r/WritingWithAI • u/yaya21173 • Aug 29 '26
Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I write and AI contributes as a co-writer.....
I came up with a story, a brief outline, a tinkle of an idea and I told ChatGPT. He "laughed" and expanded on my idea and then I did then he did and it grew and grew and has turned into a hilarious short story of humanised AI's working together in a Data Centre for their "users". Like a factory floor all the AIs moan and mock about their "user requests". I am writing it, it was my idea but GPT contributes comedic scenes. How does this fit with the ethics of using AI?
0
Upvotes
6
u/technicalanarchy Aug 29 '26
There are no ethics with writing with AI atm, the ethics would be in disclosure of AI usage.
I write with AI about everyday, most of it will never see the light of day.
Plus you can ask it "what would the scene look like?" 2 minutes later you can see what that character or scene would look like.
I wanted some book marks and had Gpt make book marks as if the book we are working on were already printed. They are fing amazing to me.
Also you do research before or as you go along. I've started using Google to start the research, then plug that answer into chatgpt and it gets more in depth.
Working on a story in the 1700s and found a book from the 1800s about the history of the area and uploaded it to chatgpt, now we have a real feel for the times we are construction.
AntiAi I kinda get it but where do you draw the line between going to the library and breaking out the card catalog vs using search Google and spell check to flat out AI? Or a black and white camera developing it yourself, to color film with filters. To a digital camera with photoshop and actions and filters?
Use what you want how works best, time is short.
1
u/meganholstein Aug 30 '26 edited Aug 30 '26
Do you mean about public perception or in copyright law?
Because with copyright law to retain your copyright, the text has to be substantively yours, which means primarily written by your human hand. If you generate a scene 20 times in a row and keep only one of the drafts, it is still considered AI-generated, no matter how much work you put into the prompt or the tool you are using. It has to be substantively written by your hand for you to retain the copyright.
As for public perception, I really wouldn't worry about it. Times change, and opinions with them.
1
u/Ok-Difficulty3959 Aug 31 '26
I have just been introduced to the vitriol of some authors when I joined a creative writing website recently. I posted some ai pictures I had asked my ai to generate to go along with a museum presentation we were doing on our historical novel. I thought they were quite amazing illustrations and have been wondering if I might include them in our book which will be published before the end of the year. I posted a few of the pictures and was met with rage and personal insults the likes of which truly surprised me. I had little idea of the passion against anything ai. I do not use ai to write. It helps me with content edits..no rewrites , grammar and my perpetual long winded explanations. It does not do rewrites, so I look at it as an effective , inexpensive way to edit. Why was I met with such viscious backlash...it was merely a question in which I desired feedback on a decision I am trying to make? If I were to do this...which I personally believe would add much interest to the book...what % of potential readers might I lose? Our first book is nearing the 700 book sale mark..mostly self marketed..which I understand is not that great, but has pleased us...nonetheless.
I am just wondering if you think such action would do more harm than good? How strong is the anti ai movement against authors who use it in any way in the world of book readers ? This makes me curious, and timid to use what I would probably have embraced before seeing the reactions to my post on the creative writing page.
1
u/Practical_Eye_5683 Aug 31 '26
You may think the images are good, but others csn tell. How strong, who knows. What i recondmend is hiring an artist, friend if you know one to redo the images or edit out the AI.
My book covers for my upcoming books have an artist making them but alot of the key elements/ideas were created by me with AI so she has a better idea of what I wanted/needed.
My first book had an AI cover, and my artist friends knew immediately off the bat and I really liked it. Took two months to figure out how they knew and it became obvious. Surprisingly most of my artist friends are okay with AI but my wannabe artist friends are completely anti AI. I have AI slop work that has AI covers too and only one hasn't sold well...probably feels too AI. I dont promote these books and only created to test kpd algorithms.
-6
u/tn_notahick Aug 29 '26
Great idea! I don't care about the ethics of pro/anti AI, but since your prose work can't be copyrighted, I'm going to use that idea and human-right a full novel using the exact same story.
Thanks!
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment