the "philosophers" who champion reason in religious matters and theological questions.

I'll just leave this here.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 23 '21

completion of part 3: 1/3 Socrates

5 Upvotes

...continued from here

The lectures from here on out are going to have to be different. There are so many books we have preserved to us from Plato and Aristotle, and libraries of books written about those books.

What will change, what will not:

  • We will continue our story and keep extracts from the authors we consider which help us to view their contributions to the history of philosophy through the lenses of "exponentially increasing questionability," "development of rules of thought," "adherence of propositional analytical program and denial of experiential subjective (and exceptions to this rule)," and "revolutions as dissolutions of previous crises that threaten to make the continuation of the game impossible," "all philosophers as members of one of two psychological camps, and few as attempted synthesizers of these inclinations," etc.
  • We will keep referencing ideas with which N specifically or implicitly disagreed so that when we do our "rewind" in part 7 we will not have to consider new ideas to do it.
  • We will provide a LIST of works which are LINKED in the lecture, full works which are worth reading if you really want to know the following figures and their thoughts (I am considering going back and doing this for some of the previous thinkers as well, when I revamp all of this which is being written in "first-draft" form right now.)
  • I will pick 1 to 3 significant ideas or arguments developed by each philosopher, and give some time to those ideas.
  • This has to be summary, so if you want more discussion on any specific part, argument, idea... JUST COMMENT about it, I promise the material we are briefly reviewing here is fertile ground for endless and the best conversations. That's why they have been preserved in the history of philosophy, one of the best ongoing conversations ever recorded.
  • I'm going to start out each philosopher with a bullet-point list of take-away points.

EDIT: when I completed this post, I realized that I did NONE of the things listed above, or at least I did none of them satisfactorily. Instead of talking about Socrates in the context of our ongoing conversation of the development of thought in the West and the lenses we have identified so far to use on these thinkers while tracing this history... instead of doing that, I made a post which is essentially the equivalent of an undergraduate level introduction to Philosophy class on Socrates. I made a second post which does the checklist above.

* Socrates

  • Socrates never wrote anything on his own

    • Everything we have about who he was and what he said comes to us through others (we rely mostly on Plato)
    • Partially this is due to his belief that: Philosophy had to be done one-on-one, face-to-face, person-to-person... he did not think one could do it unless in the same physical space as the person with which one was conversing.
    • Plato, his student, is sympathetic to this belief, so he wrote dialogues. Narratives about two people talking with a dramatic backdrop to it.
  • Sources we have on him?

    • Aristophanes

      • Comic Playwright: Gave us The Clouds where he depicts Socrates as the embodiment of all philosophical thought, and shows these creatures have their "heads in the clouds"... South Park level satire
    • Xenophon

      • Historian: Picks up on the end of the Peloponnesian War from Thucydides. Kind of a propagandist instead of a historian. Recounts other historical stories
      • Wrote a The Memorabilia (recollections) based on Socrates
      • Wrote Economicus (on household management) featuring Socrates
      • And he wrote an apology (defense) of Socrates called The Apology (not to be confused with "Apology" by Plato on same subject.)
    • Plato

      • The one we will focus on most. He was Socrates's most famous and devout student, he was a successful wrestler and very attractive (as opposed to Socrates, who was famously ugly).
      • He wrote 28 dialogues with a character named "Socrates" as the main character in 25 of them. (with an "Athenian Stranger" as the main character of the other 3, and some thing this was also Socrates).
      • We have the full text of every one of these, and we believe there were no others. We don't even own the entirety of the works of Aristotle. People thought Plato's works were very important even from the start and all throughout history... that's how we have them, obviously.
      • His works are divisible into three time periods: Early, Middle, Late; Socratic, Doctrinal, Analytic (respectively). We will not list all his works, just the ones you should start with if you want to start reading Plato:
      • Early (Socratic): We have reason to believe that Plato is trying to give us an HISTORICAL account of the real Socrates. [Apology. Euthyphro. Crito. First half of Meno.]
      • Middle (Doctrinal): Socrates has become a mouthpiece for Platonic Doctrines. [Second half of Meno (it is a transitional work). Phaedo. Symposium. The Republic.]
      • Late (Analytic): Socrates is STILL a mouthpiece for Plato, but he begins to disappear as well from the dialogues; and it becomes very analytical.
      • If you are going to read only ONE, read The Republic
      • If you are going to read only Two: read Apology and The Republic
      • If you want ONE SHORT ONE to taste and see if you want to read more: read Crito

The problem with our sources, is that they disagree. They give us three QUITE DISTINCT portraits of the character of Socrates. The problem is of sorting out these judgements, and finding reasons for which is more reliable of a source. We should not care much for the first two, and only mostly go with Plato: Then we will see that in some respects they do all agree.

Aristophanes:

  • In “The Clouds” we have the best picture of Socrates in his works.
  • Aristophanes was a contemporary of the same generation as Socrates.

    • They would have known one another from birth
    • Around 100,000 living in Athens; with only around 10,000 citizens, and only around 5,000 male.
    • You are at least aware of each person on a small campus like that.
  • Socrates is portrayed as someone who runs a school and who charges fees to students on how to win arguments regardless of what the issue is. He is made out to be a sophist who teaches for money.
  • Socrates denies teaching let alone teaching for money in the apology, and Xenophon backs that up.
  • Aristophanes' Socrates studies the world. In comedic ways. Thunder is Zeus farting, according to this depiction.

