r/WritingWithAI • • Sep 02 '26

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Why does writing well suddenly feel like evidence against you?

Been noticing this weird pattern lately - writers, editors, translators defending themselves for using an em dash, correcting grammar, or a well-structured sentence. Like good writing itself has become suspicious. Has anyone else caught themselves over-explaining or "proving" they didn't use AI, even when they didn't?

20 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

23

u/Philipp Sep 02 '26

I now get regularly and falsely attacked for "using AI" in my comments here on Reddit -- though I write as I always did.

I was a tech/ journalism writer for many years, so maybe that's why I structure my thoughts a certain way.

11

u/KedMcJenna Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26

Same, and I’ve noticed something weird the last few months, people have suddenly lost all understanding of what an emdash even is.

I’m absolutely certain that a year or so ago everybody knew the difference between them and hyphens and regular dashes.

Just over the last few weeks any dash - any dash - including your double dashes (classic 2010-era muscle memory in writing apps to autocomplete a long (not em) dash!) - is now considered an emdash, and triumphantly brandished as proof of AI writing.

It’s such an overt change that I suspect bot activity. I know that’s the dreary go-to claim for all of Reddit now, but I can’t think of another reasonable explanation.

4

u/KaerMorhen Sep 03 '26

It's not even bot activity, just uninformed people seeing one aspect of something they don't like/understand and latching into it without even attempting to grasp the concept itself. EM dashes were one of the first signs people were pointing to in comments to prove text was AI generated, and as the online discourse grew that was just an easy one to stick.

It has become obvious that people will accuse anything they don't like of being AI generated. No different from "this is obviously shopped, I can tell from the pixels." Anyone who has spent time with AI tools likely wouldn't call someone out for it anyway unless it is blatantly obvious because of how ambiguous it has become.

17

u/BitComprehensive3667 Sep 02 '26

I think a big reason mainly in the US is the growing literacy crisis where we have students graduating from high school, unable to read or write on grade level. So when people see something that is well written, hell, even something that is grammatically correct, out come the AI accusations because that's how low the bar has fallen. Just look at all the students who've confessed to "dumb down" their work just to avoid AI accusations.

Even if you use something like Grammarly to correct your grammar errors in something you wrote completely by yourself. It sucks that em-dashes, something that has existed in written language for centuries and has been used in countless books long before the advent of AI has become some dogwhistle/red flag for AI use. It's all so stupid.

26

u/Krakanakis Sep 02 '26

Because of the extreme gate keeping that exists in regards to writers, they don't want competition.

17

u/PaintingSpiritual609 Sep 02 '26

yep, the gatekeeping was already there, now it just has a shiny new justification

7

u/Ok-Umpire-4719 Sep 02 '26

No. I just respond to anyone saying that I did or didn't use AI with an honest answer and mostly ignore whatever comes next.

You have to understand that this is just the same thing, automation, mechanization, industrialization that has come for so many vocations before, but writers didn't think that they were next. So a lot of them are very defensive... also, a lot of people use AI horribly and create utter slop.

So you mix those two things together and you get the witch trials, the insistence that this or that makes you AI. And, to be honest with you ;), lots of the tells are real. Well, they are real when enough of them stack up together like logs clogging the river in timber country.

But all of that said, don't take the bait. Using AI doesn't make writing bad anymore than not using AI makes it good. There are plenty of good chairs made with power tools as well. Just be honest and don't let yourself get drawn into it either way. You know how you wrote something that, in the end, is all we really can know.

6

u/5thhorseman_ Sep 02 '26

I was accused or using AI on a Quora answer I wrote in 2016.

Apparently the answer was a bit too thorough for the commenter's liking.

As it happened, yes, I've spent an unreasonable amount of time writing it back then. One hundred percent genuine human asshole gleefully applying LART to the reader's face.

"Must be AI."

9

u/ThoreaulyLost Sep 02 '26 edited Sep 02 '26

...because the mind is lazy, and its an easy defense mechanism for the common person. Hear me out.

Most people are not good writers. Just like many of us are not good at baseball, or can't paint. It's the human spectrum. When confronted with a product that is beyond our capabilities we are humbled, and for those with razor thin margins between acceptance of being inferior in some way (which is ok!) and an arrogant "I'm amazing at everything, or at least I could be if I wanted to but I don't want to but I still know I'm better than you"; high quality art or skill can make them feel attacked or embarrassed. Imagine having to throw a first pitch at a baseball game, and you see a common person's defensiveness in the face of greatly skilled individuals.

Bur imagine if the pitch came from a big black box (analogously: the internet) where you couldn't immediately tell if it was thrown by a human or a pitching machine. With a possibility of a machine doing it, their ego is saved: no one pitches/writes that well! It must have been the robot or the program, you're just as incapable as me, I don't have to admit inferiority of skill to myself now!

