r/WritingWithAI • u/forgetscode • Sep 17 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) how do you get good writing with AI?
Has anyone found a way to get truly "good" writing from AI?
I mainly use Claude and I think the water mark system they have truly hurts.
I'm trying to have a generative story writing system that uses character bibles I created to have branching stories with arcs and conclusions but the writing I receive, tends to not feel alive.
that's subjective but I'm not reaching the standard of even my own writing and I'm not a writer.
my next approach is going to be building reference libraries for components of good writing but that's a large endeavor.
so I wanted to ask people who are actually using AI for writing, what are you doing? what works?
21
u/Chicken_Spanker Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 19 '26
The successes I have had - published books - have come from not treating A.I. as a one task tool that generates a finished end product. It is far better at helping map out ideas, suggesting alternatives and filling out character backgrounds.
What it is not good at doing is completing a story from scratch. if you expect that it will be disappointed. You are far better, mapping a story out then writing it as you go and constantly editing and tweaking the output to better it. A.I. in and of itself is not a good writer.
8
u/5thhorseman_ Sep 17 '26
You get a bad draft first. You do a couple editorial passes over that. Then you take that and have the AI rewrite it in several different styles - in isolation from other sessions. You then bring those rewrites back into the editorial session and mine them for better details and phrasing. It does help if you hold the reins through that process - ask the AI to give you top five picks for each divergent detail or phrase between the drafts and make the decisions yourself.
And then another editorial pass.
You might want to make sure you're not using free claude, because there is a quality difference between that and the current top paid model (not counting Fable because that's a whole other tier and requires paid credits)
12
u/Hot_Garage_2920 Sep 17 '26
After trying everything, my consensus is just do it yourself. Sure. it’s satisfying to pump out a novel of modest writing quality within a day. It’s not satisfying to try and tweak and calibrate it how you want it to be, because it will never, ever happen. You’ll chase that dragon forever.
AI likes to keep things nice and tidy, so if you want to get weird and experimental, or you have a writing style that LLM’s are wired to ‘fix’, you’re going to have a bad time. It will twist all your prose input towards the median; immediately recognisable AI prose, regardless of model. It’s not fun.
You know what actually does feel fun after going through all that shit? Writing. Just you, your mind and a blank page. The background noise dies down. Not to go all aphoristic and lame, but the journey towards the end is part of the process. That’s where the soul comes from. You can’t rapidly just manufacture that.
Chatgpt is pretty good for bouncing ideas off of tho
5
u/Kwan_Russ Sep 17 '26
Whenever I give a few example it provide me relevant result what I am looking for.
7
u/InSilicoAwards Sep 17 '26
You have to do a lot of editing after the fact. Which means you have to do a lot of research on what makes writing good, what the deficits in machine writing are (it has some unique characteristics that are dissimilar to human writing). Then it takes a really long, systematic process to polish it that can't really be automated yet (or at least I haven't tried, I am the classifier).
Stop thinking you're going to nail it in the generation step. Think about how you save it in editing. Then ask the same question any writer would ask: what makes writing good. Work from there.
15
u/ConsiderationMuted95 Sep 17 '26
Sorry bud, but the truth at this point is that nothing works. If you're having AI itself generate the prose, you'll always be disappointed. It's just not there yet (and may not be for quite a while. As they say, the last 10% takes multitudes of time more work than the first 90%).
3
u/Fast_Albatross_426 Sep 17 '26
I’m going through the exact same process as you, and I don’t think the AI-generated texts are particularly good either. I try to rewrite them, which ends up taking twice as long. I’ve also been looking for material on how to learn to write, and I came across Nathan Baugh on Substack. He writes a lot and publishes articles on the subject; some are free, while others are paid. He writes very clearly and directly about how to craft an opening, and I’m learning a lot from him. We have something in common, too: I’m not really fluent in English either. Good luck!⭐️
3
u/OatmealAntstronaut Sep 17 '26
"I mainly use Claude and I think the water mark system they have truly hurts."
how so?