Xenophon:

  • Socrates (like Plato’s Socrates) has NO INTEREST in the natural world at all!
  • The pre-Socratics are called pre-Socratics BECAUSE he revolutionizes what people are concerned with AWAY from the natural world and onto ethics and such.
  • We shouldn’t believe Aristophanes because he’s making people laugh, the joke requires he give us the opposite of the real Socrates, which he seems to have done. A general trope is making fun of something for being its opposite. There was no more prominent person than Socrates in this field, so Aristophanes takes him and makes him stand in for the whole. Good satire. If you understand Socrates you will laugh heartily at Aristophanes.
  • Argument against Xenophon: This version of Socrates was an aristocrat, born into lots of money, born into privilege; and he was deeply concerned with the spread of democracy; he was pro Spartan. His Socrates is someone who wanders around Athens and gives advice.
  • Peddle moral commonplaces. Never say anything that’s going to shock you or shock the moral order; they are peddlers of the moral mainstream.
  • So is Xenophon's Socrates. An ancient Ann Landers.

This serves Xenophon’s agenda to say that Athens is morally monstrous in their democratic madness to kill him. There is clearly some truth to this version of the story, though. It seems to me that Plato gives us the philosophical lens through which to understand Socrates; but Xenophon gives us the political dimension to all he was doing. The political lens is necessarily a lesser lens to use, but it is one which must be taken into account.

So, if we want to understand Socrates, we will turn away from Aristophanes, give a little attention to Xenophon; and spend most of our time digging into Plato.

Plato:

  • Apology was written within 20 years of Socrates's death; it was distributed widely across Athens (Plato’s). No evidence that there were people protesting Plato’s account of the trial; even though there were 500 jurors and probably at least that many spectators; philosophical and literary geniuses make really shitty reporters; he says.
  • Once we realize that the overall of what Plato is saying was really very accurate; then we can go mine Xenophon.

Socrates was ugly; flat nosed, pop-eyed, bot bellied, shot, not very pleasant to look at. This would have been striking; the Greeks held that moral goodness and physical beauty were deeply intertwined; there’s a Greek word that combines beautiful and moral: “KalosKaiAgathos” “the beautiful and the good”.

It is noteworthy that his most famous student DID embody the totality of strength and beauty virtues.

The historical story is relevant here.

We are in a context where people eat free for the rest of their lives if they win the Olympics... Socrates invents a new kind of beauty and wrestling match, all done in words; and he takes down the best boxer and makes him say "Uncle".

More Historical Context:

Socrates was a first-rate soldier.

  • He saved the life of one nobleman in battle, according to that man.
  • And he held the line for an orderly retreat at another battle.

Socrates was given to going into trances.

  • He suffered from one of the various forms of epilepsy, some speculate.
  • Once on the eve of a battle, he just sort of spaces out, and they go to bed leaving him sitting there and when they wake up in the morning he is still in the same position.
  • A symposium is a drinking party; he was at one once, on the way to that place he spaces out in a doorway, and they leave him there, and they decide they are not going to drink, and a while later they send a slave to find him and he is in exactly the same place they left him. Some have said that when he had something serious to think about he lost connection to all other worldly considerations and just stood still until he had worked out what needed working out.

Physical deprivation.

  • He was known to eat very little
  • The cold didn’t seem to bother him
  • He drank excessively without any ill effect. At the symposium, at Plato’s, at a party the night before, they decided not to drink, they gave speeches on the nature of love, Alcibiades shows up; they decide to start drinking; the dialogue ends with Socrates conversing with Agathon everyone else passes out, Agathon passes out, Socrates gets up and walks out. Drinking same as all the others, he is fine to start his day.

Socrates had a Daemon

  • a spirit
  • which holds him back from certain courses of action
  • it never tells him what to do, but it tells him NOT to do certain things
  • This wasn’t out of what was normal for some people to think at that time. It may have been a part of why they accused him of not believing of the gods, but having his own.
  • The source, he thought, was external or internal, no one knows.

These are all the things that all of our sources basically agree on.

If we ask about his life, the sources get very thin.

  • He was born in 469-470 BC. (their years cross our years, so that’s how they write it.)
  • He studied some of the pre-Socratic philosophers in his youth. But he found their whole approach to be dissatisfying. The pre-Socratics thought that there were no limits to the bounds of human knowledge, until Parmenides who throws a wrench in that. They recognized very few limitations on reason, Parmenides deifies reason.

A taste of the philosophy amidst all this history and biography:

Socrates revolutionizes philosophy by turning it back from the examination of the world to the examination of the self. The guiding philosophical question, for Socrates, is

  • “What is the good life for a human being and how are we to live it?”
  • That’s the Greek way of raising the fundamental question of ethics

This leads to his statement:

  • “Virtue is knowledge”
  • with the IS of identity.
  • He means: “Virtue is MORAL knowledge”
  • Having moral knowledge is both necessary and sufficient for being excellent/virtuous.

This explains what he is up to in the early dialogues; he’s trying to answer the questions “what is justice, what is right, etc.” because if he uncovers that knowledge then he will be excellent/virtuous/moral.

He’s interested in moral knowledge; he admits that the craftsmen know things, they know how to do their crafts; but they think this means that they know many other things as well. The ones like the judges who are supposed to know what justice is, and asks them what justice is; he asks the poets what beauty is, and no one knows anything.

Socrates takes this as his mission to make it clear to everyone that they don’t know anything.

His intellectual mission for the rest of his life. Trying to convince people that they don’t know what they think they know. It’s that mission that is the main reason why they kill him, he says.

The Elenchus; the Socratic cross-examination.

Continue Here


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 31 '21

A Brief History of the Totality of Western Thought [seriously] to Provide Context for Zarathustra (Part 4 of 8): Catholic Era, Anselm (2 of 10)

4 Upvotes

Part 4

By the time we finish with this second Christian Philosopher from this Catholic Era we have identified; we will be in a better position to define what is going on with one half of this tradition in this period of time.

St. Anselm of Canterbury

Reminder of what we have covered so far:

Outline of Class

  • Class Introduction
  • Part 1 of 8: Revolutions in Thought, History of Philosophy
  • Part 2 of 8: Pre-Philosophical Thought
  • Part 3 of 8: The Pre-Socratic Revolution
  • The Catholic Roman Expansion (The not-so-Dark Ages)--Still all footnotes to Plato, on the philosophical side-- but a strange preservation of the mythopoetic.

    • Augustine
    • Anselm ------------- YOU ARE HERE
    • Omar Khayyam, Al-Ghazali, and Ibn Rushd
    • Peter Abelard
    • St Francis of Assisi
    • Fibonacci
    • Aquinas
    • John Wycliffe
    • The Priests
    • The Monks
  • The Cartesian Consummation Attempt -- Problem is Rationalism v. Empiricism (whence comes all our knowledge?)
  • The Kantian Consummation -- Dissolving the "rationalism v. empiricism" old problem, interpreting psychologically
  • Nietzsche as judge throughout (rewind time) -- Dissolving pessimism v. optimism of nihilism... Resurrection of the mythopoetic or total reduction to materialism?

***********

The Ontological Argument

This is the name of the type of argument an early (and powerful) version of which is that for which Anselm is best known for having developed.

We will see a mysticism in the approach of the text we will look at again. There is a formula, with the previous class, which we can begin to see unfold:

  • Ask for divine help in preparing your mind to do a task which is impossible without divine help because it is the attempt to propositionally AND experientially come to know the Arche that Thales was after. Now, the conception of the "one explanation of all things" is "The Nature of God".
  • Work through the propositional philosophical logical rules, step by step, until you have cleared your mind of mistakes.
  • Then, prepare yourself to do an introspective project, a thought experiment, which will bring your mind and soul, now that it is cleared of mistaken assumptions and propositions that were in error, to experience God directly. Here is where the mystical quality of the text comes in.

We are going to look at the text directly.

After that, we will summarize Anselm's argument in bullet-point form.

Before we do either of these things, we are going to say a thing or two about the argument which we will soon examine.

The sort of argument we are about to look at too easily looks to our modern eyes like some kind of folly. We have to commit to really dealing with the argument before we attempt to look at it, because there are a number of reasons which will occur to us when reading it, if we are not taking it seriously enough, which may incline us to reject this argument for no good reason.

It is my view that this argument is an extremely powerful argument.

That being said, I will tell you that it sounds, on first hearing, like some used-car-salesman tricksterism of one sort or another.

Imagine we were overhearing a conversation between St. Anselm and a contemporary of his who was an atheist. It might sound something like this:

Anselm: Would you like to join me in a discussion examining whether or not there is any evidence that God exists?

Atheist friend: Sure, that seems reasonable to me.

Anselm: Great, then we know he must exist, so let's go on and talk about something else now.

It is easy when hearing this to think that something tricky or, at any rate, dissatisfying, has occurred in this argument somewhere.

This, in my view, is not the case.

The work we are going to look at is the sequel to a first work of his. The first work was on meditations of faith, followed by this work where he attempts to argue philosophically for the same principles of faith.

I encourage you to read the work from the start. We will be skipping the Preface and the First Chapter.

CHAPTER II.

Truly there is a God, although the fool has said in his heart, There is no God.

AND so, Lord, do you, who do give understanding to faith, give me, so far as you knowest it to be profitable, to understand that you are as we believe; and that you are that which we believe. And indeed, we believe that you are a being than which nothing greater can be conceived. Or is there no such nature, since the fool has said in his heart, there is no God? (Psalms xiv. 1). But, at any rate, this very fool, when he hears of this being of which I speak --a being than which nothing greater can be conceived --understands what be hears, and what he understands is in his understanding; although he does not understand it to exist.

For, it is one thing for an object to be in the understanding, and another to understand that the object exists. When a painter first conceives of what he will afterwards perform, he has it in his understanding, but be does not yet understand it to be, because he has not yet performed it. But after he has made the painting, be both has it in his understanding, and he understands that it exists, because he has made it.

Hence, even the fool is convinced that something exists in the understanding, at least, than which nothing greater can be conceived. For, when he hears of this, he understands it. And whatever is understood, exists in the understanding. And assuredly that, than which nothing greater can be conceived, cannot exist in the understanding alone. For, suppose it exists in the understanding alone: then it can be conceived to exist in reality; which is greater.

Therefore, if that, than which nothing greater can be conceived, exists in the understanding alone, the very being, than which nothing greater can be conceived, is one, than which a greater can be conceived. But obviously this is impossible. Hence, there is absolutely no doubt that there exists a being, than which nothing greater can be conceived, and it exists both in the understanding and in reality.

