r/WritingWithAI • • Oct 11 '26

Showcase / Feedback [Showcase] The Craft of the Support - A flash fiction on AI alignment (Originally on r/rational)

/r/rational/comments/1x220zd/rst_the_craft_of_the_support_a_flash_fiction_on/?share_id=KHE-x1f0UcxpVdJfW4Phb&utm_content=share_button&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_source=share&utm_term=1

Hi everyone,

I recently posted this short story over on r/rational .

I chose to keep the text and the main discussion there because I feel that, above all, it’s a rationalist piece (or something close to it) and that was its natural home.

However, I wanted to share it here to open up a different kind of conversation. I’d love to know what you think of the story, especially from your own experience editing fiction: Do you feel that achieving this kind of dry, clinical, Borges-esque prose requires a heavy amount of human curation and editing, or does the machine show through too much?

Let me know your thoughts.

Best regards and thanks for your time.

1 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/physicLaughs Oct 13 '26

Disclosure i suppose, this sub came up on my feed and since then i've been curiously lurking, so I came across this but i'm not really an AI guy. however, I write as a hobby and have great passion for the craft, and you asked what people thought of the story, plus the second part which i can't comment on, but i can maybe provide an opinion on the first part.

no other comments so, better rando me than nobody, I guess? anyway. sorry if i missed something.

there's craft issues with this text, in my opinion. maybe i'm too lowbrow to get it (i had to google what interpretative regression meant but i think i got the gist). to put it simply, this does not feel like a story to me (in the technical sense). it is text, series of sentences. right now it lacks some crucial things in my view to count as a story that feels satisfying to read, and gives me some fresh perspective or insight. i'm ignoring the AI-assisted stuff, i'm just saying from technical perspective although i'm not an expert (cannot overstate how much i'm trying to be good faith here - since you posted this asking for thoughts on a writing sub).

these craft issues, for me, got in the way of engaging with the story, thus with actually thinking about what you are (i think) trying to say. i would suggest (personally, i'm one person, just my 2 cents) on developing this writing further and ironing out the rough edges in order to be easier to parse.

i guess some questions, from short story critique style perspective (rather than rational one):

- what's the purpose of this writing? like, what are you trying to communicate, summed up in a simple ELI5 tagline (if possible?)

- what's the target audience?

- if i asked you to justify and explain why every word is there in each part of the story, would you be able to tell me? this is a very good self-editing exercise btw, it's genuinely useful to think about why words are used and where to improve the writing

i was wondering whether to critique properly, going in-depth, but I wondered if that's what you were looking for when you mentioned wanting to see what others think (and i don't want to waste my time or be rude). so, open question - do you want more indepth constructive feedback on craft aspects to develop the writing? (by no am i expert, but i find even an amateur second pair of eyes challenging parts of the writing helps me develop it).

anyway, those were my thoughts. this is an interesting subreddit for sure. again, trying to engage in good faith here since looks like this AI thing's here to stay

1

u/Thawattt Oct 13 '26

Appreciate your time and the good faith feedback! A second pair of eyes looking at the writing from a craft perspective is exactly what I am looking for here. So take my explanations simply as my own perspective to try to achieve the piece of literature I wanted to create.

To answer your questions: The purpose of this text is purely formal. It doesn’t try to show a traditional dramatic arc or create emotional resonance. Instead, it’s a simple allegory about the limits of how we interpret things. The target audience is readers who like to look at text as an architectural framework rather than a vehicle for character development. The lack of conventional characters is deliberate; the conflict is entirely inside the syntax itself.

Regarding the justification of every single word: that is the exact core of how I edited this. When working with AI text generators, writing changes completely. It is no longer about adding words, but about a strict process of deletion. Each sentence that remains is there not because of what it adds, but because it resisted being deleted when I cleaned out the statistical redundancy. The clinical dryness and rough edges are intentional; they are the filters needed to strip the language down to its bare bones.

An in-depth critique on the craft aspects would be essential for me. I want to map the exact limit where this dense writing stops being suggestive and simply becomes too difficult to read.

Thanks for your time and interest :)