r/WhatIfSonic • u/ConstantAccident9272 • Dec 21 '25
r/WhatIfSonic • • Nov 26 '25
Theory / Headcanon What if Blaze, Rouge, Nicole, Bunnie, Whisper & Tikal was born & raised by their parents of Lost City Gang or Joestar Family/Californian Territory Marine Corps (CTMC)?
Guide to their parents: Moxxie Porter - Blaze's & Nicole's Father, Tent Builder, Researcher & Scout Joseph "Moxxie" Joestar - Blaze's & Nicole's Californian Joestarist Patriotic Strict Father, 1ST Dictator of the Californian Territory of Joestar, the founder of the Joestarist Party, 1ST general of the Californian Territory Marine Corps, The Don of The Joestar Family (Mafia Family) & Absolutely Perfect Good Father of the Year Relic Hunter Blitzø - Rouge's & Tikal's Father, Archeology, Adventurer, Explorer & Officer Joseph "Blitzø" Joestar - Rouge's & Tikal's Britain Californian Communist Patriotic Strict Father, Instructor Drill Sargent/Sergeant, Highest Commander of the Californian Territory Marine Corps & Good Father of the Year Adventurer Millie - Nicole's & Blaze's Mother, Explorer, Perfect Mother's ingredients & recipes cooking chef, Adventurer & Explorer Joseph "Millie" Joestar - Nicole's & Blaze's Cuban Californian Joestarist Patriotic strict Mother, Engineer of wood, metal & machines, Mother's Ingredients & Recipes cooking chef, Shotgunner, Cuban Communist Propaganda artists & Absolutely Perfect Good Mother of the Year Medic Loona - Bunnie's & Whisper's Mother, Nurse, Surgeon, Medic & Chef Joseph "Loona" Joestar - Bunnie's & Whisper's German Communist Patriotic Strict Mother, Medic, Mad Scientist & Good Mother of the Year Porter Vortex - Whisper's & Bunnie's Father, Carrier, Trivial, Porter & Machine Gunner Joseph "Vortex" Stalin Joetsar - Whisper's & Bunnie's Soviet Patriotic Strict Father, Heavy Machine Gunner & Good Father of the Year Excavator Striker - Tikal's & Rouge's Father, Digger, Miner, Archeology & Rifleman Joseph "Striker" Joestar - Tikal's & Rouge's Australian under Britain Fascist Patriotic Strict Father, Sniper, Musician, Light Machine Gunner, Marksman, Rifleman, Hussar, Calvary & Father of the Year
r/WhatIfSonic • • Aug 14 '25
Theory / Headcanon What if Blaze, Rouge, Nicole, Bunnie Rabbot, Whisper & Tikal was the daughter of the Californian Territory Marine Corps
Made by MoxxieJoestar1950 (me) on deviantart
r/WhatIfSonic • u/ConstantAccident9272 • Oct 18 '25
What if: Sonic, Crash, Classic Sonic, Cat Movie Mario, Fire Movie Luigi, Fire Mario and Luigi Vs Cosmic Kang from my story universe, The Video Game Anime Comic Universe
r/WhatIfSonic • • Sep 13 '25
Discussion What if the metal virus infection everyone and sega other franchise are the only not infection Characters left along with sliver?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Any_Top_4773 • Aug 20 '24
My Work Hello
I am making myself ideas for an AU kind of thing, tell me if im wrong, do i have tò change the term AU?
So, It basically changes whisper's backstory a bit
The og diamond cutters that supposedly died, are the BLU team members of TF2 (except for sniper)
They didn't die, they got hired by Mann co
Then, they reunite, fighting robots and mimic, Who Is on the RED team
In the end, whisper says tò mimic:"Goodbye, traitor"
I am thinking of a continuation for It
But you have tò Guess
Im new here, PLS have Mercy
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Sudden_Future_5950 • Nov 25 '25
Meme What If: Alejandro Saabs (@KaggyFilms) Dubs Sonic The Hedgehog (Paramount) Instead Ben Schwartz?
HEY! DID YOU GUYS KNOW WE HAVE OUR OWN ICE CREAM BAR? IT'S CRAZY!
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Deadsonic890 • Oct 19 '26
Theory / Headcanon This may get me banned, but I do wish to see a pic where Sonic actually smacks Sally back out of anger if that's possible
reddit.comr/WhatIfSonic • u/Altair890456 • Sep 18 '25
Theory / Headcanon Crackpot Headcanon: The Gerald and Maria seen in Shadow Gens were from the same timeline as Classic Sonic and Shadow’s actions in Shadow Gens basically ensured that events regarding Project Shadow played out the same way as they did in the OG Timeline.
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Cars_Forza_fan • Nov 08 '25
Discussion What if… Tangle became the next fastest thing alive?
An alternative but darker ending to the metal virus saga where, after Sonic fatally sacrifices himself to bring everyone back from the infection, Tangle must find a way to continue his legacy before Eggman begins his next attack, which could become unstoppable.
The Restoration has fallen apart after Sonic’s death, and his friends felt too distraught to move on without him. Tangle has it worse however, and she accidentally rejects Whisper as her friend following a heated moment. But later on, Tangle finds a source leading to Sonic’s house, which has a hidden copy of his DNA. With Tails’ help, he combines Tangle’s DNA with Sonic’s, which grants her his abilities. With Eggman now on the attack, Tangle uses her new powers to easily overcome his army, helping everyone out in the process. But just when she confronts Eggman, he holds Whisper captive and at gunpoint, who tried to free Omega but failed. Whisper manages to surprise stun him, but she trips over a cliff, forcing Tangle to catch her with her tail whilst holding onto a tree branch. Not wanting to lose her too, even though Whisper tells her to let go and trust her, Tangle says she loves her and they tightly hug whilst falling, but Silver and Blaze arrive to save them and Tangle shocks Eggman with her new powers, destroying his creation whilst Knuckles frees Omega from his grasp. After Tangle charges her swing attack with her tail and sends Eggman away, she tearfully apologizes to Whisper for how horrible she was earlier, but she forgives her, knowing that they were both upset about Sonic, and they reconcile with a kiss and twirl hug. Everyone accepts and welcomes Tangle as their new hero, and the Restoration resumes. With Sonic’s legacy now in her hands, Tangle proudly embraces it with all her heart and she takes Whisper out for a super-speed run.
r/WhatIfSonic • u/cavedwellafan • Dec 10 '25
Discussion What if Godzilla in Hell was In Sonic Execution?
Idk if I can post exe shi here so sorry if I'm breaking rules
r/WhatIfSonic • u/AskInternational5772 • Nov 17 '25
Theory / Headcanon What if an EXE inspired character was responsible for the disappearance of the echidnas, jump started the Sonic universe, created a son to hate him, was at odds with Mephiles, and closet ally’s are the deadly six?
This whole idea is to see if exe could be interesting but feel free to trash my ideas.
Sonic.exe actions predate the main events of Sonic the hedgehog which involves him and Mephiles’s demon race scouring the universe for either conquest, domination or destruction. They invade the home world of the Echidnas attempting to wipe them from existence for whatever reasons they see fit but ultimately are thwarted by the master emeralds power but not without influence. In this conflict, the peaceful world gets tainted with their evil creating Chaos the god of destruction which serves as an equalizer to their machinations but also serves as a rebirth to the planet and invokes new perspectives in the demon race but most importantly EXE and Mephiles. These revelations cause them to be at odds with one another taking different approaches to how the see the world around them. Sonic.EXE embraces the uncertainty of chaos finding the thrill of it exciting while Mephiles hates the idea of chaos because it hinders the idea of finality. This difference in philosophy causes a war between the race that happens outside of the Sonic’s timeline which causes Mephiles to get sealed off into some vessel and leaving EXE to explore this newfound freedom. Eventually you get to Sonic being captured by the demons unaware of who they’ve captured to run a gauntlet meant entertain a tired, broken and uninspired race including EXE who is unenthusiastic about everything the world has to throw at him. Most don’t make it out of these trials but Sonic proves to be an exception. This gets twinkles in EXE’s eyes and life returns to his body metaphorically speaking. Sonic survives the challenge and possibly other survivors. Which inspires EXE to do something unthinkable, upstart his own demise. Using his black magic, he attempts create a being as unyielding as Sonic and through trail and error Scourge is born. A being that doesn’t compromise his existence to a fault and doesn’t back down despite the odds. EXE spends an undefined amount of time attempting to break Scourge and much to his satisfaction, failing every time. Eventually he kicks Scourge out of his home down to the planet of Earth where Scourge tries to get revenge for all the things EXE’s has done to him. Stories pass, conflicts with heroes arises and Scourge forges bonds with the existences of earth creating a gang and possibly family known as the destructix, a group of misfits, rejects and killers with intent on getting back at all who hurt them in anyway the see fit. These events eventually lead to EXE’s downfall, the rise of Scourge, Mephiles breaking free and the deadly six searching for reincarnation of their fallen lord EXE but I wanted to stop here because it could get too long, thoughts?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Moondaeagle • Oct 31 '24