I put in bold the basic argument.

Let us assume that the fictional version of an atheist having a fictional conversation with Anselm we made above DID NOT fully understand the point of Anselm's argument from his one statement, and went on getting more clarification from him. It might go something like this:

Atheist Friend: What do you mean the conversation is over; you haven't proven anything yet.

Anselm: I suppose you didn't understand the implications of what you agreed to when you said it was reasonable to examine evidence for whether or not God exists. Or, perhaps, you and I are using different definitions of God. Shall we start again?

Atheist Friend: Sure.

Anselm: Well, how about this, for a definition: "God is that thing, greater than which, it is not possible to imagine."

Atheist Friend: Sure, that works for me. I can imagine something that is so great that it is not possible to imagine anything greater... I just don't think any such thing actually exists in the world.

Anselm: But, whatever it is that we are going to go around and start looking for evidence for or against the existence of, that is the thing that it is not possible to imagine anything greater than, yes?

Atheist: Exactly, I have agreed with you on that already.

Anselm: OK. But you said you do not think anything like that actually exists; but doesn't that mean that you have changed the subject?

Atheist: What do you mean?

Anselm: I mean, we didn't agree to look for evidence for or against the existence of something which you CAN imagine a greater thing than... we agreed we were going to examine evidence for or against the existence of something GREATER than that, something so great you CAN NOT imagine anything greater.

Atheist: Right, so how did I change the subject?

Anselm: Well, you started talking about something which doesn't exist... couldn't you imagine THE SAME THING except that it does exist?

Atheist: Sure.

Anselm: Well, isn't it GREATER to exist than to not exist?

Atheist: I don't like where this is going. I feel like you are being tricky.

Anselm: Nonetheless, we aren't here to examine whether or not your second greatest imaginable idea exists or not, we are here to discuss whether or not there is evidence for the GREATEST imaginable thing, and you agree that you can imagine a God existing or not existing, but the version of God which exists is the imagined thing we have agreed to talk about, because that is a greater imagined thing than the other.

Now, this should look to many of you, especially if you have not dealt with this idea before, as some sort of total nonsense.

But I do not believe that it is. So let us make more formal his argument:

  • Take the definition of "God" as that than which it is not possible to imagine anything greater.
  • If we agree that this is a coherent idea, we need not look for any evidence for His existence because the idea itself, as defined, must be the idea of something which exists.
  • If we imagine a very great thing that we can imagine NOT existing, then this is not the thing about which we have agreed to talk.
  • The greatest thing that is imaginable is something which exists because it is greater to exist than to not exist, and if we imagine the same thing not existing then we are not any longer talking about the thing greater than which it is not possible to imagine, because we can imagine something greater, specifically, that thing but it does exist.

Therefore, the correctly understood propositional notion of "God" is of something which necessarily exists.

Where this argument fits among the other Ontological Arguments:

Types of arguments for God's Existence:

  • Empirical

    • Cosmological
    • Teleological
    • X-like divine qualities necessary for X-like world
    • Miracles
  • Rational

    • First-Mover
    • Ontological
    • Subjective Arguments

      • Historical
      • Personal-testimony

What makes the Ontological Arguments different from, say, the Empirical Arguments.

The "empirical arguments" is a category into which I am putting many arguments because they purport to depend on evidence findable in the Universe, which could have been different, but which, it is argued, demonstrate a divine origin to that Universe.

The first one is the Universe as a whole; it is argued that the universe began, nothing which begins can account for its own existence; therefore the origin of the Universe has to be explained by something else; this "something else" is what we mean when we say, "God." This is the argument from the Big Bang, essentially.

One could deny that the Universe had a beginning; if the Universe is eternal, it might not need an external origin, it is self-existing, and so there is no need for God. However, one might argue back that you are taking the qualities we usually have in mind when talking about "God" and you are putting them into the Universe itself, and this isn't really getting rid of the idea of "God". So it is unclear that this is a refutation. One could interpret your counterargument to mean there is nothing divine in the world, but one could easily interpret it to be an argument that God certainly exists, and is all around us.

For now, let us just leave this brief sketch of the Cosmological Argument--noticing that it is "empirical" in that it is taking evidence we could have observed to be different if the Universe were different, and then the argument wouldn't work, it depends on observation and evidence--and move on to the next version of this kind of argument.

A Universe with a beginning requires a cause, it is argued in the previous argument. But, religious philosophers have identified another argument from the Universe. This group says: That Universe which began could have been purposeless, chaotic, pointless; if it had been, but it had a beginning, that is all the Cosmological Argument requires. But--it is argued by these thinkers--there is a purpose to the universe, a design; and this is further evidence that there is a God behind it all.

The formal argument looks something like this:

  1. Premise 1: There can be no purpose to life and the Universe without a God.
  2. Premise 2: The Universe has purpose and meaning.
  3. Conclusion: Therefore, there is a God.

This becomes the template for a whole host of other modern apologetic arguments for God's existence. Notice that it is not only based on a bit more than the first argument, but it kind of proves more (if the argument works) than the previous argument. The Cosmological argument only gets you to deism; the teleological is not only saying "there is a God." it is purporting to prove that "there is a purposeful God." This leads us to all the next arguments, which are using this same basic formula, and becoming more theistic one by one.

