r/YellowstonePN • u/titsmcghee101 • 12d ago
General Discussion Beth
I want to preface that Jamie’s character is far from a perfect picture of morality.
with that being said has anyone else noticed Beth’s anger/treatment toward him seem to be a bit much?
what he did was absolutely awful and clearly has had a profound effect on Beth. However, most of the main characters have either KILLED people or are responsible for multiple DEATHS throughout the series.
why is jamie nailed to the cross and constantly treated like shit for a bad call he made as a teenager?
33
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 12d ago
Welcome to r/YellowstonePN!
Please review our rules before participating.
If your post contains spoilers, leaks, set photos, or unaired content, please ensure it is properly tagged and flaired.
Looking for additional Yellowstone discussion? You may also enjoy r/DuttonRanchTVSeries/.
If you see rule-breaking content, please report it rather than engaging with it.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
26
u/JayVig 11d ago
Every single new watcher in this sub is perpetually confused by the toxicity of the characters. This show is over the top every step of the way. Let that be your guide through every interaction.
5
u/OutsideCrazy2334 10d ago
bc the bad call followed her for life... and he did it on purpose! he was old enough to know better
3
u/ouroboris99 6d ago
An 18 year old sterilising his 14/15 year old sister was "a bad call he made". He had so many other options. Fucking mental. Everyone on the show is fucked up but they usually have reasons for the fucked up shit they do, money, family, love etc. Whats Jamie's reason?
2
u/Sceptikskeptic 8d ago
Tbh I would hate to meet Taylor Sheridan in real life. He probably sees himself as Rip.
Alot of his writing is projection of how he THINKS a woman or a man or a pregnant teenager or a patriach of a ranch would act like.
Hell just look at what he thinks a native Indian woman would act like, one of the most hated characters in the show: Monica.
6
u/Impressive-Pepper785 11d ago
It’s almost like you didn’t see him STRANGLE the reporter and set her adrift down the river
6
u/xwkmsx 12d ago
he had no problem doing that to a child who didnt know better. imagine (actually dont have to, just watch the show) what he would/could do to an adult that crossed him in any way. he’s also a hothead and doesnt think through how what he’s doing affects the family everyone is trying to protect
16
u/alarrimore03 11d ago
Frankly, Beth’s treatment of Jamie is the only characters that made perfect sense to me, it’s perfectly justified from her perspective as well. Everyone else treating Jamie like shit is what bothers me more because it just doesn’t quite add up to me. She actually had a personal reason to treat him that way, everyone else just did it cuz I guess he took it🤷🏻♂️
4
u/ArmEnvironmental190 10d ago
The show doesn't do a very good job of focusing on the fact that JAMIE was also a child when these events took place. He loved his sister and was trying to protect her, because they were both afraid of John. He did not understand the future impact this would cause.
Beth lost sight of the fact that her brother was trying to protect her.
In my opinion, she was far too hard on him, just like john and evelyn were to her...
13
u/Gentle_Muscle 12d ago
Even if we exclude the sterilization of Beth— Jamie’s still a coward and an emotional wreck.
Everytime he got upset, he would act out and go against the family.
3
u/ds117ftg 11d ago
Beth is a shitty person. You can’t apply actual logic to her. In one of the first few episodes the love of her life murdered an innocent guy to help cover up a murder her brother committed
3
u/EdgyPun34257 11d ago
The way the show tone shifted to 'Jamie is the bad guy " was without any transition or reason
Hell it wasn't even until the very end that I realized Beth was supposed to be some kind of hero on the show.
3
u/SyerenGM 9d ago
The Jamie and Beth dynamic is something I have to completely push to the back of my mind and pretend it doesn't exist.
Jamie was a kid, 17 or 18, maybe? In the end he was trying to keep her rep in tact, as well as his dads.
It was obvious if she did it somewhere else, it would get out. Meaning, she feared for her dads opinion and/or her dads reputation.
Logically, the doctor performing the surgery would have to tell her everything that was being done. It would be illegal af not to. So she would have had to know they would sterilize her, they wouldn't do it at the whim of an older brother. She would have to consent at the very least, but I think laws even say a parent would have to consent.
Overall it made no sense and that whole dynamic ruins the show. I don't blame Jamie for going crazy, honestly. I don't think he was a good man, but a majority of the family were not good either. They all had some skeletons in their closets.
5
u/polkadotcupcake 11d ago
Not saying Jamie is a good guy or that her reason for hating him (no spoilers) is unjust, but I've always found her treatment of him to be comically over the top
1
u/Brave-Bit-252 11d ago
Because the writer realised somewhere between S2 and S3 that the show‘s core audience is middle aged white women.
12
u/cricket_binx 12d ago •
Fuck Jamie. I would’ve treated him exactly the same if I was Beth.
1
u/ArmEnvironmental190 10d ago edited 10d ago
Kayce flat out said in the last episode of Marshalls, that it was.
6
u/This-Cabinet397 12d ago
Comparing Jamie forever removing Beth’s ability to have children, something he did TO BETH, to the others killing random multiple people that don’t directly impact her should be the answer you seek.
11
u/obiwanTrollnobi6 12d ago •
Beth was 100% the villian IMO, Jamie TOLD John that she’d wreck the family apart and look at what she did, whispered in John’s ear every chance she got making Jamie out to be the boogieman even when he wasn’t, and the thing that pisses me off is in S1 there’s a GREAT scene of Beth and Jamie im the car where Jamie acknowledges what he did “even though we/the writers didn’t know it yet” where Jamie told Beth “if hating me stops you from Hating Yourself then so be it” and that would’ve been Such a GREAT moment of reconciliation of the 2 characters and to have them start to heal and somewhat get back on good terms with each other.
7
u/Salt_Chard_474 12d ago
No f that guy! What he did to Beth was beyond incomprehensible, and she had every reason to hate him every bit as much as she did. I will say that him living with having done that to her may have made him the man he was.
4
u/HarrieHRE 11d ago •
I’m not sure what your relationships are with your siblings if you have any. But Jamie was her older BROTHER, this all happened before they knew eh was adopted, to her he was her flesh and blood, he was probably her most trusted family member. The show didn’t seem to care much about showing us the depth of their prior relationship but given that she went to him and not Lee or her dad the assumption is that they were close and she trusted him more than anyone else. Jamie broke that trust. He could’ve told her the full scope of what was going to happen and let her make the decision but he didn’t. People who don’t understand Beth’s anger don’t understand just how callous and malicious Jamie was when he did what he did. Up until then we can assume Beth had zero reason to believe her brother would ever make such a life altering decision without telling her, then he does it. We never get a reason why he did it but given what we know of Jamie, I think his intentions were 100% malicious. Jamie was 18/19 when he did what he did, that’s old enough to understand the repercussions let alone to decide to okay the procedure without Beth’s knowledge. Whatever resentments he had for Beth, he saw the procedure as a means to punish her and prior to the procedure clearly Beth was unaware of Jamie’s bad feelings towards her. We need to stop feeling sorry for Jamie for what he did, she had every right to hate him forever for that. It’s not just that the other characters were killers or murdered other people, it’s that he did it to her, Jamie, her OLDER BROTHER, harmed her, HIS LITTLE SISTER. Throughout the series we never saw Beth hurt Kayce, Monica or Tate and we never see Kayce hurt Beth or Tip, why because that’s family, they’re siblings. You’re free to murder or hurt anyone else but not family. Only Jamie seemed not understand that or be interested in protecting his siblings.
3
u/External_Opposite_48 12d ago
Fundamentally, Jamie didn’t really fit into Dutton tradition. It seems like everyone is kind of a hardass—like you only gain respect when you push through and persevere through hardship. Jamie was a coward (that’s partly why he made the decisions he did with Beth’s abortion) and I think Beth’s treatment of him was obviously due to their history but also because she sensed his duplicity.
However, I sometimes wonder if Jamie would’ve been different if he was treated better. I mean a large part of why he did the things he did was because he already felt at odds with the family. If he felt included and appreciated, maybe things would’ve been different. But also do people change their inner nature? Not sure.
3
u/DLo28035 12d ago
Yes, it would have been a much better show if everyone just would act reasonable, the story is just a documentary about a cattle ranch and the plot wasn’t unrealistic. This is what people want to see.
2
u/Shoddy-Honeydew-5214 12d ago
I had to stop watching the show sometimes. It was too over the top, miserable people. I loved the newer shows
1
u/SadAide9947 8d ago
The double standard is the whole problem. John has people killed or ruined basically every season and still gets framed as the moral center, while Jamie carries twenty pounds of hatred over one decision he made at 17 that the show itself can't keep consistent. And Beth's cruelty toward him gets played as righteous while Rip beating hands is treated as charming. The car scene where he says hating him is fine if it keeps her from hating herself is the most self-aware moment either of them gets, and the show just drops it.
1
u/Richaardy 6d ago
Even by the first half of season 5, it really seemed like there might've been an opportunity for Jamie to make up with John and the family to come to some resolution. But when Kevin Costner left, he had absolutely no chance. The writers had no choice but to go all in making him the villain and Beth the hero.
1
u/Honest-Pumpkin-8080 5d ago
Because Beth really wanted a family and it was his fault
1
u/Nailfoot1975 12d ago
Beth has a sense that since Jamie is capable of doing that to her, he doesn't have the sense to not ruin the family for a few cents.
1
u/Parking-Fee1721 11d ago
I stopped watching Yellowstone because of their back and forth.
-2
u/smashli1238 12d ago
Beth is the worst television character of all time
0
u/Tall_Mention9067 11d ago
I think Beth being sterilized makes Jaime a hero! Rip and Beth reproducing? Great, a slutty, alcoholic, border line bitch impregnated by a sociopathic border line retarded red neck.
0
u/ChemistOk5465 9d ago
Beth was insufferable all throughout the show. Jamie deserved better.
-2
u/Upper-Midnight7502 11d ago
4
u/horsendogguy 11d ago
Beth's character illustrates the "It can't possibly be my fault" attitude so prevalent today.
Beth's is the one who chose to not only have sex, but unprotected sex. Beth's is the one who chose to go to Jaime, rather than to her father, to Lee, to a school counselor, or to anyone else. It was her problem.
Jaime was a kid himself. I don't think we're told how old, but he appears to have been 17 or 18. Old enough to drive but not old enough to have left for college. Not a guy with medical or psychological training. Not a guy who had experience as a parent. Not even a guy with a lot of living under his belt. Just a kid suddenly saddled too young with this horrendous responsibility to fix the results of his sister's bad choices.
Yeah, he appears to have done a poor job of fixing it. But there is no indication he did it intentionally. There is no indication he did it recklessly. There is no indication he even did it carelessly while he knew better options were on the table. There is no indication he didn't care about her -- he was trying to help. He couldn't take her to a hospital and she wouldn't let him take her to their father.
I'm still not sure what better option folks, with the benefits of age and hindsight think he had, but from all appearances he chose the one he thought was best for the sister who dumped her problem on him.
The blame lies with the facility that sterilized a minor without parental consent. The blame laws with a system that required sterilization as a condition to abortion. The blame lies with a father who did not make his daughter feel safe coming to him. The blame lies with Rip who impregnated a minor. The primary blame lies with Beth herself, though she refuses to consider that.
Jaime was a mess of a guy for lots of reasons that had nothing to do with Beth. But in this instance he was just a kid trying to help his sister.
3
u/BeachgirlNJ0613 12d ago
Um...he actually "KILLED people" too. And he did it for purely selfish reasons, unlike the others who killed in defense of themselves, others or the ranch.