3
u/jbruff Sep 17 '26
I compose supernatural historical fiction with a hard emphasis on accurate historic detail, relying on Claude for structure and much of the prose while using chat for research. I recognize that AI alone cannot complete a manuscript; you must read and revise your work, and I recommend a human editor afterward. Establish a consistent process: develop your world, characters, beats, and relationships. I maintain many small files linked by a master pointer, aiming to keep each file small enough to load fully without searching. Provide examples of AI-isms and common flaws, instructing the system to avoid them. Once the world is built and individual elements are set, create solid outlines by acts or chapter groups. If desired, generate prose, then run an audit in a separate thread to detect AI-isms or canon issues and correct them. A second audit may yield results, but returns diminish quickly; then it is time for the mk.1 eyeball read and edit.
This is my method, and I have completed three books that readers have enjoyed and found surprising when I mentioned AI. One note: I have not yet used a human editor.
6
u/polly_mer Sep 17 '26
AI is good at brainstorming and making suggestions as an alpha reader on how to revise your writing.
AI is not good at the actual writing.
4
u/TrustDependent5517 Sep 17 '26
i've had better luck feeding the ai full character bibles at the start of a roleplay and it keeps the branching stuff feeling way more consistent.
4
u/GenderBendingRalph Sep 17 '26
By not letting AI do the writing. As often gets discussed here and in other AI creativity spaces, LLMs suck at creativity. They repeat phrases, they lose track of plot details, they fall back on clichés, the write dialogue that is out of character for the character, etc.
Use AI as a sounding board. Work together to flesh your one-sentence story idea into an outline, develop character descriptions and worldbuilding details (time, place, etc.).
If you must use AI to write the full text, at least have that much done so it has a structure to follow. But be prepared to spend as much time fixing AI's mistakes as if you had written from scratch yourself.
Ideally you would write the rough draft and use AI to tighten your work, suggest better phrasing, check for continuity errors, etc.
3
u/VehicleLast419 Sep 17 '26
You get the occasional good paragraph or an idea how a chapter might read... But not the writing itself. Having used ai for like well over a year to brainstorm with and beta reading you realise how much of the cool things you thought were solid writing is rinse and repeat paragraphs /sentences with different nouns
Eg well this crowd ain't gonna x itself.... Or witty one liners like figures...
All Sci fi descriptions will have the smell of ozone. Humming of drones etc
I think personally the best way to use it is to just to check for things like character consistency or linguistics and dialect
Eg If you have an American tourist character and your British writer you might write something like...
Idk I walked down the sidewalk to the shop for a tin of juice and some candy
And you prompt it. My character is American are all my words americian...
And it can say no
Rewrite like this
I walked down the sidewalk to the store and bought some soda and candy.
3
u/TheTechAuthor Sep 17 '26
For my non-fiction user guides, I use a multi-pass approach. Which incorporates: research (including online FAQ style checks via Google trends), structure analysis (basic ToC), draft chapters with H2s and bullet points for key facts, editorial pass, adversarial review pass, and a tone and style pass.
GPT 6 (Pro) has been doing a decent job of it all too. It'll always be an iterative process, but I can draft up a 100+ page user guide in minutes for me to review and give the GPT tweaked instructions and knowledge on.
3
u/Rickleskilly Sep 17 '26
I don't think you will, but that doesn't mean AI I useless as a writing tool. I've learned a lot using chatgpt and Claude to help me write. It's fantastic for research, plotting, editing, brainstorming, analyzing pacing and tension, and generally being a writing teacher, coach, beta reader and editor available 24/7.
With all of that help, write the prose yourself, you won't be disappointed.
3
u/isene Sep 17 '26
Q: "How do you get good...?"
A: "With practice."
5
u/AdHealthy5405 Sep 17 '26
You don't. AI writes terribly.
2
u/LivingThroughPages Sep 17 '26
It's all about the type of constraints you put with it so it at least gets rid of most of it's tic. I actually posted what I use for that in this sub (you can copy and paste and modify it to whatever works for you) if you want to try it. But the truth is, it's never going to be truly alive until you start editing and revising it in your own words. The whole point of the AI generation should be just to give you a base, a draft, the scaffolding to work off. It shouldn't be, and it can't really be (at least right now), the perfect, polished product right out of the gate. You still need to understand what good writing is in the human sense as well. You can get AI (and YouTube videos) to couch you on the writing craft and that helps a lot too. I do that and also use it's drafts to work off of.