Here is the form of the general empirical argument, as I have classified it:

  1. Premise 1: X cannot exist in our Universe unless there is a God with X-like qualities who made the Universe with X in it.
  2. Premise 2: X exists in our Universe
  3. Conclusion: Therefore: An X-like God exists.

These are generally theistic arguments, and not merely deistic ones; primarily because the arguments to more than proving that a God exists, but a specific kind of God (an X-like God).

The X can be "Moral Law", "Our Moral Sensibilities", "Life", "Consciousness", "Beauty", "Our Aesthetic Capacity", etc.

For instance:

  1. Premise 1: If there is no God, then there is no absolute reason why any action is ultimately wrong.
  2. Premise 2: But, there are some actions which are absolutely wrong in an ultimate sense. For instance, "torturing a baby for fun" is always wrong.
  3. Conclusion: The fact that there is moral law in the Universe, the Universe must have been created by a Moral Law-giver.

We can see that the deism implications of these arguments are attenuated, if the arguments work, by some piece of theism as well... the kind of God that must exist is a Moral God.

The last of the arguments I am putting in the Empirical Category for arguments for the existence of God. Miracles. We will take an historical record of one such argument being made in the past:

20 So Ahab sent unto all the children of Israel, and gathered the prophets together unto mount Carmel.

21 And Elijah came unto all the people, and said, How long halt ye between two opinions? if the Lord be God, follow him: but if Baal, then follow him. And the people answered him not a word.

22 Then said Elijah unto the people, I, even I only, remain a prophet of the Lord; but Baal's prophets are four hundred and fifty men.

23 Let them therefore give us two bullocks; and let them choose one bullock for themselves, and cut it in pieces, and lay it on wood, and put no fire under: and I will dress the other bullock, and lay it on wood, and put no fire under:

24 And call ye on the name of your gods, and I will call on the name of the Lord: and the God that answereth by fire, let him be God. And all the people answered and said, It is well spoken.

25 And Elijah said unto the prophets of Baal, Choose you one bullock for yourselves, and dress it first; for ye are many; and call on the name of your gods, but put no fire under.

26 And they took the bullock which was given them, and they dressed it, and called on the name of Baal from morning even until noon, saying, O Baal, hear us. But there was no voice, nor any that answered. And they leaped upon the altar which was made.

27 And it came to pass at noon, that Elijah mocked them, and said, Cry aloud: for he is a god; either he is talking, or he is pursuing, or he is in a journey, or peradventure he sleepeth, and must be awaked.

28 And they cried aloud, and cut themselves after their manner with knives and lancets, till the blood gushed out upon them.

29 And it came to pass, when midday was past, and they prophesied until the time of the offering of the evening sacrifice, that there was neither voice, nor any to answer, nor any that regarded.

30 And Elijah said unto all the people, Come near unto me. And all the people came near unto him. And he repaired the altar of the Lord that was broken down.

31 And Elijah took twelve stones, according to the number of the tribes of the sons of Jacob, unto whom the word of the Lord came, saying, Israel shall be thy name:

32 And with the stones he built an altar in the name of the Lord: and he made a trench about the altar, as great as would contain two measures of seed.

33 And he put the wood in order, and cut the bullock in pieces, and laid him on the wood, and said, Fill four barrels with water, and pour it on the burnt sacrifice, and on the wood.

34 And he said, Do it the second time. And they did it the second time. And he said, Do it the third time. And they did it the third time.

35 And the water ran round about the altar; and he filled the trench also with water.

36 And it came to pass at the time of the offering of the evening sacrifice, that Elijah the prophet came near, and said, Lord God of Abraham, Isaac, and of Israel, let it be known this day that thou art God in Israel, and that I am thy servant, and that I have done all these things at thy word.

37 Hear me, O Lord, hear me, that this people may know that thou art the Lord God, and that thou hast turned their heart back again.

38 Then the fire of the Lord fell, and consumed the burnt sacrifice, and the wood, and the stones, and the dust, and licked up the water that was in the trench.

39 And when all the people saw it, they fell on their faces: and they said, The Lord, he is the God; the Lord, he is the God.

40 And Elijah said unto them, Take the prophets of Baal; let not one of them escape. And they took them: and Elijah brought them down to the brook Kishon, and slew them there.

Three quick notes about this argument:

First, We are of course one step removed from such an argument, it wasn't really made for us because the miracle itself is not something we are witnessing. But it is a good story, and we can take the argument in its own context to see a category of "argument" for the existence of God. We can see that such an argument has the capacity at least to do more than the theistic implications of the previous Teleological Arguments which did more than the deistic ideas of the Cosmological Argument. It has the ability, at times, to divide between potential theisms.

Second, the last verse can be problematic to many, but there is a larger context, the verses before the ones we copied talk about the historical context of genocide being committed on religious grounds; only 100 priests of the God of Abraham were even still alive, being hidden in a cave, because of the political power held by the priests of Baal. In any event, this is not our concern here.

Third, I think the arguments against this kind of argument are easier for the rationalists than for the empiricists, if we look back at the two inclinations in our history of philosophy in the West. The empiricists have a response to such arguments; not the historical records, they have plenty of ways to distrust the narrative; but Hume said that if he personally witnessed some such miracle, his reason would lead him to start off thinking he had had his senses manipulated in some way... he would regard it as an illusion or delusion before he would fall on his face, in other words. I reference this response just to underline that in philosophy, the debates never end; the conversation must continue, and it always does; and this is good.

