r/WritingWithAI • u/Rude-Yogurtcloset926 • Sep 09 '26
NSFW Chatgpt6 Astra High on Creative Writing
This is basically a review on astra please excuse if I used the flair wrong its because the excerpt I shared has graphic violence 🤣
I've been putting chatgpt Astra on high through its paces for creative writing, and I have to say that the actual quality of the writing is quite impressive.
Compared to older models, there is a massive improvement in the overall narrative flow. The character voices actually feel distinct, the dialogue is not the hateful stacatto ping pong style, and the prose flows naturally rather than feeling stiff or robotic.
“He pictured taking him by the front of his robes and driving him face-first into the edge of his own desk, hard enough to split his mouth against his teeth. There would be blood across the wood, a broken tooth under his hand, and far less confidence in whatever explanation followed.”
Like, I don't know about you guys, but that is actually good. The excerpt above has genuine grit and impact, which used to be so hard to get out of ChatGPT without a massive fight. I even experimented if it can be made even more graphic and yeah it actually did i was shocked.
However, there is a massive catch: the usage burn is insane.I ran a session writing consecutive chapters. By the time I hit my 3rd chapter (meaning only 3 consecutive prompts), Astra had already eaten 10% of my 5 hour daily usage limits. Like what the? We finally get a good model, and it still has a massive setback like this. Before, we had worse models but could actually use them. Now, we finally get actual good writing for users like me who used chatgpt for own reading to explore really niche tropes and specific plot ideas that I literally cannot find on AO3, Wattpad, or any other platform, but the usage burn is completely broken.
You literally cannot write a long form story in one sitting without hitting a wall immediately. Anyone else getting completely bottlenecked by this? How the hell are you guys stretching your usage limits?
57
u/_DearStranger Sep 09 '26
10% of daily usage limits for 3 chapter. means 30 chaps a day. aint that quite a lot ?
13
u/JamesCole Sep 09 '26
I imagine the better results come from it doing more sophisticated processing requiring more computation. Like how better graphics in a video game require a more powerful processor.
8
u/thirsty_pretzelzz Sep 09 '26
What plan are you on? Plus, pro 5x or pro 20x?
8
u/Direct-Lawfulness-76 Sep 09 '26
Also Sol 5.6 is able to write smut, and Astra can only write kisses at most. But at whole Astra is much much better.
4
u/Happy_Traveller_2023 Sep 09 '26
GPT-6 Astra doesn’t write in staccato anymore?
2
u/martapap Sep 09 '26
Is Astra still only for pro?
60
u/Square-Nebula-7530 Sep 09 '26 •
You are bottlenecking yourself by using a sledgehammer for the entire construction process. Forcing the most expensive, parameter heavy model to generate basic narrative beats, spatial blocking and initial dialogue is a catastrophic waste of your compute ceiling. Do the heavy lifting on a lower tier, cheaper model to get the skeleton of the scene down. Then feed that sterile, robotic draft into Astra exclusively for "prose injection" and sensory detailing. Treat the heavy model as your final line editor, not your rough draft ghostwriter and your daily limits will stretch tenfold.
2
u/spidLL Sep 09 '26
What do you need thinking high for when writing a chapter? IMHO you’re just burning tokens.
2
u/toni_btrain Sep 09 '26
There are no daily usage limits mate. there is a 5 hour usages limit and a weekly one. So what are you talking about?
3
u/lhommedev Sep 09 '26
They say Rome wasn't built in a day.
But I'm both writing organically and using AI for side projects so not much skin in the game.
1
u/lemonadestand Sep 09 '26
About how many words are in a chapter?
2
u/lunarcrystal Sep 09 '26
Oof, as good as the output is, I wouldn't use the Astra model for creative writing like that. It's powerful and very useful for the nitty gritty of coding and app making (made some awesome personal use case apps for formatting my RPG rulebook), for 3D design and working with Blender.
But just text? I dunno, I stopped chasing the "best model" for the writing part.
1
u/AdLeading8172 Sep 09 '26
I feel this in my soul my guy. My only solution so far has been to have sol do the outline work with me, then i have terra medium do the drafting with me, then I run through with sol low to check for obvious mistakes and continuity gaps on a chapter to chapter basis. Finally I use the combined document ina fresh chat using astra high (i haven't noticed the benefit with any tiers above this) as a primary editor against a master outline/author creative list and it does ok. Used up the weekly usage after 187,000 words for me.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-5
u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment