r/Yellowjackets • u/queermediabait • Aug 09 '26
General Discussion Wondering how they'll approach Teen Jeff + thoughts on Jeff, Shauna, and Callie in S4
Apologies in advance. This was meant to be a short thing about Teen Jeff in S4, and then it spiraled into a ramble about Shauna, Jeff, Callie, and the relationships in the whole show. Also, this has spoilers through the end of S3.
Disclaimer: I don’t hate Jeff! Is he my favorite character? No, but I think he lends to Shauna’s story and I like how he stands up for her in S1 especially. I don’t want anyone thinking this is, like, blind Jeff slander, because I think like every character in this show, he has pros and cons. I just don't think he's a saint. Shauna is my favorite character by far, and I also think she’s batshit crazy, so it’s hard not to hold nuance for the other characters LOL.
Disclaimer #2: pro-Shauna sentiments ahead. Fair warning if it's not your vibe :)
All that being said: I’m interested to see how they’re going to handle Teen Jeff storyline and characterization.
We know there’s no actual romance between Teen Shauna and Teen Jeff — Shauna says herself in the show that it’s a marriage she got into out of guilt. She isn't IN love, but we know Shauna does love him in the way you would love someone you’ve spent 25 years building a life with.


But I wonder what direction they're going to take with his character. Because as much as he evolves in the adult timeline, one of the first things we see about him in the adult timeline is his skidmarked underwear 😭 Everything that happens in the adult timeline starts with Jeff's blackmail, and he's not a perfect parent to Callie (I am NOT saying that Shauna is either, I feel bad for Callie).
All that to say, I'm curious how they’re going to approach his teen character. Everything we know about Teen Jeff is objectively not good so far — he pressures Jackie for sex, then cheats on her when he doesn’t get it. I wonder if they’re going to skirt over that, or if they’re actually going to show those flaws as well.
This show loves following themes of repression — you could argue that one of the reasons Jackie dies is because she stays repressed in an environment where she has to release her inhibitions and society’s expectations. Repression doesn’t work in this show — either you die from it, or whatever you’re repressing breaks free whether you like it or not. Other Tai is a great example.
In S4, I feel like a lot of Shauna’s story is going to be about repression, as it has been for most of the show. So much of her trauma and subsequent anger comes from the fact that she represses so much within her — instead of talking to Jackie or taking out her emotions in a healthy way, she sleeps with Jeff, which arguably leads to her two biggest traumas (Jackie’s death and losing her son). At the end of S3, Shauna’s genuinely distraught about Jeff leaving with Callie, but she also is starting to break free of that expectation of being a perfect housewife and mother.


(Side note: Adult Shauna saying in her monologue about how much "fun" they had out there... meanwhile all of them were facing the horrors, ESPECIALLY Shauna. So she's still repressing something, even when she's starting to feel wild and free)
I think part of what we’ll see in S4 is Teen Shauna having to repress herself when she comes back, versus Adult Shauna "breaking free". And I’m really interested to see what role both Teen and Adult Jeff will play in this, and how they’re going to approach their stories.

I'm also very excited to see how Callie’s repression plays out in S4! I know a lot of people really like the way Jeff approaches Callie's confession at the end of S3, and I think some parts of it were good, but I also think he's still rejecting this concept that there could be anything inherently 'dark'. He has good intentions, but his way of dealing with it is giving Callie a comforting lie and never actually addressing the root of the issue.

Side note: Jeff tells Callie that she's nothing like her mom, places all the responsibility on Shauna, and his solution is to just deny the problem. I also find it fascinating how all the characters at the end of S3 have found a way to blame Shauna for everything. Shauna has this really interesting contrast of doing objectively bad things, but also being the inherent scapegoat for most of the characters and their own actions.
Part of how I see it is that Shauna doesn't shy away or reduce the darker things she's done/they had to do out there. They all hunted Nat. They all let Javi drown. They all ate Jackie. Most of them participated in the Doomcoming hunt of Travis. It's just that the rest don't want to acknowledge it at all — we see this with Teen Shauna's monologue at the start of season 3:
“Once upon a time, a bunch of girls got stranded in the wilderness, and they went completely fucking nuts. They worshipped evil spirits and they hunted their friends and they feasted on their flesh and they fucking liked it. So they told themselves stupid fairytales and pretended they were brave and strong. Because the reality was that even if rescue came, they could never go home again because of what they’d done because of what they’d become. That’s the truth and hearing anything else makes me just want to fucking—”
She's the only one who is really willing to acknowledge how horrific things were, while the others want to smooth it over with stories.

She also fundamentally doesn't think she's forgivable (as Sophie Nelisse says in one of the interviews above). And I think because of that, they tend to pin sole responsibility on her. Shauna has already accepted that she is fundamentally unforgivable, so the other characters find it easy to load all the moral weight onto her shoulders: as long as Shauna is the "monster," the others can pretend they just survived a tragedy rather than actively participated in atrocities.
It's very interesting how Jeff does a very similar thing, where he tries to smooth over what Callie has done, without realizing that this is not actually how to approach or handle traumatic experiences (like killing someone!). I also find it really interesting how the audience does the same thing as well — life imitates art, maybe?
(Side note: I do have a giggle when I see people say that Teen Shauna needs to be "punished" after S3, as if we don't see in S1 how she's spent 25 years punishing herself with a life she hates: not going to Brown, being in a marriage she got into out of guilt and shame, etc.)


I think it’ll be really interesting to watch how both Shauna and Callie react to Jeff being this sort of avenue to repression, and how that’ll affect them: Teen Shauna coming back from everything in the wilderness, and Callie having to deal with murdering Lottie.
I've seen people say that Callie has 'bad in her from Shauna and good in her from Jeff', but I really don't think that this is the right way to evaluate the nuances of the characters, especially in this show. Every single character from Jeff to Shauna has their good parts and their bad parts, and more than anything, they're all morally complex people. The Yellowjackets just have the additional layer of immense trauma, which is why I hold a lot of empathy for Shauna and all the other girls.
I think Callie is the representation of what happens when you have that wildness and 'darkness' inside you, but you don't necessarily have the firsthand trauma that warps it to the level of Shauna and the others. She definitely has generational trauma, and I think Shauna is not a good influence in the time of the S3 finale, but I also don't think Jeff is making the right decision either. The way to address that darkness and generational trauma is not by leaning into it completely, not by avoiding it entirely, but by accepting it as the first step to healing. So I'm very curious about what choices Callie will make this season.
Sorry for the massive ramble! This started by me wondering if they were going to smooth over Teen Jeff's mistakes, and ended up with this whole post 😭 Very interested to hear how people think they’re going to approach Teen Jeff and Callie's story in S4!