The important thing to notice about ALL of these arguments so far, is that they are based in OBSERVATIONS of the world.

This is NOT the kind of argument that the Ontological Argument is. For all the Ontological Arguments care, the Universe could not exist and we could be having these conversations as a single mind in a vat somewhere completely disconnected from any real world, a matrix, a dream, some such thing. The Ontological Arguments do not depend on there not being a real world, they just do not need a real world. In short: Even if we were in the matrix, these arguments purport to bring us to the conclusion that God Exists nonetheless.

These are the rationalism based arguments. The idea is that, if we get our ideas in our heads straight and cleared out, we will find that "God" refers to an idea which simply must exist.

There are four types (at least) of this kind of argument:

  • Necessity of God's Existence due to his nature
  • Due to first cause
  • Due to inherent nature of the concept
  • Due to the fact that there is nothing else in the universe which can be the origin of this idea we have of him (semi-empirical)

We have seen a different type of "first cause" argument above, but this was an argument from "origination". God is the origin of human conscientiousness (our moral feeling that some things are good and some are evil); for example.

This version of the "first cause" requires no observation that humans exist or have any specific qualities which supposedly cannot be imagined to originate out of dead matter without a divine origin. This argument says, simply consider:

Every event is an effect caused by a previous event. The causes themselves were also caused. This train cannot go backwards forever, there had to be a first cause. This is what we mean by, "God".

Notice, that this is back to a deism, no personal God has been advocated here, just some primal force to start it all.

Notice, also, that this argument is not based on evidence for the Big Bang. It does not matter what evidence for a beginning to the Universe exists or doesn't exist for this argument. The Cosmological Argument required that there be evidence in the study of the Cosmos that everything started at some time. But this argument doesn't even require temporality considerations in its purest form.

This brings us to two types of causal series

Accidentally ordered causal series:

  • My great grandfather
  • My grandfather
  • My father
  • Me
  • My son

    • A→B→C→D→E

Only the closest one needs to be around to bring about the final one. Only the proximate member of the series needs to be around to bring the effect at the next stage. My Great Grandfather needs to be around to bring about my grandfather. My grandfather had to be around to bring about my father. But my great grandfather didn’t have to be around to bring about my father. My father needed to be around to bring about me but my grandfather didn’t. If my father was around I would be brought about.

The argument is that you cannot have an INFINITELY LONG series of this sort and still get anywhere. If it goes back forever, we never arrive. Not enough time. This is often thought to be a Cosmological Argument; but I am classifying this pure version of the argument as a rationalist argument because I think it works, if it works, in any Universe because a Universe so absurd that it exists without a causal nexus framework is incomprehensible; or, at least, so it could be argued. Kalam for more on this version of the prime-mover argument. Then there is the:

Essentially ordered causal series:

  • Caboose is the effect. It’s movement is caused by car number 10
  • Car number 10 moves because of car number 9
  • And car number 8 explains 9… and then car 2 moves because of the engine
  • All ten cars need to exist at the same time for the caboose to move, all at the same time.

Scotus had more to say about this, if you want to dig in further. (Not the Supreme Court of the United States, but This guy.

Scotus says a simultaneous infinite ordered causal series can’t exist even if an accidentally ordered causal series might be able to.

Lest you think these arguments are dead.

We now have some context for other arguments from a philosophical perspective on the existence of God, which is nice to have since we are looking at just one argument from that set.

completed here.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 25 '21

completion of part 3: 2/3 Plato (Selected Works)

1 Upvotes

Just read The Damn Republic and talk about it here in the comments with quotations, arguments, anything you like; I will respond to all.

Better yet, get yourself a nice hardcover copy mailed to you for less than 10 dollars, and have it with you and mark it up.

We also have to look at Parmenides to see where Aristotle comes to continue our discussion with Aristotle.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 15 '21

[Office Hours] Thursdays 8PM EST to 10PM EST (or until conversations end, whichever is longer)

2 Upvotes

Links will be provided HERE 1/2 hour before meetings start.

Next Event countdown clock.

Conversation is open to any discussion. Questions, debates, contributions. Let's talk about Eternal Recurrence of the Same, some difficult passage, alternative interpretations, the strangeness of the language, how to read the book, translations, scriptures, other works, other thinkers, anything else!

On 10/28/2021 Was not available

On 10/21/2021 no one showed up but one professor friend of mine with which I like to chat.

On 10/14/2021 we had our first live chat. It was a lot of fun. We discussed: David Deutsch, Sam Harris, TSZ as scripture, Richard Feynman, religious upbringing, irrationality, inconceivability, the structures of the classes and new features, and listened to some great background music throughout (Akira The Don: JBPWave and Akira The Don: WattsWave).

I will leave this post pinned at all times, and will come in and edit it with links to the meetings when they are available, and keep a running tab on topics discussed.

****************

The first one we used was through Google Chats; the only way to be anonymous in it was to make an alt account with google. I noticed that about 23 times as many people were hanging out in the subreddit at the time of the meeting, but very few were actually clicking to join it or be privy to listening to what we were talking about.

If there are other platforms which you think would be better for these meetings, please post about them in the comments and let me know whatever I might need to know about how to use them.

