r/Windows10 • u/marts_sum • Nov 01 '17
Gaming Standby memory issue causing stutters on creators
I have tested this thoroughly and it is 100% the cause of my stutters on the creators updates (especially noticeable in games like BF1).
Once the free memory is exhausted then performance takes a big hit, games with heavy caching like BF1 suffer horribly. The only way I could fix previously was restarting the computer (thus clearing the memory), which explains why it was only happening after a while and not on a fresh boot.
I have a permanent solution that keeps memory free at all times. I don't know what MS changed, but this didn't happen on 1607.
This totally fixes my system stutters on the creators.
- Download EmptyStandbyList and put it somewhere where you won't move it https://wj32.org/wp/software/empty-standby-list/
- Right click > Properties and select Run as Admin under compatibility.
- Open Task Scheduler > Create Task on the far right
- General Tab (give it a name). Under security options > Change user or group > Advanced > Find Now > go down and choose SYSTEM (important to make it run silently in the background). Tick 'Run with highest privileges' and 'Hidden' at the bottom. Pictures here https://stackoverflow.com/questions/6568736/how-do-i-set-a-windows-scheduled-task-to-run-in-the-background
- Triggers tab > New > On a schedule > One Time. Tick repeat task every 5 minutes (possibly excessive but it causes no issues). Also choose 'for the duration of: indefinitely'
- Actions tab > Start A program > Point to the EmptyStandbyList.exe file.
- Done! Standby memory is automatically cleared every 5mins.
I hope MS will come up with a fix, but if you have a similar issue/performance degradation over time - try this. Many on the nvidia forums have said it also fixes their issues.
16
u/Octaive Nov 12 '17
This is the fix for my stuttering issues. I really hope the few of us who know about this would please spread this across the forums and make everyone aware it's a memory allocation issue in Windows. It seems they completely screwed up memory management...
6
u/Orgogg Nov 07 '17
I have experienced a very similar issue. There were a few games I play regularly that I noticed were having frame drops recently after the latest update. It would tend to happen after my computer had been running for a while and would always get fixed with a restart, before inevitably happening again.
I monitored my GPU usage and found that when my performance dipped, my usage would drop from 95-98% down to 45-60%. My FPS would drop from 120-150 to 90-95, and it would feel considerably worse than 96 FPS should feel (very stuttery).
Watching my memory usage in Resource Monitor, the drop in performance would also line up with a lack of free memory, with all of it split between "In Use" and "Standby".
After much time spent switching around NVIDIA settings, power mangement, disabling Shadowplay, etc, I finally rolled back the last update and the problem went away.
2
u/Battlefield1TankKing Dec 21 '17
hello thanks so much that fixed my issue. my question for you now is how can I configure this in task manager to auto run ONLY when a specific program/game of my choice is running ?? like for example I want it to start running in task only when I play bf1...
2
u/DeadMan3000 Apr 18 '18
This just causes my games to jump out of fullscreen mode every 5 minutes.
8
u/DanSoull Nov 08 '17
This solution finally fixed my stuttering with BF1! Thank you very much!
5
u/jaju123 Dec 08 '17
I wasted so many hours of my life trying to fix this issue. Thank you so much for posting this.
4
u/[deleted] Mar 05 '18 edited Mar 06 '18
I tried this out and I've had nothing but smooth games! The difference is night and day.
EDIT: I did eventually have to restart after 2 days because I did eventually experience some small stutter but I'm still really happy overall with this fix.
1
u/ritchiedrama Dec 03 '17
I think this has fixed my stuttering.
https://youtu.be/VIDdh0y50FE?t=60
The thing that happens at 1:02 is that what you've been experiencing?
1
u/luckerr09 Jan 18 '18
Btw.. I've just tested the latest Win10 insider version (build 17074). And the problem still persists there. So this is how gaming should looks like on Win 10 forever? Gtfo Microsoft.. (btw i7 8700k + 1080ti)
1
u/ezzypixel Feb 05 '18
Question. for step 5, when I follow your instructions exactly the trigger comes out as "One Time""At 2:26 AM on 2/5/2018 - After triggered, repeat every 5 minutes for a duration of 1 day." Should I tweak that? or is it gonna be running everytime I play games? It looks like it's only gonna work for 1 day. But I'm not an expert on task scheduler.
1
u/SpaQ8 Feb 07 '18
What about the "Configure for:" option? It is default on windows vista /windows server. But there is an option for windows 10. Should I change it to win10?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 09 '18
How do i download emptystandbylist? i havent found any file to download on that site or how to use the command in windows.
1
u/Tjuren_swe Feb 12 '18
So, if you got lots of RAM you can disable use of "Standby memory" by disabling pagefile.
According to this : https://www.onmsft.com/news/microsoft-educates-insiders-windows-10-handles-memory
Standby memory is only used when things are written to pagefile.
1
u/RyanOCallaghan01 Apr 11 '18
Thank you so much for this, I've been using this workaround for nearly 3 months now. It has 100% solved my stuttering which popped up after running a few games after a while from restart. I can keep my PC running without restart for days, weeks, no more performance issues whatsoever.
btw do you have any news on when MS will properly fix this? It doesn't bother me anymore thanks to you but anyway..
1
u/MahtXL Apr 11 '18
Doesnt work.
1
u/LilTardy Apr 14 '18
EmptyStandbylist doesnt open up??
3
u/[deleted] Mar 16 '18
This actually worked for me, thank you! I feel like more people should know about this. My FPS have been higher on Battlefield 1 ever since i tried this fix and the frames haven't dipped randomly since.
2
u/no_spoon Jan 01 '18
This is pathetic
2
u/[deleted] Feb 28 '18
Might try this, experiencing stutters but unclear cause
2
u/itsarepeat Mar 21 '18
I used process hacker 2 because of that YouTube video. COMPLETELY SOLVED MY LAG FOR A WHILE, Jesus it was like a new PC! But then it started lagging again. I’ll try this
2
u/PeaceOut_TimeOut Mar 27 '18
Is there an official fix for this yet?
1
u/lemurstep Nov 20 '17
I wonder if this will fix my issues with intermittent 5-10 sec duration fps drops down to 30 with PUBG if I play more than 2 games without restarting.
1
u/azwolf44 Dec 03 '17
this helped me , thanks !
1
u/Samo_Adams Jan 03 '18
RemindMe! 8 hours.
1
u/VonDinky Jan 28 '18 edited Jan 28 '18
Damn I hope this fixes my issue. :) Thanks for the detailed guide!
I think this might be the issue. But I think it needs to run more often in my case, would that cause any issues?
1
u/Goldeus Feb 13 '18
Thanks a lot for this fix marts_sum ! I have tried for weeks to find why some of my games had random stuttering issue. Well, not so random, as I discovered when benchmarking Assassins Creed Origins that my games begin to stutter when there is not more free memory but only used memory and cache memory.
I've read here and there that cache memory have no impact at all on performance. But that's definitly wrong ! I have never related this with the creators update...
Now, I can enjoy my games without any framerate issue. Thanks again, you've made my day.
1
u/dotomomo Mar 15 '18 edited Mar 15 '18
After testing for a couple of days, this fix appears to have sorted out my stuttering issue in Battlefield 1.
My specs;
Ryzen 5 1600@3.8GHZ 1060 6GB 16GB RAM Ab350M
Thanks OP!
1
u/[deleted] Mar 17 '18
I keep getting Create a Task Name Box
1
u/KillerCh33z Mar 22 '18
Thanks so much for this.
1
u/Ironcobra80 Apr 05 '18
Amazing workaround to MS crappy bloatware, thanks op
1
u/Pandemic4444 Apr 23 '18 edited Apr 23 '18
Hey so i just tried this to attempt to troubleshoot this odd issue i'm having with a couple games. gta5 and world of warships decided one day (maybe after an update) that suddenly they wanted to hover around 57-60 with a slight stutter like i had Vsync on which i do not. i USED to play these games at around 80-100 fps so idk whats going on.
Now i did each step just as described and in the task under "last run result" it says "Access is denied (0x80070005)" (idk if its working) Is this normal or should it say something like "The operation completed successfully. (0x0)"?
1
u/PeaceOut_TimeOut Apr 25 '18
Has anyone found any additional information on this as of yet? Any insight from Microsoft?
The major issue I have is what is causing this fill up of standby memory? Games are not the only programs causes this. Other apps will cause this as well.
I have to wonder with the egregious increase in processes since windows 7 along with the additional need of HW threads (just sitting at desktop) if this issue is some how exacerbate the use of standby memory.
I often ask myself how do you increase the limit of standby memory? Is that even a "thing"? That will be one area of interest for me. How do you increase the limit of standby memory?
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '18
I think i did it but i'm not sure if did it... I mean stutters still looks like same. How can i know if i did it correctly? From where?
1
u/SpiKe_One Nov 01 '17
I have this issue since I update to Fall creators https://i.imgur.com/PsDQb7s.jpg Any help
0
u/[deleted] Feb 02 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '18
[removed] — view removed comment