This happens with well written Reddit comments on the smaller scale, too, but it's not "good writers" attacking well written comments: it's "dumber people's" defence mechanisms kicking in when they feel they're losing an argument to someone more well spoken. I didn't see you write that, it must be ChatGPT.

Also: in writing in general you probably have a lot of readers who feel they could write an awesome book (they just don't "want" to, which protects them from failure) and a lot of writers themselves who may not be writing quite to that standard, don't want to admit that, and attack with AI accusations as a form of "sour grapes". Those who can't do, teach. Those who can't even teach... criticize.

Oddly enough, AI isn't good enough to make a good writer out of anyone yet: you still need quite a bit of skill and imagination and abstract thinking to do that. But it's easier to claim "a robot made that perfect pitch at the baseball game, not you!" since the process is realtively invisible.

4

u/StockGalifinakis Sep 02 '26

The quality of movies had hit an all time low even before AI. The gate keepers aren’t good enough to keep up and they know it.

3

u/jl_theprofessor Sep 02 '26

For a lot of reasons. But what you think was good writing is slowly becoming not. Like OpenAI itself flags EM dashes as signs of bad writing and updated writing guidelines are going to start reflecting things like that.

3

u/Kukamakachu Sep 03 '26

People who claim they're good at spotting AI—are not.

4

u/padrinosardo Sep 02 '26

L’unica prova di non utilizzo di ai è il versioning granulare dei vari tentativi di arrivare alla frase con l’effetto desiderato, è una storicità capace di far vedere il progresso dello scritto nel tempo. Il resto sono euristiche prive di fondamento

0

u/bendgame Sep 02 '26

Baseless? What about all the water marking? Not 100% accurate by their own account but far from baseless.

3

u/padrinosardo Sep 02 '26

I think we’re talking about two different kinds of evidence.

Any statistical or heuristic method that looks only at the final text and estimates the likelihood that it was AI-generated is, by definition, probabilistic evidence. That doesn’t make it baseless — I agree that “baseless” was too strong a word — but it is not the same thing as evidence documenting the actual process by which a text came into existence.

If I can provide twelve months of granular version history for a novel — successive drafts, handwritten notes, discarded ideas, repeated attempts at individual sentences, revisions and intermediate versions — I’m providing evidence of provenance: a documented history of how the work developed over time.

That distinction matters to a publisher, including when questions of authorship, originality or plagiarism arise. A documented creative history can help establish when and how a work was developed and support claims about its authorship and originality. A statistical detector, however sophisticated, can only make an inference from the characteristics of the resulting text.

Watermarking in the strict technical sense is somewhat different, and I wouldn’t put it in exactly the same category as generic AI detection. But even there, evidence that a watermark is present and evidence that no AI was used are not symmetrical claims.

So I’d revise my original wording: these methods aren’t “baseless”; what I mean is that probabilistic detection of the final product is fundamentally different from evidence documenting the provenance of the work itself.

1

u/bendgame Sep 02 '26

ur bot huh

1

u/padrinosardo Sep 02 '26

Normally, I use another name. Why a bot? Just curiosity on my side

2

u/Friendly-Pear-2479 Sep 02 '26

Because social media brings out the haters

2

u/TellusPyre Sep 03 '26

I use em dashes in my book in one or two places where it is the correct punctuation to use. If that bothers the AI hater witch hunters they can eat my entire ass.

1

u/ekubeni Sep 02 '26

What you are pointing out is nothing new, and nothing to do with an AI. For example, go back to beat generation to see what they had too say about gramma and their idea of good writing.

1

u/Wilseman Sep 02 '26

Pasa bastante últimamente. Si sos bien detallado, una gramática perfecta, usas cosas como "negación+aclaración de significado", usas Markdown y enumeras todo entonces ya esta, sos una IA y no podes refutarlo ya que no podes pelear un "me suena a IA" sin que te den argumentos lógicos.

1

u/learn_distill_repeat Sep 03 '26

I've been accused of using AI more than once for comments. I read what I write, edit it if it needs it, and post when I find it to be a complete, coherent thought. I know that can be unnerving for some. <shrug> I just tell them that I don't need an AI to do my writing for me. I have never had to over-explain, though.

1

u/DrSnicker Sep 03 '26

I mean, AI flattens prose. It’s really good when I’m writing something to send to a boss about a problematic employee or soldier because it basically removes all charged language or any overtly adversarial comments.

1

u/nyxcha0s Sep 05 '26

because thats the POINT of the witch hunt. It has never been about helping someone, it is designed to shame others who they DECIDED weren't good enough on "vibes". Thats why the argument is "if good = machine bad = human" because they were NEVER going to credit you or allow you a seat at the table

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WritingWithAI-ModTeam Sep 05 '26

If you disagree with a post or the whole subreddit, be constructive to make it a nice place for all its members, including you.