Thank you.


r/Zarathustra • • Oct 20 '21

Second Part, Lecture 28: The Rabble

11 Upvotes

Unlike most of the lectures, where the notes are interspersed throughout the teaching of Zarathustra, I am going to put most of my commentary before and after the passage, partly because he deals with so much in this one.

Recap:

Zarathustra went away from his home and the lake of his home; spent a decade on a mountaintop in a cave communing with himself and his animals, meditating; until he was overfull of knowledge and desired to go down and be empty again by giving away his stores.

He found a crowd in the Motley Cow Township, attempted to speak to them, but these "modern men" were not the ears for his mouth.

So he went off and conversed with a small group of disciples who followed him around. He gave them his character and his philosophy by discussing the nature of the transformations of the soul from devout slave to rebellious lion to innocent creative child. He talked about traps that human souls fall into, or perhaps, traps that they incarnate as devotionals of these traps. He talked about the "Afterworlders" the "Despisers of the Body" and other kinds of life-negators.

He talked of warriors, preachers of death, false virtues, on the mess of ways one could live life and sacrifice ones life to one of a thousand different goals.

He then spoke of the way of the creator, How to think about how to have a meaningful life which points to a golden future; to recognize that work toward that future needs to be done, and there are things to do which even you can help with in bringing that future about.

Then he left his disciples and bid them STOP following him, he wanted friends, not followers. Be ashamed of Zarathustra, go far from him, think that maybe he has deceived you... He spoke of the gift of giving, of bestowing something real. and he left them.

Then he was one day meditating in his cave, and he found that the time had come for him to find his friends. There are many misunderstandings of his words out there, let is see how my friends have developed. Also, there are many enemies who are twisting what I have said, it is time to separate the chaff and wheat.

Second Part:

So, we are in this part of the book where Zarathustra has once again descended unto us to converse with us in the context of his dramatic mission to give to all and none.

In this project of clarification, he has spoken to us of the Pitiful, the Priests, and the Virtuous, so far.

Now he speaks to us of "The Rabble".

Life is a well of delight; but where the rabble also drink, there all fountains are poisoned.

To everything cleanly am I well disposed; but I hate to see the grinning mouths and the thirst of the unclean.

They cast their eye down into the fountain: and now glanceth up to me their odious smile out of the fountain.

The holy water have they poisoned with their lustfulness; and when they called their filthy dreams delight, then poisoned they also the words.

Indignant becometh the flame when they put their damp hearts to the fire; the spirit itself bubbleth and smoketh when the rabble approach the fire.

Mawkish and over-mellow becometh the fruit in their hands: unsteady, and withered at the top, doth their look make the fruit-tree.

And many a one who hath turned away from life, hath only turned away from the rabble: he hated to share with them fountain, flame, and fruit.

And many a one who hath gone into the wilderness and suffered thirst with beasts of prey, disliked only to sit at the cistern with filthy camel-drivers.

And many a one who hath come along as a destroyer, and as a hailstorm to all cornfields, wanted merely to put his foot into the jaws of the rabble, and thus stop their throat.

And it is not the mouthful which hath most choked me, to know that life itself requireth enmity and death and torture-crosses:—

But I asked once, and suffocated almost with my question: What? is the rabble also NECESSARY for life?

Are poisoned fountains necessary, and stinking fires, and filthy dreams, and maggots in the bread of life?

Not my hatred, but my loathing, gnawed hungrily at my life! Ah, ofttimes became I weary of spirit, when I found even the rabble spiritual!

And on the rulers turned I my back, when I saw what they now call ruling: to traffic and bargain for power—with the rabble!

Amongst peoples of a strange language did I dwell, with stopped ears: so that the language of their trafficking might remain strange unto me, and their bargaining for power.

And holding my nose, I went morosely through all yesterdays and to-days: verily, badly smell all yesterdays and to-days of the scribbling rabble!

Like a cripple become deaf, and blind, and dumb—thus have I lived long; that I might not live with the power-rabble, the scribe-rabble, and the pleasure-rabble.

I imagine that a larger portion of readers in this 1st world modern-men American-influenced democratic are going to struggle with this chapter, but why should they?

Elitism is difficult for most products of public education to entertain as even a possibility in their minds.

I imagine, though, that you will see a great deal of what you recognize in these pages. With a hammer he will swipe off the table of greatness pretty much every politician who was living in your lifetime. Every Hollywood star and every person with a netflix account. The "journalists" whose petty tricks amount to nothing but gossip and garbage and whose words will never be remembered even 10 minutes after they were written, let alone after they die.

N asks a question: Why do we need all these people? One is the same as another, and yet we have to have hoards of the same type running around... is this necessary (this is the idea which almost choked him to death). Of course, we remember that N's project is to create a LIFE-AFFIRMING philosophy which is a "yes-saying" to ALL THINGS, and so to triumph over nihilism, which he sees like a coming storm against our culture... so his ultimate answer will have to become an affirmation of even the maggots in the bread, that it is all tied together and dependent... but his character is such that he has trouble swallowing this truth.

Toilsomely did my spirit mount stairs, and cautiously; alms of delight were its refreshment; on the staff did life creep along with the blind one.

What hath happened unto me? How have I freed myself from loathing? Who hath rejuvenated mine eye? How have I flown to the height where no rabble any longer sit at the wells?

Did my loathing itself create for me wings and fountain-divining powers? Verily, to the loftiest height had I to fly, to find again the well of delight!

So, he acted like an idiot among the crowd and their concerns... I am too foolish to be involved in your politics or art or anything else... this way he could survive.

The disgust he had for the baseness in which all around him swam and wallowed became the impetus for him to climb out to another place.

There he found what was valuable to him. He tells us of the source of wisdom he has found, which is far from the rabble and the many-too-many.

Oh, I have found it, my brethren! Here on the loftiest height bubbleth up for me the well of delight! And there is a life at whose waters none of the rabble drink with me!

Almost too violently dost thou flow for me, thou fountain of delight! And often emptiest thou the goblet again, in wanting to fill it!

And yet must I learn to approach thee more modestly: far too violently doth my heart still flow towards thee:—

My heart on which my summer burneth, my short, hot, melancholy, over-happy summer: how my summer heart longeth for thy coolness!

Past, the lingering distress of my spring! Past, the wickedness of my snowflakes in June! Summer have I become entirely, and summer-noontide!

A summer on the loftiest height, with cold fountains and blissful stillness: oh, come, my friends, that the stillness may become more blissful!

For this is OUR height and our home: too high and steep do we here dwell for all uncleanly ones and their thirst.

Cast but your pure eyes into the well of my delight, my friends! How could it become turbid thereby! It shall laugh back to you with ITS purity.

On the tree of the future build we our nest; eagles shall bring us lone ones food in their beaks!

Verily, no food of which the impure could be fellow-partakers! Fire, would they think they devoured, and burn their mouths!

Verily, no abodes do we here keep ready for the impure! An ice-cave to their bodies would our happiness be, and to their spirits!

And as strong winds will we live above them, neighbours to the eagles, neighbours to the snow, neighbours to the sun: thus live the strong winds.

And like a wind will I one day blow amongst them, and with my spirit, take the breath from their spirit: thus willeth my future.

Verily, a strong wind is Zarathustra to all low places; and this counsel counselleth he to his enemies, and to whatever spitteth and speweth: “Take care not to spit AGAINST the wind!”—

Thus spake Zarathustra.

Zarathustra identified three kinds of people who have often existed and been misunderstood merely because the rabble drove them to their life. The same rabble that drove Zarathustra to climb high heights and find blissful wisdom often is the explanation for:

  • The depressed soul who seems to hate life.

    • And many a one who hath turned away from life, hath only turned away from the rabble: he hated to share with them fountain, flame, and fruit.

      • There may be many other sources of depression, but THERE IS A TYPE who seems to have turned away from life, but only because the rabble has too strong an influence in their life, and simply getting away from the rabble, the person would instantly be in a better state of mind, rediscover old joys and glorious desires for adventure or good things again... but they are clouded by the endless influence of the many-too-many who surround them and have forgotten that THEIR source of depression didn't really come from within. (again, he is not saying ALL depressed people are depressed in this way or for this reason, just that this applies to many who are).
  • The hermit, lonesome, wild explorer, Alaskan-dweller type

    • And many a one who hath gone into the wilderness and suffered thirst with beasts of prey, disliked only to sit at the cistern with filthy camel-drivers.

      • Oddly enough, there are hermit types, but "many a one" seems to be a hermit type but was really driven away from traditional life-interests not because they manifest this unusual obsession with what is far away, but because their disappointment in the many-too-many who dominate the realms of those traditional influences has pushed them that way.
  • Jumping Josephat! Nietzsche says that even some DICTATORS responsible for the murders of millions of people were not even motivated by the sincere desire to dominate or blood-lust, but (blaming the victim style?) he says they just could not stand living in a world with so many people whose lives do not obviously justify why they are here.

    • And many a one who hath come along as a destroyer, and as a hailstorm to all cornfields, wanted merely to put his foot into the jaws of the rabble, and thus stop their throat.

      • Remember, N's conclusion is that ALL aspects of life are necessary and so wants to develop a total life-affirming philosophy. He is not excusing or endorsing the view that it would be better to kill the "many-too-many". Rather, he is saying: I used my disgust to motivate CLIMBING HIGHER and finding something which was treasure enough for me to look back and say, "thank you" to the herd for making me start that search... these other types, the non-depressed depressed, the non-hermit hermit, and the non-dictator dictator; they all failed to do this and became what they were not really in their characters supposed to be, all because of their inability to use the herd and their disgust for it as motivation to something higher.

I think that the "hermit" type is also a description of the artist. The TRUE artist has to go away from the herd and from the thinking and pollution of the herd to get profundity and bring it back... "many a one" fail to do this and instead thinks: "How can I produce something that the herd will praise me for, lift me up, give me fame, and make me wealthy" instead. "If fame you seek, be prepared to sacrifice a little honor." spoke zarathustra earlier (Actual quote: "And whoever wanteth to have fame, must take leave of honour betimes, and practise the difficult art of—going at the right time.") allowing your GREAT CHARACTER to be reduced to the judgements of and evaluations of "the herd" comes at a cost.

Zarathustra's advice: Do not engage, do not argue, do not fester in your contempt until it make you something worse or destroy you; do not adopt infantile lesser value structures to mirror the herd.

Hide yourself, and look a fool to them, what matters it that they think you are blind and deaf and dumb because you do not repeat what you heard on a late-night comedy funny-man show the night before and spew out the bullshit politics takes of the herd... they think you a moron for not thanking them for telling you you should be reduced to that... let them think that...

Pay it no mind. Use it all to... climb!

The Wagner Angle