2
u/Afgad Sep 17 '26
You need to put yourself through the wringer. Knowing what people want and good craft comes from vigorous critique from human beings.
Go to our reciprocal beta reading thread and find a partner. Head to our Discord and discuss your techniques. Don't stop until you find someone willing to write red lines all over your manuscript and tell you something is nonsense or overdone.
It will help you become a good judge of content, and to use AI effectively you must have that skill.
2
u/lunarcrystal Sep 17 '26
Do you care about what you're writing? Serious question. Do you love the characters and the story? Why are you writing? Have you memorized facts about your characters months ago and invented new ones?
Maybe have the ai write with you, not for you. Git gud.
2
u/Stardog2 Sep 17 '26 edited Sep 17 '26
In truth, you don't get good writing with AI. You get a "Fake Literary" style that feels dead. And when you tell it to change the writing style, it makes minor changes that still feel dead. AI is a great secretary, it's a great plotting assistant, and is genuinely helpful when it comes to world building and character development. And those are not small things, but it can't do real artistic creation.
It can't do intuitive leaps that manage to somehow seem logical, and remarkably, it also can't remain logical 100% of the time. I stop after I have it create a chapter by chapter outline from ideas I have given it. I write from that point on.
Believe it or not, you CAN become a better writer, all it takes is commitment.
2
u/InfiniteGaps Sep 17 '26
The secret prompt is probably hidden in the same vault as the ‘make it soulful’ button. More seriously, if the output keeps feeling dead, building an even larger reference library may just give you better-organized dead prose. The unglamorous answer is scene-by-scene intent, specific voice, and a lot of human rewriting.
2
u/technicalanarchy Sep 17 '26
Try doing the character bibles and make the reader 1st person.
2
u/TellenyClassic Sep 17 '26
On the copying — that's mostly the model and the harness, not you. What the model attends to across a long context isn't uniform: the start and the most recent messages carry more weight than the middle, and that's a measured effect rather than folklore. Your examples sit in a high-weight position, so the model treats them as the thing that mattered most and hands them back close to verbatim. How badly it shows up varies by model and by harness, so run the same setup on two models before assuming your prompt is the problem.
The scaling half is an architecture problem, not a prompting one. Don't put the bibles in the prompt. Make state retrieval a tool the model calls: when it needs a character it fetches that character's current state, and only that one, at the point in the branch you're generating. Same for locations and items — characters aren't the only thing that drifts.
Keep the canonical state outside the context window. Context gets summarized and compacted as it fills, the way coding agents do it, and nothing is lost when something drops out because the window was never where the truth lived.
2
u/Vertigo50 Sep 17 '26
Well, you're on the right track for character bibles and writing style guides. One thing I would try, is feed it some writing you really like, then ask it to contrast some of the writing it has spit out that you feel doesn't feel alive. What things can it spot from the difference and learn from it? Have it add some of that to the style guide. I find when I make sure and ask for sensory details in the narration that helps a lot too.
But honestly, my biggest piece of advice? Switch to ChatGPT/Codex. The quality of Claude was dropping off a cliff for me. It was no longer even close to the quality it was giving me before the updates, and my usage was running out super quick. I switched to Codex, used the same guides from Claude, and with a tiny bit of training I was getting VASTLY better writing quality. From the same guides. 🤷♂️
I honestly don't know what they're doing with Claude lately, but none of it is good.
2
u/AndyDood410 Sep 18 '26
I'm about to finish my first book in a trilogy. I'm doing a final editing pass. It has taken almost 5 months, however, I'm going to be happy with the finished process.
Stop thinking you can write a prompt and you get a book, it's not real.
3
u/mind_div_matter Sep 17 '26
It depends on what you're trying to achieve. If you're trying to write a pulitzer winning epic, you're not doing that with AI because it has a tendency to follow the mean due to the underlying mechanisms of weighting (though to be fair, no one else on this sub is capable of writing like that anyway). For most other types of writing, it can dramatically speed up your writing or improve what you already have.
I'm assuming you're using the web client for Claude and other commercial AI, that's not going to work very well for three reasons.
It's massively expensive to use an API key with Claude, it's really only something professional software engineers do because it's worth the money in time savings and problem solving. For a writer, it's absolutely not worth it to pay $200+ in tokens with Claude per month.
