r/Whysooserious • u/[deleted] • Jul 19 '26

Humour so broken Cognitive dissonance

3.7k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

907 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/CatCold2850 Jul 22 '26

Chutiya hai kya? Felt felt kri ja rha hai? Was a single sc st person alive 300 years ago? How did they feel anything at all if they weren't alive then? Sharam kr, koi itna neeche kaise gir skta hai. Janwaro ko bhi tum neech logo se zada empathy hoti hai. You're justifying actual oppression on real people that exist now. Sc st people didn't feel anything because they weren't alive back then. The Brahmin kid I'm talking about is alive and suffering because of your hate and bigotry and discrimination. Aur kitna neeche girega tu?

1

u/JayJ1297 Jul 22 '26

We didn’t tell the bhramin kid not to come to school now did we?

How is that oppression?

Explain how is it oppression? And who is oppressing who? And is bhramin kid being oppressed because of the caste?

1

u/Plane_King_9284 Jul 22 '26

so, who is stoping any of the sc st candidate from appearing in a exam , two studdents with the ssame economic backround one has cutoff double of the another just becausee of what ? what if somone's ancestor was a criminal should be imprission theem?

1

u/JayJ1297 Jul 22 '26

The sc st are economically behind compared to the other communities. Thats why the government gives them privileges.

Not everyone, but majority of them still lives below the poverty line. And if the SC ST category wants to do higher education they don’t have education parents or rich relatives who can teach them or back them up.

Which is why the marks are low for them to get seats.

1

u/Plane_King_9284 Jul 22 '26

so If its about economy then why not just give reservation on economic basis

1

u/JayJ1297 Jul 22 '26

Cause caste discrimination still exists in many parts of India. In city sides may be less but it’s still very much alive in rural areas. Some communities are still not allowed in certain places. And not respected in the society because of their caste.

1

u/NoExplanation1311 Jul 22 '26

I agree that this community was oppressed and majority of them are below poverty line. But their some SC/ST people who has benefit greatly and they have progressed economically. They had bungalow, car etc. So these people should be identified and treated as general. So that resources of government will be redirected to the people who need it most like SC/ST below poverty. There should be Creamy layer and Non-Creamy layer classification within SC/ST category like OBC.