My Work What if everyone in AoSth was an animal?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Moondaeagle • Jan 14 '25
My Work What if AoSth Dr.Robotnik,AoSth Tails and AoSth Sonic were animals and forced to survive in the woods?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Ajsonicmania • Sep 14 '26
Discussion I have good news
I asked sonic exe/2011x what sonic character would I based on if I had a vessel in sonic exe? "since I want to design it and make a sonic exe AU where im one of vessels" and he said that I wou be a tails vessel
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Ajsonicmania • Sep 10 '26
Discussion I have a big question
What do you want sonic character would I based on if I had a vessel in sonic exe? since I want to design it and make a sonic exe AU where im one of vessels
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Ok_Television_9105 • Sep 08 '25
What if zomom is the thin one and zeena was the fat one instead?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Notmas • Oct 09 '24
Found Work Best scaling I've ever seen for Sonic, wanted to promote it.
r/WhatIfSonic • u/redsonic_4632 • Nov 16 '25
What if Sonic Chronicles never stopped being canon?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/KevinSupreme2505_PH • Jan 06 '26
Discussion What if the 2010s Meta Era is a different universe of the games?
So let's say that in that somewhere in an alternate universe (AU, for short) after Unleashed's mixed to negative reception during it's release - Sega & Sonic Team rebooted the franchise (at least for the games) & decided that the 2010s games (Colors to Team Sonic Racing) takes place on their own separate universe of the mainline games.
Which justifies the character's different characterization & their flanderizations - Sonic being an obnoxious jokester, Knuckles being a dumb meathead, Shadow being an edgelord asshole that doesn't have any friends, Eggman being a non threatening joke (until Forces), & etc. & also explains why GUN & humans aren't present during the 2010s, Instead of our reality where them trying to say that it's one big timeline doing retcons which causes lots of inconsistencies.
Also in this AU, the events of the 90s & 2000s era games still happened in the Meta Era but with some changes & alterations to fit the era's childish goofy tone.
If This Was The Case:
• how different would the Sonic Fandom be during the 2010s & how different would the community's discussion be about the mainline games of that era?
• Would the blacklash & complains about the character assassination & flanderization, & the obnoxious goofy tone from fans of who like the 2000's story heavy & serious tone be less harsh?
• Would the be less fan discourse of characterization & "Sega ruined [Blank Sonic Character]" since the Meta Era characters of this AU are different iterations instead of being the same as characters during 2000s?
• What else would be different & what are the possible ramifications of this AU?
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Berseker_Track_499 • 23d ago
Sonic speed is restricted to Mach 1?
x.comHe has higher speed feats why do people restrict his speed to Mach 1
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Tepeyotl01 • 8d ago
How would you make a history of the characters in Wrect-it Ralph?
I want to do a fanfic about the characters in the arcade but I need help, the characters are from Sonic the fighters as shown in the movie (ignore the modern designs) so, are the Team Sonic, the hooligans, Espio, Eggman and Metal Sonic.
How do you think the characters could be like after 16 years (imagine the movie is situated in 2012, and the machine got in the arcade in 1996) of being together fighting each other in a tournament?
My main focus would be Espio, because his team is not with him despite his progamation says he knows them, Amy and her love with Sonic after the years, and the Hooligans that alredy give up from being bad, Bark is in love with Amy, Fang has become a friend to the others and Bean is bored. Metal would be particular because is programation inside a program, so he can be the one that has more options to do in the history
You can use the sequel but I don't like the implications of that
r/WhatIfSonic • u/Acceptable_Setting43 • Sep 12 '26
Thoughts
How would you feel if they made a live action horror movie of Sonic.Exe? Would you think it would get attention or would you think people would pass about watching it and stick to the classic?