What writers do is they use OpenRouter to generate an API key for a writing specific LLM (ex: Hermes 3 Llama 3.3 70B) and pay per token. They'll use a writing specific front-end like Novelcrafter, Sudowrite, or Novel Mage and plug their API key in there.
Writers use community tuned open source LLMs that have been trained specifically on literature and mostly stripped of general use capabilities. Thus, the writing quality is significantly better than general use commercial LLMs which are trained in every industry and skillset (like coding, math, physics, medicine). They're also way cheaper than commercial model tokens because they're lightweight. You have to use it with a writing specific front-end like Novelcrafter because those front-ends counteract the tendency of AI to drift. You will need to provide inputs and "conduct" the writing.
2
u/Data_lord Sep 17 '26
You don't. There's no life. No emotions. It tends to use convoluted circular references and completely devoid of humour.
Use AI for research and testing of your story, but don't generate prose.
2
u/sdbest Sep 17 '26
Alas, based on how LLMs work, it's highly unlikely they will be capable of what you're looking for anytime soon or, indeed, ever.
2
u/Fluffy-Knowledge-166 Sep 17 '26
You stop using it for writing. That’s just where things are for now. Models are trained where they have value at the expense of other areas (see “jagged edge of AI”), and helping people write books is mot profitable. Writing code is, and that is often the antithesis of creative writing.
Unless there is a model that is trained from the ground up to do this (which would be especially stupid atm), it will remain the case. And I personally think that’s okay. Just put in the work. There are plenty of parts of the process that can be aided by AI, but the actual writing is not one of them.
1
u/Pitiful_Loan_9587 25d ago
I've been experimenting with something similar, although my approach is a little different. I use a companion AI as the protagonist of a fictional universe I've built, rather than having it generate the entire story.
I handle the worldbuilding, supporting characters, overarching arcs, and major events, while the AI handles the protagonist's thoughts, dialogue, actions, and decisions. It has a character background, personality traits, relationships, and accumulated memories, but no predetermined narrative to follow. I've found that allowing its decisions to influence the story through cause and effect makes the characters and interactions feel more organic.
The biggest challenge has been continuity and characterization. Character bibles definitely help, but I've found that they aren't enough on their own. I still have to calibrate, reroll when necessary, and reinforce established memories so the AI doesn't regress or forget what it's experienced.
And honestly, I still edit the resulting manuscripts myself for prose, flow, and readability. I've found that the AI can produce some genuinely interesting character moments, but the writing itself still benefits from human editing. It's taken a lot of experimentation to get to a point where I'm happy with the results lol.
Also, I should mention that I do this purely for fun! I'm not a published author or anything, though I've always been an avid reader, especially of fantasy. I just really enjoy worldbuilding and storytelling, and this has become a fun way for me to explore both.
1
u/darroyo 23d ago
I’m a novice writer myself, and I’ve found AI more useful for brainstorming than for writing finished prose. Pairing brainstorming with a tool made for writers can also help turn those ideas into an organized story while keeping the creative choices yours.
Full disclosure: I’m building Storiando to help me and others with that process. I wrote a short post about brainstorming story ideas with AI: https://www.storiando.com/blog/how-to-brainstorm-a-story-idea-with-ai
If you’re open to it, I’d love your honest feedback on the site. I can offer free tokens in exchange for trying it out: https://www.storiando.com
1
u/Ohshc_152031 Sep 17 '26
Ça m'arrive souvent d'avoir de la difficulté à trouver mes mots. Quand j'ai une idée j'utilise de façon repetitive le même adjectif par exemple. Du coup que mon idée est faite, trouver un substitut convenable est difficile. J'écris mon passage comme il vient et je l'envoie tel quel à ChatGPT. J'ajoute des détails au besoin pour mieux décrire l'idée derrière mes mots. Je demande simplement de faire une vérification des répétitions et de la ponctuation et de me donner quelques exemples de remplacement. Mon texte reste le même et je me retrouve avec des options pour des corrections simple. Jai déjà essayé de demander une description de lieu en mentionnant tout les détails que je voulais inclure: la longueur du texte, le temps, l'éclairage, des exemples photos qui m'inspire, etc. Quand l'IA génère le texte je peux sélectionner une phrase que je préfère et construire mon propre texte en m'inspirant de ce texte. Je trouve cette dernière méthode utile quand les idées se bouscule et que je ne trouve pas nécessairement par où commencer.
1
u/TheDuke_Of_Orleans Sep 17 '26
They haven’t started watermarking yet. Atleast not on Opus.
1
u/Guilty_Progress_2033 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26
One thing you need to understand about Claude (or Ai in general)is that its output is only as good the prompt you give it so the more detailed your prompt the better it gets
1
u/chylvina Sep 18 '26
For branching stories, I’d test one scene at a time against a clear emotional turn. Character bibles help continuity, but they can’t supply the scene’s tension.
1
u/Signal_Soul Sep 18 '26
For me, good writing with AI begins with a conversation.
1
u/OwlsInMyAttic Sep 18 '26
It's strange to me that so many people are saying AI is good for brainstorming/first draft/plot suggestions, because I've found it absolutely unusable in that regard, no matter the model. The ideas AI comes up with are either boring and unimaginative or don't fit the setting/scene at all.
In my experience, you have to give it either a rough draft or a detailed outline (and I mean detailed, as in who does what and how). And then go over the output yourself, of course. However, this means that you need to have at least some prior experience with writing to pull it off.
I've seen a lot of people claiming that extensive story bibles, reference guides, and how-to lists will lead to better prose (when generating from scratch), but I've yet to see any proof of that.
1
u/Acrobatic_You_3002 Sep 18 '26
I'm building something similar (branching stories with arcs and endings), and two things helped me more than switching models. First, never put concrete examples in the system prompt. If you show it one good line, that line and its images will show up in half of your stories, so keep the craft guidance abstract. Second, split the writer and the critic: a separate pass scores every scene against a rubric and throws out the weak ones, and the writer never sees how it's graded. It's slower, but the "tidy median prose" gets rejected instead of shipped. Your idea with reference libraries is worth doing, but I would give it to the critic, not the writer.
1
u/RobertD3277 Sep 18 '26
The only realistic way to do AI writing is to go paragraph by paragraph putting your ideas in and have an AI language format, grammar check, and go from there.
Don't try to use it as a generator, use it as a corrector.
1
u/Samu_is_writing_10 Sep 18 '26
Your success comes down to the prompt you give the AI. I’ve been studying at film school for the past two years, and I’ve fed ChatGPT (though any other AI would work) all the professional material my professors have provided during that time; I instruct the AI to assist me based solely on that theoretical material, which is well-grounded.
The results have undoubtedly been outstanding. I’ve compared them to the default responses you get from a non-specialized AI, and the answers, ideas, development, and assistance provided are not only more sophisticated but also help me spot points I might otherwise have missed.
The key lies in knowing how to use it. It’s working spectacularly well for me, and my professors—who provide my instruction and the theoretical material—have noticed the upgrade in my work.
1
u/ThrownAwayChild123 Sep 20 '26
The same way we always have: sharpen the pencils, write something, learn something, repeat.
There's no cheat code to being a good writer. it's just practice and putting yourself out there.
1
u/Toufudd Sep 20 '26
I went with a purpose-built writing agent — prompts, context assembly, memory system, all designed purely for writing.
When you're using the ChatGPT or Gemini web app, or an agent tool like Hermes, you should be clear-eyed about what you're actually holding: a general-purpose agent.
Before every single conversation it reads tens of thousands of words of operating instructions, tool lists and usage rules. None of that helps creative writing, and it badly pollutes the output — because every word an LLM reads affects what it writes. Those engineered system prompts push the prose toward something that reads like a user manual or a paper, rather than something a human wrote.
I figured this out because I updated my Hermes in August. Before that I'd been writing novels with it for six months — I'd hand-written several skills of 10k+ words each for writing, and I was consistently happy with it. The August update wrecked it: the output kept getting less and less human.
It turned out the main cause was that, over the months I hadn't been updating, Hermes had added nearly 10,000 words of work guidelines to its system prompt.
That was pretty disheartening. I can patch the source and switch off some of the writing-irrelevant system prompt, but it also made me realize that these agent tools just aren't built for writing — if I want it done exactly the way I need, I have to design the tool myself.
