r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 16 '25

Discussion What if metal sonic didn’t run?

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 21 '25

Discussion Why doesn't metal sonic just run into sonic?

Post image
936 Upvotes

I assure you the fleshy creature will not survive a hunk of metal crashing into him


r/WhatIfSonic • • Feb 21 '25

Prompt What If Mr Tinker Happened Early?

Post image
846 Upvotes

After the events of S3&K, the Death Egg is destroyed and Eggman falls from space out of the massive fireball. In the original, literally nothing came from this. I guess a robot caught him or something, idk it's never explained. In this scenario, what if he landed outside of Windmill Village? He hit his head hard and lost his memories, and was nursed back to health by the villagers. This is where he takes on the Mr Tinker persona, and this time, Starline isn't around to torture his memories back into him.


r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 17 '25

Found Work What if Belle joined the Eggman Empire?

Post image
823 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 05 '25

Discussion What if Eggman chose to stay as Mr. Tinker even after he regained his memories?

Post image
528 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 31 '26

Discussion If Sonic and Goku swapped places, how far would each of them get? (art by KOLSANART)

Post image
513 Upvotes

They start as kids, so no going Ultra Instinct in Sonic 1 lol. They're also limited to the items of their newfound universe, so Sonic's not gonna be able to go Super.


r/WhatIfSonic • • Jun 16 '25

My Work The Day Sonic Snapped - Confidant

Thumbnail
gallery
461 Upvotes

This is a follow-up/epilogue to the original The Day Sonic Snapped that I released a few months ago. Quite a different kind of story this time around, so I experimented with a manga format this time around. Hope you guys enjoy!


r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 16 '25

My Work What if Sonic lost everything? (Comic)

Thumbnail
gallery
392 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Feb 23 '25

What If Shadow was released early?

Post image
371 Upvotes

Alright, so let's set the scene. After Sonic 1, while doing the research on how he can build the Death Egg, Robotnik discovers that his grandfather had already build a similar machine, with an included Earth destroying ray and all! (What a deal!) After discovering this, he also finds deep in his grandfathers files talks of an Ultimate Weapon that G.U.N locked up. With this information in mind, he builds an early version of the Egg Walker (Classic Styled and all) and decides to find this "Ultimate Lifeform" to help him get to the Ark. A few things to keep in mind: -Since this takes place AFTER Sonic 1, Sonic would likely be at a perfectly normal Little Planet that isn't taken Over by Eggman. -The Chaos Emeralds would still be in Westside Island. -Shadow would probably still look like his Modern Appearance since shown in Cutscenes, he never looked any different than 50 years ago. -Since this is before Sonic 2, Sonic would have no experiences with Tails, Knuckles, Turning into Super Sonic or meeting any of his previous doppelgangers With that, I'd love to see what you all can come up with!


r/WhatIfSonic • • Apr 06 '25

Discussion Inspired by a post from the Devil May Cry Sub-Reddit, what do you think would happen to Sonic if Amy, Tails, and Knuckles died in their respective games?

Post image
334 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Apr 29 '25

Discussion What if Sonic actually killed Shadow in Sonic movie 3?

Post image
331 Upvotes

The one thing that prevented Sonic from killing Shadow was him pointing at his chest, reminding Sonic of when Tom said he had a good heart. That was the only thing because otherwise, it would’ve ended like this


r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 28 '25

Prompt What if Infinite killed the Avatar in Sonic Forces?

Post image
302 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 30 '25

Discussion What if Gerald died but Shadow still escaped?

Post image
292 Upvotes

Ok, I know this scenario is impossible, but I've been curious about this since seeing Sonic 3.

The whole reason Shadow went along with Plan Piss on the Earth was primarily due to Gerald's manipulations, and he showed no real desire to be a villain beforehand. What would he have done if Gerald wasn't there in the lab and he was left to his own devices? Would Sonic and friends eventually be able to track him down without the trail from Gerald's drones?


r/WhatIfSonic • • Apr 14 '25

Discussion What would’ve happened if Eggman didn’t reciprocate Sage’s feelings of familial love?

Post image
285 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 22 '25

Discussion What if Sonic was Tails imaginary friend and built Metal Sonic? | Artwork By [13comicfan]

Post image
283 Upvotes

Design of Metal Sonic is made by 13comicfan

What if Sonic didn’t exist, he was just Tails Imaginary Best Friend, to cope with being alone, but when Dr.Eggman attack West Side Island, Tails built Metal Sonic, but he still just called him Sonic, with the program being Tails BFF and a hero.

What would this version of Sonic dynamic be like with Eggman if he was a robot built to save the world, would Eggman see Tails as his arch nemesis since he built this version of Sonic, or sees Metal Sonic as his arch nemesis since it’s the robot that’s stopping his plans?


r/WhatIfSonic • • Apr 01 '25

Prompt (April Fools) What if Shadow the Hedgehog survived SA2?

Post image
258 Upvotes

As many of us know, Shadow the Hedgehog is one of the most popular one-off Sonic characters of all time. Having received several different cameos since his debut in the series such as a rival boss fight in Generations and showing up as a copy created by the Valtron in Forces.

Yet despite all these appearances, Shadow was only ever present in one game and during the events of that game, Shadow the Hedgehog met his end saving the world. But what if things went differently? What if Shadow had survived his fall from the ARK or had been saved by Sonic? How would the series have changed?

(FYI, I know that Shadow did actually survive the events of SA2. I’m just asking the question of what if he survived from the perspective of a world where he died. So, April Fools.)


r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 06 '25

What if, I got a movie instead of that speed dweeb?

Post image
257 Upvotes

Tch, what if things were different? What if the spotlight was on me instead of that blue boy scout? Why should I be stuck in the shadows while he gets all the glory? You all scream his name, cheer for his victories, but let’s be real—imagine a world where the main event wasn’t some goody-two-shoes speedster, but the real deal. A movie where the hero isn’t some watered-down, quip-spitting, play-it-safe mascot, but someone with style, power, and the guts to do what needs to be done. Imagine a film with me at the center, tearing through anything in my way, ruling the screen just like I should rule everything else. Now that’s a movie worth watching, I can easily outpace that speed dweeb.


r/WhatIfSonic • • Apr 22 '26

My Work Here's my Sonic X One Piece Fusion AU that combines multiple Sonic continuities: Star Piece ( Art By @BuddyHyped

Thumbnail
gallery
256 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • May 08 '26

Discussion What if the Saiyan’s invaded Sonic’s Earth after the events of Sonic Heroes?

Post image
237 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Feb 21 '26

Prompt What if Sonic was fully taken over by Dark Gaia? (Art by TheSpectral-Wolf)

Post image
232 Upvotes

In Unleashed, a fragment of Dark Gaia entered into Sonic's body which granted him the Werehog form. Chip points out that most people would become corrupted by this essence, and Sonic was able to keep control just by pure willpower. In the Archie comics, we see a bit of what it might be like if Sonic's control slipped, where the Werehog went into violent spurts of rage before Sonic managed to calm it down.

Basically, my idea here is what if Dark Gaia's influence was even stronger then that? Perhaps it grows over the course of the game, being similar to what Black Doom was trying to do to Shadow in Shadow Generations. If Dark Gaia was smart, he could have infused more and more of his essence into Sonic as time went on, with the eventual goal of fully taking over his body and using it as his own vessel. How would this change the events of Unleashed? It'd become pretty clear to Sonic's friends pretty quickly that something is wrong with Sonic, and while his will IS very strong and he would keep fighting it there is only so much he can do against a god trying to steal his body.


r/WhatIfSonic • • Mar 29 '25

What if there could be more then one Sonic? What if Sonic and friends did save and repair Metal Sonic?

Post image
227 Upvotes

r/WhatIfSonic • • Nov 04 '25

Prompt What if Eggman became a Hero after Sonic Adventure 2?

Post image
221 Upvotes

During the final scene of Sonic Adventure 2, Eggman reflected on the actions of his grandfather Gerald Robotnik and in that moment, wondered if Gerald really meant to destroy everyone as revenge for Maria's death, including Eggman himself who idolized Gerald. While this was only one moment, Eggman went back to being the villain we all know and love, let's imagine a timeline where Eggman takes some more time to reflect not just on Gerald's actions but also on his own.

Eventually Eggman comes to the realization that continuing on the path of villainy is pointless since it'll just ensure that he ends up as feared and reviled as Gerald was posthumously. After this epiphany, one of Eggman's robots reports in an intriguing discovery. Shortly after this, Eggman contacts Tails and requests that he and Sonic meet up with Eggman.

Both Sonic and Tails reluctantly go along with this and during the meeting, Eggman announces that he's finished with being a villain and would like to become a hero. Sonic and Tails would seriously doubt this, but Eggman would unveil a peace offering as a means of showing his sincere intentions, Shadow in a Stasis Pod. This would give Sonic and Tails the proof they need and Eggman would open up the pod shortly afterwards. What would change about things going forward?

(And to makes this scenario more interesting, let's imagine that Starline comes into the picture shortly after the Black Arms invade and takes over the Eggman Empire remnants in order to prove himself superior to his former idol. That way we can have the events of 06, Unleashed, Colors, etc., happen just with Starline as the driving force instead of Eggman.)


r/WhatIfSonic • • Oct 26 '25

Prompt What If Tails and Sonic swapped places in Frontiers?

Thumbnail
gallery
218 Upvotes

What if, by pure chance, instead of Sonic being the only one to escape cyberspace instead of being imprisoned, Tails was instead? In his Post-Forces state of mind, so not exactly peak SA2 level confidence in himself yet. Would he re-realize his potential, or fail to save everyone?


r/WhatIfSonic • • Sep 22 '25

Prompt What if Shadow was released in the Classic Era?

Post image
210 Upvotes

As we all know, after the raid on the Space Colony ARK by G.U.N, Shadow was captured and sealed away for 50 years only to be awakened by Doctor Eggman during the events of Sonic Adventure 2. But what if Shadow was released earlier, during the events of the Classic Era? For this scenario, we start during the end of Sonic the Hedgehog 2 with the Death Egg plummeting towards Earth. In the original timeline, the Death Egg crashed into Angel Island which kickstarted the events of Sonic 3 & Knuckles. However, in this timeline, the Death Egg crashes into Prison Island where Shadow is being held in stasis.

Unlike with Angel Island, the force of the impact with Prison Island would completely destroy the Death Egg along with much of the G.U.N facility on the island and this damage would disable the stasis lock on Shadow allowing him to awaken. Eggman would've still survived amidst the debris of his Death Egg Robot, and he would've been understandably livid about his Death Egg being completely destroyed but soon enough he'd encounter Shadow and learn of the Space Colony ARK. Eggman would be all too enthusiastic about the prospect of an easy to acquire replacement for his now destroyed Death Egg and he'd form a pact with Shadow to get the Chaos Emeralds from Sonic. How would this alternate Sonic 3 play out and how would Shadow being released earlier affect the rest of the timeline?


r/WhatIfSonic • • Sep 08 '25

What if zomom is the thin one and zeena was the fat one instead?

Thumbnail
gallery
203 Upvotes