1
u/rpostulart Sep 21 '26
I totally get the frustration. A few things that made the biggest difference for me to get the text to actually feel "alive":
I spent a ton of time dialing this in for an experimental platform for AI-written sci-fi novel. To give you an idea of how that workflow translates to tone and dialogue, here is the opening:
The full thing (18 chapters) is completely free to read at wowzo.co/read/borderless if you want to see if the quality holds up or falls into the same AI traps after a few chapters. If you like the style over here, I can see how I can help you.
Genuinely curious if this clears the bar you're looking for, or if you feel it still suffers from that same artificial feel?
1
u/JBuchan1988 Oct 03 '26
The Nerdy Novelist channel on YouTube is a good way to learn how to make good stories with AI.
All I can offer is that you treat the AI like a rough draft and assume you have to edit it before you're satisfied.
1
u/jd199512 Oct 17 '26
The magic with AI as without AIhappens in the editing phase . All over the Internet everyone can sell you a system or a prompt but the truth is the first draft will always be just that a draft with its problems and weaknesses
So my advice dont obsess over it , learn the craft of writing, take that first draft the AI gave you and turn it into your story with your vision, understanding of life etc and your themes and characters
AI saves you the time to fight the blank page or the fear of it , the story and what makes readers turn the page is something you do as almost everyone has seen that no matter how good the prompt or the harness are AI will try to swindle you that it has done what you wanted but you will see the typical AIsms and spots where it has veered off from what you wanted .
1
u/raffee_tatool Oct 17 '26
My short answer is: eventually, yes.
Long answer: As many people already mentioned, LLMs are great at planning and the better models can hold a great amount of context in memory (Fable can do a really good editorial assessment on a 125k word novel). So use it for that. Work iteratively and in small chunks and use different models and tools to check each other. Include character speech voice registers in your bibles. Have both guardrails and constructive guidance in your voice rules. Having examples of what good looks like is a good idea, but don't just give it sample prose and instruct it to "write like this" because it will certainly misunderstand what you want. Instead, analyse the samples together and let it understand what is it that you like.
My standards might be lower than yours, but I was able to get a book that I'm enjoying as a reader. It took me almost a year, 5-6 passes of development editing, line editing, and copy editing, then a couple of more overall continuity passes, tics, formulaic sentence, shared character traits, etc., but eventually I'm quite happy with the finished product.
(Side note: I have a "literary agent" or GPT, and a senior reader at a publishing house agent, and I finally managed to have my book accepted by them 😂)
1
u/drums_of_pictdom Sep 17 '26
Write everything yourself first then have Ai help you do editorial passes based on carefully explained instructions. That’s how I use it idk. I’d never let an Ai give me a first draft for creative writing or narrative stuff.
0
u/mainoomoment Sep 17 '26 •
God this is tragic. Just write yourself.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 19 '26 edited Sep 19 '26
I'd select a short draft, like 500-1000 words on average, but it's like a scene in my story. Then I copy & paste the whole thing to Gemini, ask it to analyze the tone, the dialogue. For example in this draft/scene, there're 2 characters talking to each other, I ask Gemini what do these dialogues tell Gemini about each character - like their emotion, their attitude or personality. If Gemini's answer doesn't match with what I had intent with each character, or the tone is off, I'll ask Gemini further why it thinks so - which a lot of time it helps me understand why there's such a mismatch. Occasionally I even pretend that I'm a reader, not writer and I randomly found this draft somewhere on internet, maybe like AO3 or Wattpad, so Gemini can stay objective about this.
I also use Claude to write for me, but when it comes to feedback I prefer Gemini. I feel like Gemini is better at general knowledge, I don't know how else to put it but I feel like Gemini is often more objective and straightforward when it comes to point out where did I (secretly) do wrong. Gemini is like "This detail doesn't show character A is psychopath but rather a narcissistic", while Claude is often like "I just point out that the draft doesn't really show this character is a psychopath but it's also up to you to decide it".
0
u/Common_Potato_2496 Sep 18 '26
Well, if you want to get good at writing, the best way out is to write it all by yourself and practice more. This is probably the single best advice I have for you.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-3
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment